Tissue Tolerances as
Related to Breast Cancer
Radiation Therapy
Marie E. Taylor, M.D., F.A.C.R.
March 20, 2009
Therapeutic Ratio
A quantitative expression which can be used
to compare the effectiveness of different
therapeutic strategies
T.R. =
Total dose
Dose per fraction
Overall (elapsed) treatment time
Volume treated
Serial structure (e.g. GI tract)
Parallel structure (e.g. lung)
Type of radiation (photon vs. neutron or proton)
Genetic susceptibilities
Collagen vascular disease
Ataxia telangiectasia ATM
Additional therapy
systemic chemotherapy
hormonal
biologicals
When radiation therapy precedes chemotherapy, the introduction of the Second mode can
lead to the expression of subclinical damage or when Injury is present, can lead to death.
In addition to complications (broken Lines) caused by the addition of the second mode
alone, associated Infection, trauma or stress can lead to overt syndromes of injury.
(Rubin, P., Casarret, G.W. Clinical Radiation Pathology, vol. I and II. Philadelphia, WB
Saunders, 1968).
TD 5/5 -
2/3
3/3
TD 5/5 (cGy)
4500
3000
1750
TD 50/5 (cGy)
6500
4000
2450
2/3
3/3
TD 5/5 (cGy)
6000
4500
4000
TD 50/5 (cGy)
7000
5500
5000
Rate
0
7%
13%
36%
< 10 Gy
11 20 Gy
21 30 Gy
> 30 Gy
0
9%
24%
50%
4x
CLD (cm)
10x
CLD (cm)
3x
MHD (cm)
6X
MHD (cm)
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
Table 2. EUD (Gy) Corresponding to Indicated NTCP of OARs with Lyman Parameters
Fitted by Burman et al (1991) for Tissue Complications from Treatments with
Conventional Fractionation.
EUD (Gy) for indicated NTCP
0.01
0.02
0.03
0.05
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
Heart
36.4
37.8
38.7
40.0
41.8
44.0
45.5
46.8
48.0
49.2
50.5
52.0
54.2
13.8
15.2
16.0
17.1
18.8
20.8
22.2
23.4
24.5
25.6
26.8
28.2
30.2
Brachial plexus
53.3
55.9
57.6
59.9
63.4
67..5
70.3
72.8
75.0
77.2
79.7
82.5
86.6
Ribs
33.5
37.8
40.4
44.1
49.5
56.0
60.6
64.5
68.0
71.5
75.4
80.0
86.5
Skin
49.7
52.2
53.8
55.9
59.1
63.0
65.7
67.9
70.0
72.1
74.3
77.0
80.9
Spinal Cord
38.4
41.8
44.0
47.0
51.5
56.8
60.5
63.6
66.5
69.4
72.5
76.2
81.5
Thyroid
29.7
35.9
39.8
45.1
53.1
62.6
69.2
74.8
80.0
85.2
90.8
97.4
106.9
17
3 months later
Sharply defined hilar reticular density
Tenting of the (R) medial hemihemidiaphragm
Right mediastinal shift
Fajardo, L.F., Berthrong, M., Anderson, R.E. Cardiovascular System. In: Radiation Pathology,
Pathology, Oxford
University Press, New York, 2001, pp. 165 192.
Fresh cut surface of lung showing, in the center, a sharply circumscribed white are of
fibrosis next to the main stem bronchus (right). Such precisely defined scars with linear
edges are characteristic (but not consistent) result of radiotherapy for pulmonary
neoplasms. Fajardo, L.F., Berthrong, M., Anderson, R.E. Cardiovascular System. In:
Radiation Pathology,
Pathology, Oxford University Press, New York, 2001, pp. 165 192.
