May 5, 2014 Dr. Ramana Madupalli Nathan Klein, Adam Skau, Ryan McClure, Brooke Harlan, Jordyn Finke
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In response to an interest in the perception of online education, we have conducted a thorough study to gain insight into the issue. The deliverables from our study will be turned over to SIUE administrators so that they can better refine the online education programs at the university. Through the use of initial exploratory interviews, we developed research objectives to guide our analysis. The research objectives included: determine the importance of the social aspects (making friends, forming study groups, etc.) in choosing online education, determine how to make online education practical for hands on/auditory learners, find out how to motivate students to actually participate and engage in online classes, identify what level classes students prefer to take online or in (general/core classes), and identify what other key related concerns are for taking online classes.
Using the research objectives, we established survey questions that were administered to a pool of respondents. Our sampling frame consisted of people over the age of 18, and within 50 miles who have taken or are thinking about taking an online class. Our sample size included 354 respondents that were predominantly students (59.9%), but also included parents (18.9%) and employers (21.2%). The feedback from respondents led us to several important findings and recommendations regarding online education. Several of the most important findings and recommendations are highlighted below. We stressed the importance of social aspects being integrated into online education since 100% (212/212) of students disagreed that online education provides a better college experience and 100% (75/75) of employers agreed that interaction with other students was important. Furthermore, online education courses should primarily be offered for general education classes since 100% (212/212) of students agreed that online classes are better for general education courses. In order to cater to auditory and visual learners, online courses should offer a variety of media (video tutorials, virtual lectures, diagrams) to help explain difficult material clearly. Finally, administrators should choose teachers for online courses carefully since 56.13% (119/212) of students agreed that the quality of online professors was worse than traditional classes.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Executive Summary 2
Introduction 4
Marketing Management Issues and Research Objectives Management Issues 5 Problem Definitions 5 Research Objectives 5, 6 Hypotheses 6, 7
Methodology Exploratory Research 7 Descriptive Research 7 Population of Interest 8 Sample Frame 8 Sample Size 8 Sampling Plan and Data Collection 8 Questionnaire 8, 9
Demographics 9
Research Objectives, Analysis, Findings, Hypotheses and Results 9-15
Recommendations 15, 16
Regression 16
Conclusion 16
References 17
INTRODUCTION
The purpose of this project was to seek and to understand the complexities of online education. The deliverables were turned over to SIUE administrators so that they can refine the online education programs at the university.
With so many advances in technology, online education will likely grow whether the population wants it to or not. Different people learn through different teaching methods such as face-to-face, online, or case studies. In addition, there is more to online education that simply liking it or not. If the quality of education online varies from that of the classroom, people could be deterred from using online education as a learning style. There is also a stigma surrounding online education that it is not as rigorous as an in class degree. If a potential employer does not think online education has value, then that may result in frustration in the workforce for people with an online education degree. All of these aspects are important to understand and consider before moving forward with online education.
Online education is increasing in popularity because students are more constrained with their daily schedules. Instead of finding time during their day to have face-to-face lectures, online courses allow them to do their work on their own schedules. In a study done in 2013 by the Sloan Consortium, Over 6.7 million students were taking at least one online course in the 2011 term, an increase of 570,000 students over the previous term. Furthermore, working parents now have the chance to earn an excellent education inside the home without taking time away from their families or work schedules.
In addition to more convenient schedules, online education is becoming popular because better technology is emerging. Students have a wide variety of technology tools at their disposal, which allows them to video chat with a professor, or watch recorded lectures (Trends). Textbooks are also becoming digital, which allows students to access texts and learning materials online through a variety of mobile devices.
MARKETING MANAGEMENT ISSUES AND RESEARCH OBJECTIVES
Management Issues: SIUE needs to investigate the intricacies of online education and student perceptions before making online classes widely available.
Problem Definition: Determine student perceptions and experiences with online education.
