Anda di halaman 1dari 63

ADI 2011

Research Lab

1
Devt Assistance Generic Core

DA Generic Core
DA Generic Core ................................................................. 1

***DA Solves*** ................................................... 3


DA Solves Generic ........................................................... 4
DA Solves A2: Rejection .................................................. 5
DA Solves A2: Transition ................................................. 6
DA Solves A2: Long term ................................................ 7
DA Solves A2: Dependency ............................................. 8
DA Solves A2: Parties ...................................................... 9
DA Solves A2: Definitional Problems ............................ 10
DA Solves A2: Governance ............................................ 11
DA Solves A2: Governance ............................................ 12
DA Solves A2: Local Context Key ................................. 13
DA Solves A2: Local Context Key ................................. 14
DA Solves A2: Backlash ................................................ 15
DA Solves A2: Credibility/Politicization........................ 16
DA Solves A2: Credibility/Politicization........................ 17
DA Solves A2: Credibility/Politicization........................ 18
DA Solves A2: Regime Change No Link .................... 19
DA Solves A2: Regime Change Turn: Moderation ..... 20
DA Solves A2: Western Model ...................................... 21
DA Solves A2: Corruption.............................................. 22
DA Solves A2: Coordination .......................................... 23
DA Solves A2: Coordination .......................................... 24
DA Solves A2: Assessment ............................................ 25
DA SolvesA2: Complexity ............................................ 26
DA SolvesA2: Culture ................................................... 27
DA SolvesA2: Monitoring ............................................. 28

***DA Fails***.................................................... 29
DA Fails Generic ............................................................ 30
DA Fails A2: Studies ...................................................... 31
DA Fails A2: Studies ...................................................... 32
DA Fails A2: Studies ...................................................... 33
DA Fails A2: Studies ...................................................... 34
DA Fails A2: Studies Block Trick: No Solvency ........ 35
DA Fails Rejection .......................................................... 36
DA Fails Cooptation ....................................................... 37
DA Fails Long-Term....................................................... 38
DA Fails Complexity ...................................................... 39
DA Fails Culture ............................................................. 40
DA Fails Monitoring ....................................................... 41
DA Fails Parties .............................................................. 42
DA Fails Parties .............................................................. 43
DA Fails Agency Coordination....................................... 44
DA Fails Separation of Powers ....................................... 45
DA Fails Dependency ..................................................... 46
DA Fails Credibility ........................................................ 47
DA Fails Credibility ........................................................ 48
DA Fails Credibility ........................................................ 49
DA Fails Local Context .................................................. 50
DA Fails Local Context .................................................. 51
DA Fails Local Context .................................................. 52
DA Fails Local Context A2: We Build Capacity ......... 53
DA Fails Definitional Problems ...................................... 54

DA Fails Western Model ................................................ 55


DA Fails Politicized ....................................................... 56
DA Fails Poverty ............................................................ 57
DA Fails Governance Turn ............................................ 58
DA Fails Governance Turn ............................................ 59
DA Fails Accountability Turn ........................................ 60
DA Fails Transition Turn ............................................... 61
DA Fails Transition Turn ............................................... 62
DA Fails Transition Turn Impact Calc: Escalation ..... 63
DA Fails Govt to Govt ................................................. 64
DA Fails Govt to Govt ................................................. 65

***NGO DA Solves*** ........................................66


NGO DA Solves Aid Works .......................................... 67
NGO DA Solves Aid Works .......................................... 68
NGO DA Solves A2: Repression ................................... 69
NGO DA Solves A2: Repression ................................... 70
NGO DA Solves NGOs Good....................................... 71
NGO DA Solves NGOs Good....................................... 72
NGO DA Solves NGOs Good....................................... 73

***NGO DA Fails*** ..........................................74


NGO DA Fails Generally ............................................... 75
NGO DA Fails Govt Cooptation ................................... 76
NGO DA Fails NGOs =/= Govt Change ..................... 77
NGO DA Fails Repression ............................................. 78
NGO DA Fails Urban ..................................................... 79
NGO DA Fails Picking Winners .................................... 80
NGO DA Fails Divisions ............................................... 81
NGO DA Fails NGOs Bad Generally.......................... 82
NGO DA Fails NGOs Bad Accountability ................ 83
NGO DA Fails NGOs Bad Accountability ................ 84
NGO DA Fails NGOs Bad Representativeness ......... 85
NGO DA Fails NGOs Bad Representativeness ......... 86
NGO DA Fails K Link ................................................... 87

***USAID Solves*** ...........................................88


USAID Solves Generic .................................................. 89
USAID Solves Generic .................................................. 90
USAID Solves A2: Contracting ..................................... 91
USAID Solves A2: Branding ......................................... 92

***USAID Fails*** ..............................................93


USAID Fails Coordination ............................................. 94
USAID Fails Coordination ............................................. 95
USAID Fails Local Populations ..................................... 96
USAID Fails Politics ...................................................... 97
USAID Fails Generally .................................................. 98
USAID Fails Contracting ............................................... 99
USAID Fails Resources................................................ 100
USAID Fails Branding ................................................. 101

ADI 2011
Research Lab

2
Devt Assistance Generic Core

***NED Solves*** ............................................ 102

***NED Fails*** ................................................108

NED Solves Democratization ....................................... 103


NED Solves- k2 Democratization .................................... 104
NED Solves- k2 Democratization .................................... 105
NED Solves- Relations .................................................... 106
NED Solves- Modeled ..................................................... 107

NED Fails- Politics .......................................................... 109


NED Fails- Politics .......................................................... 110
NED Fails- Credibility .................................................... 111
NED Fails Picking Winners ......................................... 112
NED FailsAdministration ............................................ 113

ADI 2011
Research Lab

1
Framework

Framework
Framework ........................................................................... 1

***Kritiks Bad*** ................................................ 3

2NC Engaging Politics Solves Totalitarianism ................. 40


2NC Policy Debate Fractures Movements ........................ 41
2NC No Spillover .............................................................. 42

**Shells................................................................... 3

**Answers To .......................................................43

*Aff ......................................................................... 3

AT: Mitchell ...................................................................... 44


AT: Spanos ........................................................................ 45
AT: Kulynych .................................................................... 46
AT: Karl Rove Was A Debater ......................................... 47
AT: Hicks & Greene.......................................................... 48
AT: Hicks & Greene.......................................................... 49
AT: You Exclude Critiques ............................................... 50
AT: Debate Produces Bad Policymakers........................... 51
AT: You Create Spectators................................................ 52
AT: K Precedes Theoretical Arguments ............................ 53
AT: Rules Are Violent ...................................................... 54
AT: Minority Participation ................................................ 55
AT: Resolved Is Before The Colon ................................... 56
AT: Words Lack Determinate Meaning ............................ 57

2AC Shell............................................................................. 4

*Neg ........................................................................ 5
1NC Shell 1/3....................................................................... 6
1NC Shell 2/3....................................................................... 7
1NC Shell 3/3....................................................................... 8

**Overviews........................................................... 9
*Aff ...................................................................................... 9
1AR Overview ................................................................... 10

*Neg ...................................................................... 11
2NC Overview ................................................................... 12

**Interpretation Debate ..................................... 13


2NC Interpretation Extension ............................................ 14
2NC AT: Counter-Interpretation ........................................ 15
2NC AT: Your Interpretation is Exclusionary ................... 16
2NC AT: We Meet We Affirm the Rez as X............... 17

**Fairness Debate ............................................... 18


2NC Fairness Extension ..................................................... 19
2NC AT: Nazis Wanted Fairness ....................................... 20
2NC AT: Your Conception of Fairness is Bad .................. 21
2NC AT: Education Precedes Fairness .............................. 22
2NC AT: Fairness is Arbitrary ........................................... 23
2NC AT: Fairness is Utopian ............................................. 24

**Switch-Side Debate ......................................... 25

**Policymaking/Roleplaying ..............................58
2NC Oasis Wall ................................................................. 59
2NC Oasis Wall ................................................................. 60
Policy Framework Good Inevitable................................ 61
Policy Framework Good Decision-Making .................... 62
Policy Framework Good International Law ................... 63
Roleplaying Good Education ......................................... 64
Roleplaying Good Devils Advocate.............................. 65
Roleplaying Good Empowerment .................................. 66
Roleplaying Good Politics.............................................. 67
Roleplaying Good Solves Exclusion .............................. 68
Roleplaying Good Democracy ....................................... 69
A2: Roleplaying Utopian................................................... 70

**DA Specific Policy FW ....................................71

2NC Switch-Side Extension .............................................. 26


2NC AT: Switch-Side Kills Advocacy .............................. 27
2NC AT: Switch-Side Causes Relativism.......................... 28

Aid Debates Good ............................................................. 72


Aid Debates Good ............................................................. 73
Aid Debates Good ............................................................. 74
Aid Debates Good ............................................................. 75

**Shively Debate ................................................. 29

**Consequentialism .............................................76

2NC Shively Extension ...................................................... 30

Policymaking Requires Consequentialism ........................ 77


Policymaking Requires Consequentialism ........................ 78
Consequentialism Good Lesser Evil .............................. 79
Consequentialism Good Not Calculation ....................... 80
Consequentialism Good Morals ..................................... 81
Morality Bad International Violence .............................. 82

**Lutz Debate...................................................... 31
2NC Lutz Extension ........................................................... 32

**Boggs Debate ................................................... 33


2NC Boggs Extension ........................................................ 34
2NC AT: Debate Social Movements ............................. 35
2NC Apolitical Theorizing Does Nothing ......................... 36
2NC Apolitical Theorizing Does Nothing ......................... 37
2NC Policy Debate Can Influence Policymakers .............. 38
2NC Theory Trades Off With Politics ............................... 39

**Utilitarianism ...................................................83
Utilitarianism Good Public Sphere ................................. 84
Utilitarianism Good - Inevitable ........................................ 85
Utilitarianism Good Moral ............................................. 86
Survival Outweighs Morality ............................................ 87
AT: Calculation Bad ......................................................... 88

ADI 2011
Research Lab

2
Framework

**Extinction ......................................................... 89

Consequentialism Bad Epistemology ........................... 134

Extinction Outweighs Laundry List ................................ 90


Extinction Outweighs Discussion Key............................ 91
Extinction Outweighs General ........................................ 92
Extinction Outweighs General ........................................ 93
Extinction Outweighs Ontology...................................... 94

**A2: Pragmatism .............................................135

**Pragmatism...................................................... 95
Pragmatism 2AC Rorty ................................................... 96
Cede The Political 1NC Ketels (1/2) .............................. 97
Cede The Political 1NC Ketels (2/2) .............................. 98
Cede The Political 1NC Rorty (1/2)................................ 99
Cede The Political 1NC Rorty (2/2).............................. 100
AT: We Can Never Change Politics ................................ 101

**Generic K Answers ....................................... 102


*Statism ........................................................................... 102
State Good Movements ................................................. 103
State Good Extinction ................................................... 104
State Good Environment ............................................... 105
State Good Strategic Reversibility ................................ 106

*Language .......................................................... 107


No Alternative.................................................................. 108
A2: Word PICs................................................................. 109
A2: Word PICs................................................................. 110
Punishment of Language Bad .......................................... 111
*Narratives ....................................................................... 112
Narratives Bad Self-Fulfilling Prophecy ....................... 113
Narratives Bad Self-Fulfilling Prophecy ....................... 114
Narratives Bad Fetishization ......................................... 116
Narratives Bad Victimization........................................ 117
Narratives Bad Narcissism ............................................ 118
Narratives Bad Narcissism ............................................ 119
Narratives Bad Narcissism ............................................ 120

*Irony ................................................................. 121


Irony Bad Non-Falsifiable ............................................ 122
Irony Bad Alt Fails........................................................ 123
Irony Bad Apolitical ..................................................... 124
Irony Bad Solvency Turn .............................................. 125
Irony Bad Not Subversive ............................................. 126
A2: Irony Avoids Cooption ............................................. 127

***Kritiks Good*** .......................................... 128


**A2: Utilitarianism/Consequentialism .......... 128
Utilitarianism Bad Genocide/War/Morals .................... 129
Utilitarianism Bad Individuality ................................... 130
Utilitarianism Bad Morals............................................. 131
Utilitarianism Bad Mass Death ..................................... 132
Utilitarianism Bad Value to Life ................................... 133

Pragmatism Bad Empty Rhetoric ................................. 136


Pragmatism Bad Atrocities ........................................... 137
Pragmatism Bad Decision-Making............................... 138
Pragmatism Bad Tautological ...................................... 139
Pragmatism Bad Epistemology .................................... 140

**A2: Switch Sides Debate ................................141


Switch Sides Bad Spanos ............................................. 142
Switch Sides Bad Hicks and Green .............................. 143
Switch Sides Bad Hicks and Green .............................. 144
Affirmative Kritiks Good ................................................ 147
Affirmative Kritiks Good ................................................ 148

**State-Centricity Bad ......................................149


Statism Bad Agency ..................................................... 150
Statism Bad Agency ..................................................... 151
Statism Bad Violence ................................................... 152
Statism Bad Education ................................................. 153
Statism Bad - Identity ...................................................... 154

**Answers To .....................................................155
AT: Predictability ............................................................ 156
AT: Limits ....................................................................... 157
AT: Limits ....................................................................... 158
AT: Rules Good .............................................................. 159
AT: Education ................................................................. 160
AT: You Lead To No Limits ........................................... 161
AT: Limits/Exclusion Inevitable ..................................... 162
AT: Limits/Exclusion Inevitable ..................................... 163
AT: You Lead To Different Limits ................................. 164
AT: Shively ..................................................................... 165
AT: Do It On The Neg .................................................... 166
AT: Wrong Forum ........................................................... 167
AT: Debate Community .................................................. 168
AT: Policymaking ........................................................... 169
AT: Policymaking ........................................................... 170
AT: Policymaking ........................................................... 171
AT: Policymaking ........................................................... 172
AT: Policymaking Solves Violence ................................ 173
AT: Must Be Policy Relevant.......................................... 174
AT: Elite Takeover .......................................................... 175
AT: Topical Version ........................................................ 176
AT: Must Debate About Policy ....................................... 177
AT: Cede The Political .................................................... 178
AT: Cede The Political .................................................... 179
AT: Cede The Political .................................................... 180
AT: Focus On Solvency/Procedure ................................. 181
AT: Focus On Solvency/Procedure ................................. 182

1/188

ADI 2011
Frappier-Russell

Agamben Answers

K Answers Toolbox
K Answers Toolbox ............................................................... 1

***Western Feminism Answers***............... 3


Western Feminism No Link: Imperialism/Trade-Off .......... 4
Western Feminism Perm Solves Politics Key .................. 5
Western Feminism Perm Solves Generally ...................... 6
Western Feminism Perm Solves Generally ...................... 7
Western Feminism Perm Solves Generally ...................... 8
Western Feminism Perm Solves Generally ...................... 9
Western Feminism Perm Solves Generally .................... 10
Western Feminism Alt Fails Aff is a Prereq to the Alt ... 11
Western Feminism Alt Fails Essentialism Turn ............. 12
Western Feminism Alt Fails Exclusion Turn ................. 13
Western Feminism Alt Fails Generally .......................... 14
Western Feminism Alt Fails Generally .......................... 15

***Security Answers*** ............................... 16


Security K No Link A2: State Bad ................................. 17
Security K Link Turn: Sovereignty ................................... 18
Security K AT: Security Discourse Bad ............................ 19
Security K AT: Security Discourse Bad ............................ 20
Security K Threats = Real Generally and Historically ... 21
Security K A2: Epistemology K ........................................ 22
Security K AT: Root Cause ............................................... 23
Security K Fear Good........................................................ 24
Security K Apocalyptic Imagery Good Social Change .. 25
Security K Apocalyptic Imagery Good Social Change .. 26
Security K Apocalyptic Imagery Alt Fails ..................... 27
Security K Predictions Good ............................................. 28
Security K Predictions Good ............................................. 29
Security K Perm Solves Strategic Reversibility ............. 30
Security K Perm Solves Generally ................................. 31
Security K Perm Solves A2: Security is Totalizing ........ 32
Security K Alt Fails Discourse ....................................... 33
Security K Alt Fails Generally ....................................... 34
Security K Alt Turn Exclusion ....................................... 35
Security K Alt Fails Reject Bad ..................................... 36
Security K Alt Fails Violence Inevitable ........................ 37
Security K Alt Fails Violence Inevitable ........................ 38

***Agamben Answers*** ............................ 39


Agamben Perm .................................................................. 40
Agamben Perm: Neg Totalizes.......................................... 41
Agamben Perm: Neg Totalizes.......................................... 42
Agamben AT: Aid Links (1/2) .......................................... 43
Agamben AT Aid: Links (2/2) .......................................... 44
Agamben No Link: Liberalism Good ................................ 45
Agamben No Link: Liberalism Good ................................ 46
Agamben No Impact Turn: Trivialization ...................... 47
Agamben No Impact Turn: Value to Life/Bare Life ...... 48
Agamben No Impact A2: Root Cause ............................ 49
Agamben No Impact AT: Bare Life ............................... 50
Agamben No Impact AT: Bare Life ............................... 51
Agamben AT: Soveriegn Power........................................ 52
Agamben AT: Biopower Holocaust ............................. 53
Agamben Alt Bad Overdetermined ................................ 54
Agamben No Alt Turn: Sovereign Control .................... 55
Agamben No Alt Turn: Violence ................................... 56
Agamben Alt Fails (1/4) .................................................... 57
Agamben Alt Fails (2/4) .................................................... 58

