Anda di halaman 1dari 33

GENERAL SECRETARY'S DESK

v MEMBERSHIP VERIFICATION after the revision of Pay scales as per the 6th CPC.
We know the constraints, difficulties and problems in (i) The existing pay scales have to be substituted by
collecting Declaration forms from all members in the new pay and Grade Pay straightaway without
midst of peak summer prevailing with Loo…, General making any reference.
election etc. But we have to do it. The same constraints (ii) Single set of recruitment rules may be formulated
are available to other organisations also. and notified for merged grade.
We are having more leaders and cadres in (iii) Minimum eligibility for promotion etc in a grade
each division/branch. It is quite possible to obtain was prescribed as follows:
100% declaration forms from our members besides
SL. No. Grade Pay Minimum
attracting others by our activities, aims, objects and Qualifying Service
functioning. Our leaders and cadres, as usual, shall From To for promotion
proceed on immediate leave; go round the entire
division; collect declaration forms; Assist SBCO, P4, 1. 1900 2000 3 years
GDS Unions to collect more declarations for their 2. 1900 2400 8 years
unions too;
3. 2000 2400 5 years
We are having the history; Still we are the
sine-qua-non of Postal Employees. We are committed 4. 2400 2800 5 years
to work for the betterment of Postal workers.
5. 2400 4200 10 years
Popularize our activities among the Postal workers.
Compare the CHQ activities and works. We can 6. 2800 4200 6 years
proudly say that 90% of problems brought to the CHQ
7. 4200 4600 5 years
notice had been resolved ; of course except the issues
related to Government policy and programme - Your 8. 4200 4800 6 years
CHQ is the only CHQ contacting the Divisional
9. 4200 5400 8 years
Secretaries frequently; ascertain the problems and
taking appropriate action. Educate and Explain all 10. 4600 4800 2 years
these to the basic workers. We are not only old but
11. 4600 5400 3 years
also youth in activities. We will leave no stone unturned
in mitigating the issues of Postal workers. From the above, the qualifying service of LSG,
We are proud to hear that there is no second HSG II and HSG I may be determined as 5 years, 6
union in Patiala, Faridkot in Punjab Circle. The years and 5 years respectively. It will disturb the
Divisional Secretary, Koppal Karnataka confirmed the present qualifying service of 3 years from LSG to HSG
same. In Delhi Capital, there is no second union in P3 II and 3 years from HSG II to HSG I.
in New Delhi South West Division. We are receiving
We placed our demand to the department to
reports that in many divisions, the Divisional/Branch
follow the present prescribed 3 years of qualifying
Secretaries are taking all out efforts to increase the
service for HSG II & HSG I promotion. The Department
membership around 15 to 20%. Let it be spread to the
has assured to take up the issue and revise the
entire nation. Let us strengthen our capacity of
recruitment rules as per the present qualifying service.
collective bargaining at Division/Circle and All India
levels with our increased membership. v Classification of Posts - Gazette
Notification:
The CHQ will honour by presenting
awards and mementos to the best branches The DOPT & Training vide its Gazette Notification dt.
which enrolled more membership in the next All 09.04.2009 under S. O. 946 (E) has classified the Civil
India conference. Why not, your branch is one Posts with the following revised classification.
among the winner. Time is too short. Act, advance
and achieve the target and intimate the CHQ for BHARTIYA POST
ensuring the award.
v Amendment to Service Rules/ FOOD FOR THOUGHT
Recruitment Rules: -
The DOPT vide its OM No. AB 14017/61/2008-
Estt (RR) dt. 24.03.09 has amended the Service rules
SUBSCRIBE TODAY
BHARTIYA POST 1 JUNE, 2009
Sl. No. Description of Posts Classification of posts
1 (a) A Central Civil post in Cabinet Secretary’s scale (Rs. 90000-fixed), Apex
Scale (Rs.80000-fixed and Higher Administrative Grade plus scale
(Rs.75500-80000) and
(B) A Central Civil Post carrying the following grade pays: - Group A
Rs. 12000, Rs.10000, Rs.8900 and Rs.8700 in the scale of pay of
Rs.37400-67000 in Pay Band-4, and Rs.7600, Rs. 6600 and Rs. 5400 in
the scale of pay of Rs. 15600-39100 in Pay Band – 3
2. A Central Civil Post carrying the following grade pays: -
Rs. 5400, Rs.4800, Rs.4200 in the scale of pay of Rs.9300-34800 in Pay Group B
Band – 2.
3. A Central Civil post carrying the following grade pays: -
Rs.2800, Rs.2400, Rs.2000, Rs.1900 and Rs.1800 in the scale of pay of Group C
Rs.5200-20200 in Pay Band- 1
4. A Central Civil post carrying the following grade pays: - Group D
Rs.1300, Rs.1400, Rs.1600, Rs.1650 in the scale of pay of Rs.4440- (till the posts are upgraded)
7440 in 1S Scale
All posts carrying the Grade pay right from the end of this week. The recruitment rules for HSG I will
Rs.4200/- to Rs.5400/- (Pay band II) are now classified be submitted soon to DOPT for approval.
as Group 'B' as per the above said order. This has created v BCR from the date of completion of 26 years
some confusion about the application of Gazette status service
& others. The said notification was brought into effect Consequent upon the High court, Hyderabad
from 09.04.2009 judgment on the issue, the Department is now pursuing
v Cadre Restructuring & Formation of Anomaly to the modify the orders to grant BCR promotions on
Committee: - completion of 26 years of Service. It is told that the opinion
The proposals for cadre restructuring was of the law ministry has been obtained for this effect.
submitted by us on 02.08.2008 itself. Similarly NFPE has v GDS Pay revision: -
nominated the members for the Anomaly Committee. It The file related to GDS committee
is told that the formation of Anomaly Committee is being implementation has gone to Finance Ministry. No further
delayed due to non submission of nomination of two progress or information is available at present. The
members from FNPO. Similarly, they have not submitted implementation of the Committee's report or Ad hoc
any proposals on cadre review so far. The NFPE payment of arrears etc may be only after the conclusion of
delegation met DDG (Establishment) on 22.04.09 and General Section.
conveyed our concern over the delay in processing the v Three ACP: -
cadre restructuring proposal and formation of anomaly
The File had been returned back by the Election
committee.
Commission with the instructions to cause order after
v Meeting with DDG (Establishment): - the General Election. As such, ACP orders for Government
We met the DDG (Establishment) on 22.04.2009. employees is expected only after the General Election.
The issues like Cadre Restructuring, Road Mileage There after, it should be discussed with the Department
Allowance to Systems Administrators, Doubling of PO & to implement the same to the Postal officials besides
RMS Accountant's Special Allowance, Grant of Special processing the cadre review for ensuring more
Allowance to the Accountants holding TBOP, promotional avenues to the existing employees.
implementation of Group D higher pay for all Group D, v Sixth CPC - National Anomaly Committee:
Stoppage of recovery of OTA amount paid to ineligible
The following items were placed in the National Anomaly
officials, Formation of anomaly committee, Revision of
Committee for discussion
FSC, the recovery case of APM Accounts, Pune H.O due to
overdrawal for Postmen etc were discussed threadbare. (1) Pay Fixation in case of merger of pre-revised pay
The DDG assured for early decisions on all the issues. scale.
v Filling up of Vacant HSG I Posts (2) Issues on revised Pay Rules 2008 like (i) Option (ii)
Special Allowance for fixation purpose on promotion
The DOPT has approved the proposal of the
w.e.f. 01.01.2006 (iii) Existing pay should not be
Department relaxing the HSG I Recruitment Rules again
less than the minimum of upgraded pay scales.
as one time measure and fill up the Posts on adhoc
(iv) Removal of disparity about direct recruits &
basis with the HSG II officials without observing any
promotees (v) Date of next increment between 1st
minimum qualifying service. Similarly, the Present HSG I
Feb to June'06 - Grant one increment as one time
officials promoted on adhoc basis will continue further in
measure (vi) No Tax from arrears for Group D &
the posts. Orders are under issue and is expected before
BHARTIYA POST 2 JUNE, 2009
others be allowed to exercise option to tax arrears Fixed Daily Allowance for stay, Local travel food etc
either on receipt basis or accrual basis. (vii) as before. The proposed DA: -
Temporary status casual labourers - up gradation Grade pay 4800 to 4200 -50% of hotel rates i.e.
by imparting training to non matriculates. Rs.500/- plus 350 for local travel and food i.e.
(3) Benefit on promotion: - Minimum benefit of not less Rs.850/-
than 10% of the pay & Grade pay of the feeder post. Below Rs.4200/- -50% of hotel rates i.e. Rs.350 +
(4) Refixation of pension/Family pension - Para 9 of Rs.350 (i.e.) Rs.700/-
MOP PG & Pensions O.M. dt. 01.09.2008 to be (14) 50% of revised Pay band +Grade Pay not correctly
revised including both paras 4.1. & 4.2 thereof. determined - The revised table worked out & placed
(5) Anomaly in pension for Government servants who with the subjects to correct the irregularities.
retired/died in harness between 1.1.2006 and (15) Revision of Pension of those who are receiving two
1.9.2008. - Application of 6th CPC pensions.
recommendations that pension should be paid at Minimum floor ceiling should apply separately
50% of average emoluments during the past ten to each pension and not to the total of the pension
months or last pay drawn with minimum taken together.
pensionable service of 20years should be made (16) Special Provision for those retired on or after
to them also. 1.1.2006 but retain pre-revised scales of Pay - Such
(6) Commutation of Pension - Suitable amendment to cases may be very few. Provision be made in Para
the table is requested. 13 for suitable amendment/amplification.
(7) Grant Revised Allowance with effect from (17) Commutation of additional pension on
01.01.2006 - All allowances may be granted at the retrospective revision of pension in respect of post
revised rates w. e. f. 1.1.2006. 31.12.2005 retirees - Request to maintain status
(8) Transport Allowance - (i) Below the Grade Pay of Quo by applying the provisions of Rule 10 of CCS
Rs.4200/- should be revised to Rs. 1600 + DA for A/ (commutation of Pension) Rules 1981.
A1 Towns and Rs.1200/- +DA for other towns. (18) Constant Attendant Allowance - Correction/
(ii) Absence of more than a month for disentitling the amendment to the orders about the increase of
employees for TA may be done away with. allowance after the DA crosses 50% is required.
(iii) 50% TA may be counted as wages for (19) Grant of Grade pay of Rs.5400 in PB 2 for Asst.
determining overtime rates. Accounts/Audit officers - Demanded to upgrade the
(9) Revision of Existing Allowance: - Risk Allowance, grade pay of Rs.5400/- in PB II.
Patient care allowance etc. which were withdrawn (20) Revision in Base Index for DA: The base index in
be paid with doubled rates till alternate schemes (2001=100) series for the computation of DA in Pay
are implemented. scale of 6th CPC may be taken as 115.12 and not
(10) Parity in Pension of all Pre 1996 retirees with those 115.76.
who retired on or after 01.01.96 - Notional Pension (21) Child Care Leave - The clarification dt. 18.11.2008
as on 01.01.96 may be revised first as per the 5th may be withdrawn since the 6th CPC had not
CPC and revision of pension be granted with 50% indicated that the leave will be available only in the
of the Grade Pay of the Pay Scale from which retired event of there being no leave at credit.
and not 40% of Basic pension. (22) Cumulative loss in wages as a result of New
(11) Anomaly in Pension to those retiring with in first 9 Fixation Formula on promotion to the next higher
months of 2006 not fully rectified - The period grade: Demanding that the pay of the existing
preceding between 1.10.06 and 30.09.08 should employee shall not be fixed at a stage lower than
be taken as 'Basic Pay multiplied by 1.86 plus the pay at which a fresh recruit appointed on or
notional increase in the basic pay by the Grade pay after 1.1.2006 is fixed.
applicable and not 40% of basic pay in the pre- (23) Fixation of Pay on Promotion: - On promotion to the
revised pay scale. next higher grade pay, an employee should be fixed
(12) Revision of Pension of those retired during the by adding 10% of pay plus the grade pay as
period 01.01.2006 to 01.09.2008 - Not only those demanded by NC/JCM.
retired between 1.1.2006 to 1.9.2008 but even those (24) Denial of monetary benefit in the matter of fixation
who retired prior to 1.1.2006 may be granted full of pay while granting higher replacement scale: -
pension if they had rendered 20 years of service when a post is upgraded the fixation of pay should
(i.e.) 50% of the average emoluments for the last be done on the basis of upgraded pay scale.
10 months or the last pay if that be more beneficial. (25) Reopening of option for fixation of pay on promotion:
(13) Allowance - Daily Allowance on Tour: - Demanding - The existing employees who have been promoted

BHARTIYA POST 3 JUNE, 2009


to the higher post during 2005, 2006, 2007 or prior (viii) Charge Hands - Should be placed in PB 2 with Grade
to 2.9.2008 may be allowed fresh option for fixation Pay Rs.4200/-
of their pay. (ix) Artisan Grade - Parity from 1.1.96 at par with Railways
v Departmental Anomaly Committee:- & Defence sought for.
The following items have been notified for (x) Data Entry Operator - Should be placed with Rs.2400/
discussion in the anomaly committee constituted in the - Grade Pay at par with other C. G. Departments.
Postal department. (xi) Cash handing Allowance to PO Treasurers - It should
(i) TBOP/BCR Postal Asst. - The anomaly prevailing be common for PO & RMS and the disparity should
between Postal & Telecom may be taken in to be set aside.
account and the TBOP/LSG should be placed in (xii) P & T Dispensaries - the anomaly for Laboratory
Pay band 2. Technicians, Medical Store Keepers, Staff Nurse,
(ii) PO & RMS Accountants: - The special Allowance be removed at par with other C. G. Hospitals.
should be taken for Pay fixation on promotion. (xiii) Sorters in DAP - should be placed in PB 1 with Grade
(iii) Systems Administrators: - Promotional cadre to PAs, Pay Rs.1900/-
10% Pay + Grade Pay as Special Pay. With fraternal greetings,
(iv) Marketing Executive: - 10% pay + Grade Pay as
special pay.
(v) Supervisory Allowance: - Revival of Supervisory (K. V. Sridharan)
Allowance to LSG, HSG II & HSG I, PRI (P) - 10% Dated - 30.04.2009 General Secretary
Pay + Grade Pay.
(vi) Technical Postal Assistant: - Anomaly in grant of PB ACT SWIFTLY AND SEND REPORT TO CHQ
2 with Grade Pay at par with other Department ABOUT SUCCESSFUL MORE ENROLMENT OF
'diploma' qualified cadres. MEMBERSHIP IN YOUR DIVISION
(vii) Head Mail peon - The relativity with Postman/
mailguard to be restored. STRENGTHEN OUR UNION AND NFPE
IMPORTANT ORDER ON FILING UP OF HSG-I, HSG-II & CLG (Adhoc basis)
No.4-16/2002-SPB-II Dated, May 1,2009. any minimum service in HSG.II), for a period of one-year
(i) Continuation of ad-hoc promotion made in the or till the Recruitment Rules are notified and
cadre of HSG-I appointments are made according to the revised
(ii) Fresh ad-hoc promotions in HSG-I Recruitment Rules, whichever is earlier.
(iii) Filling up of resultant chain vacancies by ad- 3. In view of the above, it is requested that Circles
hoc promotions. may take following action:-
I am directed to refer to this Department's letter (i) Ad-hoc promotions made as per instructions
of even number dated 2nd December 2008 and 10th contained in this Department's letter of even number dated
December 2008 regarding continuation of ad-hoc 20-11-2006 in HSG.I may be further continued for a period
promotions made in the cadre of HSG-I and to say that it of one year i.e. till 19th May 2010 or till the Recruitment
has been decided with the approval of Department of Rules are finalized and regular arrangements are made
Personnel & Training to continue the said ad-hoc in accordance with that, whichever is earlier.
arrangements for a further period of one year i.e. till 19th (ii) Fill up the existing vacancies by promotion on
May 2010 or till the Recruitment Rules are finalized and purely ad-hoc basis from amongst the officers holding
regular arrangements are made in accordance with that, HSG.II norm-based posts on regular basis (without
whichever is earlier. prescription of any minimum service in HSG.II), for a
2. As many posts in HSG.I are at present lying period of one-year or till the Recruitment Rules are
vacant in various Postal Circles for want of finalisation of notified and appointments are made according to the
Recruitment Rules, it was proposed to the Department revised Recruitment Rules, whichever if earlier
of Personnel & Training to allow the Department to fill up (iii) The resultant chin vacancies in HSG.II , LSG etc.
the existing vacant posts in HSG.I as a one time measure may be filled up by promotion on ad-hoc basis for a period
on ad-hoc basis, from amongst officers holding the not exceeding one year as per the instructions contained
HSG.II norm-based post, (without prescription of any in DOP&T Oms No. 28036/8/87-ESTT. (D) dt. 30.03.1988
minimum service in HSG.II). The DoP&T have, since, and AB. 14017/542003-Estt. (RR) dt. 04-12-2003
agreed as a special case to allow the Department to fill circulated by this Department vide letters No. 6-6/88-SPB-
up the existing vacancies by promotion on purely ad-hoc II dt 05-05-1988 and 137-2/2004-SPB.II dt.13/14.01.2004
basis from amongst the officers holding HSG.II norm- respectively. Any extension in the Ad-hoc promotions os
based posts on regular basis (without prescription of made would need the prior approval of DOP&T.

