E-BANKING SERVICE PERCEPTION: AN EVALUATION OF AUTO TELLER MACHINE (ATM) USAGE IN UGANDA
BY
ASERE GLORIA SANDRA (S10B05/029)
A dissertation submitted to the faculty of Business & Administration in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the Award of Bachelors of Business Administration degree of Uganda Christian University- Mukono.
2013
ii
DECLARATION
I ASERE GLORIA SANDRA declare that this research report is my original work and to the best of my knowledge has never been submitted to any institution for any academic award.
NAME: ASERE GLORIA SANDRA Signature Date :.
iii
APPROVAL
This is to certify that this research report by ASERE GLORIA SANDRA was done under my supervision and is now ready for submission with my approval to faculty of Business and Administration.
Signature .Date. Dr.OLOBO MAURICE
iv
DEDICATION
I dedicate this work to my dear parents Mr. and Mrs. Ochieng David Ngereza for your love and support that they wholly heartedly gave me and for putting their own ambitions on hold and for accepting my studies as the last born. To my sister M/s NyanduriDaphine and brothers MR Ngereza Patrick, OchiengErisa and Bob Rawlings for all the guidance and advice and to all my friends who have assisted me in one way or another.
v
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I take this opportunity to thank the Almighty God for having given the gift of life plus my parents who bare me and also gave me a chance in life to attain all the benefits of my course at Uganda Christian University. I appreciate the efforts of all my respondents who offered me all the assistance I needed while I was doing my research especially the students (my class mates). My God reward them for their kindness and the spare time offered. Among all is my supervisor Mr. OLOBO MAURICE for giving me all the maximum attention and having patience when there was a delay and above all for the excellent guidance that was needed to complete my research smoothly. I am also indebted to send my special thanks to the following people; My parents for all the support they gave me while I was doing my degree; my sister and brothers for the help they gave me while I was doing this work; My friends Maling Samuel, Nambozo Faith, NamukobeBarbra, WeragireDarion, Brenda .A, Alice M and many others who gave me a hand while I was doing this work.
vi
ACRONYMS
P.U - Perceived Usefulness
PEOU - Perceived Ease of Use
B.I - Behavioral Intention TRA - Theory of Reasoned Action
TAM - Technology Acceptance Model
ATM - Auto Teller Machine
St.D - Standard deviation
SA - Strongly Agree
A - Agree
NS - Not Sure D - Disagree SD - Strongly Disagree.
vii
LIST OF TABLES Table 4-1: Back Ground Research Data ..................................................................................29 Table 4-2: Perceived Usefulness of Auto Teller Machines (ATM) ............................................30 Table 4-3: Perceived Ease of Use of Auto Teller Machines (ATM) ...........................................31 Table 4-4: Behavioral Intention to Use Auto Teller Machines (ATMs) .....................................32 Table 4-5: Bank Policy on ATM Usage ....................................................................................33 Table 4-6: Internet Accessibility .............................................................................................33
LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1-1: conceptual frame work....5
viii
TABLE OF CONTENTS DECLARATION ........................................................................................................................... i APPROVAL .............................................................................................................................. iii DEDICATION ........................................................................................................................... iv ACKNOWLEDGEMENT.............................................................................................................. v ACRONYMS ............................................................................................................................. vi LIST OF TABLES ...................................................................................................................... vii ABSTRACT ............................................................................................................................... xi CHAPTER ONE; ........................................................................................................................1 1.0 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................................1 1.1Background of the study .....................................................................................................1 1.2 statement of the problem ..................................................................................................2 1.3 The purpose of the study ...................................................................................................2 1.3.1 The specific objectives ....................................................................................................2 1.4 Research Questions ...........................................................................................................3 1.5 The scope of the study .......................................................................................................3 1.6 Significance of the study ....................................................................................................3 1.7 The limitations of the study ...............................................................................................4 CHAPTER TWO. .......................................................................................................................6 LITERATURE REVIEW ................................................................................................................6 2.1. Introduction ......................................................................................................................6 2.2. Perceived usefulness, Perceived ease of use and Behavioral Intention to use on ATMs ....7 2.3. Perceived usefulness and behavioral intention to use ATM ............................................11 2.4. Behavioral intention and ATM System ............................................................................13 2.5. Perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness .............................................................15 2.6. Perceived ease of use and behavioral intention to use ATM ...........................................21 ix
CHAPTER THREE ....................................................................................................................24 3.1 Introduction .....................................................................................................................24 3.2 Area of Study ...................................................................................................................24 3.3 Research Design...............................................................................................................24 3.4 Target Population ............................................................................................................25 3.5 Sampling Method / Sampling Size ....................................................................................25 3.6 Data Collection Methods .................................................................................................25 3.7 Data Collection Instruments.............................................................................................26 3.8 Research Procedure .........................................................................................................26 3.9 Data Analysis and Presentation ........................................................................................27 3.10 Ethical Considerations ....................................................................................................27 3.11 Limitation of the Study...................................................................................................27 CHAPTER FOUR .....................................................................................................................28 4.1 Back ground data of the Respondents..............................................................................28 4.2. Response on Perceived Usefulness of the Auto Teller Machines (ATM)...........................30 4.3. Perceived Ease of Use of Auto Teller Machine (ATM) ......................................................30 4.4. Behavioral Intention to Use Auto Teller Machines (ATMs) ..............................................31 4.5. Bank Policy implication on Auto Teller Machine (ATM) Usage .........................................33 4.6. Assessing the level of Internet Accessibility.....................................................................33 CHAPTER FIVE .......................................................................................................................35 5.0 INTRODUCTION ...............................................................................................................35 5.1 DISCUSSION OF THE FINDINGS .........................................................................................35 5.2 CONCLUSIONS .................................................................................................................37 5.3 RECOMMENDATIONS ......................................................................................................37 5.4 AREAS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH ......................................................................................38 REFERENCES ..........................................................................................................................39 x
APPENDICES QUESTIONAIRE FOR AUTO TELLER MACHINE (ATM) USERS/ HOLDRES..............................42 Introductory letter...46
xi
ABSTRACT The study examines E-banking service perceptions; An evaluation of Auto Teller Machine (ATM) usage in Uganda. Its expected that once customers perceive the ATM system to be useful, this consequently influences their Behavioral Intention to use the system. Further their Perceived Ease of Use influences their Perceived Usefulness leading to Behavioral Intention to use the ATM system. A conceptual frame work was developed relating to Technology Acceptance Model (TAM). Most Technology Acceptance Model studies have been empirical investigations, using the survey approach with great success. TAM is a mature model and has been validated in the different contexts. The study used Statistical package for Social Scientists (SPSS v 16.0) which was used for data analysis, Questionnaires and Observation during data collection was used during the field work study. Here, different levels of variance analysis on the TAM construct in the context of Auto Teller Machine (ATM) banking acceptance has been applied. The findings suggested that male or female, old young, ATM banking customers conceptualized the TAM construct in very similar ways. These findings allowed us to understand TAMs validity in Technology Acceptance research in relation to ATM banking in Financial Institutions.
1
CHAPTER ONE;
INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND OF THE STUDY; 1.0 INTRODUCTION This study is intended to ascertain e-banking service perceptions; an evaluation of ATM usage in Uganda. This chapter presents the background of the study, the statement of the problem, the objectives of the study, research questions, and significance of the study, the scope and limitations of the study. 1.1Background of the study In the traditional methods of banking, the use of bank tellers was the way to provide one on one contact with the customers. However, the need to provide a 24 hour continuous service and reduction of congestion in the banking hall,the ATM was brought on board as a way of improving these services. The need for cost reduction in the use of back-office staff also prompted the introduction of the ATM service. This brought about a lot of expectations from both the bank and the customers on the performance of this self-service technology. Globally ATMs (Automatic Teller Machines) first came into use in December 1972 in the UK. (http:Wikipedia.org/wiki/automated-teller-mechanic). In Uganda, ATMs were introduced in the banking sector in 1990s; the first ATM was brought in by SCI/NCR for Standard Chartered bank in September, 1997 (www.enteruganda.com). Theoretically customers perception of service consists of two dimensions. Berry and Parasuraman (1991) distinguish a process and an outcome dimension. Of the five dimensions of quality, reliability is primarily concerned with the service outcome, whereas the rest are primarily concerned with the service process. However, all the five dimensions emphasize the customers perception of the service (functional quality) rather than the service providers view of how the service should be delivered (technical quality).Gronroos (1990) however makes the distinction between functional and technical quality. The process of functional quality refers to how the service is delivered, whereas technical quality which is the outcome refers to what customers receive (the benefits of using the service). In the case of the ATM, how cash is processed is a functional benefit, whereas effectiveness, less time spent in an ATM, easy to use and efficiency over the traditional methods are known as technical benefit. 2
Parasuraman, Berry and Zeithaml (1988) categorized service quality in to five dimensions namely; reliability, tangibles, responsiveness, assurance, empathy. Reliability refers to the ability to perform the promised service dependably andaccurately. Relates to the ability to provide a service as expected by customers in terms of speed (how quick the transaction is performed), accuracy (how correct is the transaction in terms of money withdrawn) and if the equipment is operational 24 hours as expected. ATMs provide customers with numerous benefits such as time and cost savings, greater control over the service delivery ( Meuter and Bitner, 1998), convenience (Kauffman and Lally,1994), enjoyment (Dabholkar 1996) and sometimes even spontaneous delight (Bitner el al;2000). Despite these benefits, some consumers consider ATMs threatening (Curran el al; 2003). Anxiety and low-perceived ease of use are two common barriers inhibiting consumers usage of ATMs (Meuter et al; 2003). Yet, its in the interest of service organizations to reduce these barriers as ATMs can reduce costs, increase productivity ( Dahbolkor,1996) and improve competitiveness and market share (Bitner, 1998). 1.2 statement of the problem The ATM system was originally introduced in the banking sector to reduce on the congestions in the banking hall, since the ATMs were to provide a 24 hour continuous service to the people. In spite the installation of automatic teller machines (ATMs) by financial institutions in the bank premises and other strategic locations in the country, there is still congestion in the banking halls. A study carried out by (Ssenfuma, 2007) on the relationship between ATM operations on customer service quality, indicated that 12.5% miss the human teller smile. The study further revealed that over 67.5% of the customers agreed that ATMs retard customer relationship; this has been caused by the failure of the ATMs to meet the expectations of the customers and the adoption of ATM usage being affected by the different service perceptions. 1.3 The purpose of the study The purpose of this study was to examine e-banking service perceptions; an evaluation of ATM usage in Uganda. 1.3.1 The specific objectives The study was guided by the following objectives, 3
i) To establish the effect of service perception on behavioural intension to use the ATM system. ii) To establish the relationship between behavioural intention and congestion in the banking halls. iii) To examine the influence of the bank policy and internet accessibility on behavioural intension to use the actual ATM system. 1.4 Research Questions The study was guided by the following research questions, i) What is the effect of service perception on behavioral intension to use the ATM system? ii) What is the relationship between behavioral intension to use and congestion in the Banking halls? iii) What is the influence of the banks policy and internet accessibility on behavioral intension to use the actual ATM system? 1.5 The scope of the study 1.5.1 Theoretical scope The study was carried out based on two theories that is Theory of Reasoned Action(TRA) by Fishbein and Ajezen 1975 and the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) pioneered by Davis in 1989. These two theories were used to analyze and evaluate ATM usage in Uganda.
