Received 21 June 2002; received in revised form 9 April 2003; accepted 18 September 2003
Abstract
Clay materials play a key role in determining the retention capacity of a soil, and are widely used in waste treatments. One of
the most commonly used is palygorskite. The aim of this research is to determine the chemical species formed by copper when
retained in a clay material, mainly consisting of palygorskite, and find the minimized energy reached by the species adsorbed by
palygorskite. The clay material was put in contact with a copper(II) chloride solution, and after reaching the thermodynamic
equilibrium, the dry residue was analysed by using XRD, X-ray fluorescence (XRF), and extended-X-ray absorption fine-
structure (EXAFS) spectroscopy. Formation of copper hydroxychloride (atacamite, CuCl2.3Cu(OH)2) was studied. Computa-
tional studies, carried out with 890 atoms, showed the formation of an amorphous copper hydroxychloride. However, it seems
probable that the whole precipitate would be firstly amorphous, later becoming crystalline (Ostwald’s rule) in accordance with
XRD and EXAFS data.
D 2003 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Copper; Sorption; Heterogeneous nucleation palygorskite; XRD; EXAFS; Molecular modeling
0169-1317/$ - see front matter D 2003 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.clay.2003.09.002
CLAY-00886; No of Pages 8
ARTICLE IN PRESS
2 R.A. Alvarez-Puebla et al. / Applied Clay Science xx (2004) xxx–xxx
the surface (X-ray fluorescence); as well as the coor- characterized to determine: (i) chemical composition
dination number and distances around the photoad- by atomic absorption spectrophotometry (AAS) after
sorbing atom (extended-X-ray absorption fine-stru- alkaline fusion a 1273 K; (ii) mineralogical composi-
cture, EXAFS). tion (Rigaku D/max B X-ray diffractometer); (iii)
A detailed treatment on EXAFS can be found in cationic exchange capacity (López Ritas and López
the work of Koningsberger and Prins (1988). Many Melida, 1990); (iv) porous texture by N2 (77 K) and
researchers have often applied this technique to study CO2 (273 K) adsorption and mercury porosimetry
the retention and distribution of cations in different (Echeverrı́a et al., 1999); (v) surface topography and
materials. O’Day et al. (1994) identified complexes of microanalysis by scanning electronic microscopy
cobalt strongly bound to kaolinite. Reich et al. (1998) (JEOL JSM 6400 mod. 6210) equipped with an
studied the sorption of uranium(VI) onto silica gel and EDAX system (Link Analytical Pentaler Oxford,
ferrihydrite, Korshin et al. (1998) studied the most EXL-10). Selected physical and chemical character-
stable structures formed during the sorption of copper istics of the clay material are listed in Table 1.
on humic acid. Zhang et al. (2001) studied the The adsorption experiments were performed at 10
adsorption process of barium on montmorillonite. copper initial concentrations in the range 0– 31.5 mM,
Another approach is to apply computational techni- in aqueous solution, and temperature 298.0 F 0.2 K.
ques to perform theoretical studies at nanochemical For each isotherm point, 0.5000 F 0.0003 g of the
level (Schulten and Leinweber, 2000). Molecular me- palygorskitic material were placed in 50 ml polyeth-
chanics (MM) is based on Newtonian mechanics and ylene centrifuge tubes, the corresponding volume of a
has the advantage of being able to work with very large 2000 mg l 1 CuCl2 stock solution (Merck, Darm-
systems and gives the equilibrium geometry with stadt, Germany) to obtain the desired total concentra-
reasonable precision (Kubicki and Apitz, 1999). Mole- tion of Cu and distilled water was added to get a final
cular dynamic (MD) simulations introduce time and volume of 12.5 ml. The equilibrium pH was measured
temperature into the calculations, which allow the sys- after 24 h. Suspensions were centrifuged at 9000 g
tem to sample configurations that energy minimization for 5 min. Sub-samples of the supernatants were
calculations might not be able to sample due to poten- directly injected into a Malvern Zetasizer 3000 instru-
tial energy barriers (Gunstered and Berendsen, 1990). ment (Malvern Instruments, Malvern, UK); the ap-
The aim of this research was to determine the plied voltage was 100 V through 5-cm quartz cell.
