PHILIP WEISS
INTRODUCTION
Photo-induced polymerization'-6 is concerned with absorption of ultraviolet radiation to produce an unstable excited species. Subsequent formation
S + hv
S (excited state)
S + M - S + M* * M
(initiation)
M + nM - (M)M. (propagation)
(M)M. + R (M)MR (chain-transfer and termination)
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
excited molecule, possesses more energy than the ground state and is,
therefore, capable of transferring energy to another substance such as a
monomer which then undergoes bond cleavage to give a free-radical initia-
PHILIP WEISS
unexcited sensitizer molecule. In general, if the excited state of the photosensitizer has a long life, the greater will be the opportunity for transfer
of energy and subsequent polymer initiation.
The metastable-excited photosensitizer has been considered as an ultra-
PHOTOINITIATION BY DECOMPOSITION
Light-induced polymerization has also been studied in the presence of
free-radical catalysts such as benzoyl peroxide and azobisisobutyronitrile.
The energy required to decompose the catalysts to free radicals is supplied
by the ultraviolet source and the mechanism for the initiation process is
similar to free-radical initiation by application of thermal energy. Freeradical initiators in photo-induced polymerization involve competition
between thermal and ultraviolet energy for the creation of the free radical;
and heat produced in thermal polymerization has a pronounced effect on
the molecular weight and the degree of polymerization. Nickcrson'2 reported
588
PHOTO-INDUCED POLYMERIZATION
styrene in an aqueous system. Burnett16 compared the role of 2,2'-azoisobutyronitrile with 1,1 '-azo-l-cyclohexane in the polymerization of vinyl
chloride below 2800 A. The former catalyst decomposes at moderate
temperatures and causes thermal polymerization at high rates. The azocyclohexane derivative also initiates at a similar wave length but its rate of
thermal breakdown is very much less than the isobutyronitrile. The photopolymerization (irradiation at 3660 A) of styrene initiated by 2,2'-azobispropane was studied by Miyama'7. The results indicate that the rate of
photopolymerization is proportional to the square root of the light intensity
and the square root of the sensitizer concentration. Miyama also determined
that the activation energy rate for thermal polymerization in this system was
233 kcal, while that for the photopolymerization was 58 kcal.
Benzoin'9 sensitized at 3600 A was effective in the photopolymerization
9C and -CH
radicals with the latter being the more efficient initiator. Xanthate esters
such as carboxymethylene bis(ethylxanthate)2 are equivalent to or better
than benzoin in photoinitiation.
of the bonds in the dithiocarbamate. Additional sulphur-containing compounds23 such as tetramethyithiuram monosuiphide, thiophenol, p-thiocresol, and o-aminobenzenethiol have been reported as effective photopolymerization catalysts in the synthesis of poly(methyl methacrylate)
(68 per cent yield). In the absence of the sulphur-containing photoinitiator,
a 3 per cent yield of poly(methyl methacrylate) was obtained. The photopolymerization of methyl methacrylate, acrylonitrile, and acrylic acid
may be accelerated by photoinitiators containing N-nitroso groups24 (e.g.
589
P.A.C.S
PHILIP WEISS
DYE-SENSITIZED PHOTOPOLYMERIZATION
Dye-sensitized photopolymerization is a rapid process and can be considered as a free-radical initiated polymerization which can be readily
controlled. Oster27 proposed the following scheme for dye-sensitized photopolymerization.
hv
M + D R
(radical initiation)
R + M + RM (chain initiation)
RM + M - RM2
(1)
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
RM + M - RM1
tion and the smaller the light intensity the greater the molecular weight.
This is explained by the unimolecular disappearance of part of the initiating
initiating polymerization result from the reaction between the leuco dye
(reduced form) and oxygen to yield the semiquinone form of the dye and
hydroxyl radicals. Mild reducing agents used in dye-sensitized photopolymerization studies include primary and secondary amines, amino acids,
590
PHOTO-INDUCED POLYMERIZATION
thiourea and its derivatives, ascorbic acid, thiocyanates, dicarbonyl compounds such as 2,4-pentanedione and derivatives of malonic acid. Typical
dyes used in this type of photopolymerization include the acridines, thiazines,
fluoresceins, riboflavins, and chiorophyllins. Dye-sensitized photopolymeriza-
excited thionine with 6-diketones especially 2,4-pentanedione. The dicarbony! compound is capable of undergoing ketoenol tautomerism and the
enol form is responsible for the reactivity. The photopolymerization in the
absence of oxygen of methyl methacrylate36 by dyes (e.g., erythrosine,
thionine blue) in the presence of amines (e.g., triethanolamine) was also
reported.
ion pair complex. The light absorption by the ion pair results in electron
591
PHILIP WEISS
transfer to reduce the cation (e.g., to Fe2+) and oxidize the anion to an
atom or a free radical. The free radical initiates polymerization with the
available monomer. For example, Simionescu et al.38 prepared. polyacryloni-
true in stannic chloride solution at 20C using a 300 W Thelta lamp as the
ultraviolet radiation source. By a different mechanism, Hiltz and Lendrat39
polymerized acrylamide in water, as well as in polar organic solvents (e.g.,
methanol, acetone, dioxane, and dimethylformamide), at room temperature
chain initiation. Other oxides4' of importance in photo-induced polymerization include magnesium oxide, titanium dioxide, aluminium trioxide and
chromium trioxide.