Agamben Alt Fails (3/4).................................................... 59


Agamben Alt Fails (4/4).................................................... 61
Agamben No Alt A2: Witnessing .................................. 62
Agamben No Alt A2: Whatever Being .......................... 63

***Empire Answers*** .................................64


Empire No Link: DA is Not Imperial ................................ 65
Empire Imperialism Good ................................................. 66
Empire Imperialism Good ................................................. 67
Empire Hegemony Good................................................... 68
Empire A2: US is Imperialist ............................................ 69
Empire A2: US is Imperalist ............................................. 70
Empire A2: US is Imperalist ............................................. 71
Empire Anti-Imperialism Alt Fails................................. 72
Empire Anti-Imperialism Alt Fails................................. 73
Empire General Philosophy Bad ....................................... 75
Empire Perm ..................................................................... 76
Empire Impact Debate 1/3................................................. 77
Empire Impact Debate 2/3................................................. 78
Empire Impact Debate 3/3................................................. 79
Empire Alt Debate ............................................................ 80
Empire Alt Debate ............................................................ 81
Empire Alt Debate ............................................................ 82
Empire Alt Debate ............................................................ 83
Empire Alt Debate ............................................................ 84
Empire Alt Debate ............................................................ 85

***Whiteness Answers*** ............................86


Whiteness Democracy Good ............................................. 87
Whiteness Democracy Good ............................................. 88
Whiteness Democracy Good ............................................. 89
Whiteness Democracy Good ............................................. 91
Whiteness Colorblindness Good ....................................... 92
Whiteness Perm Solves ..................................................... 93
Whiteness Perm Solves ..................................................... 94
Whiteness Perm Solves ..................................................... 95
Whiteness Perm Solves ..................................................... 96
Whiteness Perm Solves A2: Monolithic Power ............. 97
Whiteness A2: Time Wise ................................................ 98
Whiteness White Supremacy = Dirty Word ................... 99
Whiteness Alt Fails Focus on White Supremacy Bad .. 100
Whiteness Alt Fails Focus on White Supremacy Bad .. 101
Whiteness Alt Fails AT: Olson Alt .............................. 103
Whiteness LatCrit ........................................................... 104
Whiteness LatCrit ........................................................... 106
Whiteness LatCrit ........................................................... 107
Whiteness LatCrit A2: Spillsover................................. 108
Whiteness LatCrit A2: Spillsover................................. 109
Whiteness LatCrit A2: Marginalizes Black History ..... 110
Whiteness LatCrit A2: Black Perspective Key............. 111

-1-

ADI 2011
Frappier-Russell

***Nietzsche Answers*** ........................... 112


Nietzsche Perm (1/3) ....................................................... 113
Nietzsche Perm (2/3) ....................................................... 114
Nietzsche Perm (2/3) ....................................................... 115
Nietzsche Perm Solvency ............................................. 116
Nietzsche Perm Solvency ............................................. 117
Nietzsche Link Turn Liberal Institutions...................... 118
Nietzsche Link Turn Liberal Institutions...................... 119
Nietzsche Link Turn Democracy.................................. 120
Nietzsche Link Turn Democracy.................................. 121
Nietzsche Link Turn Democracy.................................. 122
Nietzsche Link Turn Democracy.................................. 123
Nietzsche Impact Turn Genocide ................................. 124
Nietzsche Impact Turn Genocide ................................. 125
Nietzsche Impact Turn Violence .................................. 126
Nietzsche Impact Turn Rape ........................................ 127
Nietzsche A2: Suffering Link.......................................... 128
Nietzsche AT: Suffering Inevitable ................................. 129
Nietzsche AT: Suffering Inevitable ................................. 130
Nietzsche A2: Ressentiment............................................ 131
Nietzsche AT: Slave Morality (1/2) ................................ 132
Nietzsche AT: Slave Morality (2/2) ................................ 133
Nietzsche A2: Root Cause of Vio ................................... 134
Nietzsche A2: Root Cause of Vio ................................... 135

Nietzsche A2: Root Cause of Vio ............ 136


Nietzsche A2: Root Cause of Vio ................................... 137
Nietzsche Alternative No Solvency.............................. 138
Nietzsche Alternative No Solvency.............................. 139
Nietzsche Alternative No Solvency.............................. 140
Nietzsche Alternative No Solvency.............................. 141
Nietzsche Alternative No Solvency.............................. 142
Nietzsche Alternative No Solvency ER..................... 143
Nietzsche Alternative No Solvency ER..................... 144
Nietzsche Alternative Turn Otherness ....................... 145
Nietzsche Alternative Extinction Outweighs................ 146
Nietzsche Alternative Extinction Outweighs................ 147
Nietzsche A2: VTL ......................................................... 148

2/188
Agamben Answers

***Orientalism Answers*** .......................149


Orientalism Perm Solvency ............................................. 150
Orientalism Perm Solvency ............................................. 151
Orientalism Said Defense- Ontology .............................. 152
Orientalism Said Defense- Ontology .............................. 153
Orientalism Said Defense- Useless Theory ..................... 154
Orientalism Said Defense- Useless Theory ..................... 155
Orientalism Said Defense- Useless Theory ..................... 156
Orientalism Said Defense- Flawed Theory ..................... 157
Orientalism Said Defense- Out of Context ...................... 158
Orientalism Said Defense- Out of Context ...................... 159
Orientalism Said Defense- Out of Context ...................... 160
Orientalism Said Offense- Conclusions bad.................... 161
Orientalism Said Offense- Conclusions bad.................... 162
Orientalism Said Offense- Conclusions bad.................... 163
Orientalism Said Offense- Orientalist ............................. 164
Orientalism Said Offense- Orientalist ............................. 165
Orientalism Said Offense- Advocates Violence .............. 166
Orientalism Said Offense- Flawed Theory ...................... 167
Orientalism Said Offense- Flawed Theory ...................... 168

***Neoliberalism Answers*** ....................169


Neoliberalism Turn: Cap Good ....................................... 170
Neoliberalism Turn: Cap Good General....................... 171
Neoliberalism Turn: Cap Good Environment .............. 172
Neoliberalism Turn: Cap Good Food Production ......... 173
Neoliberalism Turn: Cap Good Space.......................... 174
Neoliberalism Turn: Cap Good Freedom ..................... 175
Neoliberalism Turn: Cap Good War ............................ 176
Neoliberalism AT: Inequality.......................................... 177
Neoliberalism AT: Value to Life..................................... 178
Neoliberalism Alt = Transition Wars .............................. 179
Neoliberalism Alt = Transition Wars .............................. 180
Neoliberalism Perm Solves ............................................. 181
Neoliberalism Perm Solves ............................................. 183
Neoliberalism Alt Fails Capitalism Inevitable ............. 184
Neoliberalism Alt Fails Capitalism Inevitable ............. 185
Neoliberalism Alt Fails Generic (And Cap Links) ....... 186
Neoliberalism Alt Fails Totalizing Bad ........................ 187
Neoliberalism Alt Fails Totalizing Bad ........................ 188

-2-

ADI 2011
Research Lab

1
SKFTA DA

SKFTA DA
SKFTA DA .................................................................................... 1
SKFTA 1NC .................................................................................. 2
SKFTA 1NC .................................................................................. 3
SKFTA 1NC .................................................................................. 4

***UQ SKFTA*** ..................................................... 5


Uniqueness SKFTA Will Pass Now ............................................ 6
UQ SKFTA Will Pass Now AT: TAA Prevents (1/2) .............. 7
UQ SKFTA Will Pass Now AT: TAA Prevents (1/2) .............. 8
Impact Uniqueness AT South Korea Wont Pass (1/2) ............ 9
Impact Uniqueness AT South Korea Wont Pass (2/2) .......... 10
Uniqueness TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (1/5) ............ 11
Uniqueness TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (2/5) ............ 12
Uniqueness TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (3/5) ............ 13
Uniqueness TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (4/5) ............ 14
Uniqueness TAA-FTA Compromise Likely Now (5/5) ............ 15

***Internal Links*** .................................................. 16


Political Capital Key to Trade Agreements (1/2) ......................... 17
Political Capital Key to Trade Agreements (2/2) ......................... 18
Internal Link Obama Political Capital Key to SKFTA.............. 19
Internal Link Obama Political Capital Key to SKFTA.............. 20
Internal Link GOP Coop Key to SKFTA .................................. 21
Internal Link Democrats Key to SKFTA .................................. 22
Political Capital Key to Agenda (1/4) .......................................... 23
Political Capital Key to Agenda (2/4) .......................................... 24
Political Capital Key to Agenda (3/4) .......................................... 25
Political Capital Key to Agenda (3/4) .......................................... 26
Political Capital Finite (1/2) ......................................................... 29
Political Capital Finite (2/2) ......................................................... 30
Internal Link Passage of TAA Key to FTAs ............................. 31

***South Korean Free Trade Agreement Good ...... 32


SKFTA Good Alliance Scenario ............................................... 33
SKFTA Good Alliance Scenario ............................................... 34
SKFTA Good Alliance Scenario Link Xts ............................. 35
Impact SKFTA Good Alliance Military Doesnt Solve ................. 35
Impact SKFTA Good Alliance AT SKFTA Not Key (1/2).......... 37
Impact SKFTA Good Alliance AT SKFTA Not Key (2/2).......... 38
Alliance Good Asia Stability Scenario (1/3) ............................. 39

Alliance Good Asia Stability Scenario (2/3) ............................. 40


Alliance Good Asia Stability Scenario (3/3) ............................. 41
Brink Asian Tensions High Now .............................................. 42
Korea War Impact Conflict Ensures Escalation ........................ 43
Impact Alliance Good AT Resiliency (1/2) ......................... 44
Impact Alliance Good AT Resiliency (2/2) ......................... 45
Impact Alliance Good Warming (1/2) .................................... 46
Impact Alliance Good Warming (2/2) .................................... 47
SKFTA Good Trade Policy ....................................................... 48
Trade Scenario - Japan ................................................................. 49
Trade Scenario - Japan ................................................................. 50
Trade Scenario - Doha.................................................................. 51
SKFTA Good AT Deregulation ............................................. 52
SKFTA Good AT Impact Turns ............................................. 53

***Aff*** ..................................................................... 54
Uniqueness & Internal Link Answer Political Capital Not Key to
Trade Agreements ........................................................................ 55
Impact Uniqueness Answer No TAA-FTA Compromise Now . 56
Uniqueness Wont Pass Now TAA (1/3)................................ 57
Uniqueness Wont Pass Now TAA (2/3)................................ 58
Uniqueness Wont Pass Now TAA (3/3)................................ 59
Uniqueness Wont Pass Now Political Stalling ...................... 60
Uniqueness Wont Pass Now Republican Boycott ................. 61
Economy Impact Uniqueness Answer.......................................... 62
Impact Uniqueness South Korea Wont Pass Now (1/2) ........... 63
Impact Uniqueness South Korea Wont Pass Now (2/2) ........... 64
Impact Answer No Conflict (1/2) .............................................. 65
Impact Answer No Conflict (2/2) .............................................. 66
Impact Answer AT SKFTA Key to Econ ............................... 67
Impact Answer AT SKFTA Key to Alliance ......................... 68
Impact Answer South Korea-US Alliance Resilient.................. 69
SKFTA Bad Economy (1/2) ...................................................... 70
SKFTA Bad Economy (2/2) ...................................................... 71
SKFTA Bad Financial Regulation Good ................................... 72
SKFTA Bad Financial Regulation Good ................................... 73
FTAs Bad Jobs .......................................................................... 74
FTAs Bad AT Trade Adjustment Assistance Checks ............. 75

Politics Link Core


Politics Link Core ...................................................................................................................................................... 1

*****NEGSTUFF***** ............................................................................................................... 2
Dem Assist Unpopular - Public ................................................................................................................................. 3
Foreign Aid Drains PC .............................................................................................................................................. 5
Dem AssistDrains PC ................................................................................................................................................ 6
USAID Drains PC ..................................................................................................................................................... 8
Dem Assist Partisan ................................................................................................................................................. 11
Spending: Dem Assist ............................................................................................................................................. 13
Spending: Generic ................................................................................................................................................... 15
State and Defense .................................................................................................................................................... 17
McCain Opposes...................................................................................................................................................... 18
Lugar Opposes ......................................................................................................................................................... 20
Saudi Lobby............................................................................................................................................................. 21
Israel Lobby ............................................................................................................................................................. 23
GOP Can Block Agenda .......................................................................................................................................... 26
Obama Gets Blame/Credit ....................................................................................................................................... 27
Public Popularity Internals ...................................................................................................................................... 29
Political Capital Internals ........................................................................................................................................ 31
PC Finite .................................................................................................................................................................. 37
AT: Winners Win .................................................................................................................................................... 38
***Country Links*** .............................................................................................................................................. 42
Egypt ....................................................................................................................................................................... 43
Tunisia ..................................................................................................................................................................... 44
Syria......................................................................................................................................................................... 45
Syria......................................................................................................................................................................... 46
Libya ........................................................................................................................................................................ 47
Bahrain .................................................................................................................................................................... 48
Yemen...................................................................................................................................................................... 49

***AFF STUFF*** ..................................................................................................................... 50


Dem Assist Popular - Public .................................................................................................................................... 51
Dem Assist Bipartisan ............................................................................................................................................. 53
Dem Assist Popular Think Tanks ............................................................................................................................ 56
Think Tanks Key ..................................................................................................................................................... 57
Winners Win Turn ................................................................................................................................................... 59
AT: Political Capital ................................................................................................................................................ 61
***Country Links*** .............................................................................................................................................. 65
Egypt ....................................................................................................................................................................... 66
Libya ........................................................................................................................................................................ 67
Syria......................................................................................................................................................................... 68
Tunisia ..................................................................................................................................................................... 69
Yemen...................................................................................................................................................................... 71
***AT: Internal Links*** ....................................................................................................................................... 74
AT: McCain Key ..................................................................................................................................................... 75
AT: DoD Key .......................................................................................................................................................... 76
AT: Public k2 agenda .............................................................................................................................................. 77
AT: Think Tanks Key Lack of Influence.............................................................................................................. 78
AT: Obama Gets the Blame ..................................................................................................................................... 79
AT: GOP hates the plan ........................................................................................................................................... 80
AT: Budget Fights ................................................................................................................................................... 81
AT: Popularity k2 Pocap ......................................................................................................................................... 82
AT: Saudi Key ......................................................................................................................................................... 83
AT: Israeli Lobby Key ............................................................................................................................................. 84

ADI 2011
Research Lab

1
IMET Aff

IMET AFF
IMET AFF ................................................................... 1
Inherency 1AC ............................................................. 3
Democracy Advantage 1AC ..................................... 4
Democracy Advantage 1AC ..................................... 5
Democracy Advantage 1AC ..................................... 6
Democracy Advantage 1AC ..................................... 7
Democracy Advantage 1AC ..................................... 8
Democracy Advantage 1AC ..................................... 9
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 10
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 11
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 12
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 13
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 14
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 15
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 17
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 18
CMR Advantage 1AC ............................................. 19
1AC Solvency 1/2 ...................................................... 20
1AC Solvency 2/2 ...................................................... 21
***Inherency*** ....................................................... 22
IMET Cuts Now 1/2................................................... 22
Top Officials are Soviet Trained 1/3.......................... 24
Top Officials are Soviet Trained 2/3.......................... 25
Top Officials are Soviet Trained 3/3.......................... 26
Top Officials Block Transition 1/2 ............................ 27
Top Officials Block Transition 2/2 ............................ 28
***CMR Advantage*** ............................................ 29
CMR Low Now ......................................................... 29
CMR Low Now ......................................................... 31
CMR Low Now ......................................................... 32
CMR Low Now ......................................................... 33
CMR Low Now ......................................................... 34
CMR Spills Over ....................................................... 35
CMR Spills Over ....................................................... 36
CMR Spills Over ....................................................... 37
A2: CMR Fails No Public Support ......................... 38
Solvency IMET Solves CMR ................................. 39
Solvency IMET Solves CMR ................................. 40
Solvency IMET Solves CMR ................................. 41
Solvency IMET Solves CMR ................................. 42
Pakistan CMR Low Now ........................................ 43
Pakistan A2: CMR in Pakistan cyclical .................. 44
Pakistan A2: IMET training spillover wont help
Pakistani CMR ........................................................... 45
Impact Egyptian Stability........................................ 46
Impact Egyptian Stability........................................ 47
Impact Democratic Transition 1/3 .......................... 48
Impact Democratic Transition 2/3 .......................... 49
Impact Democratic Transition 3/3 .......................... 50
Impact Democratic Transition EXT ........................ 51
Impact Democratic Transition EXT ........................ 52
Impact Democratic Transition EXT ........................ 53
Impact Middle East Stability 1/2 ............................ 54
Impact Middle East Stability 2/2 ............................ 55
Impact Middle East Stability EXT .......................... 56

