SN

RATE COMPARISION
Annexure A
Name of Work: - Schedule for Trenching and cable laying at NKJ & DMO station.(i) NKJ-Shifting of Shunt Signal no.66 of marshalling yard near hump cabin
(ii) DMO-Replacement of Defective Cable.
Railway Schedule
LAR 1
LAR 2
LAR 3
AVG
Tenderer
escalated
Escalated
Escalated
Escalated
Escalated
Escalated
Escalated
Description
Unit
Qty
Amount
Rate
Rate
Amount
Rate
Amount
Rate
Amount
Amount

Excavation, casting and plastering (above

ground level) of Shunt Signal foundation as
per Drg.No.SK-749 based on Drg. No. RST11173 with Contractors own materials
including Cement and Anchor Bolts of
No.
Standard Size. The hole for cable entry should
be kept as per site requirement and
instruction of Rly engineer at site. The
required scaffolding, Ferma etc for casting of
foundation will have to be brought by the
Contractor at his own cost.
Erection of shunt signal with Surface Base,
Post, Signal unit and fixing of No. plates. The
No.
work shall be done as per instructions of Rly
engineer at site.
Termination of tail cable on Shunt signal units
and wiring with contractor own material,
fixing of lenses this also includes insertion of No.
tail cable from ground to signal unit etc. The
work shall be done as per instruction of Rly
engineer at site.
Fixing of ARA/WAGO Terminals and fuse
blocks with provision of holes on hylam
sheets and fixing by galvanised nuts & bolts in
location boxes and else where. This includes No.
provision of two additional holes on the
hylam board on either side for cable
conductor entry. The work shall be done as
per the instruction of Rly engineer at site.

2096.26

2175.23

2175.23

2175.23

2337.3299

372.93

386.98

386.98

386.98

415.82

276.09

286.51

286.51

286.51

307.84

200

2094

10.86

2172.51

2297.99

11.67

11.99

2398.31

11.62

2323.15

Railway Schedule

a
7
a

LAR 2

LAR 3

Escalated
Amount

Escalated
Rate

Escalated
Amount

Escalated
Rate

Escalated
Amount

AVG
escalated
Amount

Tenderer
Rate

Unit

Qty

Amount

Escalated
Rate

Per
conductor

SN

LAR 1

400

3140

9.00

3598.73

8.71

3485.95

8.15

3258.77

3447.82

8.75

Excavation, casting and plastering (above

ground level) of Apparatus case foundation
with contractors own Metal Sheet frame,
cement, anchor bolts and other materials.
Single case as per Drg No JBP/S&T/C/084
No.

29635.48

8485.24

33940.95

8219.32

32877.28

7687.97

30751.88

32523.37

8260.89

Erection of apparatus cases.This includes

filling of location foundation with river bed
sand and plastering on top of the sand.
Single case.
No.

3386.44

1034.19

4136.77

1001.78

4007.13

878.51

3514.06

3885.99

943.97

Fabrication and fixing of phenolic board in

location box by providing all fixtures as per
Railway Drawing including fixing of PVC
coated string rods at the back side for cable
support with contractor's own materials.
Lasing and dressing of cables/wires
terminated with contractors own supply of
lasing thread. The work shall be done as per
instructions of Rly engineer at site.
Single case.
No.

4787.36

2114.75

8458.99

1920.55

7682.22

1241.92

4967.69

7036.30

1334.48

Description
Termination of cable cores on ARA/WAGO
terminal, fuse blocks, in the apparatus cases.
This includes all associated works of pulling
out the cable from underground, dressing of
cable, making wiring tree etc. Both ends of a
cable core shall be counted as per conductor.
The work shall be done as per location plans
and instructions of Rly engineer at site.

Railway Schedule
SN

Description

LAR 1
Unit

Excavation of trench as per cable route plan,

1.2 mtr deep, 300mm wide at the bottom
along main line in normal soil, This work
includes covering of cable laid in trenches by
loose soil for a layer of 50 mm thickness
approximately before covering by shahabad
stone/bricks, clearing of route, bushes etc and mtr
refilling of the trench by excavated soil and
ramming after laying of the required quantity
of cables as per instructions of Engineer at
site. If it is not possible to reach the required
depth at any location, then the contractor
shall obtain prior approval of Engineer-incharge before commencement of cable laying
process and only then shall the proportionate
payment be made to the contractor.

Fixing of GI pipes for crossing the culverts,

stone bridges etc. and concreting the ends
with brick masonry at both ends as per the
instructions of Rly. Engineer at site with
Contractor's materials. The brick masonry at
10 the ends shall be done with well-burnt bricks mtr
& cement mixture of 1:3 ratio. (GI pipes shall
be supplied by Rlys.) 3 perforation of 0.6mm
dia per meter shall be made on the GI pipe as
per the instructions of Engineer at site. This
includes fixing with contractors own MS
chanel, clamps of proper size etc as per
instructions of engineer at site.
Excavation of cable trench 1m deep and
300mm wide across the track, for track
crossing and refilling after laying of
11
mtr
DWC/RCC/GI pipes. The work shall be done
as per extant practice on W.C. Rly &
instruction of Rly engineer at site.

