OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
Volume I
Number
March 1964
CONTENTS
ARTICLEs
The Aesthetic Experience andE Thayer Gaston
Biological Man
.._........._....._.......
.............._- _.._...______.._.
Psychological Man _._............_....................................................
Kate Hevner Mueller
Sociological Man _...............................................................................
John H. Mueller
Special Education for the Emotionally Disturbed
Annamary Wilson
Child
NOTESANDCOMMENTS
Chamber Music-Proposed as a Therapeutic
Delight Lewis
Medium
DEPARTMENTS
The Authors
Announcements
Professional Opportunities
Association Activities
MEMBERSHIPDirectory 1963-1964
1
8
11
16
19
7
10
15
30
21
EDITOR
WILLIaM W. Sears, PH.D.
School of Music, Indiana University
Bloomington, Indiana, 47405
EDITORIAL
COMMITTEE
Charles
Athens,Ohio
LEO C. MusKATEVC
Milwaukee Co. Mental Health Center
Milwaukee, Wisconsin
BRASWELL
The Journal of Music Therapy is published quarterly (March, June, September, and
December), one volume per year, by THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR MUSIC
THERAPY, INC., a nonprofit organization, and is printed by THE ALLEN PRESS, Lawrence,
Kansas, U.S.A. The Journal of Music Therapy publishes original investigations and theoretical
papers pertaining to Music Therapy or any of the other related fields (see inside back cover
for information for contributors).
Manuscripts and all editorial correspondence should be addressed to the Editor. Changes
of address, inquires on membership, and all general correspondence should be directed to
THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR MUSIC THERAPY, INC., P.O. Box 15, Lawrence,
Kansas, U.S.A. Changes in address must reach the Central Office of NAMT by the 10th of
the month preceding publication to take effect the following month. Copies undelivered
because of address change will not be replaced; members and subscribers should notify the
Post Office that they will guarantee second-class postage for forwarding when changing
addresses.
Subscription rate: $5.00 per volume
Journal
of
VOL. 1
Music
Therapy
MARCH, 1964
THE AESTHETIC
EXPERIENCE
AND
No. 1
BIOLOGICAL
MAN*
E. THAYER GASTON
University of Kansas
NE of the most important developments
of modern science has been the inter
disciplinary
approach to problems, both ex
ploratory and research. Such a procedure is
commonplace in present-day literature, but, I
believe, not sufficiently commonplace in our
thinking. It is too easy to stay with the famil
iar, eschewing
strange orientations,
even
though such orientations may be well-estab
lished sciences. In clinging to the familiar we
deprive ourselves of adventure, new insights,
new knowledges, the thrill of added perspec
tives, and we stunt our professional growth.
To participate
in this panel, this three
pronged probing of the mystery of aesthetics,
seemed to me, as I prepared my part, an ex
citing venture. The sociological, psychological,
and biological are not a unique trio. Allport,1
in his survey of approaches to the study of
personality, lists these same three headings,
and under them, properly distributed, sixteen
other sciences or disciplines. We do, therefore,
have precedent, but if the material seems too
eclectic, bear in mind that its chief purpose is
the elicitation of an arousal state, and the
piquing of your curiosity.
Whatever can be learned of the nature of
man, and that product of his humanness which
we name music, will help us to understand
better the response of the organism called
aesthetic experience. For this purpose I have
chosen to speak of man as biological
man, a
part of the cosmos and subject to all of the
laws of nature. The enrichment of his life
will be shown to begin with sensory experi
and universal.
of
Experimental
Psychology,4
an
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
MARCH,
1964
OF
MUSlC
THERAPY
MARCH,
1964
potentials
..33
The outstanding
his individuality.36
characteristic
of man
is
REFERENCES
1. G. W. Allport,
New York:
p 397.
2. J. P. Scott, Animal Behavior. Chicago: Univer
sity of Chicago Press, 1958, p. v.
3. Theodosius Dobzhansky, Mankind Evolving. New
Haven: Yale University Press, 1962, p. 75.
4. S. S. Stevens (Ed.), Handbook of Experimental
Psychology. New York: John Wiley and
Sons, 1951, p. 991.
S. Larsen, Bibliography
of Research
5. William
Studies in Music Education, 1949-1956, Jour
nal of Research in Music Education, 5:2 (Fall),
1951, p. 150.
William James, Principles of Psychology, Vol. II.
NeW York: Dover, 1890, p. 639, 672675.
Abraham H. Maslow, Motivation and Personality.