chemical species formed by copper when retained by
a clay material mainly constituted by palygorskite, and Table 1
to find the most stable energy reached by the species Selected physical and chemical characteristics of the clay material
adsorbed by palygorskite. The clay material was put in Chemical composition (%) SiO2 57.1
contact with a copper solution, and after the thermo- Al2O3 18.3
Fe2O3 5.8
dynamic equilibrium was reached, the suspension was MgO 5.5
centrifuged. The dry residue was analysed by XRD to K2O 1.0
reveal the presence of new chemical species, by X-ray CaO 0.5
fluorescence (XRF) spectroscopy to check out the hete- Na2O 0.5
rogeneous distribution of the metal on the surface and, TiO2 0.1
H2O 9.9
by EXAFS to corroborate the chemical species formed Total 98.7
by the Cu. Finally, the sorption and precipitation Mineralogical composition (%) Palygorskite 51
processes were simulated using energy minimization Illite 22
and molecular dynamics computational techniques. Quartz 18
Smectite 5
Kaolinite 3
Calcite <1
2. Experimental CEC (meq kg 1 ) 361
BET surface areaa (BET) (m2 g 1
) 122
The selected material, extracted from the Perdi- pH 8.0
a
guera hill (Segovia, Spain) palygorskitic deposit, was Obtained from N2 adsorption at 77 K.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
R.A. Alvarez-Puebla et al. / Applied Clay Science xx (2004) xxx–xxx 3
Supernatant not used for electrophoretic measurement ionisation chamber and a solid-state detector, respec-
was vacuum filtered (Millipore, 0.45 Am) and copper tively. Specifications about the measurement geome-
concentrations in supernatants were analysed by AAS, try can be found in the work of Tohji et al. (1983). The
Perkin-Elmer mod. 2100 (Perkin-Elmer, Überlingen, spectra were collected between 8900 and 9500 eV in
Germany). The amount of Cu retained was obtained steps of 1 eV and a counting rate of 20 s step 1. Three
from the difference between the initial and equilibri- scans were measured and added for each sample. The
um concentrations. measurements were performed in transmission mode
To make sure the formation of a new phase that in pellets composed by 60 – 100 mg of the metal –clay
could be detected by EXAFS and XRD, 10.0-g system and the appropriate amount of boric acid
samples of clay were suspended in 250 ml of 31.5 ( f 100 mg) in order to achieve an accurate thickness
mM copper chloride solution. Suspensions were and a good noise/signal ratio.
placed in a thermostated water bath, Grant Mod. The experimental EXAFS signal was extracted
SS40-2 at 3 Hz during 24 h, sufficient time to reach from the raw spectra following standard methods
the thermodynamic equilibrium. The amount of Cu (Koningsberger and Prins, 1988). Background remov-
retained was 365 mmol kg 1. The residue was dried al was performed and the atomic absorption coefficient
at 378 K to perform the rest of the research. was determined by a low order polynomial fit of the
The samples were air-dried at 333 K before carry- spectra. The EXAFS spectra were analysed by using
ing out the X-ray powder diffraction by orientated the EXCURV package program from SERC Dares-
aggregated method. The patterns were collected using bury laboratory (Binsted et al., 1991). The Fourier
a Rigaku D/max-B instrument with a copper rotating transform of Cu K-edge, k3c(k), spectra was calculated
anode and a graphite monochromator to select the Cu using a Gaussian window in the range from 3 to 11
Ka wavelength. The device was working at 40 kV and Å 1. The structural parameters for the first and second
100 mA. The measurements were carried out in step- coordination shells were obtained by least square
scanned mode from 2j V 2h V 60 j in steps of 0.031 fitting of the Fourier filtered EXAFS signal between
with a counting rate of 1 s step 1. The phase 1.2 and 3.3 Å to the EXAFS formula (Sánchez-Sierra
identification was performed by matching the exper- et al., 1995). In order to test backscattering amplitudes
imental powders with the powder diffraction files of and phase shifts for Cu – O and Cu – Cl contributions
the International Centre for Diffraction Data (Joint provided by the EXCURV program, CuO and CuCl2
Committee on Powder Diffraction Standards, 1986), crystals were also measured and analysed under the
and the data given by Brindley and Brown (1984), and same conditions. The agreement between experimental
Wells (1984). and theoretical spectra was satisfactory in both cases.
