McElroy Commons, Box L-132, Chestnut Hill, Ma 02467
com Tuesday, February 17, 2009 Volume XXI Issue 6
UGBC Petition
Dead on Arrival
A ballot referendum is poised to pit the next UGBC
President against University policy concerning con- Anna Djintcharadzé, a Boston College doctoral student and teacher, may have her
doms and sexual health.
By JP Bonner to the concerns we’ve heard from Thomas Kurian cites the event as “first mass book burning in the 21st century.”
The Observer
A referendum on the Under-
graduate Government of Boston
College (UGBC) presidential
election ballot this week will,
with a majority of the student
vote, require the next UGBC pres-
ident to pursue improved “sexual
health education and resources at
BC.” However, specific tenets
of the resolution, which include
prescription of birth control and
“affordable” Sexually Transmit-
ted Infection (STI) testing at Uni-
versity Health Services as well as
condom distribution on campus,
appear to clash with Boston Col-
lege’s established Catholic poli-
cies.
The petition gained momen-
tum through a series of emails
through listservs, including those
of Americans for Informed De-
mocracy (AID) and College
Democrats, as well as a Facebook
group with over 1,750 members.
The effort to put these issues on
the ballot was begun by a group
calling itself BC Students for
Sexual Health (SFSH), comprised
of Alicia Johnson, Melissa Rob-
erts, Scott Jelinek, and Alexandra
Saieh. “We wanted to give voice
In This Issue
State of Safety....
News, 3
Relay for Life...
News, 4
You Don’t Know
Jacq...Opinion, 9
Chastity at BC...
Catholic Issues, 10
U.S. Census...
Opinions, 14
Bob Ryan...
Sports, 20
work revised without her permission because it is “too Christian.” Editor George
our peers about the lack sexual
health education and resources on
campus,” said the unaffiliated stu-
dent group in an email.
Student initiatives are out-
lined in Section 2, Article VII of
the UGBC Constitution, which
is available on UGBC’s website.
Essentially, any student initiative
can be included on the ballot with
one eighth of the student body’s
signatures on a petition. Once on
the ballot, an affirmative major-
ity of votes cast make it a bind-
ing resolution. Assistant Dean of
Student Development Mark Mic-
eli commented on the wording of
the Constitution. “What exactly
‘upholding the policy of the stu-
dent initiative’ means in the day-
to-day operations of the UGBC
will be up to the sitting UGBC
President.”
Vice President for Student
Affairs Patrick Rombalski also
weighed in on the issue. “The
Constitution of UGBC makes no
distinctions between binding and
non-binding referenda,” he said,
“nor does it delineate any way
for the election’s committee to
See ‘Petition’
page 2
Is Columbus
Offensive?
By Jesse Naiman
The Observer
A life-sized banner showing
a portrait of Christopher Colum-
bus impaled with an arrow hangs
in a cubicle on the second floor of
21 Campanella Way. This ban-
ner, which reads “Countering
Columbus Day,” can be found in
a student club office that the Or-
ganization of Latin American Af-
fairs (OLAA) and the Society of
Native American Peoples (SNAP)
share.
This banner is not the only
way these two clubs have shown
www.thebcobserver.
BC Professor’s
Work Censored
By Michael Reer
The Observer
A
nna Djintcharadzé, a
doctoral student and
teacher in the philosophy
department at Boston College,
may have her published work per-
manently revised without her per-
mission in order to make it more
politically correct. Djintcharadze
recently wrote two articles, en-
titled “African Church Fathers”
and “Latin,” for a new, four-vol-
ume Encyclopedia of Christian
Civilization. The encyclopedia
was published in October of 2008,
with many contributors receiving
complimentary copies of the book
before Blackwell Publishing in-
explicitly stopped printing copies
of the book and destroyed all re-
maining copies in its possession.
According to George Thom-
Anna Djintcharadzé, a BC doctoral student, is facing
as Kurian, editor-in-chief of the
project, the editorial board com- censorship for her work in the ECC.
plained that entries in the ency- clopedia is admittedly for univer- civilization for Christians,” she
clopedia are “too Christian, too sity use, Djintcharadzé disagrees explained. Furthermore, as the
orthodox, too anti-secular and too with the notion that just because book’s editor points out, Black-
anti-Muslim and not politically the book is for a university it must
See ‘Censorship’
correct enough for being used in also be completely secular. “We page 2
universities.” Although the ency- are writing a book about Christian
their apparent contempt for Co-
lumbus Day. Flyers spread
around campus last October ad-
vertising a joint OLAA and SNAP
Columbus Day presentation fea-
tured a picture of Columbus with
the following statement “Wanted
[for] Grand Theft, Genocide, Rac-
ism, Initiating the Destruction of a
Culture, Rape Torture, and Maim-
ing of an indigenous people and
instigator of The Big Lie. 500
Years of Tourism.”
Executive board members
See ‘Columbus’ Banner depicting Columbus shot with an arrow can be
page 2 found in OLAA/SNAP’s student office.

2 News
Censorship
from front
well Publishing does not have
the legal right to edit the book
at will because the project was
conceived and carried out by Ku-
rian and the contributing writers,
which makes the project their col-
lective intellectual property.
Blackwell Publishing claims
that the book’s introduction
and several other articles never
passed through the appropriate
editorial board and that once the
management of the company be-
came aware of this, it was forced
to reevaluate certain sections of
the work.
A particular point of conten-
tion seems to be over some of the
phraseology used in the introduc-
tion. For example, when speak-
ing of why only one-third of the
world is Christian almost 2,000
years after Christ’s death, Kurian
blames “the enemy” for the lack
of a mass, world-wide conver-
sion. Additionally, Kurian claims
in his introduction that before
baptism, every human “is already
written over with the message of
the anti-Christ.” Blackwell Pub-
lishing is set to delete these and
other terms of religious connota-
tion, such as “Harvest,” “Beloved
Disciple,” “Gates of Hell,” “Wit-
ness,” and “Virgin Birth,” out of
the book before resuming publi-
cation.
Blackwell Publishing also
objects to some of the 1,450
contributing entries, which cite
everything from traditionally
Christian terms to historically ob-
jective facts.
Articles that detail events
such as the Resurrection of Christ
and Muslim massacres of Chris-
tians will be posed in either a
more apologetic or more subjec-
tive light if the book is revised.
Blackwell also has indicated that
it will be adding references to
the book so that there are some
“positive” entries about Muslims.
The Observer is currently seeking
permission to publish these con-
troversial entries online.
Although Djintcharadze
acknowledges that “scholarly
reviews are indeed necessary
and desirable” for any reference
work, she argues that the review
board picked by Blackwell gives
a wanton extension to the con-
cept: it goes beyond the limits
of factual proofreading and en-
croaches upon issues of specific
content, filtering it out through an
ultra politically correct sieve.
“If being politically cor-
rect means neutering Christian-
ity from its essence, as well as
distorting historical facts (the
‘common era’ did start with Je-
sus-Christ and not with any other
religious founder…), then I do
not and will never agree to such
political correctness.”
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
Dealing with issues of
censorship is nothing new for
Djintcharadze, who spent time in
the Soviet Union as a child. She
recalled her parents searching for
fairy tale books with Christian
themes despite Soviet attempts to
suppress the volumes. She would
also correct some books that were
censored, putting their original
words in by hand.
“When I read books, even
as a child, I would change them
back to how they were supposed
to be,” she said, citing specifi-
cally the example of changing
the term “Before Common Era”
back to “Before Christ,” as well
as “Biblical legend” to “Biblical
story,” and capitalizing “god.”
She compared her experiences
in the Soviet Union to the cur-
rent situation, noting that “such
tactics are the exact copy of the
Soviet/Nazi sophistries in censor-
ship: good scholarship had…to
be ‘protected’ against any kind
of religious ‘barbarisms.’ Dele-
tions of everything that could be
even distantly and vaguely sym-
pathetic with religious connota-
tions, was… going against the
‘freedom’ of the nation.”
The editor and contributors
of the book believe that it would
have scored a success if published
uninhibited. Before publishing
stopped, the book was listed on-
line for nearly one thousand dol-
lars and most major universities
were figured to be interested in
purchasing at least one copy for
library use.
Djintcharadze said that “the
book is likely to be a universal
source as it is written in English
by an international staff of con-
tributors. I know some places
in Germany were interested in
purchasing it.” The work also
exceeded the three-volume ex-
pectation of the publisher, adding
another book to the collection at
no extra cost.
The encyclopedia was also
completed a full year ahead of
schedule, earning accolades from
the likes of Edwin Yamauchi and
Mark Noll, two highly regarded
historians.
The argument over the en-
cyclopedia is likely to end up in
the court system as Blackwell
Publishing and Kurian argue over
who owns the completed version
of the book. Kurian, who is cur-
rently organizing a class-action
lawsuit, has summarized the like-
ly future of the situation by quot-
ing British World War II Prime
Minister Winston Churchill and
claiming that he “shall fight and
expose them in the courts, fight
and expose them in the libraries,
fight and expose them in the aca-
demia and fight and expose them
in the media.”
Petition
from front
evaluate referenda except by the
amount and legitimacy of signa-
tures obtained... I do not know
what implications the referen-
dum will have for the leadership
of UGBC, but it is non-binding
for university policies and proce-
dures.”
The resolution will be on
the ballot, according to Co-Chair
of the Elections Committee
Joshua Darr. “As long as there
are enough signatures, it will be
placed on the ballot,” he stated.
“The EC refuses to comment on
the content of this ballot initia-
tive or on any matters regarding
UGBC policy, the UGBC consti-
tution, or the potential effects of
this ballot initiative... I have spo-
ken with the administration about
this, and they just want to make
sure that it’s going on the ballot.
They’re treating it like any other
election matter.”
The result of all of this is that
on Thursday and Friday, students
will not just be voting for their
favorite presidential and senato-
rial candidates but they will also
be voting to determine UGBC
policy for the coming year. But
even if the resolution is approved,
will the new president be able to
pursue such a policy?
When asked about condoms
on campus, Vice Presidential can-
didate Nick Kazimiroff added,
Columbus
from front
of both OLAA and SNAP were
unavailable for comment when
asked about the origins and the
appropriateness of the sign.
However, Dean of Student
Development Dr. Sheila Horton
offered a mixed reaction to the
banner: “The Office of the Dean
for Student Development has not
received any complaints about
the banner. The picture is not con-
sistent with our values at Boston
College because of its violent na-
ture. However, this is an example
of satire which presents an op-
portunity for students to learn that
Native American history dates
back much farther than Colum-
bus and indeed Native Americans
may have a different perspective
on Columbus than other Ameri-
cans. Perhaps broader discussion
on this issue will lead to a positive
result.”
As for the issue of whether
Columbus Day should be cele-
brated or condemned, various fac-
ulty and students offered different
points of view. Professor Den-
nis Hale of the Political Science
Department saw no reason not to
celebrate it: “Where would we
be without Christopher Colum-
bus? How did Spanish-speaking
people end up in Latin America?
“It’s something to discuss further
if we get elected. We should all
work together on this. We do
support the idea of STI testing.”
SFSH is confident that its
mandate will come to fruition.
“We anticipate that the referen-
dum will pass and when it does,
we will continue to work to bring
the goals we have described to
fruition.
We hope to have cooperation
from UGBC and the administra-
tion, as its passage would rep-
resent a clear mandate from the
student body.”
Rombalski has other ideas.
“I do not believe UGBC will pur-
chase condoms for the student
body,” he stated. “A conversation
about the sexuality of students is
needed as is a more open environ-
ment regarding intimacy, sexuali-
ty in relationships, and how these
are in dialogue with other ethical
and religious values such as re-
sponsibility and restraint. But it
seems to me we should not do this
by abrogating our responsibil-
ity to uphold Catholic teaching;
a teaching that is fundamental to
the totality of Catholic sexual eth-
ics and conduct.”
BC Students for Sexual
Health similarly acknowledged
BC’s Jesuit heritage.
“We acknowledge and re-
spect BC’s Jesuit Catholic iden-
You might say that Christopher
Columbus is the Father of Latin
American Studies.”
In addition, Professor Hale
wondered why people even
bother to protest Columbus Day:
“The people who complain about
Christopher Columbus have a po-
litical agenda that has nothing to
do with Columbus. But I don’t
know what it is.” While Profes-
sor Hale acknowledged that every
historical event has both posi-
tive and negative consequences,
he concluded that “if we were to
weigh them all accurately, we’d
have to say that Christopher Co-
lumbus’ voyage to the Western
Hemisphere was on balance a
good thing.”
Similar sentiment could be
found among the student body.
Sophomore Corey Javes also
came to the defense of Colum-
bus. Javes stated that “Chris-
topher Columbus Day is worth
celebrating because it marks the
beginning of history in America.
Columbus was the first of many
Europeans who came to America,
bringing their culture along with
them making our country what it
is today.”
History Professor Mark Gel-
fand noted that people started
The Observer
February 17, 2009
tity- this is why we care so much
about the health and well being of
our community. We have based
all of our goals off of what other
Jesuit Catholic universities are
currently providing their students
across America. As active mem-
bers of the BC community, we are
advocating for students’ health.
We are not asking for a single
dime of BC’s money to go to-
wards funding condoms. Know-
ing that 2/3 of all STI cases occur
in people under the age of 25 and
at least one half of all new HIV
infections are estimated to be
among those under the age of 25,
we are trying to protect the health
of our community.”
Philosophy professor Paul
McNellis, S.J. doubted this ar-
gument. “The mistake of people
pushing this view is that they imi-
tate the errors of secular society
by seeing sexual issues as issues
of hygiene and technique instead
of profound moral issues,” he
commented. “The best way to
avoid STIs is to lead a virtuous
life, whether a Christian or a pa-
gan one.”
“Although we could do a
better job teaching these issues,”
he allowed, “I can’t see any way
the university would say yes to
this reduced view of human sexu-
ality... Their best response is to
ignore it.”
questioning whether Columbus
Day should be celebrated in be-
tween its 400th and 500th an-
niversary: “Ideas about progress
had underwent a great change in
the interim, and the issue of what
Columbus had wrought was seen
through very different set of lens
by the later date.” He added that
Columbus Day has become par-
ticularly controversial in the last
twenty years. However, Professor
Gelfand called for a “nuanced”
approach to the day by mark-
ing it as a “commemoration,” so
“we can mark the occasion as
noteworthy, but also reflect on
its meaning in the many different
ways it has influenced the human
condition.”
Columbus Day is celebrated
on the second Monday of every
October in honor of his discover-
ing America in 1492. The first re-
corded celebration in the United
States took place in New York
City on October 12, 1792, 300
years after Columbus discovered
America. While the United States
observes Columbus Day, a num-
ber of Latin American countries
celebrate what they refer to as Día
de la Raza, (Day of the Race) as
part of a resistance to Columbus
Day.
The Observer
February 17, 2009
Chomsky Lecture
Draws Crowd
Celebrity intellectual Noam Chomsky delivers a characteristically enrapturing lecture
By JP Bonner
The Observer
Gasson Hall’s Irish Room
was packed to the rafters as
famed linguist, cognitive scien-
tist, author, and political activist
Noam Chomsky spoke at an event
planned by Psi Chi, the psychol-
ogy honors society. Chomsky, a
professor emeritus of linguistics
at the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology, covered in roughly
an hour topics ranging from ad-
vertising, Obama, and mass me-
dia to Israel, investment, and the
internet.
Always a challenging and
thought-provoking speak-e r ,
Chomsky later characterized his
overall political philosophy by
email. “Taking a long-term view,
I think the optimal system we can
envision now, at least in rough
outline, is libertarian socialist
(anarchist). I’ve discussed the
topic fairly often. There are ar-
ticles in several collections.”
His visit to Boston College
marked one of his first interac-
The State of Public Safety
BCPD Captain discusses safety issues on campus
By Megan Rauch
The Observer
Issues of public safety on the
Boston College campus extend
far beyond the recent ice, snow,
and frigid temperatures. Even
after JuicyCampus.com was shut
down, according to BCPD’s Cap-
tain Margaret Connolly, members
of the BC community are still
vulnerable to sexual harassment
and assault. In 2007, 15 instances
of forcible sexual assault were
reported on campus and the sur-
rounding public property in “The
Boston College Important No-
tices and Disclosures Report,” up
from six the year before.
Law enforcement officials
classify sexual assault in several
different categories. The most se-
rious offense, Capt. Connolly ex-
plains, is aggravated rape, which
involves one or more perpetrators
who inflict serious bodily injuries
on the victim. Because it is con-
sidered a serious felony, persons
convicted of aggravated rape re-
ceive life in prison. The second
classification of sexual assault is
also considered rape, even though
the victim is not seriously injured.
Second degree rape is punishable
by 20 years in prison.
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
tions with Jesuits in this country.
“ I was quite close to Jesuits in
Central America, but in the US
only sporadically,” he remarked.
During the reception preced-
ing the event, Gasson was filled
with students, professors, and
readers of Chomsky’s works from
as near as Lower Campus and as
far as Buffalo, New York. Intense
anticipation filled the hall from
its old floorboards to its painted
ceiling; the vegetables, cheeses
and crackers provided by Psi Chi
were devoured quickly and ex-
cited students packed around and
between the rows of chairs made
several unsuccessful attempts to
begin a “slow clap.”
By the time Chomsky, clad
in unassuming blue jeans and a
sweater, strolled up to the podium
to begin his speech, the crowd
was already spilling out into the
atrium and students were peer-
ing in through the windows of
the third floor balcony. Asked to
comment on the historic nature of
the last presidential election, he
began in earnest agreement, ac-
In either instance, the Bos-
ton College Police take the vic-
tim to one of two local hospitals,
Brigham Women’s or Beth Israel.
The BCPD’s Sexual Assault In-
vestigative Team serves as a “fact
finder” and is responsible for
compiling evidence in the case. It
is then up to the victim whether to
proceed with the case externally
through the District Attorney of
either Suffolk or Middlesex coun-
ties, or internally through Boston
College. In choosing the latter
route, “The victim has not cho-
sen to go forward with a criminal
case. We then use all systems
within the university, including
the Office of the Dean of Student
Development and judicial hear-
ings, to ensure that what hap-
pened and how it happened does
not happen again,” elaborates
Connolly.
Among the most common
forms of assault and harassment
the BCPD deals with on cam-
pus is stalking, which is usually
civil in nature, meaning that the
offender has not engaged in any
criminal act, such as use of the
Internet to harass the victim. Ac-
cordingly, the Office of the Dean
of Student Development handles
jurisprudence through univer-
News
knowledging the huge step taken
by the United States towards be-
coming a more civilized nation.
He also commented that it is im-
portant not to exaggerate its effect
and to remember that there is still
“a long way to go.”
“But what happens from now
on?” asked Chomsky of the silent
audience. “That depends large-
ly on the actions of people like
you. Freedom is never given as
a gift; if a population backs off,
the gains are lost. People with
power do not release it easily, and
I wouldn’t expect them to... So
now this army of small supporters
is sup-posed to be sitting around
waiting for instructions, kind of
like the opposite of democracy.”
He reminded the crowd that
other great democratic achieve-
ments have been made in recent
years outside of America and
Europe. Referencing the incred-
ible participation of the native
population of Bolivia in its recent
elections, he said that “it was real
popular participation, entirely
about issues. It was not about a
sity policy and hearings. These
cases are usually highly sensi-
tive because, as Captain Connolly
explains, “At BC, we’re dealing
with a small city and issues of ha-
rassment affect every population.
We have to address the cultural
differences that can be involved
in these cases.”
Part of the BCPD’s response
to cases of harassment and as-
sault is to work with the victim
to develop a plan that allows for
healing.
“What needs to be done is
what is best for the victim. We
want you to heal. You are the one
that has to live with the decision
about how to move forward after
an incident,” says Connolly.
At the same time, the BCPD
also seeks to help the victim’s
family and friends deal with the
incident. As the Captain empha-
sizes, “We try to look at every-
body involved. Our lives are so
intermeshed with others, and it’s
important that no one feels that
what they [sic] have to say is not
worth it. This is especially im-
portant for parents because these
crimes can be like losing a child.
Most of our staff are parents, so
we truly understand the impor-
tance of the family connection.”
Noam Chomsky
brand.”
On the subject of brands, he
discussed this year’s Advertising
Age Award. “The ad industry
gives an award each year for the
best marketing campaign, and
this year it was Obama. He beat
out Apple,” he said, to sheepish
chuckles from the throng.
A crucial part of the healing
process from assault or harass-
ment is creating a safety plan for
the victim, the Captain says. A
member of the police department
works closely with him or her
to help them “think of the daily
activities. That is the true con-
cern—how to go about normal
things if the goal is to stay at BC,”
explains Connolly.
By taking down basic infor-
mation, the police officer and the
victim can begin to look for ways
to ensure that the victim always
has a safety net intact, whether
it is calling home, telling a close
friend, or knowing the locations
of hospitals, police stations, or
24-hour stores where the person
can go if he or she feels “spooked
or something gets under their
[sic] skin.”
Captain Connolly encour-
ages all members of the Boston
College community to become
proactive in preventing assault
and harassment crimes. “Safety
begins at home. There needs to
be a conversation about how to
protect yourself from potentially
dangerous situations, which of
course becomes more important
when there is alcohol involved,
which is so often a factor in what
3
Larissa Jones, event organiz-
er and President of Psi Chi, has
been working to bring Chomsky
to BC since June. “We wanted
an interesting, influential speaker
who would fulfill Psi Chi’s vi-
sion statement to come to BC,”
See ‘Chomsky’
page 4
we see here on campus.”
She encourages students go-
ing out to parties to have a “des-
ignated walker, who will keep an
eye on everyone and make sure
you all get home safely.” When
going out—whether it is to class
or to a party—the Captain asserts
that, “You should carry bags that
you can get rid of at a moment’s
notice if you need to run or fight.
Don’t carry what you care about
in them either.”
On campus, Captain Connol-
ly encourages all women to sign
up for the Rape Aggression De-
fense (R.A.D.) classes, where one
can learn the basic self-defense
techniques from a trained police
officer.
The BCPD is also develop-
ing a Bystander Training class for
next year that will teach students
how to respond to roommates and
friends who are dealing with dif-
ficult emotional issues, including
harassment and assault.
If you are a victim of harass-
ment or sexual assault, contact
the BCPD immediately. Visit
their website www.bc.com/offic-
es/bcpd for information on crime
prevention and safety, Massachu-
setts state laws, university policy,
and counseling.