Impact Middle East Stability EXT .......................... 57


Impact Middle East Stability EXT .......................... 58
Impact Terrorism EXT ............................................ 64
***Elections Advantage*** ....................................... 67
Uq. Military Screws up Elections Now ................... 67
Uq. Military Screws up Elections Now ................... 68
Uq. Military Screws up Elections Now ................... 69
Uq. Egyptian Democracy on the Brink 1/2.............. 70
Uq. Egyptian Democracy on the Brink 1/2.............. 71
Uq. Egyptian Democracy on the Brink 1/2.............. 72
Uq. Egyptian Democracy on the Brink 2/2.............. 73
Military K2 Transition ................................................ 74
Solvency Stabilizes Egypt ....................................... 75
Solvency Stabilizes Egypt ....................................... 76
Solvency Stabilizes Egypt ....................................... 77
Solvency Stabilizes Egypt ....................................... 78
Solvency Stabilizes Egypt ....................................... 79
Solvency A2: Dem Fails Islamic Beliefs .............. 80
Solvency A2: Dem Fails No Public Support ........ 81
Impact Regional Stability/Oil .................................. 82
Democracy Spills Over............................................... 83
Democracy Spills Over............................................... 84
Democracy Spills Over............................................... 85
Democracy Spills Over............................................... 86
AT: Saudi DA ............................................................. 87
Democracy Spills Over............................................... 88
Democracy Spills Over............................................... 89
Egypt Modeling/Spillover .......................................... 90
Egypt Modeling/Spillover .......................................... 91
Impact Terrorism 1/2 ............................................... 92
Impact Terrorism 2/2 ............................................... 93
Impact Terrorism EXT ............................................ 94
Impact A2: Dem Bad Israeli Conflict ................... 95
Impact A2: Dem Bad Muslim Brotherhood Gets
Elected ........................................................................ 96
Egyptian Economy Uq. ........................................... 97
Dem Solves Egyptian Economy EXT ........................ 98
Dem Solves Egyptian Economy EXT ........................ 99
Dem Solves Egyptian Economy EXT ...................... 100
Dem Solves Egyptian Economy EXT ...................... 101
Egyptian Economy Economy Impact EXT ........... 102
Egyptian Economy Food Wars Impact 1/2 ............ 103
Egyptian Economy Food Wars Impact 2/2 ............ 104
Egyptian Economy Regional Stability Impact....... 105
Egyptian Economy Terrorism/Muslim Brotherhood
Impact 1/2 ................................................................. 106
Egyptian Economy Terrorism/Muslim Brotherhood
Impact 2/2 ................................................................. 107
Egyptian Economy Terrorism Impact EXT ........... 108
***Solvency*** ....................................................... 109
Solvency IMET Solves CMR ................................ 109
Solvency Egyptian IMET Effective....................... 110
Solvency IMET Expansion Necessary EXT.......... 111
Solvency Cuts Bad ................................................ 112
Solvency A2: No Civilian Training ....................... 113

ADI 2011
Research Lab
Solvency A2: Squo Training Solves .....................114
Solvency In-Country Training Key........................115
Solvency IMET Teaches Democratic Values ........116
Solvency IMET Teaches Democratic Values ........117
Solvency IMET Teaches Democratic Values ........118
Solvency IMET Teaches Democratic Values ........119
Solvency IMET Teaches Democratic Values ........120
Solvency IMET Teaches Democratic Values ........121
Solvency IMET Teaches Democratic Values ........122
Solvency IMET Teaches Democratic Values ........123
CAFD MET Solvency...............................................132
IMET Spills Over 1/2................................................133
IMET Spills Over 2/2................................................134
***Add-Ons*** ........................................................135
U.S.-Egypt Relations Add-On 1/2 ............................135
U.S.-Egypt Relations Add-On 2/2 ............................136
U.S.-Egypt Relations EXT ........................................137
Readiness Add-On 1/2 ..............................................138
Readiness Add-On 2/2 ..............................................139
Middle East Stability Add-On 1/2 ............................140
Middle East Stability Add-On 2/2 ............................141
Naval Power Add-On ................................................142
Terrorism Add-On 1/2 ..............................................143
Terrorism Add-On 2/2 ..............................................144
Terrorism Add-On EXT ............................................145
***A2: Politics DA*** .............................................146
A2: Politics Popularity L/T ....................................146
A2: Politics Bipart L/T...........................................147
A2: Politics Republicans L/T .................................148
A2: Politics Israel/Defense Lobbies L/T ................149
A2: Politics Defense Lobby L/T EXT ...................150
A2: Politics Israel Lobby Supports the Plan EXT..151
A2: Politics Israel Lobby k2 Agenda EXT ............152
***A2: Iran DA*** ..................................................153
A2: Iran DA No Internal Link................................153
A2: Iran DA Internal Link Turn- Brotherhood ......154

2
IMET Aff
A2: Iran DA Internal Link Turn- Brotherhood ...... 155
***A2: Saudi DA*** ............................................... 156
AT: Saudi DA Egyptian Stability Solves .............. 156
AT: Saudi DA No Prolif ........................................ 157
AT: Saudi DA No Prolif ........................................ 158
*** A2: Spending DA*** ........................................ 159
A2 Spending DA Cuts Coming Now..................... 159
A2 Spending DA Link Turn .................................. 160
***A2: Israel DA*** ............................................... 161
No Link Israel Fine With Military Aid .................. 161
***A2: Arab Spring DA*** ..................................... 162
A2: EU CP US Military Best for CMR ................. 164
A2: EU CP US Military Best for CMR ................. 165
A2: EU SolvencyEU Ineffective CMR................. 166
A2: EU CP Perm ................................................... 167
A2: EU CP Perm EXT ........................................... 168
***A2: Conditions CPs*** ...................................... 169
Political Conditionality Fails ................................. 169
A2: Economic Reforms ............................................ 170
***K Answers*** .................................................... 171
Generic K Offense Solves Military Bad Links .. 171
***T Answers***..................................................... 172
No Consensus on DA ............................................... 172
A2: Only USAID = DA ............................................ 173
AT: USAID Only ..................................................... 174
AT: USAID Only ..................................................... 175
AT: IMET DA ....................................................... 176
AT: IMET DA ....................................................... 177
AT: IMET DA ....................................................... 178
AT: IMET = Extra-T ................................................ 179
IMET = DA Good Governance Reform ................ 180
IMET = DA GJD ................................................... 181
CMR = DA ............................................................... 182

ADI 2011
Frappier Russell

1
IMET Neg

Egypt IMET Neg


Egypt IMET Neg ............... Error! Bookmark not defined.
***Neg IMET Inherency .................................................. 2
IMET funding high now (1/8).............................................. 2
IMET funding high now (2/8).............................................. 3
IMET funding high now (3/8).............................................. 4
IMET funding high now (4/8).............................................. 5
IMET funding high now (5/8).............................................. 6
IMET funding high now (6/8).............................................. 7
IMET funding high now (7/8).............................................. 8
IMET funding high now (8/8).............................................. 9
***Neg CMR Advantage ................................................ 10
Egypt CMR Prevents Regional CMR ................................ 10
CMR Bad (1/2) .................................................................. 10
CMR Bad (2/2) .................................................................. 13
*Solvency Take-outs.......................................................... 14
CMR doesnt solve terrorism (1/3) .................................... 14
CMR doesnt solve terrorism (2/3) .................................... 15
CMR doesnt solve terrorism (3/3) .................................... 16
CMR increasing/high now (1/2) ........................................ 17
CMR increasing/high now (2/2) ........................................ 18
U.S. influence high now..................................................... 19
CMR cant solve Conflict too great ................................ 20
CMR stopped by military (1/5) .......................................... 21
CMR stopped by military (2/5) .......................................... 23
CMR stopped by military (3/5) .......................................... 24
CMR stopped by military (4/5) .......................................... 25
CMR stopped by military (5/5) .......................................... 26
***Neg Stability Advantage ........................................... 27
Regional Stability Increasing/Stable Now ......................... 27
Plan Hurts Stability ............................................................ 27
Democracy Will Succeed Now (1/3) ................................. 28
Democracy Will Succeed Now (2/3) ................................. 30
Democracy Will Succeed Now (3/3) ................................. 31

Plan Causes Democracy to Fail ......................................... 32


Egypt Democracy Bad....................................................... 32
NATO ................................................................................ 33
Solvency Take-outs ........................................................... 34
***Neg IMET Solvency ................................................. 35
Military focus guts solvency ............................................. 35
Egypt Reject Aid/Aid Fails ............................................... 36
IMET cant solve - timeframe ........................................... 37
Econ decline tanks solvency.............................................. 39
Egyptian military kills transition (1/4) .............................. 40
Egyptian military kills transition (2/4) .............................. 41
Egyptian military kills transition (3/4) .............................. 42
Egyptian military kills transition (4/4) .............................. 43
***Links to DAs ............................................................... 44
Spending ............................................................................ 44
Politics ............................................................................... 45
***EU CP.......................................................................... 46
EU CP Shell ................................................................... 46
EU CP Solvency ............................................................. 47
***NED CP ....................................................................... 48
NED CP Shell (1/2) ........................................................ 48
NED CP Shell (2/2) ........................................................ 49
NED CP Solvency .......................................................... 50
***Topicality .................................................................... 51
Topicality 1/6 .................................................................... 51
Topicality 2/6 .................................................................... 52
Topicality 3/6 .................................................................... 53
Topicality 4/6 .................................................................... 54
Topicality 5/6 .................................................................... 55

ADI 2011
Research Lab

1
IMET Aff

IMET Aff Supplement


IMET Aff Supplement ............................................................................................................................................... 1
T A2: Extra-T E-IMET is Limited ....................................................................................................................... 2
T A2: Extra-T E-IMET is Limited Defense of the Plan.................................................................................... 3
T A2: Security Assistance ...................................................................................................................................... 4
A2: Spending/Politics ................................................................................................................................................ 5
Politics Plan Popular E-IMET ............................................................................................................................. 6

ADI 2011
Research Lab

1
IMET T Supplement

IMET Aff T Supplement


IMET T Supplement ............................................................ 1
T Military Training = DA ................................................. 2
T Military Training = DA ................................................. 3
T Security Assistance Exclusion Overlimits ..................... 4

T DoD = DA..................................................................... 5
T A2: Demo Promo =/= DA ............................................. 6

ADI 2011
Roark

1
AID T/O Disad

Aid Tradeoff DA
1NC Tradeoff DA ...................................................................................................................................................... 2
1NC Tradeoff DA ...................................................................................................................................................... 3
1NC Tradeoff DA ...................................................................................................................................................... 4
UQ ............................................................................................................................................................................. 5
Link/Impact ............................................................................................................................................................... 6
Link Wall ................................................................................................................................................................... 7
Link Wall ................................................................................................................................................................... 8
Link Wall ................................................................................................................................................................... 9
I/L: Zero-Sum .......................................................................................................................................................... 10
A2 Plan = New Funding/No Tradeoff ..................................................................................................................... 11
MPX: Turns Case .................................................................................................................................................... 12
MPX: Terror = Retal................................................................................................................................................ 13
MPX: Terror = Extinction ....................................................................................................................................... 14
MPX: Foreign Exchange/Soft Power ...................................................................................................................... 15
AFF N/U ............................................................................................................................................................... 16
AFF Readiness D .................................................................................................................................................. 17
AFF Readiness D .................................................................................................................................................. 18
AFF Soft Power D ................................................................................................................................................ 19
AFF Terror D ........................................................................................................................................................ 20
AFF Terror D ........................................................................................................................................................ 21
AFF Terror =/= Retal ............................................................................................................................................ 22

ASU 2011
Fellows

1
Bahrain Aff

Bahrain Aff
Bahrain Aff ................................................................................................. 1
1AC ............................................................................................................. 3
Inherency No US Pressure Now ............................................................. 20
Inherency Unconditioned Military Aid Now ........................................... 22
Inherency Assistance Disorganized Now ................................................ 23
Inherency Bahrain not a Priority Now.................................................... 24
Inherency Dictatorship Now .................................................................. 25
Inherency Security Crackdown Will Fail Now ........................................ 26
Inherency - Iran Backing Protesters Now .................................................. 27
Inherency Fleet Out Now ........................................................................ 28
Adv 5th Fleet/Iran .................................................................................. 30
Adv 5th Fleet/Iran - Hormuz Impact ...................................................... 33
Bases Key to Contain Iran ......................................................................... 34
ADV 5th Fleet/ Terrorism and Hormuz ................................................... 37
Adv 5th Fleet/Oil ..................................................................................... 38
ADV 5th/Pirates ...................................................................................... 39
Bases Good - Key to US Strategy ................................................................ 40
Basing Good- Hegemony ........................................................................... 41
Basing Good- Extended Deterrence ........................................................... 42
Basing Good- A2: Echelon Rearward ......................................................... 43
Adv Regional Econ Growth........................................................................ 44
Must Address Shia Grievances .................................................................. 45
Shia Want Democracy ............................................................................... 46
Should Encourage Bahrains Military to Respect HR ................................. 47
US Credibility ........................................................................................... 48
AT Iraq Undermines US Credibility ........................................................... 49
Solvency - Intervention ............................................................................. 50
Solvency Addressing Greivences ............................................................ 51
Diplomatic Pressure Solvency ................................................................... 52
Solvency US Key ..................................................................................... 55
Bahrain Key .............................................................................................. 57
AT Saudi DA .............................................................................................. 58

ASU 2011
Fellows

2
Bahrain Aff

AT T Democracy Assistance....................................................................... 60
Neg ........................................................................................................... 61
Inherency - No Shiite Takeover ................................................................. 62
Inherency Bahrain Reforming Now........................................................ 63
No Solvency Too Late ............................................................................. 64
No Solvency U.S. Cant Do Anything ....................................................... 65
No Solvency U.S. Action Bad .................................................................. 66
No Solvency Alt Causes .......................................................................... 67
No 5th Fleet Kick Out ................................................................................. 68
Alts to Bahrain Solve ................................................................................. 69
We Will Shift..............................................................................................71
Islamism Turn .......................................................................................... 72
Basing Bad-A2: Heg .................................................................................. 73
Basing Bad- Oil Dependence ..................................................................... 74
Basing Bad- Terrorism .............................................................................. 75
Iran War Scenario .................................................................................... 76
Iran Defense ............................................................................................. 79
AT Oil Shocks ........................................................................................... 81
AT Strait of Hormuz .................................................................................. 83
AT Mideast War ........................................................................................ 84
Pirate Defense .......................................................................................... 87
Turn Pirates Attack the Navy..................................................................... 90
PTX: Plan Unpopular ................................................................................ 91
Saudi DA Link ........................................................................................... 92
Saudi DA Link Magnifier ........................................................................... 97
T Democracy Assistance ............................................................................ 98

ASU 2011
Fellows

1
Bahrain Neg

Bahrain Neg
Bahrain Neg ....................................................................................... 1
Inherency - No Shiite Takeover .......................................................... 3
Inherency Bahrain Reforming Now................................................. 4
No Solvency Too Late ...................................................................... 5
No Solvency U.S. Cant Do Anything ................................................ 6
No Solvency U.S. Action Bad ........................................................... 7
No Solvency Alt Causes ................................................................... 8
No 5th Fleet Kick Out .......................................................................... 9
Alts to Bahrain Solve ........................................................................ 10
Alts to Bahrain Solve ......................................................................... 11
We Will Shift.................................................................................... 12
Islamism Turn ................................................................................. 13
Basing Bad-A2: Heg ......................................................................... 14
Basing Bad- Oil Dependence ............................................................ 15
Basing Bad- Terrorism ..................................................................... 16
Iran War Scenario ........................................................................... 17
Iran War Scenario ........................................................................... 17
Iran War Scenario ........................................................................... 18
Iran Defense .................................................................................... 20
Iran Defense .................................................................................... 21
AT Oil Shocks 1/2 ............................................................................. 22
AT Oil Shocks 2/2 ............................................................................. 23
AT Strait of Hormuz ......................................................................... 24
AT Mideast War ............................................................................... 25
AT Mideast War ............................................................................... 26
AT Mideast War ............................................................................... 27
Pirate Defense ................................................................................. 28
Pirate Defense ................................................................................. 29
Pirate Defense ................................................................................. 30
Turn Pirates Attack the Navy............................................................ 31
PTX: Plan Unpopular ....................................................................... 32
Saudi DA Link .................................................................................. 33

ASU 2011
Fellows

2
Bahrain Neg

Saudi DA Link .................................................................................. 34


Saudi DA Link .................................................................................. 35
Saudi DA Link .................................................................................. 36
Saudi DA Link .................................................................................. 37
Saudi DA Link Magnifier .................................................................. 38
T Democracy Assistance ................................................................... 39

