COM
INVESTOR
S ERVICES
JOURNAL
VOLUME 2 No. 8 - Sept/Oct. 2005
PRIME
B
MOVES
H F R
ROKERS ON THE EDGE UND ISE
For a partnership to work it needs to be built on trust. As one of the world's leading providers of
hedge fund administration services, UBS can give you the confidence you need to focus on your
core business. Our experienced team of professionals, with access to state of the art technology, deliver
accurate, timely, added-value administration solutions tailored to your needs. Based in the Cayman
Islands and Ireland, our tried and tested comprehensive range of services includes accounting, NAV
computation, shareholder services, banking and registered office. All of which means, together, we can
achieve success. You and us.
You & Us
www.ubs.com/fundservices
ANNOUNCEMENT
TOMORROW’S PEOPLE, THE ISJ STUDENT ESSAY COMPETITION 2006
It’s time again for students to test their skills and for today’s industry leaders
to scout the available talent in ISJ’s second Annual Essay Competition.
Students at over 400 business schools and universities will be invited to enter the competition, by writing an essay on the
topics listed alongside (specific questions will be set by an Academic Advisory Panel and announced on
WWW.ISJFORUM.COM along with details of Prizes, Sponsors and Venue in September 2005).
Essay Categories: · Compliance / Regulation · Hedge Funds · Outsourcing · Institutional Investment
· Risk Management · Technology in Financial Services · Prime Brokerage
Dates to diarise are; Essay Deadline - 21 March 2006 & Essay Awards Evening 22 June 2006
The Essay Awards Evening will take place at a prestigious London venue and will be attended by the winners of the essay
competition and professionals from the securities services industry. Professionals interestedin involvement in this event,
please contact ISJ on +44 (0) 207 493 9966. WWW.ISJFORUM.COM.
INVESTOR
S ERVICES
JOURNAL
Contents
6 World News The latest securities services news
HEDGE FUNDS
14 Prime Time CSFB’s Philip Vasan on hedge funds and client demands
16 Here comes the Sun Hedge funds have caused a sea change in the prime brokerage industry
22 Asian Alpha Service providers turn their thoughts to Asia, reports Alison Ebbage
28 Analyse this...Hedge Funds Hedge fund experts anwer a range of questions about their industry
32 Looking Up The latest hedge fund performance results from HFR
CUSTODY
34 Centre Strength Service providers in the Benelux region embrace the changes in Europe
OUTSOURCING
40 On Core What do recent changes in outsourcing say about the securities industry?
SECURITIES LENDING
46 On Loan Performance results and analysis from Data Explorers
48 A Meeting of Minds Carol McGinn analyses of value of securities lending networking events
50 RMA Analysis The latest performance results from the Risk Managment Association
PENSIONS
51 Defying Deficit Pension fund deficits have forced custodians to deliver creative solutions
52 Home Brew The Pensions Interview - Ray Martin of Scottish & Newcastle
CORPORATE ACTIONS
54 Automatic for the People Is CA automation within reach by Rekha Menon
56 Time for Action Roundtable the key challenges for corporate actions
REGULARS
70 Mandates Pensions funds consolidate asset services with single providers
74 Movers and Shakers Who has moved to where...
76 Directory of Services Custody, Fund Administration, Securities Lending, Technology, Prime
Brokerage, Training & Education
WWW.ISJFORUM.COM
To discover how we can design solutions that optimise returns, please contact:
jpmorgan.com/investorservices
The products and services featured above are offered by JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., a subsidiary of JPMorgan Chase & Co. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. is registered by
the FSA for investment business in the U.K. JPMorgan is a marketing name for Worldwide Services businesses of JPMorgan Chase & Co. and its subsidiaries worldwide.
© 2005 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved.
Letters to the Editor
home
DELIVERING A DOMESTIC
MARKET FOR EUROPE
News - Europe Middle East Africa
eSecLending provides services only to institutional investors and other persons who have professional investment
experience. Neither the services offered by eSecLending nor this advertisement are directed at persons not possessing
such experience. Old Mutual (US) Trust Company, an eSecLending company, performs all regulated business activities.
Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Our services may not be suitable for all lenders.
News - Americas
Trends
In a rapidly evolving industry, Vasan has noted a host of
developments that have affected prime brokers in the last
year.
“The continued flow of capital into alternative
investments has made it more challenging to maintain
performance,” he says.
“This has been temporarily compounded by cyclical
trading conditions. As the dust from that settles, we’re
seeing hedge funds continuing to explore ways to
outperform, ranging from employing new financial
instruments to diversifying strategies.”
This proliferation of hedge funds strategies has placed a
new set of demands on the prime brokerage industry to
deliver a more complete suite of capabilities to hedge
Philip Vasan funds, whose activities have broadened and become more
complex.
To meet hedge fund demand, prime brokers have
Competition
In the last five years, an overlap “We expect an increased focus on the credit quality of
has occurred between the services the counterparty in a trade in addition to the collateral”
provided by prime brokers, custodi-
ans and fund administrators.
As the hedge fund industry continues to develop, some who CSFB takes on as a client, noting that “the Firm
prime brokers have taken the step to offer custody and already has a highly-targeted approach.”
clearing. CSFB currently serves 300 managers across equity and
Vasan says: “Some prime brokers have looked to bundle fixed income prime brokerage. “To maintain high individ-
custody or administration services with their prime ual client focus we aren’t looking to take this beyond about
brokerage offering. 400 over the next eighteen months,” states Vasan.
“As an alternative we have offered an open-architecture Within Europe, the upcoming Basel II capital adequacy
approach toward these services, giving our hedge fund requirements will have an important impact on the hedge
clients transparency and access to the best of what's out fund and prime brokerage industry.
there, whether from us or externally. “We expect an increased focus on the credit quality of
“In addition some hedge funds as well as investors prefer the counterparty in a trade in addition to the collateral,”
a degree of separation between certain services, where for says Vasan.
example the prime broker and administrator are operating Vasan ultimately sees a one-time expansion in the top
on separate channels. Either way our approach is to offer tier prime brokers. “A few will emerge as 'super' prime
the choice.” brokers, each likely with a unique identity, operating on a
full-service global scale.
Range “For Credit Suisse, there is added potential to create
The range of services provided by prime brokers has value for hedge funds through our “One Bank” platform.”
expanded considerably. In order to realise its “One Bank” initiative, Credit Suisse
“Core services generally include clearing, settlement, is aligning its Investment Bank, Private Bank and Asset
reporting, client service, financing, start-up help and Management units into a one-stop shop for clients.
capital introductions, where prime brokers bring together And with an individual like Vasan leading the group’s
hedge fund managers seeking capital and the investors that Prime Services business Credit Suisse is well positioned to
supply it,” says Vasan. harness these strengths for hedge funds.
Among the recent trends, Vasan highlights the move of
hedge funds beyond equities across all asset classes. “Prime
brokerage opportunities have similarly extended beyond Philip S. Vasan is Head of Global Prime Services of Credit
servicing classic equity long-short strategies to multi-asset Suisse First Boston, based in New York.
class strategies,” he says.
He is a member of the Global Equity Management
Committee and the Firm's Management Council.
Single Platform Vasan joined the Firm in 1992 to develop CSFB's global
Noticing the emerging change in tactic among clients, currency options business.
CSFB was one of the first global prime brokers to move its In 1996 he became Head of Global Foreign Exchange,
equity and fixed income capabilities onto the same which he ran until 2000.
platform. The prime broker facilitated this move three Prior to his current position, Vasan was worldwide head of
years ago in order to meet what it saw as a growing Equity Derivatives and Convertibles.
demand for an “asset-class neutral” service. He has also led both the Firm's institutional e-commerce
Vasan has various predictions for the hedge fund and cost reduction efforts, and has co-chaired CSFB's
Managing Director Evaluation Committee. Before joining
community in the coming years. “As in any growing and CSFB, Vasan ran Citibank's FX options business in the U.S.
increasingly efficient market we expect the ‘secular’ after trading interest rate derivatives there.
pressure on returns to persist,” he says. Vasan received his B.A. with High Honours from Oberlin
“This should in turn continue to fuel a search for College and his Ph.D. in Economics from Harvard
differentiation by hedge fund managers. As for prime University, where he was named top graduate instructor in
brokers, we see competition accelerating the the University. He has authored a text on Options used to
‘commoditisation’ of traditional offerings and placing a train CSFB staff and clients, and has served as a visiting
premium on a differentiated offering as well.” lecturer in Finance at the MIT Sloan School of Management.
the Sun investment advisers that manage more than $30 million to
register as investment advisers under the Investment
Advisers Act of 1940, he reports. This includes hedge fund
advisers. Advisers with less than $25 million are prohibit-
The performance of alternative ed from registering with the SEC but are subject to state
investments has surpassed that regulatory agencies. Advisers can avoid registration by
requiring a two-year lock-up period. The SEC, as a way to
of traditional equity and fixed distinguish hedge funds from venture capital funds, insti-
tuted the lock-up criterion. The regulations become effec-
income vehicles and has caused tive in February 2006.
a seachange within the prime Registration
brokerage industry. Brian Bollen “Who bears the brunt of registration? It seems that the
hedge funds themselves will be responsible for their own
reports on the regulations compliance to the new law. But there are certainly new
opportunities for service providers to assist hedge funds in
affecting hedge funds and the achieving compliance. Prime brokers are probably already
opportunites for prime brokers registered and managing their compliance requirements
from other areas of their business. They likely possess sig-
“Sunlight is good, unless you’re Dracula, and we don’t nificant internal expertise. Smaller hedge funds are likely
want Draculas in the business.” That’s the pithy view of deficient in their expertise so an opportunity exists for
one New York-based prime broker when called upon to prime brokers to expand their realm of service.
comment upon the impact that planned new regulatory “A direct impact will be a better “accounting” of the true
arrangements will have upon hedge funds in the US. “We size and scope of hedge funds as an asset class.
want sunshine, we want openness, we want transparency,” Background information on managers will be on record
he continues, implying that anything that increases with the SEC. Hedge funds will have to spend additional
transparency must by definition be good. So long as it effort to manage the compliance requirements. It looks
does not affect performance. “We want astute, aggressive like that is about it. It is dangerous for investors to
managers to take care of our wealth,” he adds. become sanguine about the need for their own due dili-
John R. Phillips, Chief Investment Officer, Philadelphia gence when considering registered advisers. That would
be one unfavorable and unintended consequence. Some
Breaking through the cloud cover? of the resistance from the hedge funds is the fear that this
initial step becomes a “slippery slope” of regulation.
Subsequent requirements could compromise a manager’s
edge. As an example, higher levels of transparency into a
fund’s holdings may bring these types of concerns.
Outlook
“What is the outlook for further regulation? Given the
changes at the top for the SEC, it’s hard to know where the
organisation is going to focus its effort in the near term. I
think it’s safe to say that we are not moving towards an
environment of reduced regulation. It is also likely that
future regulations will create a regulatory parity among
the different investment alternatives.
“Most importantly, hedge funds need to embed a formal
process of compliance into the operation of their business.
This is likely a very good outcome from the new laws. In
the end, it should help well-run funds to increase the trust
of investors – thus making hedge funds a more desirable
investment alternative. Prime brokers should approach
this issue in the same way they approach each issue con-
fronted by their hedge fund clients. Most prime brokers
already have internal needs for services that the bank has
learned how to provide to itself (financing, stock loan,
trade clearing, risk management, capital introduction etc).
A well-managed integrated banker will leverage its internal
Frankfurt
Zurich
London
Dublin
Paris
MIG21 Luxembourg
Managing Investment Governance in the 21st century New York
expertise and provide this expertise in the form of services withdrawals cannot be made within this lock up period.
through its prime brokerage arm. “The SEC’s attempt to more closely regulate hedge funds
“As with all forms of regime change, there will be new involves requiring them to register as a Registered
problems, but there will also be new opportunities. The Investment Adviser (“RIA”) by February of 2006. This
requirement to register as an investment adviser should requirement applies to funds with assets over $25m or
not cause a severe problem for anyone who is not already those funds with greater than 15 investors. Any fund with
a lock up period shorter than two years is also sub-
“Obviously, those who don’t adapt well to the ject to this registration requirement. In addition to
registering, these funds must also appoint a full-
regulated environment will fall behind” time compliance officer to staff and subject them-
marginalised for some reason. Cost for compliance will selves to ad hoc SEC inspections. Myriad events prompted
increase, but should be manageable. The biggest question the SEC to initiate this regulation, she notes. “Since their
is where do the regulations stop? If they continue to introduction, hedge funds have always been secretive
become more onerous, they could affect a hedge fund’s about their investments, fee structures and particularly
ability to successfully execute its strategies. The opportuni- their use of leverage. The industry belief was that by keep-
ty comes in two forms. One, Improving the hedge fund ing a low profile, hedge funds could be more nimble in
image to investors may pave the way for additional invest- their investment choices. They’d prefer to move silently in
ment. Adhering to the new regulations may help to polish and out of certain names and thus be able to profit from
this image. Two, those who plan to provide compliance areas of the market that others weren’t watching.
services will have a rapid growth market into which they “The fact that few hedge funds declare a rigid investment
can sell their services. style also allows them to change their investment objec-
“Those investment managers that can adapt to a regulat- tives at will. This can increase the investment risk to an
ed environment will likely produce a positive marketing investor and the SEC hopes that by creating more trans-
byproduct (either justified or not) that will improve parency via registering, there will be less fraud committed
investor confidence. Those prime brokers that can help by hedge fund managers.