4 News
Walking for a Cure
Relay for Life brings BC Community together for a night of celebration and remembrance. The twelve-hour
event featured music, basketball, and unity for a common cause.
By Rachele Reis
The Observer
Over 1,200 students flocked
to the Flynn Recreation Complex
to participate in the American
Cancer Society’s (ACS) annual
Relay for Life. Grouped into vari-
ous teams, these students walked
laps around the indoor track for
twelve hours to raise funds for the
ACS in hopes that a cure for can-
cer can be found one day. types and “a recognition of our
Teams in the Relay for Life
of Boston College were each as-
signed a country. The team mem-
bers could dress in their country’s
colors and display national pride
in decorations around their camp-
site for the night. Countries rep-
resented included Hungary, Ecua-
dor, Barbados, and Ireland.
The event opened with the
first lap walked by cancer survi-
vors in the BC community. These
survivors were ushered around
the track by a sonorous round of
applause from all present.
Then the festivities were in
full swing. Representatives from
each team were on the track at
all times. Participants were en-
tertained by a D.J. and live band,
as well as performances from
various student groups, such as
the Boston College Irish Dance
Club and the hip-hop dance group
Phaymus.
Activities such as a bas-
ketball tournament helped keep
team members awake during the
overnight event. All participants
received a t-shirt commemorat-
ing this year’s Relay, with a space
Chomsky
from page 3
said Jones. “His political views
aren’t what brought him here- it
was really the diversity of his ex-
pertise.”
Indeed, the depth and breadth
of Chomsky’s work is staggering.
In 1992, the Arts and Humani-
ties Citation Index listed him as
the most cited living author. He
was introduced on Tuesday as
“bringing us out of the dark ages
of behaviorism.” Yet along the
way, Chomsky has contributed
significantly to the development
of modern linguistics.
Born in 1928, Chomsky grew
up in a historically Jewish Phila-
delphia neighborhood. He wrote
his first article at age 10 on the
topic of spreading fascism during
the Spanish Civil War and later
proceeded to earn a B.A., M.A.,
and Ph.D. from the University of
Pennsylvania. Along the way he
met his wife, Carol Schatz, whom
he remained married to for 59
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
A group of students at the Relay for Life.
on the back to write their reasons
for taking part in the Relay. Many
shirts read “My Mom”, “Grand-
ma,” and names of other family
and friends.
Whitney Downum, Com-
munity Executive from the New
England Division of the Ameri-
can Cancer Society, said, “This
year’s event was a blast and ab-
solutely wonderful. BC is such
an amazing community to host
a Relay, and I hope we’re able to
host it year after year.” Early esti-
mates of fundraising efforts total
over $110,000.
Relay for Life began in
Tacoma, Washington in 1985,
years until her death in December
2008. He has been a professor of
linguistics at MIT for 53 of those
years and published over 100
books on linguistics and politics.
Throughout his life Chomsky has
commented, usually critically, on
U.S. government policies. A self-
described anarchist, he was an
outspoken opponent of the war in
Vietnam and continues to deplore
practices he sees as hypocritical
and harmful.
On the whole, Chomsky
came across as skeptical of real
change coming from the gov-
ernment. “Elections are periods
in which groups of investors
coalesce to control the state...
Twenty-five percent of Obama’s
contributions came from donors
giving less than $200; the major-
ity was mass contributions from
the financial services industry.
And when the financial services
industry puts you in office, that’s
through the efforts of Dr. Gordy
Klatt, who circled the track at
the University of Puget Sound
for 24 hours, raising $27,000. In
1986, the first multi-team relay
took place. Today, Relay for Life
brings together more than 3.5
million people to celebrate the
lives of those who have battled
cancer, remember loved ones lost
to the disease, and fight back by
raising money to fund the search
for a cure.
Preparations for the Relay
for Life at Boston College be-
gan in August by a committee
of more than sixty people. These
committee members organized
your constituency.
“And look, the first thing
we’ve done is give $350 billion
to the banks, who have pocketed
it. These people should not be
planning the next stage of our
economy, they should be receiv-
ing subpoenas... In a real democ-
racy, the people would take over
the banks, but we’ve been trained
to hate that idea.”
Chomsky’s cynical ire was
not limited to the new adminis-
tration, however. Commenting
on the softer, less belligerent tone
of the second half of the Bush
administration, he said that “the
most extreme guys were thrown
out: Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz, all
those guys. They couldn’t throw
out Cheney; he is the govern-
ment.”
He expects Obama’s foreign
policy to mirror that of the last
four years, taking Vice President
Joe Biden’s recent speech as an
team captain meetings and bank
nights, gathered materials for par-
ticipants, arranged activities for
the night of the Relay, and were a
source of energy and enthusiasm.
This year marked the second
annual Relay on Boston College’s
campus. BC students previously
participated in Relay for Life of
All University, at Harvard, col-
laborating with other schools in
the Boston area.
All University 2009 will be
held on April 10th. Relays are
also being held at Boston Uni-
versity, Tufts University, Bentley
University, and Brandeis Univer-
sity.
example. “Europe will like it;
they have no higher ambition
than to shine Washington’s shoes.
They couldn’t do that with Bush,
though, he was too arrogant, too
brazen.
Now they have this nice Har-
vard grad up there to speak some
nice words... around here, the in-
ternational community consists
of Washington and the New York
Times editorial board.”
Chomsky’s visit to Boston
College will remain a memorable
one to the attendees. “You’re my
hero,” an older gentleman con-
fessed to him on the way out. “I
wish we could clone you.”
Those who missed it need
not worry: his place of work is
just down the Red Line. While
locating him at MIT to ask
questions may prove difficult,
Chomsky still makes the effort
to answer nearly every email he
receives.
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
The Observer The Observer
February 17, 2009 February 17, 2009 News 5
Dan
Moloney
KSA and CSA Celebrate 9th Annual Culture Show
Visits BC
By Mary Margaret Brinkopf different types of conflicts and
The Observer
struggles that one goes through
The Korean Students As- in life,” such as Asian-American
By Matthew Vigliotta generational conflicts. KSA fin-
The Observer sociation (KSA) and Chinese
Students Association (CSA) per- ished the third act with a modern
The Boston College Repub-
formed their ninth annual cul- rendition of “Arirang,” a tradi-
licans hosted Dan Moloney, the
ture show featuring ten various tional Korean folk song.
former senior policy analyst for
acts specific to both cultures. The second half of the cul-
religion and civil society at the
The show, entitled “When Chow ture show was dominated by
Heritage Foundation, who is also
Fun Meets Kimchi,” represented dance numbers. The fan dances
currently enrolled at St. John’s
a fusion of Korean and Chinese of KSA and CSA highlighted the
Seminary to become a Catholic
culture to showcase the “shared similarities and differences be-
Priest.
Asian-American experience.” tween the two styles of fans used
The Heritage Foundation is a
In addition, the culture show in each culture. In China, the fans
conservative political think tank
program stated that the clubs are constructed from silk, while
founded in 1973. It is a non-profit
hoped to break common stereo- in Korea, the fans are created
organization and is regarded as
from rice paper.
one of the six most successful
commonality that our voices as Additionally, the Korean Fan
non-profits in the United States.
Americans will be heard.” The Dance (Buchaechum) focuses on
As well, it is widely considered to
show accomplished this through the movements of the fan—its
be one of the most reputable and
its side-skits that featured the tri- closing, opening and fluttering
powerful organizations of its kind.
als of an interracial couple, in this alongside other fans—compared
Moloney first discussed the great
case, a Chinese man and a Ko- to the Chinese fan dance, where
impact of the Heritage Founda- KSA’s Buchaechum fan dance was one of the highlights of the culture show.
rean woman who faced criticism the dance is very movement ori-
tion on American politics in the
from their respective families and ented.
past. The organization is respon-
cultures. The skits strongly rein- The only non-dance number
sible for ten of the fourteen points
forced the idea of fusing the two of the second half was the Chi-
in former Speaker of the House
cultures together. nese yo-yo section. Even this
Newt Gingrich’s 1994 Contract
The evening commenced performance, however, was set
with America that helped the Re-
with the Lion Dance: a traditional to music as students tossed the
publican Party reclaim a majority
dance performed in the impe- yo-yo’s behind their backs and
in Congress.
rial courts of ancient China. In propelled the yo-yo’s across the
In his relatively short career
Chinese culture, the lion is con- room. The Chinese yo-yo bears
at the Heritage Foundation, Mo-
sidered a guardian creature, of- no resemblance to the popular
loney has met with congressmen,
ten driving away evil spirits and American kind. The Chinese ver-
religious leaders, and United Na-
bringing good luck and fortune. sion is much bigger and is not
tions officials. He has also been
The lion dance features three directly wound up inside the two
interviewed on the radio and
different lions, which are oper- disks. Instead, the Chinese yo-
television. Some religious figures
ated by two individuals. The lion yo is a large, two-cylinder disc
of note whom Moloney has met
costume consists of a large lion spun on a long string with two
with include the President of In-
mask with a trailing body. The wooden ends that are gripped by
donesia—a well-respected expert
body covers only the top side of the performer. In modern Chinese
of Islam—and Chinese religious
the individual. In most cases, the society, the yo-yo has a dual func-
academics to discuss a future of
two individuals who maneuver tion—it is mostly used as a chil-
more religious tolerance in China.
the lion wear specially decorated dren’s toy but can also be used in
To demonstrate the influence
pants to correspond with the li- ethnic dances.
Heritage has on Americans today,
on’s color. One of the most popular acts
Moloney explained how the orga-
Martial arts performances during the second half was the
nization affected Obama’s recent
from both clubs followed the lion Talchum, performed by KSA.
stimulus package. After the origi-
nal bill was written in the House
of Representatives, the experts
dance. KSA held demonstrations
of Taekwondo and Hwarangdo.
The Talchum is a traditional
masked dance that originated
as a rebellion technique against
Student performer poses dring CSA fan
dance.
CSA performs Lion Dance as a symbol
of good luck
at Heritage examined the bill in Taekwondo, which translates
into “the way of the foot and the the wealthy and more privileged
order to inform congressmen of
fist,” is the national sport of South classes. The students each wore
its contents. After going through
Korea. Typically, Taekwondo’s individual masks attempting to
the hundreds of pages in the bill,
purpose has been to emphasize portray the faces of the yangban
Heritage researchers realized that
self-defense and control. The (upper class).
hundreds of millions of dollars
performance featured over two- These faces often held some
of the bill were allotted for con-
dozen students who sparred with sort of deformity such as curled
traception. Four articles written
each other and broke wooden upper lip. Another distinguish-
by Moloney concerning federal
boards with their hands and feet. ing characteristic of the talchum
funding for contraception, along
In contrast, the CSA pre- dance was the long, flowing white
with the information from the bill,
sentation of Kung Fu showcased sheets that covered the perform-
were sent to House Republican
students dressed in intricately ers hands. Throughout the per-
leaders who brought this informa-
designed blue style robes. In this formance, the sheet was retracted
tion to the attention of House Mi-
show, Kung Fu’s “taolu,” or form, or thrown out to add effect to the
nority Leader John Boehner.
was strongly advocated. The show.
Majority Leader Boehner
“taolu” stresses flexibility, bal- The culture show ended with
brought this pork to the atten-
ance, coordination, and strength- a hip-hop dance featuring all the
tion of the American people who
ening one’s “qi,” or life force. performers in the entire show.
qickly saw through it. Soon af-
The musical act concluded The performers received a loud
ter, President Obama pressured
the first half of the show and was ovation from the audience as
Speaker Pelosi to remove this
divided into three sections. The the music winded down and the
provision from the bill, which she
first and second part featured a performers took their respective
did.Moloney said that he loved
small group of students singing bows on stage. The cast members
working at Heritage, but this past
both traditional and modern Chi- assembled near the ticket booth
fall he left to enter St. Johns Sem-
nese songs. The contemporary at Robsham and were greeted by KSA’s Dalchum masked performers prepare to dazzle audiences at the KSA/CSA cul-
inary located across the street.
song attempted to “capture the friends after the show concluded.
from Boston College. ture show.