ADI2011
Rumbaugh

1
MilitaryInterventionCP

Military Intervention CP
LibyaInterventionCP
Libya Intervention CP 1NC ........................................................................................................................................ 3
Libya Intervention CP 1NC ........................................................................................................................................ 5
Libya Intervention Good- Heg ................................................................................................................................... 6
Libya Intervention Good- Terrorism ......................................................................................................................... 7
Libya Intervention Good- Stability ............................................................................................................................ 8
Libya Intervention Good- Oil Shocks ........................................................................................................................ 9
Libya Intervention Good- Oil Shocks ...................................................................................................................... 10
Libya Intervention Good- Smooth Transition ........................................................................................................ 11
Libya Intervention Good- Signal Key ...................................................................................................................... 12
Libya Intervention Good- A2: We Did That ........................................................................................................... 13
Libya Intervention Good- A2: Gaddafi Steps Down .............................................................................................. 14
Libya Intervention Good- A2: Rebels Enough ........................................................................................................ 15
Libya Intervention Good- A2: AU Relations........................................................................................................... 16
Libya Intervention Bad- AU Relations .................................................................................................................... 17
Libya Intervention Bad- AU Relations .................................................................................................................... 18
Libya Intervention Bad- Middle East Democracy .................................................................................................. 19
Libya Intervention Bad- A2: Hegemony ................................................................................................................. 20
Libya Intervention Bad- A2: Terrorism .................................................................................................................. 21
Libya Intervention Bad- A2: Oil Shocks ................................................................................................................. 22
Libya Intervention Bad- Ineffective ......................................................................................................................... 23
Libya Intervention Bad- Links to Politics ............................................................................................................... 24

ADI2011
Rumbaugh

2
MilitaryInterventionCP

SyriaInterventionCP
Syria Intervention CP 1NC ....................................................................................................................................... 25
Syria Intervention CP 1NC ....................................................................................................................................... 26
Syria Intervention Good- Stability ........................................................................................................................... 27
Syria Intervention Good- Heg .................................................................................................................................. 28
Syria Intervention Good- Mil Intervention Key ..................................................................................................... 29
Syria Intervention Good- Assad Has to Go ............................................................................................................. 30
Syria Intervention Good- Successful ........................................................................................................................ 31
Syria Intervention Good- A2: NATO....................................................................................................................... 32
Syria Intervention Good- A2: Turkey ..................................................................................................................... 33
Syria Intervention Good- A2: Syria- Israel ............................................................................................................. 34
Syria Intervention Good- A2: CBW......................................................................................................................... 35
Syria Intervention Good- Politics NB ...................................................................................................................... 36
Syria Intervention Bad- Middle East War .............................................................................................................. 37
Syria Intervention Bad- Middle East War Extn ..................................................................................................... 38
Syria Intervention Bad- NATO Relations ............................................................................................................... 39
Syria Intervention Bad- Instability .......................................................................................................................... 40
Syria Intervention Bad- Turkey Relations .............................................................................................................. 41
Syria Intervention Bad- Syria-Israel War ............................................................................................................... 43
Syria Intervention Bad- Syria-Israel War ............................................................................................................... 44
Syria Intervention Bad- CBW .................................................................................................................................. 45
Syria Intervention Bad- CBW .................................................................................................................................. 46
Syria Intervention Bad- Doesnt Solve..................................................................................................................... 47
Syria Intervention Bad- Fails ................................................................................................................................... 48
Syria Intervention Bad- Links to Politics ................................................................................................................ 49
Intervention Bad Generic- Democracy .................................................................................................................... 50
Intervention Bad- No Stable Transition .................................................................................................................. 51

ADI 2011
Fellows

1
Internet Aff

Internet Aff
Internet Aff............................................................................................................................. 1
1AC Internet Adv.................................................................................................................... 2
1AC Internet Adv.................................................................................................................... 3
1AC Internet Adv.................................................................................................................... 4
1AC Internet Adv.................................................................................................................... 5
1AC Internet Adv.................................................................................................................... 7
1AC Internet Adv.................................................................................................................... 9
1AC Internet Adv...................................................................................................................11
1AC US key Adv .................................................................................................................... 13
***Uniqueness*** ................................................................................................................ 18
Inherency Syria Failing Now ............................................................................................ 19
Inherency No Internet Access ......................................................................................... 20
Inherency Assad Regime Unsustainable ......................................................................... 21
Inherency US Policy Fails ................................................................................................23
Inherency AT: Sanctions Solve ........................................................................................26
Inherency AT: Sanctions Solve ....................................................................................... 28
***Internet Advantage*** .................................................................................................. 30
Internet key to Sopo ............................................................................................................ 31
Sopo Solve Laundry List ......................................................................................................33
Sopo Solve Hegemony .........................................................................................................34
Sopo Solve Terrorism ..........................................................................................................36
Nuke Terror O/W ................................................................................................................ 37
Internet key to Human Rights Leadership ........................................................................ 38
Human Rights Impacts........................................................................................................39
Internet key to Demo ........................................................................................................... 41
Plan Spurs Global Action .....................................................................................................45
***Syria Advantage***.........................................................................................................47
now key ............................................................................................................................... 48
Syria = Lynchpin ..................................................................................................................49
US Action Solves ME Prolif ................................................................................................. 51
us action solves me stability ................................................................................................53
Syrian Instability Impacts ...................................................................................................56
ME War ................................................................................................................................ 57
***Cyber-Feminism Add-On***..........................................................................................58
Cyberfeminism Add-On....................................................................................................... 59
Cyberfeminism Good Arab World Specific...................................................................... 61
Cyberfeminism Good Key to Destroying Patriarchy .......................................................62
Cyberfeminism Good Female Empowerment .................................................................63
Cyberfeminism Good Empowering.................................................................................64
Cyberfeminism Good Fluid Subjectivity .......................................................................... 65
Cyberfeminism Good AT: Cap/Whiteness Bad ...............................................................66
***Solvency*** ..................................................................................................................... 67
Tech Exists Now .................................................................................................................. 68
Solvency Social Media Revolution Egypt proves .....................................................70
Solvency Grassroots Movements ..................................................................................... 71
Solvency Comm. Tech Key to Protests Organization ................................................... 73
Solvency Internet k2 Civil Society k2 Democracy ........................................................... 74
Solvency Conservative Dilemma k2 Civil Society ........................................................... 76
A2: Slacktivism/Gladwell .................................................................................................... 77
A2: Theyll Shut Down the Communications Grid ............................................................. 78

ADI 2011
Fellows

1
Internet Neg

Internet Neg
Internet Neg ........................................................................................................................... 1
AT: Inherency Current Internet Efforts Solve ................................................................... 2
AT: Inherency Current Syrian Policy Solve ....................................................................... 3
Syrian Democracy Impossible ............................................................................................... 4
Internet in a Suitcase Fails .................................................................................................... 6
Internet in a Suitcase Bad Breeds Anti-Americanism ...................................................... 7
AT: Soft Power Unsustainable ...........................................................................................8
AT: Soft Power Unworkable ............................................................................................... 9
AT: Soft Power States Not Susceptible ............................................................................ 10
AT: Soft Power Key to Heg Cannot Maintain ...................................................................11
AT: Soft Power Useless w/o Hard Power ........................................................................ 12
AT: Soft Power Doesnt Solve Too Weak ...................................................................... 13
AT: Soft Power Solves War Deterrence Key .................................................................... 14
AT: Middle East War No War .......................................................................................... 15
AT: Middle East War No War .......................................................................................... 16
AT: Middle East War No War .......................................................................................... 17
AT: Middle East War No US Drag-in............................................................................... 18
AT: Iran Prolif ...................................................................................................................... 19
Solvency US Action Fails .................................................................................................. 21
Solvency Intl Action Key .................................................................................................22
Solvency No Tech Base/Globalization .............................................................................24
Solvency Internet in a Box Deliveries Check ................................................................ 25
Solvency Internet Censorship ..........................................................................................26
Solvency Internet as Statecraft ........................................................................................ 27
Solvency Alt Cause........................................................................................................... 28
Solvency Soc. Networking =/= Rev .................................................................................29
Adv. CP Release Political Prisoners ................................................................................ 30
Neolib Link Communication Technology ........................................................................ 31
Neolib Link Local Assistance ...........................................................................................32
Neolib Link Media Assistance .......................................................................................... 33
Neolib Link Imperialism Internal link ............................................................................34
AT: Cyberfeminism Western Values ................................................................................ 35
AT: Cyberfeminism Race K ..............................................................................................36

ADI 2011
Fellows -- Sydnor

1
Islamic Feminism K

Islamic Feminism K Index


Islamic Feminism K Index ............................................................................................... 1
1NC ..................................................................................................................................... 3
**Links** ........................................................................................................................... 7
Democracy Assistance Link ............................................................................................. 8
Democracy Assistance Link ............................................................................................. 9
Feminism Link ................................................................................................................ 10
Freedom Link .................................................................................................................. 11
Secular-Liberalism Link ................................................................................................ 12
Secular-Liberalism Link ................................................................................................ 13
Violence Against Women Link ...................................................................................... 14
**Impacts** ..................................................................................................................... 15
Colonization ..................................................................................................................... 16
Violence (AT: Perm Blueprinting) ............................................................................. 17
**Alternative** ............................................................................................................... 18
Alternative Solves............................................................................................................ 19
**Answers to Aff Answers** ......................................................................................... 20
AT: Arab Spring States Arent Secular ........................................................................ 21
AT: Ethics ........................................................................................................................ 22
AT: Feminism .................................................................................................................. 24
AT: Perm Add Women and Stir ................................................................................. 25
AT: Perm Foreclosure DA .......................................................................................... 26
AT: Perm K First ......................................................................................................... 27
AT: Politics Good / Framework..................................................................................... 29
AT: Politics Good / Framework..................................................................................... 30
AT: Politics Good / Framework..................................................................................... 31
AT: Resignification Good ............................................................................................... 32
AT: Theyre Shaped By Patriarchy .............................................................................. 33
AT: Youre Orientalist ................................................................................................... 34
AT: Youre Sexist ............................................................................................................ 35

ADI 2011
Fellows -- Sydnor

2
Islamic Feminism K

**Aff Answers** ......................................................................................... 36


Agency Focus Bad ........................................................................................................... 37
Culturalism Bad .............................................................................................................. 38
Culturalism Bad .............................................................................................................. 39
Perm Solvency Act and Rethink ................................................................................. 40
Perm SolvencyRethink and Act ................................................................................. 41
Perm Solvency AT: Perm Indicts ............................................................................... 42
State Good........................................................................................................................ 43
Orientalism Turn ............................................................................................................ 44

ADI 2011
Fellows -- Roark

1
Heg Good/Bad

Hegemony & Leadership Toolbox


...........................................................................................................................................
===UQ=== ...................................................................................................................... 3
Heg Up Unipolarity ...................................................................................................... 4
Heg Up Military............................................................................................................ 5
Heg Up Military............................................................................................................ 6
A2: China Rising ............................................................................................................. 7
A2: Overstretch................................................................................................................ 8
A2: China Counterbalances ............................................................................................. 9
Heg Down ME .............................................................................................................. 9
Heg Down Asia Rising ............................................................................................... 11
Heg Down China Rising ............................................................................................. 12
Heg Down China Rising ............................................................................................. 13
Heg Down Economy .................................................................................................. 14
Heg Down No US Pursuit .......................................................................................... 15
Heg Down - Iraq ............................................................................................................ 16
A2: Peaceful China ........................................................................................................ 17
Soft Power Down........................................................................................................... 18
===Links===................................................................................................................. 19
Iran Containment Key to Heg ........................................................................................ 20
Demo Assist Key to Heg ............................................................................................... 21
Demo Assist Key to Heg ............................................................................................... 22
Demo Assist Key to Heg ............................................................................................... 23
Demo Promo Key to Heg .............................................................................................. 24
Demo Promo X Heg ...................................................................................................... 25
Demo Assist X Heg ....................................................................................................... 25
Demo Assist X Heg ....................................................................................................... 27
===Heg Good=== ......................................................................................................... 28
Heg Sustainable ............................................................................................................. 29
Heg Good Thayer ....................................................................................................... 30
Heg Good Ferguson .................................................................................................... 30
Heg Good Kagan Giant .............................................................................................. 32
Heg Good Calculus..................................................................................................... 35
Heg Good Economy ................................................................................................... 36
Heg Good Prolif ......................................................................................................... 40
Heg Good - Terrorism ................................................................................................... 42
===Heg Bad/Defense=== ............................................................................................. 45
Heg Bad China............................................................................................................ 50
Heg Bad Terrorism ..................................................................................................... 54
Heg Bad War .............................................................................................................. 55
Heg Bad War EXTN................................................................................................... 56
Obama Power Bad Economy ...................................................................................... 57
Obama Power Bad Conflict ........................................................................................ 57
Obama Power Fails ........................................................................................................ 59
Obama Power Fails ........................................................................................................ 60
A2 Heg Solves War .................................................................................................... 61
A2 Heg Solves Transition Wars ................................................................................. 62

ADI 2011
Fellows -- Roark

2
Heg Good/Bad

A2 ME Hegemony ...................................................................................................... 63
A2 ME Hegemony ...................................................................................................... 64
A2 ME Hegemony ...................................................................................................... 65
A2 Soft Power ............................................................................................................ 66
A2 Soft Power ............................................................................................................ 67
A2 Soft Power ............................................................................................................ 68
A2 Soft Power ............................................................................................................ 69
A2 Soft Power ............................................................................................................ 70
A2 Soft Power HP OW ............................................................................................ 71
A2 Soft Power X Key Heg ...................................................................................... 72

ADI 2011
Fellows -- Woodruff

1
Human Rights Credibility Good/Bad

HR Cred Good/Bad
****HR CRED BAD**** ............................................................................................................. 2
HR Cred Bad Uniqueness HR Cred Low ............................................................................. 3
HR Cred Bad Link Generic ................................................................................................... 4
HR Cred Bad Link Bahrain 1/2............................................................................................. 5
HR Cred Bad Link Bahrain 2/2............................................................................................. 6
HR Cred Bad Internal Link Credibility Leads to Pressure................................................ 7
HR Cred Bad Impact Human Rights .................................................................................... 8
HR Cred Bad Impact US- Kazakhstan Relations ................................................................ 9
HR Cred Bad Impact US- Russian Relations ..................................................................... 12
****HR CRED GOOD**** ....................................................................................................... 24
HR Cred Good Link Answer .................................................................................................. 25
HR Cred Good Impact Soft Power...................................................................................... 26
HR Cred Good Impact US-China Relations ...................................................................... 28
HR Cred Good Impact Heg ................................................................................................. 31
HR Cred Good Impact US-EU Relations ........................................................................... 32
HR Cred Good Impact Laundry List.................................................................................. 34
HR Cred Good Impact North Korea .................................................................................. 36
****IMPACT ANSWERS****.................................................................................................. 38
Impact Answers US-Kazakhstan Relations ........................................................................... 39
Impact Answers Democracy ................................................................................................... 40
Impact Answers Russia War................................................................................................... 41
Impact Answers Russia Relations .......................................................................................... 42
Impact Answers North Korea ................................................................................................. 43

ADI 2011
Masterson

1
Islam Reps K

Islam Reps K
Islam Reps K ...................................................................................... 1
1NC Islamic threat version .............................................................. 3
1NC .................................................................................................... 4
1NCCivil Society Assistance version................................................. 5
1NC Both versions ........................................................................... 6
1NC .................................................................................................... 6
Link Islamic Violence Reps ................................................................ 8
Islamic Terrorism Reps Link.............................................................. 9
Islamic Terrorism Reps Link............................................................ 10
Link Islam as a Threat to Democracy ................................................ 11
Link Jihad Reps ............................................................................... 12
Link Negative Portrayals of Islam .................................................... 13
Link Homogenization of Muslims .................................................... 14
Link Islam Political or Economic Impacts ........................................ 15
Link The Veil .................................................................................... 16
Link Fundamentalism ...................................................................... 17
Link Evil .......................................................................................... 18
Link Using Art to Represent Muslims ............................................... 19
Link Extension Civil Society Assistance & Womens Empowerment20
Link Extension Civil Society Assistance.......................................... 21
IL to Whiteness ................................................................................ 22
Intervention Impact ......................................................................... 23
K Turns Case .................................................................................... 24
Alt Solves ......................................................................................... 25
Framing First ................................................................................... 26
Framing First ................................................................................... 26
Discourse First................................................................................. 28
AT Experts ....................................................................................... 29
AT Experts ....................................................................................... 29
AT Consequentialism ....................................................................... 31

ADI 2011
Masterson

2
Islam Reps K

AT Realism ...................................................................................... 32
AT Perm ........................................................................................... 34
AFF .................................................................................................. 35
Perm -- Aff advocacy subverts orientalism ....................................... 37
Epistemology Focus Bad .................................................................. 38
Epistemology Focus Bad .................................................................. 39
Discourse Focus Bad ........................................................................40
Policy First ....................................................................................... 41
Policy First ....................................................................................... 42
Consequentialism Good ................................................................... 43
Islam Threat Rhetoric Good ............................................................. 44
Islam Threat Rhetoric Good ............................................................. 44
Islam Threat Rhetoric Good ............................................................. 46
AT Homogenization ......................................................................... 47
Threats Are Real .............................................................................. 48
Threats Are Real .............................................................................. 49
Realism Inevitable ........................................................................... 50
Realism AT Discourse ...................................................................... 51
Rejection Alts Fail ............................................................................ 52
Aff advocacy subverts orientalism .................................................... 53

