Proximate Analysis: - The sample is heated and volatile material is driven off in an inert atmosphere at high temperature (950) using a slow heating rate o Representative of slow pyrolysis - Classifies a fuel in terms of o Moisture content o Volatile matter o Ash content o Difference, fixed carbon - These parameters are relevant to combustion, gasification and pyrolysis
- Low MC = good - Large VM = good - Low ash content = good
Ultimate Analysis: - Attempts to determine elemental composition - Used to determine combustion and gasification air requirements, flue losses and likely emission levels - Usually reports C, H, N, S and difference by O
Lecture 3 Biomass Resources & Supply Chain
Types of Biomass
Woody Biomass Forest arisings: - What remains after logs extracted - Either on the ground of the cutover or at the landing - Low-cost biomass resource o Operational costs covered by main timber operation - Collection costs can be significant
Thinnings: - Thinning = removal of weaker and dominated trees so that remaining trees can grow better - The thinned timber trees have energy value
Wood-Process Residues: - Produced at saw-mills, pulp-mills, fiberboard plants or furniture manufacturers as a result of processing the logs or timber - Include bark, sawdust, shavings, wood chip rejects and offcuts - Very low cost but competition for uses such as fiber-board
Energy Crops: - Purpose grown, fast-growing species - Short rotation forestry (SRF) o High density planting o Harvested at much younger age o High energy yields per unit area o Require low nutrient input
Municipal Green Waste (MGW) - Used construction timber - Shipping pallets - Woody biomass from gardens
Environmental Issues: - Utilization of wood process residues for energy reduces: o The amount of material going into landfill or uncontrolled burning o GHG emissions from transport - Utilization of forest arisings or energy crops have more complex issues: o Soil erosion, water quality, nutrient removal, biodiversity, use of chemicals, addition of wastes to the soil o Site damage from vehicle access o Nutrient depletion o Continuing to cut down forests is not sustainable
Non-Woody Biomass (ACRs, animal & human residues, municipal wastes, energy crops)
Agricultural Crop Residues (ACRs) - Tend to be low in moisture content (~30% wet basis) o Suited to direct combustion and gasification - Wet wastes tend to be better suited to anaerobic digestion
Bagasse: - Fibrous residue left after sugar extraction - Most sure factories use bagasse as a source of heat for making steam
Energy Crops for Fuel Production Ethanol: - First generation ethanol requires starches and sugars o E.g. sugar-cane, corn, sweet sorghum, sugar beet
Biodiesel: - Production requires plant oils o E.g. soy, rapeseed, canola, palm oil, jatropha
Designer Biomass - Genetically modified crops
Wet Organic Wastes: - Converted via anaerobic digestion - Product is biogas that can be: o Fuel for internal combustion engines o Burnt directly for heating
Lecture 4 Chemical Thermodynamics
Stoichiometry: - Stoichiometric quantity of oxidizer is just the amount required to completely burn a quantity of fuel
Rich Mixture (fuel rich): - Too much fuel - Oxidizer < Fuel
Adiabatic Flame Temperature: - Temperature attained after combustion
Dissociation: - In combustion, if temperature is too high Stable molecules break up = Dissociation
Lecture 5 Combustion
Combustion and Steam Systems Steam Plants Consist of: - Fuel delivery and storage systems - Fuel feeding systems - Combustors - Steam equipment
Combustion Biomass Combustion Equipment is most often based on coal combustion equipment. Issues running biomass fuels include: - Higher moisture content lower efficiencies and sometimes higher emissions - Different S, N and C content different emissions - Different ash content possible issues of slagging and fouling - Lower energy density by volume Combustor de-rating (cant burn as much fuel in same place) Need larger combustors - More difficult fuel handling operations
Combustion of solid biomass fuels occurs in four key stages: 1. Heating & Drying 2. De-volatilization (Distillation of volatile gases) 3. Combustion of Volatiles (Visible flame when burning wood) 4. Char Oxidation (Combustion of fixed residual carbons glowing embers)
Phase 1: Heating & Drying. - Moisture in biomass is bound in two forms: 1. Bound or hygroscopic water 2. Free or capillary water - Fiber saturation point = when only bound moisture remains - Biomass is heated and the surplus moisture evaporates o Occurs at low temperatures, starting around 100C o Surface moisture drops to saturation point and evaporation front moves into biomass leaving behind only water vapor o Evaporation requires energy and hence lowers the temperature of the combustion chamber o Moisture varies between 10-50% (coal ~ 3-20%)
Phase 2: De-volatilization. - At higher temperatures, the biomass starts to degrade thermally and a range of gases are produced - Biomass produces much more volatiles than coal - Occurs during pyrolysis and gasification
Phase 3: Combustion of Volatiles. - Ignition takes place between 630-730C - Volatiles act exothermally with oxygen to produce mainly CO2 and water vapor - Has important effect on emissions o Biggest determinant is the flame temperature - Air-staging is an important way to control volatiles o Desire excess air to promote burnout of gases and any particulates (soot) that may have formed o Desire low air to avoid NOX formation NB - conflicting requirements!