their hedge fund managers reach compliance will secure “The case of Long Term Capital Management (LTCM)
their success by helping in the success of their client firms. illustrates what can happen if a manager is completely free
Obviously, those who don’t adapt well to the regulated to invest in whatever it wants. In this case, LTCM created
environment will fall behind.” an Offering Memorandum that stated they would take
investors’ money and use massive computer models to
“The industry belief was that by keeping a low wring money out of market inefficiencies. This is not
in itself peculiar in the industry. However, what they
profile, hedge funds could be more nimble in didn’t state was how much leverage they would take on
their investment choices” in this strategy. Leverage is basically borrowing funds by
going on margin and its effect is to magnify whatever
Opportunities trading Profits and Losses are generated. LTCM was worth
Jennifer Morrow, of GainsKeeper, a Boston-based approximately $2 billion but it had leveraged upwards of
provider of automated financial tools and services for the $1 trillion. In the simplest terms, their computer model
investment community, invited ISJ to share the benefits of bet the wrong way and all the leverage used caused the firm
background work she has carried out in recent times to to lose everything. The magnitude of their mistake was so
identify and quantify the business opportunities that great that the banks who had lent money to LTCM
might be opening up. Her style makes a refreshing change appealed to the Government for a bailout. The Federal
for those more accustomed to jargon-laden formality. “You Reserve Bank of New York stepped in and averted a major
can’t open a newspaper without reading the phrase “hedge financial crisis.
fund” lately,” she begins, by way of contextualisation. “If LTCM had been required to register, its asset size,
“They’ve garnered a lot of attention in the past few leverage ratio and strategy would have been more public
years, some for their successes and others for their failures. and red flags could have been raised before things reached
The SEC noticed that hedge funds account for a rapidly crisis level. The Fed just can’t step in and bail out every
growing proportion of transactions in the market and has hedge fund when they mess up. Other investors have been
decided that investors will be better served if hedge funds defrauded by hedge funds when those funds incorrectly
become more regulated. According to the Financial Times, value their holdings. For example, quotes for many fixed
the Hedge Fund universe exceeded assets under manage- income securities aren’t published by an exchange. Many
ment of $1 trillion in the US as of March 31 2005. The fixed income traders “mark to market” their bonds by call-
Canadian market is also a fairly sizable US$11.3 billion. ing other traders and asking how much they’d pay, obvi-
“These funds generally “invite” investors (partners) to ously highly subjective. If a fund is subject to random SEC
join their fund (partnership) via an Offering audits, it is much more likely to establish procedures to
Memorandum. This legal document details to the investor document how they price, where they get their prices
the standard terms they agree to by investing in the fund. from, etc. An investor gains the added comfort that the
Depending on the fund’s structure, a fund is typically lim- performance numbers they receive from a hedge fund are
ited to 100 investors or fewer. An investor’s money is accurate.”
“locked up” for a defined period of time meaning that
x Legal/Regulatory Update
x Industry Leaders Panel Discussion
x Collateral Management Issues
x Hedge Fund Outlook & Impact on Lending
Planning to Attend:
For registration materials or questions, call RMA, Kim Gordon, 215-446-4021
*E-Mail: kgordon@rmahq.org or visit our web site at
http://www.rmahq.org/RMA/SecuritiesLending/RMAConferenceInformation.htm
Conference Co-Chairs
Asian
can only cope with yen denominated
products and the hedge funds industry is
always in dollars.
“It’s very much the flavour of the day as
demand is significant. But outside of
Japan it’s a very fragmented market that
assets under management and thus the operational infra- staying in this industry are low enough that we’ve seen
structure in place to support those assets and mitigate risk. surprisingly few hedge funds close down across the world.
In this respect the market in Asia is similar to the US But larger funds obviously are perceived to have less
market five years ago; and in the operational risk than smaller funds. For that reason some
past five years the US market has funds will look to merge to give themselves an edge in
seen significant amounts of consol- presenting themselves as lower risk than when they
idation with new money mostly stood alone.”
finding its way to the
“Consolidation is inevitable partly due to the
larger players, forcing the
hand of the smaller bou-
tiques. capacity of Asian markets to handle the volume
Capacity constraints
within the market could of funds and inflows of capital”
also add to any consoli-
dation. Back offices
Colin Lunn Colin Lunn, head of sales and But smaller funds can also protect themselves by being
client relationships, Asia Pacific, HSBC Alternative Fund backed by well-established and reputable back office
Services comments: “Consolidation is inevitable partly due entities.
to the capacity of Asian markets to handle the volume of Indeed the presence of a major player overseeing
funds and inflows of capital. compliance and risk management can give serious com-
“Asia accounts for 15 per cent of global market fort to investors who might otherwise shy away from
capitalisation, 10 per cent of which is in Japan – the smaller funds. But that is assuming that smaller opera-
capacity constraints are therefore obvious.” tions are of interest to big hedge funds service providers
But Lunn thinks that the focus will be on mergers rather in the first place.
than folding hedge funds: “The barriers to entry and Most administrators are not looking to pick up a large
number of small assets under management. For them too big to be effective in a marketplace currently charac-
economies of scale is the name of the game and although terised by small hedge funds.”
they are willing to form relationships with boutique out- Indeed it’s independence that is being actively marketed
fits, those relationships are strictly on the basis of those by Citco whose management recently bought back the
outfits having the requisite stickiness to attract more assets company: “We recognise the ongoing evolution of the
to manage. alternative investment universe, hence the recent buy back
Pow comments: “Smaller funds are more reliant on a decision and are continuously developing new technology
good administrator and although our traditional angle is and specialised services to keep pace with industry, to dif-
to go more towards larger institutional hedge funds, we ferentiate our services and be one of the only truly inde-
can also offer a service that is more geared towards the pendent non-consolidated administrators out there. We
needs of smaller hedge funds. think our independence is critical to the administration
“We are trying to do essentially is identify which funds model,” says Dipkin.
will be successful in the long term and support them; to
do that we need to know what a fund is invested in and Opportunity
who is running it to gain a measure of likely success. The Bank of New York meanwhile, clearly sensing an
“It may well be that boutique service providers will opportunity, plans to move its existing platform to the
spring up to support some of the smaller funds that are region to create a suitable environment for local manufac-
turers.
“But smaller funds can also protect The advantage of doing this rather than setting
up a separate platform is that Western standards
themselves by being backed by well-established can be imported.
After all if the market is about to become more
and reputable back office entities” mature and attract large amounts of pensions
fund assets then the high expectations of those
not suited to teaming with larger hedge funds service investors and the resulting largely institutional market-
providers.” place will surely apply to both front and back office.
Another factor to consider is that currently there are Indeed experienced hedge funds investors demand
only a few global service providers active in the region. streamlined, volume-tolerant operations and are also look-
Until recently HSBC and Ban k of Bermuda had more or ing closely at due diligence and risk control; and demand-
less carved up the market between them. ing sophisticated and transparent performance analytics.
HSBC then took over the Bank of Bermuda and the Dipkin comments: “Small funds usually do not require
market is still waiting to see what the new combined offer- the more granular reporting and higher service levels that
ing will look like as well as how newer players in the mar- the institutional funds require.
ket such as Citco will move to gain market share. “For example, many of the institutional funds that we
service often will have multiple prime brokers, strategies
Scale and funds, so we are calculating a consolidated daily profit
Andrew Dipkin, Managing Director, Citco Fund Services and loss or reporting by strategy within the fund or per-
comments: “Scale is always an issue for every administra- forming daily trade/cash reconciliations between the street
tor and every player will focus on what types of funds they and the manager as part on an outsourced solution.
want to administer and ensure they can meet the agreed Smaller funds don't have that level of complexity to war-
upon service levels. rant these kinds of service levels.”
“Of the three global administrators here Citco is the And as with the global trend then the scale and scope of
newest to the region and we are delighted to participate in services on offer by services providers is increasing as it
what we see as a rapid growth sector.” becomes apparent that this institutionalisation of the sys-
Northern Trust is another player eyeing the market, tem is resulting in more rigourous risk management and
Jonathan Quigley senior technical sales and client service compliance systems – both of which can be outsourced.
person for the company in Dublin comments: “The hedge If a hedge fund wants true operational efficiency and
funds we are looking to administer are the ones where the competitive advantage, it must now consider the support
flow of information is good and a reputable prime broker that specialist service providers can offer to its business
has been appointed. operations in areas like stock and fund lending, capital
“We see the whole region as a superb opportunity as the market products, derivatives and structured products, in
current situation is a handful of service providers out addition to more traditional services offered.
there and anecdotal evidence suggest that service levels are
not all they could be.” Regulation
And Pow also thinks that there exists a hint of dissatis- And regulators too play their part in extending the scope
faction with the current state of play. “People liked the way of tasks undertaken by imposing greater compliance levels
the Bank of Bermuda offered independence and although and also trying to attract hedge funds to their local market
the new merged company is trying to retain that charac- with incentives.
teristic for its alternatives business, there is still the percep- In Singapore, for example, regulators have made a con-
tion that it will also have to serve its own internal business certed effort to facilitate the development of the hedge
in addition to external ones and that this makes it simply fund sector.
With a committed global team, Fortis Prime Fund facility using portfolio holdings as collateral. To cover
Solutions provides an integrated package of fund mismatches in timing of underlying portfolio
management services to maximise your per- redemptions / subscriptions we offer liquidity / bridge
formance. As your trusted partner in the alternative finance. As a result, your funds remain fully invested,
investment industry we provide leverage financing facilitating investor liquidity. Of course we can
to funds of hedge funds as well as hedge funds also meet all your stocklending and forex needs.
to enhance overall portfolio returns. Fortis' capital For more information, please contact Prime Fund
strength allows for a straightforward cash overdraft Solutions, London. Tel.: +44 207 444 8270.
www.primefundsolutions.com
Hedge Funds - Asia
Future
In the face of these increased demands then it may well
be that hedge funds service providers too need to find the
breadth and depth necessary to cope with constant evolu-
tion and expansion.
Introducing a best practice element and standards
regarding the exposure and experience of those operating
in the industry would inevitably hasten the trend towards
a smaller number of larger operators on both the manager
and service provider side of the business.
Key Trends in Asian Hedge Funds Dipkin sums up: “There is definitely room for expansion
in this area, but getting the model right is tricky. Our deci-
- Current number of funds at 563; sion to come to the region was not only to be able to offer
101 new launches in 2003; our services in the region but also to create a "sun never
105 new launches in 2004; sets" global offering.
30 new launches so far in 2005 “Other players may not able to leverage such a strong
global presence and may therefore struggle with margins.”
- Assets stood at US$60bn as of end 2004
5BLFDPOUSPMPGZPVSCVTJOFTTXJUI"EWFOUÑGPS(MPCBM)FEHF'VOET
"EWFOUTGVMMZJOUFHSBUFETPGUXBSFTVJUFGPSUSBEJOH
QBSUOFSTIJQ
BOEGVOEBDDPVOUJOHMFUTZPV
GPDVTPOEFMJWFSJOHBCTPMVUFSFUVSOTBOEPVUTUBOEJOHDMJFOUTFSWJDF8JUI"EWFOUTDPNQMFUF
TPMVUJPO
GFBUVSJOHUIFSFWPMVUJPOBSZ(FOFWBÑBDDPVOUJOHFOHJOF
ZPVDBOTUSFBNMJOFZPVSCBDL
PGGJDF
NBOBHFUIFNPTUDPNQMFYJOWFTUNFOUTUSBUFHJFT
NJOJNJ[FPQFSBUJPOBMSJTL
BOEESJWF
EPXOZPVSDPTUT
5BLFDPOUSPM"CTPMVUFDPOUSPM -FBSO.PSF
XXXBEWFOUDPNBCTPMVUF
Do you expect the regulatory ‘squeeze’ on the hedge fund Which global domiciles will continue to be hedge fund
industry to intensify? If the answer is yes, where does that leave leaders?
the service providers in terms of opportunities relating to this
industry?
Fred W. Jacobs, Senior Vice President and Managing Director in
Sean Flynn, Head of Hedge Fund Services, UBS Fund Services charge of global alternative investment business development,
PFPC Inc.
The hedge fund industry has experienced significant growth When launching a hedge fund, one of the biggest decisions
over the last few years, with assets now in excess of USD1tril- facing a manager is choosing the proper domicile that meets
lion, and the expectation of continued growth. As a result, the complex needs of his or her respective investment prod-
hedge fund trading has become a significant contributor to the uct.
trading activity on all major stock exchanges. Cayman Islands is probably the best known name within
The distribution of hedge funds goes beyond high net worth the industry, acting as the domicile for approximately 6,400 of
individuals to include institutional investors (such as pension the world’s hedge funds. Even with this stature, Cayman regis-
funds, insurance companies, etc) with products being developed tration continues to grow at a rapid pace and the domicile
to target retail investors. Many of these products use leverage as will most likely maintain its dominant leadership position
part of their strategy. due to many attractive aspects.
These developments have caught the attention of regulators in Cayman is tax neutral, compliance conscious, and has built
the United States and Europe. Given that this growing asset class the legal and administrative infrastructure to accommodate
tends to be domiciled offshore, regulators often have little infor- growth. Further, many hedge fund investors—including Asian
mation on its activity, including the amount of leverage used, institutions, among which interest in hedge funds is quickly
and no oversight of its operations. growing—readily recognise the name.
In the United States, the SEC approach has been to require all Both Ireland and Luxembourg domiciles have also experi-
investment advisors with more than 14 clients (which includes enced an upsurge over the past few years, a trend that is likely
investors in funds) to be registered by February 2006. At pres- to continue with the growth of the European institutional
ent, there does not appear to be any further planned increased markets.
regulatory requirements in the US. Ireland, in particular, has leveraged a large and educated
In Europe, The EU is reviewing the hedge fund industry and workforce to reach beyond Dublin to gain business from
it is not clear at this time what, if any, increased regulations will funds domiciled in other locales. Listing on the Irish exchange
be proposed. will probably remain a popular choice for global hedge funds.
Our view is that the increased regulation of hedge funds in the The United States is another fast growing domicile. The
United States represents an opportunity for top-level service rationale is simple—the best product to market to most US
providers of the hedge fund industry. clients is one that is US-domiciled.