New York: Harper and Brothers, 1954, p. 2.
D. E. Berlyne, Conflict, Arousal, and Curiosity.
New York: McGraw-Hill, 1960, p, 229.
Sigmund Koch, Psychological Science Versus
the Science-Humanism Antinomy. American
Psychologist, 16:10 (October), 1961, p. 630.
10. Morris Weitz, Problems in Aesthetics. New York:
Macmillan, 1959.
11. Susanne K. Langer (Ed.), Reflections on Art.
(Paperback) New York: Oxford University
Press, 1961, p. xii.
12. Herbert Wendt, The Road to Man. Garden City:
Doubleday, 1959, p. 8.
13. Dobzhansky, op. cit., p. 167.
14. G. G. Simpson, Biology and the Nature of Sci
ence, Science, 139:3550 (January), 1963, p.
87.
15. S. L. Washburn, Tools
JOURNAL
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
THE AUTHORS
E. THAYER GASTON, PH.D., RMT (The Aes
thetic Experience
and Biological Man)
is an
honorary life member and a past-President
of
NAMT.
One of the founding fathers, Dr. Gaston
is well known to members, having held many and
various offices. Presently he is Central Office
Consultant, Chairman of the Education Commit
tee, and Liaison Representative
to the American
Medical Association.
He is Professor of Music
Education and Director of Music Therapy, The
University of Kansas, Lawrence.
KATE HEWER MUELLER,
PH.D. (The Aes
thetic Experience
and Psychological
Man)
is
familiar to many because of her work (and with
her husband, John H. Mueller, below)
in the
psychology of music-mood
influences, discrim
MARCH,
1964
THE AESTHETIC
EXPERIENCE
KATE
PSYCHOLOGICAL
MAN
HEVNER MUELLER
Indiana University
AND
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
1964
facilitation
and resistance which determines
the degrees and qualities of behavior.
Do these new and difficult, and indeed still
tentative, theories have implications for music
therapy? Strange to say they do not directly
affect us, as we continue with our work on the
interaction of human beings with each other,
and with musical stimuli. For we are an ap
plied science, proceeding on the simple em
pirical evidence of what results our methods
produce. Behind our more superficial but use
ful operations stands the basic science which
deals with physiological causes and psycholog
ical explanations.
Just as we can take our
aspirin and enjoy the relief from headache
without the chemists knowledge of how the
effect is produced, we can continue to use
music to relieve symptoms
and improve the
welfare of ailing or disturbed personalities.
Indirectly, however, and in the long and
slow evolution of therapeutic practice, we
have much to gain by the constant study of
basic processes. We can plan more significant
research if we devise it to fit the modern prin
ciples and theories of how the nervous system
functions. Even more important, we can, in
fact we must, learn to interpret our successes
and our failures in the light of all that psy
chology knows about physiological structures,
human personalities, and the relation between
the two.
Hebbs thesis holds that any concept is a
system of reactions centering around a core,
but with a fringe area of action which is prob
ably unverbalized, and therefore unconscious,
but which still contributes to the meaning of
the concept. Fed into this action pattern is
another continuous pattern of action, from,
let us say, a piano sonata to which we are
listening. The two patterns may synchronize
smoothly, or they may clash disastrously. Pre
vious patterns which we call habits are of
importance beyond all comprehension.
The
plot of your EEG receiving pattern for sona
ta would be different from mine in every de
tail, due to our previous disciplines. Likewise,
our organizations of the sounds that strike our
ears as we listen make two different patterns
due to our current listening habits. Your pat
tern or mine may also be smoothed or ruffled
by the blood chemistries which are the em
bodiments of our two individual
tempera
ments. And our emotions, according to Hebb,
9
different
dimensions.
Therapeutic
or experi
mental groups represent
all the hundreds
of
stages of ability in receiving,
comprehending,
and growing in musical experience.
In count
ing its successes and explaining
its failures,
music therapy, as any applied science, needs
far more support
than its basic science of
psychology
has been able to give it. Never
theless, it will always stand to profit by trying
its own methods
and theories as closely as
possible
to the fundamental
science from
which it derives.
REFERENCES
ANNOUNCEMENTS
MUSIC
THERAPY
SCHOLARSHIPS
CHANGES
STUDY
CONFERENCE-ENGLAND
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
THE AESTHETIC
EXPERIENCE
AND
SOCIOLOGICAL
MAN
JOHN H. MUELLER
IndianaUniversity
1964
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
Following
the adage that the boy who
blows a horn will never blow a safe, Mme.