BHARTIYA POST 4 JUNE, 2009


LETTERS TO DEPARTMENT
Letter No.: P/2-21/U. P. Circle Dated - 27.03.2009 The regional administration desired to transfer
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak the major areas of the present Tiruvannamalai Division,
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 a Group B Postal Division to the Vellore Division headed
l Inordinate delay in settlement of personal by the SSPOs. The reason for the transfer is stated to be
claims like T.A, O.T.A Medical etc for want of funds - the wieldy and long distance from the head quarters of
case of U. P. Circle Tiruvannamalai to the remoted BO of the division which
The issue of allotment of adequate funds for is at present as follows.
payment of pending personal claims like T.A, OTA, Medical Tiruvannamali HO to Tellar - 98Kms.
etc have been discussed in the past several times and it Tiruvannamalai HO to Dusi BO - 118Kms.
is repeatedly replied that required funds are available to Tiruvannamalai HO to Desur - 106Kms.
dispose the claims. If the said areas are attached with vellore division
But the fact is otherwise, Complaints are pouring the distance from Vellore will be as follows.
into this union that a large number of personal claims Vellore HO to Tellar - 94Kms.
are pending unsettled in U.P. circle since long. During Vellore HO to Dusi BO - 118 Kms.
discussion in the periodical meeting (4 monthly) with the Vellore HO to Dusur - 83Kms.
Chief Postmaster General U.P. Circle. It is replied that, if From the above, it is evident that the
sufficient allotment of funds are not made, the issue will reorganization will simply transfer the workload to Vellore
remain unsettled. division where existed is more work by reducing the
You are requested to kindly bestow your kind Tiruvannamalai Division as smaller compact division.
attention in this pertinent issue of U. P. Circle and arrange Secondly if the Arni HO is attached to Vellore
special sanction of funds for payment of all personal Division, the existing GDS who are getting earlier
claims at the earliest. promotion at Vellore Division due to availability of more
Letter No.: P/2-15/Dharmanagar Dated - 09.04.2009 departmental posts could loose their fair chances and
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak they will not get their due promotions on seniority basis.
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 The abovesaid proposal will cause serious
l Non Payment of MIS incentive bills at dislocations in the Postal operations and also to the
Dharmanagar, North East Circle - reg. employees working in the division by extending the areas
Kindly refer to this union letter of even No. 15- on transfer etc.
107 followed by reminder dated 23.02.07 on the subject Similarly, the piecemeal bifurcation of Chennai
mentioned above but sorry to inform you that till date division by transferring Tambaram HO to Chennai South
neither the letters were acknowledged nor any action so Division will freeze the facilities in transfer, GDS promotion
far been taken for payment of incentive bills. etc to the existing staff of Chennai City South Division.
This union wages upon you to cause necessary More number of non HRA offices are being attached to
instructions to the Circle Administration for effecting South Division which causes serious staff problem on
payment of incentive without further delay. transfer. Earlier also, there were several such proposals
Letter No.: P/2-19/Chennai South Dated - 10.04.2009 causing unnecessary tension and restless among the
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak employees which were dropped subsequently due to the
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 unwarranted dislocation of service.
l Proposed reorganization of Divisions in The entire staff feels that the proposed
Chennai City region in Tamilnadu Circle reorganization in a piecemeal operation will not serve
It is brought to our notice that the regional any practical purpose as desired but cause severe and
administration has proposed a reorganisiaton of divisions serious problems to the employees working in these
with the following: divisions.
(i) Transfer of Sub Divisions of Arni and Vadavasi It is therefore requested to intervene and cause
from Tiruvanmalai Division. instructions not in proceed further in the said
(ii) Transfer of Tambaram Sub Division from reorganization of Vellore, Tiruvannamalai Chennai city &
Tambaram Division to Chennai City South Division and Tambaram divisions.
shifting the head quarters of Chennai City South Division A line in reply about the action taken is highly
to Tambaram and the proposed residual Tambaram appreciated.
Division to Ambattur and naming as Chennai West Letter No.:P/2-4/Chhattisgarh Dated - 10.04.2009
Division. addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak
At the outset, we wish to record that the proposals Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
are unwarranted at this juncture and it will create many l Formation of DPA office at Raichur - reg.
problems in the operations and to the staff. Ref: - This union letter of even no dt. 2.7.2007