Qty

Amount

Escalated
Rate

1850

67784

41.96

20

1072.8

80

6700

95.91

LAR 2

LAR 3

Escalated
Amount

Escalated
Rate

Escalated
Amount

Escalated
Rate

Escalated
Amount

AVG
escalated
Amount

Tenderer
Rate

77633.69

40.65

75200.72

38.02

70335.01

74389.81

40.85

59.51

1190.22

55.68

1113.53

1151.87

59.81

92.90

7432.13

86.90

6952.03

7352.25

93.38

7672.58

Railway Schedule

LAR 1

SN

Description
Unit
Preparation of Cable way 150 mm wide at the
bottom and 300 mm deep in rocky area &
refilling the same (after cable-laying) with
12
mtr
concrete mixture of proportion 1:3:6 and
grouting the ends at either side of the rocky
portion using concrete mixture with
Contractor's own cement & other materials.

Supply & laying of well burnt bricks of size

225x100x75mm inside the trench (with the
brick length being perpendicular to cable
route) after laying of cable in station area
from Outermost to Outermost signal or at
13
No.
any other location as per instruction of Site
Engineer. Note :- Size of bricks to be got
approved by Site Engineer. In case brick size
is in variance with the size given in the tender
schedule then proportionate payment on
volumetric basis shall be paid to contractor
subject to a maximum limit of schedule rate.
Laying of signalling/Power/Telecom cable of
14
KM
various cores/sizes in trenches.
Placing and securing of cable route marker in
trenches at the specified interval and at
15
No.
diversion joint etc .along the cable route The
work shall be done as per extant practice on
WCR & the instruction of Rly engineer at site.
Laying of GI/DWC/RCC pipes along with
collars in trenches at places wherever
16
mtr
required as per the instruction of the engineer
at site.
TOTAL AMOUNT

A
B

LAR 2

LAR 3

Escalated
Amount

Escalated
Rate

Escalated
Amount

Escalated
Rate

Escalated
Amount

AVG
escalated
Amount

Tenderer
Rate

Qty

Amount

Escalated
Rate

20

7223

0.00

0.00

400.66

8013.28

374.76

7495.16

7754.22

402.68

16900

39039

2.65

44845.16

2.57

43439.76

2.41

40709.57

42998.16

2.58

2.6

10383.412

4573.82

11891.92

4430.48

11519.24

4144.06

10774.56

11395.24

4452.89

30

274.5

9.51

285.31

285.31

10.20

20

863.6

1010.30

48.15

52.76

1055.11

48.27

179128.872

Total escalated Amount of Average LARs

Total Amount of Tenderer
Difference(A-B)
% above/below

965.49

198377.34

198377.34
199728.69
1351.35
0.68% Above

Annexure A

Tenderer
Amount

2337.33

415.82

307.84

2334.81

Tenderer
Amount

3501.10

33043.56

3775.88

5337.91

Tenderer
Amount

75579.16

1196.17

7470.50

Tenderer
Amount

8053.65

43528.49

11577.50

306.07

962.91
199728.69

West Central Railway

Name of Work: Revised cost for construction of additional block(G+3) Central Hospital at Jabalpur
(Pink Book Item No.427 of 2010-11)

SN

Description

Variation Between Abstact and Revised estimate

Excess/saving due to
Saving
Excess from
WP
Sanctioned
Revised
from
other than price
abstarct
cost/Abstra
detailed
estimated
abstract
Price
escalation
cost
ct cost
estimated cost
cost
cost
escalation
New
(5-3)
Qty
(3-5)
Items
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Revised cost
of S&T portion.

1000000

1576176

1860401.97

284225.97

649681

76119.04

154728

Total `

1000000

1576176

1860401.97

284225.97

649681

178188

69374

89.724

89.724

64.968

17.819

6.937

In term of %age

64.968

24.756

Remarks

11

1) There is excess in price

escalation due to increase the
rates of some items.
2)There is excess in other
than price escalation due to
increase the quantities of
some items and inclusion of
new items.

Net Excess-`897243
In % age-89.724

arks

xcess in price
o increase the
ems.
cess in other
alation due to
quantities of
d inclusion of

7243
24

ZONE/
Division

Date of Inspection

COMPLAINCE FOR BOARD'S SAFETY DRIVE ON POINTS & CROSSING (No.2014/SAFETY-1/3/5)

Date of Last
Name & Designation of inspecting Supervisors of Pway & S&T
Yard
Point No.
Joint
Inspection

WCR/JBP

Rail section
60 kg/
52 kg/
other

Type of X-ing
Builtup/CMS

Sleeper type PSC/Steel /Wooden

X-ing
Angle(1:8:5/
1:12/1:16)

Straight/Curved

Rean jointly by Supervisors of Pway & S&T

SN

(i)

2
3
4
5
6
7
8

Permissible limits or desired

value

Item

(ii)
Condition
of
Rail(chipped/Knife
Edge/Corroded)

(iii)
Torgue

Through of Switch
Housing of Tongue Rail with Stock
Rail
Vertical & Lateral Wear of Tongue
Rail & croossing
Physical Condition of Fittings of
Turn Out
Obstruction Test
Track Locking
Any other Item
ADEN Signature
Name

Past Readings

Deficiency
Noted

(iv)

(v)

Corrective
action
taken with
date
(vi)

Readings taken jointly by ADSTE & ADEN

Present reading

Discrepancy
(Present/past
reading)

(vii)

(viii)

Thickness
of
top
edge
shouldnot be less than 2 mm
over a length of more than 100
mm anywhere upto a disatance
of 1000mm from toe
5-115 mm
6 sleepers
Vertical-5mm
lateral-6mm
Crossing-10 mm
5 mm
205T drop

ADSTE Signature
Name

Pway & S&T

Remarks

(ix)