Research Objectives: 1. Determine the importance of the social aspects (making friends, forming study groups, etc.) in choosing online education. The objective will identify how important the social aspects in a traditional classroom setting are to students. Interviews revealed that some respondents value traditional classroom social aspects enough to choose an in class option over an online class option. One respondent mentioned I like in class options because it allows me to make friends, form study groups, and have a sense of camaraderie with other students in the classroom. (Aguayo) 2. How to make online education practical for hands on/auditory learners. Interviews showed that online education is the most practical for students who are self-learners. Most of the respondents indicated that they are more visual and auditory learners, and learn best in the classroom having the professor explain the material directly. To make online education more appealing to students who are visual and auditory learners, the professor must make the course more interactive for all types of learning styles. Professors can do this by making the material being discussed more relevant, letting the student explore the material being discussed and report back their findings in an online discussion board, and having the student pull content from the information provided to show they understand the material. (How to Create Interactive E- Learning) 3. How to motivate students to actually participate and engage in online classes. Interviews revealed that students are generally elated when the professor informs the class that the upcoming test will be online. This means the test can be supplemented with any resource material the student can their hands on. The motivation for students to take the test is obvious: there is a direct link from online performance to the grade earned, but what about being attentive during online lectures? Just like in a normal classroom setting, students should be encouraged to physically be present and ask questions. Some methods to incorporate active listening and participation with an online class can include mandatory student comments throughout the online session, or a short summary of what was learned at the end on class. In addition to the student motivation, the professor on the other end must be capable of receiving and replying to student responses. Lack of acknowledgment by the professor could lead to lower student activity.
4. Identify what level classes students prefer to take online or in class. (General Education/core classes). The objective will determine if students prefer to take their general education classes or core (major) classes online. Interviews revealed that students think core classes are harder than general education classes. The classification of difficult vs. easy influenced some interviewees in their choice between which classes to take online and which to take in person. Interviews showed that students would be more willing to take their easier classes (general education) online than their harder (core/major related) classes. Interviews also revealed that students are apprehensive about taking their core classes online because these classes are critical to their degree. One interviewee mentioned I take my general education classes online because ultimately I do not think they matter as much as my core classes. My degree in business is not based on my knowledge of U.S. History, or Biology. Its based on economics, accounting, management, etc. That is why I am more prone to take general education classes online. (Geiger) 5. Identify what other key related concerns are for taking online classes. The objective will determine other issues that respondents mentioned with online education. Online courses favor highly motivated students, therefore less motivated students tend to fall even further behind when enrolled in an online course. One respondent said I would not take an online course simply because Im not a motivated person. (Waldrop) Interviewees also mentioned that there are many distractions outside a classroom that would disrupt the learning process. Things like television, cell phones, and laptops have limited use for in class options, but have no restrictions in online classes. The unrestricted use of these devices can create distractions for online students. Another key issue mentioned by respondents was time management. Respondents mentioned that in class options allowed them to practice better time management. Online classes do not have a professor keeping students up to date, so some students tend to fall behind. A final key issue mentioned by respondents was instant feedback/keeping in contact with professors. Online classes force students to rely on email from professors or discussion forums to get answers. When e-mail is the only medium to contact instructors, it can create frustration because e- mail takes longer to receive and may not provide as clear of an answer as a face- to-face conversation.
Hypotheses: Based on interviews with respondents, the following hypotheses have been developed: 1. Students will take online classes more frequently for general education classes rather than core (major) classes. 2. Students and female respondents will disfavor online classes because of the lack of social aspects. 3. Auditory/hands on learners will be less likely to take an online class than a self-learner. 4. Students who take online classes are more likely to be frustrated by the lower quality of professors. 5. Male and female students will disagree that online education promotes class participation and interaction
METHODOLOGY
Our research design was a combination of exploratory and descriptive research. The initial interviews consisted of reaching out to those within our sample frame and asking open-ended questions. We used a non-probability convenience sampling process for the initial interview. This process aided in understanding the underlying issues that exist within the world of online education.
After the answers from these interviews were collected, we used them to develop five research objectives. Based upon these objectives, we then created a formal survey (descriptive research) to further investigate the issue.
In order to find respondents for the initial exploratory interview, we used simple random sampling. Respondents that were willing to donate their time and give their informed consent answered our interview questions.
Exploratory Research Our initial interview process demonstrated the use of exploratory research. Exploratory research is an unstructured, relatively informal, and the most basic type of research. It was predominately used for identifying what the underlying issues are from the point of view of the interested population. Exploratory research was used in the interview process to gain a better understanding of the problem, and establish research objectives. The interview process consisted of each group member asking three people over the age of 18 general questions about online classes. The respondents answers provided in the interviews were used to develop research objectives.