Phase 4: Combustion of Fixed Carbons. - Once moisture and volatiles are driven off, fixed carbon component remains as char, which begins to burn as oxygen becomes available - Small particles controlled by chemical reaction - Large particles controlled by diffusion
Issues to Consider in Biomass Combustion: - Emissions are better than coal but still need to be controlled - Emissions from incomplete combustion o Key is to provide enough air by good combustion design o BUT too much air leads to inefficient combustion and NOX o Good mixing and homogeneity promotes complete combustion
Ash Fuel quality and combustor design & operation are critical to control ash. Ash can be characterized as: - Extraneous inorganic material (entrained ash) o Has been added during harvesting, handling and processing of the fuel - Inherent inorganic material (inherent ash) o Exists as part of the organic structure of the fuel o More mobile than entrained ash
Fly Ash: - Small ash particles present in the flue gas - Formed from vaporization and subsequent nucleation of very small particles, then grow by coagulation, agglomeration and condensation - Responsible for slagging and fowling
Bottom Ash: - Ash that remains on the bottom of the grate after combustion - Non-volatile components may melt and coalesce inside and on the surface of the fuel - Build up on grate can lead to problems
Slagging: - Associated principally with sintering and fusion of ash particles that deposit on surfaces within the furnace, at T>1000C - Can cause poor combustion conditions, blockages of ash can lead to outages, can reduce heat exchange to boilers reducing efficiency
Fouling: - Lower temperature process, driven by deposition of volatile inorganic species in the ash - Causes problems with blockages, corrosion and metal wastage
Potential uses of Ash: - Construction and landscaping materials - Cement or mortar - Aggregates - Fertilizer
Combustors Fixed Bed Combustors: - Include grate furnace and underfeed stokers - Primary air passed through a fixed bed, in which drying, de-volatilization and char-burnout takes place - Secondary air introduced to burn volatiles
- Grate furnaces appropriate for biomass fuels with high moisture and ash contents
- Fuel direction vs. air flow: o Counter-current Flame and flow in opposite direction Good for fuels with low heating value o Co-current Same direction Good for dry fuels o Cross-current Flue gas removed in the middle of the furnace
Fluidized Bed Systems: - Contains a vessel with a perforated bottom plate, and is filled with a suspension bed of hot, inert granular material - Primary air enters from below through an air-distribution plate at a high enough velocity to fluidize the bed
- Fluidization: consider a particle subject to aerodynamic drag forces o Particle is fluidized at the point where aerodynamic drag just balances garavity
Advantages Disadvantages Can flexibly deal with different fuel types Long start-up time Low NOX can be achieved Need small particles High combustion efficiency High dust loads entrained with flue gas Possibility to add S absorbing materials in the bed Bed material must be periodically replaced Can be fired successfully down to low loads of 35% capacity High capital cost and operating costs No moving parts in the hot combustion chamber
Bubbling Fluidized Bed (BFB): - Bed material is located in the bottom part of the furnace - Fluidization velocity = 1-3 m/s - Biomass fuels fed into the bed (As opposed to coal fed onto the bed) - 20 MWTh scale and above
Circulating Fluidized Bed (CFB): - Fluidization velocity = 4-10 m/s - Sand particles are smaller - Bed material fills reactor and circulates around - Higher turbulence Better mixing and more homogeneous temperature distribution - Compared to BFBs: o Larger capital cost o Higher dust load o Smaller particle size required - 30 MWTh scale and above
Pulverized Fuel Combustion: - Fuels with small particle size - Fuel injected tangentially into a cylindrical furnace to establish a rotational flow - De-volatilization and char burnout occur simultaneously due to small particle size Allows for rapid changes in load - Fuel feeding must be controlled carefully
Lecture 8 Gasification and Pyrolysis Pyrolysis and gasification can be thought of as truncated versions of the combustion process.
