Financing for
A look at Global Migration the
Problems
urban poor
U N I T E D N A T I O N S H U M A N S E T T L E M E N T S P R O G R A M M E
Habitat Debate March 2007
Contents
ISSN 1020-3613
Opinions expressed in signed articles are those of the authors and do not necessarily
reflect the official views and policies of the United Nations Human Settlements
Programme (UN‑HABITAT). All material in this publication may be freely quoted or
reprinted, provided the authors and Habitat Debate are credited.
OVERVIEW Habitat Debate March 2007
America would suggest that governments velopment assistance will never finance the
no longer have a significant role to play massive housing and service deficit in cit-
in financing human settlements devel- ies in Africa, Asia and Latin America, nor
opment. On the contrary, the role of the should it.
State has never been more pertinent. Only The accumulated savings and purchasing
government policy, public investment and power of urban poor and the capital housed
municipal planning can ensure financial in pension funds and among private inves-
sector reforms that translate into private tors as well as dedicated public investment
investment in affordable housing and ba- constitute sources of finance that make offi-
sic services. cial development aid pale by comparison.
Government legislation on pension The future of development cooperation
funds, for example, can create a source of is to channel funds in ways that accelerate
long-term capital and trigger institutional the actions of local actors to harness these
investment in debt instruments to finance sources of finance. This includes a combi-
municipal infrastructure and/or mort- nation of targeted technical assistance and
gage facilities. Targeted public investment credit enhancements, equity investments,
is also crucial. It is estimated that 30 per- and bridging finance that preferably can
cent of the cost of home construction is build local capacity and leverage multiple
made up of expenditure in water and san- sources of finance.
itation. By dedicating public expenditure It also involves creative partnerships be-
to infrastructure, the State can spur mas- tween multilateral and bilateral develop-
sive private investment in housing—a vol- ment agencies and international finance
ume of shelter hundreds of times greater institutions geared toward fast-tracking in-
than could be constructed by government vestment for infrastructure.
funds. Municipal planning is a pre-requi- More fundamentally, development co-
site for mainstreaming private investment, operation will require coming to terms
particularly approaches to planning that with the social and economic consequenc-
build upon, rather than exclude the dyna- es of rapid urbanization and addressing ur-
mism of the slum economy and the inte- ban poverty by drawing on the potential of
gral role it plays in urban development. innovations in financing.
The change in the way affordable hous-
ing and urban infrastructure is financed at
country level has significant implications
for development cooperation. Official de-
Newly completed houses, self-build housing project Jinja, Uganda 2005. Photo: © Suzi Mutter
FORUM Habitat Debate March 2007
Home-financing in Africa
One of Africa’s biggest challenges is home delivery. But except for South Africa, Ghana and a handful of
East African countries, Cas Coovadia, Managing Director of the Banking Association of South Africa,
says the home-financing sector in the rest of Africa remains in its infancy. In an article first published in
The Banker, he highlights the good examples set by those countries leading the way.
Enhanced fiscal capacity of local governments is the capacity to do development work at a large scale. It is essential that
cities are made to work for all citizens –equitably and efficiently. There are several actions important in the immediate
phase that include:
of the cities in the developing countries dustry – although efforts are being made decades. Yet, aid flows to countries ac-
leading to very high commuting costs. to develop systems that provide finan- count for small proportion of their GDP.
In Asia, according to UN-HABITAT’s cial services for the poor. And, the State The Asia 2015 Conference strongly sup-
State of the World’s Cities 2006—7 re- remains the main provider of shelter fi- ported the increasing development as-
port, 73 per cent, of urban dwellers live nance in several Asian countries, such as sistance flows. The conference also
in non-permanent housing. Over half The Philippines and Bangladesh. recognised the need for strong technical
of the world’s inadequate housing units For the last 30 years, and thanks in no assistance in deepening development in
are located in Asia-Pacific – at roughly small measure to Muhammad Yunus, the Asia. Future aid is likely to flow to lowest
500 million units. The housing sector is Bangladeshi banker and Nobel laureate, income countries in the region.