ADI 2011
Fellows - Murray

Neoliberal Cap K
1

Neoliberal Cap K Index


1NC Neoliberalism Cap K ............................................................................................................. 3
Link Democracy Assistance ....................................................................................................... 8
Link Democracy Assistance ....................................................................................................... 9
Link Egypt ................................................................................................................................. 10
Link - Egypt .................................................................................................................................. 11
Link - Social Media Hypothesis .................................................................................................. 12
Link - Qualifications .................................................................................................................... 13
Link - Identity Politics ................................................................................................................. 14
Link - Culture............................................................................................................................... 16
Link Contingent Identity .......................................................................................................... 17
Link Interpassivity .................................................................................................................... 18
***IMPACTS*** ......................................................................................................................... 20
Turns Case - Democracy ............................................................................................................. 20
Impact Value to Life ................................................................................................................. 21
Impact Super Extinction .......................................................................................................... 22
Impact Environment ................................................................................................................. 24
Impact Ecology .......................................................................................................................... 25
Impact Space Mil ...................................................................................................................... 27
Class Oppression Outweighs All................................................................................................. 28
A/T: Cap Good ............................................................................................................................. 29
A/T: Cap Good ............................................................................................................................. 30
***ALTERNATIVE*** .............................................................................................................. 32
A/T: Permutation ......................................................................................................................... 33
A/T: Capitalism Inevitable .......................................................................................................... 36
Block Alt Ext. ............................................................................................................................... 37
Alt Solves Awakens Masses ...................................................................................................... 39
Cant Give up on Revolution ...................................................................................................... 41
Leap of Faith ................................................................................................................................ 43
Material Criticism ........................................................................................................................ 44
Objectivity Key............................................................................................................................. 46
Objectivity Key............................................................................................................................. 47
Alternative Solves the Case/ Marxist Criticism Comes First ................................................... 48
A/T Youre Violent .................................................................................................................. 49
A/T Transition Wars.................................................................................................................... 50

ADI 2011
Fellows - Murray

Neoliberal Cap K
2

***AFF ANSWERS*** ............................................................................................................... 52


Turn Space................................................................................................................................. 53
EXT Capitalism Key to Space.................................................................................................. 55
1AR Space Impacts ...................................................................................................................... 56
Turn Interdependence .............................................................................................................. 59
Turn Disease .............................................................................................................................. 60
No Root Cause .............................................................................................................................. 61
EXT No Root Cause .................................................................................................................. 62
AT: No Value to Life................................................................................................................... 64
Predictions .................................................................................................................................... 65
Uniqueness--Capitalism Sustainable .......................................................................................... 66
Capitalism InevitableUtopia/Alt Fail ..................................................................................... 67
AT: UnsustainableMarket Innovation ................................................................................... 69
A/T: Zizek ..................................................................................................................................... 70
A/T: Rev ........................................................................................................................................ 71
Transition Wars Bad ................................................................................................................... 72

ADI 2011
Marvin Carter

1
A-Spring DA

Arab Spring Movements DA


Shell ........................................................................................................................................... 2
1NC .............................................................................................................................................. 3
1NC .............................................................................................................................................. 4
Uniqueness .............................................................................................................................. 6
Uniqueness- Change Will Come .................................................................................................. 7
Uniqueness- Regimes Wont Stop Movements ............................................................................ 8
Uniqueness- Headless Movements Work..................................................................................... 9
Uniqueness- Movements Empirically Have Worked ................................................................. 10
Uniqueness- Movements Can Work........................................................................................... 11
Uniqueness- SQ is Fragile .......................................................................................................... 12
Uniqueness- US cant support Middle East ............................................................................... 13
Uniqueness- Egypt Movements Solve ....................................................................................... 14
Links ........................................................................................................................................ 15
Link- Democracy/NGOS Tanks Movements ............................................................................. 16
Link- US Help Hurts Indigenous Movements ............................................................................ 17
LinkUS Inaction Spurs Movements ....................................................................................... 18
Link- Hard Power ....................................................................................................................... 19
Link- US Action in Syria............................................................................................................ 20
Link- US In Middle East ............................................................................................................ 21
Impacts .................................................................................................................................... 22
Impact- Coups ............................................................................................................................ 23
Impact- Instability ...................................................................................................................... 24
Impact- Corruption ..................................................................................................................... 25
Impact- Human Rights ............................................................................................................... 26
Impact- Destabilize Middle East ................................................................................................ 27
Impact- Human Rights Cred....................................................................................................... 28
Impact- Terrorism ...................................................................................................................... 29
Impact- Imperialism = extinction ............................................................................................... 30
Impact- Colonization .................................................................................................................. 31
AT: Middle East Wants US ........................................................................................................ 32
AT: US Action Solve ................................................................................................................. 33

Aff Answers ......................................................................................................................... 34


Aff- Democracy Regressing ....................................................................................................... 35
Aff- Headless Movements Fail................................................................................................... 36
Aff- Movements Cant Solve ..................................................................................................... 37
Aff- Movements Fail in Syria .................................................................................................... 38
Aff- Movements Fail in Tunisia ................................................................................................. 39
Aff- Movements Fail in Egypt ................................................................................................... 40
Aff- Middle East Movements Failing ........................................................................................ 41
Aff- Movements Cant Topple Regimes .................................................................................... 42
Aff- SQ will Fail ........................................................................................................................ 43
Aff- Democracy is Failing Now ................................................................................................. 44
Aff- Democracy is Failing Now ................................................................................................. 45
Aff- Democracy is Failing Now ................................................................................................. 46
Aff- Movements dont Solve AU Regime.................................................................................. 47
Aff- Human Rights Turn ............................................................................................................ 48
Aff- Syrian Destabilization Fails ................................................................................................ 49

ADI 2011
Fellows--Carter

1
Empire K

Empire K Index
1NC ................................................................................................................................. 2
Link- Yemen and Antiterrorism Advantages ........................................................... 10
Link- Yemen and Antiterrorism Advantages ........................................................... 11
Link- Ethics/Truth....................................................................................................... 12
Link- Free Trade ......................................................................................................... 13
Link- Democratization and Good Governance Policy ............................................. 14
Yemen Impact- Oppression ........................................................................................ 16
Impact- Hierarchy ....................................................................................................... 17
Impact- Violent Revolutions ....................................................................................... 18
Impact- Extinction ....................................................................................................... 19
Impact- Empire ............................................................................................................ 20
Alt- Solvency ................................................................................................................ 21
Alt Solvency- Middle East ........................................................................................... 22
Alt Solvency- Middle East ........................................................................................... 23
Alt Solvency- Democracy ............................................................................................ 24
Alt Solvency- Democracy ............................................................................................ 25
Alt Solvency- Movements Solve Empire .................................................................... 26
Alt Solvency- Colonialism ........................................................................................... 27
Alt Solvency- Movements Key .................................................................................... 28
Alt Solvency- Acceleration .......................................................................................... 29
AT: Perm ...................................................................................................................... 29
AT: Our plan is too specific to link ............................................................................ 31
AT: The plan undermines universal oppression....................................................... 32
AT: Orthodox Marxism .............................................................................................. 33
*Aff Answers* .............................................................................................................. 35
Empire Has Faulty Link Analysis .............................................................................. 36
Alt fails Multitudes Too Vague................................................................................ 36
Alt fails Multitudes cause economic collapse ......................................................... 37
Alt fails Aestheticizing politics preserves capitalism ............................................. 38
Alt Fails Multitudes Fail to Appreciate Cultural Difference ................................ 39
Alt Fails Multitudes Fail to Appreciate Cultural Difference ................................ 40
Alt fails Utopian ........................................................................................................ 41
Alt fails Utopian ........................................................................................................ 42
Perm Adopt Plan in the Transition to Counter-empire ........................................ 43
Perm Solvency Need State Action for Global Democracy .................................... 45

ADI 11
Fellows and Dr. Dave

1
Topicality

Topicality 1NC-2AC shells Index


*1NC Shells* ...................................................................................................................... 2
Small increases in assistance T not substantial 1NC shell .................................................. 3
Conditioning assistance is not substantial 1NC shell ......................................................... 6
IMET is not Democracy Assistance 1NC Shell .................................................................. 8
Syria TV Resignation Call, Witnessing, Narratives not Democracy Assistance 1NC ..... 10
Critical Advocacy T --USFG Should Requires Advocating a Government Plan 1NC . 12
Critical Advocacy T -- Resolved Requires Plan Advocacy 1NC ..................................... 14
*2AC Shells* .................................................................................................................... 16
2AC: small increases in assistance spending not substantial ............................................ 17
2AC: assistance conditions not substantial T.................................................................... 19
2AC: IMET is democracy assistance ............................................................................... 21
2AC: Syria Call for Resignation, Witnessing, Narratives ............................................... 23
2AC: Critical T --USFG Should requires government plan ......................................... 25
2AC: Critical T- -Resolved requires plan advocacy .................................................... 26

ADI 11
Fellows and Dr. Dave

1
Topicality Definitions

Topicality Definitions Index


United States Federal Government ................................................................................. 2
Should................................................................................................................................. 3
Substantiallygeneral definitions .................................................................................. 4
Substantiallyqualitative definitions ............................................................................. 5
Substantiallyquantitative definitions .......................................................................... 6
Increase .............................................................................................................................. 6
Its ........................................................................................................................................ 7
Democracy Assistance ...................................................................................................... 9
For .................................................................................................................................... 15
One or more ..................................................................................................................... 17
Of ...................................................................................................................................... 19
The .................................................................................................................................... 20
Following.......................................................................................................................... 21
Bahrain............................................................................................................................. 22
Egypt ................................................................................................................................ 23
Libya................................................................................................................................. 24
Syria ................................................................................................................................. 25
Tunisia.............................................................................................................................. 26
Yemen............................................................................................................................... 27

USE THESE TO MAKE YOUR OWN VIOLATIONS OR ANSWERS

ASU 2011
Fellows -- Ziegler

1
Corruption Reform CP

CORRUPTION REFORM CONDITION CP


Corruption Reform CP 1NC (1/3) .............................................................................................................................. 2
Corruption Reform CP 1NC (2/3) .............................................................................................................................. 3
Corruption Reform CP 1NC (3/3) .............................................................................................................................. 4
2NC/1NR Overview ...................................................................................................................................................... 5
AT: Perm Do Both ...................................................................................................................................................... 6
AT: Perm Do the CP ................................................................................................................................................... 7
AT: Textual Competition............................................................................................................................................... 8
AT: Condition CPs Bad................................................................................................................................................ 9
EXT We Should Condition Demo Assistace ............................................................................................................ 10
Say Yes General ....................................................................................................................................................... 11
Say Yes Bahrain ....................................................................................................................................................... 13
Say Yes Egypt .......................................................................................................................................................... 14
Say Yes Libya........................................................................................................................................................... 16
Say Yes Syria ........................................................................................................................................................... 17
Say Yes Yemen ........................................................................................................................................................ 18
EXT Corruption Now ............................................................................................................................................... 19
EXT Corruption Kills Democracy ............................................................................................................................ 20
EXT Corruptions Reforms Solve.............................................................................................................................. 21
EXT Liberal Democracy Key ................................................................................................................................... 22
Democracy Good Poverty......................................................................................................................................... 23
Democracy Good Economy ...................................................................................................................................... 24
Democracy Good Terrorism ..................................................................................................................................... 25
Democracy Good Proliferation ................................................................................................................................. 26
Democracy Good Environment ................................................................................................................................ 27
Turns Case Egypt...................................................................................................................................................... 28
Turns Case Syria ....................................................................................................................................................... 30
Turns Case Yemen.................................................................................................................................................... 31
Aff Condition CPs Bad............................................................................................................................................ 33
Aff Functional Competition Bad .............................................................................................................................. 34
Aff Say No General ............................................................................................................................................... 35
Aff Say No Syria ................................................................................................................................................... 36
Aff Say No Tunisia ................................................................................................................................................ 37
Aff Say No Yemen ................................................................................................................................................ 38
Aff Corruption Reform Now Egypt ....................................................................................................................... 40
Aff Corruption Inevitable ......................................................................................................................................... 42
Aff Conditions Fail ................................................................................................................................................... 43
Aff Conditions Bad Overcrowding ........................................................................................................................ 44
Aff Democratic Peace Theory False ......................................................................................................................... 45
Aff Democracy No Solve War ................................................................................................................................. 47

ADI2011
WesRumbaugh

1
IranDA

Iran DA
IranDA....................................................................................................................................1
IranDA1NC.............................................................................................................................3
IranDA1NC.............................................................................................................................3
Uniqueness..............................................................................................................................5
UniquenessGeneral...............................................................................................................6
UniquenessGeneral...............................................................................................................7
UniquenessObamaWeakness................................................................................................8
UniquenessDomesticIssues...................................................................................................9
UniquenessIraq...................................................................................................................10
Links......................................................................................................................................11
LinksEgypt...........................................................................................................................12
LinksBahrain........................................................................................................................13
LinksSyria............................................................................................................................14
LinksSyriaMagnifier............................................................................................................15
LinksTunisia.........................................................................................................................16
LinksYemen.........................................................................................................................17
LinksLibya............................................................................................................................18
LinkInfluenceZeroSum.......................................................................................................19
InternalLinkDemocracyAssistance=Containment...............................................................20
Impacts..................................................................................................................................21
ContainmentBadMiscalc.....................................................................................................22
ContainmentBadMiscalcExtensions...................................................................................24
ContainmentBadIranProlif.................................................................................................25
ContainmentBadIraqInstability..........................................................................................27
ContainmentBadTerrorism.................................................................................................29
ContainmentBadA2:StopsWeaponsTransfer....................................................................30
ContainmentBadA2:Alliances............................................................................................31
ContainmentBadA2:Moderates........................................................................................32
ContainmentBadA2:Democracy.........................................................................................33
ContainmentBadIneffectiveHistoryWrong.......................................................................34
ContainmentBadIneffectiveResolve..................................................................................35

ADI2011
WesRumbaugh

2
IranDA

AffAnswers36
AffAnswersNonUQIraq/Afghanistan.................................................................................37
AffAnswersNonUQArabSpring........................................................................................38
AffAnswersNonUQEgypt..................................................................................................39
AffAnswersLinkTurn..........................................................................................................40
AffAnswersNoLink.............................................................................................................41
AffAnswersContainmentGoodModerateTakeover...........................................................42
AffAnswersContainmentGoodIranProlif..........................................................................44
AffAnswersContainmentGoodDemocracy........................................................................45
AffAnswersContainmentGoodCausesAlliedSupport........................................................47
AffAnswersContainmentGoodA2:Irrational/Miscalc.......................................................48
AffAnswersProlifD.............................................................................................................49
AffAnswersIranProlifD......................................................................................................50
AffAnswersMiddleEastWarD............................................................................................51
AffAnswersTerrorismD......................................................................................................52

ADI 2011
Steven Murray

1
Saudi DA

***Saudi Disad***
***Saudi Disad*** .................................................................................................................................................... 1
1NC Saudi DA ........................................................................................................................................................... 2
***Uniqueness***..................................................................................................................................................... 4
UQ US-Saudi relations Low ................................................................................................................................... 4
Relations UQ No one Trusts Anyone ..................................................................................................................... 6
***Links*** .............................................................................................................................................................. 7
2NC Link Wall .......................................................................................................................................................... 7
Link Democracy Assistance ................................................................................................................................... 8
Link Arab Spring .................................................................................................................................................... 9
Link - Bahrain.......................................................................................................................................................... 11
Bahrain Link UQ ..................................................................................................................................................... 12
Link - Shiites in Bahrain .......................................................................................................................................... 13
Link - Appeasing Iran .............................................................................................................................................. 14
Link Egypt ............................................................................................................................................................ 15
A/T: Relations Resilient Oil ................................................................................................................................. 16
A/T: Relations Resilient Security ......................................................................................................................... 17
***Impacts***......................................................................................................................................................... 18
2NC Proliferation .................................................................................................................................................... 18
Saudi Prolif Dominoes............................................................................................................................................. 20
A/T: Deterrence ....................................................................................................................................................... 21
A/T: Saudi Prolif Inevitable..................................................................................................................................... 22
A/T: Pakistan Gives the Bomb ................................................................................................................................ 23
A/T: Iran Prolif = Saudi Prolif inevitable ................................................................................................................ 24
Iran Prolif Good ....................................................................................................................................................... 25
Saudi Prolif Terrorism ......................................................................................................................................... 27
Impact - Terrorism ................................................................................................................................................... 28
Impact Dollar Heg ................................................................................................................................................ 29
Ext: Relz key to dollar heg ...................................................................................................................................... 31
EXT Oil Security .................................................................................................................................................. 32
Impact Regional Power Projection ....................................................................................................................... 33
Impact Middle East Stability ................................................................................................................................ 34
Impact China......................................................................................................................................................... 35
EXT China Fill-In ................................................................................................................................................. 37
***AFF Answers*** ............................................................................................................................................... 38
Relations Low .......................................................................................................................................................... 39
EXT No Link ........................................................................................................................................................ 40
US-Saudi Relations Resilient .................................................................................................................................. 41
EXT Relations Resilient: Oil and Security ........................................................................................................... 42
Saudi Prolif Good - Iran .......................................................................................................................................... 44
Saudi Prolif Good - Stability ................................................................................................................................... 45
EXT Saudi Prolif Inevitable ................................................................................................................................. 46
A/T: Saudi Prolif Incentive/Means ....................................................................................................................... 47
A/T: Saudi Prolif Iran Alt Cause .......................................................................................................................... 49
Prolif: Not Bad......................................................................................................................................................... 50
A/T: China Aggression ............................................................................................................................................ 51