Pyrolysis - Thermal degradation of biomass in the absence of an oxidizing agent
Biomass + Heat Oils, char, gases
- Goal is usually to maximize the product of the liquid fuel product o Referred to as bio-oil, bio-crude, pyrolytic-oil, pyrolysis-oil, tar o Dark brown mobile liquid - Process is endothermic - requires a continuous source of heat to the pyrolyzing particles - Various methods: o Direct heat transfer with hot gases o Indirect heat transfer through heat exchange surfaces o Circulating solids - Products are quite variable and depend on: o Temperature o Heating rate o Fuel characteristics o Pressure o Oxygen
Effect of Temperature - As temperature increases (>280C), there is enough energy to eventually break bonds in molecular structure and the biomass is sequentially broken down o Hemicellulose breaks down first, then cellulose, then lignin - Initial product is tars - At even higher temperatures (>500C) these tars crack, generating CH4, H2, CO, CO2, and H2O
- At higher temperatures, gas products are favored - At lower temperatures, tar of char products are favored
Effect of Heating Rate - Different kinds of pyrolysis distinguished by heating rate
- Faster heating reduces char yield - Higher temperature increases gas yield
Slow Pyrolysis: - Charcoal production - HR = 1-100 K/s - Long residence time - Low temperature =~300C - Yield: 30% oils, 35% char, 35% gas
Fast Pyrolysis: - Designed to increase oil yields - Rapid heating rates =~1000 K/s - Short residence time - Moderate temperature =~450-600C - Yield: 75% oils, 12% char, 13% gas - Requires smaller particles - Insulating char layers must be removed
Flash Pyrolysis: - Even higher HR =~10,000 K/s - Even higher liquid yields - Smaller particle size needed
Pyrolysis Reactors Fixed Bed: - Batch process - Biomass set on a grate, walls heated - Slow heat transfer and long residence time Low liquid yield Ablative Process: - Biomass impacts a hot metal surface that is externally heated Removes insulating char layer Increases heat transfer rates - Quite large particles can be used - Mechanically involved and difficult to scale up
Twin-Screw Process: - Biomass mixed with high-temperature sand (~500C) - Screw conveys and mixes sand - High HRs can be achieved with good control of residence time - Sand must be reheated in separate vessel - Risk of ash/sand conglomeration - Risk of mechanical failure
Fluidized Beds: - Similar to fluidization process used for combustors - Biomass introduced into a bed of hot, solid particles fluidized by a gas - Provides a very good heat transfer - Two types: 1. Bubbling beds lower velocity 2. Circulating beds higher velocity
Gasification - A partial oxidation process that converts a solid fuel into a gaseous fuel - Products are gas, char and oils - Optimized for high gas yields ideally CO & H2 - Liquid product (tar) is undesirable - Oxidizing agent is typically: o Air LCV gas is produced o Pure oxygen medium CV gas is produced - Gas composition depends on the temperature used o Higher temperatures break down hydrocarbons and tars to CO & H2
Process of Gasification 1. Heating & Drying Temperature raised and water is driven off
2. Pyrolysis (de-volatilization) Biomass begins to degrade thermally (in the presence of oxygen) and volatile oils are driven off, leaving behind char.
