Name of the Institutional Official responsible for grants: Prof. Edward Burns Executive Dean
Phone: 718-430-4106 email: eburns@aecom.yu.edu
Animal Subjects: Protocol no: 20060708 approval date: 08.10.07
Human Subjects: Protocol no. 00000140 approval date: CCI exempt 08.01.07
ABSTRACT
Title of Proposed Project: MOLECULAR MECHANISM OF ASEPTIC OSTEOLYSIS
Several inflammatory, autoimmune and infective conditions cause the destruction of the weight
bearing surfaces of major joints causing arthritis. Over one million people in the United States
each year undergo total joint arthroplasty. A commonly utilized surface material is ultra high
molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE). Over time different size particles are generated
from the UHMWPE implant. These wear debris are responsible for the initiation of an aseptic
inflammatory response known as osteolysis. We have identified that “in vivo” UHMWPE
breakdown generates short alkane polymers in addition to the previously reported nanometers
and micrometers size particles. Majority of these polymers presented oxidized side chain
modifications. Alkane side chain oxidation greatly enhanced their ability to activate dendritic
cells as compared to the general inertness of the non-oxidized polymers. We have reported that
mixture of oxidized alkane polymers triggered a pro-inflammatory response upon binding to
TLR2 homodimers and TLR1/2 heterodimers. This is the first report of a synthetic polymer
engaging a TLR on immune cells. Understanding the molecular recognition of oxidized alkane
polymers by TLR-2 is very important since the oxidative process is greatly facilitated by the
prosthetic implant manufacture’s procedure that creates macro-radicals. Furthermore, a model
for monocytes recruitment and differentiation at the inflamed site will be developed using GFP-
labeled monocytes and the murine model of calvarial osteolysis. All together the study will
identify the immunological mechanisms underlying UHMWPE immuno-recognition and the
pathological basis of aseptic osteolysis. These findings will also provide the basis to set up
biological assays for material testing and biocompatibility, thus, help implementing changes to
provide a better therapeutic and biocompatible alternative.
1
The major focus of this grant is to determine why and how the immune system becomes aware of UHMWPE and is
triggered to initiate an inflammatory response.
Specific Aims:
The single most common cause of total joint replacement is a process known as aseptic
osteolysis. Billions of dollars are spent each year on joint replacement worldwide and being able
to understand and impact the process is a tremendously important undertaking. Over time
different size particles and varied length polymers of wear debris are generated from the
UHMWPE implant. These alkane wear debris are oxidized in vivo by introduction of side chain
modifications such as carbonyl, hydroxyl, ketonic and aldehyde groups.
We recently reported that organic synthetic polymers with an alkane subunit backbone and
different carbonyl/amide side chain modifications act as potent TLR2 activators (Maitra, 2008).
This was the first observation of a synthetic polymer interacting with a cell surface TLR.
Understanding the molecular recognition of alkane polymers by TLR-2 is very important. The
implant manufacturers selected UHMWPE as the material of choice for prosthetic implants, not
only for its strength and durability, but also for its inertness. Our preliminary observations imply
that the oxidative process introduces modifications in the side chains of the polymeric wear
debris that overturns its inertness (Maitra, 2008). This in vivo oxidation process is greatly
facilitated by some of the manufacture’s procedure following the implant molding, namely UV
cross-linking that creates macroradicals. Macroradicals are easily converted into hydroperoxyl
radicals and then further oxidized. Thus, understanding the contribution of each side chain
modification/oxidation for alkane recognition by the immune system is fundamental since it
would help implementing changes in the implants manufacture aimed at reducing its ability to
oxidize and thus be a better therapeutic material.
The major focus of this grant is to determine why and how the immune system becomes aware of UHMWPE
and is triggered to initiate an inflammatory response.
These data lead to the central hypothesis for this application; oxidized UHMWPE wear
debris polymers induce activation of “local antigen presenting cells” by mimicking TLR2
receptor ligands and inducing a pro-inflammatory response. The inflammation is further
amplified by recruitment of circulating monocytes and immature dendritic cells, which
can differentiate into osteoclasts under the influence of the bone microenvironment, thus
further advancing bone resorption.
2
osteolysis will be monitored by CT scan and cell recruitment by GFP labeling. Staining of GFP +
cells with cathepsin K and αVβ3 integrin will determine their differentiation into osteoclasts. To
fully appreciate the role of dendritic cells in bone resorption the same experiments will be
conducted in MCSF-R -/- mice, which lack endogenous osteoclasts and macrophages.