592
PHOTO-INDUCED POLYMERIZATION
thus produced, then reacts with the available monomer to initiate graft
copolymerization. In the presence of oxygen, the photoexcited dye molecule
PHOTOINITIATION BY TRIPHENYLPHOSPHINE
In this laboratory, Mao and Eldred42 discovered that the triphenyl
derivatives of phosphorus, arsenic, antimony, and bismuth are capable of
initiating photopolymerization. A comparison of the relative effectiveness
of these compounds in photopolymerization of methyl methacrylate is q,3P,
p3Bi, qaSb, q3As. Triphenyl bismuthine, triphenyl arsine and triphenyl
stibine initiated photopolymerization of monomers which normally could
be polymerized by a free-radical mechanism induced by peroxide or azotype catalysts. For example, triphenyl bismuthine in ultraviolet decomposed
to phenyl radicals and bismuth. The phenyl radical thus was the initiating
species for the subsequent free-radical polymerization. Triphenyiphosphine
proved to be a novel initiator for photopolymerization, and very selective,
in that it initiated the photopolymerization of only acrylic-type monomers;
styrene could not be photopolymerized when ultraviolet light-excited
triphenyiphosphine was used as the photoinitiator.
Experimentally, the bulk polymerizations were carried out in Vycor
tubes and the source of ultraviolet was a 350 W 1-lanovia high pressure
593
PHILIP WEISS
mercury lamp; for solution polymerization, the source was a 450 W Hanovia
high pressure lamp. For kinetic studies, the polymerizations were carried out
ci,
c(I
0
-o
260
280
Wavelength, m
Figure 1. Effect of irradiation on (C6H5)3P in heptane
594
PHOTO-INDUCED POLYMERIZATION
methacrylate and styrene yielded 1 :1 copolymers and this further emphasized a free-radical mechanism for the propagation step; it also excluded the
possibility of propagation by an ionic reaction.
The kinetic study of the triphenyiphosphine-initiated photopolymerization resulted in a linear rate curve up to at least 10 per cent conversion. The
1-4 -
1-2
4x104 (C6H5)3P
LU
-f
1)
rj
1-0
-J
0-6
No (C6H5)3P
33
3-1
I
3.7
3-5
1/Tx iO
Figure 2. Arrhenius plot for triphenyiphosphine-initiated photopolymerization of methyl
methacrylate
+
0-8
0-6
I
0-5
10
15
2-0
25
3-0
3-5
with anthracene. In the presence of air, initiation did not occur until the
triphenyiphosphine concentration exceeded about 3 x 10 moles/litre and
595
PHILIP WEISS
then the rate was similar to the photopolymerization in a nitrogen atmosphere. The dissolved oxygen converted some of the phosphine to the oxide
and when the available oxygen was consumed, initiation then proceeded via
ultraviolet irradiation of triphenyiphosphine.
The nature of solvent employed in the triphenyiphosphine-initiated photopolymerization of methyl methacrylate has a decided effect on the rate of
Without
Initiator
Solvent
(mole l.'sec')
644 x l0
581 x lO
(mole l.1sec')
111 x 1O
222 x lO
Benzene
Ethyl acetate
M
(mole l.')
566
566
12-
(C5H5)3 P/Heplane
10
a)
1K
06
4:
(C6H5)3 P/MMA
04
02
250
Figure 4.
290
270
X,
N
310
mt
Ultraviolet spectra
596
PHOTO-INDUCED POLYMERIZATION
100
N.
10
00 -
- 10
0)
0
-J
To
Figure
2900
2850
2800
2750
Wavelength,
2700
01
2650 2625
5. Change in wave length of complex peak of methyl methacrylate and triphenylphosphine upon dilution with heptane
PHILIP WEISS
08 07
j_
E
06 -1-..,
-e
03
0
U)
<02
0.1 0
50
150
100
Time of irradiation,sec
Figure 6. Decay of complex peak of methyl acrylate and triphenyiphosphine with ultraviolet
radiation
NATURE OF COMPLEX
The first choice for the site of complex formation in methyl methacrylate
would be the double bond. However, failure of other vinyl compounds such
as styrene to be initiated by the phosphine rules out this possibility. Alter..
natively, it is proposed that there is a dipole interaction between the carbonyl
oxygen and the phosphorus. Upon irradiation, phosphorus donates one of
its unpaired electrons to the oxygen, resulting in an inter-molecular chargetransfer complex. Rearrangement of electrons throughout the system, as
shown in the following scheme, produces a methyl methacrylate radical
which can proceed to propagate the reaction.