1.5.2 Geographical scope The study was limited to financial institutions (banks) with in Kampala. 1.6 Significance of the study This research will help management of the banking sector analyze the importance of service perception on customersbehavioral intension to use the ATM. since it has got a great impact on customers usage of the ATM system. This research will help bring about improvement of the ATM facility as this will enlighten the management about the importance of service quality improvement in the ATM system. 4
This research will help improve on the level of technology being provided by the ATM service system that is in terms of security and options being provided during the transactions in an ATM. And in addition improve on the maximum amount of money that is allowed to be withdrawn with a day by the clients. 1.7 The limitations of the study The research was limited by the negative attitude of same of the respondents during the answering of the questionnaires. Same respondents attitude kept changing negatively; hence this greatly affected their response to the different questions asked, making same questionnaires invalid and not reliable to the study. The respondents didnt have the time to answer same of the questions in the questionnaires. This left same of the vital questions un answered during the research study in the field. As, same of the respondents didnt have the time to answer the questionnaires at all. This reduced the sample space that was originally planned in the research study. The different moods of the respondents towards the questions also greatly affected limited the research. Same respondents have swinging moods depending on the questions asked; this makes their responses towards the questions unreliable at all, since one is not sure if the respondent was in his/her mood at that time.
5
Fig 1-1: The Conceptual Framework Source: Researcher
Perceived Ease of use. Perceived Usefulness Behavioral intention Congestion
Internet accessibility. Bank policy Power availability
6
CHAPTER TWO. LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1. Introduction This chapter presents a review of related literature on the study variables especially perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use and behavioral intention to use. The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is an information systems theory that models how users come to accept and use a technology. The model suggests that when users are presented with a new technology, a number of factors influence their decisions about how and when they will use it. Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) posits that two particular beliefs, perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use, can predict ATM actual use. Perceived usefulness and ease of use are meant to be fairly general determinants of actual use. According to TAM, perceived usefulness is influenced by perceived ease of use because the easier a technology is to use, the more useful it can be (Dabholkar, 1996).
The Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA), (Fishbein and Ajezen 1975), posits that perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use determine an individuals intension to use a system, with intention to use servicing as a mediator of ATM usage. According to TRA (Theory of Reasoned Action), the unique behaviour of an individual is determined by ones behavioral intention (BI) to act on the behaviour, and it is performed in conjunction with an individuals attitude and subjective norm of the behaviour that is being performed. Both the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) and Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA) have strong behavioral elements that assume that when same one forms an intention to act, they will be free to act without limitations.
7
2.2.Perceived usefulness, Perceived ease of use and Behavioral Intention to use on ATMs TAM has earlier postulated that two beliefs, known as (i) the Perceived Usefulness and (ii) the Perceived Ease of Use, determine the attitudes of people toward using a particular system. Such attitudes together with Perceived Usefulness would subsequently determine use intention and furthermore, this would lead to the actual use of the system. Studies by Agarwal and Karahanna (2000) and Venkatesh and Davis (2000) both indicate that Perceived Ease of Use and Perceived Usefulness affect behavioral intentions through direct and indirect forms. Other researchers like Szajna (1996) posit that Perceived Usefulness has a direct influence on intention whereas the Perceived Ease of Use has only an indirect effect on intention through Perceived Use.
This is similar with the findings of Chen et al. (2003), who found that Perceived Usefulness appears to be the only construct that has a significant direct influence on intention. On the other hand, Mallat et al. (2006) suggested that the effect of usefulness on use intention is dependent on situations where a system is used, even though Perceived Usefulness and Perceived Ease of Usefulness are the primary predictors concerning beliefs about use intentions. In contrast, a study by Wu and Wang (2005) revealed that ease of use and usefulness was both significant factors that affect the use of a technology generally. Hence, a research model and associated hypotheses below were developed to guide this study. In the Malaysian context, it should be noted that researches on technology use have demonstrated that the Perceived Ease of Use and Perceived Usefulness are important predictors on the decision to not only adopt a technology but also to continue to use that technology (Guriting and Ndubisi, 2006; Ignatius and Ramayah, 2005; Ramayah, 2005, 2006a, 2006b; Ramayah and Jantan, 2004; Ramayah et al., 2005).
A significant body of TAM studies (e.g. Davis, 1989; Mathieson, 1991; Adams et al., 1992; Segars and Grover, 1993; Sjazna, 1994; Igbaria et al., 1997) has shown that perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use are determinants of usage. Martocchio (2005) pointed out that customers system use can be predicted reasonably well from their intentions, intervened between usefulness and behaviour intention to use. Malone (1990) in her study proved that perceived usefulness influences ones emerged the major determinant of ATM use acceptance though behavioral intention to use had a significant effect beyond perceived 8
usefulness. It has been noted that customers intention to use and ease of use have got a critical impact on successful use of the ATM system (Venkatesh, 1996). He further asserts that, if customers are not willing to accept a particular system, it will not bring full benefits to the bank. The more accepting of a system the customers are, the more willing they are to make changes in their time and effort to use the system.
The Theory of Reasoned Action (TRA), (Fishbein and Ajezen 1975), posits that Perceived Usefulness and Perceived Ease of Use determine an individuals intention to use a system, with intention to use servicing as a mediator of ATM usage. Perceived Usefulness is yet seen as being directly impacted by Perceived Ease of Use. In a bid to extend the TAM model three approaches have been taken into consideration, say by introducing additional or alternative belief factors, by introducing factors from related models and by examining antecedents and moderators of Perceived Usefulness and Perceived Ease of Use (Wixam and Todd, 2005). Both the TAM and TRA have strong behavioral elements that assume that when same one forms an intension to act, they will be free to act without limitation. In reality constraints such as limited ability, time, environment or organization limits and unconscious habits will limit the freedom to act. Perceived Ease of Use and Perceived Usefulness predict the attitude towards the system, which in turn predicts behavioral intention to use the system. which in turn predicts use of the ATM.
Fishbeins and Azjens (1975) theory of reasoned action provides the theoretical basis for TAM. Fishbein and Ajzen hypothesized that an individuals behaviour depends on his or her intention to use the system. The individuals evaluation with respect to the act, and the persons subjective norm or perception of the normative pressures regarding the behaviour. Davis (1986, 1989) adopted the belief, attitude-intention-behaviour sequence to explain user acceptance of information technology.
According to Davis et al. (1989), TAM was intended to provide an explanation of the determinants of system acceptance that is general, capable of explaining user behaviour across a broad range of end-user computing technologies. Davis (1986) proposed that perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use predict usage of the system. With theoretical support from various theories and models including expectancy theory, self-efficacy theory, cost-benefit research, innovation research, and the channel disposition model, TAM 9
postulates that computer usage is a function of the end-users behavioral intention to use the system.
Davis and Davis et al proposed TAM to address why users accept or reject information systems. Their model is an adaptation of the theory of reasoned action proposed by Fishbein and Ajzen to explain and predict the behaviors of people in a specific situation. TAM is to provide a basis for tracing the impact of external variables on internal beliefs,attitudes, and intentions. It suggests that perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness are the two most important factors in explaining system use.
Behavioral intention was jointly determined by a persons attitude toward using the system as well as the end-users perception of the usefulness of the system. TAM also postulates that perceived usefulness is influenced by perceived ease of use and external variables. External variables that influence perceived usefulness include features of the system, training, documentation, demographic characteristics of end-users, and end-user support.