also severely constrained by lack of ade- Bangladesh leads the way in creating fi-
quate and appropriate housing finance nancial products for the poor. The pen- Recommendations
systems. In fact, an Asian Development etration of microfinance into the shelter There is a tremendous scope for cross-
Bank study says Asia’s mortgage sector is finance sector is significant in many of learning across the countries of the
the least developed in the world. In Asia, the developing countries of the region. region. However, many developing coun-
many countries’ mortgage financing per Significant efforts are underway to in- tries in the region are also extremely im-
year is less than 2 per cent of GDP com- tegrate the informal (including microfi- poverished. Unless and until structural
pared to 88 per cent in the UK. nance) markets with formal ones in many and fundamental changes in financing are
Despite this gloomy picture, the re- of the countries in the region. initiated and sustained, the Millennium
gion also has excellent innovations in Innovations in capital markets – both Development Goals will remain a dream
terms of shelter finance practices includ- formal and informal – present tremen- in many of these countries. It is not just
ing through shelter microfinance and dous opportunities for introducing fi- a question of initiating few measures, but
community funds. nancial instruments for sustainable also a matter of implementing decisions
urbanization. and sustaining them over a long period
Other Financial Services of time.
The financial sector in the region is Urban development History has demonstrated that
comparatively well developed and in- Very few countries (with the exception the success of slum upgrading initia-
tegrated intra-region wise and globally. of developed and emerging economies in tives is greatest when community-driv-
Many countries have liberalized the fi- the region) have housing and urban sec- en. Community movements are gaining
nancial markets. The financial sector in tor policies for adequate, affordable shel- ground in the Asia-Pacific region. The en-
countries such as China, South Korea, ter, including related infrastructure. Land ergy of the communities needs to be har-
Malaysia, Singapore, India and Indonesia ownership and titling is complex and ex- nessed to undertake slum upgrading and
are thriving. The stock markets in many pensive. There are limited subsidies avail- slum prevention. It is also necessary to
of the countries are large and well devel- able for housing and infrastructure. The promote business solutions that provide
oped. The region is also experiencing sig- urban sector does not feature highly in services to households at the bottom of
nificant growth of the Islamic banking many of the national programmes and the pyramid.
system. strategies. There is need for a better fo- Given the innovations and improved
On the downside, many countries in cus on housing and urban development economic growth in the region, there is
the region have nascent and weak finan- in several countries of the region. significant scope for deepening of the
cial markets. The participation of finan- housing finance markets and financial
cial markets in financing housing and Donor support services industry, especially for low-to-
urban infrastructure has been limited In general, bi-lateral donors (from middle income households in many of
in many of the developing countries of within and outside the region) and multi- the developing countries of the region.
the region. Similarly, the majority of the lateral banks have supported urban devel-
low-income households are also exclud- opment in many developing countries of
ed from the formal financial services in- the region substantially during last three
Key innovations:
n Promoting affordable housing through provision of service delivery, competitive market development, private sec-
tor involvement and cost reduction measures;
n Improved land use planning as well as provision of affordable and adequate public transport systems;
n Introduction of smart subsidies for the needy;
n Establishment of special purpose vehicles for intermediating market based housing finance and for improving the
management of housing stock;
n Introduction of credit bureaus, foreclosure laws, etc;
n Establishment of mortgage insurance, credit guarantee facilities and securitisation mechanisms;
n Facilitating long term funds for housing and infrastructure;
n Deepening of life and non-life insurance products; and
n Promoting universal access to comprehensive financial services.
Source: UN-HABITAT
14 Habitat Debate March 2007
OPINION
The Community Led-Infrastructure Facility (CLIFF) Municipal Development Fund, Tamil Nadu, India
The Community-led Infrastructure Financing Facility The Tamil Nadu Urban Development Fund (TNUDF) was
(CLIFF) is an urban poor fund designed to act as a catalyst in launched in 1988 financed entirely by the public sector to re-
slum upgrading through providing strategic support for com- duce the massive backlog of infrastructure investment and im-
munity-initiated housing and infrastructure projects that have prove the delivery of basic urban services. However, it evolved
the potential for scaling up. The overall goal is to reduce urban from a municipal trust fund to one established and managed
poverty by increasing the access of poor urban communities to by the public and private sectors. In 1996, with the aim of
commercial and public-sector finance for medium- to large-scale achieving managerial efficiency and attracting private capi-
infrastructure and housing initiatives. The facility is funded by tal for urban infrastructure, it was converted into an autono-
Department for International Development (DfID) of the United mous financial intermediary. Established as a trust fund with
Kingdom, Swedish International Development Aid (SIDA), and private equity participation, it was the first public–private part-
Homeless International and co-ordinated internationally by the nership in India that provided long-term municipal financing
latter. CLIFF offers a number of financial products including: for infrastructure without guarantees. Instead of merely chan-
nelling public funds, its purpose is to attract financing from
n Technical Assistance Grants - to cover costs such as profes- the private sector. It also manages a separate grant fund owned
sionals’ fees that are required to support communities in by the state government to finance poverty alleviation projects.