Samaroff, the great pianist, erstwhile wife of
MARCH,
1964
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
REFERENCES
PROFESSIONAL
Place-State
OPPORTUNITIES
Hospital
Classification-Music
Salary-$4,428
on experience
Contact-James
C. Moore,
Music Therapy
RMT,
Director
of
Place-Dr.
Norman Beatty Memorial Hospital,
Westville, Indiana
Classification-Music
Therapist X
Salary-$405
per month, starting
Contact-Vernon
C. Brown, Director of Music
Therapy
Remarks-Male
therapist, for maximum security section of hospital
Place-Richmond
State Hospital, Richmond, In
diana
Classification-Music
Therapist
Salary-$4,260,
starting
Contact-Pauline
Marker, RMT, Director of
Music Therapy
Remarks-Must
have Bachelors degree. Hous
ing, meals, and laundry available for $25/mo.
4100
Place-Veterans
Administration
Center,
West 3rd Street, Dayton, Ohio
Classification-Music
Salary-none
specified
Contact-Dr.
Leo Rosenberg, Chief, Physical
Medicine and Rehabilitation
MARCH,
1964
Place-Mendota
State Hospital, 301 Troy Avenue,
Madison 4, Wisconsin
Classification-Music
Therapist
(male)
Salary-not
specified
Contact-Ed
Karpowicz. Director. Recreational
Therapy Department
Place-Athens
State Hospital, Athens, Ohio
Classification-Music
Therapist
Salary-based
on training and experience
Contact-Charlotte
Cox, Coordinator
of Ac
tivities Therapies
Remarks-position
begins immediately
Classification-Vocal
Music Teacher
Remarks-requires
15
SPECIAL
EDUCATION
DISTURBED
CHILD*
ANNAMARY
WILSON
Columbus State Hospital
LENWOOD
School at Columbus State
Hospital, Columbus, Ohio, is designed
for the education of emotionally
disturbed
children who are unable to function in the
public schools. This school is a division of a
day-care program for patients, known as
Hospital Community Services, which operates
primarily for those individuals who may be
in need of hospitalization.
but can remain in
the community and come to the hospital for
an intensive therapy program. About three
fourths of the children in the school are day
care patients; the other fourth are hospitalized.
At the present time the enrollment
totals 45
students with six teachers, a principal, a secre
tary, and a full-time attendant.
The school serves a dual administration:
Columbus Public Schools and Columbus State
Hospital. A general breakdown of the admin
istrative responsibilities are as follows:
1. The Columbus Public Schools provide
textbooks, teaching materials, teachers, and
teaching salaries.
2. The Columbus State Hospital provides
the school building, school equipment, jani
torial service, and psychiatric aid, i.e., med
ication, psychiatric consulation, etc.
3. Teachers are hired according to state
certification requirements with the approval
of the hospital staff.
4. Dismissal and acceptance of children
for the program are determined through
hospital and school staff recommendation.
Any outside agency can recommend the
placement of a child in this school through the
Department of Special Education of the Co
lumbus Public Schools. Upon recommenda
tion, he is screened, which is a process in
volving interview by both hospital and school
personnel. During this time he is tested for
school placement, and a psychiatric evalua
tion is made. The school does not accept chil
dren who are mentally retarded or who are
severely brain damaged; in these cases other
institutions are recommended which are de
16
curriculum
JOURNAL
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
1964
18
of effective
JOURNAL
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
NOTES AND
CHAMBER
MUSIC-PROPOSED
COMMENTS
AS A THERAPEUTIC
MEDIUM
DELIGHT LEWIS
Childrens Center, Hamden, Connecticut
The following has been written, partially,
in
response to the plea made by Dr. E. H. Schneider,
RMT, in the June, 1962 issue of the Bulletin of
NAMT.
It is hoped that this brief article may
incite some degree of interest, excitement..."1 sion
The ideas set forth are not, as yet, based on veri
fiable data and/or practices,2 but they are being
considered with that end in mind.
Chamber music sessions were held once a week
for a six-month period at the Boston State Hos
pital. Group membership varied each week, with
attendance fluctuating
between three and five.
There was usually an even patient-volunteer
ratio,
and one member of the Music Therapy Depart
ment present. A collection of assorted music
provided from private libraries of volunteers and
therapist-was
produced each week, and music
was selected to suit the instrumentalists
in at
tendance at the time. The group was basically
composed of string players, but occasional forays
into the literature for strings and wind instrument
or piano were made. No attempts at formal re
hearsal were suggested, that is, no more than
those of any small group of serious musicians play
ing together for their own enjoyment. Generally,
the activity was unstructured to the degree that
any chamber music session on the outside might
be.