6 News
Student Groups Seek to End Human Trafficking
Students Speak Against Modern Slavery
By Joe Morabito
The Observer
Slavery has not ended. It
has in fact more than doubled
its numbers, with currently over
27 million enslaved human be-
ings worldwide, up from 11 mil-
lion during the height before the
Civil War. Human trafficking is
modern slavery, and it is the fast-
est growing criminal industry in
the world, occurring all over the
world, even in our own city of
Boston.
On Feb. 3, these facts were
brought to light by the new cam-
pus group R.E.A.C.T. in a presen-
tation to the College Republicans
of Boston College. The group, an
abbreviation for Rallying Efforts
Against Contemporary Traffick-
ing, aimed to spread awareness
to politically involved student
groups, hoping that the two could
find commonalities.
“There definitely can be
ways that our interests can inter-
sect,” said Lisbee Mumford, a
senior and member of the leader-
ship board of R.E.A.C.T.
A panel made up of Lisbee
and her fellow R.E.A.C.T. lead-
ers, Hannah and Caroline, spoke
on the realities of human traffick-
ing, as well as what their group
does to help stop it.
Human trafficking is cur-
rently the second largest criminal
industry in the world and, with its
rate of growth, could soon sur-
pass the drug trade as the largest.
Hannah, explaining why gangs
are switching, said, “Profitably, it
is extremely smart because drugs
can only be exchanged one time
and a girl you can sell over and
over again.”
The two main types of human
trafficking are forced labor and its
more notorious counterpart, sex
slavery, where adults and chil-
dren of both sexes are forced into
Observer Editors Win Internships
One will travel to Prague, the other to Washington D.C.
By Jesse Naiman
The Observer
Editor-in-Chief Michael
Reer and Associate Opinions
Editor Elise Anderson will study
journalism this summer in Prague
and Washington D.C., respective-
ly. Reer will spend two weeks in
Prague as part of the Collegiate
Network’s (CN) Geo-Strategic
Journalism Course while Ander-
son will work forty hours a week
for eight weeks at The Washing-
ton Times.
Reer, who is also the Presi-
dent of the Boston College Re-
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
prostitution. Also included is the
problem of child soldiers, such as
in Northern Uganda. It is particu-
larly troubling that half of those
victimized by human trafficking
are minors.
Human trafficking is illegal
in every country yet the problem
remains unresolved mainly be-
cause of concealment and prob-
lems with enforcement. “Many
of the countries don’t enforce it;
the police don’t care.” Explained
Caroline, “The governments are
corrupt, or, like in our country,
police would enforce it, but peo-
ple keep it under cover.”
Hannah described how it is
so difficult to catch traffickers
because trafficked prostitutes are
indistinguishable from normal
prostitutes, who are criminals
themselves. When sex rings are
broken up, it is often the case that
the trafficked girls are rounded
up and prosecuted with the traf-
fickers. Traffickers use this fact to
intimidate their captives and keep
them from talking to authorities.
Another major roadblock to
prosecution is getting the victims
to testify in court about what has
been done to them. It is difficult
because their captors have such
a strong psychological hold on
them. Threats that they will be
either deported or imprisoned are
common, as well as death threats
on their families back home.
“Healthcare workers are
some of the only people that can
intervene because human traf-
ficking victims are kept so hidden
from the public eye.” Said Lisbee,
“Training healthcare workers to
notice signs of human trafficking
is absolutely vital.”
Lisbee, who traveled on a BC
grant to Thailand, considered the
global hub of human trafficking,
spoke about the conditioning and
deception used by traffickers to
persuade children to leave home
publicans, applied for a sum-
mer journalism internship with
the CN. The CN, of which The
Observer at Boston College is a
member, was founded in 1979
as a support group for conserva-
tive and libertarian newspapers
on college campuses. After Reer
was notified that he was invited
to Prague to work on his craft, he
willingly accepted.
When in Prague, he will be
assigned to write either three reg-
ular-length news articles or one
feature article. The CN will pay
all of his expenses for the dura-
tion. While Reer was offered an
Boston College students discuss human trafficking with R.E.A.C.T.
for this terrible life. “People go
into villages to recruit young
children saying that they have
fantastic jobs in the big city and
they’ll be making lots of money
to send home, and then families
send their children. Once they
get to the city, they’ll say you are
working in a brothel and you have
to pay back all the money spent
bringing you here; and until you
pay those back you’re going to
stick around. And then they in-
flate the prices of housing and
food until it becomes impossible
to get out.”
Lisbee explained that human
trafficking in the U.S. is shock-
ingly common, with 19,000 peo-
ple brought into the country every
year. People are mostly brought
in with false documents or are
smuggled. Traffickers tell their
victims that if they talk to authori-
ties they will be arrested for being
here illegally.
Trafficking spreads beyond
major cities. “The syndicates in
the U.S. are connected through
small towns and big cities,” said
Lisbee. “There have been cases
coming up now in small towns in
Missouri, Iowa and Wyoming and
also in big cities like New York
and Boston.”
Documented cases of hu-
man trafficking have occurred
internship with the CN last sum-
mer, he turned it down in order
to spend the summer in Chicago
working with underprivileged
kids.
Anderson will spend eight
weeks of her summer at the Wash-
ington Times, a D.C.-based news-
paper. Although Anderson also
applied for a CN internship, she
also sent an application directly
to the Times. They contacted her
last Friday and informed her that
she had been accepted for an in-
ternship. Anderson said that she
would “be covering events in
Washington and reporting [them]
just miles away from BC’s cam-
pus. “In Allston/Brighton they’ve
found massage parlors that aren’t
really massage parlors and also
brothels,” reported Hannah.
The resources for combating
human trafficking in Boston are
deplorably low. A task force of a
mere three officers is assigned to
cover the whole city. In addition,
though there is a federal regula-
tion, there is no anti-trafficking
law currently in Massachusetts.
Asked why legislation has
failed to pass, Lisbee responded,
“They’re asking for resources
that people aren’t necessarily
willing to sign over. And a lot of it
is arguments over definitions and
terms like what exactly is human
trafficking.”
Lisbee explained how Amer-
ican consumerism can contribute
to the funding of human traffick-
ing. “American consumers are al-
ways driving businesses in a race
to the bottom to produce things as
cheaply as possible.” Almost all
cases of slave labor use by Ameri-
can companies were in contracted
work.
American consumers should
do all they can to make sure their
products come from slave free
labor, yet the R.E.A.C.T. present-
ers acknowledged how hard this
can be. The further production
to the paper,” and that she would
also be “assigned to the Business
desk.”
She spent last summer as an
intern for the Fox News Channel
in Washington, and is especially
excited: “hopefully this experi-
ence will allow me to build on ev-
erything that I learned there, and
maybe even allow me to work
with some of the same people or
ask them for advice.”
Anderson joined The Ob-
server last fall as a writer before
joining the staff as the Editor-at-
Large before ascending to her
current slot. She has written for
The Observer
February 17, 2009
methods disappear down the sup-
ply chain, the harder it is to track
what uses slave labor. When is-
sues come to light the compa-
nies almost always did not know
themselves. What consumers can
do is pay attention to internation-
al watchdog organizations that
track what companies are guilty
of use of slavery. Such organiza-
tions include FREE2WORK and
Free The Slaves.
A key project that R.E.A.C.T.
is trying to raise money for is a
special shelter for victims of hu-
man trafficking. Explains Lisbee,
“None of the other shelters will
take in victims of human traf-
ficking because a lot of times the
women and men are still connect-
ed to their traffickers; they’re still
tracking them. Having traffickers
hanging around shelters is going
to put everyone there at risk.”
Lisbee explained that the
group is mainly concerned with
spreading awareness. “We want
to make sure that it’s not just seen
as a women’s issue or a social
justice, but really make people
aware this is attached to every-
one’s lives.” But she also stressed
that concrete steps are necessary,
saying, “We have to look beyond
just knowing what’s going on be-
cause people’s liberties are being
taken away.
both the News and Opinions sec-
tions, and has covered a variety
of issues with a primary focus on
politics.
In other news, The Observer
has made a splash in the local and
regional press for its reporting on
professors protesting classroom
crucifixes. The Boston Herald
covered the story on its front
page, and local news channel 7
covered it as well. In addition, it
received internet coverage as well
from the National Review Online
blog The Corner, The Cardinal
Newman Society, and CAMPUS
Magazine Online.
The Observer
February 17, 2009
New Pay Restriction for Wall Street
Obama Administration Hits Wallets of Wall Street Executives
By E. Michael Arnold
The Observer
New provisions for executive com-
pensation may leave a sour taste in the
mouths of some Wall Street members. The
$787 billion stimulus bill has new regula-
tions on compensation that are tougher
than the proposed $500,000 salary cap pro-
posed over a week ago.
The previous plan applies to any new
firms requesting for funds from the now fa-
mous, or infamous, Troubled Asset Relief
Program (TARP). The new provisions will
apply retroactively to any firms that have
received government money, past or pres-
ent. The restrictions will go after the bo-
nuses of executives that have sparked pub-
lic outcry in recent weeks. These bonuses
often constitute the bulk of an executive’s
pay for the year.
How steep of a cut can they expect?
Executives would not be allowed to re-
ceive bonuses equal to more than one third
of their annual pay. Furthermore, any bo-
nus received would be in the form of long-
term incentives, such as restricted stock,
which could not be cashed out until the
TARP funds have been repaid in full.
The provisions follow a rising wave of
populism and growing discontent among
taxpayers who are frustrated by the lack of
economic improvement and the compensa-
tion received by executives who were at
the helm during the meltdown. “The deci-
sions of certain Wall Street executives to
enrich themselves at the expense of tax-
payers have seriously undermined public
confidence,” said Senator Chris Dodd (D-
CT).
Some top economic advisors of the
Obama administration reportedly warned
lawmakers that the compensation provi-
sions, while politically popular, may go
too far and instigate a brain drain in the
financial sector and result in a quick repay-
ment of the federal funds and a new credit
tightening as they lose their federal capital
cushion.
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
Business 7
Furthermore, banks could retaliate by The government needs to resist populist the crisis were not adequately linked to
raising the salaries of their employees to movements that are seeking the heads of performance and were largely volume, not
make up for the reduction in bonuses. With highly paid executives. Overly punitive quality based. This led to a perverse incen-
the pay restrictions applying to top trad- measures will have detrimental effects on tive structure, whose consequences are be-
ers, managers, and portfolio advisors, the the recovery. ing felt today.
coverage is much broader than earlier mea- The banks need to accept that they Humility needs to prevail in some
sures aimed solely at executives. Congress played an instrumental role in the collapse way. However, in a showdown between
is apparently expressing their disapproval of our economy and need to start taking Wall Street executives and Washington
at Treasury Secretary Geithner’s ability to ownership for it. One should not be re- politicians, it is difficult to envision this
crack down on the lavish compensation on warded for failure. Bonuses leading up to scenario unfolding.
Wall Street.
In the wake of these moves, top trad-
ers could leave banks and head to less reg-
ulated hedge funds or even move to foreign
banks.
The government is stuck in a position
of finding a reasonable balance between
ensuring that taxpayer money does not re-
ward failure and preventing a case where
banks tighten credit and depress the econo-
my further in protest of the measure. There
is little evidence in recent years to suggest
that Wall Street is above cutting their nose
off to spite their face.
Among the things to be taken into con-
sideration is where the top talent at these
firms will move to find greater compensa-
tion. It is unlikely that they will be able to
match their compensation during the boom
times of the subprime derivative market.
Wall Street attracted talent that was seek-
ing the highest pay possible. The govern-
ment may be able to call their bluff up to
a certain price point. There are not many
places offering multimillion dollar incen-
tives, but there is a breaking point.
I am not particularly concerned by the
threat of the “brain drain” of individuals
who were too blind or lacking in charac-
ter to notice the inherent risk of the system
they had created. However, the prospect
of immediate repayment of TARP funds to
avoid federal oversight is a very real threat.
The private sector does not have the ability
to inject its own liquidity into the market,
and if banks refuse government funds, then
credit will remain constricted and econom-
ic recovery will be painfully slow.
Ideally, some balance will emerge.
 “There is no freedom without the Truth”
The Observer The Observer “There is no freedom without the Truth”

8 Editorials February 17, 2009 February 17, 2009 Editorials 9

Cautious Editor-in-Chief
Michael Karl Reer You Don’t Know Jacq
How to survive a relationship on the rocks
Endorsement
Editor-in-Chief Emeritus
Jeffery Scott Kanca
Executive Editor it intimidating to enter into cer-
By Jacqueline Marie

for Dea-Hirs
Donato Infante III
For The Observer tain conversations with his or her
Layout Editor
significant other. Instead of being
Andrea Kalsow

T
Dear Jacq, so quick to dump the relation-
Managing Editor
The Observer My girlfriend and I suddenly ship because she has not opened
he Observer gives its endorsement to Dea-Hirs in the upcoming Mary Margaret Brinkopf
Boston College
Catholic Issues Editor To the Editor: ish was Holy Trinity in Georgetown, the Jesuit par- don’t seem to be communicating. up with you in the way that you
UGBC election. The vast amount of experience that the ticket
Box L-132 McElroy Commons Max Bindernagel ish adjacent to Georgetown University. There was She seems to be going through would like, see if you can offer
displays as well as the willingness to step back and take an ob-
Chestnut Hill, MA 02467 Assoc. Catholic Issues Editor I must first preface my letter with the statement a “crucifix incident” at Georgetown. The students some stuff but talks to her girl- yourself as a support figure, even
jective look at how the undergraduate government works makes this
A Member of the Collegiate Network Michael Williams that I have no connection to Boston College. How- began an initiative to place crucifixes in classrooms friends more than me. She’s al- though you don’t know what her
ticket the best possible choice for Boston College. Both tickets display
Asst. Catholic Issues Editors ever, I am a graduate of Omaha’s Jesuit university, at Georgetown. Today, crucifixes are in all of the ways too busy to spend time with exact problems are; she might
an excellent platform and both tickets will be successful if elected but
Mission Statement Shane Ulbrich Creighton University. I have received both my bach- classrooms at Georgetown. Muslims, Jews and other me because of her “issues” but decide to confide in you at a later
we believe that Dea-Hirs present smaller, and more feasible, goals for
Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam—For the Greater Glory of God Rachele Reis elors and medical degrees from Creighton. non-Christians don’t seem to have a problem with will not even tell me what those point, when she’s ready.
the BC community. One year is an amazingly short period of time and News Editor
The Observer at Boston College is a student newspaper produced by mem- I was in the BC bookstore and picked up a copy the crucifixes. They realize that Georgetown is a issues are. How long can this go I can understand why you are
a campus that moves at a “glacial pace” must be prepared for an under- Jesse Naiman
bers of the Boston College community. It promotes and defends traditional of The Observer. The article about the crucifixes in Catholic, Jesuit university. on? Should I end the relation- concerned about your girlfriend
graduate government to take small, achievable steps to better the lives Associate News Editor
political and religious values both within Boston College and beyond. The the classrooms caught my attention. The comments I wonder if the chemistry professors would be ship? because whatever she is dealing
of students over a long period of time. In keeping with The Observer’s JP Bonner
Observer strongly champions the ideals of Western Civilization, the free of the chairman of the chemistry department were unnerved if a woman sat in their classes wearing a - Not Communicating with is affecting your relation-
tradition of endorsing candidates who have the highest probability of Assistant News Editors
market, limited government, personal freedom and responsibility, and ad- both elitist and crude. The chemistry professors burka or a traditional religious habit? ship. Remember, though, that two
achieving an acceptable platform, we encourage students to vote for Akash Chougule
herence to the Magisterium of the Catholic Church. Taking seriously the should teach chemistry and “get a life.” Boston Col- I enjoyed your newspaper very much. I espe- Dear Not Communicating, people in a relationship are a unit,
Dea-Hirs. Danielle Sanchez
values to which Boston College is committed as a Catholic university in Opinions Editor lege is a “Catholic and Jesuit” university, sponsored cially liked the honesty and challenges presented I’m sorry to hear that you so when something affects her, it
Reilly-Kaz offer many positive points to their platform that we
the Western tradition, The Observer strives to promote the highest quality Allison Gallagher by the Society of Jesus. Let me repeat: “Society of by your staff of talented writers. Keep up the good and your girlfriend have had a is unsurprising that it has the po-
hope Dea-Hirs will accept should they win the election. Taking an ob-
of journalism by providing a forum for news, opinion, and editorial at BC Associate Opinions Editor JESUS.” What figure is on the crucifix? If I was a work. relationship hiccup. I’m glad, tential to affect you as well. This
jective, business-minded look at all UGBC events and challenging the
that otherwise would not exist. Dedicated towards advancing the intel- Elise Anderson student at Brandeis, I certainly would not be offend- Sincerely, however, that you are sensitive may mean that the relationship
perception that just because UGBC has funded an event for the past
lectual life, The Observer desires an active and healthy exchange of ideas, Assistant Opinions Editor ed by any art or “icons” of Judaism. Fr. William S. Dunn, MD,MPH to the fact that something is trou- will require more on your part
ten years it must continue to do so, is an approach badly needed on our
and encourages letters and article submissions from all of the members of Matthew Vigliotta I practiced and taught at George Washington St. Mary’s Parish bling her and that you want to be in terms of flexibility and under-
campus. Furthermore, we love the accountability that Reilly-Kaz wish Dana Flynn
the University Community. University Medical School for 15 years. My par- Chelmsford, MA responsive to her situation. I do standing, or it may very well be
to bring to UGBC by supporting a sophomore on an executive ticket. Sports Editor get the feeling, though, that you that your girlfriend isn’t in the
This would be the first time in recent history that an executive ticket Erik Kreutzer
Policies are ready to jump ship on the re- right place to hold up her end of
could be held accountable in a secondary election. Associate Sports Editors
First three copies free, each additional copy $3.00. Requests for multiple To the Editor: pected to know and uphold the University Mission lationship because you feel that the relationship. It is up to you,
Ideally, the two sets of candidates would be able to merge their Lara Barger
copies can be directed to info@thebcobserver.com. Subscriptions to The Statement which gives due recognition to the Cath- you are not communicating, but then, to decide if it is primarily
platforms at the end of the election cycle to create an undergraduate Kaitlin McKinley
Observer are $50. Papers will be sent by first class mail. Please send re- I received my copy of The Observer and I thank olic character of the institution. Catholics are ex- I ask you to look at the heart of affecting the quantity or the qual-
government that is both feasible and efficient. We have confidence that Business/Photography Editor
quests to the address above. All advertisements in The Observer do not E. Michael Arnold you for it, perhaps through the good offices of my pected to uphold the mission, and non-Catholics are the issue and see what is really ity of your interactions. If you un-
Dea-Hirs recognize that there are massive inefficiencies in the current
constitute endorsement by The Observer, Inc. Editorial Assistant friend. It is a well-written and informative student required to not obstruct or undermine it. It escapes troubling you about her inability derstand that you cannot expect
UGBC government and will work to fix them over the course of the
The views and opinions portrayed in various articles within The Observer Christopher Spellman newspaper with a distinctively non-liberal theme me how anyone can seriously voice objection to the to open up in the way you would full disclosure and you still feel
next year. No matter who the next administration is, The Observer will
may or may not represent the opinion of each individual staff member. Photographer is indeed welcome on today’s campuses. I was placing of a Crucifix in a classroom, as a reminder like. that it is negatively affecting your
be carefully watching and tracking the progress of the executive branch
The Observer reserves the right to edit all letters to the editor for length Sarah Hatton shocked, yes SHOCKED, about the professors who to all about the character of the school. If anyone is As you have so perceptively relationship, you need to voice
to make sure that campaign promises are followed through on.
and clarity purposes. The Observer reserves the right to refuse any letter Editor-At-Large are allegedly “offended” by the sight of Crucifixes so highly offended, they should be counseled to seek acknowledged, communication your concerns, or else you your-
to the editor. The Observer is not responsible for grammar, punctuation, Jared Scheinuk in the classroom. At a minimum, a Crucifix sym- employment elsewhere. is important to fostering healthy self have failed to communicate
capitalization, and spelling. The Observer welcomes letters to the editor. Copy Editor Congratulations and best wishes to you and all relationships, although the part properly.
bolizes the University’s commitment to a Catholic

Why Should I Pay Submissions may be emailed to bcobserver@gmail.com.