implementing projects. The is making an important contribution to capital investment
n Capital grants - to enable projects to begin and continue at needs for large, lumpy and non-revenue generating projects.
a pace unhindered by the timings of project cost recoveries. For many small local governments that are unable to access the
As projects are completed loans are repaid and the capital is markets directly, the fund provides a pooling mechanism and
recycled at the local level as loan finance to other projects. indirect access to the market, together with enhanced credit.
n Knowledge Grants - to allow the learning from projects to The fund is quite creative, launching new financial products
be shared with as many people as possible to help achieve to tap the capital market for special purposes, such as the wa-
change beyond the project. ter and sanitation
n Management Grants - to cover the related management costs
of the organisations implementing CLIFF. Government Financed Homeownership in Singapore
One of the most far-reaching systems of state intervention
The first initiative is in India with the Society for the in housing provision through direct construction is the case of
Promotion of Area Resource Centres (SPARC), the National Singapore where 96 per cent of the households are living in
Slum Dwellers Federation (NSDF) and Mahila Milan. In 2006, homeownership apartments. Following the transition to self
thirteen projects in India and five projects in Kenya were recipi- governance in 1959, the new government was committed to
ents of CLIFF loan finance. improving housing, and it began during the early 1960s on a
These projects are expected to result in over 5,000 new safe relatively small scale by providing basic rental units for the poor
and secure homes and mean that an additional 1 million peo- who were living in congested urban shop houses and as squat-
ple will have access to decent sanitation. Five banks are now ters. The flats, built by the Housing and Development Board,
involved in providing £4.4 million in finance and municipal were let out at monthly rentals of between US$20–$40 and
guarantees for CLIFF supported projects and over 130,000 were within the paying ability of 75 per cent of the working
square metres of land have been allocated to the urban poor population. In 1964, homeownership was introduced and flats
from private and public sources. Government subsidies and were sold on 99-year leases. Once the state allowed would-be
contracts worth nearly £5 million have also been mobilised so homeowners to use their savings in the Central Provident Fund
both commercial and public agencies are beginning to become to help finance their purchase, the scheme took off. The fund
effective partners of the urban poor. is a state-managed, tax-exempted compulsory social security
fund for all citizens to which employees and employers con-
tribute. The prices of the flats are subsidized so that they re-
main within the affordability of the majority population. By
2001/2002, an estimated 85 per cent of the 3.3 million popu-
lation in Singapore were living in Housing and Development
Board dwellings (96 percent of which are owned by their occu-
pants and 4 percent of which are rented).
plots outside the city centre. Even before the financial crisis, per cent of its beneficiaries have incomes of less than US$20
some families struggled to secure their livelihood in these ar- per month. About half are widows or female single parents.
eas. Unable to find alternative sources of income, they contin- The overall costs of the house are US$450; but there is a gov-
ued with their existing work and managed either high transport ernment subsidy of US$144 (US$4 per month for three years).
costs or renting minimal accommodation closer to their previ- The client has to pay US$186 through payments of US$4–$5
ous inner-city locations. Other savings groups learned about per month. If they pay at the VHC office, the client can simul-
these experiences through the community networks that had taneously receive medical attention and lunch for themselves
been established.They realized that relocation was a difficult and their youngest children, subsidized by the government.
strategy and that families would have been better remaining They can pay with their social welfare of US$11 per month
in their existing locations. Now networks actively discourage or with other income. Some are supported by VHC’s charita-
households from relocating. As the financial crisis came to an ble funds. Currently, VHC has 16,000 clients, of whom 80 per
end, the community networks developed alternatives. Rather cent pay every month; some even pay several months in ad-
than lend money for relocation, they would work with commu- vance. Only 1 to 2 per cent of clients are regarded as perma-
nities threatened with eviction to strengthen their capacity to nent defaulters.
