Bethan Benwell and Elizabeth Stokoe. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2006. pp 314. Reviewed by Dharshi Santhakumaran
The discursive construction of identity has become a central concern amongst
researchers across a wide range of academic disciplines within the humanities and social sciences, and there are a number of different, sometimes conflicting, analytic approaches used by researchers in theorising and analysing identity. Most existing work either concentrates on a specific identity category, such as gender, sexuality, or national identity, or else offers a broader discussion of how identity is theorised. In Discourse and identity Bethan Benwell and Elizabeth Stokoe provide an overview of some of the main analytic methods and theoretical perspectives used in the study of identity, including conversation analysis (CA), membership categorisation analysis (MCA), discursive psychology, critical discourse analysis (CDA) and narrative analysis. However, what sets this book apart from much of the previous work on the discursive construction of identity is its practical focus on how researchers identify and analyse the processes of identity construction as they occur in different discursive contexts. The book is divided into seven chapters, six of which are devoted to a different discursive environment, such as everyday conversation or institutional talk. In each of these chapters Benwell and Stokoe discuss and evaluate existing work in the area, and use a variety of data examples to demonstrate how researchers can apply different methods to analyse how identity work is done in different contexts. The books chapters are also divided into two sections. Part I com-
Affiliation Dharshi Santhakumaran, Linguistics and English Language, University of Edinburgh, UK email: dharshi.santhakumaran@gmail.com
G&L vol 1.2 2007 315318
2007, equinox publishing
doi : 10.1558/genl.v1i2.315 LONDON
316
Gender and Language
prises Chapters 1 to 4, and combines a practical guide to analysis with critical
discussion of relevant methods, and the theoretical debates surrounding them. In Part II Benwell and Stokoe look at commodified, spatial and virtual identities, which are increasingly becoming the focus of identity research. This part focuses less on methodology, and more on the discursive contexts concerned. Chapter 1 provides an overview of how different theories of identity have developed over time, contrasting essentialist theories of the self with a social constructionist viewpoint. This chapter also introduces the different analytic methods used in the later chapters, drawing attention to the difference between macro- and micro-level approaches. This chapter serves as a useful introduction for students, but will be of less value to those already familiar with different discourse analytic methods. Chapters 2 and 3 deal with conversational and institutional identities. Chapter 2 demonstrates how conversational identities can be identified and analysed using either a performativity/social constructionist approach or the ethnomethodological approach of CA and MCA. Chapter 3 looks at institutional identities and addresses the problem of how to define institutional talk as opposed to ordinary talk. This chapter also contains further explanations of CA and MCA, and elaborates on the contrast between CA and CDA. Benwell and Stokoe also discuss some of the criticisms which have been levelled at each of these approaches, including the issue of what counts as permissible context, which has sparked an on-going debate amongst conversation analysts and CAs detractors. These debates have been well-rehearsed elsewhere, and will be familiar to most language and gender researchers. Benwell and Stokoes main contribution is in giving readers a clear illustration of what these different types of analysis actually look like, which they do by taking a stretch of university tutorial interaction and analysing it using first CA and then CDA. Like discourse analysis, narrative analysis is not a single unified approach, but rather an umbrella term which covers the varied approaches of researchers in an interdisciplinary field. Chapter 4 looks at how researchers in different disciplines have analysed the relationship between narrative and identity, flagging both the commonalities and differences between approaches, and again providing illustrative examples and practical advice on how researchers go about collecting narrative data. As in the previous chapters, Benwell and Stokoe pay particular attention to the tensions between micro- and macro-level forms of analysis. In Chapter 4 they look at how Scott Kiesling (forthcoming) combines the two levels when analysing an extract from an interview with a member of an American college fraternity, and then go on to discuss issues and problems involved when combining top-down and bottom-up approaches. Chapter 5 draws on critical discourse analysis and critical discursive psychology to explore the concept of commodified identities, looking at the
d. santhakumaran 317
identities of consumers, the process of identity commodification through acts
of consumption, representations of identities in commodified contexts, and self-commodifying discourses such as CVs and job applications. One of the benefits of Benwell and Stokoes approach is that they look at how identities are constructed at both the sites of production and consumption, for example by comparing textual analysis of mens lifestyle magazines with analysis of interviews with male consumers. Chapters 6 and 7 address spatial and virtual identities. These aspects of identity have been relatively under-explored by identity researchers until recent years. Spatial identities in particular have been neglected by discourse analysts, who have tended to focus purely on linguistic practices, without taking into account the embodied, visual aspects of identity. Chapter 6 uses both visual and textual data to explore the role of space and place in identity construction, looking for example at the context of the beach, and what peoples location within this context can tell us about identity practices, particularly regarding group identity. Benwell and Stokoe trace the development of the spatial turn across the humanities and social sciences, and briefly discuss how work done by feminist geographers theorizes the relationship between gender and public and private space. Perhaps the most illuminating part of this chapter is the section in which Benwell and Stokoe use both visual and linguistic data to explain and illustrate the spatial basis of neighbour relations, and specifically the way in which complaints against neighbours tend to be based on perceived breaches of the spatial moral order. Chapter 7 deals with the growing field of work on computer-mediated communication (CMC). In this chapter Benwell and Stokoe use MCA to analyse the ways in which different identity categories are invoked and negotiated in online chatrooms, and apply politeness theory to the category Newbie and its associated characteristics, rights and obligations. They also problematise the concept of virtual identity, as defined in opposition to authentic or real identity. This book provides an engaging and accessible overview of a broad and varied field which will be of use to all identity researchers. Furthermore, Benwell and Stokoes judicious use of examples and clear demonstration of different analytic methods make the book an essential practical guide for students and newcomers to the field of identity research. Although the book deals with identity in general, much of the analysis focuses on gender identity, a point which is acknowledged by the authors. This is a reflection not only of the research interests of the authors, but also of the fact that the majority of existing work in the field of language and identity is concerned primarily with gender. As such, much of the research and the analytical
318
Gender and Language
approaches discussed, particularly in Part I of the book, will be familiar to
language and gender researchers. However, the authors are particularly strong in their analysis and practical demonstration of the tensions between top-down and bottom-up approaches to discourse, and they make a persuasive case for the advantages of using conversation analytic and other ethnomethodological approaches in the study of identity. This discussion will be of interest to language and gender researchers as these issues continue to inspire considerable debate within the field. Reference Kiesling, Scott Fabius. (forthcoming). Hegemonic identity-making in narrative. In Anna de Fina, Deborah Schiffrin and Michael Bamberg (eds). Discursive construction of identities. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.