We anticipate that the increased transparency that this new In addition, there is no domicile competition for a 3c1 or
regulation supports will also be aligned with a ‘flight to quality’ 3c7 fund as there is for an Undertakings for the Collective
in the service providers hedge funds select, which in itself cre- Investment of Transferable Securities (UCITS)-based fund.
ates opportunities for an organisation such as UBS. Although many advisors will soon need to be registered with
the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the pop-
Newsflash: UBS launches alternative asset management business ularity of domiciling hedge funds in the US will likely grow,
as traditional investment banks are showing an amplified
UBS has formed a new alternative investment management interest in alternatives.
business, Dillon Read Capital Management. John Costas, cur- The hedge fund industry has borne witness to dramatic
rently Chairman and CEO of UBS’s Investment Bank, will lead growth in the past few years.
this business as CEO. Dillon Read Capital Management will With this growth, the competition has grown fierce among
form part of UBS’s Global Asset Management business led by the commonly recognised domiciles, which, in addition to
Chairman and CEO John Fraser. those mentioned, includes Bermuda, BVI, Guernsey, and
John Costas will leave UBS’s Group Executive Board at the end Jersey, among others.
of 2005. He will remain as non-executive Chairman of its While each domicile has its own distinct cannon of advan-
Investment Bank. tages that can help ensure future growth, it appears that some
are breaking away from the pack.
Comment on the future of algorithmic trading and its Please comment on the current STP levels among the hedge
impact on transparency in the hedge fund industry. fund manager community. Do you foresee further outsourc-
ing opportunities in this sector?
Robert J. Miller, CEO CorrectNet, Inc. & Frank R. Brown, Chief Mike Gamson, Director, Trade Order Management and
Quantitative Strategist, EDGETRADE Compliance, Advent Software
Trading has always been an information game. Devising and In the US, SEC registration is the big issue as it pertains to
optimising an investing strategy relies on knowledge, quantita- hedge funds.
tive reasoning and accurate execution—all fueled by quality It’s certainly been a driver for our business. Firms now
information. More than ever, hedge fund managers are seeking
need better control of their accounting and back office proce-
ways to improve their strategy execution by using information
technologies to bolster their core competency—investment dures to comply with the 1940s Investment Advisor Act obli-
decision making. A clear trend is a push to eliminate expensive, gations.
error-prone manual processes in favor of automation. And an From a regulatory standpoint, it’s clear that the old spread-
obvious expression of this general movement is the adoption of sheets that may or may not be right are not going to cut it any
algorithmic trading capabilities. more.
Algorithmic trading tools automate the labour-intensive tasks Recognising this is the first step in creating an environment
associated with trade execution, freeing up traders from tedious of greater automation, and higher levels of STP. But hedge
distractions so they can use their expert judgment and market funds also rarely build their own systems.
knowledge to add value to the trading process. These tools also These firms are typically quite lean, and focus their internal
enable rapid execution of trades requiring significant calcula- expertise on trading. They’re very interested in going outside
tion, such as in risk arbitrage strategies, and trades that must be the shop for expertise in technology.
made in response to an event such as a stop price being reached. Additionally, institutional assets are clearly fueling the
Algorithmic trading, as the term is understood, does not growth of the industry.
attempt to create “alpha” or P&L, so proprietary strategies such There are now more players, greater profitability, and
as “black-box” trading or statistical arbitrage do not fall into this greater management demands, all leading to an increased
category. Instead, once the investment or trading decision has demand for technology.
been made, algorithmic trading is a tool to help execute the As existing players get bigger and new players enter, hedge
trade more efficiently. An example - A trader wishes to trade the funds need to fundamentally provide greater transparency on
arbitrage between a basket of the stocks in the Dow Jones
their strategies and performance, and a lot of progress has
Industrial Average, and the associated Diamond (DIA)
exchange-traded fund (ETF). To do so requires tracking the been made here.
prices of the thirty stocks in the basket, using those prices to cal- STP is becoming more important in other areas of hedge
culate the fair value for the DIA, and executing the trade when fund trading though. For instance, the volume of derivative
the spread between the market price for the DIA and its fair trades is increasing and we do not have well established cen-
value exceeds some threshold. It is simply not practical to carry tral trade matching facilities – there is still a lot of manual
out this procedure manually. work being done in this area.
Why are hedge funds just now beginning a broader use of algo- Part of the solution will be to get Financial Products Mark-
rithmic trading tools? A convergence of robust business func- up Language (FPML) used more widely, and while it is get-
tionality plus two key business drivers is pushing hedge fund ting there, at this point it is by no means universally adopted.
managers to add algorithmic tools to their arsenal. Along with a Swaps Wire and the DTCC are both building derivatives set-
demonstrated ability to handle the more complex trading tlement capabilities, so that should also bring more efficiency
strategies employed by fund managers, the critical factors speed- gains.
ing the adoption of this class of trading support software are: a) Overall, greater STP will be achieved when firms can scale
non-stop competition for alpha forces managers to continually their business through electronic assistance in executing and
innovate and improve execution capabilities, and b) the “institu- settling trades.
tionalisation” of hedge funds is driving deeper and more sophis- This should lead to an increased velocity of trading, and in
ticated reliance on information technologies to provide a quality the end, greater profits.
investment platform for clients. Ultimately, the evolution of
more sophisticated algorithms will enable hedge fund managers
to have greater success implementing their existing strategies in
a more efficient manner.
INVESTOR SERVICES JOURNAL 29
Analyse this...Hedge Funds
What opportunities do hedge funds currently present to Comment on the types of insurance available for the
service providers? Comment on opportunities for hedge directors and officers of hedge funds?
fund service providers from a hedge fund
outsourcing/servicing perspective?
How realistic is the possibility of one global regulator for As the hedge fund industry continues to grow, how relevant
the hedge funds industry? is the role of the fund administrator as a “watchdog” for
these funds and the guardian of investors’ interests?
Gavin Gray, Managing Director, Phoenix Financial Services
Limited Tony McDonnell, Head of Sales and CRM, Dublin, HSBC's
Alternative Fund Services
In looking at the prospects for international convergence of
regulation for the hedge fund industry, it is necessary to con- It is exactly because the hedge fund industry has seen such
sider the recent pronouncements of the key global regulatory explosive growth (and because it is widely accepted that this
bodies in regard to hedge fund regulation. growth will continue albeit on a region by region or strategy
In the US, following the publication of the Securities and
by strategy basis) that the role of the administrator has
Exchange Commission Staff Report on Implications of the
Growth in Hedge Funds, we have seen the adoption of the become even more important and diverse.
new Hedge Fund Adviser Registration Rule. The new rule, Fund administrators have always been acutely aware of their
which significantly curtails the 15 client exemption previously role as fiduciaries to a fund’s investors.
available to advisers, will have the effect of significantly However, the drivers for growth in the hedge fund space
extending the US SEC’s ‘corporate governance’ style regula- i.e. the push for return and increased use of sophisticated
tion into the hedge fund adviser arena. strategies and instruments, add complexity at a time when
Following the recent EU Green Paper on the Enhancement there is a demand for greater clarity and more information.
of the EU Framework for Investment Funds, we have had the These two opposing elements, mean that the entity holding
announcement that the EU will establish an industry working direct relationships with all parties in the fund management
group to study whether a common regulatory approach, with- lifecycle, with an overview of the whole process, is best posi-
in the EU, can facilitate the further development of the tioned to both provide information and also act as an inter-
European markets for hedge funds and private equity funds. face between all parties.
Alongside the publication of this paper, the EU indicated that That entity is the fund administrator. It is becoming
its current view is that there is no compelling case for EU leg- necessary for fund administrators to work closely
islation on hedge funds and indicated that there is no demand alongside their fund manager clients – allowing them to
from market participants for EU coordination to remove bar- outsource those areas of the business that are not core
riers to market access. However, the EU did outline that the competencies such as NAV's, performance measurement,
gradual market opening towards retail investors does, along trading platforms, etc.
with a number of other issues, deserve further attention.
The role is not simply one of oversight but rather active
In the UK, the Financial Services Authority has recently pub-
lished two discussion papers related to the hedge fund indus- participation in an iterative relationship that reflects the
try. One of these focuses on the risks hedge funds present to manager’s internal and external requirements at any given
the FSA’s statutory objectives and confirms the establishment time.
of a dedicated centre of hedge fund expertise within the FSA. Moreover, as fund managers are faced with increasing
The second paper looks at the regulatory regime that applies regulatory requirements, the administrators’ role will become
to sophisticated investment products, including hedge funds, significantly relevant in this area in terms of guiding
and particularly wider range retail investment products. managers through the plethora of new regulations and
These pronouncements highlight the fact that that there are tax requirements, reporting etc.
a number of relatively common issues of key concern to the While small, emergent managers have always needed
global regulators in the area of hedge funds, such as increased (and utilised) the specialist knowledge, skills and services
focus on the regulation of the operations of the hedge fund that administrators provide, it is the institutionalisation of
manager/adviser and the entry of the hedge fund product the hedge fund business which is having the greatest impact,
into the retail arena. bringing as it does, the demand for greater transparency,
However, having these regulatory bodies focus on common independent third party oversight and the reassurance that
concerns and asking them to defer to one global regulatory comes from looking at the institution behind the fund.
body are two entirely different matters. While we are currently
seeing the former the only foreseeable potential for increasing
the likelihood of the latter scenario would appear to be in the
hands of the EU, and the outcome of any discussions with
industry on a common regulatory approach.
Looking Up
June 2005 proved to be a good month for hedge fund performance,
according to the latest results from Hedge Fund Research
Incorporated. ISJ presents the latest data
Good fortune blessed the hedge funds industry in June of return for this index was -5.47 for the year to
2005, according to HFR. The company’s Fund Weighted June 2005.
Composite index posted a rate of return of 1.63 for June
2005. Fund of Funds
This result compares favourably with the result of 1.91 for Fund of Funds performed well during June 2005,
the year to June 2005. according to HFR’s performance results.
The HFRI Regulation D category performed well in June The top performer was the HFRI Fund of Funds:
with a return of 3.47. The return from this index for the Market Defensive Index, which delivered a return
year to June 2005 was 7. of 2.17 for June 2005.
The HFRI Sector (Total) returned 2.34 for June 2005, The same index delivered an overall return of
whereas performance for this sector for the year to June 0.38 for the year to June 2005. The HFRI Fund of
2005 delivered a return of just 1.30 Funds: Strategic Index also performed favourably,
The HFRI Short Selling Index delivered a return of 1.66 for with a return of 1.82 for June 2005.
the month of June 2005. The return posted by this category Long-term performance for this Index was 1.70
for the year to June 2005 was a brilliant 8. for the year to June 2005.
Emerging markets proved to be a worthwhile investment, The weakest performer in Fund of Fund terms
with the HFRI Emerging Markets Index reporting a return was the HFRI Fund of Funds: Conservative
of 1.67 for June 2005. This Index delivered a return of 5.52 Index, which delivered a return of 0.88 for June
for the year to June 2005. 2005.
The weakest performance for the month of June 2005 came The Index delivered a rate of return of 0.72 for
from the HFRI Equity Market Neutral Index: Statistical the year to June 2005.
Arbitrage. Overall performance for this index for the year It is worth noting that the HFRI Fund
to June 2005 was 1.85 Weighted Composite Index delivered a return of
Another index worth noting is the HFRI Convertible 1.63 in June 2005, while its Fund of Fund coun-
Arbitrage Index. terpart delivered a return of 1.36 for the year to
This index reported return of 1.02 for June 2005. The rate June 2005.
Over the year to June 2005, the HFRI Fund
HFR Hedge Funds Index Rate of Return June 2005 Weighted Composite Index delivered a return of
JUN YTD 2005
1.91, whereas the Fund of Fund Weighted
HFRI Fund Weighted Composite 1.63 1.91 Composite was 1.02 for the year to June 2005.
HFRI Convertible Arbitrage 1.02 -5.47
HFRI Distressed Securities 1.41 2.62
HFRI Emerging Markets (Total) 1.67 5.52
Market Benchmarks
HFRI Equity Hedge Index 2.00 1.76
All but one of the leading market indices per-
HFRI Equity Market Neutral 0.79 2.87 formed favourably in June 2005. The top per-
HFRI Equity Market Neutral: Stat. 0.43 1.85 former was the HFRI Fund Weighted Composite
Arb.
HFRI Equity Non-Hedge 2.81 1.28
Index, with a return of 1.63. The NASDAQ
HFRI Event-Driven 1.40 1.82 Composite Index had a poor month, with a
HFRI Fixed Income (Total) 0.72 2.22 return of -0.54 for June 2005.
HFRI Macro 1.15 0.98 The second best performance was delivered by
HFRI Market Timing 1.71 3.11
the Lehman Brothers Aggregate Corporate Bond
HFRI Merger Arbitrage Index 1.23 2.20
HFRI Regulation D 3.47 7.00
Index: 0.85 for June 2005. Its counterpart, the
HFRI Relative Value Arb. 0.80 0.46 Lehman Aggregate US Government Bond Index,
HFRI Sector (Total) 2.34 1.30 delivered a return of 0.61 for June 2005. The
HFRI Short Selling 1.66 8.00
Source: HFR
Miller Insurance Services Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority
Custody - Benelux
Centre
Dutch pension fund trustees are under increasing pressure
from the regulator, making them more open to out sourcing
and to hiring a professional firm for custody and other
administrative services,” says van Katwijk. “We anticipate
Strength
that being a local provider of services will give us the best
opportunity in this space.”