The Observer, Inc. is a non-profit 501(c)3 organization; all donations are
Megan Rauch
Webmaster
Sarah Gilliland
identity, which seems to have escaped some of these
protesters. The snide comment about administrators
those on your staff for putting forth this needed addi-
tion to the BC campus. God bless you for your work
that is sometimes left out is that
communicating with someone
does not necessarily mean tell-
Try saying, “I notice that
you’ve been acting differently
tax deductible. All content is property of The Observer and may not be not being “academics” displays a disdain bordering at promoting Truth. lately, and I feel like I don’t get
used without expressed written permission. © 2008, The Observer, Inc. Sincerely, ing one person anything and ev- to see you as often. I was won-
for your Screw-ups? on contempt for the University, which issues their
paychecks.
At the university where I teach, everyone,
Dr. Peter W. Frey
Professor Emeritus
erything. In fact, it sounds like
your girlfriend IS communicating
dering if there’s something you
need from me.” She may not have
to a large extent, except it’s with

A
Pope Benedict Catholic or non-Catholic who is hired to teach is ex- Holy Family University realized that her mood has been
her female friends and not with affecting you, or you may have
XVI is to meet
student referendum to be placed on the ballot this week calls with Nancy Pe- you. What’s important to recog- been voicing her very concern.
for condoms to be made available on campus, for STD testing losi this week to nize is that, if, for some reason, Sometimes it can be your own
to be partially financed by the university, and for prescription explain why 12th your girlfriend does not feel that disclosure that encourages others
birth control in health services. The petition is being sponsored by century Catholic Please submit letters to the editor to bcobserver@gmail.com she can disclose certain issues to to reveal how he or she is feeling
a group calling itself BC Students for Sexual Health. The Observer anatomy should The Observer reserves the right to edit for length and content you, it should not necessarily be about a relationship.
encourages students not to sign the petition and to furthermore vote A Vietnam era documen- not carry more a relationship deal breaker, or a Remember, it can be really
against the referendum. The issue of STD testing aside, the referen- tary with Jane Fonda will weight than cur- reflection of her feelings for you. hard for some people to confide
dum is incredibly vague, contradicts the university mission, and in- be released imminently rent Church doc- Sometimes women really need to to those closest to them. The time
sults the resourcefulness of BC students. over Fonda’s objections. trine. The Swiss speak with other women, and you

Quote of the Issue

that it takes for you to sort every-
Boston College students are intelligent people who have been Said Fonda, “the Ameri- Guard has been should be glad that she has such thing out might be lengthy, but it
can imperialists are try- issued silver bul-
taught to be responsible. At no point has anyone been given an in- After BC’s victory against lets and have good girlfriends that can help her may just be a bump in the road
alienable right to sexual health services. Furthermore, sexually ac- ing to ruin my image by Duke, Tyrese Rice was erected a wooden with whatever is bothering her. and a chance for your relation-
tive students are fully capable of finding their own contraception off releasing documentaries quoted as saying “I’m so Now, although her issues
stake “just in ship to go stronger. Since people
I would rather burn. As a high right now.”
campus at such places as Campus Convenience, a mere two minute
walk away. If the generous donations of university benefactors are
communist, I am deeply
troubled by this trend.”
case.”
We cannot open the Gospel without could be something that she is
unable to share with you, this is
come with problems, so do rela-
tionships, and you have to decide
consumed by students who voluntarily engage in needlessly risky be-
havior, those who chose not to engage in this type of behavior are Some BC students want university funded condoms on campus. Right,
finding in every page the sentence of not to say that your girlfriend will
not ever let you in on what she is
how you’re going to handle it.
Are you going to run off as soon
robbed of the potential benefits that this money could otherwise bring. and Father Leahy is going to remove the crucifixes in every classroom. reprobation pronounced by our Blessed dealing with, especially if you’ve as things start getting messy? Are
Students who desire to live a chaste life should not be required to
fund the sexual activity of other students through their tuition money.
Sociology Professors
Lord against the world. Its doctrines done your part to prove yourself
as a reliable confidante. Namely,
you able to recognize when poor
communication is hurting a rela-
Tuition is already over $50,000 a year. If students wish to add STD
testing to their BC insurance, they should do so solely out of their own
In recognition of Chicago’s high stan-
dard for ethics, Obama will give Chi-
rushed the court with and maxims are placed continually in make sure that you have made
yourself a willing and listen-
tionship? Can you gauge when a
relationship is broken and when it
pocket. cago native Rahm Emmanuel charge
reckless abandon-
ment after BC’s win opposition to those of the eternal wis- ing audience. Instead of saying, requires an extra dose of commit-

dom and holiness.

BC is a Catholic university. As such it subscribes in policy to of the 2010 census. Emmanuel had “Hey, what’s wrong?” and forc- ment on your part?
pledged to extend suffrage to every cat
over Duke Sunday
the teachings of the Catholic Church, which believes that the marital ing her to feel that you need an When it comes down to it,
and dog in blue states. night until they re-
embrace is an expression of love that demands a lifelong commitment all-or-nothing answer, remind her a relationship involves work on
alized that students
within marriage. Moreover, the sexual act, when divorced from the that you care about her and are the part of both parties. If you’ve
were celebrating a
possibility of new life by use of artificial contraception constitutes a Coach Spaziani has returned to the re-
cruiting trail after growing frustrated basketball win and -Bishop John Carroll there if she needs to talk, without done your part, and you feel that

entitled “The Christian and

violation of authentic, life giving love. BC students know and under- coming across as pushy. you are not getting any response
stand the Catholic nature of the university they attend. They should
with Dominique Davis. He is hoping to not the election of from a sermon I know it sounds strange, but back, it is necessary to enter into
the World”
lure Brett Favre out of retirement. Hugo Chavez to Dic-
not look to pick a fight they know they cannot win with an administra- sometimes, even in a committed a discussion about it.
tion that has just reaffirmed the Catholic nature of this college. tator-For-Life. relationship, one partner may find

10
BC Jesuit Challenges Men
Is Chastity Possible?
By Max Bindernagel
The Observer
To Boston College philoso-
phy professor Fr. Paul McNellis,
S.J., living a chaste life in today’s
culture is not only possible but
necessary. This past Thursday in
a packed lecture hall, Fr. McNellis
presented his “Chastity and Cour-
age: A Challenge for Men,” a lec-
ture now well-known and highly
anticipated on campus. He began
giving this talk five years ago in
response to the pain he saw in his
students, suffering from the hook-
up culture and one-night stands in
an age of emotional detachment.
Ever since, the campus has re-
sponded with likeminded events
such as “Bring Back the Date.”
However, as Fr. McNellis notes,
even though BC and universities
nationwide are turning away from
the hook-up scene, such a culture
remains the norm. “[Hooking up]
is unnatural,” he argued, “It is full
of the pain and suffering which go
along with using another person.”
Though speaking from a
pastoral, Catholic perspective,
McNellis emphasized that it is
simultaneously “a common sense
approach.” He urged listeners to
Dialogue and Discernment in the Church: Is Chastity Possible?
Reflections on the 2009 Candlemas Lecture
By Shane Ulbrich
The Observer
Each year the Lowell Hu-
manities Series sponsors a Can-
dlemas Lecture about Church and
society. In recent years, the series
has featured a plethora of distin-
guished speakers. On Wednes-
day evening, Fr. Thomas Reese,
S.J., editor of America Magazine
(1998 to 2005) and a senior fel-
low at the Woodstock Theologi-
cal Center, spoke on “How to
Survive as a Thinking Catholic.”
The audience turnout was
impressive for the number of
Jesuits and theology faculty, no
doubt due to the provocative title,
“A Survival Guide for Think-
ing Catholics.” As the title hints,
the purpose of the talk was to
outline—from a self-described
liberal point of view—the ways
toward more productive dialogue
amidst polarization in the Church.
Fr. Reese offered ten guide-
lines for the “thinking Catholic.”
Ignatian discernment played a
driving role: a person’s words
should always be interpreted
“in the best possible light,” he
said. “I have jokingly noted that
people should know that we are
Christians by our love rather
than know that we are Catholics
“Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam”
Catholic Issues
be “Catholics without compro-
mise.” He said that men in par-
ticular need to accept this chal-
lenge because so many problems
in our culture stem from the lack
of virtuous father figures. Even
though virginity and chastity are
seen as being “in some way ab-
normal,” he noted the presence
of all-male spiritual groups at
Catholic universities nationwide
as a sign of cultural change. One
such group at BC, the Sons of
St. Patrick, says in their consti-
tution: “Founded on the pillars
of faith, fortitude, and fraternity,
we seek to create a brotherhood
of Christian gentlemen dedicated
to leading virtuous lives, whose
actions, particularly in their in-
teraction with women, reflect an
understanding of what it means to
be a true disciple of Christ.” Mc-
Nellis sees such trends in higher
education as a sign of great hope.
“Boys can have sex,” he asserted.
“It takes a man to lead a chaste
life.”
Explaining the genesis of
current sexual standards, Fr. Mc-
Nellis noted that the generation of
the 60’s and 70’s experienced the
greatest social upheaval in histo-
ry. A 50% divorce rate, abortion
by our fights,” he said. We must
also ground dialogue in moving
beyond sound bites and “doing
our homework,” knowing Church
history so as to take a holistic
view of things.
Some further remarks dealt
with the need to distinguish dis-
ciplinary law (such as priestly
celibacy) from doctrine and to
understand the relative weight of
different magisterial decisions,
documents, and encyclicals. Fr.
Reese finally suggested the need
to settle disagreements by com-
promise rather than convincing
by argument.
The heart of Fr. Reese’s lec-
ture, though, came through in his
concluding remarks: “One must
pray not simply for the conver-
sion of one’s opponents, but for
the conversion of oneself. With-
out humility and charity, we
have anarchy, witch-hunts, and
schisms—the things which divide
and bring down the Church...
Christians have faith in the Word
of God that shows us the way,
and Christians have hope based
on Christ’s victory over sin and
death and his promise of the Spir-
it, and Christians have love which
compels them to forgiveness and
companionship at the Lord’s
table. Any survival strategy for
on demand, and a stunning lack
of good fathers can all be traced
back to the lifestyle of the 60’s.
As McNellis said, “Never has a
culture survived with these sta-
tistics.” Though he would claim
that our generation is very pro-
family, he also notes that “men
and women do not relate to each
other” very well, and our “moral
order is that of broken promises.”
The late John Paul II spoke of the
culture of death, and such a cul-
ture will not change until “men
lead chaste lives” and ask them-
selves, “What kind of man do
I want to be? Because women
have come to expect far too less
from men.”
Many listening may have
wondered why the two virtues of
chastity and courage were juxta-
posed by McNellis. He explained
that in ancient culture, chastity
(or temperance), was valued es-
pecially for women for social
stability while courage was seen,
especially by Aristotle, as being
able to face death in battle. With
Christianity, chastity becomes
valuable for men as well and cour-
age can take the form of speaking
the truth in the face of opposition.
John Paul II spoke of martyrdom
thinking Catholics must be based
on such faith, hope, and love.”
Fr. Reese set a tone of harsh
sarcasm when, at the very begin-
ning of the lecture, he forewarned
the audience, tongue-in-cheek:
“If you are completely happy
with everything that is going on
in the Catholic Church, you’ve
come to the wrong lecture. If
you’ve never had a doubt about
your faith, please leave now… If
you’ve never disagreed with any-
thing said by a Bishop or a Pope,
I think your time would be spent
better somewhere else.”
Moreover, in the discussion
period, Fr. Reese began to draw a
helpful analogy for the role of the
hierarchy in the Church. Too of-
ten, he explained, “the Church” is
thought of as simply synonymous
with “the hierarchy,” when re-
ally the hierarchy is only a part—
though a crucial part—of the oth-
er, larger Body of Christ. From
the mistaken view, clericalism
and a kind of undue veneration
of the hierarchy easily result. As
members of “the Body of Christ,”
he explained, the hierarchy is “the
skeleton” that holds this body to-
gether and keeps it from losing its
potency. “They hold us together,”
he said. Yet he moved this helpful
skeletal analogy further: “They’re
“by enduring sarcasm,” a martyr-
dom which McNellis said many
Christian men face.
From the Catholic perspec-
tive, the loving process of pro-
creation is to be of highest value,
not a mere mechanized process
of reproduction. The Church has
always taught that sexuality is in-
herently incarnational, meaning
the body is part of one’s selfhood.
To act with the body is to act with
the whole of one’s person. With
this in mind, a total gift of self
ought to manifest itself sexually
by a total loving commitment to
another. For this reason, McNel-
lis claimed that those who live
chastely tend to be more level-
headed and focused. The current
accepted divorce between sexu-
ality and marriage can be traced
back to irresponsible men who
find it too easy to ignore respon-
sibility for their sexual actions.
In concluding his talk, Fr.
McNellis fulfilled his promise
and did indeed challenge men.
He urged men to orient them-
selves towards lifelong love for
their future spouse, because “if
you use ‘love’ when you don’t
mean it, what’s left when you
do mean it?” Chaste courtship
pretty ugly on their own, they’re
scary! They’re not the brain,
they’re not the heart, they’re not
the muscles, they’re not going to
get much done…”
Much of the discussion peri-
od proceeded similarly, with un-
derstandable criticisms of recent
actions of the hierarchy, and yet
with an air of laughing sarcasm
unbecoming of ecclesial commu-
nion. At several points the eve-
ning’s discussion devolved into
the exact opposite of Fr. Reese’s
ideals of conciliation.
Nonetheless, some in atten-
dance raised valid concerns. One
professor worried about the lack
of avenues for effective dialogue
within the Church outside of aca-
demia. Parishioners especially
find themselves isolated and inca-
pable of connecting to the larger
Church. Another asked about
the hope for various “initiatives”
within the Church for liberal re-
form which seem to be waning, to
the frustration of supporters.
In the Rule of St. Benedict,
abbots are told when deciding
upon very significant matters
within the monastery to call to-
gether the community and to lis-
ten especially to the young, since
“the Lord often reveals to the
younger what is best.” St. Bene-
The Observer
February 17, 2009
Father McNellis
is natural, healthy and “corre-
sponds to what the heart really
wants… and with God’s help it
is possible.” Furthermore, he re-
minded listeners that “Catholics
have a great gift with the Sacra-
ments,” including opportunities
for grace and healing which are
needed for living chastely. BC
junior Grayson Heenan said after
the lecture, “Chastity is a choice
oriented towards our fulfillment
as humans… In the end, you lose
nothing in being chaste.”
At a time when BC hosts per-
formances of the Vagina Mono-
logues and students challenge the
university’s policy concerning
contraceptives and abortion refer-
rals, McNellis spoke of the true
freedom which can only come
by leading a virtuous life. “As a
Catholic university, you deserve
to hear this at BC.”
dict’s words from the sixth cen-
tury are quite applicable to lay-
persons today. In trying to come
to terms with the contentious,
confusing, and often spiritually
dangerous polarization in the
contemporary Church, one ought
to listen to all voices, privileging
the hierarchy as the guarantors of
that “rule of faith,” but also look
to the Church where it is most
youthful and invigorated.
What are the concerns, then,
of young, committed Catholics?
At their best, young Catholics,
without being reactionary, have
moved beyond more liberal con-
cerns towards a new understand-
ing of aggiornamento, of a vibrant
present in continuity with the
past. At their best, these young
peers are also eminently Christo-
centric. They see a Catholicism
which has not simply rejected lib-
eralism, as much as it has learned
from it and moved beyond it.
Those who wish to foster genuine
dialogue could follow the Spirit
in the Church today, and attempt
in faith, hope, and charity humbly
to submit initiatives to the dis-
cernment of the larger Church.
Ultimately, we must first look not
to our grievances and confusion,
but to him in whom all things
hold together, Jesus Christ.
The Observer
February 17, 2009
Prevention First Act Book Review:
‘Priestblock 25487’
Meets Opposition
By Christopher Spellman
The Observer
Many have heard of the pro-
posed Freedom of Choice Act
(FOCA), a reproductive health
bill that has been getting much
press recently. Yet, fewer have
heard of a similar bill introduced
in the House and Senate called
Prevention First Act. Though re-
ceiving little media attention, the
Prevention First Act (PFA) also
strongly advances a public policy
regarding human sexuality that
divides our nation.
First and foremost, PFA
seeks to greatly expand access to
and use of contraceptives in the
United States, especially among
its poorest citizens. Specifical-
ly, the bill will greatly increase
funding for Title X of the Public
Health Service Act, which was
established to provide contra-
ceptives and other reproductive
health services to low-income
and uninsured individuals. Un-
der this bill, funding would more
than double, rising from $300
million to $700 million. PFA will
provide full coverage for contra-
ceptives for those with incomes
up to 200% of the federal poverty
level. It also promises to pro-
vide recently pregnant women
with information about and ac-
cess to “emergency contracep-
tion,” which remains controver-
sial, with some arguing that it is
actually an abortifacient. Lastly,
it seeks to provide additional
funding for “safe sex” education
in public schools, which greatly
encourages use of contraception,
while providing no funding for
“abstinence only” education.
Planned Parenthood Presi-
dent Cecile Richards, in a recent
statement, argued that PFA is “key
to preventing unintended preg-
nancy and reducing the need for
abortion by expanding access to
birth control and real sex educa-
tion.” Planned Parenthood stands
much to gain if PFA is passed.
The organization receives about
25% of funding from Title X,
which would increase from $75
million to $175 million under
PFA. It will also receive a great
increase in sales of “emergency
contraception” kits, from which
it profits $37.5 million each year.
House Rules Committee
Chairwoman Louise M. Slaughter
(D-NY), who introduced the bill,
concurs with Richards, explain-
ing that this bill would “empower
women to prevent unintended
pregnancies through education
and access to contraception.”
Slaughter and other supporters
point to the fact that half of the
“Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam”
Catholic Issues
over six million pregnancies in
the United States each year are
unintended. Moreover, nearly
half of these unintended pregnan-
cies end in abortion. Supporters
of PFA claim that increased use
of contraception will reduce the
rate of abortion and also of sexu-
ally transmitted infections (STIs).
By pushing a public policy of
contraception, those in favor of
PFA seek to attack the dual prob-
lem of a vast number of abortions
in the United States each year and
the rampant spread of STIs.
It seems intuitive that in-
creased availability and knowl-
edge of contraception will pre-
vent unintended pregnancies,
which lead to both abortion and
perpetuating the cycle of poverty
when young girls bear children
to unstable and impoverished
homes. Additionally, use of con-
traception adds a level of protec-
tion against the spread of STIs.
Since effective use of contracep-
tion does by-and-large prevent
pregnancies and help prevent the
transmission of STIs, this appears
to be a good argument. increases. The problem is that the
Yet, PFA does not come with
universal support. Many oppose
it on the grounds that “emer-
gency contraception” is actually
an abortifacient, ending the life
of a developing fetus days after
conception. Yet, even without a
provision for “emergency con-
traception,” many people oppose
increased governmental spending
on contraception. They advance
the view that more widespread
use of contraception actually in-
creases unintended pregnancies
and the spread of STIs. Dr. Wil-
liam E. May, Senior Fellow of the
Culture of Life Foundation, ad-
vances this argument: “The Act
is based on the false premise that
contraception prevents abortion.
The more contraception is avail-
able, the more abortions occur
because contraception is the gate-
way to abortion.” He continues,
claiming that most abortions oc-
cur “because men and women do
not want to have a baby but none-
theless have sexual intercourse.
Contraception facilitates premar-
ital sex and has led to an alarming
increase of sexually transmitted
diseases.”
Since the introduction of ef-
fective contraception in 1960s,
the percentage of both unintend-
ed pregnancies and the number
of cases of STIs in the United
States have drastically increased,
not decreased. While there may
be other factors leading to these
increases, it seems that contra-
ception has not proven itself an
effective means to decrease unin-
tended pregnancies or reduce the
spread of STIs in society.
Opponents of legislation like
FOCA and PFA offer an explana-
tion: when contraception increas-
es in society, sexual relations
among unmarried couples also
effectiveness of contraception, in
preventing both the conception of
a child and the spread of an STI,
is not consistent: it is liable to
human error. When this occurs,
these couples face unintended
pregnancies and possibly an STI.
Therefore, accompanying this
increase in non-marital sexual re-
lations, especially with multiple
partners, is a parallel increase
in unintended pregnancies and
STIs. Those who oppose PFA
argue that the government’s job
should be not to make people’s
use of contraception perfect, for
this is impossible, but rather en-
courage a return to the only form
of “contraception” that is 100%
effective: abstinence.
11
Rev. Robert John Araujo S.J.
For The Observer
resilience of the human person
who bears the image of his Cre-
ator. Like so many others sent
Over the past several weeks
to the concentration and death
the denial of the Holocaust by
camps, Fr. Bernard chronicles
Bishop Richard Williamson of
how the just seek ways of sav-
the Society of St. Pius X has
ing themselves and others from
brought to public consciousness
the inhumanity that man who has
the inexorable need to remember
succumbed to evil can devise.
and never to forget the atrocities
Particularly striking about
perpetrated by National Social-
his memoir is the constant de-
ism. As one ponders the magni-
sire to remain faithful to God and
tude of the vicious plan to annihi-
to the sacraments. This was no
late the Jewish people, the extent
small feat as he describes the re-
of scope of National Socialism’s
sourcefulness in the methods the
terror begins to emerge as the
Nazis continued to fabricate to
identity of additional targeted
undermine the faith in those who
groups such as Poles, Gypsies,
persevered and remained true to
and others come to mind.
their fidelity to God. Although
Hitler’s genocide strategy
death was always a close com-
encompassed many who, while
panion in Dachau as Fr. Bernard
diverse in race, nationality, and
demonstrates in many passages
ethnicity, professed faith in God.
of his memoir, so was this disci-
It is clear that National Socialism
ple’s yearning to remain commit-
intended to erode, if not extermi-
ted to what God asks of all who
nate, the leadership of organized
call upon Him as His disciples.
religions if they did not cooper-
With the coming of Lent and
ate with the Nazis and submit to
the wish for many of us to seek
their reprehensible will. Included
authentic spiritual reading as we
in this category were Catholics—
prepare to join Christ in his pas-
lay, clerical, and religious. Rev-
sion, Priestblock 25487 provides
erend Father
an excellent ve-
Jean Ber-
hicle for meet-
nard, a dioc-
ing this necessi-
esan priest
ty. One fashion
from Luxem-
bourg, who
denounced
in which this
extraordinary
testament to the
the National
Socialists,
faith accom-
plishes this task
was one ex-
is the chapter
ample. He
entitled “Ten
was arrested
Days’ Leave
by the Nazis
and My Return
in the spring
to Dachau.”
of 1941
[This is the ma-
and sent to
terial that is the
D a c h a u ’s
source of the
“ p r i e s t
film The Ninth
block.” The
Day.] Here, Fr.
account of his
Bernard chronicles his account of
imprisonment, torture, and re-
a maliciously planned “release”
markable release is the subject of
designed to make him an accom-
Priestblock 25487. The prisoner
plice to the nefarious plans of the
number 25487 used in the title is
National Socialists. I think it fair
not the ZIP code of a Washington,
to say that the “release” did not
D.C. suburb, but the identification
achieve its objective from the
Fr. Bernard was forced to assume
standpoint of the Nazis.
as the dehumanizing replacement
In short, the reviewer highly
for his name at Dachau.
recommends this book for several
This remarkable book was
reasons. The first is that it gives
penned by its author shortly af-
us of the present moment the in-
ter his permanent release from
sight of one who suffered the con-
Dachau before the end of the War.
centration camps and survived to
It is by the grace of God that he
tell about it. Second, it is the tes-
survived the dehumanizing ob-
tament of a disciple convinced of
jectification that the Nazis had
and confirmed in the truth of his
perfected. Even though he was
faith to stand up against the pow-
released and not killed from the
er of evil. In short, Fr. Bernard’s
camp, he was closely monitored
chronicle demonstrates once
by the authorities until National
again the truth that we hear in
Socialism collapsed. The reader
the preface of the Mass for mar-
should find his account from the
tyrs that God chooses the weak
moment of his imprisonment to
and makes them strong to do His
his final release a profound in-
work and to follow His will in
sight into the gift of faith and the
this world. Amen.
 The Observer The Observer
“Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam” “Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam”