TRA and TAM propose that external variables intervene indirectly, influencing attitude, subjective norms, or their relative weight in the case of TRA, or influencing perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness in the case of TAM. Behavioral intention to use is a common construct in both TRA and TAM, and Davis usedFishbein and Ajzens method to measure them. Davis chose not to keep the variable subjective norms, because he estimated that it had negligible effect on Behavioral intention. In TAM2, Venkatesh and Davis reconsidered this choice.
Perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use are strong determinants of behavioral intention to adopt ATM banking system. Also an indirect effect of computer self-efficacyand prior general computing experience on behavioral intention through perceived usefulness perceived ease of use. The Technology Acceptance Model pioneered by Davis (1989) advances the TRA by postulating that perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use are key determinants that inevitably lead to the actual usage of a particular system. Perceived ease of use has a direct effect on both perceived usefulness and technology usage (Adams, Nelson & Todd, 1992; Davis, 1989).
10
Having discussed technology acceptance in light of the TAM model and other modified theories relating to technology acceptance with all its constructs, its necessary we discuss why some customers reject ATM system use in Commercial Banks. As regards the review of some of the most popular theory, the focus is basically on elements that encourage acceptance of technology. There is scarcity of theory on why customers do not accept ATM system use. The review of the literature and the theory speaks to the need for further research in this area and for the need to expand upon current theories which focus solely on technology acceptance. TAM and TAM2, TRA, and TRB theories, as already described are the prominent theories which have established a base of academic knowledge on technology acceptance.
All of the literature is derived from the concept of intention based theory; intention that when exercised allows an individual to adopt technology. Yet what then is the theory that causes an individual to reject technology? If intention and attitude remain at the heart of behaviour, we must scrutinize the motives that result in rejection of technology in order to provide a balanced view of why someone would reject using ATM banking system. On the surface it is one of the most logical and convenient technological devices that one could utilize. Ease of use, convenience and personal security are the hallmarks of ownership of this technology. Yet there are a proportion of Commercial Bank customers who choose to reject this seemingly beneficial service. What are the intentions and attitudes that drive the behaviour of rejection and resentment?
(Goode, 2005) asserts that, acceptance is not the opposite of rejection. Technology rejection, as a topic, has been largely ignored in the research literature. Goode produced a working paper that looked at the current literature on technology rejection. He calls for the advancement of further research in order to develop an adequate understanding of why organizations and end-users reject information technology systems. From that research, existing theory can be expanded or new theory developed, as to why technology is rejected.
There exists a general belief in the IT community that technology adoption leads to organizational success as well as the success of end-users. Yet not everyone adopts technology and the reasons why do not appear to be well researched or understood. There is a call for new thinking and new approaches to the adoption problem. Research has overlooked the thinking that rejection of technology is in fact an alternative to acceptance. 11
Understanding why people accept or reject information systems has proven to be one of the most challenging issues. (Davis et al. 1989) This same statement can apply to individuals acceptance or rejection of ATM banking system in Commercial Banks.
As Davis (1989) noted, future technology acceptance research needs to address how other variables affect usefulness, ease of use, and user acceptance. However, factors affecting the acceptance of a new IT are likely to vary with the technology, target users, and context(Moon and Kim, 2001). Recent research has indicated that trust has a striking influence on user willingness to engage in online exchanges of money and personal sensitiveinformation (e.g. Hoffman et al., 1999; Friedman et al., 2000). Therefore, PEU and PU may not fully reflect the users intention to adopt Internet banking, necessitating a search for additional factors that better predict the acceptance of e- banking.
2.3. Perceived usefulness and behavioral intention to use ATM Perceived Usefulness is the degree to which an individual believes that using a particular system would enhance his or her job performance (Al-Gahtani, 2001; Davis, 1993; Mathwick et al., 2001). Another study by Tan and Teo(2000) indicates that Perceived Usefulness is an important factor in determining the adaptation of innovations. As observed by Bhattacherjee (2002), a persons willingness to transact with a particular system is already considered as Perceived Usefulness. It shows that user behaviour is determined by perceptions of usefulness and the ease of use of the technology (Adams et al., 1992). According to Gong and Xu (2004) he defines perceived usefulness as the users subjective probability that using a specific application system will increase his or her expectations. Awamieh R. &Fernandes, C (2006) added that perceived usefulness is the degree to which a potential customer views ATM banking as offering advantages over previous ways of performing the banking transactions.
Behavioral intention to use is the measure of the strength of ones intention to perform a specified behaviour (Malhotra, Y 1999). According to Chan, (2004) underlying processes in which a customer engages when he/she adopts induced behaviour may be different.He presented three different processes that greatly affect customers behaviour: compliance: when an individual adopts the induced behaviour not because she believes in its content but with the expectation of gaining rewards; Identification: when an individual accepts influence 12
because she wants to establish a satisfying self-defining relationship to another person and; Internalization, when a customer accepts influence because it is congruent with her value system. By distinguishing between these processes, one ascertains that behavioral intention to use a system is influenced by perceived usefulness.
Previous researches have provided evidence of the significant effect of Perceived usefulness on behavioral intention to use (Agarwal& Prasad, 1999; Davis et al., 1989; Venkatesh, 1999; Venkatesh, 2000; Venkatesh& Morris, 2000; Chau& Hu, 2001; Ramayah et al., 2003; Pikkarainen, et al., 2004). Perceived usefulness has a direct effect on behavioral intention and above attitude. The perceived usefulness behavioral intention relationship is strongly based on the idea that, people form intention toward behaviors they believe will increase their system use, over and above whatever positive or negative feeling may be evoked toward the behaviour. Hence, the Perceived usefulness -behavioral intention relationship in TAM represents the outcome of direct effect, hypothesizing that people form intention toward using ATM system based on a cognitive appraisal of how it will improve their ATM system use.
Davis original model explains perceived usefulness and behavioral intention to use in terms of social influence and cognitive instrumental processes. The extended model was tested in both voluntary and mandatory settings. The results strongly supported model and the authors were able to explain 60% of their adoption model using this updated version of TAM(Venkatesh and Davis 2000). The study highlights social influence through subjective norm, defined as persons perception that most people who are important to him think he should or should not perform the behaviour in question, significantly influences perceived usefulness. Cognitive factors also play an important role. For example, the greater the perceived system relevance, defined as the individuals perception regarding the degree to which the target system is applicable to his or her job) of a new system is, the more important output quality (defined as the consideration of how well the system performs those tasks) becomes. (Venkatesh, Davis, 2000).
Venkatesh and Davis (2000) presented theoretical extensions to the technology Acceptance Model (TAM) (Davis, 1986, 1989). Their new model, TAM2, explains perceived usefulness in terms of cognitive and social influence processes. Vankatesh and Davis suggested job relevance, one of the cognitive processes that demonstrated a statistically significant relationship with perceptions of usefulness of technology and suggested this construct may be 13
analogous to construct of person-job-fit (Meyer & Allen, 1991). From its original model, TAM has evolved over time. The notion of time has also been included in the analysis of the factors that influence use. Research has shown that the influence of some factors on intention to use ATM system influence perceived usefulness. Presently, the works of (Venkatesh& Davis, 2000) on the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) has focused on developing theoretical extensions that explain perceived usefulness, in particular, in terms of cognitive and social influence processes.
2.4. Behavioral intention and ATM System Technology adoption (or usage) decisions have been typically characterized by a strong productivity orientation (Venkatesh and Brown, 2001). The Automatic Teller Machine, once considered a luxury, has become the conventional communication tool. The contents that used to deliver limited information are now able to provide a variety of information and banking services such as withdrawing, deposit, inquiries (Cheong, J., and Park, M., 2005).with the rapid increase of the ATM usage, the growing penetration of wireless devices, and the rapid technological innovation, wireless technology shifts the world of wired internet to the wireless mobile internet. ATM is expected to deliver great business opportunities to market participants. The key factor of the success is dependent on understanding the concerns of customers and identifying the determinants that leads to individuals behavioral intention to adopt the ATM.
In TAM, similar to TRA, an individuals belief determines the attitude toward using the system and, in turn, the attitude develops the intention to use. Finally, this intention influences the decision of actual system usage. These causalities are broadly studied and accepted (Chen et al., 2002; Suh and Han, 2002; Morris and Dillon, 1997; Teo et al., 1999).
Actual system use refers to (how often) and the volume of system use (how much) by the user (Davis, 1989). Davis asserts that ones behavioral intention influences actual system usage. This is due to the internalization and identification that may influence behavioral intention directly via compliance. Its further argued that, once end users of the system are not informed or educated about the need or relevance, this will greatly influence their behavioral intention to use.
14
Technological Acceptance Model (TAM) has been tested in many studies such as (Davis etal, 1989; Mathieson, 1991; Adams et al., 1992; Davis, 1993; Segars and Grover, 1993; Taylor and Todd, 1995), and it has been found that an individuals behavior to use a system largely explains their intentions. Consequently, (Methieson, 1991) previous studies have found that TAM consistently explains a significant amount of the variance in usage intentions and behaviour. The model puts it that behavioral intention to use has a significant impact on a users ability to actually use a system. Behavioral intention to use the system is modeled as a function of actual system use and perceived usefulness (Davis et al., 1989 Taylor and Todd 1995). The Theory of Reasoned Action has been considered with much attention as it gives a clear explanation between behavioral intention to use and actual system use with regards to adoption of technology. Theory of reasoned action (TRA) is a much researched area that has been applied across a number of areas. The authors, Ajzen and Fishebein ascribe that their theory applies to behavioral intention to use. Several researchers have used this theory extensively to better understand users behaviors in technology adoption.