Citigroup also stands to benefit from asset pooling, which
will become a major trend in the pension fund pooling space
In the last decade, Belgium, the Netherlands and in the coming years. “Individual markets and individual leg-
Luxembourg have become test drivers of new rules intended islation will evolve into a European space,” says van Katwijk.
for implementation across Europe. As far as regulation is “Asset management is the first area where it is now possible
concerned, these countries often have first hand knowledge to bring assets into a single pool across jurisdictions and
of new developments emanating from Brussels and can act legal entities in the European Union. Local pension funds in
accordingly. Financial service providers have a similar advan- the European community will benefit from this develop-
tage. Their countries were among the first to enact regula- ment. Pension services companies in Holland are beginning
tions for hedge funds, providing custodians with significant to acquire third party businesses, providing them with a
servicing opportunities. These opportunities have spurred larger region to serve when pension funds mature and invest
providers to fine tune their core competencies, paving the further into the European Union. Alternative investments are
way for outsourcing deals in the Benelux region. On decid- permissible under the current investment laws. Pension
ing to stick with global custody services in their core offer- funds will allocate more money to
ing, ABN AMRO sold its domestic custody operations in hedge funds, which provide a better
eight markets (amongst them the Netherlands) to Citigroup, return.”
making the US provider the largest sub-custodian in the An evolving infrastructure and
Netherlands and furthering consolidation in the securities tightening investment laws are set to
services sector. trigger further consolidation among
Custodians who are present in the Dutch market stand to service providers in the Benelux
benefit from the newly-announced pensions legislation. The region. “The clients will have a limit-
Dutch government is also committed to positioning the ed choice of providers who are com-
Dutch funds industry more competitively. “The offshore peting for the same business. These
centres of Luxembourg and Dublin have tax advantages and clients are more inclined to choose
friendly regulatory regimes,” says Sikko van Katwijk, strategic partners to work with. ”
Managing Director, Citigroup Global Transaction Services Sikko van Katwijk
EMEA. “The Dutch government is focusing on changing the
current legislation for the Dutch funds business in order to Mergers
compete more effectively.” The foremost example of securities services provider con-
Consolidation among securities services providers in the solidation in the Benelux region is that of Dexia with
Benelux region is impacted by underlying changes within the Canada’s RBC. While this development is important, it has
securities infrastructure globally and within the European minimal impact on the banks who are firmly established in
Union. “We are trying to be as scaleable as possible in order the region. Providers like BNP Paribas Securities Services
to prepare for what we see as the next phase of development (BP2S) are nonetheless mindful of this consolidation and
in the securities industry,” says van Katwijk. “International continue to seek out new opportunities in the region.
Central Securities Depositories such as Euroclear and Securities services providers in the Belgian market will be
Clearstream are moving up the value chain and are consoli- heavily impacted by the imminent arrival of a local law that
dating with the local markets. Euroclear has acquired the will allow investment funds to lend some of their assets to
local CSDs in Holland, France and Portugal. As part of our other institutional investors like pension funds, insurance
deal with ABN AMRO, we are trying to establish ourselves as companies or brokers.
a provider of more than just sub-custody activities. Based on “This is a major advantage for the Belgian market and an
the assumption that clients will, in the future, connect direct- opportunity for these institutions to earn an extra return on
the assets they hold,” says Renaud Vandenplas, BP2S' head central securities depositories in the region. ABN AMRO
of location in Belgium. “Currently being prepared, the law is Mellon Global Securities Services (GSS) recently announced
not expected to come into force before the end of the year, the launch of in inhouse custody operation in the
or even until the beginning of 2006.” Netherlands. “This shows our commitment to the Dutch
With a strong presence in the Benelux region and in the market and to our clients in this market,” says John Gout,
Euronext market, BP2S is confident it will hold its own in senior sales manager for the Benelux region. “This is our
the face of increasing consolidation. “Although the merger of home market and most of our senior management are of
Dexia and RBC on the one hand and Credit Agricole and Dutch origin. Having a connection to the market makes our
Cas d’Epargne on the other gives them a bigger size, we are infrastructure much more efficient from an STP, control and
confident about our position in this market. Similarly, the risk point of view.”
outcome of a possible merger between European stock
exchanges is dependent on whether Euronext or the “Asset management is the first area where it is
Deutsche Borse will succeed in their bid for the London
Stock Exchange. Whatever the outcome, we are well estab-
now possible to bring assets into a single pool
lished in the Euronext market and have a respectable posi- across jurisdictions and legal entities in the
tion in Germany. But if Euronext has proposed to place European Union”
their central office in London if it wins the bid, does this
mean our trading and settlement operations could move to As one of the largest pension fund markets in Europe, the
London? Certainly not. Nevertheless, there many unknown Netherlands is regarded as the land of opportunity. Gout
impacts. But we are comfortable, having the size and a pres- explains: “We are having interesting discussions with corpo-
ence in all markets concerned, including London.” rate pension funds, who are feeling the heat of the new
accounting rules. They have to change their asset structures
Law of the Land in order to avoid any fluctuations in the company balance
Belgium’s new securities lending law would translate into sheet, occurring from the liabilities of the pension fund.
extra revenue for investment funds, who would be able to lend Clients want us to add liability information when reporting
their assets through a securities lending provider. “In addition for them. Accounting, reporting and risk management tools
to securities lending, providers can offer a host of value added are key. We are shifting our conversations from traditional
services, including settlement, the management of the securi- custody and safe keeping to data provision, consolidating
ties lending process and the corporate actions,” says individual information on whatever level our clients would
Vandenplas. like. The discussions are getting more sophisticated and are
Despite new laws allowing for hedge funds in Belgium, the centred on regulatory reporting, performance measurement,
industry has had a prolonged take off. “The Belgian market is risk management and data warehousing.”
quite small compared to Germany, France and Italy, as there The Dutch regulator has introduced asset liability match-
are a smaller number of institutional investors who are ready ing laws for corporate pension funds. “This is a big change
to invest in such asset classes that are more risky and less well for the pensions community,” says Gout. “Previously, these
known,” says Vandenplas. “The Belgian investor is not very funds had a calculation rate of four per cent. They now have
fond of a lot of risk. He tends to invest in new products later to follow the market interest rates when matching assets with
rather than sooner.” liabilities. Rate fluctuation has implications on matching
In addition to hedge funds, STP and levels of automation in assets with liabilities. As a consequence these funds are look-
the Belgian market are low. “On the pure buyside, STP levels ing for derivative-related instruments, which enable them to
are far from 90 per cent,” says Vandenplas. “There is a lack of control the liability matching issue. Custodians who can
market standards for a lot of instruments, including invest- offer clients the systems, which can handle those exotic
ment funds. Competing STP platforms do not help. Small instruments (derivatives), are in favour. Most investments
fund managers in Belgium do not have the skills or the finan- are related to matching assets with liabilities. Any liquidity
cial means to invest in an automated process. Some of them left is likely to be steered towards generating alpha. At the
still send faxes to their agent in order to process orders. STP moment, everybody is looking at hedge funds and com-
levels have improved in recent years, but they are still far away modities are getting quite interesting. Pension funds are
from 90 per cent.” starting to put sizeable amounts into hedge funds. These
BP2S and other service providers in Belgium are awaiting investments have risk and transparency issues. Pensions
the outcome of Euronext’s and the Deutsche Borse’s bids for funds find it extremely difficult to get the necessary data out
the London Stock Exchange and the impact this will have on of hedge fund managers on a regular basis, once a month if
the settlement platforms. “We welcome competition between possible. But this data enables them to find out what the
the providers and the settlement infrastructure, but this com- allocations are and it ensures transparency. We provide look-
petition should be open and fair. We are taking the necessary through vehicles to enable pension funds to look through
measures to study the legal text emanating from the European the fund and to find out the allocation to the fund. It gives
Commission and undertaking the necessary actions to ensure the pension fund the transparency and the knowledge of
fair and open competition. This could have a major impact where the hedge fund is investing. Dutch pension funds are
for the securities services landscape in the coming years.” investing in hedge funds and we have to ensure we provide
the accounting and the performance tools relating to those
Locale funds.”
In order to commit to the Benelux countries, custody In addition to look-through vehicles, custodians provide
providers have established connections with the relevant the necessary technology to accommodate the range of
investment vehicles available. “Of course everybody can do underlying administrators to ensure they can deliver the
the traditional instruments but if you look at OTC deriva- information we need in an electronic format, which makes
tives, this is very much a fax/ e-mail based market,” says it easy for us to consolidate that information,” says Knapen.
Gout. “The STP levels among alternative investments are “If a client is directly investing in a variety of hedge funds,
not great, but this it still not a very developed market.” they will get information in different types of formats, dif-
Most service providers in Europe currently welcome a ferent contract notes, different types of statements all from
DTCC-style approach to the securities confirmation and different time zones. We consolidate this information to
affirmation process. “We are certainly not there yet, but any ensure our client receives it in one format. Citco Bank com-
consolidation is good from an IT point of view and an effi- pletes these documents for its clients. Although we do not
ciency and cost reduction point of view,” says Gout. “We are see any change to this labour intensive work in the short
hoping for a DTCC style approach for Europe and perhaps term we do see a change in the number of administrators
later in Asia and agree with the concept of harmonisation who can deliver information electronically.”
and consolidation in the long term. This would make the
world a better place to work in.” United
As a pioneer of industry consolidation, ABN AMRO Mellon Systems and technology are a key theme for Luxembourg’s
is continuing its quest for economies of scale. “Typically Credit Agricole Investor Services, which recently joined
when there is a joint venture or merger people always ques- forces with Caisse d’Epargne to provide additional services
tion how long these arrangements will last. We have a great to the Spanish market. The new Group, to be called
story to tell in this regard,” says Gout. “Pension funds and CACEIS, already has fund administration operations in
asset managers are also joining forces. Today, I may be talk- Luxembourg, Brussels and Amsterdam and is hopeful that
ing to a small to medium-sized client, which may be part of the regulators in these countries will drop their guard about
a bigger group tomorrow. Custodians should think about where fund safekeeping and administration should be car-
this. Smaller clients may generate small revenues but you ried out. In Holland for example, funds are legally obliged to
have to look at the bigger picture as tomorrow they may be custodise assets in their country of origin.
part of a larger organisation.” Commenting on the impact of the RBC/Dexia merger on
CACEIS, Bens says: “It is a nice move but integration still
Alternatives needs to take place. We definetely will see more of these con-
Citco Bank is an international player which provides cus- solidation processes in the securities services business in the
tody services to large- and private banks that are active in the months to come. CACEIS is another example of this trend.”
hedge- and mutual funds industry. “An increasing number of While Holland presents the largest pensions market in the
institutions are investing in alternative products,” says Mark Benelux region for CACEIS and other providers, countries
Knapen, Marketing Manager, Citco Bank Nederland N.V. such as Belgium and Luxembourg have to modify their regu-
“These traditional banks are looking to outsource parts of latory frameworks to address their underdeveloped pensions
their business relating to the hedge- and mutual funds markets. “Luxembourg will manage this better because the
industry. This part of the business has a significant impact domestic market is very small,” says Bens. “The domicile can
on their systems. Economies of scale are required in order to provide one solution to offer to pension schemes across
justify the investment in the infrastructure, and to continual- Europe. The SEPCAV, created a few years ago, did not gener-
ly change your systems in order to handle investments in ate the success levels everybody hoped for. But there are reg-
these funds.” ulatory discussions in Luxembourg to be able to provide a
Citco also targets fund of hedge fund managers by provid- European passport for pension schemes.”
ing administration and transfer agency services to their Despite a hopeful attitude towards hedge funds in Europe,
funds through Citco Fund Services and custody is supplied Bens admits that these funds are clearly not based on the
through Citco Bank. Continent. “The asset managers may be based in the US or in
“Fund of funds investing in hedge funds need a custodian or Europe but the products they manage are definitely based
a single point of access in order to consolidate all of their offshore,” he says. “While there has been a lot of talk about
investments in the various single manager funds,” says hedge funds and fund of hedge funds, there has also been a
Knapen. “A lot of fund of hedge fund managers are looking lot of fear. The UK Financial Services Authority is suggesting
for a combined custody and administration service or a so to the Alternative Investment Management Association the
called one- stop shopping concept. Particularly in markets installation a guidance code, instead of waiting for the frame-
like Germany, where hedge funds are emerging, transparency work to be passed down from the regulatory bodies in
is a must. A lot of hedge funds and fund of funds managers Europe.”
are trying to provide transparency because investors such as While Bens admits that Luxembourg has attracted a fair
pension funds and insurance companies are highly regulat- share of the hedge fund market, the domicile is chiefly a cen-
ed. The increase in transparency requirements is largely due tre for fund of hedge funds. “UCITS III is still being imple-
to the institutionalisation of the hedge funds industry. We mented in Belgium, Luxembourg and Holland,” he says.
try to deliver transparency as much as possible by investing “Most of the products distributed in Holland are domiciled
in the necessary systems, although it is difficult to deliver the in Luxembourg. Only a few fund promoters in Luxembourg
transparency if the underlying target funds in a hedge fund have converted to the UCITS III regulation. This will provide
are not providing this transparency.” the industry with a challenge, when fund companies attempt
To ensure transparency, Citco Bank ensures that the to implement UCITS III at the same time. The European
administrator with whom it has to place hedge fund orders Commission has issued a Green Paper which which seeks to
has set up a digital format of order placement and settle- clarify the investment funds landscape. It will be interesting
ment communication. “We try to establish alliances with the to see what comes out of that.”
With an expert knowledge of the Luxembourg, Holland kits to better understand their assets and liabilities. Some of
and Belgium markets, Bens believes the development of pen- these funds need to look into their returns and consider
sion schemes in Holland will prove extremely beneficial to instruments such as long term swaps, which in turn require
securities services providers. “We are one of the largest third collateral management services we can deliver.”
party providers in Belgium and we hope to grow here,” he “We service Dutch and Belgium players with the global
says. “We are still looking for business in Luxembourg, custody product, which will not be affected by developments
where service providers who can cope with the requirements at Euronext, Euroclear, Clearstream and the Deutsche Börse.
of UCITS III and the European Union Savings Directive will The global custody franchise is more affected by the regula-
win the business. We look forward to more opportunities tory environment for pension funds. As far as clearing and
coming out of these directives.” sub-custody services are concerned, the consolidation of the
settlement and clearing infrastructure is very high on our
Opportunity agenda as the main European clearing services provider.”
While specialist service providers focus on regulation to Fortis has concentrated its European clearing and custody
acquire business, global providers like Fortis continue to activities in Amsterdam, supported by offices in Frankfurt
capitalise on opportunities created by the consolidation in and London.“Consolidation in the trading and clearing
securities services industry. Jan Bart de Boer, Global Director infrastructure in Europe will most likely involve either the
Commerce, Global Clearing & Custody, Fortis Bank says: Deutsche Börse Group and/or Euronext,” says de Boer. “It is
“The sale of ABN AMRO 's domestic custody business to important that we have a strong market position in both
Citigroup, for example, triggered an evaluation process pillars. We are developing as a local custodian in more
among ABN AMRO clients, which assessed whether they markets than just the Benelux region.”
should transfer to Citigroup or opt for another provider.