BHARTIYA POST 5 JUNE, 2009


Apropos reference, it is constrained to note that 6. While visiting any office when he found any lapse
neither our reference is acknowledged not replied so far. or any incomplete work, he used to insult the SPMs by
Consequent upon the bifurcation of Chhattisgarh using abusive and filthy language in front of subordinate
Circle, the formation of DPA office for the Circle at Raipur staff without considering the difficulties of the SPMs. He
becomes absolute necessary. asked Sri. R. N. Talakar, SPM, Swargate to credit the
Now the officials working in Jagdalpur and amount of his arrears of pay on Sixth CPC to make up the
Raigarh divisions have to travel for their needs at DPA target of oriental insurance company policies.
office, Bhopal to the distance of 800 & 750 KMs 7. Without understanding the fact/truth behind the
respectively. case, he express his anger, dissatisfaction regularly by
The entire circle is depending on the Postal shouting, insulting or by using improper remarks which
Accounts for every items or work and now there is ultimately have adverse effect in the office decorum and
abnormal delay in settlement of many personal claim create unnecessary mental stress to women employees.
including the pay Commissions arrears. The officials The attitude of this rude officer has created bad
could not exert pressure through their Circle impact in office environment and ultimately on the family
administration also since the DPA is situated in other and social life of the women employees. If an enquiry
circle administration. The formation of separate DPA office over these episode is ordered, many more grievances of
at Raipur is the absolute necessary. the women employees which could not be recorded shall
It is requested to consider the proposal and come out.
cause immediate action. It is requested to cause instructions to enquire
Letter No.: P/2-13/Pune City West Dated - 11.04.2009 and rein in the SSPOs in order to ensure peace and
addressed to Ms. Radhika Doraiswamy, Secretary, congenial atmosphere to the officials for the uninterrupted
Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 and efficient work.
l Harassment to women employees unleashed Letter No.: P/2-8/Hamirpur Dated - 11.04.2009 addressed
by Sri Jose Kokanoor, SSPOs, Pune City West Division. to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New
It is constrained to bring the following to your Delhi - 110001
kind notice about the atrocities, highhandedness and l Regularizing LSG Promotion by implementing
abuses unleashed by the SSPOs, Pune City West the CAT judgment, Chandigarh - case of Sri K. D.
Division for immediate intervention and rein in the SSPOs Kaushal, SPM, Mehre (Hamirpur) in H. P. Circle.
who is running amuck. The abovesaid official has opted for Accounts
The SSPOs is unleashing terror in the minds of line and regularly posted as APM Accounts w.e.f
women employees working in the divisional office and 15.10.1991. However his name has been considered for
the following are few examples. HSG II & HSG I promotion thereafter.
1. He is always using unparliament words while Aggrieved due to the denial of due promotion,
talking with women employees like 'Nonsense', 'Bloody the official has approached the CAT, Chandigarh in O.A.
Buggers' etc. Always shouting is his attitude towards all 15-HP/2005 and the CAT held that since the official's LSG
which disturbs the office environment and invited mental promotion should be treated as norm based promotion
stress. with consequental benefits.
2. He used to through the files on the floor for The officials representation seeking HSG II &
showing his anger which found very difficult to women HSG I promotions to the DPS, Shimla has been referred
employees to pick up those files from the floor. He may to Directorate for implementation of CAT judgment stated
have other intention to behave like this with all women in Para supra. The copy of the judgment is also enclosed
employees. He neither gives instruction/decision orally for your reference.
or in writing but always shouting at the staff very loudly. It is therefore requested to cause appropriate
3. During his visit at Ex-Servicemen Colony, he has orders in this case and also extend the same to all the
broken the water pot kicking by his foot to exhibit his anger similarly situated persons working in the department.
towards the lady SPM. A line in reply about the action taken is highly
4. He used to abuse all the staff resulting mass appreciated.
declination to work at D.O. On 24th November 2008. He
accepted his mistakes in front of all employees and Letter No.: P/2-4/Bilaspur Dated-11.04.2009 addressed
promised for the improvement in his behavior but nothing to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New
has been emerged. Frequently he used the phrase 'I will Delhi - 11001
not spare you'. l Harassment of Postal officials - case of
5. He does not behave properly with women Bilaspur Division in Chhattisgarh Circle
employees and always shout at them. He has very bad/ One Smt. Pooja Okener, MPKBY agent who took
disgusting facial expressions when he deals with the undue advantage of the working condition of Bilaspur
Dealings Assistants. They are often crying and weeping H.O. misappropriated the amount collected form RD
and the working atmosphere gets disturbed. depositors and the Department has lodged one F.I.R
BHARTIYA POST 6 JUNE, 2009
against her in the Civil line police station, Bilaspur. leave encashment, commutation has been made so far.
But to the surprise and shock, the Police officers Only he has been granted with provisional pension.
arrested Sri Sheker Mone APM on 30.05.2008 without The Treasurer of the HPO has been proceeded
any evidence of proof and released on bail on 21.06.2008. under Rule 16 merely on flimsy grounds to recover the
They have also summoned another 11 officials for enquiry. amount looted by dacoits despite the fact that the
Instead of proceeding against the MPKBY agent, the police maximum cash balance of the HO was fixed as Rs.50
harassed the postal officials due to her influence and the lakhs and minimum of Rs.20 lakhs.
divisional administration has not come in the way to The APM SB has been proceeded and awarded
protect the postal officials. with the punishment of recovery of Rs.1,46.398 alongwith
The police is not in a position to secure evidence stoppage of increment for sixth months. The Deputy
against the said APM Sri. Sheker Mone so far and no Postmaster is also charge sheeted who is also at the
charge sheet has been filed in the court of law. Due to verge of retirement.
wrong notion, they apprehended the staff without any proof. The Divisional/Regional heads instead of
Adding salt to injury, the department has also placed the tracing the real culprits and enquire the duties and
official under suspension from 30.05.2008 and four more responsibilities of the Armed guards are punishing the
officials namely Sri. G. R. Banerjee (24.05.2008) Sri. innocent on one pretext or the other just to recover the
Tarkeshwar Baghel (30.05.08), Sri Neipal Singh loss sustained to the department.
(24.05.08) and Sri Kishore Kumar Yadav (24.05.08) on This is nothing but misuse of contributory factors which
the grounds of contemplated disciplinary action. None of should not be imposed on any official if he is not directly
the officials is at fault and no disciplinary action has so responsible for the loss sustained to the department.
far been initiated. The officials are still under suspension. While the miscreants entered the HPO from the
The agent who got anticipatory bail exerts main hall and broke many doors and locking
pressures outside to humiliate the postal officials who arrangements including the safe, what was the
brought the case in to light. The Postmaster who was responsibilities of the Armed guards provided in the PO
responsible in this episode having nexus with the agent and how can it be possible to the entruders to take hours
has been safely allowed to retire. There is a total tension together to break all the locks and doors. Till date the
and unsafe condition prevailing in the minds of the officials case has not been enquired properly about the nexus
of Bilaspur Division. between the dacoits with the Armed guards or the
It is requested to intervene and render justice to responsibility of such huge number of armed guards
the aggrieved officials duly reinstate them and pressurize provided for the safely and security of the office.
the Police to take deterrent action against the main The action is inhuman and terrible. The poor
offender. innocent officials should not be fixed as scapegoats
Letter No.: P/2-3/Munger Dated - 11.04.2009 addressed leaving the culprits scat free. A full fledged directorate
to Ms. Radhika Doraiswamy, Secretary, Department of level enquiry or entrusting the case to CBI may reveal so
Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 many hidden skeletons rolling on the cupboard.
l Arbitrary recovery under contributory factors It is requested to intervene and ensure
for the loss sustained in the Dacoity - case of Munger appropriate action to safe guards the innocents duly
HPO in Bihar Circle refunding the amount arbitrarily and unilaterally recovered
It is brought to our notice that there was a dacoity towards the loss sustained to the department despite
in the night of 26/27.01.2008 by burglars at Munger HPO they are not directly responsible and drop the pending
who took away the Government cash to the extent of charge sheets.
Rs.26,04,990.18 from the iron safe embedded in the A line in reply about the action taken is highly
strong room of the Head Post office after breaking and solicited.
cutting all the locking arrangements in Public Hall, PO Letter No.: P/4-1/Staff Dated - 11.04.2009 addressed to
Hall, Treasury room, Strong room and iron safe. Ms. Radhika Doraiswamy, Secretary, Department of
It is a paradoxical to note that the said HO is Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
provided with ten Armed Police guards and three Arm l Filling up of JAO vacancies in DAP Chennai &
guards on their turn round the clock for the security and others - regarding
safety of the buildings, property and valuables of the HPO. A kind attention is invited to the discussions we
Besides there is one departmental night guard working had on the subject and the assurances to cause action
in this HPO. to fill up the vacant posts available at DAP offices with the
Instead of tracing the burglars and also enquiring wait listed candidates in JAO cadre and also to consider
the arm guards, the Postmaster of the HO who was having the requests of qualified officials to work in other states
only 33 days for his superannuation has been proceeded in case of non availability of vacancies in parent circles in
under Rule 16 and the case has been now converted as the DAP offices.
Rule 9 after his retirement even though he submitted his No orders have so far been issued from the
defence before his retirement. No payment of DCR gratuity, Directorate for that effect. In Tamilnadu Circle, about 125
BHARTIYA POST 7 JUNE, 2009
JAO qualified officials are awaiting for promotion since revised and arrears of revised pay and allowance have
1992. There are unfilled vacancies in the JAO cadre also not been paid so far by citing the provisions vide
available both in regular/Adhoc. In utter violation of rules note below Rule 7 of CCS (Revised Pay) Rules 2008.
unqualified and ineligible officials of senior Accountant Sl.No. Name of the official Period of suspension Date of Remark
cadres are irregularity posted as JAOs in the 90% quota revocation
From To
earmarked for qualified wait listed candidates.
01 Shri B.A.Vadera 05/06/2008 12/06/2008 13/06/2008
Despite instructions from Directorate, the 13/08/2008 14/10/2008 15/10/2008
irregular postings ordered by the DAP Chennai have not 02 Shri R.M.Devmurari 17/06/2008 22/06/2008 23/06/2008
been cancelled. In Andhra Pradesh, such irregular 13/08/2008 14/10/2008 15/10/2008
postings were set aside by the Hon'ble CAT recently. 03 Shri J.R.Makwana 17/06/2008 22/06/2008 23/06/2008
13/08/2008 14/10/2008 15/10/2008
The Secretary (P) has taken a decision not to 04 Shri P.B.Dhanani 05/06/2008 13/06/2008 14/06/2008
absorb the JAO Qualified officials in Telecom despite the 14/08/2008 14/10/2008 15/10/2008
fact that the Ministry of Communications & IT vide its letter 05 Shri S.L.Desai 13/08/2008 14/10/2008 15/10/2008
no. 27-1/2006-SEA II dt. 1.10.2007 ordered for the 06 Shri B.A.Sarvaiya 13/08/2008 12/02/2009 13/02/2009
amalgamation of JAO cadre of both the Department of
07 Shri S.Y.Joshi 16/09/2008 14/10/2008 15/10/2008
Posts & Department of communications. However, at
least in Postal, if the irregularities prevailing in adhoc 08 Smt. J.D.Parekh 14/08/2008 14/10/2008 15/10/2008
and officiating vacancies in JAO cadre is DPA in set aside, 09 Shri H.K.Tank 16/09/2008 12/02/2009 13/02/2009
several eligible wait listed candidates may be absorbed
10 Kum. M.C.Kokani 16/09/2008 14/10/2008 15/10/2008
on regular basis.
It is therefore requested to bestow your personal The above officials were under suspension on
attention to review the irregular arrangement made in the date of issue of the notification but the officials at Sl
most of the DPAs and absorb the wait listed candidates No. 7, 9, & 10 were on duty on the date of notification but
either in their home circles or in the nearby circles. the provision of Note 4 ibid has been applied to all the
A line in reply about the action taken is highly said officials irrespective of the date of suspension.
solicited. The action is nothing but violating the provisions
Letter No.: P/4-1/Staff Dated - 11.04.2009 addressed to of GOI (2) below FR 53 (1) according to which the
the Ms. Radhika Doraiswamy, Secretary, Department of Government Servant under suspension shall be allowed
Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 to exercise the option under FR 23 even if the period
l Engagement of short duty PA staff - restriction during which he is to exercise the option falls within the
of 60 hours per month - reg. period of suspension and he will be entitled to the benefit
Ref: - Directorate letter No. 37-40/2007-SPB I dt. of increase in pay, if any, in respect of duty period before
14.08.2008 suspension, as a result of such option.
A kind attention is invited to the discussions we The above said officials are still awaiting for
had on the subject and the assurances to consider the justice and facing mental torture due to non payment of
lifting of the restrictions of 60 hours per month in order to dues over six months.
meet the shortage of staff prevailing in the Post offices.
It is requested to cause appropriate orders at
In fact, the SDPAs could be engaged only for 12
the earliest to revise the pay of the said officials and draw
days with the restrictions of 5 hours per day in a month
the arrears without any further delay.
which is not practically resolve the shortage of staff
A line in reply about the action taken is highly
prevailing in PA cadre. Further in many places, the SDPAs
solicited.
are not carrying forward due to the restriction of 12 days
Letter No.: P/2-19/Chennai South Dated - 13.04.2009
in a month.
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak
If the restriction is removed and authorized the
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
divisional head to utilize the SDPA services optimum, this
will resolve the existing problems of shortage to some l Grant of peripheral HRA to the officials working
extent. in Okkiyam, Doraipakkam, Palavakkam Korapakkam
It is requested once again to kindly bestow & Sholinganallur at par with Chennai City - case of
appropriate orders at the ealiest. Chennai City south Division.
Letter No.: P/2-6/Amreli Dated - 11.04.2009 addressed to The areas of okkyam, Doraipakkam,
the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Palavakkam and Korapakkam are situated within three
Delhi - 110001 kilometer from the peripheral limit of Tiruvanmiyur
l Non drawal of arrears and non revision of Pay Chennai Corporation limit and they are totally depending
- case of Amreli Division - reg. on the Chennai City Corporation for their daily needs.
It is brought to our notice that the pay of the The officials working in these offices are not drawn
following officials of Amreli Division who were placed on peripheral HRA so far despite they are eligible as per the
suspension and revoked subsequently has not been Government orders on the subject.
BHARTIYA POST 8 JUNE, 2009
Similarly Sholiganallur which is about the rates - case of Tambaram Division.
10Kms from the Chennai Corporation limit is the main The areas of Pallikaranai and Medavakkam are
town of software industries and big companies in situated within 8 Kms from the Corporation limit of
Chennai and it is also totally depending upon the Chennai velachary in Chennai City Corporation and they are totally
city for all its needs. depending upon the Chennai City for all requirements.
It is therefore to cause action to grant peripheral The department has opened these two post
HRA to the officials working in the said offices at the offices last year only in the said areas but the Chief PMG
earliest. Tamilnadu Circle has not taken proposal to obtain
Letter No.: P/2-7/Gurgaon Dated - 13.04.09 addressed to essentiality certificate from the District Collector for the
the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New grant of HRA at par with Chennai City to the officials working
Delhi - 110001 therein.
l Filling up the Posts of wire man & Liftman at It is requested to cause necessary action to grant
Gurgaon HO in Haryana Circle peripheral HRA to the officials working in the said Post
It is brought to our notice that the Chief PMG offices at the earliest.
Haryana Circle has sought approval to fill up the posts of Letter No.: P/2-7/Karnal Dated - 15.04.2009 addressed to
wireman and lift man in Gurgaon division for the smooth the DDG (P), Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New
functioning and to avoid mishappening during Mar 2008. Delhi - 110001
The Post of liftman is lying vacant since l Non filling up the Post of APMs (LSG),
December 94 and the post could not be filled up for want Postmaster (HSG I) and Accountant at Jind HO in Karnal
of candidate of desirable qualification either in the Division, Haryana Circle.
Department or through employment exchange. Similarly It is brought to our notice that all the three APM
the technician and two unskilled labourers are looking Posts in LSG cadre and the Postmaster (HSG I) have not
after all the maintenance of electrical installation in the been filled up on regular basis. Similarly the Post of
division which is difficult. Accountant, Jind HO is also vacant for years together.
It is requested to expedite the proposal of the Despite it was brought to the notice of the
Circle and accord sanction to fill up the posts at the earliest. divisional administration, no action has so far been taken
Letter No.: P/4-4/CEA Dated - 10.04.2009 addressed to to fill up the posts on regular basis.
the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New It is therefore requested to cause appropriate
Delhi - 110001 instructions to the concerned to cause action to convene
l Children Education Allowance - non drawal of DPC at Circle level for LSG, HSG POs and fill up the posts
due amount to the officials w.e.f. 01.09.2008 at the earliest.
The Department of personnel & Trg vide its letter Letter No.: P/2-7/Faridabad Dated - 15.04.2009
No.12011/03/2008-Estt (Allowance) dt. 11.11.08 has addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak
clarified under Para (ii) that the Children Education Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
Allowance for the year 2008-09 may be calculated on l Unhelpful attitude of the SSPOs, Faridabad
prorate basis at the maximum of Rs.1000/- per month division in resolving staff problems.
per child w.e.f. 01.09.2008. It is brought to our notice that the SSPOs,
In many circles, the spirit of the orders stated in Faridabad division is not exerting any action in mitigating
para supra has not been implemented. For instance, in the staff problems despite they are being repeatedly
Tamilnadu Circle, the Chief Postmaster Anna Road HPO brought to his notice in every monthly meeting. The
is relectant and not considering the requests of the following are the few examples: -
officials to effect payment proportionately w.e.f. 01.09.08 i. The Aqua Guard provided at the NIT HO is under
for the bills the officials had submitted before the issue of repairs over 2 years. No action has so far been taken to
orders but restricted payment to the earlier rate. Even the resolve the water problem. The staff are either purchasing
fresh bills are also not entertained for the current period water or bringing from their home. No water facility is
after 01.09.2008. available.
Suitable instructions may please be issued to ii. The UPS provided to the computers are not
all Circle Heads to implement the clarifications of the working. over two years. Similarly is the case of sub offices
DOP&T in true spirit and effect arrear payment, also. No tangible action has so far been taken to repair
proportionately if the officials had paid amount in advance the same.
to the institutions and submitted the receipts earlier. iii. The post of PRI (P) has not been filled up over
Letter No.: P/2-19/Tambaram Dated - 15.04.2009 one year despite there are suitable volunteers. which has
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak adversely affected the service in verifying the papers and
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 checking the delivery staff.
l Grant of Peripheral HRA to the officials working iv. The post of Cash Overseer at NIT HO has not
in Pallikaranai, Medavakkam at par with Chennai City been filled up resulting the PAs are entrusted with cash
BHARTIYA POST 9 JUNE, 2009
conveyance despite their hard work in the presence of Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
acute shortage. l Non Circulation of MOF OM No. F. No. 1/1/2008-
v. There is no basic amenities like toilet, potable IC dt. 29.01.09 with regard to clarification on Fixation of
water etc in the present building of Amarnagar delivery Pay & Grant of increments in the revised Pay structure
LSG office. The proposal to shift the PO into better building The copy of the above said OM regarding the
has not been pursued by the divisional administration clarification of Pay fixation and grant of increments in the
years together. revised pay structure and in particularly, providing one
vi. The electricity connection to Surajkund P.O. has more chance for revised option for pay fixation under FR
been disconnected two years before. Similarly the 22 (1) (a) (1) with in one month has not been circulated to
telephone connection was disconnected. No tangible Circle/Field levels. Resultantly the officials who could
action has so far been taken either to shift the PO into exercise their revised option due to non grant of
better building or restore electricity. increments between Feb to June '2006 consequent upon
vii. The personal claims like TA Bills, MIS incentive TBOP/BCR promotions etc could not avail the exercise
bills are not disbursed over six months. so far.
The above are few examples and in general It is therefore requested to circulate the said OM
there is a feeling that the SSPOs is not interested in immediately and provide one month time for submission
mitigating the staff problems which causes resentment of revised option by the affected officials, from the date of
amidst officials. receipt of such communication.
It is therefore requested to cause appropriate instructions A line in reply about the action taken is highly
to attend the staff problems and mitigate their grievances solicited.
at the earliest. Letter No.: P/1-1/Hanamkonda Dated- 24.04.2009
Letter No.: P/2-7/Faridabad Dated - 15.04.2009 addressed to the DDG (P), Department of Posts, Dak
addressed to the DDG (Estates), Department of Posts, Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 l Arbitrary denial of BCR promotion by
l Repairs & colour washing to staff quarters at application of Bench Mark - Case of Hanamkonda
Sector - 3, Faridabad in Haryana Circle. Division - Andhra Pradesh Circle
It is brought to our notice that during the past 10 The PMG, Hyderabad region has denied BCR
years, no maintenance work or colour washing has taken promotion to one Sri. K. Ram Reddy, OA, Divisional office,
place in the staff quarters situated in the Postal colony, Hanamkonda division by application of grading arbitrarily.
Sector 3, Faridabad. The abovesaid official was due on BCR
The buildings require immediate minor repairs promotion with effect from 01.07.2007 and there was no
and colour washing. punishment against him. Later on 31.03.08, the official
It is requested to cause appropriate instructions was awarded with a punishment of censure for
to Haryana Circle administration to carry out the work at contributory negligence which is not a bar for promotion
the earliest. as per the DOPT OM No. 21/5/70-Estt (A) dt. 15.05.71.
Letter No.: P/2-13/Pandharpur Dated - 20.04.2009 The copy of the representation submitted by the
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak official is enclosed herewith which itself is self explanatory
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 and exhaustive.
l Provision of Holiday Home at Pandharpur in It is requested to cause appropriate orders and
Maharashtra Circle render justice to the aggrieved official.
Pandharpur in Maharashtra Circle is one of the Letter No.: P/2-1/Hyderabad South East Dated -
important religious places known as 'South Kasi' and 24.04.2009 addressed to the Secretary, Department of
Lakhs of people are visiting the Vittobha Temple here Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
during four big yatras period in a year. More postal l Grant of Peripheral HRA to the Staff working at
employees are visiting this pilgrim place. Rajannaguda P. O in Hyderabad South East Division,
However no holiday home has been available Andhra Pradesh Circle.
in this holy place. There are ample space available in the It is brought to our notice that the Post office
Pandharpur at Navi Peth TSO Department building to functioning at Rajannaguda is situated with in 8 Kms
provide these facilities to the visiting Postal families. from the peripheral limit of L B Nagar Municipality under
The issue has been taken up by the circle Union Hyderabad Greater Corporation.
yielded with no results. However the officials working in the Post office
It is therefore requested to cause appropriate are not drawn peripheral HRA due to non sanction of
orders to consider the same and cause action at the proposal from the Directorate.
earliest to provide holiday home at this holy city. It is requested to expedite the proposal and
Letter No.: P/4-12/Sixth CPC Dated - 23.04.2009 accord orders at the earliest.
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Letter No.: P/2-1/Gudur Dated - 24.04.2009 addressed to
BHARTIYA POST 10 JUNE, 2009
the ADG (Medical), Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, However the same clarification has not been
New Delhi - 110001 forwarded to other circles and this union has also not
l Recognition of Bollimeni Ramanaiah Super received any reply for the reference cited above.
Specialty hospital Nellore for medical treatment to It is requested to communicate the same
Postal employees. clarifications to all Circle Heads besides reproducing the
Ref.: This union letter of even no. dt. 12.09.2008 orders 27.01.89 & 12.09.89 and a copy of the same may
Apropos reference, it is constrained to note that please be forwarded to us for vide circulation among the
neither the reference is replied nor the issue settled so postal employees.
far. Letter No.: P/4-4/Incentive Dated - 24.04.2009 addressed
The communication of the Ministry of Health & to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New
Family welfare letter No. 5/14021/66/2001-MS dt. Delhi - 110001
04.12.2003 recognising the abovesaid hospital for l Grant of incentive under NREGS.
treatment to Central Government employees and their Ref: - Yours letter No.01-07/NREGS - funds/RB - 09
families has not been circulated yet by our department dt. 06.03.09
resulting non reimbursement of medical claims for the While thanking the gesture in accepting our
treatment taken in the said hospital. The copy of the said demand for uniform fixation of incentive related to NREGS
letter is endorsed herewith for your ready reference. work, it is pertinent note that the condition put forth in the
The endorsement of the said OM by the said orders that ten transactions in one account in a
Directorate will resolve the problems. financial year for governing the grant of incentive is
It is requested to cause immediate action and unjustified and arbitrary.
communicate the same to the Postal divisions at the The instructions seems that if there is no ten
earliest. transactions in one account in one year, incentive is not
Letter No.: P/2-1/Anakapalle Dated - 24.04.2009 payable for the said account. In such cases opening of
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak ledgers, Specimen book, entries in the Pass book will
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 become unproductive labour. This may please be
l Promotion to I. P. Cadre - case of Sri. G. reconsidered and removed such conditions.
Srinvasarao, Accountant, Anakapalle in Andhra Circle. Further, the calculation of ten transactions etc in
Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 30.07.2008 each account will be cumbersome exercise. The
Apropos reference, it is constrained to note that provisions which were made earlier for MSY Accounts
neither the letter above in the reference is replied nor the will be more suitable for easy calculation and payments.
issue settled so far. It is therefore requested to kindly reconsider the
The abovesaid official has secured good marks same and cause early orders.
in the IPO exam and his result was withheld due to the Letter No.: P/4-1/Staff Dated - 28.04.2009 addressed to
proposed disciplinary action which was ended Sri. A. K. Sharma, DDG (Establishment), Department of
subsequently with the awarding of censure. However the Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
result has not been released so far, the justice has not l Non grant of Special Allowance to the TBOP
been yet rendered to the official despite his repeated officials holding the operative Accountant Posts in
representations. HPOs
It is requested to consider the issue and render The TBOP officials who are ordered to work as
justice to the aggrieved official which is pending over one Accountants in HPOs have not been paid with the
year. Allowance pertaining to Accountants. Since the Special
A line in reply about the action taken is highly Allowance has not been taken into account for pay fixation
solicited. benefits, the stoppage of such allowance on acquiring