According to TRA, the unique behaviour of an individual is determined by ones behavioral intention (BI) to act on the behaviour, and it is performed in conjunction with an individuals attitude and subjective norm of the behaviour that is being performed. Attitude is the result of what the person believes about the action that is being performed and the expected result. Subjective norm is the result of an individuals response to the perceived expectations of his or her peer group and his belief that he must comply with those expectations. TRA addresses a persons internal psychological variables by which multiple external variables are studied. Information technology researchers have relied heavily on this theory to lay the groundwork for a better understanding of why users adopt technological innovations.
Intentions to perform behaviors of different kinds can be predicted with high accuracy from attitudes toward the behavioral subjective norms and perceived behavioral intentions; and these intentions, together with perceptions of behavioral control, account for considerable variance in actual ATM use. Attitudes, subjective norms and perceived behavioral control are shown to be related to appropriate sets of salient behavioral, normative, and control beliefs about the behaviour, but the exact nature of these relations is still uncertain by (IcekAjzen 1985, 1987).
15
In addition to that, Ajzen theory is rooted in the psychological exploration of human behaviour and all of the intricacy that is involved in understanding a persons behaviors. Concepts dealing with behavioral intention to use such as social attitude and personality trait have played an important role in these attempts to predict and explain actual system use (Ajzen, 1988; Campbell, 1963; Sherman & Fazio, 1983). Behavioral intention to use the ATM system is determined by the intention to perform. The behaviour which is predicted by three factors: attitude towards the behaviour, subjective norms, and perceived behavioral control that eventually determines ATM system use.
2.5. Perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness Perceived ease of use refers to how clear and understandable interaction with the system is, ease of getting the system to do what is required, mental effort required to interact withthe system, and ease of use of the system (Ndubisi et al., 2003). Rogers (1962) theorized that Perceived Ease of Use demonstrates the degree to which an invention is seen as being not too difficult to understand, learn or operate. Perceived Ease of Use in Technological Acceptance Model has been defined as the extent to which a person believes that using a certain technology will be free of effort (Davis, 1989). Perceived Ease of Use has been demonstrated in previous studies to influence behaviour, either directly or indirectly via Perceived Usefulness.
However, previous researchers have not found conclusive evidence about whether the construct in TAM would have a significant influence on the PU of technology (e.g. Keiland Brenner, 1997; Lederer et al., 2000; Straub et al., 1997; Teo et al., 1999). Some studies have linked Perceived ease of use to the success and quality of an information system (Seddon, 1997) as well as to customer satisfaction (Wang et al., 2001). In fact, Brown (2002) argued that PU is not a major influence on usage but more on the external variables, which would be more likely to affect Perceived Ease of Use.
In addition, Davis et al. (1989) proposed that perceived ease of use is an antecedent of Perceived usefulness. Results from previous research also revealed the significant effect of perceived ease of use to perceived usefulness (Kleijnen et al., 2004; Wang et al., 2003; Davis et al., 1989). Huang,J. Linn Y., and Chuang S. (2006) posits that two particular 16
behavioralbeliefs, perceived usefulness (PU) and perceived ease of use (PEOU), are two fundamental factors for predicting user acceptance, and that the effect of external variables on intention are mediated by these two key beliefs (Adams et al., 1992; Davis, 1989; Davis et al., 1989; Mathieson, 1991). PU is defined as an individuals perception that using a new technology will enhance or improve her/his performance (Davis, 1989, 1993).
Perceived ease of use (PEOU) is defined as an individuals perception that using a new technology will be free from effort (Davis, 1993). Perceived Ease of Use is hypothesized to be a predictor of Perceived Usefulness. Moreover, both Perceived Usefulness and Perceived Ease of Use are affected by external variables (Hu et al., 1999; Venkatesh et al., 2002; Wang et al., 2003). Furthermore, Perceived Usefulness and Perceived Ease of Use have a positive effect on attitude. Unlike in TRA, the subjective norm is not a determinant of behavioral intention in TAM; instead, BI in TAM is affected only by Perceived Usefulness and attitude (Davis, 1989). Perceived Ease of Use is normally related to the intrinsic characteristics of IT (ease of use and ease of learning the technology), whereas the Perceived Usefulness to the user relates to extrinsic factors like efficiency and effectiveness. As noted by Agarwal and Prasad (1997), previous researchers adopted TAM because of its parsimony and the wealth of empirical support.
Basing on what previous studies say (Awamleh&Fernandes, 2005) support for one or two of the constructs was not provided thus a theoretical overlap between these two constructs i.e.( perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness) whereas factor analyses have provided support for this conclusion. Perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use significantly contribute to an individuals behaviour (Hung 2004). According to Rogers (1995) the perceived ease of use characteristics is supposed to provide the framework of how potential adopters perceive usefulness of an innovation.
Perceived ease of use is defined as the individuals perception that using the new technology will be free from efforts (Davis, 1989, 1993). Apply this to this researchcontext; perceived ease of use is the customers perception that banking using ATM willinvolve a minimum effort. Whereas perceived usefulness referred to customersperception regarding the outcome of the ATM banking system, perceived ease of userefers to perceptions regarding the process leading to the final ATM banking use.According to TAM, ease of use has dual effect, direct as well as indirect, on customers intention to bank using ATM system. The indirect effect on 17
intention is through perceivedease of use and the direct effect is through perceived usefulness.
By looking at the prevailing theory in the area of technology adoption, The Technology Acceptance Model (TAM) is an information systems theory that models how users come to accept and use a technology. The model suggests that when users are presented with a new technology, a number of factors influence their decisions about how and when they will use it.
Perceived usefulness defined by Fred Davis as the degree to which a person believes that using a particular system would enhance his or her performance. Another factor presented by Davis deals with perceived ease-of-use which is also defined by Davis as the degree to which a person believes that using a particular system would be free from effort. (Davis, 1989) The technology acceptance model was developed by Fred Davis and Richard Bagozzi. (Bagozzi et al., 1992; Davis et al, 1989). It was an extension of the work of Ajzen and Fishbeins theory of reasoned action. (TRA) TRA is an important model from social psychology that focuses on explaining the relationship between perceived ease of use and usefulness.
TAM replaces many of the TRA attitude measures with the technology acceptance measures, ease of use, and usefulness. TRA and TAM, both have strong behavioral elements, assume that when someone forms an intention to act, that they will be free to act without limitation. Within the normal operating environment there are many constraints, such as limited ability, time constraints, environmental or organizational limits, or unconscious habits which will limit the freedom to act (Bagozzi et al., 1992) The mere fact that new technologies such as ATM systems are complex and an element of uncertainty exists in the minds of decision makers with respect to the successful adoption of them, people form attitudes and intentions toward trying to learn to use the new technology prior to initiating efforts directed at using. Behavioral intentions to use may be ill-formed or lacking in conviction or else may occur only after preliminary striving to learn to use the technology evolve. Thus, actual usage may not be a direct or immediate consequence of such intentions. (Bagozzi, Davis, Warshaw, 1992).
18
TAM posits that two particular beliefs, perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use, can predict ATM actual use. Perceived usefulness and ease of use are meant to be fairly general determinants of actual system use. Davis et al. (1989) described them as belief sets that are meant to be readily generalizable to different system use. They argued that the ability to take well-formed measures of the determinants of user acceptance early in the development process can have an impact on actual system use acceptance by enabling developers to weed out bad systems, refine the rest, and generally cut the risk of deliveringfinished systems that get rejected by users.
Davis provided strong theoretical support for his perceived usefulness and ease-of-use instrument(s) and used a rigorous development methodology (Davis et al., 1989). The instruments are widely regarded and have received considerable attention by researchers (Adams, Nelson, & Todd, 1992; Chin & Todd, 1995; Hendrickson, Massey, &Cronan, 1993; Igbaria, Guimaraes, & Davis, 1995; Mathieson, 1991; Segars& Grover, 1993; Straub, Limayem, &Karahanna-Evaristo, 1995; Subramanian, 1994). Davis (1989), Adams et al. (1992), and Subramanian (1994) have suggested that these instruments might be used broadly within and across organizations to evaluate technologies, make comparisons between users, and predict actual usage.
Subramanian (1994) found that the perceived usefulness and ease-of-use constructs were robust and concluded that information systems researchers can use these instrumentsin varying technological and organizational contexts. Software packages are tools that are used for the purposes/tasks of the end-user. The concept of "usefulness" implies a purpose. Applications can be considered "useful" if they contribute to accomplishing the end-users purpose, and "easy to use" if the effort required to make use of the application is modest relative to the end-user's frame of reference. Goodhue (1992) referred to purpose as the end- users task. He argued that task characteristics influence behavioral intention to use and in the end actual system use.
Past research provides evidence of the significant effect of perceived ease of use on usage intention either directly or indirectly through its effect on perceived usefulness (Agarwal& Prasad, 1999, Davis et al., 1989, Venkatesh, 1999; Venkatesh2000; Venkatesh&Morris, 2000; Ramayah&Aafaqi 2004, Ramayah 2006). Information systems that users perceive easier to use and less complex will increase the likelihood of its adoption and usage (Teoetal., 19
1999). Perceived ease of use has been shown to influence behaviour for example information technology adoption through two causal ways: (1) a direct effect on behaviour intention and (2) indirect effect on behaviour intention via perceived usefulness.