The literature attempted did not vary accord
ing to the ability of the members present, as much
as it did according to the instruments they were
able to play. Sometimes the hour was devoted to
the simple-movements
of Haydn string quartets,
occasionally to Purcell pieces for two violins and
piano, or various works by Handel, Beethoven,
and DIndy.
Probably the most rewarding ses
sion was a reading of Mozarts Clarinet Quintet in
A Major, k. 581.
Music Therapy as a profession has developed to
the point that involved, inspirational
accounts of
the special moments are no longer necessary. To
anyone familiar with, and fond of, the chamber
music available to performers of any degree of
competence, a reminder of the often unexpected
flashes of genuinely satisfying musical experience
should suffice. Sometimes a phrase is actually
good; everyone is aware of, and in accord with,
everyone else. (Sometimes the triumph comes
merely from all players finishing a difficult moveMARCH,
1964
references
1. Erwin H. Scheider,
Professional Literature,
Creator of an Image, Bulletin of NAMT, 11:2
(June), 1962, p 9.
7.. Ibid
3. Dorothy T. Summer, Treating the Second Illness,
Bulletin of NAMT, 11:1 (March), 1962, p. 6.
4. Schneider, op. cit., p. 11.
JOURNAL
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
MEMBERSHIP
DIRECTORY
1963-1964
honorary life:
*Gaston, Dr. E. Thayer, 311 Bailey Hall, University
of Kansas, Lawrence, Kan.
*Harbert. Mrs. Wilhelmina K.. 125 W. Mendocino.
Stockton. Calif.
*Thompson, Mrs. Myrtle Fish, 356 Melrose Place,
South Orange, N. J.
Underwood, Dr. Roy, 17938 Schoenborn, Northridge,
LIFE:
Barone, Mrs. Anthony M., Martin Lane, Northfield,
Ill.
Black, Durel, Bon 1440, Now Orleans, La.
Brady, Miss Mildred J., 8 Warren Place, Saugerties,
N. Y.
Brahms, Mrs. Michael, 2707 W. Chase Ave., Chicago
45, Ill.
*Dick, Mrs. Alexander, 30 East 81st Street, New York
28, N. Y.
*Dierks, Mrs. Freda, 3438 Russell Blvd., St. Louis 4,
Mo.
Harris, Mrs. Joyce G., 2428 West Berwyn, Chicago
25. Ill.
Haverlin, Mr. Carl, Pres., B.M.I., 589 Fifth Ave.,
New York 17, N. Y.
Howe, Mrs. Mary, 1821 H Street, N.W., Washington
6, D. c.
1964
Iowa
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
1964
Vernon,N.
J.
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
*Moore,
MO.
Mrs. Katherine F., 3323 Mitchell Ave., St.
Joseph, MO.
Morris, Jane, Central State Hospital, 3000 West
Washington, Indinnapolis 22, Ind.
*Morrow, William D., Logansport State Hospital,
Logansport, Ind.
Moseley, Jean, P.O. Box 7.44, Audubon Station, New
York 32, N. Y.
*Mueller, Robert J., 8316 West Howard Avenue,
Milwaukee, Wis. 53220
Munn, Adoline H., 102 Mulligan Road, Athens, Ohio
*Musketevc, Mr. Leo C., 9307 W. Melvina, Milwau
kee 22, Wis.
Myers, Mrs. Cecelia M., 1285 Meadowbrook Court,
Stow, Ohio
Myran, Mr. Palmer, Box 41, Indiana State Prison,
Michigan City, Ind.
*Nagel, Christina, 809 North Spring, Independence,
Moore,
MO.
1964
Pa.
Avenue, Par
Hospital,
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
1964
1964
Station, Denton,
Tex.
29
ASSOCIATION
NEW
JOURNAL
ANNUAL
CONFERENCE
ACTIVITIES
ship participation
in symposia and discussion
groups. New concepts in music therapy, exciting
research possibilities,
and demonstrations
will
highlight the program. It will be a time for new
ideas, new learning, and a time for fun.
RESEARCH
COMMITTEE
Members of the NAMT Research Committee
are initiating a study of music therapist classifica
tions and salary ranges in various type hospitals
in the United States. The committee
also is
identifying
specific areas of needed research in
music therapy.