The micrographs of the clay and clay – copper Computational calculations were carried out by
system were obtained by SEM, in the experimental using HyperChem 7 (HyperChem 7, 2002) in a Tosh-
conditions described by Humphries (1992). We used a iba Pentium III computer. To simplify the problem,
JEOL JSM 6400 mod. 6210 microscope, equipped twelve palygorskite cells (2 2 3) were fixed and
with an EDAX system (EXL-10) from Link Analyt- put into contact with 4Cu2Cl(OH)3 formulas as adsor-
ical Pentaler (Oxford, United Kingdom). The Cu K- tive. The crystalline structure of palygorskite was
edge XAFS measurements were carried out at the constructed according to Chisholm (1992), and the
EXAFS National Service (Zaragoza, Spain). The charges were placed by using the SE methods
source was a rotating anode X-ray generator (Rigaku PM3(tm) (Gale, 1997). Two experiments were
RU-300, 18 kW). A bent crystal of Ge (220) was used designed: four Cu2Cl(OH)3 formulas were placed over
as monochromator. The anode, the bent crystal and the (001) surface (system I), and over the (100) surface
the receiving slit were held on a Rowland circle with (system II). In both cases, MM simulations were
R = 320 mm. The device was working at 25 kV and carried out with MM+ force field (Hypercube, 1994).
120 mA using a gold anode. A divergence slit of 11 Energy minimizations were performed on initial struc-
and a receiving slit of 0.1 mm were used. The energy tures, then MD simulations were performed at 300 K
resolution was around 3 eV at the Cu K-edge. Incident for 30 ps with fs time steps. Energy minimizations
and transmitted beams were detected by using an were performed on final structures of MD simulations.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
4 R.A. Alvarez-Puebla et al. / Applied Clay Science xx (2004) xxx–xxx
Table 2
X-ray fluorescence microanalysis from several spots on the clay –
copper system (expressed as atomic percentage) Fig. 4. Radial structure functions from EXAFS analysis: (a) Fourier
transforms of the measured spectra corresponding to the Cu
Element Spot 1 (%) Spot 2 (%) Spot 3 (%) Spot 4 (%)
adsorbed at the palygorskitic material; (b) filtered EXAFS and
Si 18.5 1.3 10.1 45.9 theoretical simulation for the first and second coordination shell;
a a
Al 6.1 29.3 and (c) Fourier transforms of filtered spectrum and theoretical
a a a
Mg 3.4 simulation of the first and second shell of the retained Cu.
a a
K 1.1 19.1
a
Fe 2.8 1.3 3.1
a
Cu 46.8 67.2 57.7
Cl 21.6 31.0 25.7 a
The radial distribution shows a main peak around 1.55
Total 96.9 99.5 98.2 97.4 Å (without energy shift correction) corresponding to
a
Non detected. the first coordination shell. The peak at lower distances
ARTICLE IN PRESS
6 R.A. Alvarez-Puebla et al. / Applied Clay Science xx (2004) xxx–xxx
Table 4
1
Components of the total energy (kJ mol ) for systems I and II
System I System II
Initial Final Initial Final
a
EB 16,684.83 0.02 16,684.92 0.04
EAb 2658.13 0.04 2658.10 0.05
EDc 50.82 19.23 49.83 24.08
EVWd 1024.83 347.27 1063.59 478.58
ETe 20,418.61 327.98 20,456.43 454.41
a
Bond energy. Fig. 5. Twelve palygorskitc unit cells facing four Cu2Cl(OH)3
b
Angle energy. formulas after molecular dynamics and geometry optimization: (a)
c
Dihedral energy. system I, over plane (001) and (b) system II, over plane (100).
d
van der Waals energy. (Atom colours: copper blue, chlorine cyan, magnesium green,
e
Total energy. silicon black, oxygen red and hydrogen white).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
R.A. Alvarez-Puebla et al. / Applied Clay Science xx (2004) xxx–xxx 7
20418.61 kJ mol 1 with a converging gradient of copper – clay system reflected the apparition of new
1279.04 kJ nm 1 mol 1. Geometrical optimization signals characteristic of atacamite. Quantitative micro-
resulted in the structure showed in Fig. 5a, with analysis by X-ray fluorescence at several spots select-
energy of 327.98 kJ mol 1 and a converging ed for their different electronic densities revealed the
gradient of 0.18 kJ nm 1 mol 1. The 4Cu2Cl(OH)3 heterogeneous distribution of Cu on the clay surfaces.