We were able to attract a number of clients following this
move. When people withdraw from the business it provides “There is a lack of market standards for a lot
us with opportunities to attract new clients, yet it is a bit of instruments, including investment funds”
hard to build a business model on such events.”
Another way of attracting clients, providers have found, is
via additions to the traditional custody product. “If you can Transatlantic partners
add something to the mature custody product, which will Following the announcement of its merger with RBC
save the client money or adds efficiency, you will continue to Global Services, Dexia Fund Services predicts further consol-
attract clients,” says de Boer. “Fortis integrated its electronic idation in the securities services industry. “These trends will
brokerage services with the clearing and custody product. continue in the foreseeable future,” says Gilles Reiter, Global
We offer this combination to our sub-custody clients and Head of Sales & Marketing at Dexia Fund Services. “Scale is
our global custody clients. We can take in brokerage flow via not everything but it is the key to a lot of other things. One
SWIFT, FIX and a number of proprietary systems. As this is of the objectives in joining forces with RBC Global Services
an intergrated product clients do not have to sent additional is to increase our scale. Pending regulatory approval, both
settlement instructions. This is a way of reducing their all-in partners will expand their geographical reach; broaden their
executing and operational costs.” service range and increase their investment capacity as a
Thanks to the Markets and Financial Instruments result of the merger. We are both on the same wave length
Directive, pension funds will have an opportunity to become and that’s really essential,” adds Reiter.
market participants by trading directly on a stock exchange. RBC Global Services is a well-established global custodian
“This, in turn, gives service providers the opportunity to whereas Dexia is officially recognised as one of Europe's top
offer direct market access solutions,” says de Boer. “Under fund administrators and transfer agents. “The extension of
FTL regulations Pension funds in the Netherlands also face asset optimisation services, which we will be able to offer in
challenges relating to their solvency levels. We have therefore addition to the core services of custody, fund administration
adopted a consultative approach towards pension funds and and transfer agency, makes for an excellent combination,”
are trying to deliver much-needed products and services. says Reiter.
Going the extra mile, we will provide these funds with tool Reiter acknowledges there are very distinct differences
.ETHERLANDS
(ONG +ONG
0EOPLE 4ECHNOLOGY
3INGAPORE
3WITZERLAND
"ELGIUM
#AYMAN )SLANDS WWWDEXIAFUNDSERVICESCOM
Custody - Benelux
between the asset servicing markets of Belgium, Luxembourg At a macro-level, despite the Dutch public's shunning of
and the Netherlands. “Luxembourg is the second largest centre the European Constitution, ING Securities Services is con-
for the administration of mutual funds world-wide,” he says. vinced that the advantages of European harmonisation and
“It is a very mature and innovative funds market. It is consid- consolidation far outweigh the disadvantages. “We are com-
ered an offshore market and has no domestic market as such. mitted to playing our part within a future integrated
When it comes to Belgium and the Netherlands, the domestic European capital market,” says Reichmann-Kops.
mutual funds are very small in size. The Netherlands makes The quest for one European CCP and one European
up one of the most sizeable pension fund markets in Europe.” CSD is gaining acceptance by providers like ING on a daily
basis. “The debate is characterised by concerns about
“We are having interesting discussions with further exchange-consolidation and the impact this
could have on intermediaries if a proper level of user
corporate pension funds, who are feeling influence is not provided for,” says Reichmann-Kops.
“We are actively discussing the minimum-require-
the heat of the new accounting rules” ments for user-involvement in infrastructures that are
Reiter predicts that the current bids for the London Stock de-facto monopolies and which users can not bypass.”
Exchange will have little impact on the European investment A variety of securities services providers want to stimulate
fund industry. “It may have an impact on transaction costs, harmonisation and consolidation of the post trade environ-
which are higher in Europe than in the US” he says. “In this ment in order to decrease the costs of cross border-trading in
regard, consolidation may benefit the investors.” Europe. “This requires the formation of one European CCP
Pending regulatory clearances, one of the key objectives of and one European CSD,” says Reichmann-Kops. “These enti-
the RBC Global Services and Dexia Fund Services alliance is to ties could operate in the same way as SWIFT. It should be
increase the merged entities’ activities in the European pen- governed by users, it should want to create efficiency for its
sion fund sector. “The knowledge and recognition of our serv- users and it should be financially independent on members to
ices in this mutual fund market paves our way to become a develop new initiatives.”
more active player in the servicing of pension funds,” says Clearing and settlement procedures have an impact on the
Reiter. “The domestic pension fund markets in France, Italy pension funds market in the Benelux region. These pension
and Belgium will create further opportunities. We are current- funds also are impacted by the interim reporting of hedge
ly analysing the pension pooling vehicles in Luxembourg results and the valuation of assets and liabilities. “Pension
where a lot of institutional, and increasingly retail, money is funds require frequent reporting on the “coverage ratio” in
invested into alternatives instruments such as fund of hedge particular,” says Reichmann-Kops.
funds, private equity, venture capital and property funds.” The implementation of the Prospective Directive in The
In addition to Luxembourg, Dexia services hedge funds in Netherlands' Securities Transaction Supervision Act aims to
Dublin, South East Asia and France. “If it makes sense, accord- create a single European passport for prospectus approval. As
ing to a client's distribution policy, to have the vehicle domi- a result a prospectus approved in one European country is
ciled in the Cayman Islands and serviced out of Dublin, that is also valid in other EEC member countries. The Directive
the service we will offer to them,” says Reiter. “Compliance and requires the appointment of one central authority per juris-
regulation will increase in importance, creating opportunities diction, in this case the Authority for the Financial Markets in
for service providers. It accelerates outsourcing and will also the Netherlands, which must approve prospectuses.
affect consolidation among service providers. There are a One of the most amended parts of the Act is that which
number of service providers, especially in domestic markets, relates to the prohibition of inside information trades. Dutch
who will find it difficult to cope with the systems required to legislation is presently subject to an overall review. In the
satisfy the new regulatory regime. Other providers may see future, the current Netherlands' Securities Transaction
this as an opportunity.” Supervision Act will be replaced by one all embracing act, the
Act on Financial Supervision.
Infrastructure “We expect further developments as a result of the
Commenting on the changes to the clearing and settlement implementation of MiFID,” says Reichmann-Kops. “This
infrastructure, Ingrid Reichmann-Kops, Director of Marketing includes specific rules for acting as internal systemisor, a role
and Sales at ING Securities Services, highlights the change in currently prohibited in the Dutch market. We expect further
ownership of the Dutch CSD Euroclear Nederland from harmonisation of the regulations governing the content, for-
Euroclear Bank SA/NV to Euroclear SA/NV. “In the new mat, approval and publication of prospectuses around
structure, Euroclear Bank SA/NV is a sister company,” she Europe, effective from 1 July 2005. ING is actively involved in
says. all the relevant working groups and consultative bodies. The
In June this year, the Euroclear Settlement for Euronext- same applies where operational efficiencies are possible. The
zone securities (ESES) MSC (Market Steering Committee) key issue in our market is the ongoing harmonisation within
and the Cross-border MAC (Market Advisory Committee) the European clearing and custody markets. These could (or
advised the Euroclear Board to proceed with the ESES project. should) lead to a future where there are competing trading
“ING expects that the Euroclear Board will follow this advice,” platforms, but one clearing platform and one settlement plat-
says Reichmann-Kops. “ESES represents the first step in the form for a large chunk of Europe's markets. The implementa-
consolidation of Euroclear's settlement platforms. It will offer tion of ESES for the Dutch market, originally planned for end
streamlined settlement for the three Euronext markets and it 2007, will be reviewed in the context of the revised planning
precedes the implementation the Single Application of the (Euroclear) TARGET II project.” ISJ
Platform.”
www.abnamromellon.com
Outsourcing
re-evaluating the best locations for services but there are these providers for all their
a lot of complex trade offs which have to be made,” says services instead of going through
Abraham. “The desire to move functions offshore has its a full RFP exercise with other
challenges, some of which are regulatory, cultural, lan- providers. For each service, a
guage-based and based on finding people with the requi- provider has a differente advan-
site skills. We have people in over 100 countries.” tage over the others. For example,
Abraham is confident that financial institutions will the time and effort to complete
continue to explore a range of outsourcing options. “The transitions in the investment
basic economic factors that have driven these decisions administration and fund
will continue,” he says. “People will be a bit more careful accounting area, may seem risky
in terms of how they select their providers and the terms to consolidate away from that
of the contract. Providers have an opportunity to distin- provider. The existing custodian
guish themselves in terms of how they execute the deals Paul Stillabower has a price advantage generated
and not necessarily by taking on more deals and bigger from holding the assets.
deals. These are very difficult transactions to undertake, HSBC Securities Services has recorded a lot of interest
especially when you’re stepping into firms and helping in both component-bundling and in lift outs. “The
them change their overall business model. This change initial lift out deals were a lot about technology, where
has to be managed carefully. We distinguish ourselves the suppliers did not have sufficiently advanced or
from other providers by our quality of execution.”
Partners
“The desire to move functions offshore has
The partnership approach between service provider its challenges, some of which are regulatory,
and the company that has outsourced also has its trade
offs. “We are very much dependent on each other,” says cultural and based on finding people
Abraham. “If we do something wrong they feel it or if
they do something wrong then we feel it. That is a key
with the requisite skills”
element of making these transactions work, realising that future-proof technology to support their middle office.
you both have to work at making them succeed. We are seeing less of these deals because suppliers have
Historically, when looking at some of the other transac- or are working towards strategic platforms. There is still
tions, there has not been this sense of sharing. We’re a lot of interest in lift outs but owing to the initial push
reluctant to use the word partnership because it is over- a lot of suppliers already have their platform partners.
used to a degree. But clearly we share the responsibility These technology lift out contracts, for the most part,
and the risk. We have to recognise this and work more are not re-emerging, yet.
closely together.” “Once the original lift out deals have reached their
contract term – i.e. five or seven years - a client may
Components decide to re-enter the market and look at other outsource
According to Paul Stillabower, global head of business service suppliers. Although it seem risky to transition
development at HSBC Securities Services, 2004 was more from the existing supplier, the process may be easier if
lift-out oriented than 2005. “There have been a lot of that particular client has not been integrated within the
outsourcing initiatives in 2005 but the number of clients provider's strategic platform.”
looking for lift outs has slowed. However, we have seen a The beauty of component bundling is that it can involve
lot of interest in component outsourcing where clients more complex services or functions such as performance
are looking to their existing suppliers for more services,” measurement, derivatives and futures clearing, and broker
he says. execution in addition to the more traditional custody and
“If clients have outsourced custody to one firm, invest- fund administration services. This gives the supplier pric-
ment accounting to another and performance measure- ing power and minimises transition risk for the client.
ment to a third, they may opt to consolidate with one of “This arrangement plays to the strengths of global banks
Outsourcing
who have deep pockets and wide product ranges to sup- or strategic cash management in house. A separation of
port it,” says Stillabower. those functions has gathered a lot of interest in 2005.”
In response to the suggestion that outsourcing can Specialist accounting for derivatives and derivatives
enhance an asset manager's shareholder value, service and futures clearing are functions which clients are
providers deliver mixed views. “From a supplier's per- beginning to farm out on a component basis.
spective, we would love to say that by putting business To this end, Stillabower predicts an increase in compo-
with the supplier community you can increase share- nent based outsourcing. “Clients have the comfort of
holder value,” says Stillabower. “In certain instances, dealing with a provider they may already be doing busi-
depending on how the transaction is struck and how it is ness with. The client knows the provider culturally and
accounted has a functioning relationship manager to serve the rela-
for, you may see a surge in shareholder value. I don't tionship. Additionally, the client knows the service struc-
think anyone disputes that firms who outsource and ture of the provider as well as who constitutes the man-
focus on product development, marketing, distribution agement team. That, from a European perspective is a
of their products and asset selection are following a log- differentiator for HSBC Securities Services.”
ical path but there are numerous factors that determine In contrast to component bundling, Stillabower
success. The large global asset managers generally have expects a decrease in the number of technology-based lift
more processing scale and brand, which allows them to out deals, owing to capacity constraints and execution
do more internally than middle-sized, locally focused quality issues. “The market will continue to push towards
the private client space, including segregated private
“People will be a bit more careful in client investment outsourcing and more pan-European
retail custody services. We are seeing a lot of interest in
terms of how they select their providers our broker custody product. This is provided in conjunc-
and the terms of the contract” tion with HSBC's Investment Bank which provides the
broker clearing and execution services. HSBC Securities
managers who have large middle and back office func- Services provide the custody and the client does not pay
tions accumulated over the years. Hedge funds managers, any transaction charges. This is a good fit for the retail
by contrast, are start ups who have no baggage and who clients, which execute a lot of trades.”
start up fully outsourced. The question about sharehold- In addition to outsourcing opportunities in the retail
er value depends on the supplier. Again, integration is sector, Stillabower foresees consolidation among suppli-
critical. If deals are not being integrated onto strategic ers. “Margins and prices are continuing to squeeze,” he
platforms, it becomes harder for the service provider to says. “The available resources plays to the strengths of the
manage the deal. If the service is not bedded down, global banks who have deep pockets, a lot of resources
whether you have a cheque or some value delivered in and are not really dependent on their share price to sur-
year one, year two or year three, the contract becomes vive. A lot of firms have to focus on quarterly earnings to
dilutive over five, seven or 10 years. A client may find support their share price for survival. They are heavily
that in year’s five, six and seven you are adding people to dependent on asset servicing and that is going to contin-
make up for some of your supplier shortfalls.” ue to cause problems unless the stock markets pick up
As a consequence of capacity constraints in the securi- drastically.”