Osteolysis observed in those mice will derive from recruited dendritic cells which differentiate
into osteoclasts. The results will identify the role played by recruited dendritic cells in “de
novo” osteoclastogenesis during bone inflammation.
Experimental Design
Specific Aim 1:
Characterization of the molecular interaction between oxidized alkane polymers and
soluble TLR2 molecules.
Rationale
The UHMWPE utilized in the manufacturing of prosthetic implant is characterized by long chain
sequence of -CH2- backbone, which is artificially cross-linked between carbon moieties, using
UV radiation, to increase the stability and durability of the implant. Surface modifications are
also introduced (OH and COOH groups) to facilitate UHMWPE coating with hydroxyapatite
(Chiesa et al., 2000).
Mass Spectra analysis (acquired on a Varian Fourier transform Mass Spectrometer (FTMS)
equipped with a MALDI source) of the polymers generated by UHMWPE breakdown indicated
the majority of the compounds presented side chain modification consisting of aldehyde, ketonic
and hydroxyl groups (Maitra et al., 2008). Likely, under hyper-oxidative conditions and in
presence of many enzymatic complexes, the free
radicals (formed upon breakage of the C-C cross-
linking) react with oxygen giving rise to peroxide
ROO• radicals. Subsequently the peroxide radicals
will be further converted to aldehyde, ketonic or
hydroxyl groups as we previously determined by
FTIR, and FTMS (Maitra et al., 2008) (Abu-Amer et
al., 2007; Brach del Prever et al., 2003; Fiorito et al.,
2001; Goodman, 2005; Kurth et al., 1988; Kurtz et
al., 2005; Kurtz et al., 2007).
3
reason for implant failure (Kurth et al., 1988; Kurtz et al., 2005), the mechanisms responsible for
the ability of alkane polymer to induce a strong inflammatory response was still unknown.
In our previous analysis a mixture of oxidized polymer was utilized for the binding experiments
(Maitra et al., 2008). In this Aim, using a series of chemically defined oxidized alkane polymers,
we propose to pin point the effect of each side chain modification for alkane binding to TLR2
receptor. Each oxidized polymer will be compared with the non-oxidized counterpart, and the
binding affinity (Kd) to TLR2 will be determined. Furthermore, the biological activity of each
modified alkane will be tested in regard to their ability to activate the TLR signal transduction
pathway and production of pro-inflammatory cytokines. Identification of alkane side-chain
modifications, that trigger TLR2 binding and initiation of an inflammatory cascade, would help
designing strategies to prevent such modifications to occur. Altogether this would help retaining
the immunological inertness of alkane polymers.
Hypothesis to be tested
Side chains modifications of UHMWPE polymers added by the in vivo oxidative process greatly
enhance the binding affinity for the TLR2 receptors. Increased binding affinity results in greater
production of pro-inflammatory cytokines and chemokines furthering the osteolysis.
4
Each compound will be tested for binding affinity to soluble TLR2. Biological experiments to test
their efficiency to stimulate a pro-inflammatory response will also be performed on each
compound.
Figure 2. Basic chemical structure of synthesized alkanes.The figure depicts alkane
polymers with one side chain oxidation. Each polymer will be synthesized with 2, 3 or 4
modified groups according to the length of the polymer. Polymers will also be synthesized with
either multiple number of the same side chain oxidation or multiple numbers of different side
chain oxidation.
5
Island, NY, USA). Immature DC will be cultured in presence of different amount of each one of
the oxidized alkane polymers for 24 and 48 hours.
To determine which one of the oxidized alkane polymer was capable of inducing DC activation a
surface staining will be performed. DC will be washed with cold PBS, and labeled for 30 min on
ice with saturating amounts of anti human HLA-DR (clone TU36), B7-1 (CD80) or B7-2
(CD86) (BD Biosciences, Pharmingen, San Diego, CA) in staining buffer (PBS/0.1 % BSA/
0.01% NaN3). Cells will be analyzed using a FACSCalibur flow cytometer and
cellquest software program (BD Biosciences Mountain View, CA, USA).
Mean and standard deviation of the mean fluorescence index will be calculated for each one of
the tested polymers in a set of three independent experiments.
6
the site of inflammation could also potentially differentiate into osteoclast. In vivo DC
differentiation into osteoclasts has never been previously analyzed.