ADI 2011
Sovereignty K

Sovereignty K
Sovereignty K ............................................ 1

AT: Cede the Political ............................. 26

1NC ............................................................. 2

AT: Framework ...................................... 27

1NC ............................................................. 3

AT: Framework ...................................... 28

1NC ............................................................. 4

AT: Framework ...................................... 29

**Links** ................................................... 6

AT: Permutation ..................................... 30

Democracy Link ........................................ 7

AT: Sovereignty Solves War .................. 31

Democracy Link ........................................ 8

AT: State Co-option ................................ 32

Democracy Link ........................................ 9


Economy Link ......................................... 10

**Aff Answers** ..................................... 33

Humanitarianism Link ........................... 11

Alt Fails .................................................... 34

Security Link ........................................... 12

Biopower Good ........................................ 36

Security Link ........................................... 13

Cede the Political..................................... 37

Terrorism Link........................................ 14

Cede the Political..................................... 38

**Impacts** ............................................. 16

Cede the Political..................................... 39

Oppression Impact .................................. 17

Democracy Solves.................................... 40

Totalitarianism Impact........................... 18

Democracy Solves.................................... 41

Value to Life Impact ............................... 19

No Impact ................................................ 42

**Alternative** ....................................... 20

No Impact ................................................ 43

Individual Resistance Alt ....................... 21

Perm Solvency ......................................... 44

Reject Democracy Alt ............................. 22

Utilitarianism Good ................................ 45

**Answers to Aff Answers** ................. 23

Utilitarianism Good ................................ 46

AT: Cede the Political ............................. 24

Strategic Sovereignty Good.................... 47

AT: Cede the Political ............................. 25

Securitization Good ................................ 48


Securitization Good ................................ 49

2011 Arizona Debate Institutes

Spending Disad

spending disad 2011 adi - maria


1nc ............................................................................................................................................................................... 3
***Neg Uniqueness ..................................................................................................................... 4
2nc uniqueness........................................................................................................................................................... 5
at: obama veto ............................................................................................................................................................ 6
at: military spending outweighs ................................................................................................................................ 7
at: funding demo assistance now .............................................................................................................................. 8
--xt: republican factionism ........................................................................................................................................ 9
--xt: civil society ....................................................................................................................................................... 10
--xt: egypt .................................................................................................................................................................. 11
at: no credit downgrade ............................................................................................................................................12
at: econ low................................................................................................................................................................13
***Neg Links ............................................................................................................................. 13
generic .......................................................................................................................................................................14
demo assistance ........................................................................................................................................................ 15
civil society ................................................................................................................................................................ 17
civil society/rule of law ............................................................................................................................................ 18
internet assistance ....................................................................................................................................................19
usaid ......................................................................................................................................................................... 20
ned .............................................................................................................................................................................21
***Neg Internal Links ................................................................................................................ 21
deficit reduction key................................................................................................................................................. 22
fiscal discipline key .................................................................................................................................................. 23
deficit reduction and fiscal discipline key ............................................................................................................... 24
deficit plan key to solve credit downgrade .............................................................................................................. 25
credit downgrade --> econ collapse ........................................................................................................................ 27
gridlock --> econ collapse ........................................................................................................................................ 28
***Neg Impacts......................................................................................................................... 28
dollar collapse --> collapse heg ............................................................................................................................... 29
dollar collapse --> econ collapse ............................................................................................................................. 30
dollar collapse --> trade wars ...................................................................................................................................31
xt: econ collapse --> war .......................................................................................................................................... 32
econ turns all impacts .............................................................................................................................................. 33
econ turns democracy .............................................................................................................................................. 34
econ turns heg .......................................................................................................................................................... 35
***Aff Answers .......................................................................................................................... 35
econ low .................................................................................................................................................................... 36
no spending cuts ...................................................................................................................................................... 38
no spending cuts obama veto ............................................................................................................................... 40
spending now generic ............................................................................................................................................41
spending now democracy assistance ................................................................................................................... 42
spending now internet assistance ........................................................................................................................ 44
spending now egypt .............................................................................................................................................. 45
spending now yemen ............................................................................................................................................ 46
link non-unique lots of spending now ................................................................................................................. 47
no link ....................................................................................................................................................................... 48
plan saves money/link turn ..................................................................................................................................... 49
deficit spending good ............................................................................................................................................... 50
1

2011 Arizona Debate Institutes


Spending Disad
spending cuts bad ..................................................................................................................................................... 51
deal not key to econ.................................................................................................................................................. 52
econ resilient US ................................................................................................................................................... 53
econ resilient - world ............................................................................................................................................... 54
at: credit downgrade ................................................................................................................................................ 55
at: dollar collapse ..................................................................................................................................................... 56
no impact econ collapse........................................................................................................................................ 58

china relations disad


china relations disad ................................................................................................................................................... 1
1nc ............................................................................................................................................................................... 2
1nc ............................................................................................................................................................................... 3
1nc ............................................................................................................................................................................... 4
***uniqueness ............................................................................................................................ 4
relations high ............................................................................................................................................................. 5
relations high ............................................................................................................................................................. 6
relations high military ............................................................................................................................................ 7
relations high human rights ................................................................................................................................... 8
relations = brink......................................................................................................................................................... 9
***links ...................................................................................................................................... 9
--xt: paal 1nc link...................................................................................................................................................... 10
hates democracy ........................................................................................................................................................ 11
hates democracy ........................................................................................................................................................12
sco proves ..................................................................................................................................................................13
oppose obama policy .................................................................................................................................................14
intervention ............................................................................................................................................................... 15
internet assistance ....................................................................................................................................................16
unilat action bad ....................................................................................................................................................... 17
at: oil concerns o/w democracy ............................................................................................................................... 18
***impacts ................................................................................................................................. 18
asian stability ............................................................................................................................................................19
--xt: asian stability ................................................................................................................................................... 20
hegemony ..................................................................................................................................................................21
laundry list ............................................................................................................................................................... 22
rogue prolif ............................................................................................................................................................... 23
rogue prolif ............................................................................................................................................................... 24
--xt: prolif ................................................................................................................................................................. 25
taiwan war ................................................................................................................................................................ 26
***aff answers .......................................................................................................................... 26
relations low taiwan .............................................................................................................................................. 27
relations low taiwan .............................................................................................................................................. 28
relations low military ............................................................................................................................................ 29
relations low human rights................................................................................................................................... 30
relations resilient ......................................................................................................................................................31
--xt: relations resilient ............................................................................................................................................. 32
alt causes .................................................................................................................................................................. 33
alt causes .................................................................................................................................................................. 34
no link not worried about the middle east ........................................................................................................... 35
no link only worried about oil .............................................................................................................................. 36
relations bad heg ................................................................................................................................................... 37
at: relations solve asian stability .......................................................................................................................... 39
at: relations solve prolif ........................................................................................................................................ 40
at: fear china spring ................................................................................................................................................41

ADI 2011
Fellows -- Ziegler

1
Israel DA

ISRAEL DA
1NC (1/2) ....................................................................................................................................................................... 3
1NC (2/2) ....................................................................................................................................................................... 4
2NC/1NR Overview ................................................................................................................................................... 5
***Uniqueness.............................................................................................................................................................. 5
UQ Relations Up Now ................................................................................................................................................ 6
UQ Pro-Israel Assistance Policy now ......................................................................................................................... 7
AT: Obama Shifted Relations........................................................................................................................................ 8
Brink US-Israel Relations on the Brink .................................................................................................................... 10
***Link ....................................................................................................................................................................... 10
Link UQ Security Up Now .................................................................................................................................... 11
Link Generic ............................................................................................................................................................. 12
Link Egypt ................................................................................................................................................................ 15
Link Egypt Relations Zero Sum ............................................................................................................................ 16
Link Bahrain, Libya, Syria, Yemen .......................................................................................................................... 17
Link Syria ................................................................................................................................................................. 18
Link Syria Failed Overthrow ................................................................................................................................. 19
Link Yemen/Gulf States ........................................................................................................................................... 20
Link Magnifier Israel is Delusional ....................................................................................................................... 21
Link Magnifier Iran Factor .................................................................................................................................... 22
AT: Link Turn Israel Likes Democracy ................................................................................................................... 23
***Impact ................................................................................................................................................................... 24
EXT ME War On The Brink .................................................................................................................................... 25
EXT Relations Key to ME Stability ......................................................................................................................... 26
Relations Good Hegemony ....................................................................................................................................... 28
EXT Relations Key to Heg ....................................................................................................................................... 29
Relations Good Turns ME Democracy ..................................................................................................................... 30
Relations Good Iran Prolif ........................................................................................................................................ 31
AT: No Israel First Strike ............................................................................................................................................ 32
AT: No Israel First Strike Escalation ........................................................................................................................... 33
EXT Relations Check Iran Prolif .............................................................................................................................. 34
Relations Good Terrorism ........................................................................................................................................ 35
Relations Good AT: Relations Bad .......................................................................................................................... 36
AT: Peace Process Fails............................................................................................................................................ 37
AT: Peace Process Prolongs Conflict ....................................................................................................................... 38
***Aff Answers .......................................................................................................................................................... 38
Aff Relations Down Now ......................................................................................................................................... 39
Aff Alt Cause Peace Process ................................................................................................................................. 40
Aff No Link .............................................................................................................................................................. 41
Aff Impact UQ Thumpers ......................................................................................................................................... 42
Aff Relations Resilient ............................................................................................................................................. 43
Peace Process Turn 2AC (1/3) .................................................................................................................................. 44
Peace Process Turn 2AC (2/3) .................................................................................................................................. 45
Peace Process Turn 2AC (3/3) .................................................................................................................................. 46
Aff AT: Relations Key to Heg .................................................................................................................................. 47
Aff No Issue Spillover .............................................................................................................................................. 48
Aff Other Issues Key ................................................................................................................................................ 49
Aff Relations Bad Middle East Stability ............................................................................................................... 51
Aff AT: Iran Prolif Inevitable ................................................................................................................................ 52
Aff AT: Iran Prolif Exaggerated ............................................................................................................................ 53
Aff Relations Bad Terrorism ................................................................................................................................. 54
Aff EXT Relations Cause Terrorism ..................................................................................................................... 55

ADI 2011
Fellows -- Ziegler

2
Israel DA

Aff AT: Relations Key to Heg .................................................................................................................................. 56


Aff AT: Israel Lashout ............................................................................................................................................. 57

ADI 2011
Lundeen

1AC - Inherency................................................................... 2
1AC Advantage................................................................. 3
1AC Advantage................................................................. 4
1AC Advantage................................................................. 5
1AC Advantage................................................................. 6
1AC Solvency ................................................................... 8
1AC Solvency ................................................................... 9
Inherency ........................................................................... 10
Inherency - AT: Syrian Opposition Solves SQ .................. 11
Solvency - Calls to Step Down .......................................... 12
Solvency - U.S support Key............................................... 13
Solvency Calls to Step Down.......................................... 14
Solvency Demand step down .......................................... 15
Solvency Diplomatic Pressure ........................................ 16
Solvency - Only Assad Step Down Solves ........................ 17

***Human Rights Adv*** ................................. 18


Human Rights Abuses........................................................ 19
Human Rights Abuses........................................................ 20
Human Rights Abuses........................................................ 21
Human Rights Abuses........................................................ 22
Human Rights Abuses........................................................ 23
Human Rights Abuses........................................................ 24
Human Rights Abuses........................................................ 25
Torture ............................................................................... 26
Freedom of Speech & Expression ...................................... 27
Homosexual discrimination ............................................... 28
Must Act Now Ramadan ................................................. 29
Impact - Genocide .............................................................. 30
Impact - Terrorism ............................................................. 31
Impact - Dehumanization ................................................... 32
Impact - Solves War........................................................... 34
Impact - Democracy ........................................................... 35
Impact Democracy ............................................................. 36
Impact - Extinction ........................................................... 37
Plan Solves Human Rights Abuses .................................... 38
Rhetorical Support Solvency ............................................. 39
AT: Need International Action/US Key............................. 40
AT: Reforms Solve ............................................................ 41
AT: SQ Elections Solves ................................................... 42
AT: Human Rights are Western ......................................... 43
US Human Rts Credibiity Low Now ................................. 44
Political Participation is Fundamental Right...................... 45

***Regime Change***........................................ 46
Intl Pressure Causes Regime Change ............................... 47
Opposition Groups Ready to step In .................................. 49
Ready for Post Assad ......................................................... 50
Post Assad will be Democratic .......................................... 51
Shadow Government Ready............................................... 52
Regime Change Key .......................................................... 53
Iran ..................................................................................... 54
Food Shortages .................................................................. 55

***Answers To*** .............................................. 56


Topicality Democracy Assistance ................................... 57

1
Syria

AT: CP Other forms Dem Assistance............................. 58


AT: CP Fund Opposition ................................................ 59
AT: CP Other Actor ....................................................... 60
AT: UN CP ........................................................................ 61
AT: Syrians should decide for themselves ........................ 62
AT: Plan Causes Crackdown ............................................. 63
AT: Radical Muslim Takeover .......................................... 64
Politics - Bipartisan Support for Syrian Democracy ......... 65
Politics - no loss of political capital ................................. 66
AT: Civil Society Bad Args .............................................. 67
AT: K ................................................................................ 68
AT: DA War Impacts ........................................................ 69

***NEG*** ...........................................................70
***AT: Human Rights Adv.***........................................ 70
SQ Solves Human Rights .................................................. 71
SQ Solves Syrian Reforms ............................................ 72
SQ Solves US Condemnation Now ................................ 73
US Human Rts Promotion Bad.......................................... 74
AT: Womens Human Rights ............................................ 75
Human Rights Bad War ................................................. 76
No Solvency Pressure Fails ............................................ 77
No Solvency - US Hypocrisy ............................................ 78
No Solvency Human Rights ........................................... 79
No Solvency - Negative U.S. image in Syria .................... 80
Turn - Plan Causes Civil War............................................ 81
Turn - Plan Causes Crackdown ......................................... 82
K US Response is Hypocritical ...................................... 83
UN CP ............................................................................... 84
UN CP ............................................................................... 85

ADI 2011
Critical Lab

1
Nietzsche K

Nietzsche Index
Nietzsche Index .......................................................................................................................................... 1
1NC Shell ................................................................................................................................................... 3
Link- Ascetic Life ....................................................................................................................................... 5
Link- Brutality ............................................................................................................................................ 6
Link- Causes ............................................................................................................................................... 7
Link- Crusade ............................................................................................................................................. 8
Link- Constitution and Rule of Law ........................................................................................................... 9
Link- Conscious........................................................................................................................................ 10
Link- Denying .......................................................................................................................................... 11
Link- Doing Something >.<...................................................................................................................... 12
Link- Doing Something >.<...................................................................................................................... 13
Link- Democracy ...................................................................................................................................... 14
Link- Democracy ...................................................................................................................................... 15
Link- Democracy ...................................................................................................................................... 17
Link- Democracy ...................................................................................................................................... 18
Link- Evil.................................................................................................................................................. 19
Link- Evil.................................................................................................................................................. 20
Link- Guilt and Justice ............................................................................................................................. 21
Link- Justice and Fairness ........................................................................................................................ 22
Link- Justice Rhetoric ............................................................................................................................... 23
Link- Morality .......................................................................................................................................... 24
Link- Morality .......................................................................................................................................... 25
Link- Morality .......................................................................................................................................... 26
Link- Memory .......................................................................................................................................... 27
Link- Root Causes .................................................................................................................................... 28
Link- Resistance Movements ................................................................................................................... 29
Link- Regime Change ............................................................................................................................... 30
Link- Science=Ascetic Ideal ..................................................................................................................... 31
Link- Scientific Knowledge...................................................................................................................... 32
Link- Truth ............................................................................................................................................... 33
Link- Truth ............................................................................................................................................... 34
Link- Truth ............................................................................................................................................... 35
Link- Universal ......................................................................................................................................... 36
Impact- No Value to Life.......................................................................................................................... 37
Impact- Passivity ...................................................................................................................................... 38
Impact- Purity ........................................................................................................................................... 39
Impact- Hate and Revenge........................................................................................................................ 40
Impact- Dehumanization .......................................................................................................................... 41
Impact- Self Torture ................................................................................................................................. 42
Framework ................................................................................................................................................ 43
Alt Solvency- Embrace Life ..................................................................................................................... 44
Alt Solvency- Ascetics ............................................................................................................................. 45
Alt Solvency- Forgetting .......................................................................................................................... 46
Alt Solvency- Aceeptance ........................................................................................................................ 47
Alt Solves- Democracy ............................................................................................................................. 48
Alt Solvency- Empowering the Self ......................................................................................................... 49
AT: Perm-slave ......................................................................................................................................... 53
At: Rude.................................................................................................................................................... 54
AT: Exercising Power Bad ....................................................................................................................... 55
AT: Pain.................................................................................................................................................... 56
AT: Perm is Slave Morality ...................................................................................................................... 57
At: Impacts ............................................................................................................................................... 58
AT: Framework ........................................................................................................................................ 60
AT: Schopenhauer .................................................................................................................................... 61
AT: Truth is Real ...................................................................................................................................... 62