ties services industry, buyside firms who are currently
looking for an outsourcing partner are finding their Institutional investors
options are limited as providers are quite full up. The pace of outsourcing by fund managers and pen-
“Suppliers are quite interested and you will find, out of sion funds continues to be strong, says Suresh Gupta,
the eight or nine suppliers in the market, a provider who partner at Capco. Fellow Capco partner Pedro
is willing to do the deal,” says Stillabower. “But their tran- Matthynssens, adds that there is a convincing economic
sition times and workloads may make for a risky situa- and strategic rationale for outsourcing. “Outsourcing
tion. The result is that clients are focusing on the compo- buyside middle and back office can typically generate an
nents of their services that are causing them pain.” equivalent value of three to six basis points of assets
Over the last year, HSBC Securities Services has seen under management,” he says. “Until last year custodians
more interest in trade matching and settlement services. offered to take over entire buy-side operations of large
“We can offer a bespoke trade matching and settlement scale asset managers with favourable offers based on a
service on a modular basis. The clients we provide these business case that migrates them onto a common archi-
services for may consider fitting this service in with tecture. But the migration to a common architecture
another service we could already be providing for them,” often compromises the asset manager's functionality,
says Stillabower. Other areas of interest include securities resulting in a systems integration nightmare for the cus-
pricing and valuation and securities related treasury todian. Also, as revenues for asset managers have begun
activity. “The whole valuation process, especially for to improve, they have become more hesitant to take the
complex instruments which require daily pricings also an big outsourcing step and the business case gains limited
issue,” says Stillabower. “In addition, clients are also con- traction.”
sidering outsourcing treasury functions in relation to
securities related foreign exchange and the related cash Offshoring
forecasting whilst keeping strategic hedging of currencies Fund managers are beginning to offshore pieces of the
middle office and back office activities. “This incre- benefits of superior technology deployed by a vendor,
mental approach reduces the risk and cost of implemen- thereby releasing capital for revenue-generating business.
tation, and can produce quick wins,” says Matthynssens. Information and data management and corporate
As part of the drive towards offshoring, the asset man- actions processing are among the functions that will be
agement divisions at Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley outsourced by financial institutions in the coming years.
and Fidelity, all have captive service centres in India. “There will be a growing number of asset managers, also
“Some hedge funds, including Gartmore Group, Venus sub scale and less sophisticated companies, outsourcing
Capital and Constellation Capital use offshore providers functions rather than complete middle and back offices,”
for a variety of middle office/back office functions, says Matthynssens. “This so-called component outsourc-
including, research, portfolio accounting, quantitative ing indicates that many asset managers still consider the
credit modelling and data mining,” says Gupta. “Many control of the entire operation a competitive advantage,
smaller fund managers have engaged offshore vendors for especially the large scale asset managers that have the
routine middle/back office functions, including asset ambition to play a consolidating role in the industry. But
accounting, custodian reconciliations, and portfolio valu- the opportunity to outsource functions without compro-
ations.” mising the functionality and control of the architecture
There appears to be growing demand, especially among as a whole will become more and more appealing for
sub scale asset managers for outsourcing key functions asset managers.”
instead of whole scale lift-out of an entire middle or Outsourcing providers and consulting firms predict a
continued componentisation of middle
“There have been a lot of outsourcing initiatives office and back office outsourcing,
involving functions such as reference
in 2005 and we have seen a lot of interest in data, corporate actions and reconcilia-
tions. “We foresee an increased share of
component outsourcing where clients are looking the outsourcing market by offshore
to their existing suppliers for more services” vendors or captive centres, putting
pressure on the Big 5 as well as a
back office. “Reference data and corporate actions are greater impetus by the large providers in boosting their
two such examples. The Big 5, including State Street, offshoring capabilities,” says Gupta. Matthynssens adds:
Bank of New York, JPMorgan, Citigroup and Mellon “Outsourcing will be characterised by an increasing
must adapt to meet this demand lest specialised importance of operational risk in outsourcing contracts.”
providers begin to encroach on their market share,” says
Gupta. Here to Stay
The so-called Big 5 have begun to counteract competi- It is certain that outsourcing is here to stay, says Mark
tion from offshore vendors by establishing centres in low Austin, Senior Vice President at JPMorgan Worldwide
cost locations. State Street, for example has a presence in Securities Services. “The gestation period for outsourcing
India and South Africa. JP Morgan and the Bank of New is a minimum of 18 months to two years. We know that a
York also have joint ventures in South Africa . number of chief operating officers were actively consid-
ering it two years ago and some of those deals began to
Risk flow through over in the last 12 months. As a result we
New laws such as Basel II have highlighted the impor- do not see the activity abating. The level of people
tance of operational risk. “New regulation increases the reviewing outsourcing is going to continue. A number of
capital allocation due to the operational risk implicit in people are re-reviewing their outsourcing decisions. Last
outsourcing,” says Matthynssens. “Outsourcers will year was about behind the scenes preparation, this year is
design contracts and procedures to mitigate risk. about the deals actually coming to fruition.”
Regulated outsourcers with big balance sheets will have a Most of Europe's top asset managers have already out-
competitive advantage.” sourced or partly outsourced. “If you run down the list of
Gupta and Matthynssens agree with the suggestion that names, the majority of asset managers have outsourced
outsourcing can enhance shareholder value, adding that in some way, shape or form, somewhere and to some-
it also saves money. “The three main reasons for out- one,” says Austin.
sourcing are scale, efficiency and risk,” Matthynssens Commenting on the recent outsourcing study by the
adds. “If half of the value released thanks to the scale and Bank of New York and Oxford Metrica, Austin says it is
efficiency, it represents a 1.5-3.0bp operating cost saving entirely appropriate to say that outsourcing can enhance
for the asset manager. Transition costs can be high but shareholder value. “I would refer you to some research
they are sometimes funded by the outsourcer. If the out- conducted by Henry McVeigh when at Morgan Stanley.
sourcer is also providing core custody services, costs of He defined a series of criteria to evaluate a winning fund
transition and service can be bundled in core custody management company. One of these was to look at
fees, spread over many years. Next generation outsourc- whether the company had outsourced or not. The ana-
ing will also focus on mitigating risk for the company lysts were firmly of the belief that outsourcing, done
that outsources.” properly, was a shareholder value enhancing exercise.
Faced with the prospect of heavy investments in There is no doubt that as outsourcing moves a business
upgrading technology, a company often can enjoy the forward, some of the headline costs – which could be
On Loan Securities lending group summary at 27 July 2005 (values presented in USD million)
Security Type
All Securities
Lendable
Assets (M)
5,993,497
Total Balance
(M)
1,413,704
Utilisation
(%)
17.16
SL Fee (Bp)
29.27
SL Return to
Lendable
Assets (Bp)
3.64
SL Tenure
(days)
111
Americas
including top performing Equities
Asian Equities
1,770,628
329,203
284,615
54,029
8.49
8.77
48.64
76.32
3.35
5.40
92
131
The total balance of assets on loan at this date was 2 DELTA AIR LINES INC 2 RHODIA SA
$1,41 trillion (in Table 1). Out of the total amount 3 FAIRFAX FINANCIAL 3 JEAN COUTU GROUP
of securities available for lending ($5,99 trillion), 4 OVERSTOCK.COM INC 4 FED. REP. OF BRAZIL
about 17.16 per cent of those securities were 5 NOVASTAR FINANCIAL 5 DELPHI CORP
utilised in a securities lending program. 6 PREPAID LEGAL 6 CINCINNATI BELL INC
Government bonds were clearly the most active 7 FED. REP. OF BRAZIL
7 NETFLIX INC
participants. Out of the total $1,199 trillion
8 ARCHIPELAGO 8 GENERAL MOTORS
available for lending, 41.92 per cent of that amount
9 BOWATER INC
was utilised in a securities lending programme. 9 CALPINE CORP
At 27 July 2005, the most lendable equity by fee was Source: Data Explorers Source: Data Explorers
Taser International (in Table 2), for equities that are Top 10 Lendable Equities Top 10 Lendable Corporates
27 July 2005 27 July 2005
greater than USD $ 100 million. Equities by Fee > 10 <100 mn Corporates by Fee > 10 <100mn
Rank Stock description
Rank Stock description
The Republic of Argentina (in Table 3) was the top 1 MARTHA STEWART
performing corporate stock at 27 July 2005 for 1 CALPINE CORP
2 EUROTUNNEL SA ESA
corporate stocks that are greater than USD $ 100 2 CALPINE CANADA
3 GLOBAL CROSSING
million 3 GENERAL MOTORS
4 MEDIS TECHNOLOGIES
4 GENERAL MOTORS
Martha Stewart (in Table 4) was the top 5 ANTIGENICS INC
5 YAHOO! INC
performing equity at 27 July 2005 for equities that 6 WPT ENTERPRISES INC
6 CALPINE CORP
are greater than USD $ 10 million but smaller than 7 IONATRON INC
USD $100 million. 8 GRAMMER AG
7 CONTINENTAL
8 CALPINE CORP
9 KRISPY K. DOUGHNUTS
Calpine Corporation (in Table 5) was the top 10 BIOLASE TECHNOLOGY
9 DELPHI CORP
performing corporate stock at 27 July 2005 for Source: Data Explorers
10 ICON H & F
corporates that are greater than USD $ 10 million Source: Data Explorers
but smaller than USD $ 100 million. Securities Lending & Reinvestment Return to
Lendable Assets (Bp)
8
0
4/13/2005
6/15/2005
4/27/2005
5/11/2005
6/8/2005
6/22/2005
5/25/2005
7/20/2005
4/20/2005
5/18/2005
6/29/2005
5/4/2005
4/6/2005
6/1/2005
7/6/2005
3/30/2005
7/13/2005
3/23/2005
7/27/2005
FINACE® is currently the only fully-integrated solution which supports FINACE® is a product of IFBS AG
future business models within the areas of Securities Finance and Buckhauserstrasse 11, CH-8048 Zurich
Collateral Management. With flexibility at its core, customer-driven Phone +41 (0)44 218 14 14
modifications and extensions can readily be implemented. www.finace- www.ifbs.com finace@ifbs.com
solution.com
Conference Digest - RMA Securities Lending preview
A Meeting
There are broker/dealers and agent lenders who feel the
language in this document needs to be softened, according
to one source, and that the document has a negative tone in
of Minds
how it addresses potential abuses in securities lending.
A session on structured finance followed, in which speak-
ers talked about the different asses classes being used and
how to assess the risks and rewards of swaps and other
derivative products.
The conference closed with a session, ostensibly about
technology, in which the panellists focused mainly on the
extent and impact of greater automation on both the trading
Securities lending events are and post-trade segments of the securities financing industry.
useful platforms for advancing Forthcoming Attraction
growth. Carol McGinn reports Agent lenders, broker/dealers, vendors, and other industry
participants will have an opportunity to discuss domestic
on the latest conference and issues at the RMA Conference on Securities Lending, to be
presents the expectations for the held October 18-21, in Boca Raton, Florida, USA.
The fall conference will open with a Securities Lending
next major securities lending Round Table, an open discussion where participants can dis-
cuss key issues affecting the industry. “I would expect this
conference in October 2005 round table to be quite informative,” says Anthony Schiavo,
Managing Director, Morgan Stanley, who, along with Louis
A business program reflecting the current issues affecting Molinari, President, Metropolitan West Securities LLC, is
securities lending in Europe was the focus of the ISLA/RMA chairing this conference.
14th Annual Conference on International Securities “I anticipate topics we might discuss will include agency
Lending, held this past May in Athens, Greece. An impressive lending disclosure and corporate governance.”
list of speakers, representing the borrowing and lending The conference continues on Wednesday with a session on
community as well as technology vendors, highlighted this developments in hedge funds and an industry leaders’ panel.
annual event, which drew almost 600 attendees.
The conference featured sessions on European clearing and Hedge Funds
settlement, the equity markets, regulatory issues, the fixed- Hedge funds continue to be an intriguing topic for both
income and equity markets, structured finance, and technol- lenders and borrowers.
ogy. Two prominent keynote speakers — Spyros Capralos, Panellists at this session are scheduled to discuss a variety of
chairman, Athens Stock Exchange, and David Taylor, author issues pertaining to the hedge fund industry that are of rele-
and 2004 European Business Speaker of the Year — rounded vance in the securities lending market. “We welcome the par-
out the comprehensive business program. ticipation of a number of hedge fund representatives, who
The conference opened on Wednesday, May 11, with wel- can provide us with insight into the growth of this segment
coming remarks from Conference Co-Chairs Philip of the market and the impact on the securities lending indus-
Reichardt, Director, Euroclear Bank, London, and Timothy try,” says Schiavo.
Douglas, Managing Director, Citigroup Global Markets, New The conference closes on Thursday with two sessions: one
York. Their remarks were followed by a panel discussion on on regulatory developments and the other on collateral man-
fixed income, hedge funds and equities. agement issues.
Speakers covered alternative investment strategies, focusing The regulatory panel, as always, is much anticipated, with
on growth among these strategies and if they are being ade- updates on the agent lending disclosure project, a discussion
quately serviced by the prime broker. on Reg. SHO, along with other topics related to broker/dealer
Wednesday’s program also featured panel presentations on net capital treatment.
European clearing and settlement, including a discussion on “The industry has invested a great deal of resources to com-
central bank money vs. commercial bank money and collat- ply with a number or regulatory changes that we have been
eralisation requirements, and on equity markets, where faced with,” says Schiavo. “This forum should provide
speakers discussed the opportunities and risks surrounding updates for a number of professionals that support our busi-
developing/emerging markets. ness.”
“The RMA Conference on Securities Lending business pro-
Regulation gram will once again attempt to reflect current and impor-
Thursday opened with a panel on regulatory issues, in par- tant issues facing our industry,” according to the co-chairs.
Securities on Loan
North American Treasuries/Bonds
on Loan Q2 2005 / Q2 2004 in
USD $ million
Analysis of the latest securities Canadian Bonds
Q2 2004
Q2 2005
lending industry results from US Corporate Bonds
100,000
150,000
300,000
200,000
50,000
350,000
250,000
ond quarter of 2004 Source: RMA
Replicating the pattern from the first quarter of this year, US European Equities on Loan Q2 2005 / Q2
2004 in USD $ million
treasuries were extremely active in securities lending during All other Eur. Equities
the second quarter. About USD $ 345,94 bn worth of US
treasury securities were on loan during the second quarter of Scandinavian Equities Q2 2004
2005, compared to USD$ 259,41 bn for the second quarter of UK Equities Q2 2005
2004. US Corporate bonds also enjoyed a good second quar-
Italian Equities
ter, with the value of securities on loan worth USD$ 70,197
bn, compared to USD$ 68,434 bn for the second quarter of German Equities
2004.