negotiate with their landowners.The costs are lower and the lo-
cation is better with regard to income-earning opportunities. Remittances from the United States to Mexico
Cemex of Mexico is the world’s third largest cement produc-
Launching a housing microfinance product: Mibanco, er. Since 2002, Mexican residents in the US can buy cement
Peru and other building materials directly in eight Cemex branches
With 70,000 active borrowers, Mibanco in Peru is one of in the US (a subsidiary called Construmex) and have the ma-
the largest microfinance institutions in Latin America. The terials delivered directly to a chosen address in Mexico. Since it
organization started as an (NGO), but became a commercial began this service (early 2002 to October 2004), US$3 million
bank in 1998. The conversion into a deposit-taking institution have been taken in construction sales. The company estimates
gave Mibanco the funding necessary to expand from micro-en- that the building materials needed for a two-bedroom house
terprise lending into other areas. During mid 2000, Mibanco costs about US$6,700.
added a housing product, Micasa, in the form of a loan for im-
provement, expansion, subdivision, or rebuilding or replace- Adding value: The uTshani Fund, South Africa
ment of existing housing. The uTshani Fund of the South African Homeless People’s
After 12 months of operation, Micasa had 3,000 clients, Federation was set up in 1994. From 1995 to 1999, the uTshani
with portfolio at risk greater than 30 days of 0.6 percent and Fund received substantial grant funding, including 10 million
a return on loan portfolio of 7 to 9 percent. Loan size ranged rand (US$1.5 million) from the South Africa Department of
from US$250–$4000, and averaged US$916. Interest rates Housing and many millions more from European donors who
were 50 to 70 per cent per annum. These rates are less than supported the federation’s strategy. It lent this money to fed-
those Mibanco charges on micro-enterprise loans. Loan peri- eration members who used it to start building houses while
ods were as much as up to 36 months; but most households waiting for subsidy approval. During this period the uTshani
preferred loans of 6 to 12 months, and the average loan peri- Fund facilitated the construction of almost 15,000 houses, all
od was 11 months. Mibanco uses its analysis of repayment po- of them larger and of better quality than comparable develop-
tential and household assets to guarantee most loans. Mortgage er-built products.
liens are sometimes taken, but only on larger loans (those above In just eight years, the uTshani process has created assets
US$4000) if the client already has clear legal title. In total, worth seven times the value of the original investment. In con-
mortgage liens secure only 7 percent of Mibanco’s home loans. trast to much privately developed state housing in South Africa,
The housing loan product has strong profitability and demand, a federation house is worth considerably more than the resourc-
and Mibanco expects such loans to represent half of its portfo- es put into it.
lio over the coming years.
To order these and any other publications, go to www.unhabitat.org and click on publications
22 News & Events Habitat Debate March 2007
Mrs. Tibaijuka meets new Secretary and cities. It marks the beginning of a new urban era. It is project-
ed that by 2030 that figure will rise to two-thirds.
General on his first official overseas
trip Moving into Eastern Europe and
The new UN Secretary General Mr. Ban ki-Moon visited Kenya in beyond
January where Mrs. Tibaijuka, escorted him through a section of
the crowded Kibera slum to give him his first taste of extreme ur- UN-HABITAT’s work in the transition economies of Central,
ban poverty in Africa. Eastern and Southern European States, took a boost in February
at the First meeting of the Advisory Council of the UN-HABITAT
Warsaw Office, the agency’s newest regional centre. “I am strong-
ly convinced that the UN-Habitat Office Poland can improve the
effectiveness and enhance the regional cooperation in the field
of sustainable development of human settlements,” said Mr.
Andrzej Aumiller, Minister of Construction of Poland said in wel-
coming remarks to over 70 delegates from 18 countries in the re-
gion. To fulfil these functions, the UN-HABITAT Office in Warsaw
would provide advisory services and facilitate the exchange of
knowledge and information, he said. It would also promote var-
ious contacts aiming at widening the cooperation in the fields
of housing and urban development. The Advisory Council is
made up of ministers of Central, Eastern and Southern European
countries responsible for housing and human settlements. Mrs.