ADI 2011
Critical Lab

2
Nietzsche K

AT: Anti-Semetism................................................................................................................................... 63
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 64
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 65
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 66
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 67
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 68
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 69
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 70
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 72
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 73
Aff Answer ............................................................................................................................................... 74

ADI 2011
Nielson

1
Bear Witness

Syrian Bearing Witness Affirmative


Syrian Bearing Witness Affirmative .................................... 1
FYI ....................................................................................... 2
Syrian Bearing Witness Critical 1AC .................................. 3
Syrian Bearing Witness Poetics 1AC................................. 10
Narrative: Riad Al-Turk ..................................................... 13
Narratives: Torture Testimony ........................................... 16
Harms: Syrian Police Force Violence ................................ 19
Harms: Refugees ................................................................ 20
Harms: Torture ................................................................... 21
Impact: Freedom ................................................................ 22
Impact: Torture .................................................................. 23
Advantage Add-On: Social Amnesia ................................. 26
Advantage Add-On: Global Justice ................................... 28
Solvency Bearing Witness Confronts Syria .................... 31
Solvency Bearing Witness Subjectivity ..................... 33
Solvency Bearing Witness Responsibilty .................. 35
Solvency - Bearing Witness Action .............................. 39
Solvency Bearing Witness Ethics .............................. 44
Solvency - Bearing Witness & Media................................ 45
Solvency Spillover Effect ............................................... 46
Solvency Global Justice .................................................. 47
Solvency Must Have A Plan ........................................... 48
Solvency Poetry .............................................................. 49
Message In A Bottle Metaphor .......................................... 50
Answer To: Asad Reforming ............................................. 51
Answer To: Political Pluralism Reform ............................. 52
Answer To: Riad Al-Turk Indicts ...................................... 53

Answer To: Something is Wrong with the Narrative ........ 54


Answer To: Framework Wrong Forum .......................... 55
Answer To: Framework - Predictability ............................ 58
Answer To: Framework - Switch Sides ............................. 59
Answer To: Framework Policy Making Education ........ 61
Answer To: Framework Aff is a Pre-req to the Topic .... 62
Answer To: Framework USFG Topicality ..................... 64
Answer To: Framework Democracy Assistance ............... 65
Answer To: Not 1st Hand Experience ................................ 66
Answer To: Speaking for Others ....................................... 68
Answer To: Desiring/Fetish the Other............................... 75
Answer To: Fetish/Pity/Resentment .................................. 77
Answer To: Need to Hear the Silent.................................. 78
Answer To: Tyranny of Truth ........................................... 79
Answer To: History Bad.................................................... 83
Answer To: Hypocrisy ...................................................... 86
Answer To: Muslim Brotherhood Are Evil ....................... 88
Answer To: Humanitarian Intervention Bad ..................... 90
Answer To: Human Rights Kritiks .................................... 92
Answer To: Feminism ....................................................... 94
Answer To: Whiteness ...................................................... 95
Answer To: Terrorism ....................................................... 96
Answer To: Muslim Brotherhood ..................................... 98
Answer To: Utilitarianism ................................................. 99

ADI 2011
Critical Lab

1
Syria Bearing Witness Neg

Syrian Bearing Witness Case Negative


Syrian Bearing Witness Case Negative ...................................................................................................... 1
Harms Take-Outs........................................................................................................................................ 2
Solvency Take-Outs: Bearing Witness ....................................................................................................... 6
Answer To: Torture Advantage ................................................................................................................ 11
No Obligation to the Other ....................................................................................................................... 12
Riad Al-Turk Neg ..................................................................................................................................... 12
Framework: Must Have A Plan ................................................................................................................ 14
Framework: Fairness ................................................................................................................................ 16
Exploiting the Other ................................................................................................................................. 17
Speaking for Others .................................................................................................................................. 18
Tyranny of Truth ...................................................................................................................................... 21
Confessions............................................................................................................................................... 26
Ethics Bad ................................................................................................................................................. 27
Link: Western Imperialism Ks ................................................................................................................ 28
Link: Neoliberalism .................................................................................................................................. 29
Disaster Porn K Shell ............................................................................................................................... 31
Disaster Porn Link Torture .................................................................................................................... 33
Critical Counter-Plan: Endless Mourning................................................................................................. 34
Counter-Plan: UN Sanctions..................................................................................................................... 36

ADI 2011
Nielson

1
Whiteness

Whiteness Index
Whiteness Index .................................................... 1
1NC Shell............................................................................. 3
1NC Shell............................................................................. 4
1NC Shell............................................................................. 6
1NC Shell............................................................................. 7

**Links** ............................................................... 8
Christianity........................................................................... 9
Colorblindness ................................................................... 11
Courts ................................................................................. 12
Debate ................................................................................ 13
Democracy Assistance ....................................................... 15
Democracy Assistance ....................................................... 16
Democracy ......................................................................... 17
Democracy ......................................................................... 18
Democracy ......................................................................... 19
Democracy ......................................................................... 20
Democracy ......................................................................... 21
Difference .......................................................................... 22
Equality/Freedom............................................................... 23
Feminism/Marxism ............................................................ 25
Human Rights .................................................................... 26
Identity Politics .................................................................. 27
Inclusion ............................................................................ 28
Individual Action ............................................................... 29
International Law ............................................................... 30
Kritikal Affs ....................................................................... 31
Marxism ............................................................................. 32
Multiculturalism................................................................. 33
Negative Rights.................................................................. 35
Omission ............................................................................ 36
Omission ............................................................................ 37
Omission ............................................................................ 38
Omission ............................................................................ 39
Postmodernism................................................................... 40
Postmodernism................................................................... 41
Postmodernism................................................................... 42
Postmodernism................................................................... 43
Postmodernism................................................................... 44
Racial Ideology .................................................................. 46
Reform ............................................................................... 47
Subaltern ............................................................................ 48
White Folk ......................................................................... 49
White Liberals.................................................................... 50
White Liberals.................................................................... 52
White Philosophy ............................................................... 53
View from Nowhere .......................................................... 54

**Impacts** ......................................................... 55
Bad Faith ............................................................................ 56
Bad Faith ............................................................................ 57

Biopower ........................................................................... 58
Cultural Genocide ............................................................. 59
Dehumanization ................................................................ 60
Dehumanization ................................................................ 61
Dehumanization ................................................................ 62
Democracy ........................................................................ 63
Discrimination ................................................................... 64
Ethics ................................................................................. 65
Imperialism........................................................................ 66
Inequalities ........................................................................ 67
Inequalities ........................................................................ 69
Interventionism.................................................................. 70
Interventionism.................................................................. 72
Ontological Violence......................................................... 73
Segragation ........................................................................ 74
Violence ............................................................................ 75
War .................................................................................... 76
War .................................................................................... 77
White Suffering ................................................................. 78

**Alternative** ....................................................79
Abolish White Citizenship ................................................ 80
Abolish White Citizenship ................................................ 81
Abolish White Citizenship ................................................ 82
Abolish White Citizenship ................................................ 83
Need Perspectives of Color ............................................... 84
Ontological Criticism ........................................................ 85
Ontological Criticism ........................................................ 87
Outrage .............................................................................. 88
Presence of Mind ............................................................... 89
Refuse Normalized White Body ........................................ 90
Resistance .......................................................................... 91

**Answers To Aff Answers** .............................92


AT: Apologies ................................................................... 93
AT: Cap ............................................................................. 94
AT: Cap ............................................................................. 96
AT: Cap ............................................................................. 97
AT: Cap ............................................................................. 98
AT: Black/White Binary ................................................... 99
AT: Black Responsibility ................................................ 101
AT: Feminism ................................................................. 102
AT: Framework Race First ........................................... 104
AT: Framework Debate Key ........................................ 105
AT: Framework Ballot Key .......................................... 107
AT: Framework Bracketing Out Bad ........................... 108
AT: Framework Fairness/Predictability ....................... 110
AT: Framework Ontological Expansiveness ................ 111
AT: Framework Switch-Side Debate ........................... 112
Switch Side Debate Bad .................................................. 113
Switch Side Debate Bad .................................................. 114
AT: Intersectionality........................................................ 115
AT: No Link .................................................................... 116

ADI 2011
Nielson
AT: Perm ......................................................................... 117
AT: Perm ......................................................................... 118
AT: Perm ......................................................................... 119
AT: Race is Biological ..................................................... 120
AT: Race is Ethnicity ....................................................... 121
AT: Race Isnt Real ......................................................... 122
AT: Race Isnt Real ......................................................... 123
AT: Race is Neutral ......................................................... 124
AT: Homogenizes Whiteness........................................... 125
AT: I Didnt Intend To Be Racist! ................................... 126
AT: I Hate Racism Too ................................................ 127
AT: Inevitable .................................................................. 128
AT: Oprah Effect/Blacks are Privileged ....................... 129
AT: Racism Inevitable ..................................................... 130
AT: Reverse Racism ........................................................ 131
AT: Thats the Past ....................................................... 133
AT: Thats The Past ..................................................... 134
AT: You Exclude Whites ................................................. 135
AT: WE ARE INDIVIDUALS ........................................ 136
AT: We Arent Racist ...................................................... 137
AT: Whiteness is Monolithic ........................................... 138
AT: Whiteness Can Be Reclaimed................................... 139
AT: White Bashing .......................................................... 140
AT: White Skin = Whiteness ........................................... 141
AT: White Skin = Whiteness ........................................... 142
AT: Uncomfortability ...................................................... 143

2
Whiteness
AT: Utopianism Bad ....................................................... 144

**Aff Answers** ................................................145


Black/White Binary Bad ................................................. 146
Capitalism K Link ........................................................... 147
Debate Space Bad............................................................ 148
Monolithic Turn .............................................................. 150
Totalizing Turn ................................................................ 151
Essentialism..................................................................... 154
Privilege Talk Bad ........................................................... 156
Victimization Turn .......................................................... 157
Revealing Whiteness Bad ................................................ 158
White Bashing ................................................................. 159
Perms ............................................................................... 160
Perm: Policy Making ....................................................... 161
Reclaiming Whiteness Turn ............................................ 162

**Random** .......................................................166
Middle Eastern = Catch 22 .............................................. 167
Middle Eastern = Catch 22 .............................................. 168
Middle Eastern = Catch 22 .............................................. 169
White Privilege is Upheld Unconsciously ....................... 170
White Privilege is Invisible ............................................. 171

ADI 2011
Critical Lab

1
The Gift K

The Gift Kritik Index


The Gift Kritik Index .................................................................................................................................. 1
The Gift Shell ............................................................................................................................................. 2
Link: Gifts Secure Majority Power ............................................................................................................. 5
Link: Democracy ........................................................................................................................................ 6
Link: Democracy Assistance ...................................................................................................................... 7
Link: NGOs ............................................................................................................................................. 10
Link: NED ................................................................................................................................................ 11
Link: US Arab Spring Democ Assistance ................................................................................................ 12
Link: Egypt ............................................................................................................................................... 13
Link: Bahrain ............................................................................................................................................ 15
Link: Bahrain Military to Military Assistance .......................................................................................... 16
Link: Libya ............................................................................................................................................... 17
Link: Yemen ............................................................................................................................................. 18
Link: Democracy Process Affs................................................................................................................ 19
Link: Conditions on Assistance ................................................................................................................ 20
Uniqueness: US influences Crumbling ..................................................................................................... 21
Impacts: Case Turn ................................................................................................................................... 22
Impacts: Oppression ................................................................................................................................. 23
Impacts: Democracy Turn ........................................................................................................................ 24
Impact: Military Intervention ................................................................................................................... 25
Impact: Colonialism ................................................................................................................................. 26
Alternative: Support the Agency of Springers .......................................................................................... 27
Alternative: Global Citizenship ................................................................................................................ 28
Answer To: Perm ...................................................................................................................................... 35
Answers To: The Plan helps X Country ................................................................................................... 36
Answer To: Democracy Assistance is Different from Aid/Promotion ..................................................... 39
Answer To: Democ Assistance is Not Intervention .................................................................................. 40
Affirmative Answers: Perm ...................................................................................................................... 42
Affirmative Answer: Global Citizenship Alt ............................................................................................ 44
Affirmative Answer: Democracy Promotion Good .................................................................................. 45
Affirmative Answer: Target Wants the Plan ............................................................................................ 46

ADI 2011
Critical Lab

1
Aff Torture Impacts

Torture Supplement
Torture Supplement ................................................................................................................................................... 1
Torture Impacts.......................................................................................................................................................... 2
Answer To: Disaster Porn.......................................................................................................................................... 9

ADI 2011

AFF Stuff
1

Egypt Aff/Neg Supplements


Egypt Aff/Neg Supplements ....................................................................................................................... 1
***Aff***................................................................................................................................................... 2
Inherency .................................................................................................................................................... 2
Inherency Egyptian Econ Down .............................................................................................................. 3
Inherency MB Wins Now ........................................................................................................................ 4
Inherency MB Wins Now ........................................................................................................................ 5
Inherency MB Wins Now ........................................................................................................................ 6
Solvency Elections Dem Assist Solves Extremism .............................................................................. 7
MB Bad ...................................................................................................................................................... 9
Obama Cred Adv U: Heg Decreasing Now ........................................................................................... 12
Obama Cred Adv ME Peace Solvency .................................................................................................. 15
Egyptian Democracy International Pressure Key .................................................................................. 16
Egyptian Democracy US Key ................................................................................................................ 17
Egypt Modeled ......................................................................................................................................... 18
A2: Kritik No Alt to Liberal Order ........................................................................................................ 19
A2: Muslim Brotherhood Moderate ......................................................................................................... 20
A2: Talks w/ MB ...................................................................................................................................... 21
A2: EU CP No Solvency ....................................................................................................................... 22
A2: Regional Stability DA........................................................................................................................ 24
A2: Israel DA ........................................................................................................................................... 26
***Neg ..................................................................................................................................................... 27
No Inherency ............................................................................................................................................ 27
Inherency MB Wont Win Now ............................................................................................................ 28
Inherency MB Wont Win Now ............................................................................................................ 29
MB Good .................................................................................................................................................. 32
MB Good .................................................................................................................................................. 33
MB Good Not anti-Israel ....................................................................................................................... 36
MB Good Moderate ............................................................................................................................... 37
MB Good Secular .................................................................................................................................. 38
MB Good Non-violent ........................................................................................................................... 39
MB Good Non-violent ........................................................................................................................... 40
MB Good Not Terrorists........................................................................................................................ 41
No Solvency ............................................................................................................................................. 43
No Solvency NGOs ............................................................................................................................... 46
A2: Democracy Advantage....................................................................................................................... 47
A2: US Credibility .................................................................................................................................... 48
A2: US Credibility .................................................................................................................................... 49
A2: US Credibility anti-Arab perception ............................................................................................... 50
CP Solvency Conditions ........................................................................................................................ 51
DA Turns Case Econ ............................................................................................................................. 52

ADI 2011

EU Supplement
1

***EU CP Supplement***
EU CP Supplement .................................................................................................................................................................................................... 1
Uniqueness EU Cred Low....................................................................................................................................................................................... 2
Uniqueness EU Cred Low....................................................................................................................................................................................... 3
Uniqueness EU Cred Low....................................................................................................................................................................................... 4
Uniqueness EU Cred High ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 5
Solvency Egypt ....................................................................................................................................................................................................... 6
Solvency Shield US Aid Rejected .......................................................................................................................................................................... 7
Solvency EU > US .................................................................................................................................................................................................. 8
Solvency Egypt Election Assistance....................................................................................................................................................................... 9
Solvency Arab Spring/ Generic ............................................................................................................................................................................ 10
***AFF Counterplan Answers*** .......................................................................................................................................................................... 11
Permutation .............................................................................................................................................................................................................. 11

ASU 2011
Jason Sanchez

1
File Title

Aff
Aff ........................................................................................ 1
1AC - Inherency................................................................... 3
1AC - Plan ........................................................................... 4
1AC Adv:_____ AQAP .................................................... 5
1AC Adv _____: Yemen Instability ............................... 10
1AC Adv _____: Leadership .......................................... 12

Inherency ............................................................. 14
Aff Inherency Police Corrupt Now ............. 14
Aff Inherency Judges Corrupt Now ............................. 15
Aff Inherency No Independent Judiciary Now ............ 16
Aff Inherency Judges Untrained Now.......................... 17
Aff Inherency AT Prosecuting Terrorists Now ............ 18
Aff Inherency - AT Military Solving Now ..................... 20
Aff Inherency Military Aid Fails Now......................... 21
Aff Inherency More DA Needed.................................. 22
Aff Inherency Violence Now ....................................... 23