Descriptive Research Descriptive research is structured and designed to gain additional, more in-depth information. Using the information gathered from the exploratory research, we developed research objectives. The research objectives led to the development of survey questions that gave a better understanding of students perception of online education.
We used a cross-sectional research design during our descriptive research study. This implies that all participants will be surveyed only once instead of multiple occasions over time. Each survey was exactly the same and they were self-administered.
Population of Interest The population of interest was anyone over the age of 18 who is able to take an online class.
Sampling Frame The sample frame consisted of people over the age of 18, and within 50 miles who had taken or are thinking about taking an online class.
Sample Size The sample size for our population was 354 people who are over 18 years old, within 50 miles, and had taken or were thinking about taking an online class.
Sampling Plan and Data Collection We used probability and non-probability methods to distribute our surveys and collect data. Probability methods included simple random sampling, while non-probability methods included quota, convenience, and referral sampling. Our team picked people at random from our sample frame and asked them to take part in our survey, which incorporated simple random sampling. Quota sampling was used because respondents had to be at least 18 years old and considered taking an online class, or taken an online class before. We used convenience sampling because it was an easy and effective method to distribute surveys. Convenience sampling was utilized by asking potential respondents near us to take part in the survey. In addition to convenience sampling, referral sampling also allowed us to get a large amount of respondents. Asking respondents to get their friends to take the survey qualified as referral sampling.
Questionnaire We used the information gathered from exploratory interviews to develop these survey questions. The survey questions provided us with data that we analyzed and subsequently made recommendations from.
1. I like going to class because____ a. My teacher is present to help b. My friends are in class c. It helps me stay focused 2. Are you a parent? a. Yes/No b. If yes then how likely would you be to take an online class? i. 1- not likely, 5-very likely 3. Do you work 40 or more hours a week? a. Yes/No b. If yes how much does this play into your decision to take an online vs. in person class? i. Not at all ii. Very much iii. Some what 4. Would you be more likely to take an online class for _____ a. A general education class b. A core (major related) class c. Neither 5. Which best describes your learning style? a. Visual b. Hands on c. Self-learner d. Auditory 6. How important are the social aspects (making friends, forming study groups, etc.) in your choice of online vs. in person classes? a. 1-not important, 5-very important 7. Have you taken an online class before? a. Yes/No
DEMOGRAPHICS
Our investigation into the world of online education focused chiefly on those who identified as students (59.9%). The remaining sample was composed of parents (18.9%) and employers (21.2%) The average age was 34.6 years with a standard deviation of 15.4 (range of 20 to 66). The ratio of women to men was 52:48. The sample size was 354 participants.
Research Objective One: Determine the importance of social aspects in online education
Analysis: Correlation, Cross tabs, and Chi-Square analysis
Results: Finding 1: Using correlation, we determined that there is a positive relationship (.001) between the variables age and interaction with other students is important, but that the relationship is extremely weak (.176). Using more analysis tools, we found that 100% (224/224) of young people (35 years old or younger) agreed that interaction with other students is important. Additionally, 71.54% (93/130) of older respondents (over 35 years old) agreed that interaction with other students was important.
Finding 2: Using cross tabs and the chi square test, we determined that 100% (184/184) of females thought that interaction with other students was neither important nor unimportant. In addition, 100% (170/170) of males agreed that interaction with other students was important.
Finding 3: By using cross tabs and the chi square test, we found that 100% (212/212) of students agreed that interaction with other students was important. Furthermore, 100% (75/75) of employers agreed that interaction with other students was important.
Finding 4: In using correlation analysis, we determined that the variables age and online education provides a better college experience are moderately (.78) related. There is a positive direction to the relationship; meaning that as age increases respondents will increasingly believe that online education provides a better college experience.
Finding 5: Cross tabs and the chi square test analysis revealed that 44.02% (81/184) of females disagreed that online education provides a better college experience. Furthermore, 32.94% (56/170) of males disagreed that online education provides a better college experience.
Finding 6: Using cross tabs and the chi square test, we determined that 100% (212/212) of students disagreed that online education provides a better college experience. In addition, 100% (75/75) employers neither disagreed nor agreed that online education provides a better college experience.
Hypothesis and Results: Our hypothesis for this research objective was that students and female respondents would disfavor online classes because of the lack of social aspects. Our results in finding 2 found that 100% of males (170/170) are, in fact, more concerned about social aspects than females. In addition, finding 3 found that all students (100%) did in fact believe that interaction with other students was important.
