LEAD SHEET
Person reporting information:
NAME:
ft/
ep
p
P4
ADDRESS:______________________________
PHONE: (home)
3?//
(Work_________________________
Where dCcl you see victim?
__________________________________________
When did you see victim?
C Date & time)
_____________________________
Was victim alone?_______ If with someone, do you know other
person?________ Can you describe other person?___________________
Direction and mode of travel? fie. walking, riding, driving)
I C in vehicle, can you describe vehicle?
What was the victim wearing?_________________________________________
Did you make personal contact with victim?_______________________
f so, what was content of conversation, if any?________________
What was victim doing when seen?________________________________
Were you alone when you saw victim?_____ If not., please tell US
who was with you_________________________________________________
you know victim personally, or did you identify from his/her
s cr Pt ion?___________________________________________
v other information you can provide us with?__________________
rovers i needed)
V
(
t
i
,
N
4
/
4
I
i
Iw-
I
00
PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
Respondent,
-against-
GARY THIBODEAU,
Defendant-Appellant.
STATE OF NEW YORK)
COUNTY OF OSWEGO) 5$.:
1, Tracey Breckenridge, being duly sworn, deposes and states as follows:
1. At the time Heidi Allen disappeared in 1994 I was married to Roger Breckenridge
and we lived together on Kenyon Road, not far from Gary Thibodeau. Roger left
our house that Easter morning, although I am not sure about the time, it could have
been between 8:00 and 9:00 AM. He went to his brothers house in Parish for
coffee.
2. Roger returned later that day for supper.
3. I recalled a conversation between Roger and Thumper during which Roger said he
did not want anything to do with the van. At some point during or after their
conversation, I left the house and when I returned home Roger was gone. I thought,
oh God, did he go with Thumper to get rid of the van?
4. Roger and I separated sometime in 1994, after Heidi Allen disappeared, Roger did
go to Florida with Jen, but I do not recall when they went.
5. Every time I turned around I was getting pulled over in Mexico and I was repeatedly
asked to provide more information about the Heidi Allen case and I was fed up with
Donald Dodd. I gave him a written statement 20 years ago and I recently gave
another statement to investigators. They were out at our house so many times it was
unreal.
Sworn to before me this
j.day of August 2014
Ftentdiflo0
.
Not2IS1&f NY
Appointed In OnondagaCo
Reg#01SA5070697
My CommIeson Expires 1243.4g.
COUNTY COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF OSWEGO: CRIMINAL TERM
AFFIDAVIT
INDICTMENT #94-161
Tracey
EXHIBIT EE
COUNTY COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF OSWEGO: CRIMINAL TERM
PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
Respondent,
-against-
GARY THIBODEAU,
Defendant-Appellant.
AFFIDAVIT
INDICTMENT #94-161
STATE OF NEW YORK)
COUNTY OF OSWEGO) $5.:
I Linda McKie, being duly sworn depose and state as follows:
J.iIt
qii.n+h
45O 5
.
1. I was recently contacted by a friend of mine who I told severpl yar&ago about a man
telling my husband and I that he drove crushed vehicles to Canada and he was sure Heidi
Allen was in one of the loads. My friend directed me to the recent media accounts about
a van used in the abduction of Heidi Allen being crushed and shipped to Canada. I was
alarmed and very upset because neither my husband nor I ever said anything to the police
because we did not know whether to believe him.
2. These statements were made by Ed Lewis, an individual we met in 2006 and we started
socializing with him regularly for about a year. He told us that he worked for Richard
Murtaugh driving crushed vehicles. I do not know whether he worked full time for
Murtaugh or periodically because we never asked him. On approximately five occasions
he specifically told us that he drove a load of crushed cars to Canada and he was sure
Heidi Allen was in those cars. He was very serious when he made these statements to my
husband and I and we feel terrible that we never said anything.
Linda cKie
Sworn to before me this
,,?t day of August, 2014
Notary Public
LISA A. PEOELES
Notary
Pubto, State t tew York
Quatfd in
Onondaga County
[cg.
IO2PE5O2123
Wi
Comrr,0Si00
Expires Dec. 13, 20_
i
f
i
Iw-
I
-
F
1
1
COUNTY COURT Of THE STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF OSWEGO: CRIMiNAL TERM
PEOPLE OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
Respondent,
-against-
GARY THIBODEAU,
Defendant-Appellant.
AFFIDAVIT
INDICTMENT #94-16 1
STATE OF NEW YORK)
COUNTY OF OSWEGO) 5$.:
I Clifford McKie, being duly sworn depose and state as follows:
1. My wife and I recently heard about new evidence surfacing in the Heidi Allen case and
we were concerned when we realized there was information that a van used in the
abduction of Heidi Allen may have been crushed and sent to Canada. This information
was consistent with admissions made by a man we befriended several years ago.