12
The Vatican Celebrates
Anniversay
Vatican City State commemorates 80th Anniversary of Lateran Treaty clared war on the Papal State and
By Rachele Reis
The Observer
On Monday, February 9,
2009, journalists gathered in
Rome to attend a special exhibit
to celebrate the 80th anniversary
of the Vatican City State. That’s
right: the Vatican, the epicenter of
the Catholic world, has only ex-
isted since February 11, 1929.
The Catholic Church in
Rome dates back to about 64 AD,
when St. Peter was crucified- up-
side down- in the Circus of Nero
and buried nearby on Vatican
Hill. His burial site was marked
with a red rock, and Christians
built a shrine above the tomb a
few years later.
Three hundred years later,
the Emperor Constantine began
construction of St. Peter’s Ba-
silica. Built in the typical Latin
cross form, the basilica was used
until the period of the Avignon
Papacy. By the end of the 15th
century, however, the basilica
was in desperate need of repair.
Pope Nicholas V began plans to
Catholic Issues
restore St. Peter’s, but died before
any construction could be ac-
complished. In 1505, Pope Julius
II held a competition for designs
for the new basilica. During the
next 120 years and 20 Popes, the
“new” St. Peter’s Basilica was
built. Throughout the years, reno-
vations of St. Peter’s uncovered
remains of the Old St. Peter’s and,
from 1939 to 1941, Pope Pius XII
had Old St. Peter’s systematically
excavated.
In 756, the Papal States were
created and donated to the Church
by Pepin the Short, the father
of Charlemagne. When Char-
lemagne took over his father’s
kingdom, he affirmed the right
of the Pope to control the Papal
States and the Pope took an active
secular role in governing. Pope
Leo III crowned Charlemagne the
first Emperor of the Romans. It
was unclear, however, how much
control the Pope had, if the Papal
States were separate from the Ro-
man Empire, or if the Pope was
an administrator subordinate to
the Emperor.
The ratification of the Di-
ploma Ottonianum by Pope John
XII and Emperor Otto I, in the
mid -10th century, guaranteed the
independence of the Papal States.
From 1305 to 1378, the Avignon
Papacy, the Pope’s control over
the Papal States was merely a for-
mality. When the Popes returned
Rome, Avignon was added to the
Papal States and remained as such
until the French Revolution. A
piece of legislation, the Constitu-
tions of the Holy Mother Church,
was passed during the Avignon
Papacy, which became the first
constitution of the Papal States. It
divided the Papal States into five
provinces, and remained in effect
until 1816.
The French Revolution was
disastrous for the Papal States.
French forces invaded the Papal
States and declared a Roman Re-
public. The States were restored
after the fall of Napoleon and the
end of the Napoleonic Era. Dur-
See ‘Vatican’
page 13
Catholic Identity
Cardinal Paupard: Don’t be a ‘degree factory’
By Donato Infante III
The Observer
According to the Catholic
News Agency, President emeritus
of the Pontifical Council for Cul-
ture, Paul Cardinal Poupard, gave
a talk in Madrid recently in which
he said the “university cannot just
yield to the demands of the mar-
ket and become a mere degree
factory.” The talk, sponsored by
the John Henry Newman Institute
of the Francisco de Vitoria Uni-
versity raises serious questions
for Boston College as a Catholic
university in the Ignatian tradi-
tion, which aspires to become the
February 17, 2009
Cardinal Poupard
greatest Catholic university in the
world.
Poupard added that the
Catholic university should aim
to form the whole person, some-
thing which Boston College
speaks of often, and said that “the
mission of the Catholic university
is not complete if it does not as-
pire to evangelize.” He said that
professors are to “be teachers of
their students and not only in-
structors.” In many ways, Boston
College succeeds in this regard as
well, with programs such as In-
tersections which get professors
See ‘Identity’
page 13
February 17, 2009 Catholic Issues 13
Vatican
from page 12
ing Italian nationalization, the
Papal States were viewed as an
obstacle and eventually Italy de-
took Rome by force. Pope Pius
IX declared himself a “Prisoner
in the Vatican” and the “Roman
Question” arose.
The “Roman Question” was
answered in 1929, when the Lat-
eran Pacts were made between the
Kingdom of Italy and the Holy
See. These agreements, signed by
then Prime Minister Benito Mus-
solini and Cardinal Gasparri for
Pope Pius XI, created the state of
the Vatican City and guaranteed
independent sovereignty to the
Holy See and established Catholi-
cism as the religion of Italy.
Fast forward to the present,
and the Vatican City State is cel-
ebrating its 80th anniversary. An
exhibit has been erected over two
floors of the “Braccio di Carlo
Magno” (Arm of Charlemagne) and radio stations. On display “The first concerns the Vatican the construction of the State, its a great mission” held at the Con-
under the end of the colonnade for the first time are the original prior to 1929; the second is dedi- projects and its new buildings; ciliation Hall of the Lateran Pal-
in St. Peter’s Square. An entire documents of the Lateran Pacts, cated to Pius XI, the architect of and the fifth is dedicated to the six ace and the New Synod Hall in
room is dedicated to Pope Pius presented alongside a life-size conciliation and the great builder pontiffs who succeeded Pius XI, the Vatican. The third initiative
XI, including his gold and white photograph of the signing and the of the juridical and architectural each of whom left his own mark.” was a concert on February 12th
cope, tiara, and his car – a Citroen table that was used at the event. structures of the new State; the The exhibition is the first of in the Vatican’s Paul VI Hall. Our
Lictoria. Other items on display Cardinal Giovanno Lajolo, third focuses on the Lateran Pacts three initiatives to commemorate Lady’s Choral Society of Dublin
include wall-sized maps, portraits President of the Governorate of themselves, in other words the this anniversary. The second is Cathedral and the RTE Concert
of the seven Popes who have Vatican City State, explained at a Treaty and the Concordat signed an academic congress that took Orchestra of Dublin performed
reigned since 1929, and photo- press conference that the exhibi- in the Lateran Palace on 11 Feb- place February 12th to 14th, on Handel’s Messiah for the Holy
graphs of the Vatican’s railway tion is divided into five sections: ruary 1929; the fourth illustrates the theme “A small territory for Father.

SSPX Bishops Granted Full Communion Catholic Identity

Amid controversy, Pope Benedict XVI extends a hand of reconciliation to a famous dissident religious group.
By Michael Williams
The Observer
On January 21, 2009, Pope
Benedict XVI signed an official
decree lifting the excommunica-
tions of four bishops of the Tra-
ditionalist Society of St. Pius X.
The papal decree was made in re-
sponse to the Society-head Bish-
op Bernard Fellay’s December
15th epistolary request for the re-
moval of the excommunications.
The decree, made public three
days after it was signed, marks a
large step for the full communion
of the Society as a whole with the
Church.
With this decree, Pope Bene-
dict lifts his predecessor John
Paul II’s 1988 excommunication
order on four bishops ordained
against his wishes by Archbishop
Marcel Lefebvre, the late head
of the Traditionalist Society. The
then elderly Archbishop Lefebvre
was motivated to illicitly conse-
crate the four priests of his Soci-
ety so that it could continue to ex-
ist under the jurisdiction of one of
her own, rather than a non-Soci-
ety priest. Thus the Society could
continue to defend the traditional
norms of the Church. However,
by disobeying the wishes of the
Holy Father, Archbishop Lefe-
from page 12
bvre patently broke one of the ments.” The Vatican, though re- communion to the Society’s 463 how overlooked by some reac-
central traditions of the church storing his communion with the priests would be extremely bene- tionary progressivists in light of involved in the formation of the ones,” it was very clear that he is words “Jesuit” and “Catholic” in- Catholicism is being forced on few other Catholic schools in
– submitting his wishes to that of Church, does not agree with his ficial in a wider celebration of the the Traditionalism of the Society, whole person. not in line with the principles of sult the hard-working men of the him or her. However, the Catho- the United States have five Jesu-
the Holy Father. Lefebvre and his rather outrageous oversights. A extraordinary form of the Mass it cannot be denied that it is the Former Superior General Jesuit education. As one Jesuit Society of Jesus who would never lic intellectual tradition should be its volunteer to take a year and
bishops thus warranted schism group of French Catholics have made possible through 2007’s Holy Father’s primary intention of the Society of Jesus, the Rev. put it recently concerning dis- say the two words are opposed, held up as something positive and lead fifteen students through the
and automatic excommunication. also been averse to the Vatican’s Summorum Pontificum. The great in bringing the Lefebvrite bishops Pedro Arrupe S.J., in a famous gruntled chemistry professors, even if particular Jesuits disagree explanations on Church teachings 19th annotation of the Exercis-
No serious attempts at recon- openness towards the Tradition- desire of many faithful Catholics back into full communion. At the speech, said that Jesuit universi- “Haven’t they ever read the first with Church teachings.) Boston should be provided by faculty. es. However, in many regards,
ciliation were made from either alists, stating fears that relaxed to participate in this traditional same time, the Vatican must take ties must produce graduates who principle and foundation? The College must be more adamant Controversial university policies, BC still has a long way to go,
side up until the turn of the cen- restrictions on the celebration of form of worship thus would be measures to make sure to not re- do not live for themselves but only reason we do chemistry is about hiring for its mission. such as the ban on dispensing of and much of that lies with what
tury. However, since then, both the Tridentine Mass would fur- more readily and worthily satis- admit the Society as a whole until for Christ and neighbor. This for Christ.” The community of Boston contraception from health ser- types of professors are hired here
sides have made attempts for re- ther damage church unity with an fied. A wider celebration of the it has fully submitted to the Holy phrase is often worded as “men The first principle and foun- College needs to become more vices, should be explained in full and how they go about teaching.
union, escalating in the past few apparent celebration of two dif- extraordinary form of the Mass Father’s authority and wishes. and women for others.” This is dation is the cornerstone of the spiritually Ignatian. More stu- (“the Church is opposed to arti- “Since the objective of a Catho-
years under Benedict’s reign and ferent Masses. would also increase awareness in Benedict’s lifting of the ex- an insufficient rendering and is a Spiritual Exercises. It says, “The dents should undertake the Exer- ficial contraception” doesn’t cut lic university is to assure in an
culminating in the Janu- the overall Church communications of the Lefebvr- symptom of the one area in which human person is created to praise, cises under sound spiritual direc- it) to questioning students by the institutional manner a Christian
ary 21st decree. Key to Boston College does not measure revere, and serve God Our Lord, tors. administration, not solely by The presence in the university world
“The Holy Father’s decision of the importance of ite bishops thus reflects the most
up to Cardinal Poupard’s talk: as- and by doing so, to save his or her Not only should Catholic Observer or any other student confronting the great problems
the reconciliation has
been the Society’s new-
to restore the four Lefebvrite retaining the time-
honored traditions
typically Catholic attitude, bal-
anced and rational while at the piration to evangelization. soul. All other things on the face professors do likewise, but they group. of society and culture, every
found desire to “believe
bishops into full communion with of the Mass, which same time inducing tension for The Boston College com- of the earth are created for human should be knowledgeable about Furthermore, Catholic moral Catholic university, as Catholic,
firmly in the Primacy of the Church actually represents have sadly gone un- further progress. The Holy Fa- munity sadly has many mem- beings in order to help them pur- the order by having read the au- teachings, such as abstinence must have the following essential
Peter and in its preroga- the most Catholic position and der so much clerical ther’s timely decision caves in bers who treat the university as sue the end for which they are cre- tobiography of Ignatius, looked before marriage, fidelity within characteristics: 1. A Christian in-
tives” under Benedict, stands in a wonderfully ironic manipulation in the neither to modernists’ demands if it is a degree factory. Take, ated. It follows from this that one at the Jesuit resources online at marriage, and moderation in spiration not only of individuals
according to Bishop Fel- light.” ordinary form of the of a rejection of potentially old- for instance, the recent contro- must use other created things, in websites such as CompanionofJe- drinking need to be promoted but of the university community
lay. Mass. fashioned worship nor Tradition- versy over religious artwork in so far as they help towards one’s sus.com, and read modern day among all students as part of the as such; 2. A continuing reflection
The decree has come under However, the Holy Father’s While the Holy Father’s alism’s claims of Vatican II’s il- classrooms. When Prof. Shrayer, end, and free oneself from them, Ignatian books such as the works law on the hearts of all people and in the light of the Catholic faith
fire from various sources, both decision to restore the four Lefe- decree speaks to his traditional legitimacy. chairman of the department of in so far as they are obstacles to of Rev. Timothy Gallagher OMV. not merely some quaint and prud- upon the growing treasury of hu-
outside and inside the Church. bvrite bishops into full commu- leanings, it also reveals his “anti- Through his careful and non- Slavic and Eastern Language and one’s end.” It may even be beneficial to train ish teaching of the Church. This man knowledge, to which it seeks
Jewish groups have criticized nion with the Church actually Traditionalist” ecumenical mo- conciliatory negotiations for full Literature, said in an interview Therefore, according to St. some lay professors in spiritual is evangelization of the culture. It to contribute by its own research;
the restoration of Bishop Richard represents the most Catholic po- tives. While the restoration of communion for the Society of St. with The Boston Globe, “I be- Ignatius, the only reason one direction. Do the Catholic pro- should not be the sole responsibil- 3. Fidelity to the Christian mes-
Williamson of the Society due sition and stands in a wonderfully full communion to the Society Pius X, Benedict’s desire to in- lieve that the display of religious would study anything is to be fessors here seek to understand ity of a handful of members of the sage as it comes to us through
to his incomprehensible denial ironic light. On one hand, the would be helpful in reorienting clude both of these circles under signs and symbols, such as the brought closer to Christ. It is controversial Church teachings, philosophy and theology depart- the Church; 4. An institutional
of the Holocaust. However, as move speaks towards Benedict’s the Church’s liturgy in the tradi- the same large tent – so long as crucifix, in the classroom is con- fine if a particular professor does such as on sexuality, in order to ments to promote these, but God commitment to the service of the
Vatican spokesman Jesuit Father desire to restore more traditional tion, its primary benefit would they respect and submit to his au- trary to the letter and spirt (sic) of not believe this, but professors at be able to explain it to students? bless them for doing so already. people of God and of the human
Federico Lombardi stated, “Say- elements in the celebration of the be simply the reunion of those thority as the Successor of Peter – open intellectual discourse that Boston College need to at least The university needs to as- Boston College has a won- family in their pilgrimage to the
ing a person is not excommuni- Mass. While only acceptable if lost sheep under the care of the represents the most universal and makes education worthwhile and be okay with the fact that Bos- pire to evangelize. To evangelize derful head-start on its way to transcendent goal which gives
cated is not the same as saying the Society submits fully to pa- chief Shepherd of the Church. Al- consequently most Catholic line distinguishes first-rate universi- ton College is a Jesuit, Catholic is not the same as to proselytize. becoming the world’s greatest meaning to life” (Pope John Paul
one shares all his ideas or state- pal authority, a restoration of full though this ecumenism is some- of action. ties from mediocre and provincial college. (Those who oppose the No student should ever feel like Catholic university. Probably II, Ex Corde Ecclesiae).