Letter No.: P/4-5/SB Operations Dated - 24.04.2009 TBOP financial upgradation is highly deplorable.
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak It is requested to cause instructions to draw the
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 Special Allowance to the Accountants irrespective of the
l Payment of S. B. Allowance to the SPMS of fact whether the official is holding TBOP or BCR but with
Single handed Post offices. the condition that he should work as Accountant in the
Ref: - This union letter of even no. dt. 06.05.2008 HPOs.
Apropos reference, it is brought to our notice Letter No.: P/4-1/Staff Dated - 28.04.2009 addressed to
that the Directorate has issued clarifications to Sri. A. K. Sharma, DDG (Establishment), Dak Bhawan
Maharashtra Circle alone vide letter No. 113-08/08- SB New Delhi - 110001
dt. 09.01.2009 that the SPMs of Single handed SOs are l Protection of Pay of defunct scale of PO & RMS
only PAs but have been designated as SPMs and therefore Accountants who opted for general line.
covered under Para 1 (iii) (a) of order No. 2-3/86 - SB dt. Ref: - Directorate letter No. 2-1/2001- PEI dt. 28.05.02
27.04.89 addressed to Chief PMG, Punjab Circle
BHARTIYA POST 11 JUNE, 2009
A kind attention is invited to the reference cited duly taking into account of the facts, merits and also on
above in which the Directorate has clarified about the humanitarian grounds and render justice by set aside
protection of Pay to defunctant scale of PO & RMS the recovery at the earliest.
Accountants in the Case of Sri. Natha Singh, Accountant, Letter No.: P/2-2/Golaghat Dated - 28.04.2009 addressed
Punjab Circle. to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New
However the same decision has not been Delhi - 110001
communicated to other circles for application of such l Maintenance of Golaghat HPO building in
benefits to the similarly situated officials. Sivasagar Division, Assam Circle
It is therefore requested to communicate the said Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 30.07.2008
decision to all the Circle Heads to dispose the Apropos reference, it is constrained to note that
representations of the similarly situated officials. neither the reference is replied not the work attended so
Letter No.: P/4-2/Allowance Dated - 28.04.2009 addressed far. There is no electrical or civil maintenance carried out
to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New to this departmental building over twelve years.
Delhi - 110001 Similarly due to inadequate allotment of funds,
l Applicability of FR 35 in Pay fixation on adhoc the required furnitures could not be purchased and
appointments/officiating arrangements etc provided to the HPO.
According to Directorate clarifications vide letter It is requested to cause appropriate action at
No. 2-54/2005- PAP dt. 28.02.06, the official appointed on the earliest.
adhoc basis in any promotional post may be initially fixed A line in reply about the action taken is highly
under the provisions of FR 22 (i) (a) (i) but restricted the appreciated.
Pay under FR - 35 Letter No.: P/2-2/Cachar Dated - 28.04.2009 addressed
In the context of Revised pay Rules 2008, and to Sri. R. K. Singh, Member (P), Department of Posts, Dak
the officials holding adhoc/officiating arrangements will Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001.
get the corresponding grade pay. As such, the relevance l Arbitrary abolition of residual vacancies in
of FR 35 restricting the limit of Rs.1000/- become absolute. Cachar Division, Assam Circle
In some divisions, while officiating in IPO cadre Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 30.07.2008
etc, the officiating pay is being restricted to the limit of A kind attention is invited to this union reference
Rs.1000/- by applying FR 35 which causes resentment. in which we enclosed the copy of letter obtained under
It is requested to cause appropriate clarifications RTI Act received from the PMG, Dibrugarh letter No. Vig/
on this to all the Circle Heads at the earliest possible RTI Appeal/02-03 dt. 29.11.07 admitting the abolition of
either removing the conditions under FR 35 or enhance 47 posts kept under residual vacancies since 2000.
proportionately the limit based on the Sixth Pay The PMG Dibrugarh has stated that the unfileld
Commissions increase over the earlier emoluments. up vacancies in LGO exam from 2000 has been arbitrarily
Letter No.: P/2-5/Delhi South West Dated - 28.04.2009 abolished every year and it cannot be revived at this
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak juncture. There is no provision to abolish such vacancies
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001 earmarked for departmental Quota and the unfilled up
l Waiving of market rent of Rs.14378/- arbitrarily vacancies could have been filled up among the eligible
imposed - case of Sri. Ajab Singh, SPM, Green Park PO, GDS officials or by direct recruitment. There are 47 posts
New Delhi South West Division abolished arbitrarily which requires immediate revival.
Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dated 25.10.2008 It is therefore requested to cause appropriate
Apropos reference, it is constrained note that action to revive the posts immediately and allieviate the
neither our letter under reference is replied nor the issue sufferings prevailing due to shortage of staff in the region.
settled so far. A line in reply about the action taken is highly
The official has been granted permission to solicited.
retain the Quarters attached to Kidwainagar West Post Latter No.: P/2-3/Madhubani Dated - 28.04.2009
office up to 19.06.07 after his transfer and there was no addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak
reply to the officials letter seeking extension of permission Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001
up to 31.07.07. l Non Payment of officiating Pay in HSG I - Case
However recovery has been ordered to the extent of Sri Kamal Kant Jha, Postmaster, Madhubani HO in
of Rs.14378/- as market rent from the official which is Bihar Circle.
unjust and arbitrary . The official has represented his Ref: -(i) This Union letter of even no. dt. 17.12.2008
cause which has resulted in futile. Hence the officials (ii) Yr. Letter no. 2-04/2009 - PAP dt. 20.01.2009
has represented onceagain to the Secretary, Department Apropos reference, it is constrained to note that
of Posts requesting to render justice. The delay is causing the issue has not yet been settled and due officiating
a concern. HSG I pay has not been drawn and paid to the official.
It is requested to consider the official's request It is therefore requested to kindly expedite the
BHARTIYA POST 12 JUNE, 2009
same and cause appropriate orders early. Letter No.: P/4-4/Incentive Dated - 30.04.2009 adderessed
Letter No.: P/2-3/Muzaffarpur Dated - 28.04.2009 to Ms. Aruna Jain, DDG (Training), Department of Posts,
addressed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001.
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001. Training on Computer Operations to Non-
l Delay in filling up the Post of DPS, Northern Matriculates Group 'D' employees - reg.
region Muzzaffarpur in Bihar Circle The Department has prescribed training module
Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 11.12.2008 on Computer Operations for imparting training to the Non-
Apropos reference, it is constrained to note that matriculate Group 'D' employees vide its letter No. 1-55/
due to non filling the post of DPS, Muzaffarpur, the appeals 2009-Trg dt. 06.04.2009.
preferred by the officials are pending over eighteen Such non matriculate Group 'D' should be given
months. The staff representations including the review training for six days at divisional level or at WCTC etc.
cases are still undisposed. It causes a concern. However no incentive/honorarium has been fixed to the
It is requested to cause action to fill up the DPS trainers who are imparting such training. In many places,
post at the earliest and ensure disposal of pending the Systems Administrators have been ordered to impart
appeals, review cases and representations of the officials training in the midst of their overburdened works. But no
at the earliest possible. incentive/honorarium is paid for them at divisional level
Letter No.: P/2-4/Durg Dated - 28.04.2009 addressed to and also at the Computer Training Centre. This causes a
Sri. R. K. Singh, Member (P), Department of Posts, Dak concern.
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001. It is requested to kindly consider to fix incentive/
Delay in disposing the petition - Case of Sri. V. honorarium to the trainers who have been entrusted with
K. Jain, SPM Motilal Nehru Nagar PO Durg in Chattisgarh this laborious and hard task.
Circle A line in reply about the consideration is highly
The petition preferred by the abovesaid official solicited.
has been forwarded to the Directorate by the Chief PMG, Letter No.: P/2-1/Mysore Dated - 30.04.2009 adderessed
Chattisgarh Circle vide his letter No. 5TA/3-2/petition/05- to the DDG (FS), Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New
06 dt. 25.02.05 is still undisposed and pending at Delhi - 110001.
Directorate over four years. Recovery of huge amount being interest Paid
The abovesaid official has been awarded with on PPF Account opened on Self name and also in the
the punishment of recovery of Rs.9549/- for no sufficient name of Minors (i.e. on two accounts) prior to
reasons and he preferred the petition since the appellete 06.12.2000 - case of Karnataka Circle.
authority has upheld the decision of the disciplinary Ref: - This Union letter of even No. dt. 31.07.2008
authority. Apropos reference it is constrained to note that
It is requested to cause immediate action to neither the reference is replied nor the issue settled so
dispose the petition at the earliest. far which causes a concern.
Letter No.: P/2-6/Bardoli Dated - 28.04.2009 addressed The SBCO, Mysore HO has raised an objection
to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New about the payment of interest on two PPF accounts
Delhi - 110001. opened on self name & another in the name of a minor
Relocating the Divisional office, Bardoli division prior to 06.12.2000.
to Vyara, the District Head Quarters of Tapi District, in According to PPF Act 1968, an individual can
Gujarat Circle - regarding open a PPF Account in his own name and also separate
Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 30.07.2008 account in the name of minor. But on 06.12.2000, the
Apropos reference, it is constrained to note that Finance Ministry has issued another order stating that
there is no reply to the reference and the issue remains the total investment in such two accounts should not
unconsidered. exceed Rs.60000/- (Now Rs.70000/- in a year)
The Head Quarters of Tapi District is Vyara and The date of effect of revised provisions has not
all the Central & State Government offices are functioning been mentioned in the MOF order dated 06.12.2000. As
there it self. Whereas the Divisional office is functioning such it should be taken with prospective effect only and
at Bardoli in a rented building inccurring monthly rent of shall not be applied this effect to the accounts opened
Rs.10000/- prior to 06.12.2000. The SBCO Mysore has wrongly
The post office at Vyara has a well furnished objected with retrospective effect and raised objections
and specious departmental building and most of its built to the tune of Rs.29 lakhs which is against to the spirit of
up areas remains unutilized. There is every justification PPF Act 1968.
to shift the divisional head Quarters to Vyara and it will Further, MOF has caused guidelines that
provide better business development to the department. irregular accounts opened earlier prior to issue of
It is therefore requested o kindly consider the clarification and exact date of receipt of those orders by
proposal and cause necessary action. the lower operate offices should be regularized.
BHARTIYA POST 13 JUNE, 2009
It is therefore requested to cause suitable Sports persons - regarding
instructions to all concerned besides set aside the The special provisions of granting special
irregular objection raised by the SBCO Mysore. increment for participating in the national games and
A line in reply about the action taken is highly secured within third position to the postal employees
solicited. have not been reiterated after the implementation of Sixth
Letter No.: P/2-13/Mumbai North Dated - 30.04.2009 CPC.
adderessed to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Resultantly, this has not been granted to any
Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001. postal officials after 1.9.2008.
Medical Reimbursement claim under It is requested to cause necessary clarifications
relaxation of rules - Case of Sri. V. P. Gurav, P. A., Banda about the continuance of special increments to the
(W) Mumbai City North Division. officials participating in the national sports events and
Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 22.12.2008 securing places with in third position.
Apropos reference, I wish to state that the Chief Letter No.: P/4-4/Allowances Dated - 01.05.2009
PMG, Maharashtra Circle has sanctioned Rs.10000/- adderessed to Sri. A. K. Sharma, DDG (Est), Department
from the Circle Welfare Fund and directed the official to of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001.
pay the difference amount between the CGHS rates & Revision of Cash Allowance to the SPMs
hospital charges amounting to Rs.17367. handling cash in the absence of treasurer
The official was admitted in hospital in It is brought to our notice that the cash allowance
emergency condition due to his brave and historic act of drawn to the SPMs working in Triple/Four handed offices
saving many lives and their belongings in his residential who are entrusted with the treasury work in the absence
area during the mega flood of Mumbai City and the of treasurer has been stopped in many places after the
disease called 'leptospirosis' is a new kind of disease implementation of Sixth CPC.
which was not brought under the rules earlier. This is arbitrary, unjust and against to the
This case is entirely different one there is clear decisions arrived on the subject. Further the amount
justification to reimburse the full claims as no package requires revision based on the increase after the Sixth
was there for the disease. As such asking the official to CPC implementation.
remit Rs.17367 is causing concern. Either the entire bill It is requested to consider the same and cause
may be admitted as if the official was admitted in appropriate orders at the earliest.
emergency and the disease is a new one not brought Letter No.: P/4-1/Staff Dated - 02.05.2009 adderessed to
earlier in any CGHS package or the remaining amount in Sri. A. K. Sharma, DDG (Establishment), Department of
full may be adjusted from the Circle/Central welfare fund Posts, Dak Bhawan New Delhi - 110001.
appreciating his yeomen service caused to the humanity Anomaly in fixation of Pay in respect of the
during the mega flood of Mumbai. officials promoted on 01.01.96 under BCR Scheme -
It is requested to consider his case as a special reg.
one and accord reimbursement of full claim at the According to Biennial Cadre Review (BCR), the
earliest. officials are to be placed in the higher pay scale w.e.f. 1st
Letter No.: P/2-15/Agartala Dated - 01.05.2009 Jan or 1st July and had the option to get their pay fixed
adderessed to Sri. R. K. Singh, Member (P), Department from date of promotion in the higher pay scale or from the
of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001. date he earns his next increment in the lower pay scale.
Non drawal of additional HRA to the SPMs not According to rule 5 of CCS (Revised Pay) rules,
provided with post attached Quarters - case of Agartala 1997 "Save as otherwise provided in these rules, a
division in NE Circle Government servant shall draw pay in the revised scale
It is brought to our notice that the additional HRA applicable to the post to which he is appointed.
granted to the SPMs in lieu of rent free Quarters had been Provided that a Government servant may elect
stopped from 01.09.2008 by the Postmaster, Agartala to continue to draw pay in the existing scale until the date
arbitrarily and without any orders from the Directorate. on which he earns his next increment or any subsequent
Despite the issue was taken by the Circle Union, increment in the existing scale or until he vacates his
there is no improvement and the SPMs are denied and post or ceases to draw pay in that scale."
deprived of their dues in NE Circles. According to Explanation 2 below Rule 5 of CCS
It is therefore requested to kindly cause (Revised Pay) Rules, 1977: -
appropriate orders to draw the dues forthwith "The aforesaid option shall not be admissible to any
retrospectively from the date it was stopped arbitrarily. person appointed to a post on or after the 1st day of
Letter No.: P/2-15/Agartala Dated - 01.05.2009 January, 1996, whether for the first time in Government
adderessed to Sri. A. K. Sharma, DDG (Establishment) service, or by transfer or promotion from another post
Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001. and he shall be allowed pay only to the revised scale."
Sixth CPC - Drawal of special increment to Consequent to this explanation, officials who
BHARTIYA POST 14 JUNE, 2009
were placed in BCR on 1.1.1996 could not get their its letter No. 113/10/2004 - SB. Dt. 12.08.05 caused
promotion in the pre-revised pay scale which resulted in instructions to close all the savings accounts other than
drop in their emoluments. Had these officials been individual accounts. The Accounts holder were issued a
allowed to get their promotion in the pre-revised pay scale notice asking them to close their account with eligible
on 1.1.1996, they were at the advantage. interest by 15.12.2005.
Considering the above views, the Directorate The Chief PMG, A.P. Circle has further issued
vide its letter no. 1-28/2004-PCC dt.23.08.06 addressed clarifications vide letter no. SB/1-4/Rulings/corr IV dt. 2.2.06
all circles seeking the information about the no. of that 'as per the amendment, S.B. accounts other than
officials affected by the Explanation No. 2 below Rule 5 of individuals are to be closed. The TPF accounts opened
CCS (RP) Rules 1997 and its financial upgradation. in the individual names can be continued. However, the
Thereafter there is no improvement or action in TPF accounts standing in the name of institutions, trusts
this regard. The issue remains unsettled so far due to etc have to be closed."
which such officials affected due to the explanation stated The above clarification was issued based on
in preparas remained looser in the fixation of pay after the Finance Ministry's amendment as the provisions of
the Sixth Pay Commission recommendations. rule 4 (a) 1 (e) contained and retained under which the
It is therefore requested to kindly expedite action P.F. accounts in the name of individual can be opened
and accord orders at the earliest. and operated even today.
Letter No.: P/2-1/Bhimavaram Dated - 04.05.2009 Accordingly, the TPF accounts operated in the
adderessed to Sri. R. K. Singh, Member (P), Department name of individual names are allowed to continue in all
of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001. circles and in particular to A.P. Circle.
l Arbitary recovery from innocent officials on The Finance Ministry vide its letter No. F7/12/05-
contributory factor towards irregular payment of NS II dt. 10.11.06 has issued a clarification that 'however'
interest on non eligible TPF accounts at Palakal HO, provident fund accounts can't be opened in the name of
Narsapur and Royepet in Bhimavaram division, A.P. individuals as such accounts as implied by their name
Circle. are opened and operated by provident funds and
Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 12.06.2008 therefore are not covered within the ambit of the principal
Apropos reference, it is constrained to note that Acts and Rules as amended from 13th May 2005.
neither our reference is replied nor the issue is settled Since the above said clarification was not
so far. Besides the recoveries from the innocent officials specific and there were no detailed procedure with time
are being continued which causes a serious concern. frame to implement the instructions and infact the
The gist of the case is reproduced onceagain for your instructions are not as specific as the Chief PMG's clear
kind notice and immediate action. cut clarifications dt. 2.2.06, the same has not been
The SSPOs, Bhimavaram has issued noticed implemented in many divisions.
to many officials stating that in view of PMG, Vijayawada's Suddenly, the SSPOs Bhimavaram has initiated
observation there is a proposal to recover the amount as action against all the officials on the basis of the
irregularly paid to the TPF account holders and also fixed observation of the PMG and started recovery proceedings
huge sum to each individuals. to the tune of lakhs of rupees from all the LCS, Supervisors
The fact of the case is as follows: - & Postmasters. This has caused a serious tension and
The Ministry of Finance vide its notification no. turmoil in the minds of the officials. The orders are arbitary
286 (E) dt. 13.05.05 amended the Post Office Savings unjust and against to the canon of natural justice.
Account Rules 1981 in which under Rule 4, the clause (i) This is quite contrary to the provisions of Rule 4
(b) group accounts and (e) institutional accounts were (A) and most particularly violate of sub rule 1 (e) of the
deleted. The Rule 4 (a) and all other entries were Rule 4 (A) which clearly stated that' An authority controlling
continued to be in existence as per the amendment. a provident fund, Superannuation fund or gratuity fund,
As per the table under Rule 4 (a) 1 (e) under the may open, an account on behalf of its individual
category of individual account, 'an authority controlling a members."
provident fund, Superannuation fund or gratuity fund on (ii) There is no amendment issued for the Rule 4
behalf of individual members, without any limit, one on (A) in its totality or substituted till to day. unless amending
behalf of each member can be operated by the member the Rules, the clarification order as if amendment will not
on the production of a letter from the controlling authority." hold good before law.
The Ministry of Finance, subsequently vide its (iii) It appears in the latest volumes of Sri A.N. Dureja
notification GSR 509 (E) 27.07.05 amended further the Guide and also in the version of Post. Office small savings
Posts Office Savings Accounts Rules 1981 in which, a scheme, part two of 2008 that the said rule was not
time frame was fixed to implement the provisions of the amended. Thus the individual depositors under TPF are
amendment stated in para supra. eligible for payment of interest.
Based on the same, the Postal Directorate vide (iv) There was no clear cut directions from the
BHARTIYA POST 15 JUNE, 2009
Directorate on the said clarification. However after it was and keeping them for a long period and disturbing the
felt, the TPF accounts were closed hurriedly in the entire counters and smooth functioning of the office. Many times
division without giving any notice to the depositors. As no public have to stand on counters for a long period due to
notice was issued to the depositors regarding non her frequent calls.
eligibility of interest from a particular date, interest was 4. The Sr. Postmaster is abusing the Senior Staff
paid to them which cannot be treated as excess payment. and in charges unnecessarily and unwarrantly in the midst
(v) Even the Department feels that it is excess of all and demoralizing the staff.
payment the Department would have initiated action to It is pertinent to mention that the present Sr.
recover the amount from the depositor in the same Postmaster worked as Postal Asst., Patiala for a long period
manner, as arrears of land revenue. The poor Postal and she remained as IPOs and ASPOs for long periods
officials should not be made as scapegoats and recover and again she was posted as Senior Postmaster, Patiala.
the entire amount under one pretext or other by using the This has developed vested interests and formation of
weapon of contributory negligence. coterie group and she is directly favouring to her near and
(vi) It is most pertinent to note that even in A.P. Circle, dear ones including in the payment of personal claims.
except Bhimavaram division, no action has so far been She is abusing and shouting against those whom they
initiated in other divisions due to the non existence of were not liked by her since her earlier days.
amendment to the P.O S.B. Rules. 4 (A). Which cannot be The staff are very much agitated and all the
set aside by any clarificatory orders. unions have submitted memorandum to the SSPOs
(vii) Further, the incharge SBCO, Palakal HO has seeking his intervention to set right things before it
sought clarifications on 4.9.2007 from the R.O about the becomes out of control. But to their dismay there is no
existence of TPF accounts in the name of individuals as improvement in her attitude and is continuing the same
per Rule 4 (a) on the background of the Finance ministry harassment on staff.
letter dt. 10.11.06 for which no reply was given by R.O. It is therefore requested to kindly intervene and
(viii) It is most unfortunate that the recovery has been rein in the Senior Postmaster and ensure smooth and
ordered retrospectively from the date of issue of the OM peace atmosphere to the staff working there at Patiala.
and not considering the ambiguity in the clarification A line in reply about the action taken is highly
issued by MOF on 10.11.06 without amending the solicited.
statutory rules. Letter No.: P/4-1/Staff Dated - 04.05.2009 adderessed to
Under these circumstances, it is requested the DDG (P), Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New
onceagain to stall the entire proceedings and review the Delhi - 110001.
decision based on the above factors and relieve the l Non drawal of officiating Pay to senior BCR
officials from the cluches of unjustified and untenable officials in HSG I cadre - Case of Tamilnadu Circle
factor of contributory negligence and unbecoming of a Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 15.08.07 & others
Government Servant. In the absence of clear cut clarifications about
A line in reply about the action taken is highly the officiating arrangements in HSG I Cadre, there were
solicited. instances of allowing officiating arrangements in HSG I
Letter No.: P/2-17/Patiala Dated - 04.05.2009 adderessed Cadre beyond one year in Tamilnadu Circle.
to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New There are about seventy cases of such officiating
Delhi - 110001 arrangements and the due amount for the officiating
l Highhandedness of Senior Postmaster, Patiala period exceeding one year has not been drawn to such
HO in Punjab Circle. officials and many of them were retired on superannuation
It is brought to our notice that the now resulting in denial of due retirement benefits.
highhandedness of the Sr. Postmaster, Patiala duly The Principal Chief PMG, Tamilnadu Circle has
harassing and abusing the staff has created a tension also sought approval to regularize officiating periods
and panic situation in the Patiala Ho and the congenial beyond one year to those officials as one time measure
and cordial atmosphere hitherto prevailed has totally been since the arrangements are now ensured to with in one
spoiled. The following are few examples: - year.
1. The Sr. Postmaster has arbitrarily changed the It is requested to consider the same and accord
distribution of work of Patiala HO without keeping in view sanction at the earliest.
the workload and sanctioned strength of office. The New A line in reply about the action taken is highly
distribution is practically impossible to work in counters. appreciated.
2. The Senior PM is calling the Staff on Sundays Letter No.: P/4-1/Staff Dated - 04.05.2009 adderessed to
and holidays regularly. The women employees are Sri R. K. Singh, Member (P), Department of Posts,Dak
specifically hard hit by these orders. Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001.
3. The Sr. Postmaster is calling the counter l Waival of declaration to be submitted at the time
Assistants, PAs and APMs again and again to her chamber of initial appointment in Postal Assistant Cadre - reg.
BHARTIYA POST 16 JUNE, 2009
Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 23.08.07 Apropos reference and further reference in the
This is regarding the obligatory declaration discussions on charter of demands held in April 2007, it
submitted by an entrant in Postal Assistant Cadre at the was agreed to drop the confirmation examination since it
time of initial appointment. becomes irrelevant and assured to introduce the
Under relevant provisions of Postal Manual certification by the Postal Training Centers itself in lieu of
Volume-IV an entrant has to submit an obligatory the existing confirmation examination.
declaration in connection with having read Postal Manual After the Government had issued orders
Volume-IV, CCS (CCA) rules, 1965 & CCS (Conduct) delinking the confirmation for promotion etc, the existence
Rules, 1964. Perhaps you too will appreciate that it is not of confirmation examination has no relevance and it
quite realistic that an outsider or a new entrant have gone should be dropped.
through & understood the ruling provisions as laid down It is therefore requested to kindly cause
in these named books. Even only a minimum portion of appropriate action and accord orders early.
relevant ruling provisions as is laid down in these manual Letter No.: P/4-3/Dept. Exam Dated - 04.05.2009
are being taught during the Induction Training adderessed to Ms. Aruna Jain, DDG (Training),
Programme at respective Postal Training Centres. Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New Delhi - 110001.
As such, it is our considered view that the l Revised Syllabus for LGO Examination - reg.
conditionality for submitting such a declaration shall be Apropos discussions and earlier references on
waived with immediate effect. the subject, it is constrained to note that the revised
It is therefore requested to cause necessary syllabus finalized in the midst of 2008 for the LGO exam
orders to this effect at the earliest convenience. has not been brought in to effect so far.
A line in reply is highly solicited. The revised syllabus as formulated earlier has
Letter No.: P/4-3/Exam Dated - 04.05.2009 adderessed been circulated in the journals of the Unions to the
to the Secretary, Department of Posts, Dak Bhawan, New divisional levels and there are lot of enquiries about its
Delhi - 110001. implementations.
l Request to drop the Confirmation Examination - reg. It is requested to expedite the process and
Ref: - This Union letter of even no. dt. 14.05.07 & cause orders duly implementing the revised syllabus in
subsequent discussions the ensuing LGO examination.