distributed on the external surface of palygorskite, When Cu and Cl were detected, they appeared in a Cu/
fixing close to siloxanic cavities. System II that Cl ratio of 2.2:1. EXAFS analysis supported the
included 4Cu2Cl(OH)3 over (100) plane evolved presence of atacamite. Finally, molecular modeling
from 20,456.43 kJ mol 1 for the initial state to with 890 atoms lead to the formation of an amorphous
454.41 kJ mol 1 for the final state, with converg- copper hydroxychloride instead of an ordered structure
ing gradients of 5617.49 and 0.20 kJ nm 1 mol 1, of atacamite. However, it seems likely that the whole
respectively. Even though none of the systems could precipitate would eventually become crystalline (Ost-
be considered as a crystalline structure (Fig. 5), it wald’s rule), as XRD and EXAFS data would suggest.
seems probable that the whole precipitate would be
amorphous first, later becoming crystalline (Ost-
wald’s rule) in accordance with XRD and EXAFS References
data.
The stability of system II is larger than that of Binsted, N., Gurman, S.J., Campbell, J.W., Stephenson, P., 1991.
system I, 454.4 and 328.0 kJ mol 1, respective- EXCURV Program. SERC Daresbury Laboratory, UK.
ly. As shown in Table 4, the increment in this stability Bradley, W.F., 1940. The structural scheme of attapulgite. Am.
Mineral. 25, 405 – 410.
is due to a decrease in the van der Waals energetic Brindley, G.W., Brown, G., 1984. Crystal Structures of Clay
term. This fact can be read as an increase in the Minerals and their X-ray Identification. Mineralogical Society,
stability due to the penetration of some adsorbate London.
atoms inside the channels, since this phenomenon Chisholm, J.E., 1992. Powder-diffraction patterns and structural
only occurs in system II. However, the Cu2Cl(OH)3 models for palygorskite. Can. Mineral. 30, 61 – 73.
Echeverrı́a, J.C., Morera, M.T., Mazkiarán, C., Garrido, J.J., 1998.
has such a high affinity for penetrating the channels Competitive sorption of heavy metals by soils. Isotherms and
that block them (Fig. 5b), also the high adsorbate – fractional factorial experiments. Environ. Pollut. 101, 275 – 284.
adsorbate and adsorbent – adsorbate interaction limits Echeverrı́a, J.C., Morera, M.T., Mazkiarán, C., Garrido, J.J., 1999.
the diffusion of ions across the surface to more stable Characterization of the porous structure of soils. Adsorption of
nitrogen (77 K) and carbon dioxide (273 K), and mercury po-
sites (i.e. channels).
rosimetry. Eur. J. Soil Sci. 50, 497 – 503.
To summarize, the molecular modeling in the two Gale, J.D., 1997. Semi-empirical methods as a tool in solid state
experiments confirms a preferential adsorption in the chemistry. Faraday Discuss. 106, 219 – 232.
channels (Table 4, Fig. 5b), in agreement with Giles, C.H., McEwan, T.H., Nakhawa, S.N., Smith, D., 1960. Stu-
Janeba et al. (1998). When channels are occupied dies in adsorption: Part XI. A system of classification of solution
or the molecule size is too large and too stable to adsorption isotherms and its use in diagnosis of adsorption
mechanisms and in measurement of specific surface areas of
break up, sorption takes place on the external surface solids. J. Chem. Soc., 3973 – 3993.
(Fig. 5a) (Pruissen et al., 2000). It was also found Gunstered, W.F., Berendsen, H.J.C., 1990. Computer simulation of
that affinity to the retention in the edges was higher molecular dynamics—methodology, applications and perspec-
(Fig. 5a), in line with findings by Zhang and Bailey tives in Chemistry. Angew. Chem. 29, 992 – 1023.
(1998). Humphries, D.W., 1992. The Preparation of Thin Sections of
Rocks, Minerals and Ceramics. Oxford Univ. Press. Royal Mi-
croscopical Society, Oxford.
