natural selection using two examples Natural selection is the mechanism to explain evolution. Natural selection requires three things: 1. a change in the environment 2. a variation in phenotypes which shows at least two sorts of phenotype (ie behaviour) available, one of which has a selective advantage 3. a genetic basis to this variation Behaviour evolves just as do physical traits and characteristics. Variations in behaviour can occur in populations just as easily as physical variations. The environment can select variations in behaviour. Since a genetically programmed behaviour can have variations, one behaviour can work better than another in a changing environment. That variation will allow one group of organisms to survive and reproduce better in the new environment. The theory of natural selection states that in a population, individuals of a species who are best fitted for the environment are more likely to survive and thus reproduce. European Blackcap (Silvia atricapilla) These birds are small warblers which migrate between Spain and Germany. They breed in Germany in the spring and summer and spend the winter in Spain. 50 years ago blackcaps were going to the UK instead of Spain for the winter. Also UK blackcaps left to go back to Germany 10 days earlier than the Spanish blackcaps. The earlier the birds arrived in Germany the more choice of territory they had and the more eggs they laid. The UK blackcaps had an advantage over the Spanish blackcaps. To test this behavioural characteristic an experiment was performed where eggs were collected from the UK birds and also from the Spanish birds. With no parents around to teach the young in what direction to fly it was possible to test whether the behaviour was learned or genetic. All of the birds tended to migrate in the same direction as the parents would have gone which suggested that blackcaps are genetically programmed to fly in a certain direction. Arriving in Germany early is an advantage and the warm winters in the UK have increased the survival rate of the birds. This change in migration patterns may eventually result in a new species. Sockeye Salmon A species that was introduced into Lake Washington that then proceeded to migrate to the Cedar River which flows into the lake. The river flows quickly, but the lake is deep and quiet. DNA evidence has shown that the river salmon and lake salmon have stopped interbreeding. The two types of salmon have different breeding habits. The lake males have heavy bodies perfect for hiding in the deep waters of the lake, whereas if put in the river are not efficient at navigating fast currents. The river males are naturally selected to be successful in fast moving water, their bodies narrow and thin. Variations in the original salmon population were selected for by the two different environments. The original population diverged into two different breeding populations. Sockeye salmon are now split into two genetically distinct populations beach spawning lake salmon and river spawning salmon.
Loggerhead Turtles: Caretta caretta
Loggerhead turtles are known to always return to the beaches where they were born, known as natal beaches, to lay their eggs. They make this journey across the ocean, far from their breeding and feeding sites to lay their eggs specifically on the beach they were born - loggerhead turtles would not lay their eggs on another beach. It is said that when the baby turtles hatch and crawl out of their nest in the sand and head towards the ocean, they instinctively learn to remember the beach. Studies have shown that turtles of a specific natal beach show differences in their mitochondrial DNA that distinguish them from turtles of other nesting areas. Many turtles from the same beaches show up at the same feeding areas. Once reaching sexual maturity in the Atlantic Oceans, the female Loggerhead makes the long trip back to her natal beach to lay her eggs. The Loggerhead sea turtle in the North Atlantic cover more than 9,000 miles round trip to lay eggs on the North American shore. Thus, this and other evidence suggests the return of the loggerhead turtles back to their natal beach to lay eggs is an example of animal response affected by natural selection - the turtles are genetically programmed to remember the beach that they were born as since they have survived their birth on that particular beach, it offers a higher birth survival rate for their offspring. Asian Honeybees: Apis florea The Asian Honeybee colonies always build their nests of beeswax combs amid dense foliage, suspended from the branches of bushes and understory trees. American biologist Thomas Seeley investigated this behaviour of nesting in dense vegetation. He identified pairs of naturally occurring colonies and for one of them, removed the surrounding vegetation, leaving only enough to provide shade but rendering it conspicuous to predators. The second colony, the control, was kept the same with complete vegetation surroundings. Measurements of nest site temperatures one day later revealed no significant differences between the two nests. Within one week, however, four of the seven experimental colonies had been discovered and destroyed by predators (most likely by monkeys and tree shrews) whereas none of the control nests had suffered any damage. From these results, it can be deduced that the Asian Honeybee's behaviour of building its nest amid dense foliage has developed through natural selection; the species has learned that building its nest in dense foliage renders it conspicuous and thus increases chances of survival. Through natural selection, this behaviour is learned and instinctive to offspring and the whole species.
VAMPIRE FINCH Geospiza difficilis septentrionalis
An example: Among Darwins finches in the Galpagos Islands, one particular sub-species, appropriately called the vampire finch, foregoes the vegetarian diet of seeds and nuts of other finches and prefers instead the taste of blood, obtaining it by perching on the back of a booby (a larger bird) and jabbing it with its pointed beak until it draws blood. Since this is the only bloodthirsty finch on the islands, it is reasonable to assume that the species descended from birds that did not drink blood probably the sharp-beaked ground finch which is found on the islands of Wolf and Darwin. Because of natural variation in the behaviour of its ancestors, some of these finches must have tried pecking at other birds and found some nutritional advantage from the practice, producing more offspring than birds that tried pecking at other objects. Within any one generation, these birds would show natural variation in feeding behaviour; and after many generations of variation and selection the vampire finch that we know evolved. So unlike Lamarcks theory, which assumed that an animals learned behaviours were inherited by its offspring, Darwins selectionist account of instinctive behaviour can work only with a population whose individuals already vary in their behaviour, selecting behaviours leading to greater survival and reproductive success. Darwin, unfortunately but understandably, hadnt a clue as to why individuals of a species varied in form or behaviour, or how these variations could be inherited by following generations. Our current knowledge of genetics and the molecular basis of mutation and sexual reproduction provides answers to these questions and strong support for Darwins conclusion.
A tiny extract from: The evolution of animal behaviour: the impact of the Darwinian revolution http://faculty.ed.uiuc.edu/g-cziko/twd/pdf/twd07.pdf