Medical Reimbursement Boost For Govt. Workers


THE CENTRAL Administrative Tribunal (CAT) According to the Medical Reimbursement
has ruled that government employees can claim Rules of CDOT, emergency includes open heart surgery,
medical reimbursement beyond the prescribed limit in serious accidents while on official tour, accidents leading
complicated cases of pregnancy and other serious to surgery, surgery for malignant tumour, renal failure
medical procedures which can reasonably be and medical reimbursement over and above the limit is
categorized as "emergency". to be made only in exceptional circumstances.
Observing that medical reimbursement to an Rejecting the department's contention, the CAT Bench
employee is not charity by the government, the CAT said: "An emergency in medical science is to be viewed
Principal Bench said restricting medical emergency to with a resultant damage to the person, who is
only a few cases- like kidney failure, heart surgery, undergoing treatment." It also took note of the fact that
malignant tumour surgery and serious accidents -was "exceptional circumstances" weren't defined under the
not logical Rules. After examining the medical records, the tribunal
The ruling will benefit lakhs of central concluded that the procedure Bhatia had under gone
government employees as it expands the scope and was an emergency and ordered the department to
ambit of the term "emergency" used under the medical reimburse her within two months.
reimbursement rules. Bhatia's counsel had pointed out that her client
The verdict came on a petition filed by Veena was being discriminated against as in a similar case in
Bhatia, an employee of the Department of the past, another employee was given similar benefits.
Telecommunications, who was denied reimbursement The counsel contended that any medical emergency
for expenses on her treatment during pregnancy "over would include an emergency within the meaning of the
and above the prescribed limit" on the grounds that it Medical Reimbursement Rules.
was not an emergency case. Bhatia had on September But the government counsel had opposed the
17,2004 delivered a boy via caesarean section contentions on the ground that the relevant rules allowed
prematurely. Thirty-eight years old then, she had been reimbursement of medical expenses beyond the
35 weeks pregnant. Doctors had acknowledged her prescribed limit only in exceptional circumstances.
surgical procedure as an emergency but the department (Courtesy : Hindustan Times, 14-4-2009)
had rejected her claim.
BHARTIYA POST 17 JUNE, 2009
LETTERS FROM DEPARTMENT TO CHQ
u Representation of All India Postal Employees (No. 25-1/2009-PE-I Dated: 29-04-2009)
Union Group 'C' regarding non sanction of MIS incentive u Alleged unhelpful attitude of the SSPOs,
bills by Dharmanagar HPO. Faridabad Division in resolving staff problems-Haryana
The undersigned is directed to enclose copy of Circle.
representation dated 9.4.2009 of All India Postal I am directed to enclose a copy of letter No. P/2-
Employees Union Group 'C' regarding non sanction of 7/Faridabad dated 15.4.2009 received from the General
MIS incentive bills by Dharmanagar HPO. It is requested Secretary, All India Postal Employees Union Group 'C' on
that to send a detailed report on the matter urgently. the above mentioned subject.
This issues with the approval of Director (FS) 2. It is requested to look into the matter and furnish
(No. 116-13/09-SB Dated: 21-04-2009 addressed to Chief a detailed report to this office at the earliest.
PMG NE Circle) (No. 16/22/2009-SR Dated: 28-04-2009 addressed to
u Amendments to the constitution of All India Chief PMG, Haryana Circle)
Postal Employees Union Group 'C'-request approval- u Arbitrary recovery under contributory factors
reg. for the loss sustained in the Dacoity-case of Munger
I am directed to refer the Department's letter of HPO in Bihar Circle-reg.
even number dated 16.03.2009 on the above-mentioned I am directed to enclose a copy of letter No. P/2-
subject. The following amendments in the aforesaid order 3/Munger dated 11.4.2009 received from the General
may be read as under:- Secretary, All India Postal Employees Union Group 'C' on
i) In the third line of page 1 of the order the name the above mentioned subject.
of the association may be read as 'All India Postal 2. It is requested to look into the matter and furnish
Employees Union Group 'C' instead of 'All India Postal a detailed report to this office at the earliest.
Accounts Employees Association'. (No. 16/21/2009-SR Dated: 29-04-2009 addressed to
ii) In page no. 2 Article 7 (b), the whole text is not Chief PMG Bihar Circle)
deleted. The deleted portion is only 'except as provided Entrusting of sorting work to Post Offices-case
in article 6 (b). of Chhattisgarh Circle.
iii) In page 5, under Article 39 (b), the entry 'All I am directed to refer to your letter No. P/2-4/
India Union 08-00' appearing under Branch Union may Chhattisgarh dated 1.4.2008 on the above mentioned subject.
be read as 'Circle Union 08.00'. 2. The matter has been examined in consultation
(No. 15-1/2004-SR Dated: 22-04-2009) with the Circle Office. As reported, six National network
u Proposed reorganization of Divisions in Speed Post Centres and 30 State Speed Post Centres
Chennai City Region in Tamil Nadu Circle. are functioning in Post Offices at various towns in
Reference: Your representation vide letter No. P/2-19/ Chhattisgarh. They perform duties relating to collection,
Chennai South dated 10th April, 2009 booking, dispatch and delivery of Speed Post articles as
It is informed that no such proposal, as alleged, prescribed by the Department.
is pending with this Directorate. (No. 16/26/2009-SR Dated: 4-05-2009)

List of office bearers elected for Haryana Circle in the circle conference
held on 9.05.2009 at Hissar
President : Rajesh Pahlwan, P.A, Bahadurgarh (Rohtak)
Sonepat H.O (Sonepat) 4. Bir Singh, SPM, Lohar Bazar
(Bhiwani)
Vice President 1. Balbir Singh, SPM, Kanak 5. Karan Singh Thakaran, SPM,
Mandi (Rohtak) New Colony (Guragaon)
2. S. K.. Sandhu, PA, Jind HO Financial Secretary : Dev Raj, ME, SPC,
(Karnal) Faridabad (Faridabad)
3. Dev Raj, SPM, Patelnagar Astt. Financial Secy. : Lal Chand, PA, Punjabi
(Hissar) Mohalla Cantt (Ambala)
Circle Secretary : K. K. Saini, SPM, Mini Organizing Gen. Secy.: 1. Shamsher Singh, Acct,
sect, (Hissar) D.O (Kurukshetra)
Astt. Circle Secretary : 1. Naresh Kumar Gupta, 2. Jeet Ram, PA, SPC,
Manager SPC (Ambala) Faridabad (Faridabad)
2. P. D. Saini, P.A, Narnaul
3. Hetram Kataria, P.A,
H.O(Gurgaon)
Govindnagar (Ambala)
3. Ishwar Singh, TBOP P.A,
BHARTIYA POST 18 JUNE, 2009
DONATION RECEIVED BY THE CHQ Karnal (Haryana) 500
(From 05.02.2009 to 06.05.2009) Vadodara West (Gujarat) 1800
The following Branches have responded further Chikodi (Karnataka) 500
and remitted donations to CHQ @ Rs.20/- per Raipur (Chhattisgarh) 1000
membership & more than the prescribed amount. Our Puri (Orissa) 400
Sincere thanks to all of them.
Dhenkanal (Orissa) 1500
Keonjhar (Orissa) 200
Dharmanagar (North East) 1500
Tiruvananthapuram RLO (Kerala) 140
Jamnagar (Gujarat) 1800
Asansol (West Bengal) 1000
Akola (Maharashtra) 500
Mumbai City South (Maharashtra) 3000
Morena (Madhya Pradesh) 600
Kanpur (Uttar Pradesh) 1000
Tadepalligudem (Andhra Pradesh) 600
Khandwa (Madhya Pradesh) 1000
Bhiwani (Haryana) 1000
Srinagar (Jammu & Kashmir) 1000
Durg (Chattishgarh) 1000
Faizabad (Uttar Pradesh) 1000
Guwahati Local (Assam) 1000
Vadodara East (Gujarat) 2000
Guwahati Distt. (Assam) 1600
Dibrugarh (Assam) 1415
Ranchi GPO (Jharkhand) 800
Narsipatnam (Andhra Pradesh) 500
Ranchi Division (Jharkhand) 1000
Com. G. P. Prajapati, Asst. Circle Secretary,
Bellary (Karnataka) 1000
Kalol (North Gujarat) 100
Howrah (West Bengal) 2100
Com. K. M. Ganeshmurthy (Balasore) (Orissa) 500
Sibsagar (Assam) 1333
Kudos to the office bearers & members who
Birbhum (West Bengal) 1000 contributed to CHQ. All other branches are also
Sonitpur/Tezpur (Assam) 800 requested to remit the donation at the earliest.
North Hooghly (West Bengal) 2000 v Doubling of cash handling Allowance to
Chittoor (Andhra Pradesh) 1000 Treasurer, Special Allowance to JAO Qualified officials
Khanna (Punjab) 400 & PO & RMS Accountants
Dehradun (Uttarakhand) 1000 No Specific order is required since the Department
of Posts vide its letter 4-4/2008-PCC dt. 24.10.08 while
Nagpur RLO (Maharashtra) 400
communicating the DOPT OM No.4/6/2008-Estt (Pay II) dt.
Saharasa (Bihar) 1000 01.10.08, stated that the orders are applicable to all special
Parvatipuram (Andhra Pradesh) 5000 Allowance drawn & also the cash handling Allowance. If there
Mumbai City North (Maharashtra) 2400 is any non drawal, the Divisional Secretaries are requested to
make a reference to CHQ.
Varanasi East (Uttar Pradesh) 1000
v Confidential Report, Not a secret one
Aurangabad (Maharashtra) 500 The Central Information Commission, New Delhi while disposing
Barmer (Rajasthan) 1500 a reference of Coimbatore division, Tamilnadu Circle, ordered
Medak (Andhra Pradesh) 620 to supply the copy of the 'Confidential Report' of the applicant
Kolkata Central (West Bengal) 2000 sought under the RTI Act. 'Confedential Report' shall not be the
secret document and it should be supplied on demand to the
Tumluk (West Bengal) 1100
concerned officials, it observed.
Darjelling (West Bengal) 630 v Copy of the valuated Answer Sheet should be
Asansol (west Bengal) 1000 supplied if sought for
Tirunelveli (Tamilnadu) 700 In another case of Mayiladuthurai Division, Tamilnadu
Circle, the Central Information Commissioner, New Delhi directed
Tirunelveli PSD (Tamilnadu) 200
the department to supply the copy of the answer sheets of the
Mumbai City East (Maharashtra) 1000 Departmental examination to the applicant to know about the
Mumbai GPO (Maharashtra) 6600 valuation of marks in his answer sheets. It further observed
Bikaner (Rajasthan) 1200 that however, the names of officers who valuated the answer
Kavali (Andhra Pradesh) 300 papers should not be disclosed.
Many can utilize this provision to verify their answer
Moradabad (Uttar Pradesh) 1408
sheets of the Departmental examination in case if they are having
Mathura (Uttar Pradesh) 600 doubts about valuations of and answer papers.

BHARTIYA POST 19 JUNE, 2009


INCENTIVE FOR NREGS WORK-UNIFORM TO ALL
n SUPPORT FOR PAYMENT OF WAGES UNDER (Ministry of Communications & IT Department of Posts
NATIONAL RURAL EMPLOYMENT GUARANTEE SCHEME (Rural Business Division) O. M. NO. 01-07/NREGS-
- ALLOTMENT OF FUND FOR THE YEAR 2008-09. FUNDS/RB-08 dated 6th March 2009)
1. A provision has been made in the Plan funds to ANNEXURE - II
meet the expenditure incurred towards implementation INCENTIVE STRUCTURE FOR NREGS WORK
of National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme Conditions governing grant of incentive under
(NREGS) made available during the year 2008-09, the NREGS work
activities on which this amount is to be utilized and the 1. Incentive is eligible as per table below for NREGS
head of account are given in the table of allotment work per account with at least 10 transactions in that
enclosed (Annexure - I) account in a financial year. Both deposits and withdrawals
2. The funds under the above scheme are placed will be taken in to account of the purpose of arriving at the
at the disposal of Circles for implementation of the NREG number of transactions.
Scheme. A provision has also been made for North East 2. If more than one official has worked on any
region consisting of Assam and North East Circles particular post then the incentive may be decided based
separately in the Annexure - II. on the following guidelines:
3. The guidelines and conditions governing the (a) Incentive is eligible of those officials only who
payment of incentive to the officials on account of have worked on a post of at least 3 months
additional work due to opening and operations of NREGS (b) The incentive should be paid on pro-rata basis
accounts in enclosed in Annexure - II. for the period of work and the total being limited to the
4. All expenditure incurring offices may prepare a maximum eligible incentive based on the total number of
monthly statement giving date, amount, nature of work in accounts in a financial year.
respect of all items booked against present fund 3. Incentive should be calculated on the basis of
allotment. work carried out in a particular financial year only.
5. The funds should be utilized within the allotment 4. The incentive payable to employees on account
made under each activity for this financial year 2008-09 of additional work due to opening of NREGS accounts
after obtaining expenditure approval of the competent should be restricted to the ceiling as laid down by
authority in each case. Director (Budget), Department of Department of Personnel and Training and administrative
Posts to whom a copy of this letter has been endorsed is orders issued form time to time by the Department of
being requested to allot necessary funds as aforesaid to Posts.
the respective Circles. It must be ensured that the funds Guidelines for calculation of incentive by the Circles
allotted are utilized within the current financial year and BRANCH OFFICES & GDS SUB POST OFFICES (GDSBOS
booked in the appropriate head of account as indicated & GDSSOS)
in Annexure - I. (Rs. 8.60 per account per annum having 10 transactions
6. This issues with the concurrence of JS & FA vide in a financial year)
Diary No. 458 dated 6th March 2009.

SL DESIGNATION INCENTIVE (RS.) REMARKS

GDS Branch offices/GDS Sub offices with one official only

1 GDS BPM/GDS SPM 8.60 Per account per annum

GDS Branch offices / GDS Sub offices with a GDS BPM / GDS SPM and a GDS official

1 GDS BPM / GDS SPM 7.60 Per account per annum

2 Other GDS Official 1.00 Per account per annum

GDS BO / GDS SO with three officials

1 GDS BPM / GDS SPM 6.60 Per account per annum

2 GDS – 1 1.00 - do -

3 GDS – 2 1.00 - do -

BHARTIYA POST 20 JUNE, 2009


SUB POST OFFICES
(Rs. 4.40 per account per annum having 10 transactions in a financial year)
SINGLE HANDED SUB POST OFFICES (CL – III)

1 SPM 3.40

2 Group – D /Packer 1.00 Performing NREGS work

DOUBLE HANDED/TRIPLE HANDED SUB POST OFFICES (CL – II AND CL – I)

1 SPM / Supervisor of SB work 1.40 Supervisory work of NREGS a/cs

2 Postal Assistants 2.00 Doing NREGS work

3 Group – D / Packer 1.00 Doing NREGS work

LSG and HSG Sub Post Offices


1 Supervisor of SB branch 1.15 Supervisory work of NREGS a/cs
2 SB PA 2.00 Entrusted with NREGS work
3 Group – D / packer 0.50 Entrusted with NREGS work
4 Treasurer 0.50 Entrusted with NREGS work
5 Cash Overseer 0.25 Entrusted with cash conveyance
HEAD POST OFFICES n Setting up of Departmental Anomaly
(Rs. 3.00 per account per annum having 10 transactions Committee of Department of Posts
FNPO in a financial year) The undersigned is directed to say that in
1 APM / Supervisor 0.50 Entrusted with NREGS work accordance with the instructions contained in the OM
2 Leger PA 1.00 Entrusted with NREGS work No. 11/2/2008-JCA dated 12-01-2009 of Department of
3 SBCO – PA 0.25 Entrusted with NREGS work Personnel & Training, New Delhi, appropriate Anomaly
4 SBCO-Supervisor 0.25 Entrusted with NREGS work Committees should be set up by each Ministry/
5 Treasurer / ATR 0.50 Entrusted with NREGS work Department to settle the anomalies arising out of the
6 Group-D / Packer (SB) 0.25 Entrusted with NREGS work implementation of the Sixth Central Pay Commission's
7 Cash / Mail overseer 0.25 Entrusted with NREGS work recommendations.
Editorial........ continued from page1 2. Accordingly, competent authority has approved
day but could not receive their dues in time. setting up the Departmental Anomaly Committee. The
The demands of the workers like cadre restructuring, Anomaly Committee will comprise the following
three promotions, settlement of anomalies arisen after the
representatives from Official Side and Staff Side:
implementation of the Sixth CPC, better promotional prospects,
OFFICIAL SIDE STAFF SIDE
and improvement in the service conditions are still in doldrums 1. DDG NFPE
and there is no proper discussion in settlement of the demands. (Establishment) - 1. Shri K.V. Sridharan
There was no periodical meeting and the collective bargaining Chairman Leader Staff Side
through JCM as it seems as outmoded and outdated due to the 2. JS&FA 2. Shri Giriraj Singh
scant regard and discard extended to the forums by the Govt 3. DDG (P) Secretary Staff Side
and its departments. 3. Shri K Raghavendran
The workers have to meet these challenges posed Member
4. Shri Ishwar singh Dabas
and defeat the moves to undermine their interests. Our intention
Member
is to bring mounting and massive force behind our plea for the 5. Shri S. P. Mukharjee
settlement of our demands. Mobilization of strength to achieve Member
the demands should be our strategy and idea. We should stick to FNPI
the guns of content and character of Trade union that there will 6. Shri D Theagarajan
be no lasting truce till our just demands are conceded and genuine Member
grievances are redressed. The Road to salvation and success 7. Shri D Krishna Rao
Member
is that of organized strength, unity, collective bargaining and
struggle. This is the one and only Road. 3. The date of next meeting and agenda items for
The challenges have to be met and will be met by the discussion will be intimated in due course.
Postal workers and by the lakhs of the Central Govt employees. (No. 1-16/2008-PCC Dated: 30-04-2009)