2. These statements were made by Ed Lewis, an individual we met in 2006 and we started
socializing with him regularly for about a year. He told us that he worked for Richard
Murtaugh driving crushed vehicles. We do not know whether he worked full time for
Murtaugh or periodically because we never asked him. On approximately five occasions
he specifically told us that he drove a load of crushed cars to Canada and he was sure
Heidi Allen was in those cars. He was very serious when he made these statements to my
wife and I, and we feel terrible that we never said anything.
Clifford McKie
Sworn to before me this
,70.C
day of August, 2014
Notary Public
USA A. PEBBLES
Notaiy Pubc. State of New Yoric
Onalified in Onandaga County
Beg.
102PE5021 239
LyCarnmiSSiOll
Expires Dec. 13,20
I
l
l
Iw-
I
00
COUNTY COURT OF THE STATE Of NEW YORK
COUNTY OF OSWEGO: CRIMiNAL TERM
PEOPLE OF THE STATE Of NEW YORK,
Respondent,
-against-
GARY THIBODEAU,
Defendant-Petitioner.
AFFIDAVIT
INDICTMENT #94-161
STATE Of NEW YORK)
COUNTY Of OSWEGO) SS.:
I, Elizabeth Head, being duly sworn, depose and state:
1. I sat as Juror #3 in the Gary Thibodeau trial in 1995 and after sending out 15 notes and
deliberating for approximately four hours we returned a verdict of guilty against Mr. Thibodeau
for first-degree kidnapping.
2. I have always been bothered by our decision because we were never certain he was guilty and
there really wasnt much to go on because there was no hard evidence. We kind of felt like there
had to be something or they wouldnt have gotten that far.
3. Recently, I learned about several potential suspects who may have been the actual perpetrators of
Heidi Allens abduction and I am haunted by the thought we may have been responsible for
sending an innocent man to prison. I am very upset to learn that we were not provided all of the
facts during the trial. In particular the fact that Heidi Allen was a drug informant and the Deputy
i) dropped an index card disclosing the fact she was an informant1in-the very paikig lt in vhih
V
h have been critical during our deliberations. This
information alone would have definitely widened the scope of possible suspects and made a
difference in my decision.
4. After listening to the phone conversation between Tonya Priest and Jennifer Wescott, I was more
convinced that Gary Thibodeau was wrongly convicted and I believe he should be released
immediately.
Ebeth Head
Sworn to me this
qAA
_____
day of August 2014.
USA A. PEPDLF
Notary Pubrc, $tate of Nw Yor1
Qualified In Onondaga County
Notary Public Reg. 102PE5021239
ty Commission Expires Dec. 13,
204(1
mzw-
I
zz
COUNTY COURT Of THE STATE Of NEW YORK
COUNTY Of OSWEGO: CRIMINAL TERM
PEOPLE Of THE STATE OF NEW YORK,
Petitioner,
-against-
GARY THIBODEAU,
Respondent.
AFFIDAVIT
INDICTMENT #94-1
STATE Of NEW YORK
COUNTY OF OSWEGO SS.:
I, Amanda Braley, being duly sworn depose and state as follows:
Between 2000 and 2006, I hung out with, among others, Jennifer Wescoff, James
Steen (Thumper), Roger Breckenridge and Tonya Priest. There were multiple
conversations between Steen, Breckenfidge and Wescott when they discussed
scrapping the van used in the abduction of Heidi Allen.
2. I specifically recall admissions made by Steen and Breckenridge regarding the
crushing of the van at Murtaughs junk yard and then transporting it to Canada. I
heard them say her body was still in the van and she would never be found. I
remember len Wescott laughing about it when they would make these statements
and I heard Jen talk about driving the van to Murtaughs.
3. In 2003, there were five or six people, including myself and we were standing on
the back/side deck of Jennifer Wescotts parents house on County Route 3$ in
Hastings. We were just hanging out having a conversation and, although I do not
recall how, the topic of Heidi Mien came up. Someone mentioned her name and
Jen and Roger just laughed. Roger then stated, we took that bitch to the scrap
yard in the van, had it crushed and she was shipped to Canada. Shes long gone
now. He swung his hand up and pointed his finger in the northern direction of
the sky and said, see-ya-bye. He laughed and Jen slapped him on his shoulder
and said, Roger, you cant be saying that shit. He responded with what Jen?
That shit is done and over with, and besides nobody is ever going to find her.
Roger proceeded to laugh and Jen shook her head and rolled her eyes and said,
whatever Roger.
4. Sometime in 2006, Tonya Priest asked me to walk with her in the woods to try
and find a cabin where she said Steen told her Heidi Allen was buried. We never
found a cabin or Heidi Allens remains.
5. I never came forward because I feared for my safety but I have always believed
their claims and admissions.
Sworn to me before me this
5fday of August, 2014.
Notary Public
RICHARD L. HAUMANN
Notary
PibLc in the State of New York
Qualifi8d ia Onon. Co. No. Oifl.k6O2683l
My
Comm.
Expiree June 1 Z5
I I L I 9 I H X !