Perceived ease of use positively influences behaviour intention. Past research by Hong et al.,(2001), Gefen et al.,(2003), Heijden (2003), Venkateshet al.,(2003) and Heijden(2003) also found Perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness to influence behavioral intention . Perceived usefulness describes the perceptions of an individuals innovativeness. It has been seen to have a great influence on ones behaviour reflected in terms of compatibility, feedback, relative advantage and subjective norms. Perceived ease of use however describes the individuals perception of how easy the innovation is to learn and use. This includes support, complexity, and change. The model postulates that the users perceptions lead to adoption behaviors that is an outcome of both perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness that will eventually determine ATM system use.
Perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness study show that, usefulness makes an individual underestimate the difficulty associated with using the technology since they simply enjoy the process its self and do not perceive it to be arduous (Vankatesh, 2000). In addition to that, studies based on Decis motivational theory (Deci, 1975) or Davis et al.s work, on motivational model of technology acceptance (Davis et al 1992). The reason behind this is that, systems that are perceived as easier to use are more likely to be perceived as useable (Toe et al., 1999). Bandura (1986) shows the relationship between perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness by showing self-efficacy as having a significant impact of the effect : therefore , perceived ease of use (self-efficacy) is supposed to have a significant impact on perceived usefulness.
However, its possible to argue that perceived ease of use influences intrinsic motivation, rather than intrinsic motivation influences perceived ease of use. Given the focus on the TAM model, an outcome and process expectancy model, intrinsic motivation is expected to influence perceived ease of use as well as perceived usefulness (Vankatesh, 2000).
Applying the definition of perceived usefulness to our research context, as new information systems are being introduced in place we classify ATM banking system, and as the individuals performance the outcome of the ATM banking system use. Then, perceived 20
usefulness refers to customers perception that using ATM as a banking system enhances the outcome of their banking needs. These perceptions influence customers attitude toward ATM baking system and their intention to bank using ATM system. TAM posits a weak direct link between perceived usefulness and attitude and a strong direct link between perceived usefulness and behavioral intention to use (Davis et al., 1989). This was explained as originating from customers intending to use ATM banking system because it was useful, even though they did not have a positive affect toward using it. In addition to that, there is a very strong link between perceived ease of use and usefulness that determines customers attitude towards using ATM banking system.
According to TAM, perceived usefulness is influenced by perceived ease of use because the easier a technology is to use, the more useful it can be (Dabholkar, 1996). There is also extensive research in the IS community that provides evidence of the significant effect of perceived usefulness on usage intention (Agarwal and Prasad, 1999; Davis et al., 1989; Hu et al., 1999; Jackson et al., 1997; Venkatesh, 1999, 2000; Venkatesh and Davis, 1996, 2000; Venkatesh and Morris, 2000). The ultimate reason people exploit Internet banking systems is that they find the systems useful to their banking transactions.
Service excellence is the customers appreciation of delivered promises and performed functions. This is yet another factor to consider in a way that, service excellence operates as an ideal standard against which judgments are ultimately formed (Holbrook, 1994). If ATM banking meets this ideal by enabling the customers to accomplish the banking tasks he/she has set out to perform then customers will judge the ATM banking performance positively (Mathwick et al., 2002). This leads to positive perceptions regarding perceived usefulness of ATM banking system.
21
2.6. Perceived ease of use and behavioral intention to use ATM Perceived ease of use of a particular system means a good system in the minds of the customer, therefore he/she feels good about the system thus influencing the customers behavioral intention to use it. Gong and Zu (2004) defines perceived ease of use as thedegree to which a prospective user expects the target system to be free of effort. A system that is perceived to be easy to use will automatically influence ones behaviour to use it (Succi and Walter, 1999).
Extensive research over the past decade provides evidence of the significant effect of perceived ease of use on usage intention, either directly or indirectly through its effect on perceived usefulness (Agarwal and Prasad, 1999; Davis et al., 1989; Hu et al., 1999; Jackson et al., 1997; Venkatesh, 1999, 2000; Venkatesh and Davis, 1996, 2000; Venkateshand Morris, 2000). Moreover, Guriting and Ndubisi (2006) found that perceived ease of use had a significant positive effect of behavioral intention to use online banking. In order to prevent the under-used useful system problem, Internet banking systems need to be both easy to learn and easy to use. Internet technologies that are easy to use are less threatening to the individual (Moon and Kim, 2001).
Likewise, bank customers are likely to adopt online banking when it is easy to use (Guriting and Ndubisi, 2006). The study conducted by Ramayah et al., (2003) found that perceived ease of use has proven to have significant impact on intention to use internet banking. The result corroborates the findings by Ramayah et al. (2002), Adams et al. (1992) and Davis et al. (1989).
Considering predictors of ATM usage could serve a number of customers by helping them to recognize how to promote that usage (Lederer, 2000). The TAM is based on Fishbeinand Ajzens theory of reasoned action posits that an individuals attitude towards carrying out that behaviour and an evaluation of the value of each of those outcomes influences behavioral intention to use the system.
22
In the TAM model, perceived ease of use positively affects perceived usefulness. Moreover, perceived ease of use and perceived usefulness positively affect the attitude towards an information system, and further, positively affect behavioral intention to use and accept of the information system. Bandura, (1986) suggests that perceived ease of use plays an important role in affecting motivation and behavioral intention to use a given system. The individuals perceived ease of use to attain the standards they have been pursuing has an impact on individual behavioral intention to use. Therefore, individuals may be more likely to undertake behaviors they believe will result in valued out comes than those they see as having un favorable consequences.
Its further believed that for any system put in place, perceived ease of use is an important determinant of behavioral users intention of acceptance and usage behaviour. In addition to that, a study by Clarke (2000) shows that, among the factors affecting the use of Automatic Teller Machine banking system is a persons perceived ease of use thus in the end determines ones behavioral intention to use. Technological Acceptance Model is believed to be the most robust, parsimonious, and influential model in explaining systems adoption behaviour in a way that perceived ease of use serves as a basis for attitudes towards using a particular system, which in turn determines the intention to use, and then generates actual system use behaviour.
Although many studies on perceived ease of use have received a fairly attention from previous researches, there is no research that explores the factors influencing behavioral intention to use ATM system. Furthermore, the TAM model was originally created toexamine information system adoption in organizations. Considering Kelmans frame work, Davis et al. (1986) social behaviour influences may affect behavioral intention indirectly via attitude due to internalization and identification processes, or influence behavioral intention directly through compliance.
The most effective tool to describe the relationship between perceived ease of use and behavioral intention to use the system is Davis (1986). As this model explains usage behaviour, it further states that beliefs influence attitudes, which further leads to intentions and finally behavioral intention to use. TAM goes ahead to explain perceived ease of use as the degree to which a person believes that using a particular system would be free from 23
effort. Perceived ease of use is consistently in literature review as a significant factor in Influencing behaviour intention to use that finally determines actual ATM system use.
24
CHAPTER THREE 3.1 Introduction This chapter is about the methodological research design that was used in the process of conducting the research study. It specifically identified the processes of gathering, analyzing of data that were used in the study. This chapter begins with the research design, which is a description of the research approach. It also looks at the data collection tools that were used in the course of the research. It also presents the data collection instruments that were used in the process of data collection and methods that were used to maintain the validity of the research and interpreting of data going to be used for the research. It also covered the area of study, research designs, sampling strategy, population of the study of 0.775 and the methods of data collection. 3.2 Area of Study The study was held at the financial institutions in Kampala city, namely; Stanbic bank, Centenary, Equity, Barclays, Standard Chartered, and Baroda among the other banks in Kampala city. The study aimed at the users of the ATM system in the different banks. 3.3 Research Design Kothari (2003) defined a research design as an arrangement of conditions for data collection and analysis of data in a way that aims to combine relevance with the research purpose. Its a conceptual structure within which research is conducted. Bell (1997), notes that the research design outlines the basis for making interpretation of data and establishes the format for detailed steps to follow when conducting the study. It is the plan which shows how data will be collected and analyzed. The researcher used a descriptive design which helped her to evaluate ATM usage in Uganda, organize, describe and explain the detailed findings in the research. The term descriptive research refers to the type of research question, design, and data analysis that will be applied to a given topic. The type of question asked by the researcher ultimately determines the type of approach necessary to complete an accurate assessment of the topic at hand. 25
3.4 Target Population Kombo (2002) defines population as a group of individuals or items which are taken for measurement. The research targeted 40 ATM holders from the different banks in Kampala as they were directly linked to the study. They included students, unemployed, employed, and self-employed ATM holders. 3.5 Sampling Method / Sampling Size Enron (1998) defines sampling as a deliberate process of selecting apart of population for study with the intention of generalizing the findings to the whole population. Purposive sampling was used to collect data from only ATM holders and users. Patton (1990) says that logic and power lying selecting rich cases for depth study. The sample size consisted of 31 respondents from the population of over 10,000 ATM holders. (13 employed 9 self-employed, 2 unemployed and 7 students). 3.6 Data Collection Methods The researcher used various methods to collect both primary and secondary data for the study. As such primary data was collected through the use of questionnaires, Interview and Observation methods and secondary data was collected through the use of Document analysis method. Under this method both published and grey literature materials such as research papers, journals and internet resources and related sources was reviewed as explained below. The methods are as follows; 3.6.2 Questionnaire According to Mbaaga (2000:25), questionnaires are defined as a set of related questions designed to collect information from respondents on an intended topic. These maybe structured or unstructured, or the researcher can decide to use them both. Questionnaires need factual answers that call for facts as well as for explanation about the usage of the ATM system. Questionnaires were distributed to employed staff, unemployed, self-employed and students in the different banks in Kampala.The structure of the questionnaire had a linear scale of Strongly Agree (5), Agree (4), not sure (3), Disagree (2) and Strongly Disagree (1).