Tibaijuka, who was in Warsaw for the occasion to thank the Polish
government, held talks with a number of senior officials, includ-
Mrs. Tibaijuka shows UN Secretary General Ban ki-Moon around
ing Mr. Aumiller, Ambassador Janusz Stanczyk, Undersecretary
Kibera slum in Kenya. Photo: © UN-Habitat/N.Kihara
of State at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, responsible for the
UN System, and Mrs. Hanna Gronkiewicz-Waltz, the Mayor of
“I feel very much humbled by what I am seeing now. That makes
Warsaw.
me resolve again my firm commitment to work for the improve-
ment of the living conditions, education, water, sanitation, hous-
ing – all these are the challenges which we must overcome,” Mr. Young people graduate as
Ban said outside the UN-HABITAT offices in Kibera, as journalists entrepreneurs
and members of the public scrambled to hear him speak. “This is
not the only place, I know. There are many other billions of peo- Twenty-five young people from the One Stop Youth Resource
ple suffering from lack of affordable housing – all the facilities Center in Nairobi recently graduated from the first ever Global
which make our life decent,” he said. “We must work together and Partnership Environmental Entrepreneurship Program spon-
generate the political will to have a smooth implementation of sored by UN-HABITAT, Youth for HABITAT and the Environmental
the Millennium Development Goals and I will work very closely, Youth Alliance. “This training is important because it recognizes
and harder than before.” both the youth need for employment combined with their con-
cern for the environment,” said Jane Bisanjou, a trainer with Youth
for HABITAT. “The programme demonstrates that youthful ideal-
First Asia Pacific Ministers Conference ism for the environment can be combined with the pragmatic
held in New Delhi need for a job.”
The first Asia-Pacific Ministers Conference on Housing and Urban
Development was held in December last year in New Delhi, India Blind cyclist carries UN-HABITAT
with clarion calls to reduce urban poverty and pollution in the message
world’s most populous region. “Increasing urbanisation is emerg-
ing as the most pervasive and dominant challenge in the region,” In January a blind Kenyan cy-
India’s Minister of Housing and Urban Poverty Alleviation, Kumari clist started a marathon cycling
Selja told the opening plenary. Cities, she said are the hubs of challenge from Cairo to Cape
economies, investments, technology, innovation, economic Town as a UN-HABITAT good-
growth and tertiary jobs. They make huge contributions to GDP will ambassador: “The message
as reservoirs of skills and hope for millions of people in the rural I want to tell all those in pain
hinterlands. and suffering is that it is pos-
Mrs. Tibaijuka said she appreciated the collaboration with coun- sible to pick up the pieces and
tries in the region, the Asian Development Bank and sister agen- start life afresh.”
cies like UNESCAP. “You represent the world’s most populous Coming from Douglas Sidialo
region – the region with most of the world’s largest cities. You this is in fact a passionate state-
represent a part of the world that is the global economic power- ment. Before 7 August 1998,
house of the future. You are gathered here to help devise a com- Photo: © UN-Habitat/N.Kihara Sidialo was an ambitious sales-
mon new vision aimed at harnessing some of that great Asian man with a Nairobi firm who
know-how and economic power to ensure that our growing cit- had his vision of the future well cut out. However, that Friday
ies of the future will not only be better managed, but managea- morning everything changed, thanks to the terrorist attack at
ble – or what we in the United Nations call, sustainable,” she said. the United States embassy in downtown Nairobi. Sidialo who
Mrs. Tibaijuka told the conference the year 2007 will be the year was driving by when the bombing occurred was blinded for life
in which for the first time, half of humanity will be living in towns in the bombing. The 37-year-old father of two girls overcame the
gloom that pervaded those early days after the bomb attack and
Habitat Debate March 2007 News & Events 23
with time has become a leading voice for the disabled. Known as Mines, in the capital Kigali on
Tour d’Afrique, the test of man and machine was to wind its way 22 February. During a day-long
over a period of 120 days across some of the roughest terrains in visit that coincided with the
the world to end up in Cape Town. 2007 International Women’s
Parliamentary Conference, Mrs.