Research Objective Two: How to make online education practical for hands on/auditory learners.
Analysis: Exploratory research designs, secondary research, and correlation and cross tabulation methods.
Results: Finding 1: Using exploratory research, we preformed 15 different interviews and found that most respondents preferred to take classes face to face with a professor rather than online. These respondents gave a few insights on how they would like an online class to become more practical for their learning style. Respondent 1 said, I am more of a visual learner and would prefer to sit in a classroom but I would take an online class if there were online video tutorials showing exactly how to perform each step. This type of lecture would cater to my learning style. Respondent 2 said, As a nursing student, I have practicals that require me to have hands on experience in the classroom. Therefore, for me to take an online course, I would need a hybrid course where lectures are videos put online and labs were in the classroom.
Finding 2: After conducting secondary research, we found that professors can provide diagrams and sketches, videos, and tutorials on difficult material in online classes to help students who are more visual and hands on learners understand material. (Felder, Soloman)
Finding 3: Using correlation, we found that the variables age and online courses are better for methodology courses are not related (.24).
Finding 4: Using the cross tabs and chi square test, 72.28% (133/184) of females disagreed that online courses are better for methodology courses. Also, 47.06% of males disagreed that online courses are better for methodology courses.
Finding 5: Using the cross tabs and chi square test, 100% (212/212) of students disagree that online courses are better for methodology courses.
Hypothesis and Results: Our hypothesis for this objective was that auditory and hands on learners will be less likely to take an online class than a self-learner. Our analysis proved the hypothesis true. The results in finding three found that there was not a relationship between age and taking a methodology course online. In addition, the results from finding five found that 100% (212/212) of students, both male and female, disagreed that online courses are better for methodology courses.
Research Objective 3: How to motivate students to participate and engage in online classes.
Analysis: Correlation, cross tabulations, and chi-square
Results: Finding 1: Using correlation, we determined that there is a relationship (.000) between the variables age and online course effectiveness in class participation. This is a moderate (.61) positive correlation. This would indicate that was age increases, respondents will increasingly believe that online courses are effective in class participation.
Finding 2: Using cross tabs and the chi square test, we discovered that 22.35% (38/170) of males and 52.17% (96/184) of females disagreed that online courses were effective in class participation.
Finding 3: Cross tabs and chi square tests revealed that 88.68% (188/212) of students disagreed that online classes are effective in class participation.
Finding 4: Using correlation, we found that there is a weak negative relationship (-.23) between the variables age and online education reduces the interaction ability of students. This would indicate that as age increases, respondents will decreasingly believe that online education reduces the interaction ability of students.
Finding 5: Using cross tabs and chi square testing, we determined that 57.07% (105/184) females agreed and 35.88% (61/170) of male respondents agreed that online education reduces the interaction ability of students.
Finding 6: Using cross tabs and chi square testing, we found that 84.91% (180/212) of students and 76.12% (51/67) of parents agreed that online education reduces the interaction ability of students.
Hypothesis: Our hypothesis for this objective was that both male and female students will disagree that online education promotes class participation and interaction. Our finding established that this hypothesis is somewhat false. Only 22.25% of males and 52.17% of females disagreed that online classes were effective in class participation, meaning that 77.75% of males and 47.83% of females agree that online courses are effective in class participation. 88.68% of students, however, did indicate that online classes are not effective in class participation.
Research Objective Four: Identify what level classes (core, general education) students prefer to take online or in-class
Analysis: Correlation, cross tabs, and the chi square testing.
Results: Finding 1: Using Correlation, we found that there is a weak (.491) relationship between the variables age and online courses are better for elective courses. The direction of the correlation was positive, which means that as age increases respondents will increasingly believe that online courses are better for elective courses.
Finding 2: Using Cross Tabs and Chi Square, we found that 47.16% (71/170) of males agree that online education is better for elective classes. Furthermore, 77.72% (143/184) of females disagreed that online education is better for elective classes.
Finding 3: Using Cross Tabs and Chi Square test, we discovered that 90.09% (191/212) of students disagreed that online education is better for elective classes. In addition, 57.33% (43/75) of employers agreed that online education is better for elective classes.
Finding 4: Using Correlation, we found that there is a positive and moderate relationship (.61) between the variables age and online education is better for core classes. This means that as age increases, the belief that online education is better for core classes should also increase.