14
Making Sense of the Census
Obama’s transfer of the census responsibilities from the Commerce Secretary to the Chief-of-Staff is unac-
ceptable.
By Elise Anderson
The Observer
As Obama settles in to his
first 100 days in office, it seems as
if he faces an overwhelming num-
ber of problems. Obama recently
announced his intention of tak-
ing control of the United States
Census Bureau from the Com-
merce Department, suggesting
that, despite his campaign prom-
ises, he may just be like any other
politician with ambitious political
goals. Ultimately, the Census Bu-
reau assesses population numbers
by which districts can be redrawn
by the political party in power
(gerrymandering). The Census
Bureau has been controlled by
the Commerce Department since
its establishment, and has never
served as a political arm of any
administration. Historically, the
President of the United States has
played no role in its operations,
other than appointing the Com-
merce Secretary. In fact, nowhere
does it say that the Commerce
Secretary is even responsible for
reporting the results to the Presi-
dent; instead the Secretary is only
obligated to publish the Census
findings.
But by placing the Census
Bureau under the White House,
politicians will then control
what non-partisan government
employees have always run. In
Obama’s case, instead of the
Commerce Secretary controlling
the Census, it would be controlled
by Obama’s Chief of Staff, Rahm
Emanuel, former Chairman of the
Democratic Congressional Cam-
paign Committee (DCCC). For
a president who boasts of trying
to reach across party lines, this
seems like a blatantly partisan act.
In announcing Senator Judd
Gregg of New Hampshire as the
Commerce Secretary nominee,
as well as two other Republican
nominees to his cabinet, it seemed
that perhaps Obama really was
reaching across the political aisle
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
President Obama converses with Rahm Emmanuel, his Chief of Staff, who will have authority over the census under
the President’s plan.
and acting in a bipartisan manner.
However, after Gregg’s nomina-
tion was withdrawn, due to “irre-
solvable conflicts,” Obama faces
a major setback in building his
administration on terms that he
has previously communicated.
President Obama has established
the idea of bipartisan participa-
tion and cooperation between
parties, but it seems that until he
listens to the concerns of the Re-
publicans, his appointments and
rhetoric will not win over conser-
vatives.
For example, nominating
Senator Gregg could have been
an important milestone in the
Obama administration and could
have conveyed the idea of unity
for our country, but it is clear that
the nomination did not ensure
Opinion
Gregg’s concerns would be heard
or addressed. Senator Gregg re-
fused to support the stimulus
bill, a sign that perhaps Obama’s
Cabinet would not be as cohesive
as he had first intended. But af-
ter Obama’s intentions of mov-
ing control of the Census Bureau
surfaced, it seemed that Senator
Gregg’s appointment was just a
political move to further Obama’s
image. Even the Associated Press
reported that, “Obama also had
politics in mind when tapping
Richardson and Gregg, and nei-
ther plan worked out. Richardson
is a prominent Hispanic, an eth-
nic group increasingly important
to both parties… And Gregg, a
lifelong Republican, would have
helped Obama fulfill his prom-
ise of building a truly bipartisan
Cabinet.” But Gregg pulled out,
and frankly, I would have too.
It is unbelievable to nominate
someone of another party to the
position of Commerce Secretary,
claim bipartisanship, and then rid
him of his most important duty—
controlling the Census Bureau.
For a president who seems to
be most concerned with change,
it is extremely disconcerting to
consider the implications of this
action. What is most disturbing is
how this change will dramatically
change the way funds are appor-
tioned, as the Census numbers
determine the amount of federal
funds that go to each individual
city.
If the Census is not conduct-
ed fairly (and by means which are
strictly non-political), some cit-
ies may benefit while others suf-
fer. What kind of message does
that send? It is imperative that the
Census be conducted in a man-
ner that is accurate and efficient,
as it determines practical things
such as the number of schools
that should be built and where
they should be located. Similarly,
as was briefly mentioned earlier,
Census numbers are required for
assessing population numbers, by
which Electoral College votes are
determined and political districts
are drawn.
If this task is directed by the
White House, and let’s face it,
any administration is going to be
biased, how are we to know it will
be conducted properly and fairly?
The Observer
February 17, 2009
It’s no secret that Rahm Emanuel
played a key role in electing the
Democrats into the majority in
2006; it’s hard to imagine he
would be able to fulfill the role of
controlling the Census in a bipar-
tisan manner.
Handing over the Census to
a political operative like Eman-
uel raises a number of important
ethical questions. And to put
this change in to some perspec-
tive, consider this: if Karl Rove
and George W. Bush would have
tried to politicize the Census Bu-
reau, congressional Democrats
(and much of the media) would
have used any means necessary
in order to stop such a transfer of
power.
Larry Sabato, the director
of the Center for Politics at the
University of Virginia, recently
told Fox News, “I’ve always re-
membered what Joseph Stalin
said: ‘Those who cast the votes
decide nothing. Those who count
the votes decide everything.’ The
same principle applies to the cen-
sus.”
And I couldn’t agree more—
one party will always be in con-
trol when the Census is conduct-
ed, but the other party should at
least be given the opportunity to
observe the process to ensure its
fairness, especially because the
census is only conducted once ev-
ery ten years. In this case, howev-
er, it doesn’t seem as if Obama’s
campaign claim of transparency
will be in effect.
The Observer
February 17, 2009
So Newsweek thinks we’re Socialists
Newsweek cover inaccurately labels our nation as Socialist
By Matthew Vigliotta
The Observer
The cover of the the Febru-
ary 16th issue of Newsweek reads,
“We Are all Socialists Now.” If
that comes as a shock to you, you
are not alone.
I was not aware that we are
all socialists, but thank God we
have Newsweek to tell us. The ar-
ticle went on to say, “We remain
a center-right nation in many
ways—particularly culturally.”
When you put the two together
we have a center-right nation
composed of Socialists. I guess
nobody at Newsweek has read
Karl Marx’s Communist Mani-
festo or witnessed the USSR in
the mid 20th century, but true
socialism is a step on the path
to communism. Socialism is, of
course, left of liberal, so how can
a center-right nation be socialist?
Granted, the bailout in Sep-
tember was very disconcerting
and a step away from true capi-
Pro-Life Club Not Vocal Enough
Anti-abortion club needs to improve visibility
By Dana Flynn
The Observer
This past January, over
300,000 pro-life supporters na-
tionwide gathered in Washington
D.C. to participate in the March
for Life. The largest organized
protest in our nation, this year’s
March attracted many newcomers
who attended to voice opposition
toward the Freedom of Choice
Act, which President Obama
promised to sign. Boston Col-
lege’s Pro-Life Club sent only
26 representatives. In a school
of 9,081 full-time students, is
this number a sufficient repre-
sentation of Boston College as a
Catholic university, and therefore
a pro-life institution?
The question of student in-
volvement in pro-life affairs can
be taken in two directions: is the
Pro-Life Club of Boston College
enough of a presence on campus?
And are the pro-life students tak-
ing a sufficient stand on this issue
of life and death? The answer to
both questions is undoubtedly, no.
Two approaches can be taken
when defending life: to act in a
confrontational manner or a non-
confrontational one. Both ways
have their positives and nega-
tives; the non-confrontational
manner is one that Pro-Life
Club has taken in the past. The
club’s approach has the potential
to make a strong impact, quietly
informing the population of the
negative effects of an abortion
on a mother, or the number of
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
talism, but that does not make
us all socialists. Did Newsweek
forget that the bailout bill failed
the first time in the House? Did
Newsweek forget that thousands
of Americans called their repre-
sentatives to tell them not to vote
for it? Make no mistake: we are
not “all socialists.”
I was somewhat shocked that
many of my peers were not very
upset by the idea of socialism.
Free healthcare, universal equali-
ty, and all that socialism promises
sound appealing to them.
Then I realized that our gen-
eration was born after or during
the fall of a real socialist state in
the Soviet Union. We have for-
gotten what our parents all knew,
that socialism is inherently evil.
How could we forget this essen-
tial premise?
Well, it is quite simple. Many
of our parents have forgotten and
they now glorify socialism in the
media and on websites like the
daliykos. In reality, socialism is
children killed each year in an at-
tempt to preserve a woman’s right
to “choice” has convinced many a
wavering supporter. At the same
time, a non-confrontational ap-
proach also runs the risk of dis-
Pro-lifers protest Roe v. Wade at annual March for Life in Washington, D.C.
Opinion
evil; it compromises the individ-
ual, suppresses religion, demon-
izes hard work, and enslaves a
people.
Socialism has somewhat lost
its meaning over the years be-
cause many refer to quazi-social-
ist states like France as socialist.
However, Marx used socialism
and communism interchangeably,
and those heavily centralized
states like Sweden and France do
not fit Marx’s description.
missing the importance of the is-
sue. For one to simply hold true
to his belief, without making an
attempt to inform and persuade
others, treats the abortion debate
as if it were any other everyday
Most of the Newsweek article
is focused on the idea that we are
moving towards a European-type
economy, which is somewhat ac-
curate.
However, most European na-
tions are not socialist, but rather
they are heavily centralized.
Similarly, most Americans are
not socialist, as the cover of the
magazine suggests. Rather than
becoming socialist, we are be-
coming centralized. However, we
are not past the point of no return
and considering the lack of public
support for the recent stimulus, it
looks like Americans are starting
to turn away from those European
ideals.
So let’s look at the bailout
that moved us towards a central-
ized state: are things any better?
As far as I can see, millions of
that bailout money cannot be ac-
counted for, unemployment is ris-
ing, and the Dow Jones Industrial
Average has continued to fall.
Of course that has not fazed
disagreement over fiscal policy.
It is not. It is an issue of pre-
serving the most basic of rights-
the right to life. When speaking
with Peter Weicher, a member of
the Pro-Life Club, regarding the
15
Treasury Secretary Geithner, who
is proposing a new bailout that is
even bigger than the last. When
questioned about the stimulus and
bailout mindset, many Keynes-
ians point to the New Deal spend-
ing they claim brought us out of
the Great Depression.
They apparently failed to see
things from the point of view of
Henry Morgenthau, FDR’s Trea-
sury Secretary: “We have tried
spending money. We are spend-
ing more than we have ever spent
before and it does not work. ...
I say after eight years of this
administration we have just as
much unemployment as when we
started ... And an enormous debt
to boot!”
We can turn this economy
around without falling apart like
we did before World War II. And
if we listen to Mr. Henry Mor-
genthau, we can learn about our
mistakes from the past rather than
have our future doomed by re-
peating them.
proper approach to defending life,
he affirmed that “removing the
emotional dimension of abortion
for the sake of a debate treats the
fetus as if it were not human. If
we can talk about it like it’s not
human, abortion activists have
already won the debate.” If the
Pro-Life Club continues to ap-
proach their opposition to abor-
tion in such a diplomatic manner,
is it likely that their words will
run in and out of students’ ears
without ever really making an
impact?
A more confrontational ap-
proach, such as displaying images
of a child during all stages of preg-
nancy, certainly is more effective
in terms of treating the issue ac-
cording to its gravity. I believe
this is the approach that should be
employed by the Pro-Life Club.
Although it has many benefits, an
overly aggressive pro-life stance
does run the risk of classifying the
movement as extremist, and scar-
ing undecided individuals toward
a more moderate stance. When
approached carefully, a confron-
tational method has the power to
plant a powerful message in the
minds of bystanders, which will
later shape their attitude toward
the abortion debate. It is the
method with the most promise for
positive results regarding gaining
defenders of the sanctity of life,
and the approach least likely to
reduce the issue to a simple politi-
See ‘Prolife’
page 18