French Equities
10,000
40,000
15,000
45,000
30,000
20,000
5,000
35,000
European neighbours, with a total on loan worth USD$ 25,000
43,152 bn for the second quarter of 2005, compared to USD$ Source: RMA
second quarter of 2004 to USD $ 22,756 bn in the second 0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000 25,000
quarter of 2005. Australian equities were also fairly active in Source: RMA
Home Brew
SCHEME: SCOTTISH & NEWCASTLE PENSION FUND.
appointed by the company, two are independent, and three
are appointed by employee members and two from pension-
ers. The trustees have a long established Investment
Committee which handles investment matters a summary is
included in our SIP which is attached.
CUSTODIAN: THE BANK OF NEW YORK
SIZE OF FUND: £1.73BN. What is the investment strategy?
Our strategy is to achieve a return of 3% per annum above
Sterling risk free rate with a similar duration to our
liabilities, and to minimise the risk required to achieve this.
Currently we invest as follows to achieve this:
UK Equities - 15%; European Equities - 10%; Global
Ray Martin Equities - 20%; UK Bonds - 30%; Global Bonds - 10%
Commodities - 5%; Global Private Equity - 5%; Long Lease
Property - 5%
In 2004 a review of the assets and liabilities of the Plan was
carried out, and the Trustee consulted with the Principal
Employer to the Plan. Following this review it was agreed to
adopt the following long-term asset allocation: 70% growth
assets, 30% matching assets.
Ray Martin, HR director for Growth Assets include global equities, commodities, bonds
with yields above UK Gilts, private equity, hedge funds,
Reward and Group Office at property, and any other investment the Trustee believes will
Scottish & Newcastle Pension enhance returns or bring diversification. Matching assets are
an appropriate mix of fixed income and index linked bonds,
Fund talks to James Wallace both Government and Corporate. The Trustees believes this
investment policy is, on balance, appropriate for managing
about the fund’s set up the risks associated with our objectives, and is expected to
Who are the fund managers? provide a long-term return sufficiently in excess of the
The Trustees have delegated the choice of investment man- return available on long-dated UK Gilts to meet the
agers and their investment objectives and restrictions to an actuary's long-term funding assumptions. The Trustees
Investment Committee. The Trustees will be notified of any periodically review the objectives and the overall strategy of
changes in the investment managers selected by the the Fund. The Trustees will also monitor compliance with
Investment Committee at the meeting subsequent to any this Statement annually, responding to any material changes.
change.
The Trustees receive regular reports from the Investment How do you make decisions about where to invest?
Committee, including a summary of investment perform- We use a Value at Risk model to try to minimise the amount
ance as measured by an independent performance measure- of risk we take to achieve our return strategy. This leads to
ment service. The pension fund has appointed the following significant diversification of our Growth assets into a
fund managers: number of different asset classes.
UK Equities - Baillie Gifford, Liontrust, European Equities -
Fidelity, Global Equities - Capital, Wellington, Global Are there any investment restrictions?
Bonds - PIMCO, UK Bonds and Global Commodities - The Trustees have entered into a detailed investment
Barclays Global, Private Equity - Quellos, Property- management agreement with each investment manager and
Standard Life. each agreement includes the following restrictions: - Dealing
in shares or other investments of Scottish & Newcastle is not
Does the fund participate in a securities lending program? permitted (except within an index-tracking fund).
Yes. Our programme is operated through the Bank of New Adherence to all legal requirements and restrictions applying
York. It has been in operation since 1998 and we see it as an to exempt approved pension schemes.
important part of incremental added value to our portfolio.
It is, however, a relatively small component compared to our How important is corporate governance and socially respon-
commission recapture programme. We currently have no sible investment?
plans to increase or decrease the scale of the programme The Trustees have delegated responsibility for the selection,
over the small or medium-term. retention and realisation of investments to the investment
managers. The Trustee's policy is that the extent to which
How much of the fund’s assets are allocated towards social, environmental or ethical considerations are taken into
alternative investment instruments? account in these decisions is left to the discretion of the
The pension fund has a 5 per cent allocation to investment managers. The Trustee's policy is to delegate
commodities, global private equity and long lease property. responsibility for the exercising of rights attaching to invest-
ments (including voting rights) to the investment managers
How is the fund structured? although the Trustees reserve the right to instruct each
We have a Trustee Company of 12 Directors, five are investment manager in particular situations.
The leading provider of Custody and Clearing Services in Norway
Nordic Custody & Clearing Alliance: Swedbank, Sweden – Amagerbanken, Denmark – OKOBank, Finland
www.dnbnor.no
Corporate Actions
Automatic
Telecommunication), which developed the among broker/dealers, banks, investment
15022 standard in association with the managers and hedge funds worldwide in
International Standards Organisation our GCA Validation Service.”
for the
(ISO), corroborate the trend towards The increased level of standardisation in
increasing usage of 15022 for corporate the corporate actions space has signifi-
actions data. According to SWIFT, corpo- cantly impacted the take up of corporate
DTCC:
Voted Best
Corporate Actions Solutions Provider.
The Depository Trust & Clearing Corporation is grateful to be selected as the Best Corporate
Actions Solutions Provider in Waters magazine’s 2005 Annual Ranking.
Voters from five continents chose our Global Corporate Action (GCA) Validation Service as the best
solution to provide comprehensive, accurate and timely corporate action information.
We’d like to thank those brokers, banks, investment managers and hedge funds worldwide.
Our customer-centric approach is helping customers minimize risk and grow their revenue.
London +44 (0)20 7444 0417 New York +1 866 382 2422 Shanghai +86 21 3220 4710
Improving trading decisions at the front end … and reducing risk at the back end.
www.dtcc.com/gca
Panel Discussion - Corporate Actions
What are the latest developments to affect the corporate front office to drive trading strategies and help make wise
actions landscape over the last year? investment decisions.
Colborne: One of the latest developments I have noted is Lott: Most notably I would say it has been the EU Savings
the change in approach by the larger institutions. In the Directive. This will certainly cause more firms to discover
past implementation was mostly initiated using a 'Big new ways to report the underlying holder of a security or
Bang' approach, whereby the solution was implemented in their participation in a fund. With the requirements gen-
a single phase with all of its modules enabled. What seems erated by Sarbanes Oxley and Basel II, we are seeing more
to be becoming increasingly popular is a phased modular attention being given to the client/counterparty data,
approach. This only really works if the target system has specifically as it related to owners and issuers of securities,
true modular switching, i.e. certain core modules can be and the need to have this kept current as a result of corpo-
switched off with their dependencies to other core mod- rate actions which effect name changes or changes in the
ules minimised. As an example, client A wishes to use data underlying corporate structure.
scrubbing and event notification capture, but is not inter-
ested in implementing reconciliation or entitlement calcu- Patel: The data vendors coming on board to work towards
lation. This may be due to those areas of functionality / offering a SWIFT based service. The further impact of an
processing being the regarded as the most high risk for expanding hedge fund business where speed of informa-
that particular organisation or due to other systems work- tion update gains importance is another development. The
ing well in the areas out of scope. I believe that we will see business world is also coming up with more complicated
more 'shorter' systems being implemented to cover off the events such as 4 phase processes.
higher risk areas of corporate action process-
ing. This also means the practitioners costs can “Over the last 12-18 months the securities
be reduced and timescales improved upon.
industry has embraced a desire to automate
Farrell: Custodians were the first to address the
need for automating corporate actions with corporate actions, although it has been an uphill
predominantly in-house developed bespoke
systems. However, as corporate actions
struggle to make this desire a reality”
announcements increase in volume and com-
plexity (and the in-house developments becoming more Smart: Over the last 12-18 months the securities industry
tedious, time consuming and costly) the appetite has has embraced a desire to automate corporate actions,
moved towards licensing specialist software such as XSP™, although it has been an uphill struggle to make this desire
as part of an integrated STP solution. From our perspec- a reality. The core drivers for automation have been the
tive, Xcitek continue to see great demand from global need to reduce operational risk and cut costs – manual
financial institutions of all types including asset managers, processing of corporate actions is a resource intensive and
hedge funds, and broker/dealers to automate their corpo- costly process. As well as the corporate events themselves,
rate actions processing. These forward-thinking, global we are also seeing an increased demand for delivery of
organisations realise the benefits that automation brings to resultant reference data changes related to capital events.
their operations –i.e., reduced risks, reduced costs, This trade support reference data forms an essential part
increased service levels to their clients and ultimately of the whole corporate actions’ picture.
increase in profits. As firms expand the range of products
and services they offer the requirement for some form of Comment on attempts to standardise the corporate
automation in corporate actions processing increases. actions landscape. Is the securities industry close to
Firms who have not yet fully embraced the need for implementing standards for corporate actions?
automating their corporate actions processing tend to be
those who hold fewer positions for example inter-dealer Colborne: I believe the move from the ISO7775 standard
brokers or firms where the range of products is limited or to the ISO15022 standard a significant step for the
concentrated on debt or income where mandatory events industry. Under the old standard it was very difficult for
predominate. However, even in these firms the require- software houses to utilise the notifications as most of the
ment to receive and cleanse data from multiple sources is market were using free format narrative (and potentially
increasing and along with it the pressure to automate. in-house templates). Once the new standard was imple-
mented, almost immediately, STP rates picked up as the
Femia: Over the past several years, corporate actions have MT564 notification message was structured and format-
become an area of growing risk and cost for many finan- ted. Therefore software houses could target certain fields
cial services firms. Both the sheer volume and the com- of the message to expect particular data items.
plexity of events are increasing. As a result, many large
organisations are reengineering their business processes, Farrell: There is nothing else in the same league as ISO
including the way they handle corporate actions. This has 15022. It is the largest industry initiative for automation of
created greater demand for automated solutions. In addi- corporate actions so far. The real issue is keeping up to
tion, we’re finding more investment managers and hedge date with the market driven user changes to the way the
funds are employing corporate action information in the ISO standard is interpreted and used, and of course edu-
cating the global custodians. Many European market play- the variations in the message data.
ers now realise the need for an ISO compliant solution. However, the custodians and buy side firms have now
realised that message standards are needed if costs are to
Femia: Standardisation of corporate actions is an evolu- be reduced through automation. It is now only a matter of
tionary process of continuous improvement towards the time whilst firms catch up with the software developments
ultimate goals of achieving STP and reducing risk. These required, and for the business guidelines, such as those
are goals to which DTCC, as an organisation, is fully com- from ISITC and the SMPG to percolate down internally
mitted. In the US, we co-chair the Corporate Actions within the marketplace.
Working Group of the International Securities Association
for Institutional Trade Communication - International Smart: The industry has demonstrated its belief in open
Operations Association (ISITC-IOA). We also have repre- standards by its commitment to initiatives such as ISO
sentatives on national and global Securities Market 15022. The major data vendors, including FT Interactive
Practice Groups (SMPG) working to harmonise industry Data, have undertaken significant work to map global cor-
standards. We are also fully committed to the industry porate actions data from their proprietary formats to the
goal of “at source” standardisation, targeted to address the MT564 event types specified within the industry data
integrity of the corporate actions announcements at the standard. This represents a significant step towards realis-
point of origin. ing the desire to automate. The next steps involve the con-
sumers of the data (our customers) investing
“Overall European financial institutions are resource in adopting the new standards themselves.
ahead of their North American counterparts” What are the current barriers to automation and the
latest moves to automate the industry?
Lott: I believe they are closer. I would say that when you
look at the European community, they are ahead of the Colborne: If you look at the market for reconciliation soft-
North American community primarily because of the ware four to five years ago, there was a surge of activity
standards that have risen from SWIFT ISO 15022 initia- which remained relatively consistent from the start. This is
tives and the level of participation from the European very different to what we have seen in the adoption of cor-
market. When you look at what people have done to inte- porate action processing solutions. What we have wit-
grate the new standards you will find that many software nessed, is that practitioners, being acutely aware of the
vendors have already achieved compliance with others not complexity of corporate action processing, have been
very far behind. Overall European financial institutions are holding back and watching the systems mature. During
ahead of their North American counterparts. I would say this time there have been some serious and adverse market
that North America remains somewhat behind because for conditions, like 9/11 and the dot com market re-valuation,
the most part they are heavily “US-oriented” in terms of which have also caused further slow down in the sector.
their interfaces with US clearing agents, which are some- Now with a return to profits for the budget holders, we are
times more automated than some of the European clear- starting to see more movement in general.
ing houses and therefore already have proprietary stan-
dards that are widely adopted and used . Is there standard- Farrell: The major barriers to automation include the lack
isation? Yes. What SWIFT have done for the financial serv- of broad adoption of ISO 15022, the perceived notion that
ices industry is very good. Can they go a little further? Yes corporate actions can not be automated, and the lack of
they can. I think they are moving in that direction, but for funding within organisations to take on a technology proj-
other reasons its does not appear to be forefront. ect of this kind – until they are hit with a costly error due
to manual processing. We do see that in many cases the
Patel: This is a slow moving ship that is at least now head- client is just too busy with not enough qualified/experi-
ing for the correct port rather than drifting in the ocean. enced staff in place. The client realises the need for
There are a number of issues to consider here- automation and process efficiencies but can often not
Firstly corporate events has always been seen by the busi- afford to release the ‘experts’ from the day-to-day to exe-
ness world as the poor relation to trading. It doesn’t make cute the project for automation effectively. At Xcitek, we
profits for the business and therefore comes down the list continue to see a growing trend to automate. With over 50
of priorities. In too many cases the answer to the question clients utilising XSP, financial institutions benefit from a
of standardisation is - “we have a system, it works, why proven, ‘turnkey’ solution that can be implemented
change?” between 90 to 120 days. Firms will only entrust their cor-
Secondly, the players who really matter in this arena – the porate actions processing to stable and solid providers
custodians - found themselves wrestling with trying to get with excellent implementation track records. Advanced
their clients and counterparties onto automated platforms technology, research & development, and a team backed by
through the upheaval of ISO 15022 implementation at the strong and dedicated business and technical resources
same time as managing a downturn in the global markets. allow Xcitek to continue leading the industry with the
Thirdly, the concept of allowing vast variety within the most widely-implemented solution in the marketplace.