26
3.6.3 Observation Observation can be defined as a purposeful examination of research phenomenon for purposes of gathering data. It involves the use of sensory organs to make sense of the study phenomenon. It allows one to collect data in a purposeful and systematic way about the behavior of an individual or a group of people at a specific time or place. 3.7 Data Collection Instruments Several research instruments were constructed to aid the researcher to collect data 3.7.1 Questionnaire guide The questionnaire is the most widely used technique in data collection. It consists of written questions to which the respondent responds to in writing (Busher and Hunter, 1980). The guide was used to find out the users perceived usefulness and perceived ease of use, of the ATM system. (See Appendix ) 3.7.2 Observation guide It constituted several guidelines which the researcher used to assist herself in observing all the details concerning the research. The researcher used her naked eyes to examine the phenomena and hence recorded the findings accordingly. 3.8 Research Procedure A research procedure refers to a particular course of action intended to achieve a research result. Bell (1997), states that whatever procedure for collecting data is selected, it should always be examined critically to assess what extent it is likely to be reliable and valid. An introductory letter from UCU, Faculty of Business and Administration, was obtained to authorize the researcher to conduct research at the different financial institutions (banks). The researcher re- tested the instruments to see if they can collect the right information before a full scale data collection exercise was embarked on.
27
3.9 Data Analysis and Presentation Data analysis is the process which involves the way data will be presented, coded and collected in an understandable, systematic and clear way. All data collected was edited to ensure accuracy and consistency. It involved preparation of the collected data into useful, clear and comprehensive information. It was based on the researchers objectives and questions the data was presented in form of explanatory notes. The researcher used SPSS data analysis software to analyze quantitative data. 3.10 Ethical Considerations Mbaaga (2000) considers ethical considerations as explanations of how the study will be conducted according to the accepted norms and regulations of the discipline of the researcher. The information taken from the respondents was strictly confidential and it was used only for purposes of this research. The researcher got permission from the respondents before writing down what they had mentioned. The research was also strictly for educational purposes. 3.11 Limitation of the Study The researcher faced one limitation; The time constraint: the researcher was limited by the time as well as the respondents delay in filling out the questionnaires however this did not prevent the study from being carried out. In this chapter, the researcher discussed the area of study, the research design, the target population, the sampling method, the data collection methods and instruments, data analysis and presentation and the ethical considerations.
28
CHAPTER FOUR Response rate of the study; The study had a response rate of 0.775. This was a combination of both male and female, working class and the unemployed in Uganda. And this consisted of respondents between the ages of 20years and above. 4.1 Back ground data of the Respondents The study analyzed the back ground composition of respondents. The back ground composition included, age, sex, marital status, education level, employment status, how long one owned an ATM, type of account held and the type of bank one went to for his/her transactions.
29
Table 1-4: Back Ground Research Data VARIABLE FREQUENCY PERCENTAGE (%) Age
20-29 30-39 40 and above 21 5 5
67.7 16.1 16.1
Sex
Female Male 16 15
51.6 48.4
Marital status
Married Not married 12 18
38.7 58.1
Educational level
Secondary University Tertiary Others 4 19 5 3
12.9 61.3 16.1 9.7
Employment status
Employed Self-employed Un employed Student 13 9 2 7
Where do you carry out your transactions Centenary Stanbic Equity Barclays Standard chartered Others 5 10 3 5 3 5 16.1 32.3 9.7 16.1 9.7 16.1 Source: primary data The study revealed that majority of the respondents where in the age bracket of 20-29 years- 67.7%, of these 51.6% were female and 48.4% male and 58.1% were not married. Furthermore educational level, employment status, access to ATM, account and where the 30
transactions are made (banks), was evaluated and the findings were as following 61.3%, 41.9%, 54.8%, 64.5% and 32.3% respectively.This indicated that majority of the respondents are youths who are determine in pursuing their careers rather than getting married. 4.2. Response on Perceived Usefulness of the Auto Teller Machines (ATM) The table 2-4, below shows how the respondents perceived the usefulness of Auto Teller Machine (ATM) system/ technology in their day to day life. Table 4-2: Perceived Usefulness of Auto Teller Machines (ATM) Variables SD f (%) D f (%) NS f (%) A f (%) SA f (%) Mean St.D ATM enables me to utilize banking services more quickly 0 0 2(6.5) 7(22.6) 22(71.0) 4.65 .608 ATM enables you to bank or withdraw money many times as one wishes 0 5(16.1) 4(12.9) 11(35.5) 11(35.5) 3.90 1.076 ATM has reduced the burden one encounters in the bank 1(3.2) 0 1(3.2) 9(29.0) 20(64.5) 4.52 .851 ATM is rigid and inflexible to interact with 11(35.5) 7(22.6) 4(12.9) 5(16.1) 4(12.9) 2.48 1.458 Using ATM is better than going to the counter 0 1(3.2) 3(9.7) 9(29.0) 18(58.1) 4.42 .807 ATM simplifies life and the way of doing business 1(3.2) 1(3.2) 3(9.7) 11(35.5) 15(48.4) 4.23 .990 ATM offers freedom, flexibility and convenience in the time of banking 2(6.5) 2(6.5) 2(6.5) 10(32.3) 15(48.4) 4.10 1.193 ATM provides reliable security controls I need 1(3.2) 5(16.1) 5(16.1) 12(38.7) 8(25.8) 3.68 1.137 ATM enables me save money 6(19.4) 9(29.0) 3(9.7) 6(19.4) 7(22.6) 2.97 1.494 Source: Primary data From table 4-2 above, the study revealed that, most respondents acknowledged the importance of technology (ATM) and how it has influenced service delivery or interface with the bank (Mean=4.65; StD=0.68, Mean=4.52;StD=0.85, Mean=4.42;StD=0.807; Mean=4.23, StD=0.990, Mean=4.10, StD=1.193; and Mean=3.90, StD=1.076). However there was concern on the flexibility of ATM services offered by the bank. Such flexibility were in terms Money deposits, money savings (Mean=2.48; StD=1.458; Mean=2.97, StD=1.494). Due to this its possible that this could be the probable course of long queues in the bank. 4.3. Perceived Ease of Use of Auto Teller Machine (ATM) The table 4-3 below represented the composition of the different responses from the respondents on how ease it was for them to interact with the ATM system in their banks. This was guided by the structured questions that are found in the table 4-3 below. 31
Table 4-3: Perceived Ease of Use of Auto Teller Machines (ATM) Variables SD f (%) D f (%) NS f (%) A f (%) SA f (%) Mean St.D Its easy to use an ATM 1(3.2) 0 2(6.5) 6(19.4) 22(71.0) 4.58 .765 You never feel nervous when using an ATM 5(16.1) 3(9.7) 3(9.7) 12(38.7) 8(25.8) 3.48 1.411 Using ATM does not require a lot of training 2(6.5) 1(3.2) 1(3.2) 12(38.7) 15(48.4) 4.19 1.108 ATM is easy to use even by people without prior computer knowledge 4(12.9) 1(3.2) 2(6.5) 14(45.2) 10(32.3) 3.81 1.302 ATM is user friendly 0 0 2(6.5) 15(48.4) 14(45.2) 4.39 .615 ATM enables my ability to bank 1(3.2) 2(6.5) 1(3.2) 15(48.5) 12(38.7) 4.13 .991 ATM enables me to access all my accounts in the bank 1(3.2%) 2(6.5) 5(16.1) 10(32.3) 13(41.9) 4.03 1.080 ATM enables me do transactions anywhere around the country 2(6.5%) 0 2(6.5) 5(16.1) 22(71.0) 4.45 1.091 I find it easy to do what I want with an ATM 1(3.2) 2(6.5) 7(22.6) 11(35.5) 10(32.3) 3.87 1.056 My interaction with ATM is clear and understandable 0 0 1(3.2) 14(45.2) 16(51.6) 4.48 .570 Source: Primary data The study further evaluated the ease of use of ATM services to the respondents. The findings shown in table 4-3above revealed that the respondents agreed to the friendly nature of the Auto Teller Machine (ATM) because of its clear and understandable instructions and how easy it was to use it since it didntrequire a lot of training. (Mean=4.58; StD=0.765; Mean=4.48; StD=0.570; Mean=4.45; StD=1.091; Mean=4.39; StD=0.615; Mean=4.19; StD=1.108).This revealed that all the respondents found it easy to interact or operate the ATM since majority of the respondents were youths (20-29 Yrs.). 4.4. Behavioral Intention to Use Auto Teller Machines (ATMs) The table 4-4 below, represented the data of the respondents on their intention to use an Auto Teller Machine (ATM) that is what their motivation to use the new technology was.