UN HABITAT hosts WSF delegates Tibaijuka also held talks with
President Paul Kagame. The aim
Hundreds of delegates to the World Social Forum in January con- of the programme in Rwanda
verged at the UN-HABITAT headquarters for a special session will be to upgrade water and
highlighting the troubles women face worldwide. sanitation services for the ur-
Known as the “World Court of Women on Poverty: lives, liveli- ban poor in Kigali, and look at
hoods, lifeworlds”, the session heard testimonies from women President Kagame meeting new ways financing local wa-
in developing countries on problems of poverty, pain, survival delegates. Photo: © UN-Habitat ter and sanitation initiatives.
and resistance to the structural causes of poverty and destitu- They said they would moni-
tion. The testimonies were received by a jury of wise women and tor progress on Millennium Development Goal 7, Target 10 for
men from all parts of the world. In a key note address to the par- improved water and sanitation. UN-HABITAT’s Water for African
ticipants, Mrs. Tibaijuka said that the World Social Forum 2007 Cities programme will also be taken into schools to provide class-
was being held at a critical time in human history, when half of es on water conservation, publicly promoted to ensure people
the global population will live in urban areas. are better informed, and promote the special needs of women in
all water and sanitation programmes. The Water for African Cities
Programme is currently running in 17 cities across 13 countries in
Africa – Burkina Faso, Cameroon, Cote d’Ivoire, Ethiopia, Ghana,
Kenya, Mali, Mozambique, Nigeria, Senegal, Tanzania, Uganda,
and Zambia.
Photo: © UN-Habitat/N.Kihara
WWW
UN-HABITAT Regional Office for UN-HABITAT Geneva Office - ONU-HABITAT E-mail: office@unhabitat.org.yu
(CMDA Building)
Asia and the Pacific Bureau de Genève Egmore, Chennai 600 008, India
www.unhabitat.org
ACROS Fukuoka Building, 8th Floor Maison Internationale de l’Environnement 2 - Tel.: +91 (44) 2841 1302
Poland
1-1-1 Tenjin, Chuo-ku International Environment House 2 Fax: +91 (44) 2851 6273 UN-HABITAT Warsaw Office,
Fukuoka 810-0001, Japan 7, Chemin de Balexert, 5th Floor E-mail: unchssp@md2.vsnl.net.in Ul. Chalubinskiego 4, 00-928 Warsaw,
Tel.: +81 (92) 724 7121 CH-1219 Châtelaine, Genève Poland
Fax: +81 (92) 724 7124 Tel.: +41 (22) 917 8646/7/8 China Tel.: +48 (22) 630 1720
E-mail: habitat.fukuoka@unhabitat.org Fax: +41 (22) 917 8046 Fax: +48 (22) 630 1722
E-mail: habitatgva@unog.ch UN-HABITAT Beijing Information Office
Web: www.fukuoka.unhabitat.org Email: office@unhabitat.org.pl
No. 9 Sanlihe Road
Web: www.unhabitat.org.pl
Beijing 100835
People’s Republic of China
Tel.: +86 (10) 6839 4750/6835 0647
Fax: +86 (10) 6839 4749
E-mail: unchspek@public.bta.net.cn
Web: www.cin.gov.cn/habitat
ADVERTISE
I N H A B I TAT D E B AT E
With its worldwide circulation online and in print, in planners and key global urban policy makers, Habitat
five languages – English, Spanish, Russian, Chinese, Debate also reaches leading universities and research
and Arabic – Habitat Debate has a readership of about institutions.
35,000. Distributed to some 20,000 institutions, it is an
ideal advertising medium for all spheres of interest to Four times a year, Habitat Debate, UN-HABITAT’s flagship
people and corporations working with cities, in cities magazine, carries a series of authoritative articles by the
and for cities around the world. world’s leading experts on global urban developments,
looking objectively at both the good and the bad of our
In addition to its distribution to the world’s leading rapidly urbanising world.
mayors, government ministers, architects, urban
Correspondence
Editorial Assistant, Habitat Debate, P.O. Box 30030, Nairobi 00100, Kenya.
E-mail: habitat.debate@unhabitat.org Website: www.unhabitat.org Telephone: (25420) 762 3120, Fax: 762 42 64.