BHARTIYA POST 21 JUNE, 2009


GOVERNMENT ORDERS
n Accountability for delay in decision making. delay in decisions making and/ or harassment of the pubic.
A core Group on Administrative Reforms (CGAR) has been 4. Ministries/Departments are also requested to bring the above
constituted under the chairmanship of Cabinet Secretary in cited provisions of the Conduct Rules and CCA Rules to the
February. 2003 to formulate specific changes in the systems notice of all the officers and officials in the Ministry/Department
and procedures in consultation with the ministries/departments (proper) and in the organizations/offices under their administrative
concerned and to advise strategies for changing attitudes. The control to clarify that if they are found responsible for willful
Core Group has decided that the existing provisions about delay in disposal of the various types of cases dealt with by
accountability mechanism should be reiterated with a view to them, finally leading to delay in decision making, they shall be
bring to everyone's notice that these provisions are adequate liable for disciplinary action in terms of the relevant provisions
for initiating disciplinary proceedings when an officer adopts a referred to in para 2 and 3 of this OM.
dilatory attitude leading to delay in decision - making and/or (DO P&T L. No. 11013/2/2004-Estt. (A) dt: 16.2.09)
harassment of the public. n Absorption of surplus Dramin Dak Sevaks on
(ii) In view of the above the following provisions of CCS abolition of Posts and maintenance of waiting list-reg.
(Conduct) Rules, 1964 are brought to the notice of all Ministries/ A reference is invited to note (iv) below rule 3 of GDS
Departments for information and necessary action: - (Conduct & Employment) Rules, 2001 according to which a Sevak
Rule 3 General shall not be eligible for transfer in any case from one post/unit to
(1) Every Government servant shall at all times- another post/unit except in pubic interest.
(i) maintain absolute integrity; To mitigate the hardship to the CDS, Directorate, vide
(ii) maintain devotion to duty; and letter No. 19-10/2004-GDS dated 17.7.2006 issued amendment
(iii) do nothing which is unbecoming of a Government to rule 3 of GDS (Conduct & Employment) Rules 2001 and allowed
servant limited transfer facility to GDS on specific grounds on fulfillment
(2) (i) Every Government servant holding a supervisory of specific conditions.
post shall take all possible steps to ensure the integrity and The matter has been further examined and it has been
devotion to duty of all Government servants for the time being decided that consequent upon the abolition of GDS posts, the
under his control and authority; surplus Gramin Dak Sevaks should be accommodated in the
(ii) No Government servant shall, in the performance of his official alternative posts in the following manner: -
duties, or in the exercise of powers conferred on him, act (1) The surplus Gramin Dak Sevak may be accommodated
otherwise than in his best judgment except when he is acting as far as possible under the accounts jurisdiction of the Sub
under the direction of his official superior; Office where he is working subject to availability of vacancies
Explanation I :- A Government servant who habitually fails to and also fulfillment of the conditions of educational qualification
perform the task assigned to him within the time set for the prescribed for the post etc.
purpose and with the equality of performance expected of him (2) If there is no vacancy in the Branch Offices under the
shall be deemed to be lacking in devotion to duty within the Accounts jurisdiction of the Sub Office, the surplus Gramin Dak
meaning of clause (ii) of sub rule (I). Sevak may be informed of the details of the vacancies available
Explanation II :- Nothing in clause (ii) of sub-rule (2) shall be in the whole division/sub division and he will be asked to exercise
construed as empowering a Government servant to evade his option for choosing the post.
responsibilities by seeking instructions from, or approval of , a (DG(P) No. 17-14/2008-GDS Dated - 26.02.2009)
superior officer or authority when such instructions are not n Recommendations of 6th Central Pay
necessary under the scheme of distribution of powers and Commission- clarification regarding encashment leave
responsibilities. With regard to entitlement of encashment of leave
Rule 3A promptness and courtesy during LTC, a doubt has arisen whether the leave encashment
No Government servant shall during LTC can be allowed per less than 10 days period. The
(a) in the performance of his official duties, act in a issue was referred to department of personnel & Training for
discourteous manner; clarification.
(b) in his official dealings with the public or otherwise Department of personnel & Training as clarified wide
adopt dilatory tactics or willfully cause delays in disposal of the their U.O. No. 14028/2/2009-Estt (L) dated 09.02.2009 that interms
work assigned to him. of Rule 38-A of the CCS (Leave) rules, 1972. Government
3. Rule 11 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 provides that Employees are entitled to encash up to 10 days Earned Leave at
the penalties (ranging from 'censure' to 'dismissal') mentioned the time of availing LTC subject to the condition that earned leave
therein may be imposed on a Government servant 'for good and of an equivalent duration is also availed of simultaneously. Hence,
sufficient reasons'. Thus any Government servants violating the the applicant is entitled to encash leave for less than 10 days but
provisions of conduct Rules can be proceeded against as it will and earned leave of an equivalent duration is also required to be
form 'good and sufficient reasons' for imposing the penalties availed of simultaneously.
prescribed in Rule 11. In other words, disciplinary proceedings (DG (P) No. 4-4/2008-PCC Dated 27.03.2009)
could be initiated if an officer adopts a dilatory attitude, leading to n Clarification regarding commutation of pension
BHARTIYA POST 22 JUNE, 2009
after the implementation of recommendations of 6th them to this Department.
CPC. 4. This issues with the concurrence of Ministry of Finance
The undersigned is directed to say that in accordance (Department of Expenditure) vide their UO No.43/EV/2009 dated
with the instructions contained in this Department's OM. No. 38/ 13.02.2009.
37/2008-P & PW (A) dated 2nd September, 2008, in the case of (Dept of Pension & PW OM F. No. 38/79/2008-P & PW (A) dt.
those pensioners, in whose case commutation of pension 16.02.2009)
became absolute on or after 01.01.2006 but before the issue of n Travelling allowance Rules-Implementation of
that OM, the pre-revised Table of Commutation Value for Pension the Sixth Central Pay Commission
will be used for payment of commutation of pension based on In para 4 (c) column (3) of O. M. No. 19030/3/2008-E-
pre-revised pay/pension. Such pensioners shall have on option IV dated 23.09.2008 on the above subject, the following may be
to commute the amount of pension that has become additionally corrected: -
commutable an account of retrospective revision of pay/pension Rate per Km. for transport by Road (Rs. Per km.)
on implementation of the recommendation of the Sixth Central 18.00 (Rs. 30 per Kg in per km)
Pay Commission. On exercising such an option by the pensioner, 18.00 (Rs. 30 per kg per km)
the revised Table of Commutation Value for Pension will be used 9.00 (Rs. 0.31 per kg per km)
for the commutation of the additional amount of pension that has 4.60 (Rs. 0.31 per kg per km)
become commutable on account of retrospective revision of READ
pay/pension. 18.00 (Rs 0.003 per kg/per km)
2. A number of references have been received in this 18.00 (Rs. 0.003 per kg/per km)
Department seeking clarifications in regard to various issues 9.00 (Rs. 0.0031 per kg/per km)
relating to commutation of pension in case a pensioner opts for 4.60 (Rs. 0.0031 per kg/per km)
commutation of pension that has become additionally commutable (MOF DOE F. No. 19030/3/2008-E IV dt. 18.02.2009)
on account of retrospective revision of pay pension. The matter n Implementation of the Government's decision
has been examined in consultation with the Ministry of Finance on the recommendation of the Sixth CPC-Revision of
(Department of Expenditure) and the following clarification are provisions regulating special benefits in the case of death
issued in this regard: of disability in service-payment of ex-gratia lumpsum
Points raised : compensation to families of Central Government
1. What would be the age to be used for commutation of Employees-modification regarding
additional Commutable pension and which factor would be used The undersigned is directed to say that in
for such additional commuted value of pension. implementation of the decisions on the recommendation contained
The age reckoned for calculation of commuted value in Para 5.1.45 of the Report of the Sixth Central Pay Commission,
of pension at the time of original application for commutation of the rates of ex-gratia in cases of death occurring due to accidents
pension will apply for calculation of commutation value of in the course of performance of duty, death attributable to acts
additional commutable pension. However, as mentioned in the of violence by terrorists, anti-social elements etc., death occurring
O.M. dated 02.09.2008, the commutation factor in the revised due to enemy action in international war or border skirmishes or
Table of Commutation Value for Pension will be used for the action against militants, terrorists, extremists etc. or death on
commutation of the additional amount of pension that has account of natural disasters, extreme weather conditions while
become commutable on account of retrospective revision of on duty in the specified high altitude, inaccessible border posts,
pay/pension. etc., have been revised vide this Department's O. M. No. 38/37/
2. From which date the reduction in pension on account 08-P&PW (A) dated 2nd September, 2008.
of additional commutation of pension will take effect? 2. In certain cases, relief is also provided to families of
Reduction in pension on account of additional deceased Government servants from sundry Government
commutation of pension will be in two staged as per the provision sources, such as the Prime Minister's Relief Fund, Chief Minister's
contained in Rule 6 of the CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules, Relief Fund, etc. In such cases, it should be ensured that the
1981. aggregate of the relief/ex gratia compensation paid from different
3. What will be the date of restoration of additional sources does not exceed Rs. 20 lakhs in each individual case.
commutation of pension? Para 12 of Annexe to this Department's OM 45/55/97-P&PW (C)
The Commuted portion of pension shall be restored dated 11th September, 1998 will stand modified to this extent.
after 15 years from the respective dates of commutation as 3. All other terms and conditions in the O.M. dated 11th
provided in Government of India decision No. 1 under Rule 10 September, 1998 shall remain unchanged.
of CCS (Commutation of Pension). Rules 1981. Necessary 4. This issues with the concurrence of the Ministry of
endorsement should be made in the PPO. Finance, Department of Expenditure U.O. No. 4.2/39/2009-IC dated
It is impressed upon all the Ministries/Department of 11.2.2009.
the Government of India to keep in view the above clarification 5. In so far as persons serving in the Indian Audit &
while disposing of the cases of commutation of additional pension. Accounts Department, these orders issue after consultation with
They are also advised to dispose the representation received by the comptroller & Auditor General of India.
them from pensioners on the above issues without referring (Dept. of Pen & PW OM No. 45/7/2008- P & PW (F) dt. 16.03.09)

BHARTIYA POST 23 JUNE, 2009


OFFICE MEMORANDUM classification of the post) consequent upon the merger
n Criteria for assessing suitability of officers of upgradation and where there is no higher responsibility
where there is revision/upgradation/merger of pay or higher qualification involved, assessment of the
scales. suitability will not be necessary before the revised grade
The undersigned is directed to invite reference is allowed. There will also be no need for the incumbents
to the Department of Personnel & training OM No. 22011/ to complete any minimum eligibility service in the earlier
10/84-Estt.(D) dated 04-02-1992 wherein the criteria to scale of pay. However, suitability of the officer who has
be adopted for assessing the suitability of incumbents of been placed in a upgraded/replacement pay scale which
posts and the date of appointment to the upgraded post, fall in Group 'A' by recommendation/ award of the pay
wherever there is a revision of pay scale/upgradation of Commission will continue to be assessed.
post, have been laid down. 3. Assessment of suitability will continue to be
2. There has been merger of a number of pre- necessary in the following situations arising out of cadre
revised scales without any pre-condition for possession reviews, restructuring etc., not covered in the
of higher qualifications for placement of incumbents in the recommendations of the 6th CPC:
higher/upgraded scale, in the revised pay structure (i) Where the upgradation involves higher
recommended by the 6th CPC and accepted by the responsibilities and higher eligibility service;
Government. In this context, the instructions of 4.2.92 have (ii) Where the upgradation or merger is part; where
been reviewed and it has been decided in consultation the upgraded post will be the promotion grade for the
with Ministry of Finance (Department of Expenditure) who posts left in the lower grade and the normal DPC
have issued certain instructions in this regard under OM procedure will apply.
No. 1/1/2008-IC dated 13.09.2008, and the UPSC that the (DoPT, O.M. No. AB 14017/66/2008-Estt.RR Dated:
procedure for assessment of suitability in such cases may 09-03-2009)
be as follows for placement in the upgraded/merged grade: MINISTRY OF PERSONNEL,
(i) Where all posts in one or more pre-revised scales PUBLIC GRIEVANCES AND PENSIONS
are merged with a higher pre-revised scale and given a ORDER
common replacement scale/grade pay/pay scale, the New Delhi, the 9th April, 2009
suitability of the incumbents need not be assessed for n S.O. 946(E),- In exercise of the powers conferred
granting them the higher replacement scale/grade pay/pay by the proviso to article 309 and clause 5 of article 148 of
scale; there is also no need for the incumbents to complete the Constitution read with rule 6 of the Central Civil
any minimum eligibility service in the earlier scale of pay. Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965
There will be no change in the inter se seniority of the and in supersession, of the notification of the Government
incumbents in the merged grade which shall be decided of India in the Department of Personnel and Training
based on the general instructions on the subject ; and number S.O. 332(E) dated the 20th day of April, 1998 and
(ii) Where all posts in a particular grade have been after consultation with the Comptroller and Auditor
granted a higher replacement pay scale/grade pay, as General of India in relation to persons serving in the Indian
per upgradation recommended by the 6th CPC, suitability Audit and Accounts Department, except as respects things
of the incumbents need not be assessed for granting done or omitted to be done before such supersession,
them the higher replacement scale/grade pay. Here also, the President hereby directs that with effect from the date
there is no need for the incumbents to complete any of publication of this order in the Official Gazette, all civil
minimum eligibility service in the earlier scale of pay; and posts under the Union, shall be classified as follows:-
(iii) Where there is a change in the Group (that is
S. No. Description of Posts Classification of Posts
(1) (2) (3)
1. (a) A Central Civil post in Cabinet Secretary’s scale
(Rs. 90000-Fixed), Apex Scale (Rs. 80000-Fixed) and Higher
Administrative Grade plus scale(Rs. 75500-80000); and
(b) A Central Civil post carrying the following grade pays:- Group A
Rs. 12000. Rs. 10000, Rs. 8900 and Rs. 8700 in the scale of
pay of Rs. 37400-67000 in Pay Band-4, and Rs. 7600, Rs.
6600 and Rs5400 in the scale of pay of Rs. 15600-39100 in
Pay Band-3
2. A Central Civil Post carrying the following grade pays:-
Rs. 5400, Rs. 4800, Rs. 4600 and Rs. 4200 in the scale of pay Group B
of Rs. 9300-34800 in Pay Band-2.
3. A Central Civil post carrying the following grade pays:- Group C
Rs. 2800, Rs. 2400, Rs. 2000, Rs. 1900, and Rs. 1800 in the
scale of pay of Rs. 5200-20200 in Pay Band-1
4. A Central Civil post carrying the following grade pays:- Group D
Rs. 1300, Rs. 1400, Rs. 1600, Rs. 1650 in the scale of pay of (Till the posts are upgraded)
Rs. 4440-7440 in IS Scale

BHARTIYA POST 24 JUNE, 2009


Explanation: For the purpose of this order pay Band, in these, it has been decided that the following
relation to a post, means the running Pay Bands specified consequential steps to amend the existing service Rules/
in Part-A Section 1 of Column 5 of the First Schedule to Recruitment Rules shall be undertaken on a priority basis:
the Central Civil Services (Revised Pay ) Rules, 2008. (i) Substituting the existing scales by the Grade
(F.No 11012/7/2008-Estt.(A)) Pay alongwith the Pay Band
n Classification of posts under the CCS (CCA) The existing pay scales have to be substituted
Rules, 1995 by the new pay structure (Pay Band and Grade Pay/Pay
Under the Central Civil Services (Classification, scale) straightaway without making a reference to the
Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, all Central Government Department of Personnel and Training (DOP&T)/ Union
posts are classified into four categories, viz., Groups "A", Public Service Commission (UPSC). The heading of
"B", "C" and "D". This classification at present is based column No. 4 of the Schedule on RRs may be modified to
on the norms prescribed by the Department of Personnel "Pay Band and Grade Pay/Pay Scale". In cases where
and Training vide S.O. 332(E) dated 20.04.1998 deputation is also one of the methods of recruitment, the
published in the Gazette of India Extraordinary. field of selection for deputation, which might include
2. As per clause (4) of the Central Civil Services various grades, should also reflect the corresponding
(Revised Pay) Rules,2008 notified vide notification No G. Grade Pay alongwith the Pay Band /Pay Scale, and the
S.R. 622(E) dated 29-08-2008, the pay band and grade minimum eligibility service as per the revised guidelines,
pay or the pay scales, as applicable, of every post/grade as enclosed in Annexure.
specified in column 2 of the First Schedule thereto shall (ii) Where there is an upgradation of posts
be as specified against it in columns 5 and 6 thereof, The instructions issued by Department of
Consequent upon the notification of the said rules, it had Expenditure under OM No. 1/1/2008-IC dated 13th
become necessary to prescribe revised norms for September, 2008 and DoPT O.M. Mo. AB-14017/66/08-
categorization of posts into the abovementioned four Esst (RR) dated 9th March, 2009 may be applied in such
categories based on the pay band and grade pay or the case.
pay scales as applicable, as approved by the Government. However, for each of the merged grades, a single
Accordingly, an Order classifying the various Central Civil set of Recruitment Rules may be formulated and notified.
Services posts into Group "A", "B", "C" and "D" based on (iii) Consequential changes
the revised norms of pay has been notified in the Gazette It is necessary to make consequential changes
of India Extraordinary vide S.O. 946 (E) dated 09-04-2009. in the Recruitment Rules/Service Rules so as to prescribe
A copy of the Order is enclosed. All posts in the Central eligibility conditions with reference to the revised Grade
Civil Services would now stand classified strictly in Pay/Pay scale. It is also necessary to review other columns
accordance with the norms of pay band and grade pay or of the Recruitment Rules/ Service Rules, where some
pay scales as prescribed in the said Order. minimum service in a particular scale/grade is prescribed
3. In some Ministries/Departments, posts may exist for consideration for appointment on deputation/
which are not classified as per the norms laid down by absorption etc., keeping in view particularly the merger of
this Department. If, for any specific reason, a Ministry/ a number of pre-revised scales, upgradation of some
Department proposes to classify the posts differently, it scales and the consequential changes in the minimum
would be necessary for that Department to send a specific eligibility service in a grade.
proposal to Department of Personnel and Training giving (iv) Department promotion Committee (DPC)
full justification in support of the proposal within three Where two or more scales have been merged,
months of this O.M. so that the exceptions to the norms of the existing DPC for the higher/highest grade will be the
classification laid down in S.O. 946 (E) dated 09-04-2009 DPC for the merged grade.
can be notified. (v) Regulation of regular service rendered in the
(No. AB 11012/7/08-Estt.(A) Dated: 17-04-2009) pre-revised scales
OFFICE MEMORANDUM The revised pay structure approved includes a
n Sixth Central Pay Commission's number of 'merged grades' with a common grade pay
recommendations-revision of pay scales-amendment and the concept of pay bands with grade pay introduced
of Service Rules/Recruitment Rules effective from 1.1.2006. Insofar as the issue of regulation
The recommendation of 6th CPC have been of service rendered prior to 1.1.2006 is concerned, while
considered by the Government and the CCS (Revised the general rule may be that such regular service be
Pay) Rules 2008 have since been notified on 29th August, deemed to be service rendered in the corresponding
2008. Consequently, in place of the pre-revised pay grade pay/pay scale approved effective from 1.1.2006 or
scales, the revised pay structure comprising the Pay Band from a subsequent date, as the case may be, this
and Grade Pay/Pay Scale has come into effect. Some of formulation cannot apply in cases where there has been
the pre-revised pay scales have been merged and some merger of more than one grade into one with a single
others are upgraded/likely to be upgraded. In the light of grade pay/pay scale. Since the merger is effective from