Hypothesis to be tested
Circulating DC’s are recruited to the site of inflammation and can differentiate into osteoclasts
further enhancing the osteolytic process.
7
Receptors for both MCSF and RANKL are present on different myeloid derived cells indicating
that there is a potential for their transformation into osteoclast.
MCSF-R KO mice have no osteoclast and reduced number of early and late osteoclast
progenitors (Dai et al., 2002; Dai et al., 2004)These mice are currently available in the
laboratory (kind gift of Richard Stanley, AECOM and constitute a perfect model to address the
osteoclastogenic potential of immature DC.
In these mice all endogenous myeloid precursors’ lacks expression of the M-CSF-R, thus
cannot differentiate into osteoclast. Injection of exogenous GFP+ immature DC, which do
express M-CSF-R and RANK-L will constitute a clean model to address the osteoclastogenic
potential of immature DC.
A mouse model of osteolytic necrosis, closely resembling the aseptic necrosis observed in
patients with UHMWPE implants, is already available in the laboratory (Figure 3). Oxidized
alkane polymers, manufactured to mimic the oxidations observed in UHMWPE failed prosthesis
(Abu-Amer et al., 2007; Brach del Prever et al., 2003; Jahan et al., 1995; Maitra et al., 2008),
will be implanted under the periostium of the mouse calvaria (Figure 3) Bone resorption will be
quantified by CT scan (preliminary data indicate that bone resorption is already evident 10 days
following surgery) (Figure 3). GFP-positive DC will be injected intervenous into the mice and
their recruitment to the calvaria will be assessed by confocal analysis of calvaria bone sections.
In order to be effective participant in bone remodeling recruited DC cells need to undergo
several transformations. Firstly, an actin polarization at the plasma membrane is required to
form a close contact between the recruited cells and the bone surface. This polarization is
mediated by the αVβ3 integrin which is absent on DC but expressed at high levels on
osteoclasts. Secondly a polarization of the lysosomal compartments near the plasma membrane
has to occur to enable H+-ATPase mediated extracellular transport of protons. The acidification
of the extracellular environment mobilizes the bone mineral,
thereby exposing the organic phase of bone that is
degraded by cathepsin K. Such enzyme is absent in
immature DC but very much up-regulated in osteoclasts.
Confocal analysis will be utilized to determine whether GFP-
positive DC, upon recruitment, start expressing markers
classically associated with osteoclasts and bone resorption
(αVβ3 integrin, cathepsin K, and actin ring polarization).
Also, confocal analysis will determine whether recruited DC
are observed in the Howship’s lacunae which are the site
8
were bone resorption occur. Bone resorbing osteoclasts, organized into multinucleated giant
cells, attach to the bone matrix and upon polarization of their lysosomes start secreting H+ ions
as well as cathepsin K. The organization into giant cells is required to form a cell wall around
the bone matrix to ensure that the lytic enzymes are uniquely released and contained within the
resorptive microenvironment. These formations are known as bone resorptive pits or Howship’s
lacunae and can be easily identified as pits in the bone tissue surrounded by multinuclear giant
cells (Figure 12). The recruitment of injected GFP-DC into multinuclear giant cell formation
present around the Howship’s lacunae will also be analyzed by confocal microscopy.
Murine Calvarial Model. A murine calvarial model of UHMWPE osteolysis has already been
set up in the laboratory (Wedemeyer et al., 2007) Briefly both MCSF-R ko (Csf1r (-/-) or
littermates control (-/+) will be randomized in two groups. One group will undergo sham surgery
the other group will receive chemically defined modified alkane polymers. Mice in each group
will be sedated with isoflurane gas and anesthetized with Ketamine (20% Ketamine HCl, 15%
Xylazine and 65% Saline at 0.1ml per 20 grams body weight). A 10 mm incision will be made
over the calvaria sagittal midline suture. A 1.0X1.0 cm area of the periosteum will be exposed.
In the control group the incision will be closed without any further intervention whereas in the
experimental set mice will received 10 microgram of a mixture of oxidized alkane polymers. The
polymers will be distributed over the periosteum using a sterile sharp surgical spatula. Pre and
post (twelve days) operative micro-computed tomography (micro-CT scan) will be performed on
each subject to confirm and verify development of particle induced osteolysis. Micro-CT scan
will be performed with a La Theta software (Omnipotent CT) running on an Aloka La Theta
laboratory CT scan machine (Japan). The x-ray voltage will be set at high. For each skull 162
slices will be scanned with an average section to section distance of 0.03 nm at slow acquisition
speed with face down head front position. Statistical analysis of the following collected
parameters will be performed among the groups: cortical volume, trabecular volume, total
volume, cortical bone mass density and total mass density. Data will quantify the amount of
bone resorption between MCSF-R ko (Csf1r (-/-) or heterozygous (-/+) littermates control.