HyperChem. vol. 7 Hypercube, Gainsville, FL.
4. Conclusions Hypercube, 1994. Hyperchem Computational Chemistry Hyper-
cube, Waterloo, ON, Canada.
The X-ray diffractogram of the clay material sus- Janeba, J., Capkova, P., Schenk, H., 1998. Molecular simulations of
Zn-montmorillonite. Clay Miner. 33, 187 – 204.
pended in water showed that palygorskite was the Joint Committee on Powder Diffraction Standards, 1986. Powder
main component, with appreciable amounts of illite Diffraction File Sets 1 – 36. International Centre for Diffraction
and quartz. The diffractogram corresponding to the Data, Swarthmore, PA.
ARTICLE IN PRESS
8 R.A. Alvarez-Puebla et al. / Applied Clay Science xx (2004) xxx–xxx
Koningsberger, D.C., Prins, R., 1988. X-ray absorption: principles, N.M., Shuh, D.K., 1998. An EXAFS study of uranium(VI) sorp-
applications, techniques of EXAFS, SEXAFS, and XANES. tion onto silica gel and ferrihydrite. J. Electron Spectrosc. Relat.
Chem. Anal. (NY). vol. 92. Wiley, New York, pp. 211 – 253. Phenom. 96, 237 – 243.
Korshin, G.V., Frenkel, A.I., Stern, E.A., 1998. EXAFS Study of Sánchez-Sierra, M.C., Garcı́a-Ruiz, J., Proietti, M.G., Blasco, J.,
the inner shell structure in copper(II) complexes with humic 1995. Structural characterization of monometallic and bimetallic
substances. Environ. Sci. Technol. 32, 2699 – 2705. Ruthenium based catalysts. J. Mol. Catal. 96, 65 – 75.
Kubicki, J.D., Apitz, S.E., 1999. Models of natural organic matter Schulten, H.R., Leinweber, P., 2000. New insights into organic-
and interactions with organic contaminants. Org. Geochem. 30, mineral particles: composition, properties, and models of mo-
911 – 927. lecular structure. Biol. Fertil. Soils 30, 399 – 432.
López Ritas, J., López Melida, J., 1990. El Diagnóstico de Suelos Stumm, W., 1992. Chemistry of the Solid – Water Interface. Wiley,
y Plantas. Métodos de Campo y Laboratorio. Mundi Prensa, New York, pp. 229 – 232.
Madrid. Tohji, K., Udagawa, Y., Kawasaki, T., Masuda, K., 1983. Labora-
O’Day, P.A., Parks, G.A., Brown Jr., G.E., 1994. Molecular struc- tory EXAFS spectrometer with a bent crystal, a solid-state
ture and binding sites of cobalt (II) surface complexes on kao- detector and a fast detection system. Rev. Sci. Instrum. 54,
linite from X-ray absorption spectroscopy. Clays Clay Miner. 1482 – 1487.
42, 337 – 355. Wells, A.F., 1984. Structural Inorganic Chemistry, 5th ed. Claren-
Parise, J.B., Hyde, B.G., 1986. The structure of atacamite and its don Press, Oxford.
relationship to spinel. Acta Crystallogr., C Cryst. Struct. Com- Zhang, Z.Z., Bailey, G.W., 1998. Reactivity of basal surface, steps
mun. 42, 1277 – 1280. and edges of muscovite: an AFM study. Clays Clay Miner. 46,
Pruissen, D.J., Capkova, P., Driessen, R.A.J., Schenk, H., 2000. 290 – 300.
Structure analysis of intercaled smectites using molecular sim- Zhang, P.C., Brady, P.V., Arthur, S.E., Zhou, W.Q., Sawyer, D.,
ulations. Appl. Catal., A Gen. 193, 103 – 112. Hesterberg, D.A., 2001. Adsorption of barium(II) on montmor-
Reich, T., Moll, H., Arnold, T., Denecke, M.A., Hennig, C., Geipel, illonite: an EXAFS study. Colloids Surf., A Physicochem. Eng.
G., Bernhard, G., Nitsche, H., Allen, P.G., Bucher, J.J., Edelstein, Asp. 190, 239 – 249.