Finding 5: Using Cross Tabs and Chi Square test, 72.35% (123/170) of males and 74.46% (137/184) of females disagree that online course are better for core course.
Finding 6: Using Cross Tabs and Chi Square Test, we found that 92.45% (196/212) of students disagree that online courses are better for core classes. Additionally, 57.33% (43/75) of employers agreed that online courses were better for core classes.
Finding 7: Using Correlation, for the variables age and general education classes, we determined that there was no presence and therefore no relationship (.828) between the two variables.
Finding 8: Using Cross Tabs and Chi Square test, we found 72.35% (123/170) of males disagreed that online courses are better for general education. Furthermore, 74.46% (137/184) of females disagreed that online classes are better for general education.
Finding 9: Using Cross Tabs and Chi Square test, we found that 100% (212/212) of students agree that online courses are better for general education classes.
Hypothesis and Results: Our hypothesis for the research objective was that students will take online classes more frequently in general education classes than core (major) classes. From our findings, we discovered that this hypothesis is true. 100% (212/212) of students agree that online courses are better for general education classes.
Research objective 5: Identify what other key related concerns are for taking online classes.
Analysis: Correlation, cross tabs, and chi-square.
Results: Finding 1: Using correlation, we identified a positive, but very weak relationship (.38) between age and the quality of professors teaching online classes is better than traditional teachers. Using more analysis tools, we found that 53.13% (119/224) of young respondents (35 years or younger) disagreed that professors quality of online classes is better than traditional teachers.
Finding 2: Using Cross tabs and Chi square testing, we identified that 58.70% (83/184) of females disagreed that online professors quality is better than traditional teachers while 37.06% (63/170) of males agreed that online professors quality is better than traditional teachers quality.
Finding 3: Using cross tabs and chi square tests, we discovered that 56.13% (119/212) of students disagreed that the professors quality of online classes is better than traditional teachers. However, 67.16% (45/67) of parents agreed that the quality of online classes is superior.
Finding 4: Using correlation, we identified a positive, weak relationship (.46) between the variables age and professors are better involved in online classes rather than traditional classes. This indicates that as age increases, the respondents belief that professors are better involved in online classes would also increase.
Finding 5: Using cross tabs and chi square, we established that 51.63% (95/184) of females disagreed that professors are better involved in online classes rather than traditional classes, whereas 18.24% (31/170) of males agreed.
Finding 6: Through cross tabs and chi square, we found that 32.08% (68/212) of students disagreed that professors are better involved in online education classes, whereas 67.16% (45/76) of parents agreed.
Findings 7: Using correlation, we identified a negative, very weak (-.29) relationship between the variables age and online classes being perceived as easy relative to traditional classes. Using more analysis tools, we found that 80.36% (180/224) of young respondents (35 years or younger) agreed that relative to traditional classes, online classes are easy.
Finding 8: Using cross tabs and chi-square, we discovered that 40.59% (69/170) of males and 57.07% (105/184) of females agreed that online classes are easier relative to traditional classes.
Finding 9: Through cross tabs and chi square testing, we found that 84.91% (180/212) of students agree that online classes are easier compared to traditional classes.
Findings 10: Using correlation, we identified a negative, very weak relationship (-.23) between the variables age and online classes providing a better balance of life relative to traditional classes. Using more analysis tools, we found that 80.36% (180/224) of young respondents (35 years or younger) agreed that relative to traditional classes, online classes provide better balance of life.
Finding 11: Using cross tabs and chi square testing 35.88% (61/170) of males and 57.07% (105/184) of females agree that online classes provide a better balance of life.
Finding 12: Using cross tabs and chi square we found that 84.91% (180/212) of students agreed that online classes provide a better balance of life relative to traditional classes.
Hypothesis and Results: Our hypothesis for the research objective was that students who take online classes are more likely to be frustrated by the lower quality of professors. From our findings, we discovered that this hypothesis is true. 56.13% (119/212) of students said that the quality of professors in online classes is much worse than traditional classes and 32.08% (68/212) stated that online professors are less involved than traditional professors.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
Our recommendation for research objective one is that given that 100% (224/224) of young people (35 years or younger) agreed or agreed that interaction with other students was important, we recommend that online courses offer some sort of social interaction to meet young peoples social need. Furthermore, social aspects should be made available in online courses because 100% (75/75) of employers agreed that interaction with other students was important to them. Social aspects should also be made available in online classes because 100% (212/212) of students disagreed that online education provides for a better college experience.