9
injection cells will be retrieved from the calvaria and analyzed by FACS to determine the
percentage of recruitment of GFP positive DC at the site of osteolysis.
Confocal Microscopy.
Calvaria from surgically implanted mice and sham controls will be extracted and fixed in 4%
paraformaldehyde in PBS pH 7.4 and placed at 4oC. After 24 hours, samples will be placed in
10% EDTA in PBS pH 7.4 for 48-72 hours at 4oC until decalcified. Calvaria samples will then be
placed in O.C.T. compound (Tissue-Tek, Sakura-Fientek, Torrance, CA) and frozen in 2-
methylbutane chilled in dry ice. Ten micrometer frozen sections will be placed on glass slides
and stored at -20oC for immunohistochemical evaluation. One set of serial sections will be
directly visualized under fluorescent microscope to determine GFP-DC recruitment to be bone
and giant cells formation. A second set of slides will be stained with Cathepsin K, beta-actin and
αVβ3 integrin antibodies. Injected DC are cathepsin K and αVβ3 integrin negative, also the β-
actin staining is spread throughout the cytosol (data not shown). Thus confocal analysis will
determine whether GFP+-DC, upon recruitment to the bone matrix acquire cathepsin K and
αVβ3 as osteoclasts markers and polarize the β-actin, typical of lysosomal secreting cells.
Stained slides were examined using a scanning confocal microscope (Leica AOBS system). All
images were collected under identical PMT detector settings.
Preliminary Data
The preliminary data which supports and initiates the current research proposal has been
recently published 1. Maitra, R., Clement, C.C., Crisi, G.M., Cobelli, N., Santambrogio L.
Immunogenecity of modified alkane polymers is mediated through TLR1/2 activation. PLoS
ONE. 2008 Jun 18;3 (6):e2438) and 2. Maitra R, Clement CC, Scharf B, Crisi GM, Chitta S,
Paget D, Purdue PE, Cobelli N, Santambrogio L. Endosomal damage and TLR2 mediated
inflammasome activation by alkane particles in the generation of aseptic osteolysis. Mol
Immunol. 2009 Oct 3. [Epub ahead of print]
10
utilized for calvarial surgery. Analysis of the calvarial osteolysis pre and post surgery by CT
scan and immuno-histochemistry will be extensively utilized to follow the fate and contributions
of antigen presenting cells during initiation and development of osteolysis. Studies will be
directed to follow if any osteoclastogenesis occur as a consequence of the presence of
UHMWPE and the exact mechanism of the formation of osteoclasts.
Selected References
BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH
Summary of Education
Professional Experience
11
Publications
1.Maitra R, Clement CC, Scharf B, Crisi GM, Chitta S, Paget D, Purdue PE, Cobelli N,
Santambrogio L. Endosomal damage and TLR2 mediated inflammasome activation by alkane
particles in the generation of aseptic osteolysis. Mol Immunol. 2009 Oct 3. [Epub ahead of print]
2. Maitra R, Sadofsky M.J. "A WW-like module in the RAG1 N-terminal domain contributes to
previously unidentified protein-protein interactions. "Nucleic Acids Res.2009 Jun; 37(10):3301-9.
3. Maitra, R., Clement, C.C., Crisi, G.M., Cobelli, N., Santambrogio L. Immunogenecity of
modified alkane polymers is mediated through TLR1/2 activation. PLoS ONE. 2008 Jun 18;3
(6):e2438
4. Bunbury, A., Potolicchio, I., Maitra, R., Santambrogio L. Functional analysis of monocyte
MHC class II compartments. FASEB J. 2009 Jan;23(1):164-71
5..Zak, E.A.., Norling, B., Maitra, R., Huang F., Anderson, B., and Pakrasi, H.B. (2001) The
initial steps of biogenesis of cyanobacterial photosystems occur in plasma membranes. Proc
Natl Acad Sci U S A. 98, 13443-8.