18
54 year old man received 40 Gy to the mantle in 5 weeks for Hodgkins disease. Three months
after initiation of therapy (radiation only), he developed ARP and died of it 37 days later. This
lung section shows thickening of alveolar septa by edema, fibrosis tissue, and a few inflammatory
cells. Dark hyaline membranes of variable thickness line most of the alveolar spaces. Fajardo, L.F.,
Berthrong, M., Anderson, R.E. Cardiovascular System. In: Radiation Pathology,
Pathology, Oxford
University Press, New York, 2001, pp. 165 192.
Dense, sharply defined fibrosis obliterates the normal parenchyma. The edge of this fibrous scar
corresponds roughly to the edge of the radiation field. Fajardo, L.F., Berthrong, M., Anderson,
R.E. Cardiovascular System. In: Radiation Pathology,
Pathology, Oxford University Press, New York, 2001,
pp. 165 192.
19
Radiation pneumonitis
radiologic manifestations
Acute phase ground glass
opacities and/or
consolidation in the
irradiated port
20
Radiation Fibrosis
Radiologically appears as a well defined volume loss
Linear scarring
Consolidation with typically sharp borders
Traction bronchiectasis
Displacement of the mediastinum
Adjacent pleural thickening or effusion
Clear demarcation of normal and irradiated lung is
seen with evolution of radiation fibrosis
21
22
Conclusions::
Conclusions
Radiological lung abnormalities were common
after XRT.
These abnormalities were usually reversible.
No correlation between symptoms and lung or
pleural reactions was seen.
23
V20
Max
Min
Mean
Lung Dose
Mean
Lung Volume
Lung:
Upper Lobe
43
7291
39
2607
3657
Lung:
Lower Lobe
39
8056
25
2452
3886
Hodgkins
Disease
(Involved Field)
31
4586
12
1453
2915
Physician A
(Lt. Breast)
24
6583
11
1242
2255
Physician B
(Rt. Breast)
23
7276
1233
3092
Radiation Pneumonitis as a
Finding of Mean Lung Dose:
An Analysis of Pooled Data of 540 Patients
Kwa, S. et al. IJROBP 42(1):142(1):1-9; 1998
24
Radiation Pneumonitis as a
Finding of Mean Lung Dose:
An Analysis of Pooled Data of 540 Patients
Kwa, S. et al. IJROBP 42(1):142(1):1-9; 1998
25
Results
Cumulative dose of radiotherapy
administered to the lung can be a consistent
predictor of radiation pneumonitis.
For both paired and ipsilateral lung
volumes, the difference between the mean
DVHs of the complication and complication
free patients is small. Suggests differences
in patient sensitivity may contribute
significantly.
Tsougos, I. et al. Physics in Med & Biol 52:105552:1055-1073; 2007
26
Results
Of the NTCP models examined, dose
distribution to the ipsilateral lung was able to
predict pneumonitis only for grade II
pneumonitis. The LKB model gave the best fit.
Modeling on the basis of paired organs did not
get acceptable results.
No positive statistical correlation could be
established between the incidence of radiation
pneumonitis and PFTs (FEV1, bronchial
obstruction) FVC (index of lung compliance).
Tsougos, I. et al. Physics in Med & Biol 52:105552:1055-1073; 2007
27
Methods
87 patients who received breast cancer
irradiation with complete DVH of the
ipsilateral 1mg
Prospectively followed with clinical and xx-ray
outcomes (CXR CT)
Four NTCP models used
Endpoints of Study
Clinical pneumonitis, Grade 11-3 CTCCTCNCIC criteria
Radiological changes on CXR
Radiological changes on CT
28
Results
28% of patients developed pneumonitis (including
grade 1)
35% had CXR changes
15% had density changes on CT.
Analysis showed that pneumonitis is a smooth function
of EUD and was predicted well by all 4 models.
The EUD or mean lung dose is a robust and simple
parameter that correlates well with the risk of
pneumonitis.
For all endpoints the D50 values ranged between 1010-20
Gy.
Rancati, T. et al. Radiother and Oncol 82:30882:308-316, 2007
29
CT Assessed Pneumonitis
Figure 2. (c) Incidence of CT assessed pneumonitis as a function of EUD for the LOGEUD model.