32
Table 4-4: Behavioral Intention to Use Auto Teller Machines (ATMs) Variables SD f (%) D f (%) NS f(%) A f (%) SA f (%) Mean St.D I intend to use ATM more frequently for all money deposits 3(9.7) 5(16.1) 8(25.8) 10(32.3) 5(16.1) 3.29 1.216 I intend to use ATM only if there is a long queue in the banking hall 8(25.8) 9(29.0) 7(22.6) 2(6.5) 5(16.1) 2.58 1.385 I intend to use ATM to access all my bank accounts 2(6.5) 3(9.7) 2(6.5) 10(32.3) 14(45.2) 4.00 1.238 I intend to use ATM for cheque deposits only 13(41.9) 10(32.3) 3(9.7) 4(12.9) 1(3.2) 2.03 1.169 The reason I prefer to use ATM is because the bank encouraged me to do so 11(35.5) 7(22.6) 4(12.9) 6(19.4) 3(9.7) 2.45 1.410 I intend to use ATM because I feel sense of personal ownership 3(9.7) 0 4(12.9) 10(32.3) 14(45.2) 4.03 1.224 I intend to use ATM because my colleagues talk up the issue as a great use 14(45.2) 8(25.8) 3(9.7) 5(16.1) 1(3.2) 2.06 1.237 Unless am rewarded for using ATM in same way I see no reason to spend extra effort in using it 21(67.7) 7(22.6) 1(3.2) 2(6.5) 0 1.48 .851 Source: Primary data The research analyzed the composition of the different respondents and revealed that majority of the respondents intended to use the ATM service because they felt the sense of personal ownership and to access all their bank accounts (mean=4.03; stD=1.224; mean=4.00;stD=1.238). However other respondents declined to them using the technology because of their colleagues talking it up to be of great use, being rewarded for using it and only if there was a long queue in the banking hall,(mean=1.48;stD=0.851; mean=2.06;stD=1.237;mean=2.58;stD=1.385). Furthermore the respondents declined to use the ATM service for all money deposits (mean=3.29;stD=1.216). This indicated the likelihood of the banking hall being congested since people would prefer lining up in the banks then use ATMs.
33
4.5. Bank Policy implication on Auto Teller Machine (ATM)Usage This table represents the banks policy on how to use an ATM. These policies may include; the maximum amount to be withdrawn, policy on how to change pin and replace the lost card Table 4-5: Bank Policy on ATM Usage Variables SD f (%) D f (%) NS f (%) A f (%) SA f (%) Mean St.D I know my banks policy on how to use an ATM 0 0 0 13(41.9) 18(58.1) 4.58 .502 I know the maximum amount of money that I have to withdraw from my account when using an ATM 0 0 1(3.2) 12(38.7) 18(58.1) 4.55 .568 Its very easy for me to change my pin code 4(12.9) 3(9.7) 5(16.1) 8(25.8) 11(35.5) 3.61 1.407 Its fast for me to replace my ATM in my bank 6(19.4) 8(25.8) 3(9.7) 4(12.9) 10(32.3) 3.13 1.586 I love my banks policy 2(6.5) 0 5(16.1) 12(38.7) 12(38.7) 4.03 1.080 Source: primary data Table 4-5 revealed that the respondents knew their banks policy on how to use a the technology, the maximum amount to be withdrawn and they loved their bank policy (Mean=4.58;St.D=0.502; Mean=4.55;stD=0.568;Mean=4,03;St.D=1.080). However the policy on the replacement of the ATM card (Mean=3.13;St.D=1.586) indicated the probable cause for congestion in the banks since it take quite long for one to replace his/her ATM card once lost. 4.6.Assessing the level of Internet Accessibility The table 4-6,analyzed the opinions of the different respondents on the accessibility of internet in the ATM system of their banks. Table 4-6: Internet Accessibility Variables SD f (%) D f (%) NS f (%) A f (%) SA f (%) Mean St.D I find it easy to access internet all the time 7(22.6) 5(16.1) 4(12.9) 6(19.4) 9(29.0) 3.16 1.573 My banks internet is very fast via the ATM point 5(16.1) 4(12.9) 6(19.4) 8(25.8) 8(25.8) 3.32 1.423 The ATM of my bank does not use internet 17(54.8) 5(16.1) 6(19.4) 2(6.5) 1(3.2) 1.87 1.147 The ATM of my bank is always down in my area of residence 13(41.9) 7(22.6) 3(9.7) 8(25.8) 0 2.19 1.250 Its difficult to access internet in my area 12(38.7) 8(25.8) 3(9.7) 6(19.4) 2(6.5) 2.29 1.346 Source: primary data 34
Table 4-6 evaluated that the respondents declined to the ATM of their bank not using internet, the system being down all the type and the difficulty to access internet in their areas (Mean=2.29;St.D=1.346;Mean=2.19;St.D=1.250;Mean=1.87;St.D=1.147). However respondents had augments on how fast the internet was via the ATM, finding it easy to access internet all the time (Mean=3.16; St.D=1.573; Mean=3.32; St.D=1.423). This indicates the likelihood of congestion in the banking hall.
35
CHAPTER FIVE DISCUSSION, CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS;
5.0 INTRODUCTION This chapter presents the discussions of the major research findings presented in chapter four, which are guided by the research questions. It also presents conclusions, recommendations and suggested areas for further research. 5.1 DISCUSSION OF THE FINDINGS The findings of the study indicated that majority of the respondents are youths (67.7%), of which 22.6% are students. This showed their great use of the ATM (Auto Teller Machine) since they use it most for banking their school fees and tuition in their respective banks, 32.2% of the transactions being in stanbic bank. The study further more revealed that 41.9% were the employed youth at university level; this showed how the youth are more flexible to technology compared to the other age groups. This is probably due to the curiosity among the youth to adventure on whats always new in the market. In addition to the above, the employed youth use the ATMs for business transactions, paying of the utility bills due to them since the ATM is quick and fast at withdrawing the money. This revealed that the youth believed in the usefulness of the ATM since it offers freedom, flexibility and convenience in the time of banking (Mean=4.10; St. D=1.193), and has also reduced the burden they encounter in the banking hall (Mean=4.52; St. D=0.851). This implies that the more the bank ensures that customers perceive the system is applicable, flexible and interactive; the more customers behavioral intentions to use will change by identification, internalization and compliance. These revelations further confirm studies by Pikkarainen, et al; (2004) which support the view that stressing a perceived usefulness leads to behavioral intention improvements. The managerial implication of these findings seem clear, the changes of behavioral intentions of customers can be enhanced through the adoption of particular system that the customers are willing to use for the transactions. Another study by Tan and Teo (2000) indicates that 36
perceived usefulness is an important factor in determining the adoption of innovations. As observed by BhattaCherje (2002), a persons willingness to transact with a particular system is already considered as perceived usefulness. It shows that user behaviour is determined by perceptions of usefulness of the technology (Admans et al; 1992). Findings that customers perceived ease of use of the system, that is, its easy to use an Auto Teller Machine (Mean=4.58; St. D=0.765) and Auto Teller Machine (ATM) being user friendly (Mean=4.39; St. D=0.615) is essential for long-term growth of banks. This findings concurs with the study conducted by Davis et al ;( 1989) which showed that Perceived Ease of Use (PEOU) of the firms system which affects its long-term viability and Perceived Usefulness. Results from previous research also revealed the significant effect of Perceived Ease of Use on Perceived Usefulness (KleiJnen et al; 2004; Wang et al; 2003; Davis et al; 1989). Huang ,J.Linn Y; and Chaung S. (2006) posits that to particular behavioral beliefs, Perceived Usefulness (PU) and Perceived Ease of Use (PEOU), are two fundamental factors for predicting use, acceptance, and the effect of external variables on intention are mediated by these two key beliefs (Admans et al; 1992; Davis, 1989; Davis et al;1989; Mathieson, 1991). PU is defined as an individuals perception that using a new technology will enhance or improve her/his performance (Davis, 1989, 1993). This Stance is reinforced by Rogers (1995) who examined PEOU characteristics that are supposed to provide the frame work on how potential adopters PU of an innovation. Myers and Marquis (1969) found that new products are more successful if they are designed to satisfy perceived customer needs than if they are developed simply to take advantage of new technology. Gray et al; (2002) concluded that innovation is an important source of competitive advantage in dynamic markets. This findings means that for financial institutions to improve the customers perception that using the new technology will be free from efforts they not only come up with new products, processes or ideas but they must ensure that products, processes and ideas satisfy customer needs hence successful implementation which enhances perceived usefulness of the system.