BHARTIYA POST 25 JUNE, 2009


1.1.06 only, even notional benefits of the merger cannot
be extended for periods falling prior to 1.1.06. A note to
the following effect may, therefore, be inserted under
col.12 of the Schedule on RRs, and under relevant
provisions in Service Rules, to take care of the
requirements:
Note:
For the purpose of computing minimum
qualifying service for promotion, the service rendered
on a regular basis by an officer prior to 1.1.2006/ the
date from which the revised pay structure based on the
6th CPC recommendations has been extended, shall
be deemed to be service rendered in the corresponding
grade pay/pay scale extended based on the
Commission. For purposes of appointment on
deputation/absorption basis, the service rendered on a
regular basis by an officer prior to 1.1.2006/ the date
from which the revised pay structure based on the 6th
CPC recommendations has been extended, shall be
deemed to be service rendered in the corresponding
grade pay/pay scale extended based on the
recommendations of the Commission except where
there has been merger of more than one pre-revised
scale of pay into one grade with a common grade pay/'
pay scale, and where this benefit will extend only for the
post(s) for which that grade pay/pay scale is the normal
replacement grade without any upgradation.
2. The Recruitment Rules/Service Rules are of
statutory nature. Therefore, the changes brought out by
other relevant instructions have to be incorporated in DoPT No. AB14017/61/2008-Estt.(PR) Dated : 24.03.2009
the Recruitment Rules/ Service Rules by suitable n Change in mode of dispatch of Advice of
amendments so that the necessary steps like holding Transfer (AT) in case of transfer of accounts.
of DPC etc. are taken to fill the post carrying the revised The undersigned is directed to say that from
Grade Pay/Pay Scale on regular basis. All the Ministries/ some time past, fraud cases relating to opening of
Departments are, therefore, requested to effect accounts by use of bogus Advice of Transfers (AT) and
necessary amendments to the Recruitment Rules/ then misappropriation of money are being reported. To
Service Rules notified by them after following the normal control such type of frauds, it has been decided that from
procedure of furnishing proposals to the Department of 16.3.2009, the transferring Head Post offices will dispatch
Personnel and Training and the UPSC in the format Advice of Transfer (AT) by Service Insured Post for Rs.
prescribed in the general guidelines on Recruitment 100/- duly sealed instead of Service Registered Post.
Rules circulated by the DOPT OM No. 14017/12/87- The AT received by other than Insured Post after this date,
Estt.(RR) dated 18.3.1988, and also in consultation with should be returned to the Transferring HPO by Transferee
the Legislative Department. HPO for sending the same by Insured Post and account
3. Ministries/Departments may initiate action to should not be opened.
complete the review in this regard and furnish necessary 2. This may kindly be brought to the notice of all
amendment proposals to the DOPT and the UPSC in the post offices and strict compliance of the aforesaid order
case of Group A and Group B posts within six months may be ensured.
from the date of issue of this Office Memorandum. They 3. This issued with the approval of DDG(FS)
may also, simultaneously, take similar action in respect (DG(P) No. 113-01/2009-SB Dated: 4-03-2009)
of Recruitment rules for Group C and D posts, which are OFFICE MEMORANDUM
within their delegated powers. Appropriate action to n Providing Acrylic Paints on the External walls
update the Service Rules for organized Group A,B Services, of Assets/ Buildings.
etc. shall also be taken up with DOPT/UPSC within a DG (Works), CPWD has issued circular vide No.
period of six months. 54/S&S Unit/Finishing/06 dated 19-01-2005. As per
circular acrylic paint has been allowed on the external
walls of the building. Accordingly it has now been decided

BHARTIYA POST 26 JUNE, 2009


to switchover to the acrylic paint on external walls of Post 20/2008-PCC dated 27.03.2009 on which is reproduced
Office Buildings & Staff Quarters. Following steps should below:
be taken to ensure proper execution of the work. "The issue was referred to Ministry of Finance
1. The acrylic paints manufactured by reputed paint for fixation of pay scales of these employees of the
manufacturing company shall only be used. A list of Department of Posts before completion of the training
specific makes brands of acrylic paint may be got and that Ministry has concurred in the proposal subject to
approved from Zonal CEs (Civil) and same should be the conditions that necessary computer training may be
indicated in the tender documents. provided to enhance their skill. Action may be initiated by
2. The surface preparation before applying the Heads of Circles to complete the required training on
paint shall be required to be done as per manufacturer's computer operations in consultation with the Training
specifications. It should be ensured that before works division of the Directorate. Training division of the
are taken up, necessary repairs to plaster, chajjas etc. Directorate will take necessary action to get the module
have been done and seepage, if any, has been arrested. developed to train all such Non-matriculate employees
3. Since the financial implication of providing acrylic in basic data entry and circulate to all Circles ."
paint at the initial stage is higher than that of providing 2. The module for the multi skilled employees in
white washing or cement paint, the work shall be done in computer training is enclosed. The module is in two parts:
phases, keeping in view the availability of funds. (a) Be able to make data entry in MS Word and MS
4. Necessary provision for obtaining suitable excel,
performance guarantee for the lifecycle of the product (b) Booking articles on Point of Sale in Meghdoot
against fading and/or peeling of the paint should be kept Millennium.
in the contract. The total duration of the training is of two hours for 6 days.
5. To alleviate spurious quality paint, a special The programmer is mainly hands on experience of
condition should be inserted in the tender document that performing basic functions on computers on computers.
all purchases of paint shall be made directly from the 3. Imparting Training:
manufactures or their authorized dealers. The delivery (a) Training on data entry be imparted at local level
challan shall be issued by the manufacturer's stock-yard at divisional centers/computerized post offices or it
directly with full description of the work for which the required at institutes, which provide such training.
purchase is being made. This condition shall apply for Preference to institutes involved in literacy Mission of State/
all purchases for 100 liters or more in a work. Central Government may be given where charges are
This issue with the approval of Secretary (Posts), reasonable.
New Delhi. (b) Training on "Point of Sale" in Meghdot Millennium
(DG(P) No. PPND/SW-II/W/135/2006/384 Dated: 19-06- may be given by System Administrator/Computer knowing
2008) SPM/PA in the local/ nearby computerized post office.
n Regarding payment of SB allowance to SPM of (c) In case WCTC are used for such training, please
Single Handed SOs ensure that the Project training is not hold up.
Since long, the matter regarding payment of SB 4. The expenditure for the training will be met from
allowance to SPM of Single Handed SOs has been Non Plan funds under 'PS' for payment to professional
figuring in meetings with union representatives at various agency, if outside Institute is engaged and 'TE' for
levels. Directorate in its communication No. 113-8-SB Traveling. Kindly work out the tentative expenditure for
dated 9-01-2009, quoting its earlier letter No. 55-2/90-SB this training and requirement of funds may be projected
dated 4-05-1990 has now informed that SPMs of Single to Budget Section in the respective Non Plan heads.
Handed SOs are only PAs but have been designated as 5. A certificate in respect of completion of
SPMs and, therefore covered under para 1(iii)(a) of order prescribed training may be issued by the divisional head
No.2-3/86-SB dated 27-04-1989 (substituted vide and entry recorded in the Service Book of each employee.
Directorate letter No. 2-3/86-SB dated 12-09-1989). This 6. The training is to be completed by 30th April,
clarification still holds good. 2009. A completion report in this regard be sent to this
In other words, if by calculation of workload of office by e mail which will include the total number of
single handed post office SB work alone is more than 4 employees.
hours (i.e. at least 0.5 of the work hours justifying sanction Training Module for Basic computer Training for non-
of Postal Assisstant) the S.B. Allowance will be payable, matriculate Group 'D' employees
subject to fulfillment of conditions laid down in Directorate Programme Title : Training programme for
letter No. 2-3/86-SB dated 27.04.1989. Group 'D' non-matriculate employees
(Chief PMG, Maharashtra letter No. Estt/7-1/II/Allowance Overall Objective: 1. Trainees be able to make Data
Dated: 03-02-2009) entry in MS Word and MS Excel.
n Training on computer Operations to Non 2. Trainees by able to book articles
Matriculate Group 'D' Employees. on Point of Sale, Meghdoot
Kindly refer para 3 of DDG (Estt.) memo No. 1- Millennium
BHARTIYA POST 27 JUNE, 2009
Time Frame: Two hours for six days Central Government.
(Recommended) Methodology: Mainly hands on experiences on
Venue: Divisional level training centers/ computers, simple description on
Computerized Post offices/ Institute computer hardware, software. Data
involved in literacy mission of state/ entry and article booking exercise.

Please note 25 articles are proposed based on time are non-matriculates, the output has been slightly
allowed for registered articles i.e. 2 minutes per article. reduced.
Keeping in view that this training is for Group 'D' who (DG(P) No. 1-55/2009-Trg Dated : 6-4-2009)
(Contd. from page 33) employees. Only then a good governance is possible. These
public administration require that all entries (whether poor, fair, directions do not apply to Military Officers because their position
average, good or V. good) in the annual confidential report of is different. These direction, however, apply to employees of
public servant, whether in civil, judicial, police or any other State statutory authorities, Public Sector Corporation and other
service (except Military) must be communicated to him within a instrumentalities of the State (in addition to Government servants).
reasonable period so that he can make a representation for its 9. Non-communication of entries ACRs of a public servant,
upgradation. This rule prevails even if there may be no rules/G.O. whether he is in Civil, Judicial, Police or any other service (other
prohibiting it, because principles of non-arbitrariness in State than Military) has civil consequences because it may affect his
action as envisaged by Article 14 of the constitution requires chances of promotion or get other benefits. Such non-
such communication. Article 14 overrides all rules of Government communication would be arbitrary and therefore violative of
orders. Article 14 of the Constitution".
8. When an entry is communicated to a public servant, he In view of the above, the judgments of the High Court
should have a right to make a representation to the authorities was set aside. In the meantime as the Appellant, had retired, he
concerned who must decide the representation in a fair manner may be conveyed the "Good" entry in CR 93-94 for his
and within a reasonable period. The representation must be representation and it upgradation. If his representation is allowed
decided by an authority higher than the one who gave that entry, and the entry is upgraded as "V. Good" he may be given promotion
otherwise likelihood is that, the representation would be retrospectively if selected by DPC. His arrears to be paid due to
summarily rejected without adequate consideration. All this would this promotion may be paid with 8% interest per annum.
be summarily rejected without adequate consideration. All this Appeal is allowed as above.
would be conducive to fairness and transparency in public {Dev Dutt v. Union of India and other, 2/2009, Swamysnews
administration and would result in fairness to public servant. The 74, 2008 2) SCC (L&S), 771 date of judgment 12.5.2008)
State must be a model employer and must act fairly towards its Courtesy : Swamysnews February 2009
BHARTIYA POST 28 JUNE, 2009
HEADWISE DETAILS OF INCOME 24 Photostat 18968.00
W.E.F 01.10.2008 TO 31.03.2009 25 Newspapers 1590.00
Quota 508284.00 26 M. R. Claim to General Secretary 7898.30
Bhartiya Post Receipts 198992.00 27 Legal Court Expenses 50000.00
Confederation 1860.00 28 Gifts 4406.00
Quota to NFPE 88007.00 29 Agitational Programmes 3038.00
Donations 472609.00 30 Computer Repairs & Accessories 11212.00
Publication sale 12715.00 31 Ticket Cancellation Charges 2120.00
Sale of old Newspaper 168.00 32 TA/DA for Strike Tour 4420.00
Refund of Loan from Ex- Financial Secretary 5000.00 33 Tarapada Bhawan Maintenance 15834.00
Tarapada Bhawan Receipts 170.00 34 Quota transfer to NFPE 17316.00
1287805.00 35 Bank Charges 686.00
36 Social Security Contributions to Staff 4500.00
HEADWISE DETAILS OF EXPENDITURE 37 Cost of Reference Books 1133.00
W.E.F. 01.10.2008 TO 31.03.2009 38 Audit fee 1000.00
1 Loss of Pay to General Secretary 151174.00 39 Cost of Mobile Phones 12800.00
2 H. Q. Allowance to General Secretary 15000.00 40 Transfer to Confederation 1000.00
3 Bonus & Arrears to General Secretary 8882.00 1268392.87
4 Loss of Pay to Dy. General Secretary 53608.00 Rs. Twelve Lakhs Sixty Eight Thousand Three Hundred
5 Bonus Arrears to Deputy General Secretary 2220.00 Ninty Two and paisa Eighty Seven only
6 H. Q. Allowance to Dy. G. S. 5000.00
7 Pay Commission Arrears to CONSOLIDATED INCOME & EXPENDITURE
Ex G. S, Com. R. N. Chaudhary 37615.00 W.E.F. 01.10.2008 TO 31.03.2008
8 Bonus Arrears to Ex- G. S, Balance on 01.10.2009 = 4355766.78
Com. R. N. Chaudhary 1151.00 RECEIPTS
9 Pay Commission arrears & OCT - 08 269563.00
Bonus arrearsto EX-Dy. G.S & Sundaramoorthy 4000.00 NOV - 08 533938.00
10 TA/DA to Office Bearers DEC - 08 243137.00
General Secretary 57964.00 JAN - 09 94593.00
Deputy General Secreatary 11605.00 FEB - 09 95152.00
Officer Bearers 17600.00 87169.00 MAR - 09 51422.00
11 Pay & Allowances to Staff 1287805.00 1287805.00
Office Assistant 55767.00 5643571.78
Office Attendant 51662.00 Interest on SB & FD Accounts 622176.29
Peon 48738.00 6265748.07
Sweeper 2350.00 158517.00 LESS EXPENDITURE
12 All India Conference 226718.00 OCT - 08 208894.54
13 Cost of Bhartiya Post 176252.00 NOV- 08 154725.76
14 Office Maintenance 10404.00 AIC 226718.00
15 Office Requirements 13379.00 DEC - 08 247526.26
16 Telephone Bills 12091.00 JAN - 09 171637.06
17 Mobile Phone Bills 14740.00 FEB - 09 147740.25
General Secretary 11229.00 MAR-09 111151.00
Deputy General Secretary 650.00 1268392.87 1268392.87
Office Staff 2861.00 4997355.20
18 Laptop Data Card 1319.32 BALANCE AS ON 31.03.2009
19 Electricity/Water Charges 8302.00 Details of Balance as on 31.03.2009
20 Conveyance Charges FD A/c Syndicate Bank 4000000.00
General Secretary 22210.00 Syndicate Bank SB A/c No. 90742010070474 981380.60
Deputy General Secretary 680.00 Cash in Hand = 15974.60
4997355.20
Financial Secretary 16000.00
Forty Nine Lakhs Ninety Seven Thousand Three Hundred
Asstt. Financial Secretary 3000.00
Fifty Five & Paisa Twenty Only
Staff 1889.00 43779.00
Sd/- Sd/-
21 Postage Charges 63844.00 Financial Secretary General Secretary
22 Stationaries 3897.00
23 Sumptuaries 11410.25
BHARTIYA POST 29 JUNE, 2009
CASE LAW - AN IMPORTANT SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT ON
APPLICATION OF BENCH MARKS ON PROMOTION
1. When an entry in the confidential report of a for promotion. Nomenclature is not relevant; it is the effect which
Government servant is going to affect his further career the entry is having which determines whether it is an adverse or
prospects, it should be communicated to the employee not. It is thus the rigours of the entry which is important, not the
even if it is not an adverse remark. phraseology. Grant of "Good" entry is of no satisfaction to an
incumbent if it in fact makes him in eligible for promotion or has an
2. All gradings in the confidential reports are to
adverse effect on his chances. "Good" entry should have been
be communicated to adhere to the principles of natural
communicated to the Appellant so as to enable him to make a
justice within a reasonable period after CRs are finalized
representation praying that the said entry for the year 1993-94
Facts: The Appellant joined Border Road Engineering Services should be upgraded from "good" to "Very Good". After considering
as Group 'A' Officer. The Border Road Group 'A'. Services Rules such a representation, It was open to the authority concerned to
governs the service. He was promoted as Executive Engineer reject the representation and confirm the "good" entry (though in
on 22.2.1988. He is eligible for further promotion as a fair manner), but at least an opportunity of making such a
Superintendent Engineer after five years of service as Executive representation should have been given to the Appellant and that
Engineer from 21.2.1993. But he was overlooked for promotion would only have been possible had the Appellant been
and his juniors were promoted as Superintendent Engineer on communicated "good' entry. Non-communication of 'good" entry
the ground he obtained only 'Good" grading in CR for the year was arbitrary and hence illegal.
1993-94. For promotion as Superintendent Engineer, he should
2. Every entry (not merely a poor or adverse entry)
have got the grading of "Very Good" which is the benchmark in
relating to an employee under the state or an instrumentality of
terms of the OM, dated 10.4.1989 and hence he was overlooked.
the state, whether in Civil, Judicial, Police or other service (except
The grading of good was also not communicated to him. Hence
the Military) must be communicated to him within a reasonable
he filed a writ petition in Gauhati High Court which by its Order,
period and it makes no difference whether there is a benchmark
dated 26.11.2001 in W.P. No.447 of 2001 dismissed his application.
or not. Even if there is no benchmark, non-communication of an
Hence the present appeal lies before the Supreme Court.
entry may adversely affect the employees' chances of promotion
The legal issue involved in this case was whether (or getting some other benefits) because when comparative
"good" entry n the ACR which adversely affected the Appellant's merit is being considered for promotion (or getting some other
promotion ought to have been communicated to him so as to benefits) a person having a 'Good' or 'Average' or 'Fair' entry,
afford him an opportunity of making representation against it. certainly has a less chances of being selected than a person
Communication of Government of India, dated 10/11.9.1987 having "Very Good" or "outstanding' entry. In most of the services,
provides for communication of only adverse entries in the gradation of entries usually is, (i) Outstanding (ii) Very Good, (iii)
confidential report is to be communicated. Good, (iv) Average, (V) Fair and (Vi) Poor. A person getting any
The Appellant argued that non-communication of of the entries at Serial Nos. (ii) to (Vi) should be communicated
grading "Good" affected him against which he could have such entries so that he has an opportunity of making a
represented. That non-communication violated the principles of representation praying for its upgradation, and such a
natural justice. representation must be decided fairly and within a reasonable
The Respondent submitted that only adverse entries period by the authority concerned. If it is to be held that only
are to be communicated as per standing instructions. As 'Good' 'poor' entry is to be communicated, consequences would be that
is not an adverse entry, it need not be communicated. To state persons getting "Fair, Average, good or Very Good" entries would
so, the Respondents relied on the case of Vijay Kumar v. State of not be able to represent for it upgradations and this may
Maharashtra [1988 SCC (L&S) 42] to state only non-communicated subsequently adversely affect their chances of promotion (or
adverse entries only cannot form the foundation to deny get some other benefits). If Office memorandum, dated 10/
promotion. In the case of State of Gujarat v. Suryakant Chunilal 11.9.1987 is interpreted to mean that only adverse entries (i.e.
Shah [1999 SCC (L&S) 317], it was held that adverse entries 'poor' entry) need to be communicated and not "fair, average or
only are to be communicated to improve his performance and to good" entries, it would become arbitrary (and hence illegal) since
represent against it. Other entries not adverse need not be it may adversely affect the incumbent's chances of promotion or
communicated. get some other benefit.
The views of the Respondent was not agreed to by 3. Every entry in the ACR of a public servant mush be
the Apex Court and in its opinion all entries from bad to outstanding communicated to him within a reasonable period, whether it is a
are to be communicated. An opportunity need to be given to "poor", "Fair", " Average", "Good" or "V.Good" entry. This is
represent if any of the entries are detrimental to his progress. because non-communication of such an entry may adversely
In view of the above, the observation of the Apex affect the employee in two ways: (i) Had the entry been
Court are noted as below: - communicated to him, he would know about the assessment of
his work and conduct by his superiors which would enable him
Held: "1. In this situation, the "good" entry is in fact adverse
to improve his work in future; (ii) he would have an opportunity
entry because it eliminates the candidate from being considered
of making a representation against the entry ihhe feels it is