3. Partial Oxidation Volatiles and some char are partially burned in the oxidizer to generate heat and produce gas
4. Reduction Reaction between heated CO2 or H2O and the remaining char (C), adding CO or H2 to the producer gas
The aim of the gasifier reactor is to: - Produce volatile gases and carbon char - Convert the volatiles to CO, H2 and CH4 gases - Convert the char to CO
Gasifier Designs Moving Bed Gasifier: - Oldest technology - Biomass bed sits on fixed grate and moves down as progressively gasified - Smaller scale 0-15 tons dry biomass per hour - Hard to scale up
Updraft Gasifier (counter-Current Moving bed): - Fuel fed from top - Oxidizer fed from bottom - Fuel size, shape and moisture content are not critical to operation - Suitable for direct heating but not for use in engines
Downdraft Gasifier (co-current moving bed): - All introduced in the bed instead of under it - Syn-gas removed at the bottom - Pyrolysis tars must pass through the high-temperature oxidatuion zone where they convert into simple hydrocarbons giving a gas with low tar content - Better for internal combustion engines or gas turbines - Large portion of biomass is converted to heat leading to LCV gas
Crosscurrent Gasifier: - Simple design - The air and gas product move across the feedstock flow - Controlling the gas to pass evenly through the zones is difficult and poor quality gas results
Fluidized Bed Designs: - Most common in larger sized reactors - Hot bed of sand or dolomite particles are kept in constant motion by the air o Air is introduced through a nozzle at the base - Feedstock of small particle size fed into the upper part of the reactor - Due to good mixing, temperature is more even (800-1000C) but the product gas contains tar and ash o Gas cleanup must be a key part of the process - Bed materials may agglomerate and therefore need to be changed
BFBs: - Fuel is fed into or on top of the sand bed - Gasification medium (air or CO2) is introduced from below at speeds of 2- 3 m/s - Syngas drawn off at top
Advantages Disadvantages High rates of throughput compared with moving beds High particulate content resulting in gas Good mixing, heat transfer and control of temperature high conversion of carbon Large bubbles may results in gas bypass through reactor Tar content low (still requires cleanup)
CFBs: - Similar to BFBs - Fluidization velocity is higher ~5-10 m/s - Bed particles are suspended throughout the reactor and must be re- circulated - Compared with BFBs: o Higher yields o Lower tar content o Even higher particulate content o Possibility of erosion at high velicity
Lecture 9 Biochemical Gasification
Anaerobic Digestion - The decomposition of organic wastes to gaseous fuel by bacteria in a low oxygen environment. - Arises naturally in marshy grounds and landfills o Can be captured from landfills (landfill gas) or deliberately harnessed in biogas plants. - Products are primarily CH4 and CO2 - Four stages 1. Hydrolysis 2. Acidogenesis 3. Acetogenesis 4. Methanogenesis
Hydrolysis - Fermentative hydrolytic bacteria break down fats, proteins and carbohydrates into smaller molecules. I.e. break down larger sugar based molecules into smaller ones. - Some H2 and CO produced
Acidogenesis - Acidogenic bacteria metabolize the hydrolysis products - Products are CO2 and H2 and short chain organic acids
Acetogenesis - Simple molecules created in Acidogenesis are further broken down by acetogenic bacteria - Oxygen in the feedstock is also consumed - Products include acetate, CO2 and H2
Methanogenesis - Methanogenic bacteria converts acetate, CO2 and H2 released from previous steps into the end products - End products = CH4, CO2 and trace gases
Elements of a Biogas Plant - Procurement of the fuel o Organic wastes used on site or green crops grown specifically to supply the plant - Bio-gasification of the slurry feedstock into a digester, collection of the gas and storage - Scrubbing o Remove of H2 o Possibly remove CO2 - Biogas utilization (after scrubbing) o In gas reticulation systems o Generation of heat and electricity - Sludge disposal
Digester Process: - Enclosing organic material in a large tank and restricting oxygen supply encourages the process - Proportion of CH4, CO2 and impurities such as H2S in the gas, depends on: o Feedstock material o Scale of the plant o Retention time (RT) in the digester o Process temperature
Feedstocks: - Moisture content =~10-15% o Anaerobic digestion is suited to wet wastes - Total Solid (TS) = amount of solid in the feedstock per total mass of the feedstock o Low TS convenient handling (i.e. liquid), BUT lower yield
Containments: - Physical such as plastic can reduce blockages - Chemical might inhibit digestion process
Heating: - Internal coils or heat exchangers, or external heating jackets - Burns some of the biogas or uses waste heat from an associated engine as heat source - Mesophilic digesters need a relatively stable temperature of 35C (+- 4- 7C)