SWIFT messages for corporate events caught out a num-
ber of IT software departments and suppliers in that con- Femia: The increasing sophistication and complexity of
siderable additional programming was needed to cater for corporate actions definitely presents a challenge. When it
standards say by SWIFT, the same message for the same fits of automation upon suffering major losses through
event can be presented differently by multiple custodians. failure to act upon a corporate event.
This will cause really STP issues for the Asset Managers. Comment on the latest regulatory developments/direc-
In essence to implement an Automated Corporate Actions tives which are affecting the corporate actions landscape.
environment is very complicated. Only when proper Do you foresee further regulatory involvement in this
resources are dedicated to this type of implementation area of the securities industry?
project can it deliver benefits to about 80 per cent of the
current activity. Colborne: One of the main regulatory drivers on every-
b) Buy-side firms investing in automated links to 3rd one's lips at the moment is the BASEL II accord. The main
parties theme for operational risk is capital adequacy. I.e.
Whilst the bigger players in the buy-side arena have identi- Practitioners may have to put aside a certain amount of
fied the advantages of automation for corporate events a capital in advance of potential losses. The practitioners can
large number of mid and small sized investment houses reduce this amount by improving processes, auditing,
are still relying on paper based systems to handle corpo- implementing new software control systems etc. etc.
rate events. The main barrier to these market players are Fortunately for practitioners, unfortunately for vendors,
the cost of automation and the business benefits it may BASEL II was initially supposed to come into force in
offer. A lot of these mid and smaller sized organisations 2005, but was postponed until 2007. Currently the main
were caught out in the late nineties and early part of the questions I hear are, 'Is it going to happen? When? Will it
new millennium with the automation of trading processes be regulatory, or a set of guidelines?'
through the introduction of middleware. In many cases
the projects had limited success and, with consideration to Farrell: Regulatory directives such as the Basel II Accord,
the downturn in global markets, many firms were not pre- Sarbanes-Oxley, and other industry drivers geared towards
pared to get their fingers burned again. minimising operational risks and fulfilling compliance
However with the industry in general raising the profile obligations further the need to automate the corporate
of corporate event automation, and better product fits actions process.
becoming widely available these smaller buy-side firms are
beginning to identify the cost savings that can be made Femia: One of the most challenging and visible areas sur-
through automation of Corporate Event processing. rounding our business today is the assessment and man-
c) Data Vendors agement of operational risk. Sarbanes-Oxley introduced
Data vendors have been guarded so far with regard to the basic foundations in 2002, and the proposed Basel Capital
availability and data coverage of information provided in Accord (Basle II), for example, place the spotlight clearly
SWIFT standard format. The commercial and political on the concerns of operational risk. Financial firms must
issues are obviously clear here. However without the data more actively manage their operational risk to effectively
vendors standardising with the rest of the industry true reduce their capital reserves. It is clear that the effective
straight through automation and exception handling will management of the corporate action process, together
continue to be held up by the need for multiple with its mitigating strategies and control functions, are,
proprietary feeds. and will become even more essential in helping firms run
their business.
“A lot of these mid and smaller Lott: The EU Savings Directive is an attempt to address
sized organisations were the problem that seems to have existed forever, which is
“who is the underlying owner of the investment in the first
caught out in the late nineties place and are countries losing out on taxable income that
they could be charging these investors?” Typically, many of
and early part of the new the custodians maintain omnibus (un-named) accounts.
millennium with the We know mutual funds are in fact omnibus account driv-
en where a single fund is a recordkeeper for a number of
automation of trading investors that could be located anywhere in the world.
Because of tax treaties you never really know the underly-
processess through the ing beneficiaries of the income. I think countries are get-
introduction of middleware” ting smarter and more aware that there is revenue out
there they should be entitled to. You will see more regula-
Smart: Automation could be held back by the resource tors making sure they understand who the underlying
requirements taken up by various regulations and direc- holders of the income are.
tives such as the EU Savings Tax Directive, Basel II, UCITS
111 or Sarbanes-Oxley. And now there’s MiFID… In Patel: The changes to the landscape are likely to be busi-
comparison to some of these projects, the bottom line is ness driven as corporate events are a by-product of securi-
that achieving a decent level of corporate actions automa- ty trading. With greater regulation of trading business, in
tion has often been seen as a ‘nice to have’ as opposed to particular hedge funds and derivative trading, there is like-
being of real stand-out benefit. It could be true to say that ly to be a knock-on effect to corporate actions regulation
many investment firms will only wake up to the true bene- In addition the operational risk strategies of organisations
are likely to change over the coming year to reflect the uneconomical for smaller firms to automate their
requirements of the Basel II accord. In some cases this will corporate action processing. However we are starting to
mean greater automation to cover the risk elements related see more of the software vendors creating out-of-the-box,
to corporate action processing. affordable packages for the smaller firms.
the parties involved is likely that, once again, corporate commercially driven solutions when processing corporate
actions will lag behind treasury and securities settlements. actions?
Femia: The Securities Market Practice Group strives to Colborne: As mentioned earlier, SWIFT has definitely
harmonise corporate actions to create best practices, helped to increase automation through standardisation.
however, it does not have the power to dictate confor- The new ISO standard has been a breakthrough for STP. It
mance to the standards and market practice that has been is now possible to have mandatory events achieve
agreed to. The aim of developing market practice is to extremely high, and previously joked about, rates of
provide guidelines on the use of ISO 15022 corporate straight through processing.
action messages, from notification to payment, regardless
of where the event originates. The key benefit of the ISO Farrell: SWIFT’s initiative to standardise corporate actions
standard for corporate actions is the existing database and provides some relief for institutional clients because they
the facility to maintain and update the data elements, provide and act on information. However, SWIFT does
definition and business rules as they evolve with no cost to not process corporate actions. Institutions must rely
the industry. This allows the industry to focus and build on software providers like XSP to deliver proven
upon its knowledge and strengths. solutions that automate the end-to-end processing for
corporate actions.
“Currently there is a lot of focus on risk management, Femia: Sure, message standards go a
long way to improving communications
particularly around market and client risk, and and processes associated with corporate
actions. But even with message stan-
consolidation and adoption of data, which again dards, content is still disparate and can
redirects funds from corporate actions initiatives” cause, extensive mapping and makeshift,
work-around solutions. For standards to
be successful, it will require the efforts of
Lott: In my opinion I have seen the efforts slow down a all participants – including issuers of corporate actions,
little bit, for a couple of reasons. One is Basel II. The other their downstream recipients, and organisations like
is Sarbanes Oxley, which firms are still trying to address. SWIFT. The challenge for developers of commercial solu-
Consequently, there is more energy being focused on client tions for processing
data as opposed to corporate actions. If you look at user corporate actions will be to continue to find ways to add
groups such as FISD, REDAC and RDUG, their current value as the landscape for corporate actions evolves.
focus is still on standardisation of securities reference data.
Unless there is some regulatory reason for people to put Lott: SWIFT has the potential to do something very big
corporate actions on the front-burner it will continue to for the industry in terms of corporate actions. The issue
receive less attention. There was a time when it got a lot of may be that they are struggling with how to move this
attention and that was primarily driven by SWIFT and the forward and how to become a utility for corporate actions.
industry to begin to create standardisation plus it was This is why you are seeing all of the other players like the
always one of these areas that was highly manually DTCC and Deutsche Börse provide their own niche mar-
intensive. Currently there is a lot more focus on risk ket offerings. SWIFT definitely has the potential, especially
management, particularly around market and client risk, since they are a driver of industry standardisation. Could
and consolidation and adoption of data, which again they be a utility, which becomes the information hub for
redirects funds from corporate action initiatives. issuers and users? Certainly they could. We know there
have been conversations about it, but we also know they
Smart: Somewhat surprisingly a group of traditionally haven’t gone anywhere.
fiercely competitive vendors is working together for the
betterment of the industry. The Market Data Provider Patel: SWIFT will only help to standardise the industry if
User Group’s published ‘Principles’ document serves to their services become more prevalent in the mid to smaller
demonstrate that mountains can be moved when leading buy side firms and if the range of messages for corporate
vendors buy into the concept of standardisation. Vendors events is refined to better reflect automated solutions.
might be at slightly different stages of implementation, but In the short term Custodians, the biggest influence on
the core of their corporate actions offerings should now this marketplace, are likely to stick with proprietary solu-
look very similar indeed. Software vendors have com- tions as the path of least resistance.
mented favourably on the progress that has been made – Adoption would be greater if some form of enforcement
and in most cases, ISO 15022 files that have been tested by was implemented. This will create pure standards which
the leading software vendors have reportedly been will leave very little room for interpretation.
processed with little or no manual intervention. What a There is also the issue where the Standard itself does not
difference from the proprietary formatted world! lend itself to complete business situations. For example
Securities Lending activity to be incorporated in the actual
Will utilities such as SWIFT help to standardise the Corporate Action event notification can be very difficult.
industry or will the securities industry come to rely on
DATA SERVICES
• EQUITIES
• FIXED INCOME
• CORPORATE ACTIONS
IT’S THE END OF AN ERA...
• PRICING
• CLIENT/COUNTERPARTY
• INDICES
Enhance your efficiency and reduce your costs with the global finan-
cial industry expertise of our knowledgeable team. The exciting new
era of outsourced reference data services is beginning – jump into
the future with Capco Reference Data Services.
Panel Discussion - Corporate Actions
Without complete business coverage of the standard there maximum operational efficiency and reduced cost
will always be limitations to the levels of automation that in the processing of corporate actions.
can be achieved through the use of SWIFT.
Femia: The business of processing corporate actions is
Smart: Market feedback shows that there is significant nothing if not challenging. From a global perspective,
interest in receiving ISO 15022 formatted corporate perhaps the most significant challenge is for all firms to
actions data over the SWIFTNet network – FT Interactive commit to supporting industrywide efforts to develop
Data considers this approach to be a natural progression standards that will bring greater harmony to what
of open standards adoption within the industry. SWIFT remains one of the most complex, labour-intensive and
has an excellent record of promoting standardisation risk-filled processes. Other challenges include keeping
across the industry and will clearly be a key industry up with the continuing sophistication of instruments
facilitator in this initiative. and new corporate actions event types that the creative
minds of investment bankers and other
“financial institutions can no longer ignore advisors devise.
automation in their quest for maximum Lott: The first challenge is for firms to
recognise that corporate actions processing,
operational efficiency” including the collection and
communication, can best be done by a utility. We will see
What are the key challenges and opportunities for the
more adoptions of the utility services, which could also
corporate actions landscape over the next two years?
mean that these utility services will start to share data
with each other. This will help the industry overall. The
Colborne: The main challenges facing the industry cur- question is, how much will adoption of the utility model
rently are; to utilise the web more, either making their occur over the next two years to provide what the
whole product available as a web service or at the very industry needs? Quite frankly it is still a slowly evolving
least to offer elections for voluntary corporate actions over proposition. I think you will still see basic levels of
the web. The benefit for buyers being mobility and ease of functionality from the industry utilities in the next
deployment. For the vendors that don't currently have couple of years. In the longer term, there are pretty good
modular switching a move into this level of flexibility, I prospects for utility models to move the industry for-
believe, will become imperative for selling into larger ward in terms full processing or corporate actions, like
financial institutions. Finally, the common goal of increas- we saw with payroll and other outsourced services. I also
ing STP rates. This is something that most vendors will think you will see steady deployment of market and
work on continuously in the hope of providing a system country specific utilities.
that can cope with all types and levels of corporate actions
with minor human intervention. Patel: The landscape is likely to be market driven. With
the upturn in the global economy there is a greater
Farrell: Global financial institutions that have not fully chance of corporate activity – companies coming to
embraced the need for automation are faced with ever- market, take-overs, mergers, etc. and this should fuel the
increasing volumes, complex offerings, securities class argument to automate to deal with volume.
actions, staffing issues, multi-market processing, and Further expansion of the global marketplace for trading
losses stemming from errors due to manual processing. should have a knock-on effect to corporate activity and
Automating the process with a solution like XSP man- automation of this line of business.
ages the peaks in volume because it is insensitive to the The challenge will be to get the message standardisation
increase in activity, thus allowing staff to be reassigned right in the global marketplace to ease the passage to
to more complex issues. Securities class actions are automation. This can only be achieved if all the players –
becoming another global issue for the industry requiring custodians, security houses, data vendors and system
a solution to manage the process. suppliers – work together with a common purpose of
Xcitek’s market data group recently launched Xcitek producing a global automation solution.
Class Actions™ to allow financial institutions to identify,
track and ultimately collect from positions held in the Smart: We as an industry need to decide now how
ever-expanding list of securities class actions. The serv- important automation really is. There is currently a
ice includes information and features to assist in the window of opportunity to get this project completed, but
process of claiming and collecting funds to which the regulations such as MiFID are bearing down on the
industry. Implementation of MiFID is due in 2007;
investor may be entitled. XSP plans to deliver a new
project work will need to be conducted during 2006 and
module to address full back-office automation of the budgets have to be set very soon. MiFID looks as though
class action data by leveraging the existing functionality it will be a massively resource-greedy project, so how
of XSP to manage the class action lifecycle for complete much will be left for corporate actions automation if it is
end-to-end processing. not completed by the end of 2005?
In today’s global marketplace, financial institutions can
no longer ignore automation in their quest for ISJ: Thank you.
to be able to promote a single customer view across all largely with great success. This has resulted
nicsa
Luxembourg Fund Industry
9OUR FAST TRACK TO THE ,ATIN !MERICAN HEDGE FUNDS
"//+ ./7
MARKET (EDGE &UNDS 7ORLD ,AT!M
s 'AIN ALL THE INTELLIGENCE YOU NEED TO INVEST IN THE BURGEONING ,AT!M HEDGE FUNDS MARKET 4EL OR
s 3ECURE PROlTABLE PARTNERSHIPS AND ALLIANCES IN THE REGION FAX OR AT
s -EET WITH INVESTORS AND UNDERSTAND THEIR NEEDS AT THE ONLY INTERNATIONAL EVENT ON ,AT!M