37
5.2 CONCLUSIONS In general, this study looked at E-banking service perception, an evaluation of ATM usage in Uganda. In particular, the study examined relationships between study variables. All the relationships were significantly positive. Its evident from the study that if customers perceived the system to be clear, understandable and interactive, this improves the customers believes that using a particular system would satisfy his/her needs and strengthens ones intention to perform a specified behaviour. Once end users of the ATM system are informed/ educated about the need or relevance, this will greatly influence their behaviour intention to use hence actual use in financial institutions. In conclusion to attract customers, banks should develop usefulness completing financial products offer on internet at a very close level they offer at the branch. This is good for the customer and for controlling bank costs (Wang, Wang, Lin and Tang, 2003). 5.3 RECOMMENDATIONS Basing on the results of the study, recommendations are suggested that should help to improve ATM actual system use. These recommendations do not solely apply to the studied financial institutions but to all organizations that are committed to technological competiveness through a Perceived Ease of Use, Perceived Usefulness and Behavioral Intention to use. In light of the research findings, the following recommendations are made; Organizations should not focus necessarily on defined end results in assessment of the ATM actual system use. Consideration should be made to customer needs, internal functions and processes that enable the realization of results. Organizations which have embraced innovations by focusing on changing customer needs and wants, monitoring their strategies closely, should create on enabling environment that facilities PU, PEOU and interactions, BI are enhanced when positive perceptions exist. Finally, this intention influences the decision of actual usage. Organizations should undertake a deliberate policy to develop and adopt technological innovations perceived to be useful and easy to use by customers so as to foster significant actual system usage. 38
5.4 AREAS FOR FURTHER RESEARCH The results of the study, point to a number of opportunity for further research into e-banking service perception; an evaluation of ATM usage in Uganda. Future research should attempt to collect data from other service industries such as; insurance, health, schools and hotels among others to see whether other services are the same and could therefore benefit from this study. Future research should determine other factors like organization strategy, top management decisions, HR competences and environmental factors that influence actual system use in Ugandan firms.
2. McAdrews, J.J. (2003), Automated Teller Machine Network Pricing-A Review of the Literature, available at http://www.rnejournal.com/articles/ (accessed on 15.09.2005).
3. Bradley, L. and Steward, K. 2002. A Delphi study of the drivers and inhibitors of Internet banking. International Journal of Bank Marketing, vol. 20 (6), pp. 250-260.
4. Brown, I; Hoppe, R; Mugera, Newman, P; and Stander, A. (2004). The impact of National Environment on the Adoption of Internet Banking: comparing Singapore and South Africa. Journal of Global information Management, 12 (2), 1-26.
5. Brown, R. D. 2001. E- commerce: customer service success factors. Futures, 25, 18- 30.
6. Bobbitt, L.M; and Dabholkar, P.A. (2001). Integrating attitudinal theories to understand and predict use of technology- based self- service industry management, 12 (5), 423-450.
7. Amin, H. (2007). Internet banking adoption among young intellectuals. Journal of Internet Banking and commerce, and Risk with the Technological Acceptance Model. International Journal of Electronic commerce, 7 (3), 101-134.
8. Al-Ashban, A.A. and Burney, M.A.2001. Customer adoption of tele-banking technology: the case of Saudi Arabia. International Journal of Bank marketing. Vol. 19 (5), pp. 191-200.
9. Akinci, S; Aksay, S; and Atilgan, E. (2004). Adoption of internet banking among sophisticated consumer segments in an advanced developing country. The International Journal of Banking Marketing, 22(2/3), 212-232. 40
10. Ainin, S; Lim, C.H; and Wee, A. (2005). Prospects and challenges of e- banking in Malaysia. The Electronic Journal of information systems in Developing countries, 22(1), 1-11. 11. Al sukkar, A; and Hasan, H. (2005). Toward a model for the acceptance of internet banking in developing countries. Information Technology for Development, 11(4), 381-398.
12. An empirical test in the United Kingdom. Information Resources Management Journal, 14(3), 37-46.
13. Rigopoulos, G; &Askounis, D. (2007). A TAM framework to evaluate users perception towards online electronic payments. Journal of Internet Banking & Commerce, 12(3),16.
14. Yi, Mi $ Hwang, Y.(2003). Predicting the use of web-based information system: self- efficacy, enjoyment, learning goal orientation, & the technology acceptance model. International Journal of Human Computer studies, 59, 431-449.
15. Wheaton, B; Muthen, B;Alwin, D.F. and Summers, G.F; 1977. Assessing reliability &Wixam, B.H. $ Todd, P.A (2005). A Theoretical integration of user satisfaction & technology acceptance. Information system research. World Wide Web. International journal of electronic commerce, 1.59-88 16. Venkatesh,V;& Davis, F.D.(2000). A theoretical extension of the technology acceptance model: Four longitudinal Filed studies. Management Science, 46, 186-204.
17. Venkatesh, V; & Davis, F.D.(1996).A model of the antecedents of Perceived Ease of Use: Development & test. Decision Science, 27,451-481.
18. Venkatesh, V (1999). Creation of favorable user perceptions: Exploring the role of intrinsic motivation. MIS Quarterly, 23(2), 239-260.
41
19. Venkatesh, V and Davis, F.D. (2002). A theoretical Extension of the technology acceptance model: Four longitudinal studies. Management Science, 46 (42), 186-204
20. Tan, M. &Teo, T.S.H.2000. Factors influencing the adoption of Internet Banking. Journal of the association for information systems. Vol.1 (5), pp.1-42.
21. Thornton, Jennifer and White, Lesley (2001), Customer Orientations and Usage of Financial Distribution channels journal of services marketing. Vol. 15(3), 168-185.
22. Teo, T.S.H; Lim, V.K.G;& Lai, R.Y.C. (1999).intrinsic and extrinsic motivation in international usage. International journal of information management, 27(1), 25.
23. Taylor,S; & Todd, P.(1995). Decomposition & crossover effects in the theory of planned behaviour: A study of customer adoption intentions. International journal of Research in marketing, 12(2), 137-155
24. Tan,M.&Teo, T.S.H. (2000). Factors influencing the adoption of internet banking. Journal of the association for information system. Vol.1 (5), pp.1-42.
25. Sable, M.E. (1987). Direct and indirect effects in linear structural equation models. Sociological stability in panel models. Sociological methodology, 8, 84-136
26. Surry, D.W; Ensminger, D.C; and Haab, M. (2005). A model for integrating instructional technology in to higher education. British journal of Education Technology, 36(2), 327-329
27. Shih, H.P; 2003. An empirical study on predicting user acceptance of e-shopping on the web. Information & management, 41, 351-368.
28. Selim,H.M. (2003). An empirical investigation of student acceptance of course web sites. Computers & Education, 40, 343-360.
42
Appendix 1 QUESTIONAIRE FOR AUTO TELLER MACHINE (ATM) USERS/ HOLDRES. Dear respondent, this instrument is designed to facilitate collection of data on perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, behavioural intention to use (ATM), internet accessibility and bank policy on ATM usage. This is an academic study and all information collected shall be utilized purely for this study. Thank you for taking time to record your insight on the subject. SECTION.1 Social- background information Tick where appropriate Age bracket. 20-29 30-39 40 and above
Sex Female male
Marital status married Not married
Educational level primary secondary university tertiary Others specify
Employment status employed Self- employed unemployed student
43
For how long have you owned your ATM card? 1 year 2 years 3 years 4 years and above
Which account do you hold? current savings fixed Others specify
Where do you carry out your banking transactions? centenary stanbic Equity Baroda Barclays Standard Chattered Others specify
SECTION 11 Please tick the number that most accurately indicates your response. For example, if you strongly agree tick 5, agree 4, not sure 3, disagree 2, and strongly disagree 1. PERCEIVED USEFULNESS OF AUTO TELLER MACHINE (ATM) STATEMENT 5 4 3 2 1 1. Using ATM enables me to utilize banking services more quickly. 2. Using ATM enables you to bank or withdraw money many times as one wish.
3. Using ATM has reduced the burden one encounters in the bank. 4.ATM is rigid and inflexible to interact with 5. Using ATM is better than going to the counter. 6. Using ATM simplifies life and the way of doing business. 7.ATM offers freedom, flexibility and convenience in the time of banking 8. ATM provides reliable security controls I need. 9. Using ATM enables me save money.
44
PERCEIVED EASE OF USING AUTO TELLER MACHINE (ATMs) Statement 5 4 3 2 1 1 Its easy to use an ATM 2 You never feel nervous when using an ATM 3 Using ATM does not require a lot of training 4 ATM is easy to use even by people without prior computer knowledge
5 ATM is user friendly 6 ATM enables my ability to bank 7 ATM enables me to access all my accounts in the bank 8 ATM enables me do transactions anywhere around the country 9 I find it easy to do what I want to do with ATM 10 My interaction with ATM is clear and understandable BEHAVIOURAL INTENTION TO USE AUTO TELLER MACHINE (ATMs) Statement 5 4 3 2 1 1 I intend to use ATM frequently for all money deposit 2 I intend to use ATM only if there is a long queue in the banking hall 3 I intend to use ATM to access all my bank accounts 4 I intend to use ATM for cheque deposits only 5 The reason I prefer the use of ATM is because the bank encouraged me to do so
6 I intend to use ATM because my colleagues talk up the issue as a great use
7 Unless I am rewarded for using ATM in some way I see no reason to spend extra effort in using it.
8 I intend to use ATM because I feel sense of personal ownership
45
BANK POLICY ON AUTO TELLER MACHINE USAGE (ATMs) Statement 5 4 3 2 1 1 I know my bank policy on how to use an ATM 2 I know the maximum amount of money that I have to withdraw from my account when using an ATM
3 Its very easy for me to change my pin code 4 Its very fast for me to replace my ATM card in my bank 5 I love my bank policy
INTERNET ACCESSIBILITY Statement 5 4 3 2 1 1 I find it easy to assess internet all the times 2 My banks internet is very fast via the ATM point 3 The ATMs of my bank do not use internet 4 The ATM of my bank is always down in my area of residence 5 Its difficult to assess internet in my area