In all cases observed complication rates [solid symbols] and predicted NTCP curve [continuous
line, curve obtained using best estimated parameters] are plotted. The dotted lines depict the
two--dimensional 68% confidence region [see the text] for the NTCP curve. Rancati, T. et al.
two
Radiother and Oncol 82:30882:308-316, 2007.
30
FVC Decreases during radiation therapy and can transiently improve over time.
Magnitude of decrease is greater in patients having chemotherapy and irradiation.
31
FEV1 - Decreasing trend over 12 months, with significant decrease even at 1 month.
Effect is greater in patients also receiving chemotherapy.
32
Clinical Evaluation
Symptoms
Sputum production
Dyspnea
Flat surface
Hurrying gentle slope
Hurrying steep slope
Hemoptysis
Cough dry or productive
Wheeze
33
1
64%
3
64%
6
0%
12
0%
34
# of pts
Median
F/U
Cardiac Morbidity
Relative Risk
960
20 yrs
Cardiac Mortality
Relative Risk
2.0 (ischemic
heart disease)
DBCG 82
3,083
12 yrs
Kings College
(population based)
20,871
15 yrs
0.86 (ischemic
heart disease)
0.84 (ischemic
heart disease)
1.59 (ischemic
heart disease)
1.27 Cardiovascular
disease
SEER
(population based)
48,353
10 yrs
Ontario Cancer
Registry
(population based)
25,570
14 yrs
No increased risk of
MI with XRT
Left
Left--sided treatment
2.10 fatal MI
35
Cardiovascular Effects of
Breast Cancer Radiotherapy
Senkus--Konefka, E., et al. Cancer Treat Rev 33:578Senkus
33:578-593, 2007
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
A.
36
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
B.
Heart, from behind, with blood vessels injected
This posterior view of the same specimen as in A shows the coronary sinus (12) in the posterior atrioventricular groove and thre
threee
large tributaries entering it
itthe great cardiac vein (17), the posterior vein of the left ventricle (16) and the middle cardiac vein
(13). The four pulmonary veins (2, 4, 9 and 10) enter the left atrium (5).
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
37
Musculophrenic artery
38
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
31.
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
Sternocleidomastoid muscle
Deltoid muscle
Pectoralis major muscle
Anterior cutaneous branches of intercostal nerves
Cut edge of anterior layer of rectus sheath
Rectus abdominis muscle
Tendinous intersection
External abdominal oblique muscle
Lateral femoral cutaneous nerve
Femoral vein
Great saphenous vein
Medial supraclavicular nerves
Pectoralis minor muscle (reflected) and medial pectoral nerves
Axillary vein
Long thoracic nerve and lateral thoracic artery
Internal thoracic artery
Intercostal nerves
Lateral cutaneous branches of intercostal nerves
Superior epigastric artery
ThoracoThoraco-abdominal (intercostal) nerves
Transversus abdominis muscle
Posterior layer of rectus sheath
Inferior epigastric artery
Lateral femoral cutaneous nerve
Inguinal ligament and ilioilio-inguinal nerve
Femoral nerve
Femoral artery
Spermatic cord
Testis
Posterior intercostal arteries
Internal abdominal oblique muscle
Lateral cutaneous branch of intercostal nerve
Dorsal branch of spinal nerve
Latissimus dorsi muscle
Deep muscles of the back (medial and lateral tract)
Anterior layer of rectus sheath
Posterior layer of rectus sheath
Thoracolumbar fascia
Spinal cord
Aorta
Ventral root
of spinal
Dorsal root
nerve
The long axis taken along the heart itself shows the soso-called four
four--chamber projection.
Anderson, R.H., et al.; J Anat 2004; 159159-177
39
The magnetic resonance image in frontal projection shows that the soso-called
anterior descending coronary artery emerges from the aorta in superior position.