16
Boston Sex Trafficking
Must End
Students are obliged to speak out against women trafficking.
By Lisbee Mumford
For The Observer
When I see a public display
of affection (PDA), I know that I
should look away- I will almost
always see something that I don’t
want to see. Still, I usually can’t
help myself. Last week at South
Station, “what I don’t want to
see” took on a new meaning when
I saw a young woman and a late-
twenties looking man making out
on the Amtrak lines. While it was
their grandiose PDA that original-
ly caught my eye, I soon noticed
that they were not like the other
lovesick couples trying to get that
one last kiss in before they regret-
fully parted ways. As I passed,
the man grabbed the woman’s
arms and asked, “Now what are
you going to do for me?” She
answered, “Have a lot of sex.” I
glanced at her to see tears running
down her face. I realized that this
woman was likely one of many in
our city exploited in the rings of
sex-trafficking that run rampant
through the Northeast. When the
making-out resumed as I passed,
this time I couldn’t look – I was
too heartbroken and enraged to
look at the scene.
Now, granted, I do not know
all the details of this situation. I
do not know the context of these
snippets of conversation. But
what I do know is what sex-traf-
ficking looks like in the Boston
area. I do know that slavery is
still a rampant practice, not sim-
ply in different countries and cul-
Sex trafficking occurs at many transportation hubs in Boston, such as South Station.
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
tures, but also here in America, in
our cities.
There are two large catego-
ries of trafficking – sex traffick-
ing and forced labor. Though both
are rampant in the US, what we
hear most about in Boston are the
sex-trafficking rings (note: “hear
most” is directed at those will-
ing to dig deep into newspapers
and local journals). Within the
category of sex-trafficking, there
is both domestic trafficking that
exploits American women, and
international trafficking that ex-
ploits foreign-born women. When
it comes to American women, it
must be noted that the term “traf-
ficked” refers to the forced nature
of their work rather than how far
they were transported – whether
they are from across the city or
across the country, if they are
physically or psychologically
controlled and unable to leave the
sex industry willingly, they are
assigned this term. Further, any
minor that is being prostituted is
considered trafficked, as coercion
and manipulation is inferred.
The enslavement of Ameri-
can women in Boston is largely
operated through gangs. As De-
tective Kelly O’Connell said
during her keynote speech at the
Brighton Center for Peace and
Justice, “it seems that girls have
become the new drug.” While
many gangs once thrived on
money made from drug deals,
deals involving women have
been found to be much more
profitable. While a drug is simply
Opinion
passed from one hand to another,
a woman can be treated as a reus-
able commodity. By roping in just
one woman under his influence, a
pimp can make thousands of dol-
lars a week. The typical strategy
of control is for a man to find a
teenage girl who is vulnerable,
usually due to an unstable fam-
ily situation, or simple insecuri-
ties. The man will fill a protective
boyfriend or father role, earning
the girl’s trust while wearing her
down.
After a matter of weeks, as
the girl becomes emotionally and
often financially dependent on
him, he will present her with a
message along the lines of “if you
love me, then you will help us
make money.” This process is so
common that it has been assigned
the psychiatric term “seasoning.”
These young women sometimes
escape their exploitation only by
being arrested for prostitution,
though at least in Boston, police
have made it clear that they want
to assist, not prosecute prostituted
girls and women. As some agen-
cies have found that the average
age of entry into prostitution for
American girls is 11-12 years
old, it is clear that not only is our
social system failing to protect
these women from networks of
exploitation, but it is largely lack-
ing action against the pimps who
re-victimize the women and al-
low the cycle to perpetuate.
See ‘Sex Trafficking’
page 17
Campus Buildings
Need Saints
Empty Niches for Saints Abound on Campus
A vacant niche borders the front door of Devlin Hall.
By Allison Gallagher
The Observer
As a student in a Catholic
university, I would expect to walk
around campus and see symbols
that remind me that the university
is religiously affiliated. However,
while an occasional cross is vis-
ible on some academic buildings
at BC, and controversial cruci-
fixes were just installed in class-
rooms, it seems that there are
several places on campus where
reminders of our Catholic mission
as a university are conspicuously
absent. Devlin Hall, Burns Li-
brary, Bapst Library, and Gasson
Hall all exhibit prominent niches
where saints were intended to be
displayed. But these niches are
obviously empty. The buildings
are openly flouting the fact that,
although the administration that
commissioned them found saints
to be appropriate for their Jesuit
university, the current administra-
tion has not filled such spaces.
In London, England, St.
Paul’s Cathedral is also stripped
of its saint statues, with empty
niches circling the building.
However, these statues were re-
moved when Protestantism was
established as an official religion
in Britain; Catholic statues were
viewed as offensive. The empty
niches on St. Paul’s are reminis-
cent of the vacant niches on the
buildings on the BC campus. Our
school is still a Catholic universi-
ty, so where are our statues? There
are a total of 17 empty niches to-
The Observer
February 17, 2009
tal among the buildings, with the
exception of one on Burns Li-
brary, filled with a nondescript,
unrecognizable woman holding
a scroll and devoid of a defined
halo. I propose to fill these niches
with saints that reflect the univer-
sity’s core values, in accordance
with our mission as a Catholic
university.
It would be appropriate to
adorn Burns Library, which is
home to 11 vacant niches, with
statues of patron saints of learn-
ing. Lesser-known saints like St.
Anastasius XI and St. Ralph could
join St. Augustine and St. Thom-
as Aquinas, classic examples of
Catholic learning. Nine of the 11
niches flank the main door. Pass-
ing under patrons and examples
of holy learning when entering
would be ideal for a library that
showcases educational exhibits
on a Catholic campus.
For Bapst Library, the art
history library, saints associated
with art should be placed in a
niche to the side of the main door.
St. Catherine, the patron saint of
art, could flank one side of the
door, while St. Bernward, the pa-
tron saint of architects, could be
housed in the opposite niche. St.
Catherine was a Poor Clare nun,
which is an order known for its
extremely austere lifestyle, who
used to paint her spiritual visions.
Saint Bernward would honor a
building that houses architectural
See ‘Buildings’
page 18
The Observer
February 17, 2009
The Classical
Conservative IV
“A Rich Jesuit-Catholic Tradition”
By Max Bindernagel
The Observer
I made an unofficial vow to
myself when I began to write this
column early last semester not to
drift into the subject of religion.
Not being the type who likes to
go back on his word, something
very urgent came about which
changed my mind, so I unfortu-
nately need to change the direc-
tion of this column for now.
In light of recent complaints
of crucifixes and Christian art be-
ing hung in the classrooms, sev-
eral questions have been raised.
Despite overwhelming positive
support from the student body,
alums, and the world of Catholi-
cism in general, several profes-
sors find the placement of reli-
gious iconography “offensive”
and “intolerant,” to use some of
the less poignant verbiage spew-
ing from their statements. Such
claims beg the question: What
place does such art have at a
Catholic university, especially a
Jesuit-Catholic university?
In their statements, critical
professors and even some an-
guished students implied that,
because Boston College was a
Jesuit university, we are radically
different from other Catholic uni-
versities.
Prof. Amir Hoveyda of the
Chemistry department was quot-
Sex Trafficking
From page 16
The other face of Boston-ar-
ea trafficking is the foreign rings
which not only traffic women into
the country for the purpose of
sexual exploitation, but also cir-
culate women through networks
up and down the northeastern
sea-board. This models the prac-
tices most commonly ascribed to
human trafficking.
For one, debt-bondage is of-
ten used, where people are told
that they must first work off their
travel costs before they can start
earning money; added to their tab
are inflated costs of living that
pile up faster than they can be
repaid. Thus while the enslaved
people maintain the hope that
they will be making money, this
is an impossibility. They are often
kept from leaving their trafficking
situation by intimidation, lack of
legal papers, or simply because
they are in an entirely unfamiliar
culture. Women trafficked inter-
nationally into Boston are often
“There is no freedom without the Truth”
ed as saying that he believed upon
arrival here that “Boston College
was an inclusive and welcoming
Jesuit University,” a perception
which he claims was shattered by
the imposition of faith via Chris-
tian art.
People of such a mindset
are horribly mistaken about the
nature of both Catholicism and
the Jesuit order. Catholicism
has easily triumphed historically
as producing the best educators,
schools, methods of disputation,
and pedagogical tools. Some of
the most beautiful poetry, art, mu-
sic, and literature has stemmed
from the religious conviction of
Catholics yearning to express
their love for God and Church.
In the recent university effort to
put Catholic art in classrooms, the
aim was not to impose faith, but
rather to offer a warm reminder
of the rich history from which BC
comes and the values upon which
we were founded.
But what is the significance,
if any, of belonging to a Jesuit-
Catholic school? When Prof.
Hoveyda suggested that being
part of a Jesuit school was “in-
clusive and welcoming,” did he
imply that the norm for Catholic
schools was the contrary? When
St. Ignatius founded the Jesuit
order, he did so with a certain
charism in mind. Each religious
order in the Catholic Church
kept in brothels run out of houses
or apartment complexes that are
largely out of the public view.
These brothels are connected
to an extensive costal network;
often women are circulated be-
tween them so that they don’t get
too familiar with their surround-
ings.
Knowing this context, not
only was I more on the lookout
for potential trafficking situa-
tions, especially at transportation
hubs like South Station, but I was
also more brokenhearted by what
I heard, because I knew that it
was not simply a one-time trag-
edy, but part of a much larger evil
within our society.
I spent my bus ride hating
how helpless I had been when
faced with a potential trafficking
victim. But where I was unable to
directly assist this one woman, I
have the ability to add my voice
and time to the slowly rising
movement fighting human traf-
Opinion 17
expresses a certain aspect of
the faith with particular vigor.
Nonetheless, in placing a certain
value on a particular charism,
such as poverty, the Franciscans
bring a unique gift to the Church,
as do Dominicans with teaching
and Trappists with contempla-
tion. St. Ignatius envisioned an
order which paid particularly
close attention to fidelity to the
Magisterium or teaching body of
the Church. In other words, to
see a Jesuit who fails in fidelity to
the Church is equivalent to seeing
a Franciscan driving a Ferrari.
The point I am making is
that the Jesuit order is not at all in
conflict with Catholicism precise-
ly because its aim is to express a
certain aspect of Catholicism in
a particularly fruitful manner.
When transposed to the univer-
sity level, this does not involve a
Christian art in classrooms reflects St. Ignatius’ belief in
compromise of academic and in-
tellectual honesty. The university fidelity to the Church.
can remain faithful to and fos- lic school is the ideal place to ask A response like that to a student
ter appreciation for Catholicism such questions. But to assert that body that overwhelmingly sup-
without the imposition thereof or the foundation of the school itself ports the university’s decisions
the stifling of new ideas. Chris- should be stifled is ludicrous to is uncalled for and disrespectful
tian art in the classrooms can and an extreme. To quote theology at best. A student body willing to
should be seen as an appropriate professor Fr. John Paris, S.J. con- pay this much for these profes-
expression of a Catholic commit- cerning those who go as far as to sors’ services elsewhere would
ment to intellectual growth and threaten resignation over this is- be hard to find. I would rather
fidelity to the Church. sue, “This is a small problem for pay upwards of $200,000 for an
Professors are still allowed to those with small minds.” education which stays true to its
challenge and question the claims Several teachers say these principles than one which looks
of Christianity in an open, re- recent actions conflict with mak- good in the far off eyes of “world
spectful manner. In fact, a Catho- ing BC a “world class” university. class” academia.
ficking in Boston. money to support local efforts to that cheapens sexuality, and the
The student voice has al- inhibit trafficking and assist vic- guilt that lingers in our silence,
ways been a powerful tool, only tims. Though not everyone will and if we can open up discussion
bound by energy, passion, and be able to join the anti-trafficking on the matter, that in itself will
creativity. In Boston, it can be movement full-speed ahead, ev- add power to the anti-trafficking
used to launch awareness-cam- eryone has a place in this fight. movement.
paigns on campuses and within Broader awareness on this issue I must warn you though that
the city, rally politicians to sup- is necessary so that there can be once I began digging into this is-
port anti-trafficking legislation, a real social space to pursue so- sue and realized the horrors that
pressure stores to sell slave-free lutions. Just by living in this so- still are permitted to persist in our
goods, speak to personnel who ciety, we are perpetuating some world, I’ve found it impossible to
may come in contact with vic- of the forces that drive traffick- stop from doing everything pos-
tims (health care workers, police ing – consumerism and gender sible to fight the forces that cut
officers, even electricians), pres- inequality. If we simply stop and the most basic strings of human-
sure newspapers to stop publish- think about our purchasing pat- ity from 27 million people world-
ing erotic services ads, and raise terns, our complicity in a culture wide.
Subscribe to The Observer at Boston College
www. bcobserver.com
bcobserver@gmail.com
 “There is no freedom without the Truth”
The Observer The Observer “There is no freedom without the Truth”

18 Opinion February 17, 2009 February 17, 2009

Parent Sounds Off On Crucifixes
By Michael A. LaTona
For The Observer
I read with interest your
front page article of the 27 Janu-
ary 2009 issue of The Observer,
titled “BC Professors Protest
Crucifixes.” It served as a vivid
reminder of the very real cultural
war which continues to rage in
the world. Professor Amir Hov-
eyda, Chair of the Boston College
Chemistry Department ‘found
it disconcerting the faculty were
{sic} not consulted’ before the
crucifixes were hung in class-
rooms. So what?
Boston College was founded
by Jesuit Catholic priests spe-
cifically to serve and educate
the children of Irish and Italian
Catholic families whose chil-
dren had no other alternatives for
higher education. As such, it was
founded as a Catholic university.
The earliest Christians wore cru-
cifixes or crosses around their
necks to identify themselves as
followers of Jesus Christ. Many
Christians continue to do that.
Where is the shock or surprise to
anyone if a university founded as
a Catholic institution displays its
most ancient identifying symbol?
If Prof. Hoveyda is offended
by religious icons, why did he ac-
cept a position to teach at an obvi-
ously Catholic university?
In my research on Boston
College before my son accepted
BC’s offer to attend, I discovered
crucifixes, which had been con-
tinuously displayed in classrooms
Sports 19
Pro-Life Club
From page 15
Poor Ranking Prospects for BC Football
By Kaitlin McKinley off-season, and it is up to sports one for special teams.
Tennis Update
The Observer fans to decide how much weight Rivals gave only one player By Michael Vann Bulldogs took the doubles point
employer to reclaim in the future, tors.” While I have not yet been the only way the crucifixes will
replacing the crucifixes at BC in any of the affected classrooms negatively impact the level and to give these rankings. in BC’s recruiting class a four star The Observer by winning at second and third
cal disagreement. In this regard, doubles, but the Eagles fought
which were removed in the 1970s since the introduction of the cru- quality of education at BC is if Boston College finished the While there are many differ- rating, Dillon Quinn, a defensive
I do not believe that the Pro-Life The men’s basketball team back in singles. Skinner earned
would likely be a difficult chore. cifixes, I am relatively certain Prof. Hoveyda continues to dwell 2008 football season with a 9-5 ent rankings out there—ESPN, tackle out of Pawling, New York.
Club is making enough of a pres- was not the only Boston College the first point for the Eagles by
In deciding to accept BC’s offer, they did not replace the Periodic on them. overall record, going 5-3 in the Rivals, Scout, and others, there Rivals also rated him as the num-
ence on campus. While the group team that had its court stormed on blasting past Calvin Bennett. The
however, my son was pleased to Table of the Chemical Elements. As indicated above, I am a Atlantic Coast Conference. Dur- are variations between them con- ber ten defensive tackle in the
undoubtedly makes a positive ef- a fantastic Sunday for Eagles ath- Bulldogs edged back ahead after
read of University President Fr. I am also relatively certain the parent of a BC student, who grad- ing the current off-season, BC cerning where teams are placed. country. ESPN ranked quarter-
fort and does host meetings and letics. On Sunday morning it was Brendon Wong fell at six singles.
William Leahy’s efforts over the crucifixes were not accompanied uated from a Jesuit high school. has named a new head coach, For example, Clemson is ranked back Michael Marscovetra, an-
pro-life events, the vast majority the men’s tennis team mobbing Down two points to one, all
course of his tenure to reclaim by new textbooks and lesson In selecting a university, my son offensive coordinator, defensive first in the Scouts ACC rank- other recruit, as the number one
of my friends mentioned that they the court after a thrilling come- four of the other matches went
BC as a more traditional Catholic plans written by long-forgotten had a wide range of schools from coordinator, tight ends coach, ings but third for the Rivals ACC quarterback in New Jersey.
had never heard of the club or the back victory over Yale Univer- into a decisive third set. Erik
institution. alchemists of the Middle Ages. which to select. The decision and offensive line coach. For the ranking. Defensive back Jim Noel is
opportunity to attend the March sity. The Eagles 4-3 win against Kreutzer rebounded from los-
Would Prof. Hoveyda display In other words, the appearance to accept BC’s offer was based, 2009 season, the Eagles will have One thing, however, remains rated as the number three player
for Life – an indication that the Yale University was the highlight ing the first set and rolled past
the same temerity if he taught at of the crucifixes in classrooms in part, on the reports we found seventeen new players joining constant in all the rankings: Bos- in Massachusetts and as a top 50
Pro-Life Club is not being seen of a strong showing at the ECAC Connor Dawson in the final two
Yeshiva University and returned has no negative effect on the indicating Fr. Leahy has been them from their recruiting class. ton College is ranked last among defensive back nationwide. Tight
or heard. Championships. sets at third singles, but Muppidi
from a semester break to discover education which Prof. Hoveyda steadily working to make BC a Out of twelve teams in the ACC teams in every ranking. For end Mike Naples is rated as the
Few fliers are seen around The Eagles entered the lost at number two. The Eagles
the placement of a Menorah or a is charged with delivering to his more traditionally Catholic uni- ACC, ten teams signed more re- the Rivals top 100, BC is ranked forty-fourth tight end in the coun-
campus and events are not highly ECAC tournament, which took ‘hopes looked bleak when both
Star of David in his classroom? students; they are merely symbols versity. Consequently, while the cruits to their 2009 football class 70th, lower than all other eleven try. Sterlin Phifer, a running back,
publicized (unless you are on the place at Harvard University, as Nolan and Brian Locklear were
Or would he fear being labeled of in Whose name BC was found- uproar raised by Prof. Hoveyda is than Boston College. The ACC teams from the ACC. is rated as the number sixty-six
group’s listserv). For the most the tenth seed, but finished the down 4-2 and a service break in
an anti-Semite? Of course, he ed and in for Whose greater glory disconcerting to me, Fr. Leahy’s team with the fewest commit- Many polls are attributing player in the country. Andre Law-
part, events that are intended to weekend with a 2-1 record. In the each of their third sets. Nolan and
will pro- this edu- consistent walk with God is grati- ments to their 2009 class is Clem- the last place ranking to all of rence is rated as the number sev-
shock students with the horrifying opening round, the Eagles upset Locklear would both have to win
test and cation is fying. son, but they recruited such high- the Eagle’s coaching changes. enteen outside linebacker in the
realities of abortion are not hosted
claim any
“While the uproar raised to be em- All BC students are required ly ranked players that they are in Whether or not the firing of for- country and number one in Con- seventh seeded Princeton Univer- in order for the Eagles to clinch
by the Pro-Life Club, and there- sity 5-2. After winning at number the match. Both players dug deep
f a i t h ’ s by Prof. Hoveyda is dis- ployed. to take two theology courses as ESPN’s top 25 for recruitment mer head coach, Jeff Jagodzinski, necticut.
fore are not likely to make a large one doubles and falling at number and broke back each match at 4-4.
iconog- rankings. In addition to Clemson, and then the promoting of last Luke Kuechly was rated as
raphy is
concerting to me, Fr. spiteD ethe- part of their Core Curriculum.
Did the introduction of crucifixes
impact on any observer’s opinion.
four other ACC teams—the Uni- season’s defensive coordinator, the number thirty-five prospect two doubles, captain Sam Wagner Nolan finished off his opponent at
Given the magnitude of the issue, and Akash Muppidi clinched the number one singles with an ace
a n a t h - Leahy’s consistent walk a b s o l u t e come with a corresponding com- versity of Miami, Florida State Frank Spaziani, as the new head in Ohio and the number four
the Pro-Life Club should be tak- doubles point for Boston College down the middle to win his third
ema in University, North Carolina, and coach, had any real impact on the outside linebacker in Ohio. Ro-
the class-
with God is gratifying.” lack threat to
of mand that students must now take
two Catholic Doctrine courses?
ing a more visual, vocal, and pub-
Virginia Tech—also made it into recruiting class, other than the landan Finch, a running back, is with an 8-6 victory. The Eagles set in an exciting tiebreaker. After
lic approach toward informing rode the momentum from tak- Nolan’s victory the spotlight was
r o o m ; his aca- If not, what has been imposed ESPN’s top 25. low recruiting rankings, remains ranked as the number three player
students of the truths of abortion ing the doubles point into singles on Locklear who was attempt-
however, d e m i c upon the students? The appear- BC did not make ESPN’s top to be seen in the 2009 season. in Kentucky, and offensive line-
and the necessity to protect life. where they captured four of the ing to serve out his match up six
that is being disingenuous. It is integrity, Prof. Hoveyda “can ance of a symbol of the religious 25. The Eagles have the fewest BC’s recruiting class consists man Keith Bourne was rated as
On the other hand, part of the six matches. Thomas Nolan, games to five in the third set. After
not being exclusive to display re- hardly imagine a more effective faith tradition which founded and and lowest ranked players, ac- of one quarterback, one kicker, the number four prospect in state.
responsibility to uphold Boston Brian Locklear, and the Eagles’ losing his first two match points,
ligious iconography; it is a sym- way to denigrate the faculty of an operates the very university to cording to ESPN. three offensive linemen, three With many analysts regard-
College’s reputation as a pro-life two diaper dandy freshmen Alex the third time was the charm for
bol of inclusion! educational institution.” I agree which they consciously applied Rankings are not always ac- linebackers, one wide receiver, ing this as the worst recruiting ef-
institution falls into the hands of Skinner and Muppidi recorded Locklear who clinched the match
That a private, Catholic insti- with Professor Hoveyda there is and agreed to attend? They have curate, and they certainly do not one defensive lineman, one de- fort in recent years by BC, Eagles
its students. Boston College, as straight set wins. for the Eagles on his third match
tution opens its doors to everyone denigration taking place here; merely been exposed to an icon mean that a low-ranked player fensive end, two running backs, fans will have to hope that Spa-
a Catholic university, has a duty After defeating Princeton, point opportunity.
in the name of God, through Jesus however, it is by Professor Hov- of the Savior of the world. cannot outperform a higher one tight end, one defensive back, ziani and his coaching staff can
to defend the right to life from the the Eagles brought their 5-0 sea- The victories over Princeton
Christ, is the ultimate freedom eyda when he argues administra- Finally, the article closed ranked player. The information and two defensive tackles; eight work with these new players to
moment of conception. Although son record into a matchup against and Yale were not the only wins
which a private institution enjoys tors “who are either not scholars with an unattributed quote which and statistics currently available players for the Eagles defense, show that off-season rankings
the majority of students may not second seeded Columbia Univer- over Ivy League schools that the
which a public one neither does or have never in their lives been would have been amusing, if it have resulted in these rankings eight players for the offense, and aren’t always accurate.
oppose abortion, an informal sur- sity. However, the teams’ hopes of Eagles have notched on the young
not nor cannot! If his sensibilities highly respected serious schol- was not so disturbing. The Tony that most people focus on in the
vey revealed that there are far upsetting another Ivy League op- season. The Eagles bring their 6-1
are so offended by the existence ars” are not responsible for the Soprano-wannabe professor who more than 26 pro-life students on ponent were dashed as the Lions record to conference play this