Mixing: - Maintains an even temperature gradient - Maintains a homogeneous and even supply of feedstock - Prevents settlement of solids - Avoids crust formation on surface - Achieved by recirculating gas back through the tank digester o Typically 30 x digester Volume needs to be re-circulated per day
Operation: - Require gas yields of 70-80% of the maximum theoretical yields per kg of feedstock to ensure positive economics
Gas Scrubbing: - Removes inert components (N2 & CO2) o Increases energy density o Necessary if it is to be compressed or liquefied for a vehicle fuel - Reduces corrosion of process equipment by removing H2S and water vapor - Reduces potential health hazards and environmental pollution - Expensive process
Benefits Barriers Digester sludge can be used as fertilizer or animal feed supplement Poor comprehension Risk of biological process failing Reduces nitrate pollution levels from conventional disposal of wet wastes High transport costs of feedstocks Multiple end use decision outputs needed for what is a finite resource
Landfill Gas: - A large portion of MSW is biological material that once disposed of in landfills, experiences conditions suitable for anaerobic digestion - Process is similar to AD, except that: o Slurry is replaced with solid waste o Enclosure tank reactor vessel is replaced with a hole in the ground - Produced biogas is a mixture of CH4, CO2, H2S, and other gases - Process is slower than biogas digester due to lower temperature and drier conditions but the end product gas is similar - In theory, for 1 ton of MSW 150-200 m 3 of biogas can be produced with a heat value of 5-6 MJ/kg - Extraction of landfill gas uses a network of perforated pipes laid as the site is filled
Landfill Gas Uses: - Direct combustion in kilns, boilers and furnaces, provided the supply is in close proximity to the user o This is the most cost effective use - Electricity generation - Gas can be cleaned and then supplied to the gas utility network
Integrated Treatment of Municipal Wastes: - Includes solid and liquid wastes o Usually the treatment of both is total separate: Solid = local landfill Liquid = local sewage treatment plant - May be beneficial to consider treating both in an integrated fashion in order to minimize costs and maximize the benefits - As part of the treatment system: o An energy crop could be grown to absorb the effluent and sludge components of the waste by land application Avoid dumping in the sea or waterways Biomass would then be harvested as additional duel for an energy conversion plant
Lecture 10 Bioenergy Permanent Plantings - Not harvested other than for o Thinning or ecological purposes o To remove debris for fire management - Carbon stock plateaus - No revenue once maximum carbon stock reached
Rotational Crops - Benefit from offset of fossil fuel use - Ongoing revenue to fund management
Wood Chips Conventional Wood Pellets Torrefied Wood Pellets LHV [MJ/kg] 7.4-11.4 17-18 21-22 MC [%wet basis] 30-50 <10 <1 Bulk Density [kg/m 3 ] 250-400 650 900 Energy Density [GJ/m 3 ] 3.1 11.4 19.4
Torrefied Wood Pellets: - Torrefication can be described as a mild form of pyrolysis at temperatures between 200-320C - The biomass properties are changes to obtain a much better fuel quality for combustion and gasification application o Removes moisture and low energy volatiles from the roasted wood - More energy dense than wood almost as dense as coal - Easier to grind than wood
Advantages: - Energy content per kg (energy density) is similar to coal and approximately 17-37% greater than conventional wood pellets o Lower shipping costs per tonne o Improves handling characteristics - Bulk density is lower than coal but higher than wood pellets o Higher bulk density lower shipping costs per tonne - Requires less energy to grind than both wood pellets and coal - Can be ground in existing coal equipment - Ash content is similar to wood pellets but much lower than coal - Sulfur content is similar to wood pellets but much less than coal
Barriers to Bioenergy Implementation: - Low cost of fossil fuels - Concerns about using native forest biomass for fuels - Now removed from the LRET - Economics of fuel procurement
Lecture 12 Liquid Biofuels for Transportation The Need for Alternative Liquid Fuels: - Oil is a major source of world energy use and CO2 emissions - Australia is increasingly reliant on imported oil, which increasingly comes from fewer countries - Oil prices are rising
Alternative and Advanced Fuels Biofuels: - Bioethanol, biodiesel, biobutanol, biogas, hydrogenation derived renewable diesel, hydrogen, etc. Non-Biofuels: - Electricity, propane, LNG, Methanol, synthetic fuels from coal and natural gas