6.Inagaki, N.,Maitra, R.,Satoh, K. and Pakrasi, H.B. (2001) Amino acid residues that are
critical for in vivo catalytic activity of CtpA, the carboxyl-terminal processing protease for
the D1 protein of photosystem II. J Biol Chem, 276, 30099-105.
7.Maitra, R. and Thakur, A.R. (1993) Multiple fragment ligation on glass surface: A novel
approach. Indian Journal of Biochemistry and Biophysics, 31, 97-99.
8. Maitra, R. and Thakur, A.R . (1993) Hydroxyl radical induced DNA damage: choice of
an in vitro model. International Journal of Toxicology, Occupational and Environmental
Health. 56, 6-7.
9. Maitra, R. and Thakur, A.R. (1992) Silanisation of glass bound baked DNA permits
enhanced polymerization by DNA polymerase. Current Science 62, 586-588.
Honors
•Winner of "SHANTI BHAKTA MEMORIAL AWARD" for the best speaker at the student
seminar held between 15th-21st January 1990 in the Department of Biochemistry ,Calcutta
University.
•Qualified at the "ALL INDIA NATIONAL ELIGIBILITY TEST (NET)"of 1989 in LIFE
SCIENCES and was awarded scholarship and eligibility to carry out research for the
attainment of doctorate degree from any Indian University or Institute. The scholarship was
valid for five years.
•Qualified for Senior Research Fellowship at all India level in the examinations conducted by
"COUNCIL FOR SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH (CSIR) of 1993. The fellowship
was valid for three years.
Membership
Scientific Review
Scientific meetings
12
•Endosomal damage and TLR2 mediated inflammasome activation by alkane particles in
the generation of aseptic osteolysis Radhashree Maitra, Cristina C. Clement, Brian Scharf,
Giovanna M, Crisi, Sriram Chitta Daniel Paget, P. Edward Purdue, Neil Cobelli, Laura
Santambrogio. Albert Einstein College of Medicine (AECOM), Bronx, NY, USA. Oral
Presentation. 4th International Meeting on UHMWPE for arthroplasty from powder to debris,
16th -18th September 2009 . Turin, Italy.
• Self-Peptidomic Repertoire of the human pre-nodal lymph.Clement, Cristina C.; Maitra,
Radhashree, Sahu, Ranjit, Santambrogio, Laura. Pathology, Albert Einstein College of
Medicine (AECOM), Bronx, NY, USA. Young Investigator Award talk, 21st American
Peptide Symposium, Bloomington, Indiana-July 2009.
• Binding of modified alkane polymers to human recombinant TLR-2 receptor monitored
by intrinsic Tyr fluorescence. Clement, Cristina C.; Maitra, Radhashree Santambrogio,
Laura. Pathology, Albert Einstein College of Medicine (AECOM), Bronx, NY, USA.
Abstracts of Papers, 236th ACS National Meeting, Philadelphia, PA, United States, August 17-
21, 2008 (2008), BIOL-178.
13
Arthritis National Research Foundation
PROPOSED BUDGET
Personnel/Salary $ 30000.00
Supplies $ 10000.00
Equipment $ 3000.00
Animals $ 5000.00
14
TOTAL REQUESTED $ 50000.00
Please note that ANRF will not fund indirect or overhead expenses, or post-doctoral researchers
” to be named.”
Personnel Radhashree Maitra (PI) of this project will draw a part of her salary which will
amount to $30000.
Supplies: $ 10000 will be spent towards buying several chemicals, including antibody labeled
magnetic beads, cytokines such as GM-CSF, M-CSF, RANK, RANK-L, antibodies to cathepsins
K, S, B, D and L for western blotting. Fees for the services used at the in house facilities:
confocal imaging, electron microscopy, histology, FACS and proteomics facility are also
included.
Equipments: A few small equipments will be purchased with in a budget of $ 3000, one vortex
machine, one set of pipetteman, one magnetic separation column, one small refrigerator.
Animals: $5,000 will be spend towards purchasing TLR2 knock out mice, GFPlabelled beta
actin mice, maintenance of CSF-1 -/- knock out mice as well as C57/BL6 mice necessary for
setting up of experiments of the mouse calvarial model of osteolysis.
Travel to Professional Meetings: $2000.00 will be utilized for presenting the data generated
out of the current investigation at appropriate meetings and conferences.
NONE
15
Email: eburns@aecom.yu.edu
Details of Institutional Review Board Approval for study of Animal and Human
subjects
16