Based on the results of our findings for research objective two, our first recommendation is to improve online courses for the more auditory and hands on learner by including online video tutorials, virtual lectures, diagrams and charts to better explain difficult material. Also, given that 100% (212/212) of students disagreed that online courses re better for methodology courses, we recommend providing online education for non-methodology courses if possible.
From our results in research objective three, we recommend that administrators find a way to engage students to participate in their online classes. Although only 22.25% of males and 52.17% of females disagreed that online courses were effective in class participation, 88.68% (188/212) of students disagreed that online classes are effective in class participation. Since students are the group that will predominantly take part in any online education programs offered, we recommend catering to their needs first and foremost.
We found that 92.45% (196/212) of students disagree that online courses are better for core classes, therefore our recommendation for research objective four is online classes should not be offered for core classes. Also, we would recommend that since 57.33% (43/75) of employers agreed that online education is better for elective classes that offering elective classes online would benefit that student. Finally, since 100% (212/212) of students agreed that online courses are better for general education classes, online general education classes should predominantly be offered.
Lastly, for research objective five we recommend that professors become more involved in their online classes and establish a system to respond to students questions promptly. The lack of instant feedback from professors could have prompted 56.13% (119/212) of students to state that the quality of professors in online classes is much worse than traditional classes. We would also suggest that professors be more involved in their lesson plans to make the online classes more demanding so students will take the classes more seriously. 84.91% (180/212) of students agreed that online classes are easier; a main factor could be the lack of care by the professor.
OTHER FINDINGS: Regression
Our regression analysis involved the variables how old are you and I would take online classes again. How old are you was our independent variable while I would take online classes again acted as our dependent variable. Based on our regression output, the r-squared value was .027 or 2.7%. This would indicate that the variable I would take online classes again explains 2.7% of the variation in the variable how old are you. Our analysis also concluded that how old are you explains a statistically significant amount of variation in I am satisfied with online classes based on the .000 sigma.
CONCLUSION
With all of our efforts, a great step has been taken to help better understand the perceptions and reality surrounding online education. Through cross tabs, chi square testing, correlation, and regression analysis of answers from our 354 respondents, we have identified many valuable findings and have subsequently provided recommendations based on the findings.
Several important of the most important findings and recommendations are as follows. Student respondents have made it quite clear that they value social aspects in their college experiences (100% disagreed that online education provides a better college experience), therefore social aspects should be integrated into online education. Student respondents also overwhelmingly agreed (100%) that online education classes are better for general education courses versus core courses, so online classes should predominantly be offered for general education courses. Because many people have different learning styles, online education should use a variety of media including video tutorials, virtual lectures, and diagrams to explain information in a way that different learning styles will understand. Finally, only capable and experienced teachers should be chosen to teach online education courses since 56.16% of students agreed that the quality of teachers in online courses was worse than traditional classes.
As mentioned in our introduction, technology is always expanding and thus online education will also become increasingly utilized throughout universities around the country. The analysis and recommendations provided in this study will give SIUE administrators accurate information to help tailor online classes to the needs of its student body. We believe that SIUE will be able to provide a more pleasant and comprehensive online education program at the university by using the findings and recommendations provided.
References
Aguayo, Gabriel. Personal Interview. 31 March 2014.
"Changing Course: Ten Years of Tracking Online Education in the United States | The Sloan Consortium." The Sloan Consortium. The Sloan Consortium, 2013. Web. 30 Mar. 2014.
Felder, Richard, and Barbara Soloman. "Learning Styles and Strategies." Learning Styles and Strategies. North Carolina State University, n.d. Web. 29 Apr. 2014. <www4.ncsu.edu/unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/ILSdir/styles.htm>
"How to Create Interactive E-Learning - The Rapid ELearning Blog." The Rapid ELearning Blog RSS. N.p., 1 May 2012. Web. 07 Apr. 2014. <http://www.articulate.com/rapid- elearning/how-to-create-interactive-e-learning/>.
"Trends in Online Education: From the 90s to Now." Online Learning Mag RSS. N.p., n.d. Web. 30 Mar. 2014.
Waldrop, Nathan. Personal Interview. 31 March 2014