BHARTIYA POST 30 JUNE, 2009


unjustified and pray for its upgradation. Hence non-communication an adverse entry.
of an entry is arbitrary. It is only when there is a bench mark, but 5. Rules of natural justice are not codified nor are they
in all cases that an entry (whether it is "Poor, Fair, Average, unwarying in all situations, rather they are flexible. They may,
Good or V.Good") must be communicated to a public servant, however, be summarized in one word: Fairness. What they
otherwise there is violation of principles of fairness, which is require is fairness by authority concerned. What is fair would
the soul of natural justice. Even an outstanding entry should be depend on situation and context. Rules of natural justice are
communicated since that would boost the morale of the employee flexible. The question to be asked in every case to determine
and make his work harder. whether the rules of natural justice have been violated is, have
4. Communication of entries and giving opportunity to the authorities acted fairly?
represent against them is particularly important on higher posts 6. Originally, there were said to be only two principles of
which are in a pyramidical structure where often principles of natural justice (i) Rule against bias and (ii) right to be heard (audi
elimination is followed in selection for promotion, and even a alteram partem). However, subsequently, some more rules came
single entry can destroy career of an officer which has otherwise to be added namely, requirement to give reasons. Natural justice
been outstanding throughout. This often results grave injustice has also been held to be part of Article 14 of the Constitution.
and heart-burning, and may shatter the morale of many good Natural Justice is not a stagnating but an expanding concept. It is
officers who are superseded due to this arbitrariness, while open to Court to develop new principles of natural justice in
officers of inferior merit may be promoted. In the present case, appropriate cases.
action of the Respondents not communicating "Good" entry for
7. In the present case a new principle of natural justice is
the year 1993-94 to the Appellant is arbitrary and violative of
being developed by holding that fairness and transparency in
natural justice because in substance 'Good' entry operated as
(Contd. on page 30)

¼i`"B2dk'ks"k½
fnolksadkvodk'klkFkghnksfnoldkizfrcaf/krvodk'k djldsA,u-,Q-ih-bZ-,dvkUnksyugSftldsfy,dbZ
feykANFPTE usghloZizFkedsUnzh;deZpkfj;ksaadsfy, 'kghngq,gSaA;gdsoycM+kla?kghughgScfYdblesalHkh
cksul dh ekax dh vkSj bls izkIr Hkh fd;k x;kA tc deZpkfj;ksadkfo'oklgSAtksfdblla?kdhvkRekgSaA
dsUnzh;deZpkfj;ksaadks,slhdksbZinksUufrfeyrhughaFkh pfy,gevkSjvf/kdlnL;cukdjviuslaxBu
rcNFPTEusnks&nksinksUufrdksizkIrfd;kA dksvkSjetcwrcukrsgSaAMkdr`rh;tks,u-,Q-ih-bZ-ls
P&T dsfodkldsckn,u-,Q-ih-bZ-ghlHkh ekU;rkizkIrgSviuhc<+hgqbZlnL;rkdslkFk[kM+kgks
dSMjksadkusr`RodjusokyklaxBugSAekU;rkizkIr;wfu;uksa ldsA
dsvraxZriwjh,drkgSAoMkdfoHkkxdksthforj[kusds gk¡];glEHkogSizR;sdmllnL;rdigqapstks
fy,,dtqVjgrsgSA u,lfEefyrgq,gSAviusLof.kZebfrgkldsckjsesa
,u-,Q-ih-bZ-usljdkjvkSjvQlj'kkghdsdbZ ckrdjsavkSjcrk,adhLVkQleL;kvksaijdksbZle>kSrk
izgkjksadkslgudjrsgq,vkxsdnec<+k;kgSD;ksafdbldh ughagksxkAgekjsiqjkuslkfFk;ksadsikltk,satksigys
tM+ksesa,drkgSao;glksple>djfu.kZ;ysrhgSAblus fdlhdkj.ko'kgelsvyxgksx,Fks]mUgsaokilyk,a
viusvknksyuksalsdbZ,slsfu.kZ;ksadkfojks/kfd;ktks muds csgrj Hkfo"; ds fy,A pfy, ge viuh rkdr
pqukodsnkSjkufdlhO;fDrxrQk;nsdsfy,fd,tkjgs c<+krsgSavkSjviusla?k"kZdsiFkijvxzljgksrsgSaA
gksvkSjcknesa,u-,Q-ih-bZ-dksghijs'kkudjldsA vxjizR;sdlnL;dksblhizdkjlsljkgktk,rks;g
,u-,Q-ih-bZ-deZpkjhJs.khdh,dek=klaLFkkgS fuf'pr :i ls gj ,d dk;Z laHko gSA
tksHkkr`Roesafo'oklj[krhgSA;gviuslHkhfu.kZ;[kqys laxfBrjfg,]laxfBrjfg,
fodYiksadksysdjoiwjhrjglksple>djdjrhgSAbldk vkSjlaxfBrjfg,
y{;ges'kklxaBudh,drkjgkgSaljdkjhfoHkkxdsfy, ,u-,Q-ih-bZ-lsekU;rkizkIrAIPEUxzqi‘C’
gekjhuhfr;kaurksMjokyhjghgSavkSjughmudsfgresa dslnL;gkusijxkSjkfUorjfg,A
lkspusdsfy,];gges'kkeqíksadhizo`frijfuHkZjdjrkgSA
deZpkfj;ksaolnL;ksaesadwV&dwVdjHkjhlH;rk]
vkRefo'okl]Hkkr`Ro]la?k"kZdhHkkoukvkfn,u-,Q-ih-bZ-

BHARTIYA POST 31 JUNE, 2009


NOTES OF THE MONTH
v Federal Secretariat of NFPE has met on decided to accept the invitation and depute the
25th May 2009 in the Office of the AIPEU Group 'C' at Secretary General to the above International
Dada Ghosh Bhawan under the chairmanship of Conference.
Comrade Ishwar Singh Dabas Deputy Secretary v Delhi GPO Biennial Conference was held on
General NFPE. The Secretariat reviewed the 17.04.09 under the presidentship of Com. Balwan
undergoing process of fresh re-verification and decided Singh. General Secretary attended the Conference and
to make an effort to at least increase the membership inaugurated. The other prominent speakers were Com.
of all NFPE Unions by 10 to 15%. The Secretariat Balwinder Singh, Financial Secretary and Com. Aishwir
also decided to depute office bearers of NFPE and Singh, Circle Secretary. Com. Balwan Singh, Com.
the General Secretaries of Affiliated Unions to S.K. Vashishtha, Com. Pancham Singh were
whichever circle that feels the need to organize any unanimously elected as Divisional President, Secretary
meetings in connection with the Membership & Financial Secretary respectively. The CHQ
Campaign. The Secretariat also decided that there shall congratulates the newly elected office bearers.
be no denial of membership to any employee due to v The CHQ convened all Divisional Secretary's
intra-union rivalry etc at any place and to view the meeting of Haryana Circle at CHQ on 14.04.2009. All
complaints in this regard very seriously by the attended and decided to hold the Circle Conference at
respective All India Union. Hissar on 09.05.09. Com. Subhash Sharma, Ex-Circle
v UNI Apro (Union Network International - Asia Secretary contributed more for the successful meeting
Pacific Regional Organisation) has extended invitation of unifying all the forces of Haryana Circle.
to NFPE to depute a representative to the four days v General Secretary & Financial Secretary
International Seminars on Posts and Logistics to be attended the All Secretaries meeting of Punjab Circle
held in Bangkok (Thailand) from 8th June to 11th June at Ludhiana on 26.04.09. Very purposeful meeting. It
2009. The international Seminars to be participated was decided to hold the Circle conference of Punjab
by leaders of Trade Unions belonging to major Postal Circle on 24.05.09 at Amritsar. A real unity was emerged
Players in the Asia Pacific Region would be highly for the benefits of Punjab Circle.
educative and interactive. The Federal Secretariat
v The Circle Council of Delhi Circle was held on
considered the invitation and decided to depute
28.04.09 at New Delhi GPO. General Secretary
Comrade K. V. Sridharan, General Secretary AIPEU
attended the Circle council and had an interaction with
Group 'C' as the representative of NFPE to the
all divisional Secretaries. The main focus was given in
International Seminar.
the Circle council for enrolling more membership in
v UNI Apro is organizing the Posts & Logistics the current verification.
Conference of its member organizations in the Asia
v As decided earlier, the Circle conference of
Pacific Region in Jakarta (Indonesia) from 25th July to
Haryana Circle was conducted at Hissar on 09.05.09
29th July 2009 and has extended the invitation to the
and the office bearers were elected unanimously. Com.
Secretary General NFPE to participate in the
Balwinder Singh, Financial Secretary, CHQ and Com.
Conference. The membership of NFPE in the UNI Apro
Subhash Sharma, Ex-Treasurer CHQ and Ex- Circle
is under process and the Application for membership
Secretary Haryana Circle assisted the General
is being sent to the UNI in the proforma sent to us by
Secretary for the smooth conduct of the conference.
the UNI. The Federal Secretariat has decided to remit
The list of office bearers elected unanimously is printed
membership to the extent of 35000 and increase it to
inside this journal. The CHQ congratulates the newly
our full level in due course.
elected office bearers.
v TUI (Trade Union International) is holding its
v Divisional/Branch Secretaries meeting of
International Conference of all Government Sector and
Tamilnadu Circle was organized by the Circle Union,
Financial Sector organisations of PSUs in Bracilia,
Tamilnadu Circle on 11.05.09 at Chennai com. K.
Capital City of Brazil (South America) from 28th to
Ragavendran, Secretary General NFPE and Com. K.
29th June 2009. The confederation of CG Employees
V. Sridharan, General Secretary attended the special
is a member affiliate of TUI and is offered two delegates
meeting and discussed about the problems confronting
to attend the above Conference. The Confederation
the Group 'C' comrades. Com. J. Ramamoorthy, Circle
delegation will consist of Comrades K. K. N. Kutty
Secretary deserves all appreciations for organizing
(Secretary General) and K. Ragavendran (Secretary
such a good meeting for interaction with the leadership
General NFPE). The Federal Secretariat of NFPE has
of NFPE/CHQ directly to the grass root level leaders.
BHARTIYA POST 32 JUNE, 2009
eghusdslekpkj
,u-,Q-ih-bZdsdsUnzh;inkf/kdkjh 25ebZdks,- tujylSØsVjhds}kjkmn~?kkVufd;kx;kAvf/kos'kuesa
vkbZ-ih-bZ-;w-xzqi^lh*dsdk;kZy;esadk-bZ'ojflagMckl izeq[koDrkvksaesadk-cyfoUnzflag]foÙklfpo]dk-,s'kohj
fMIVhlSØsVjhtujy,u-,Q-ih-bZdsusr`Roesa,df=krgq,A flag lfdZy lSØsVjh FksA dk- cyoku flag] dk- ,l- ds-
dsUnzh;inkf/kdkfj;ksausfj&oSfjfQds'kudslEcU/kesappkZ of'k"B o dk- iUpe flag vkfn fMfotuy v/;{k] lfpo ,oa
dhvkSj,u-,Q-ih-bZlstqM+hlHkh;wfu;uksalseSEcjoSjhfQds'ku foÙklfpopqusx,Alh-,p-D;wu,inkf/kdkfj;ksadksgkfnZd
esa10ls15izfr'krc<+ksrjhdsfy,iz;kldjusdsfy,dgkA c/kkbZnsrkgSA
,u-,Q-ih-bZ-uslHkh;wfu;udstujylSØsVjhdksdgkfd dsUnzh;eq[;ky;}kjkgfj;k.kkizns'kdslHkh
tksHkhldZyvius{ks=kesaoSjhfQds'kulslEcU/khehfVax fMfotuy lSØsVjh dh ,d cSBd dk vk;kstu fnukad 14-4-
j[kuk pkgrk gS mudh lgk;rk ds fy, ,u-,Q-ih-bZ- ds 2009dksfd;kAftlesalHkhinkf/kdkfj;ksausHkkxfy;k,oa
dsUnzh;inkf/kdkjhfu;qDrfd;stk,sxsaAinkkf/kdkfj;ksaus 9-5-2009dksfglkjesajkT;Lrjh;vf/kos'kuesaHkkxysusds
;gHkhQSlykfy;kgSfd;fndksbZlnL;rkdkfojks/khgS fy,vkàkufd;kftlesadk-lqHkk"k'kekZ]iwoZlfdZylSØsVjh
;kfdlhdksdksbZf'kdk;rgSrksmldks lEcfU/kr;wfu;u usHkkxfy;kvkSjgfj;k.kkizsn'kdhleLr'kfDrvksadks
}kjkxaHkfjrklsfy;ktk;sxkA ,dtqV gksdj vf/kos'ku dks lQy cukus ds fy, dgkA
;wfu;u usVodZ baVjuS'kuy& ,sf'k;k isflfQd fjtuy egklfpo,oafoÙklfpousyqf/k;kukesafnukad26-
vkWxsZukbts'ku}kjk,u-,Q-ih-bZdsvUrZjk"Vªh;Mkdo 4-2009dksizkardslHkhe.MylfpoksadhlHkkesaHkkxfy;kA
yksftLVhdijvk;ksftr,dlsehukjesaHkkxysusdsfy, lHkkvfrmís';iw.kZFkhAftlesaiatkcizkafr;vf/kos'ku
fueU=k.k fn;k gSA lsfeukj8 ls 11 twu2009 dks cSadkd fnukad24-5-2009 dksve`rlkjesadjusdkQSlykfy;kx;kA
¼FkkbZyS.M½esagksxkAvUrZjk"Vªh;lsehukjesa,sf'k;kjhtuds blesaokLrfod'kfDrmHkjdjlkeusvk;htksfdiatkcds
;wfu;udslHkhusrkHkkxysaxsAtksfdlHkhMkdlslEcU/ fy,ykHknk;hgSA
kj[krsgSaA;glsehukjMkdlEcU/kh,oavkdZ"kdgksxkA fnYyhlfdZydhdk;Zdkfj.khdhcSBdfnukad28-
,u-,Q-ih-bZ-dsdsUnzh;inkf/kdkfj;ksausdke-ds-oh-Jh/ 4-2009 dksubZfnYyh th-ih-vks-esadhxbZAtujylSØsVjh
kju tujy lSØsVjh] ih&3 dks ,u-,Q-ih-bZ- dh rjQ ls uscBSdesaHkkxfy;kolHkhfMfotuylfFk;ksadkslEcksf/
lsehukjesaizfrfuf/kRodjusdsfy,pqukgSA krfd;kAcSBdesaubZoSjhfQds'kuesavf/kdlsvf/kd
;w-,u-vkbZ- ds ,sf'k;k jhtu dh ,d dkUÝSUl lnL;ksadksHkkxysusdsfy,tksjfn;kx;kA
tdkrkZ¼bUMksusf'k;k½esa21ls29tqykbZdksgksxhftlesadsoy TkSlsfdigysQSlysdseqrkfcdgfj;k.kkifje.My
bldslnL;HkkxysldrsgSaAdkUÝSUlesaHkkxysusdsfy, dkvf/kos'kufglkjesafnukad9-5-2009 dksvk;ksftrfd;k
,u-,Q-ih-bZ-dslSØsVjhtujydksvkeaf=krfd;kx;kgSA x;kAvkSjifje.Myh;dk;Zdkfj.khdkloZlEerhlsfuokZpu
,u-,Q-ih-bZdh;w-,u-vkbZ-esalnL;rkdsfy,dk;Zizxfr fd;kx;kA dk-cyfoUnzflagfoÙklfpo]dsUnzh;dk;kZy;
ijgSA;w-,u-vkbZ-dhlnL;rkdh 35000 QhlijQSMjs'ku vkSjdk-lqHkk"k'kekZ]iwoZdks"kk/;{kdsUnzh;dk;kZy;oiwoZ
fopkjdjjghgSA ifje.Myh;lfpogfj;k.kkldZyusvf/kos'kudkslqpk:
Vh-;w-vkbZ-¼VsªM;wfu;ubUVjuS'kuy½,ddkUÝSl :ilspykusdsfy,egklfpodhlgk;rkdhAuofuokZfpr
dk vk;kstu 28 o 29 twu 2009 dks czkflyk esa dj jgh gS ifje.yh;dk;Zdkfj.khdhlwphblhvadesaizdkf'krgSA
tksfdczkthy¼lkÅFkvkÝhdk½dhjkt/kkuhgSAftlesalHkh uofuokZfprifje.yh;dk;Zdkfj.khdksdsUnzh;eq[;ky;
ljdkjhfoHkkx,ofoÙklaLFkkvksadh;wfu;uksadslaxBuHkkx gkfnZdc/kkbZnsrkgSA
ysxsaAdsUnzh;ljdkjhdeZpkjhlaxBu¼dUQSMjs'ku½Vh-;w- rfeykukMw ldZy ds e.Myh;@'kk[kk lfpoksa dh
vkbZlsekU;rkizkIrgS]dUQSMjs'kudsnksizfrfuf/k;ksadks cBSdldZyla?k}kjkfnukad11-5-2009dkspsUubZesavk;ksftr
lsehukjesaHkkxysusdsfy,vkefU=krfd;kx;kgSftlesa dhxbZAdk-ds-jk?kosUnzu]egklfpo,u-,Q-ih-bZ-odk-
dke-ds-ds-,u-dqV~Vh¼lSØsVjhtujy½vkSjdke-ds- ds-oh-Jh?kju]egklfpo]uscSBdesaHkkxfy;kr``rh;Js.kh
jk?kosUnzulSØsVjhtujy¼,u-,Q-ih-bZ-½HkkxysxsaA,u-,Q- dsdeZpkfj;ksadhToyarleL;kvksaijfopkjfoe'kZfd;kA
ih-bZusfueU=k.kdksLohdkjdjrsgq,lSØsVjhtujydks dk-ts-jkekewrhZifje.Mylfop]fo'ks"k:ilsc/kkbZdsik=k
vUrZjk"Vªh;lsehukjesaHkkxysusdsfy,euksfurfd;kA gSaftUgksausbl'kkunkjcSBddhO;oLFkkdhftlesatehuh
fnYyhth-ih-vks-dh}hokf"kZdvf/kos'ku17-4-09 Lrjdsusrkvksauslh/kk,u-,Q-ih-bZ@lh-,p-D;wdsusr`Rols
dks dk- cyoku flag dh v/;{krk esa vk;ksftr dh xbZA lh/khokrkZdhA
BHARTIYA POST 33 JUNE, 2009

Anda mungkin juga menyukai