AQAP Advantage ................................................ 25

Aff Leadership in Yemen Down Now............................ 58


Aff Democracy solves terrorism .................................... 59
Aff Democracy Solves Econ .......................................... 60
Aff Solvency State Formation ..................................... 61
Aff Solvency - State Formation ...................................... 62
Aff Solvency Free Media ............................................ 64
Aff Solvency US Action.............................................. 65
Aff Solvency CSO ........................................................ 67
Aff Solvency CSO ........................................................ 68
Aff - Major democracy assistance package solves Yemeni
support ............................................................................... 69
Aff Solvency - Democracy Assistance ........................... 70
Aff Solvency Democracy Assistance .......................... 72
Aff Solvency Democracy Assistance Terrorism ...... 74
Aff Solvency Governing Assistance............................ 75
Aff Solvency Governing Assistance Terrorism ......... 76
Aff Solvency Governing Assistance Terrorism ........ 80
Aff Solvency Governing Assistance Terrorism ........ 81
Aff Solvency Power-Sharing Solves Instability .......... 82
Aff Solvency Political Institutions .............................. 83
Aff Solvency Peaceful Transition................................ 85
Aff Solvency MEPI ..................................................... 86
Aff Solvency Laundry List .......................................... 87
Aff Solvency Structural Violence................................ 88
Aff AT No Solvency Tribes ........................................ 89

Aff Inherency AQAP Strong Now ............................... 25


Aff Inherency - AQAP Strong Now................................ 26
Aff Inherency - AQAP Strong Now................................ 27
Aff Military/security approach in Yemen fails ............... 28
Aff Terrorism Advantage ................................................ 29
Aff Terrorism Advantage ................................................ 30
Aff Police - Terrorism ..................................................... 31
Aff Police Bioterrorism................................................ 32
Aff Drone Strikes Increase AQAP strength .................... 34
Aff Solvency US Action - Terrorism ........................... 35
Aff State department law enforcement training solves ... 36
Aff Drone Internal Links ................................................ 37

Random Inherency Args Irrelevant to the Aff..90

Instability ............................................................. 38

Random Adv.........................................................96

Aff Yemen Instability Impact ......................................... 38


Aff Yemen Instability Impact ......................................... 39
Aff Yemen Instability Impact ......................................... 40
Aff Regional Instability .................................................. 41
Aff Yemen Economic Collapse Impacts ......................... 42
Aff Stability Spillover ..................................................... 43
Aff - Yemen Collapse causes Saudi take over ................... 44
Aff Inherency Yemen Econ Collapsing Now .............. 45
Aff - Corruption reforms key to solve................................ 48
Aff AT Companies Adapt to Corrupt Gov ...................... 49
Aff Courts Key to the Economy-General........................ 50

Aff US Leadership Internal Links .................................. 96


Aff Inherency No Womens Rights Now .................... 99

Solvency ............................................................... 51
Aff - Judicial Reform Key ................................................. 51
Aff Judical Reform Solves Corruption ........................ 52
Aff Judicial Reform Solves ............................................. 53
Aff Solvency Law enforcement and Judiciary ............. 54
Aff FYI-What Judicial Reform Initials ........................... 56
Aff - Democracy assistance undermines AQAP recruitment
........................................................................................... 57

Aff Inherency HR Abuse Now .................................... 90


Aff Inherency Not Supporting Democracy Now ......... 91
Aff Inherency No Free Speech Now ........................... 92
Aff Inherency No Democracy Now............................. 93
Aff Inherency Yemen Water Crisis Now .................... 94

Aff Womens Rights Adv ...............................100


Aff Womens Rights Impact Poverty ........................ 101
Aff Womens Rights Impact - Poverty ......................... 102
Aff Womens Rights Impact - Ethics ........................... 104
Aff Solvency Democracy Assistance Womens Rights105
Aff Yemeni Women Want Rights ................................ 106

A2: Neg args .......................................................107


Aff AT Movements DA ............................................... 107
Aff AT Movements DA ............................................... 108
Aff AT Succession DA NU .......................................... 109
Aff AT Succession DA NL .......................................... 111
Aff AT Succession DA No Impact ............................... 112
Aff AT Saudi DA ......................................................... 113
Aff AT Consult CP Perm Do CP ............................... 115
Aff AT EU CP Perm Do Both ................................... 116
Aff A2 EU CP .............................................................. 117

ASU 2011
Jason Sanchez
Aff A2 EU CP ............................................................... 118
Aff AT EU CP No Solvency ...................................... 119
Aff AT UN CP No Solvency - Statistical Support ..... 120
Aff AT UN CP No Solvency Special Interests ....... 121
Aff AT UN CP No Solvency Socialism .................. 122
Aff AT UN CP No Solvency Money Doesnt Reach
People .............................................................................. 123

2
File Title
Aff AT UN CP No Solvency - Method ..................... 124
Aff AT UN CP No Solvency Competing Visions .. 125
Aff AT UN CP Supports Oppression ........................ 126
Aff AT Saudi CP Perm Do Both ............................... 127

ADI 2011
Pointer/Symonds

1
Yemen Neg

Yemen Neg
Yemen Neg .......................................................................... 1

Neg .......................................................................... 2
Neg SQ Solves .................................................................. 2
Neg Inherency - Saudi Arabia Solves Now ...................... 3
Neg Inherency Aid Now ................................................ 4
Neg Inherency AQAP Being Solved Now ..................... 5
Neg Inherency AQAP Being Solved Now ..................... 6
Neg Inherency Leadership in Yemen High Now ........... 7
Neg Yemen Economy stabilizing ..................................... 8
Neg Terrorism No Nuclear Terrorism.......................... 10
Neg Terrorism No Nuclear Terrorism.......................... 11
Neg No Nuclear Terrorism AT: Retaliation ................. 12
Neg No Solvency-Empirically Denied............................ 13
Neg No Solvency Tribes .............................................. 14
Neg No Solvency Yemen Leadership .......................... 15
Neg No Solvency US Action ....................................... 16
Neg No Solvency Public Defection ............................. 17
Neg No Solvency Decentralization .............................. 18
Neg No Solvency Alt Causes ....................................... 20
Neg No Solvency Alt Causes ....................................... 22
Neg No Solvency Ending Patronage ............................ 23
Neg No Solvency Civil Society ................................... 25
Neg No solvency - Womens Rights............................... 26
Neg No solvency - Womens Rights............................... 27
Neg No solvency Parliament........................................ 28
Neg No solvency NGOs............................................... 29
Neg No Solvency - Corruption ....................................... 30
Neg No Solvency ............................................................ 31
Neg No Solvency ............................................................ 32
Neg TURN Governance Assistance bolsters AQAP.... 34
Neg Alt Cause Overwhelms the Case ............................. 35
Neg Democracy Assitance Not Key ............................... 36

Neg Instability Answers No Escalation ....................... 37


Neg AT Economic Instability ......................................... 39
Neg Movements DA....................................................... 40
Neg Movements DA....................................................... 41
Neg Movements DA....................................................... 42
Neg Succession DA 1NC ............................................... 43
Neg Succession DA 1NC ............................................... 44
Neg Succession DA UQ ................................................. 45
Neg Succession DA Link ............................................... 46
Neg Succession DA Impact ............................................ 47
Neg Succession DA Impact ............................................ 48
Neg Succession-Secession D/A ...................................... 49
Neg Heg Answers........................................................... 51
Neg Conditions CP Solves ............................................. 53
Neg UN CP..................................................................... 54
Neg UN Solves - Police Training ................................... 55
Neg UN Solves - Water Management ............................ 56
Neg UN Solves - Experience .......................................... 57
Neg UN Solves - Good-Mandate ................................... 58
Neg US assistance bad for Yemen NGOs ...................... 59
Neg EU CP - Solves ....................................................... 60
Neg PTX GOP Hates Plan.............................................. 61
Neg PTX GOP Hates Plan.............................................. 62
Neg PTX GOP Hates Plan.............................................. 63
Neg PTX Plan Partisan ................................................... 64
Neg PTX Congress Supports .......................................... 65
Neg PTX GOP Supports................................................. 66
Neg PTX Dems Support ................................................. 67
Neg Terrorism Turns ...................................................... 68
Neg Terrorism Turns ...................................................... 69
Neg US is a terrorist nation ............................................ 70
Neg Fragmentation/US promotion Case Turns .............. 71

ADI 2011
Carter/Sydnor

1
Democracy Assistance Neocolonialism Starter K

Democracy Assistance Neocolonialism K


Democracy Assistance K ..................................................... 1
1NC ...................................................................................... 2
1NC ...................................................................................... 3
1NC ...................................................................................... 4
**Links** ............................................................................ 5
Link- Democracy Assistance ............................................... 5
Link- Governmental Action ................................................. 6
Link Governmental Action ............................................... 6
Link Governmental Action ............................................... 7
Link- Soft Power .................................................................. 9
Link- Soft Power ................................................................ 10
Link- Terrorism.................................................................. 11
Link- Terrorism.................................................................. 12
Link- State.......................................................................... 13

Alt- Solvency..................................................................... 20
**Answers To** ............................................................... 21

AT: Democracy Good ...............................................................


AT: Mouffe Colonialism ................................................ 21
AT: Perm ........................................................................... 23
AT: State Good.................................................................. 24
AT: Democracy solves Liberation..................................... 25
AT: Moral Imperative ....................................................... 26
**Aff Answers**

Aff Answer Perm + NB .................................................. 27


Perm .................................................................................. 28
Perm overcomes the link ................................................... 29 14
**Impacts** .........................................................................................................................................................
Aff- Egyptians prefer Democracy ..................................... 30
Impact- Extinction ............................................................. 14
Aff- Democratization Good Great Power Wars Kill ...... 31
Impact- Extinction ............................................................. 15
Aff- Democratic Institutions = Liberation ......................... 32
Impact- Democracy = Oppression ..................................... 16
Aff- Transition Assistance Requires US Action 33
Aff- Demo Assistance Undermines Imperialism............... 34
**Alternative** ...................................................................................................................................................
17
Aff- Demo Assistance Avoids the Link ............................ 35
Rejection Alt / AT: Framework ......................................... 17
Rejection alt / AT: Framework .......................................... 18
Sub-Altern Strategies Alt ................................................... 19

ADI 2011
Fellows

1
Egypt Aff

Egypt Elections Aff


Egypt Elections Aff.............................................................. 1
1AC ...................................................................................... 2
Obama Credibility Adv ........................................................ 2
Obama Credibility Adv ........................................................ 3
Obama Credibility Adv ........................................................ 4
Obama Credibility Adv ........................................................ 5
Obama Credibility Adv ........................................................ 6
Obama Credibility Adv ........................................................ 7
Obama Credibility Adv ........................................................ 8
Elections Adv ....................................................................... 9
Elections Adv ..................................................................... 10
Elections Adv ..................................................................... 11
Elections Adv ..................................................................... 12
Elections Adv ..................................................................... 13
Elections Adv ..................................................................... 14
Elections Adv ..................................................................... 15
Egyptian Democracy Adv .................................................. 16
Egyptian Democracy Adv .................................................. 17
Egyptian Democracy Adv .................................................. 18
Egyptian Democracy Adv .................................................. 19
Solvency ............................................................................ 20

Inherency Aid ................................................... 21


Inherency NGOs ............................................................. 22
Inherency Election Monitoring ....................................... 23
Inherency Egyptian Econ Collapsing .............................. 24
Inherency Election Violence Now .................................. 25
***Obama Cred Adv ......................................................... 26
Solvency - Plan Key to Heg ............................................... 26
Solvency Peaceful Transition.......................................... 27
Solvency US Key/American Interests ............................. 28
Impact Smart Power Laundry List ............................... 29
Impact Soft Power Terrorism ....................................... 30
Impact Soft Power Terrorism ....................................... 31
Internal Link Election k2 New Constitution ................... 32

***Egyptian Demo Adv ...................................... 33


Solvency ME Demo Spillover ........................................ 33

***Elections Adv ................................................. 34


Inherency MB Takeover Now......................................... 34
Muslim Brotherhood Bad Democracy ............................ 35

Muslim Brotherhood Bad Terrorism .............................. 36


Solvency Political Organizations ................................... 37
Solvency Training Programs/Civil Society .................... 38
Solvency Civil Society Key............................................ 39
Solvency Common Rules ............................................... 40
US assistance is key .......................................................... 41
US assistance is key .......................................................... 42
US assistance is key to defeating Muslim Brotherhood .... 43
AT: Monitoring Increases Violence .................................. 44
***Negative ...................................................................... 45
Inherency Egyptian Econ Strong .................................... 45
Inherency International Aid ............................................ 46
Inherency UNDP ............................................................ 47
**Neg Obama Cred Adv ................................................ 48
Status Quo Good ............................................................... 48
Plan Sparks Backlash ........................................................ 49
Plan Sparks Backlash ........................................................ 50

**Neg Elections Adv .........................................51


Inherency No MB Takeover Now .................................. 51
No Impact to MB............................................................... 52
No Impact to MB (Suez Canal) ......................................... 53

**Neg Brotherhood Moderation Adv .............54


Brotherhood Is Democratic ............................................... 54
Brotherhood is Tolerant/Peaceful ...................................... 55
Brotherhood is Tolerant/Peaceful ...................................... 56
No Solvency Egypt Demo Assist Fails Empirically .... 57
No Solvency Civil Society ............................................. 59
No Solvency Capital Flight ............................................ 60
No Solvency Rejection ................................................... 61
No Solvency Permits ...................................................... 62
No Solvency Monitoring Fails ....................................... 63
No Solvency Blocked Funding ....................................... 64
No Solvency Military Wont Relinquish Control........... 65
Democracy Assistance Bad ............................................... 66
Democracy Assistance Bad NGOs ................................. 67
Democracy Assistance Bad Hurts Liberals .................... 68
Election Monitoring Bad Violence ................................. 69

ASU 2011
Fellows

1
EU Counterplan

European Union Counterplan


European Union Counterplan............................................... 1
***Neg Section*** .............................................................. 2
1NC Cards............................................................................ 2
EU Succeeds Generic ........................................................ 3
EU Succeeds Credibility Gap ........................................... 4
EU Succeeds Experience .................................................. 5
EU Succeeds A2: Not Committed .................................... 6
EU Succeeds A2: EU empirically sucks ........................... 7
EU Succeeds CP Solves Better 1/3 ................................... 8
EU Succeeds CP Solves Better 2/3 ................................... 9
EU Succeeds CP Solves Better 3/3 ................................. 10
Solvency Human Rights ................................................. 11
Solvency Conditions Affs ............................................... 12
Solvency Bottom Up Development ................................ 13
Solvency K affs ............................................................... 14
Solvency Radicalism ....................................................... 15
Solvency Regional Stability/ Cooperation ...................... 16
Solvency Good Governance............................................ 17

Solvency Womens Rights ............................................. 18


Solvency Civic Engagement........................................... 19
Solvency Movements/ Local Politics ............................. 20
A/T: EU Fails .................................................................... 21
A/T: US is Superior ........................................................... 22
***Aff Section*** ............................................................ 23
EU = Ineffective - Method ................................................ 23
EU = Ineffective - Goals ................................................... 24
EU Fails - Funding ............................................................ 25
EU Fails - Infighting.......................................................... 26
EU Fails Laundry List .................................................... 27
EU Fails Credibility........................................................ 28
EU Fails Unconditional Aid ........................................... 29
EU Fails Decentralized ................................................... 30
EU Fails Civil Society .................................................... 31
EU Fails Egypt ............................................................... 32

ASU 2011
Ziegler/Roark

1
Ptx Starter Pack

Politics Starter Pack


Politics Starter Pack .......................................... 1
1NC...................................................................... 2
1NC...................................................................... 3
Yes Pass ............................................................... 4
Yes Pass ............................................................... 5
Yes Pass ............................................................... 6
Spending Link XT ............................................... 7
PC Key................................................................. 8
Yes PC ................................................................. 9
AT: Thumpers Demo Assistance .................... 10
AT: Thumpers Egypt Demo Assistance ......... 11
Republicans Link/IL .......................................... 12
Egypt Unpopular General ............................... 13
Egypt Unpopular Spending ............................ 14
Assistance Unpopular Regime Change
Conflation .......................................................... 15
AT: Plan Popular Entropy .............................. 16
AT LT: Winners Win ..................................... 17
PC K Agenda ..................................................... 18
AT No Default ................................................ 19

AT Default Short .............................................20


Debt Ceiling K Econ ..........................................21
Debt Ceiling K Econ ..........................................22
Econ MPX ..........................................................23
Econ MPX ..........................................................24
***AFF..................................................................24
No Pass ...............................................................25
No Pass ...............................................................26
No Pass ...............................................................27
Thumpers ............................................................28
No PC .................................................................29
No Link No Conservative Backlash ................30
Egyptian Election Assistance Popular ................31
Egyptian Election Assistance Popular ................32
Winners Win.......................................................33
PC =/= Key .........................................................34
MPX D No Default..........................................35
MPX D Econ =/= War .....................................36