Anderson, R.H., et al.; J Anat 2004; 159159-177
The magnetic resonance image, taken in lateral projection (saggital plan), shows that the sosocalled rightright-sided structures, the right ventricle, infundibulum and pulmonary trunk, are in
reality anterior to their leftleft-sided counterparts
Anderson, R.H., et al.; J Anat 2004; 159159-177
40
A slice parallel to the image shown in the previous slide reveals the location of the
esophagus directly posterior to the soso-called left
left--sided cardiac structures.
Anderson, R.H., et al.; J Anat 2004; 159159-177
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
1)
3)
4)
5)
14)
15)
16)
21)
41
42
Chest pain
Dyspnea, weakness, unusual fatigue, cold sweats or
dizziness during an acute MI
Prodromal symptoms
Unusual fatigue
1 month or more sleep disturbance
Shortness of breath prior to MI
Unstable angina, women tend to have less chest pain
and more diaphoresis, dyspnea, nausea and epigastric
pain
13 women
12 men
43
256 Deaths
102 breast cancer
50 other malignancies
100 other causes
4 unknown
Non breast cancer deaths accounted for 60% of
known deaths
(72% for those > 70 yrs., 48% for those < 70 yrs.)
44
Results
Cardiovascular disease was associated with a
significantly increased risk of death from other
causes (p
(p = .002)
Osteoporosis was associated with a significantly
increased risk of dying from other malignancy
(p = .05)
Node (+) breast cancer associated with an increased
risk of breast cancer specific death (p
(p < .001)
Increased death from all 3 causes was associated with
older age (p
(p < .001)
V40
Max
Min
Mean
Mean
Volume cm3
Lung:
Upper Lobe
19
7093
231
2642
681
Lung:
Lower Lobe
36
7789
426
3840
458
Hodgkins
Disease
0.5
4010
65
545
477
Physician A
(Lt. Breast)
5.6
5516
99
1471
616
Physician B
(Rt. Breast)
4334
11
312
760
45
46
47
phantom 15 patients
dose distributions from TPS vs. NTCP values obtained
with study methodology difference 0.1% + 0.3%
48
49
Results
Mean
FB
2.5 mm
IG
1.1 mm
EG
0.7 mm
DIBH
4.1 mm
EBH
2.6 mm
22.4%
3.6%
50
45.6%
29.5%
DIBH 27.7%
EBH and EG both the irradiated heart, LAD
and lung volumes increased compared with FB
Korreman, S.S., et al. Radiother Oncol 76:31176:311-318, 2005.
51
52
Variations in Normal
Tissue Tolerances
Alsbeigh, G., et al. IJROBP 68(1):22968(1):229-235, 2007
53
At 2Gy Exposure
Clonogenic survival fraction was 0.150.15-0.5.
The number of risk alleles were increased
with increasing radiation sensitivity
Alsbeigh, G., et al. IJROBP 68(1):22968(1):229-235, 2007
Conclusions
Reduction in risk for late pulmonary and cardiac
effects of radiation therapy for the treatment of
breast cancer requires minimal radiation
dose/exposure to those normal tissues.
Normal tissue tolerance is affected by many
factors, including genetic susceptibilities of the
host.
Genetic susceptibility studies are currently
underway with evaluation of genetic predictive
markers.
54
Conclusions (contd)
NTCP models for lung and heart are
under development and evaluation:
V20 for lung cancer over predicts risk of
radiation pneumonitis
EUD or mean lung dose (10 20 Gy) is
best simple predictive factor for risk of
pneumonitis in breast cancer patients
Conclusions (contd)
Emerging technologies with gated inspiration breath
holding, IMRT or tomotherapy have promise for
reducing medium or high dose radiation exposure to
heart and lungs. IMRT and tomotherapy increase the
integral dose (volume of tissue receiving any radiation
dose).
Although accurate treatment planning and normal tissue
models guide our estimates of safe and effective
therapy, the practical aspects of daily positioning and
set up also remain a critical part of safe radiation
practice. For this, we must acknowledge excellence in
daily practice by our treating radiation therapy
technologists.
55