from the university’s founding,
were removed at some point
in the 1970s so as not to offend
the sensibilities of non-Catholic
students and teachers. Just as in
collective bargaining between
an employer and a labor union
where a “benefit” once granted
becomes very difficult for the
Duke Upset
of a crucifix in “his” classroom, level and quality of education of said “. . . I can tell you that we campus. Why, then, were only 26
ended the Eagles undefeated run. week as they open up their ACC
perhaps Prof. Hoveyda might be BC students. First, Prof. Hov- are not going just to sit back and students willing to travel to Wash-
The loss to Columbia set season with a road trip to take on
happier at the University of Mas- eyda’s premise is faulty as the watch this” should not just sit ington in defense of their beliefs –
up the epic battle with Yale. The Virginia Tech and UVA.
sachusetts. crucifixes impact neither the level back. He should go to his nearest a trip at little to no personal cost?
Professor Hoveyda claims nor the quality of education; and house of worship and pray for the Considering the ever-in-
from back
“in any respectable university, it second, he immediately launches wisdom to reconsider what is in creasing importance of standing
is the faculty who are responsible into the weakest form of argu-
for the level and the quality of the ment: personal attack on admin-
his heart and then take the appro-
priate corrective action.
up for one’s beliefs, and the need
to the take a strong stand against
super fans in gold shirts, jumping
up and down.
The first shot of the second
coach Skinner said, “This is a
big stage. He showed the type of
player he is. I’m not sure I’d cer-
Krzyzewski said.
Going in to Sunday’s game,
BC had a 13-0 record when they
Frisbee
education of our students; this istrators when he claims they are May God continue to bless abortion, the March for Life from back
does not pertain to administra- unworthy scholars. Ironically, you and the BC community. half was a 3-pointer by Rice tainly take some of those shots, scored 80 or more points; on Sun- tice times during the winter are usually consist of college gradu-
should have had far more Boston
College attendees – especially about 15 seconds into the half. but you’ve just got to let him.” day, they won 80-74 to improve less than ideal. The average time ates who just cannot seem to get
considering the threat FOCA pos- With that shot, Rice became the The Eagles shot 58.8 percent that record to 14-0. allotted is 10:30 p.m. until 12:30 enough of this exciting sport.

Campus Buildings es against the pro-life cause.

From page 16
reference books and databases.
The two saints would greatly
improve Bapst’s blatantly empty
doorframe.
For buildings with no singu-
lar use, more university-specific
saints would be appropriate. Gas-
son Hall, for example, also has
two empty niches bordering the
doorway. Perhaps statues of some
the Jesuits whose ideals inspired
the university’s founding would
be relevant here. Boston College
already has a statue of St. Ignatius
of Loyola on campus, but his con-
temporaries Blessed Peter Faber
and St. Francis Xavier, co-found-
er of the Society of Jesus, would
be perfect. It is not unreasonable
for a university that is home to
one of the largest communities of
Jesuits in the world to put statues
of Jesuits on their buildings.
“It is not unreasonable for a uni-
versity that is home to one of
the largest communities of Jesu-
its in the world to put statues of
Jesuits on their buildings.”
Devlin Hall, home to our ad-
missions center, should showcase
the ideals of Boston College for
prospective students and their
parents. As a university, our de-
sire for service is extraordinarily
strong. Boston College students
seem to be especially concerned
with social justice, as evidenced
in the numerous service immer-
sion trips undertaken by Boston
College students each academic
year. Therefore, displaying stat-
ues of saints who pay tribute to
this particular aspect of our stu-
dent body would be appropriate.
Saints like Mother Seton, found-
ress of the Sisters of Charity of
St. Joseph, and St. Francis, who
devoted his life to outcasts, would
be fitting. When prospective stu-
dents come to tour the campus,
they could be made aware of Bos-
ton College’s apparent devotion
to social justice, and conscious
of the tradition of social Catholic
justice that BC is influenced by.
BC should undertake filling
the niches immediately. What is
holding the administration back
from making our Catholic uni-
versity look like a true Catholic
university?
Boston College often teaches
its students they must use their
education to make a difference
in the world, to stand up for their
beliefs.
Beginning with orienta-
tion, incoming freshman are en-
couraged to “go set the world
aflame,” in the words of St. Ig-
natius of Loyola. Shouldn’t this
Jesuit principle apply to the de-
fense of the most basic of rights?
Shouldn’t those pro-life students
on campus be able to find an out-
let for their beliefs in the form of
a vocal Pro-Life Club?
Considering that the debate
over abortion is one of the most
pressing moral issues faced by
our nation today, shouldn’t there
be more than 26 students out of
9,081 at the annual March for
Life?
seventh player in Boston College
history to reach the 2,000-point
milestone.
The last Boston College play-
er to reach 2,000 points in their
career was Jared Dudley, who
now plays for the Phoenix Suns
in the NBA. Dudley, former BC
player and 2006-07 ACC player
of the year, was sitting courtside
across from Duke’s bench during
Sunday’s game.
After Jackson’s two-point
jumper gave the Eagles a 76-74
lead with 50 seconds remaining in
the game, Rice grabbed a key de-
fensive rebound when Henderson
missed a 3-point attempt. Rice
then made two free throws on a
foul by Singler, giving the Eagles
a 78-74 lead with just 23 seconds
left to play.
Referring to Rice and some
of his key plays from the game,
from the field, making 70.6 per-
cent of their free throws, and 44.4
percent of their 3-pointers.
The Blue Devils only shot
42.6 percent from the field and
18.8 percent from behind the arc,
but made 81.3 percent of their
free throws. Each team had 19
fouls.
Despite the Eagles turning
the ball over 19 times, and Duke
stealing the ball four times, BC
shot over 60 percent from the
field in the second half and made
four of their eight 3-pointers in
the second half.
“We’re not playing very well
on the defensive end of the court.
In the last two ballgames, teams
have shot 60 percent against us
and scored 101 and 80 points -
and this is from a team that has
been playing for the whole year
really well defensively,” coach
Prior to Sunday’s game,
BC had lost two of its last three
games. The Eagles had lost two
ACC games to Clemson and
Wake Forest.
Coming in to Sunday’s game,
Duke had also lost two of its last
three games. The Blue Devils had
lost two ACC games to Clemson
and North Carolina.
Next up, the Eagles will play
at University of Miami on Satur-
day the 21st and against Florida
State at home on Tuesday the
24th, both of which are ACC
games.
Up next for the Blue Devils
is Madison Square Garden where
they will play St. John’s in a non-
conference match-up on Thurs-
day the 19th. After that, they’ll
play Wake Forest at home in an
ACC game on the 22nd. Wake
Forest is currently ranked #7.
a.m. various nights a week. In
these instances, sacrifices must
be made. Fortunately, the teams
have become close, and practices
are more than just hard work;
they are quality time spent with
good friends.
During the weekend of Feb-
ruary 5th, members from both
teams traveled to Las Vegas and
participated in the largest college
ultimate tournament in the coun-
try. Although the weather was de-
spondent, the team still had a suc-
cessful weekend out West. Most
of the top teams in the country
attended, and it was tough com-
petition.
The weekend before the col-
lege tournament occurred, Cul-
timate (a newly formed group
that sponsors these tournaments)
held one just for club teams from
around the country. These teams
The underground world of
Frisbee is an intense environment
consisting of college club teams
from around the country, but it
does not stop there. Many college
players choose to pursue ultimate
at the club level and compete na-
tionally during the club season in
the summer.
Boston club teams are con-
sistently ranked in the top ten
national teams. With one of the
most competitive sections in the
country, success does not come
easily. Both teams from Boston
College practice extremely hard
and work every spring to make it
past the sectional tournament to
the regional event. Other schools,
such as Boston University, Har-
vard, Tufts, MIT, Northeastern,
Bentley, and Brandeis are all
strong competition in these tour-
naments.
The Observer “There is no freedom without the Truth”
February 17, 2009 Sports 20

Bob Ryan Speaks on BC Sports

Bob Ryan sits down with The Observer to discuss BC sports in the first of a two-part series with the Globe columnist.

By Michael Reer has a little of that in him.

The Observer
Reer: Is the BC men’s basketball team
going to be playing in the NCAA Tourna-
ment this March?
Mr. Ryan: I was looking at it again to-
day and I was looking at where they’re sit-
ting. There are four locks in the ACC. We
all know that. Even Clemson can’t screw it
up this year. BC sits at the top of the next
year…21 wins and I can’t see how they’re
not it. The Harvard game just drives you
out of your mind.
Reer: Well, that team gets hot and then
gets cold.
Mr. Ryan: I know. The Harvard game
is why they’re not a lock. If they win four
more games they’re in. I think they’ll be
in and let me tell you what: That’s a great
achievement this year. When the season
started I didn’t think they had a chance to
get in. I’ll be very happy to see them in the
tournament.
I did hit the nail right on this team,
though. The very first game I saw them
play (against Iowa), I came back and
said,“Here’s the deal: They have compo-
nents. There are some nights that they’re
all going to come together and accidentally
play well and beat a great team.” Of course
that happened on January 4th (against
North Carolina) but then on January 7th
the same group of guys come home and
lose to Harvard…The x-factor on this team
is definitely Reggie Jackson. I compare
him to Ryan Sidney. When Sidney came
into the game it was like someone threw an
electric switch on the entire thing. Reggie
Reer: What about Tyrese Rice, though?
Is he going to be playing in the NBA?
Mr. Ryan: He has a chance. It’s going
to be hard, but I think we’re going to find
out a lot in the post-season because I’m not
sure ultimately how quick he is. He looks
quicker than he is. He can create space…I
would say it’s about 40-60. I certainly hope
he makes it.
Reer: What about next year without
Rice? Do they regress a little bit?
Mr. Ryan: That’s asking a lot. They
have won games where Rice was not a big
factor this year, but that’s asking a lot. Par-
is is okay but I don’t know that he’s going
to fill Rice’s shoes. They’re going to need
some recruiting because you know with Al
it’s always a little worrisome about what
they’re going to get. People should know
not to write BC off, though. That’s the en-
tire story of the Al Skinner era. He does put
teams together somehow someway.
Reer: Speaking of recruiting, today is
signing day for football and BC just turned
in one of the most disappointing classes in
Division I.
Mr. Ryan: I’m a big, profound recruit- Globe Sports columnist Bob Ryan.
ing day skeptic. I’m not into recruiting day.
That’s what they say? Fine. In three years the other night, my first one of the year. ing the first two periods and then turned it
at least fifty percent of the people we will When I was at BC, my first year we went off because I didn’t see the team having a
be talking about will have not been dis- to the national championship so it was hard miracle finish in them. From the start of
cussed at all today. I mean, when has Notre not to get interested. I’m not a big, big the season BU and Northeastern have been
Dame not had a top recruiting class? Not hockey guy but I follow it. Jerry [York] better. I’m not greedy, though. Jerry’s got-
in the past fifty years! It’s just something was at school when I was there so I’m a ten the job done twice and I’ve been to at
where people want direct knowledge right big fan. My wife follows it closer than I do. least five Frozen Fours or so. I know for a
away but I’m just not interested. Reer: We were out in the first round of fact that at least twice I went from the Fi-
Reer: Do you ever follow BC hockey? the Beanpot. A little disappointing… nal Four to the Frozen Four. No one else in
Mr. Ryan: Yeah, I just went to a game Mr. Ryan: Yeah, clearly. I was watch- America did that I can promise you.

BC upsets #5 Duke Spoonheads and Flix

Spring Season Begins
The BC men’s basketball team beat #5 Duke 80-74 basic Frisbee throws, the flick.
By Lara Barger
By Kaitlin McKinley son scored 20 points and had four game in a row. Prior to Sunday’s The Observer “Only one or two of us knew how
The Observer rebounds for the Blue Devils. game, they had lost to #7 Wake to play Frisbee before we came
When the final buzzer sound- Forest and #11 Clemson. The casual toss of the Fris- to BC, but as a team, we learned
With nearly 50 seconds re-
ed, BC students rushed the court At one point, Duke had a bee may be fun to some people, from each other and gained good
maining in the game, Reggie
from both ends to celebrate the 13-point lead, but the Eagles but to members of the men and friends, as well,” exclaims Mal-
Jackson made a two-point jump-
win. The Eagles had lost the last went on an 8-0 run to cut Duke’s women’s club ultimate Frisbee lory Heitzenrater CSOM ’10. The
er to break the final tie and gave
eight games they played against lead to five and end the first half team, this is not just an apa- lone senior captain, Jackie Ouel-
Boston College the lead. The
the Blue Devils, and were 1-9 32-37. thetic fling of a piece of plastic. let A&S ’09, has been with the
Eagles went on to score the next
all-time. The last time they beat “You can’t mess around. If This 175-gram disc is a way of team the longest and was one of
four points for an 80-74 victory
Duke was nearly 24 years ago on you have a team down you have life. Many colleges across the the original members to revital-
over #5 Duke on Sunday.
March 17, 1985. to step on their throats. That’s country, including Boston Col- ize the women’s team after a brief
Tyrese Rice led the Eagles
“We always felt that we had been a problem with us this year - lege, offer students the chance lapse without a team. After three
(19-8, 7-4 Atlantic Coast Confer-
the talent. It’s getting them to un- we haven’t approached leads like to participate in a club ultimate years rebuilding the team, they
ence) with 21 points including a
derstand what it takes,” Boston that, so we need to change that,” team. Men’s and women’s ulti- are finally back on top and com-
key three pointer that gave Bos-
College coach Al Skinner said. Gerald Henderson said referring mate frisbee are two of the lowest peting in multiple tournaments in
ton College the lead about half-
Sunday’s victory was BC’s to Duke blowing their 13-point funded club teams at Boston Col- both the fall and spring seasons.
way through the second half. It
second win over a highly ranked lead. lege. Although the team receives Before they can attend tour-
was BC’s first lead since their
team this season. The first was BC made eight three point- nominal funding from the univer- naments, both teams practice at
first possession of the game.
their 85-78 win over then-num- ers and had two dunks, which sity and does much fundraising least three times a week at the
“They’re good and they
ber one North Carolina in Chapel energized the crowd of 8,606 to make more money, fun is not St. John’s Seminary fields during
have one of the best players in
Hill on January 4th. It was North people in Conte Forum. There absent. The Men’s Spoonheads the fall and spring. If you ever
the country,” Duke coach Mike
Carolina’s first loss. were a few Duke jerseys scat- and Women’s Flix have grown see someone running with disc
Krzyzewski said, referring to
Trapani, who sat out last sea- tered throughout the arena, but close and become good friends. and cleats in hand, that’s where
Rice.
son after transferring from Ver- their cheering was silenced by The name Spoonheads was con- they’re headed. During the cold
Joe Trapani contributed to
mont, said, “I would say in a per- chants of “Let’s go Eagles.” The ceived in the 1970s by free-spirit- winter months, the teams prac-
the Eagles win with 20 points and
fect world we’re beating Duke student sections behind the bas- ed alumni who used to wear their tice in the annually constructed
seven rebounds. Jackson finished
and Carolina in my first year in kets consisted almost entirely of hair in ponytails, and from behind “bubble” placed over Alumni
with 15 points and five rebounds.
the league.” they looked similar to spoon- Stadium. Unfortunately, the prac-
Kyle Singler led Duke (20-
The Eagles played a nation- See ‘Upset’ heads. The women’s team, the
5, 7-4 ACC) with 25 points and
ally ranked team for their third page 19 Flix, is a variation of one of the See ‘Frisbee’
eight rebounds. Gerald Hender- page 19