Advantages of Liquid Fuels for Transportation: - High energy density - Quick and easy - Easy to handle and transport - Existing infrastructure - NB Historical Advantages of Oil that are Decreasing: o Cheap o Easy to find, mine, upgrade Alternatives: Transport Systems: - Reduce need for transport o Telecommuting - Increase public transport - Increase efficiency
Alternatives for Fossil Fuel Resources: Enhanced Oil Recovery (EOR) - CO2 injection to increase recovery rate
Tar-sands - Heavy oils mixed with sand - Hard to extract
Gas-to-liquid Synfuels - Convert natural gas to liquid by Fischer-Tropsch
Coal-to-liquid Synfuels - Convert coal to liquid by gasification then Fischer-Tropsch
Oil-shale - Rock containing organic materials - Very hard to extract
Electrical Car Alternatives: - CO2 emissions depend on original source of energy - Battery technology developments will enable rapid increase in market penetration
Advantages Disadvantages Increase drive train efficiency Expensive, heavy and bulky batteries Zero local emission Limited range and battery life Long charging times
Biofuels - Fuel derived from biomass using biological or thermochemical processes - Utilizing recently captured carbon rather than historically captured carbon reserves - Engines must be modified in order to effectively utilize biofuel
Ethanol: - Formed by fermentation of sugars or hydrolysis of ethane - Typically used as a blend (E5/E10) o Mixing properties with gasoline are important
Advantages Disadvantages Neat ethanol (pure) is an excellent fuel Potential corrosion problems High octane (>100) high compression ration increased efficiency
Starting problems in cold weather because vapor pressure is too low at low temperatures
Lower flame temperature lower NOX emissions
Lower energy density than gasoline decreased fuel economy
Biodiesel (FAME): - Fatty Acid Methyl Ester (FAME) - Formed from transesterification of soybean or rape seed oil using a catalyst and methanol byproduct = glycerol - Mixed with normal diesel (B10/B20) or used pure - Decreased emissions of particulates and CO when combusted in a diesel engine
Biomass: - Agricultural and forestry wastes can be converted into energy o Full and partial pyrolysis o Syngas from steam reforming to generate hydrogen
Biobutanol: - Anaerobic process to generate acetone (& butanol) by fermentation of molasses or starch. - Low vapor pressure - Energy content is similar to petroleum - Can blend with petroleum
First Generation Biofuels Process: 1. Pretreatment (milling) 2. For starches: enzymatic/acid hydrolysis to release monosaccharides 3. Fermentation 4. Product extraction distillation and dehydration
Diesel: - Can be obtained from natural plant oils and animal fats through transesterification reaction - Straight vehicle oil (SVO) can be burned in modified engines, HOWEVER problems exist with o High viscosity injector choking o Poor low temperature properties
Transesterification: - Original oils composed primarily of molecules of triglycerides - Involves the reaction with an alcohol (methanol/ethanol) in the presence of a catalyst (Triglyceride) + (Methanol) (Glycerol) + (FAME) - High quality fuel can results, which can be burned in unmodified engines Advantages Disadvantages Can be burned in unmodified engines Low yield of fuel/ha Can be blended with fossil fuels Direct competition with other uses Decreased emissions Increased NOx When produced from wastes, avoids disposal costs and enviro impacts Led to massive deforestation in South- East Asia
Ethanol: - Produced by fermentation of monosaccharides (simple sugars) - Yeasts metabolize glucose - Starches can be broken down into glucose by enzymes or acids through hydrolysis (adding H2O), then fermented - Carbon cycle: o Closed cycle associated with ethanol production, fermentation and combustion
6CO2 + 12H2O + light 6CO2 + 12H2O + heat
Second Generation Biofuels Cellulosic Ethanol: - Uses not just sugars and starches like first generation ethanol, but also uses cellulose and hemicellulose =~70% of the plant and are also made of sugars
Pretreatment: - Cell wall structure must be opened up (without degrading basic sugars) to allow enzymes access for hydrolysis - Me
Advantages (relative to 1 st gen.) Disadvantages Lower cost raw materials Largely unknown technology at scale no commercial scale plants Increased availability No direct competition with food crops Cannot use lignin fraction Increased GHG reduction Sustainability issue remain
Significant R&D is still required!
Third Generation Biofuels Fuels from Algae Algae: - Diverse and large groups of organisms - Interest for fuels are mostly on micro-algae because: o High productivity, oil content o Non-competitive with arable land or fresh water - Potential for carbon capture and recycling into fuels
Closed Systems vs. Open Ponds: Closed Systems: - Possible to avoid infection by unwanted strains - Possible to avoid infestation by bugs that eat algae - Good control of conditions growth rate and/or yield optimized - CO2 capture facility - Water conservation Open Ponds: - Much lower capital costs