CH3
h
cH=c_rO.jPi
OCH3
cc=o;
CH3
CH3
CH2C=C0
OCH3
Similar complexes can be formed between the monomer and other triphenyl
PHOTO-INDUCED POLYMERIZATION
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The author wishes to thank Dr. T. J. Mao and Mr. R. J. Eldred of the
Polymers Department, General Motors Research Laboratories, for many
helpful suggestions and stimulating discussions in the preparation of this
manuscript.
References
'G. Oster. J. Polymer Sd. Pt. C. No. 12, 63 (1966).
2 T. Tsunoda. Yoki Gosei Kagaku Kyokai Shi 20, 1120 (1962).
3M. Imoto. Kagaku 18, 1019 (1963); Chem. Abstr. 60, 8813c (1964).
' D.
W. Woodward, V. C. Chambers and A. B. Cohen. Photo. Sci. Eng. 7, (6), 360 (1963).
G. M. Burnett in Mechanism of Polymer Reactions, Interscience, New York (1954).
18 W. E. Mochel,J. L. Crandall andJ. H. Peterson. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 77, 494 (1955).
19 B. R. Chinmayanandam and H. W. Melville. Trans. Faraday Soc. 50, 73 (1954).
20 V. A. Englehardt and M. L. Peterson, U.S. 2 716 633 (1955); Chem. Abstr. 50, P1365i
(1956).
21 R. Norrish andJ. Simons. Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) A251, 4 (1959).
22 M. Okawara, T. Nakai, K. Morishita and E. Imoto. Kogyo Kagaku Zasshi 67, (12), 2108
(1964); Chem. Abstr. 62, 14827b (1965).
23 R.J. Kern, U.S. 2861933 and 2861934 (1958); Chern. Abstr. 53, 3768i (1959).
24 A. Hrubesch, H. Craubner, W. Luck. DR. Pat. 1 099 166 (1961); Chem. Abstr. 55, 24108g
(1961).
25J. W. Breitenbach and H. Frittum. J. Polymer Sci. 24, 300 (1957).
26 U. Larilon, G. Delzenne and A. Conix. Photo. Sci. and Eng. 9 (6), 364 (1965).
27 G. K. Oster, G. Oster and G. Prati. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 79, 595 (1957).
28 G. Oster. Nature 173, 300 (1954).
29 G. Oster andY. Mizutani. J. Polymer Sci. 22, 173 (1956).
3 G. Oster, U.S. 2 850 445 (1958).
31 G. Deizenne, S. Toppet and G. Smets. J.
Polymer Sci. 48, 347 (1960).
32 M. Koizumi and A. Watanabe. Bull. Chem. Soc. Japan 28, 136 (1955); Chem. Abstr. 52,
2447a (1958).
M. Koizumi, A. Watanabe and Z. Kuroda. Nature 175, 770 (1955).
Z. Yoshida, K. Maeda and R. Oda. Kogyo Kagaku Zasshi 60, 1161(1957); Chem. Abstr. 53,
12735i (1959).
S. Chabarek, R. J. Allen and G. Goldberg. J. Phys. Chem. 69, (9) 2834 (1965).
36 A. Gosh and M. Saha. Indian J. Chem. 3 (10),
467 (1965).
' M. G. Evans, M. Santappa and N. Un. J. Polymer
Sci. 7. 243 (1951).
38
C. Simionescu, D. Feldman and A. Liga. Plaste Kautschuk 13 (1), 32 (1966) ; Chem. Abstr. 64,
19785c (1966).
39A. A. Hiltz and E.G. Lendrat. U.S. 2880152 (1959); U.S. 2880153 (1959); Chem.
40J.
Markham. J.
PHILIP WEISS
45J. Hicks and H. Melville. Nature 171, 300 (1953); J. Polymer Sd. 12, 461 (1954); Proc. Roy.
Soc. A226, 314 (1954).
46 G. Oster and 0. Shibata. J. Polymer Sci. 26, 233 (1962).
G. Oster, G. K. Oster, and H. Mordson. J. Polymer Sci. 34, 671 (1959).
4 N. Geacintov, V. Stannet and E. W. Abrahamson. Makromol.
Chemie 36, 52 (1959).
G. Smets, W. DeWinter, and G. Deizenne. J. Polymer Sci. 55, 767 (1961).
5 T. Otu. Kogyo Kagaku Zasshi 62, 1462 (1959); Chem. Abstr. 57, 13980b (1959).
51 M. Okawara, H. Yamashina, K. Ishiyama, and E. Imoto. Kogyo Kagaku Zasshi 66, (9)
1383 (1963); Chem. Abstr. 60, 14628e (1964).
52J. Guillet and R. Norrish. Proc. Roy. Soc. A233, 153 (1955).
600