N Vleugel 5th
In the final stanza of the first poem it is clear that the children dont see their own victimization in the labor they perform. They stay hopeful throughout all situations hoping for a better (after)life, keeping them happy & warm. On the other hand it can also be seen as the way of the church & superiors to oppress the working-class by them making the children believe they will eventually be rewarded for their unquestioning obedience, and the children gullibly accepting it as a truth. In the second poem Blake is more focused on the natural nature of children and the hypocrisy of the church the monarchy and the parents. A little black thing among the snow emphasizes again how the childrens childhood is taken or polluted for the comfort to others through imagery and symbolism. Imagery is displayed in the poem as the black amongst all the pure white snow. And the symbolism in the irregularity of black disturbing the image of all the white. This can be interpreted as the unjust and cruelty done to a small part of innocent children and so many other lives entirely untouched and unaffected. It can also be concluded from the diction- using words like: up, think, praise and make up- that the child/narrator depicts the parents, church and monarchy to be very hypocritical. Hypocritical, because they dont lay the blame by themselves or anyone for that matter even though they are the cause of the childrens misery. And just like the first poem it mentions the good attitude and natural ability of children to have fun in the worst of times. In the second stanza it says that as the child was naturally positive they specifically had to teach him the notes of woe. However, in this poem it is evident that, because the child is happy & dance & sing, people think that they have done no wrong, that the children have not been wronged, or that at least they do not feel like they have been wronged. Lastly, William Blake as well as the narrator, the child, expresses a lot of anger in this second poem. The children being clothed in the clothes of death by their parents is Blake blaming the parents of sentencing their children to a young death and misery because of the work they will be forced to do. And again, as in the first poem he expresses his anger towards the monarchy and church for guaranteeing heaven if the people suffer enough in this life. Only the difference lies in the sarcasm or irony being harsher in the second poem because of the already stated hypocrisy and the possibility that the hopeful tone in the first poem can be intended to be true.
To summarize, in both poems Blake uses devices like connotation, imagery and diction to form a tone on the same subject even though the ton e they express is different. In the first one Blake strains that practically the only way for them to be freed of their sad lifestyle is by an early death. These deaths are also described in the second poem, where he blames the parents for sentencing the children to an early death because of the profession they are forced into by these parents. The church and monarchy are also blamed for ensuring the people they will get heaven after their lives full of suffering to suppress them. Also in both poems the writer or narrator mentions the naturally positive and playful spirit children posses. However in the first poem he describes how children are the happiest: playing outside, while the second poem states that because these children remain with certain happiness even in their miserable situations, people falsely assume no harm has come to them. Moreover, the tones differ in the way that poem 1 is more hopeful for these children, while poem 2 mostly blames society for their conditions.