These research needs, with de
sign refinements, will be presented at the Annual
Conference. It is the hope of the committee that
several companion projects will develop in these
identified
areas of needed research.
Richard
Graham is providing leadership in this endeavor.
Reports of this work will be published in forth
coming issues of the Journal.
CLINICAL
PRACTICES
COMMITTEE
Geneva Folsom, chairman of the Clinical Prac
tices Committee,
and her committee members,
Barbara Romerhouse and Johanna K. Stein, are
engaged in a study of new developments
and
approaches in therapy.
The committee,
after
careful study and discussion with hospital staff
members, will indicate the importance of these
developments for music therapy. The results of
this work will lead to several reports which will
he published in the Journal, and to several sessions
at the next conference.
PUBLIC RELATIONS
COMMITTEE
Members of the Public Relations Committee
are contacting hospitals in their areas who are
not represented
on NAMT
membership
rolls.
This activity has as its purpose acquainting such
hospitals and institutions with the work of NAMT.
Dr. Donald E. Michel, committee chairman, has
also prepared reports on NAMT activities for the
use of committee members in their respective
regions.
NEW ENGLAND
REGIONAL
CHAPTER
The Fall Conference of the New England Re
gional Chapter of NAMT was held at the Howard
Johnson Motor Lodge in Hamden, Connecticut,
on November 8-9, 1963. Dr. William B. Curtis,
of the staff of the Childrens Center in Hamden,
discussed various types of atypical children and
pointed out how music could be beneficial in
their treatment programs. He stressed that while
music can be very helpful in treating the overall
problem of retardation,
care must be taken in
using music with children who have specific
organic defects.
JOURNAL
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
Mishara
CHAPTER
1964
LAKES
REGIONAL
CHAPTER
REGIONAL
CHAPTER
The Mid-Western
Regional Chapter of NAMT
presents itself as a challenging region. Being the
largest of the regions, it is difficult to communi
cate and gain the cohesiveness needed to present
a united front.
Despite this fact, significant gains have been
made in some areas. In June, 1963, the Kansas
and Colorado Civil Service Commissions both
granted new classifications for Music Therapists.
A position for a Music Therapist was provided
for Colorado State Hospital,
where none pre
viously existed. In Kansas, the Director of Psy
chiatric Music Therapy position was reclassified
as Music Therapist II, and new Music Therapist
I positions were allocated.
32
OF
MUSIC
THERAPY
INFORMATION
FOR CONTRIBUTORS
The Journal of Music Therapy publishes original investigations and theoretical papers
pertaining to Music Therapy or any of the other adjunctive or activity therapies, Psychiatry
and Psychology and their various branches, Medicine and Nursing, Special Education, or
any field in which information regarding the uses of music and musical activities are relevant
to the therapeutic processes.
Manuscripts should be submitted in duplicate, double spaced, and preferably with a
setting of forty-five (45) characters and spaces per line. Only one side of the paper should
be used. All references used or cited should be collected in a list of References at the
end of the paper. Use superscripts in the text to refer to the references.
Manuscripts to be considered for publication in a specific issue should be received by the
Editor on or before the following dates: No. I-February 1; No. 2-May 1; No. 3-August 1;
and No. 4-November 1. Receipt, however, does not guarantee publication in the specific
issue desired. Manuscripts and all editorial correspondence should be addressed to the
Editor.
OFFICERS
THE NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION
FOR MUSIC
THERAPY,
President-Elect:
INC.
LEO C. Muskatevc
Alverno College
Milwaukee,
Wisconsin
STANDING
Education:
COMMITTEES
E. THAYEr GASTON,PH.D.
PH.D.
YEARBOOKS OF NAMT
(Articles and Proceedingsof National Conferences)
$3.68
Music Therapy, 1951
Music Therapy, 1952 __~__________.______.....~~....~~....~~...~..~.........~.
$5.20
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1953
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1954
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1955
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1956
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1957
Music Therapy, 1958 _________________
-- ____._..______~_________________________~...
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1959
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1960
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1961
$5.20
Music Therapy, 1962
prices are postpaid in U.S.A. Order directly from Allen Press, Law
rence, Kansas.
Them volumes contain the most comprehensiveand reliable informa
tion about music therapy-its practice and development in this country;
research and bibliographic references. Considered essential to all prac.
ticing therapists, volunteers, and interested supporters of NAMT, and
valuable to all those who are interested in the general field of medical
and adjunctive therapies.