Anda di halaman 1dari 73

Contents

1. - CONCEPTUAL DESIGN.................................................4
1.1. Identify the location of the building...................................4
1.2. Plan View and Elevation....................................................4

2. LOAD ANALYSIS FOR A TYPICAL FRAME......................7


2.1. - Dead Load Analysis...........................................................7
2.2. - Live Load Analysis.............................................................8
2.3. - Wind Load Analysis............................................................9
2.4. - Seismic load....................................................................13

3. STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF A TYPICAL FRAME..........19


3.1. Structural Analysis for Dead Load...................................19
3.2. Structural Analysis for Live Load.....................................24
3.3. Structural Analysis for Wind Load....................................27
3.4. Structural Analysis for Seismic Load...............................31

4. LOAD COMBINATION.................................................34
4.1. Girder Moment................................................................35
4.2. Girder Shear Due To Moment Only..................................35
4.3. Column Moment..............................................................36
4.4. Column Axial Force..........................................................36
4.5. Load Combination Girder Moment...................................39
4.6. Load Combination Column Moment.................................40
4.7. Load Combination Column Axial Force............................41

5. - DESIGN OF MEMBERS...............................................42
5.1. Critical Load Acting in Members......................................42
5.1.1 - Calculus of the critical moment and axial force for the case of exterior
and interior columns from R-7 to 5-4...........................................................45

5.1.2 - Calculus of the critical moment and axial force for the case of exterior
and interior columns from 4-3 to 2-1...........................................................47

5.2. Girder Design..................................................................51


5.3. Column (Beam-Column) Design......................................54
5.4. Beam Design...................................................................70

6. STRUCTURAL DETAILS..............................................76
6.1. Connections....................................................................76
6.2. Column Splice.................................................................78
6.3. Column Base Plate..........................................................79
6.4. Interior Shear Walls.........................................................81
6.5. Composite Slab...............................................................82

7. Self Weight of the Steel Structure............................83


7.1. Weight of the Typical Frame............................................83
7.2. Weight of the Beams.......................................................84
7.3. Total Weight of the Steel Structure..................................84

8. ANSYS ANALYSIS......................................................85
8.1 Static analysis..................................................................... 85
8.1.1. Materials.................................................................................................. 85
8.1.2. Mesh......................................................................................................... 85
8.1.3. Loads........................................................................................................ 86
8.1.4. Results..................................................................................................... 86

8.2. Modal Analysis...................................................................94

Bibliography...................................................................95

1. Conceptual Design
1.1 Introduction
Design of 8 story building is required of office building located in Tucson,
Arizona. The dimensions of the building are as shown 90x120. In this report
will find in details the calculations for the design of the 8 floors and roof with
all the moments details and the choice of the member after the trial and
error based on the (live, dead, wind, seismic load).

1.2 Plan view and Elevation:


The office building be a steel structure frames of 90X120 with height of
107 which is 8 stories and a roof as shown below in the figure.

2. LOAD ANALYSIS FOR A TYPICAL FRAME


2.1. - Dead Load Analysis
The considered weights in dead load calculation are summarized in Table 2.1.
The weights are calculated based on the size of a typical frame (30 width) as
shown in Figure 2.1.

Figure 2.1 Typical frame

Table 2.1 Dead load

Type of weight
Self-weight of the
slab (4 thick slab
density=144
[p/qft])
Self-weight of the
frame
Floor finish(hard
wood)
Ceiling(Fiber Board)
Mechanical
equipment
Water proofing
Misc. weights

Floor 2-8
weight
weight [kip/ft]
[p/sqft]
48
1.44

weight
[p/sqft]
48

Roof
weight [kip/ft]
1.44

16

0.48

16

0.48

0.12

1
4

0.03
0.12

0.15

7
80

0.21
2.4

1
5
75

0.03
0.15
2.25

In Figure 2.2 is shown how the dead load is acting in the frame.

2.2. - Live Load Analysis


The minimum roof live load L R=20R1R2 based on the handout (page 10.
-Section 4.9)

1, A t 200 ft 2
R1= 1.2 0.003 A t ,200 ft 2< A t <600 ft 2
0.6, A t 600 ft 2

1, F 4 inch/ ft
R2= 1.2 0.05 F , 4 inch/ft < F< 12inch/ft
0.6, F 12 inch/ft
Where At is the roof area, in our case 90x120=1080 ft2. R1=0.6.
F is the # of inches of rise/ft. This building has a flat roof so R2=1.0.

Table 2.2 Live load

Type of weight
20 R1 R2=200.61
Minimum
distributed load
Partition wall

Floor 2-8
weight
weight [kip/ft]
[p/sqft]
50
1.5
8
58

0.24
1.74

weight
[p/sqft]
12
12

In Figure 2.3 is shown how the dead load is acting in the frame.

2.3. - Wind Load Analysis


Windward side
p=q z G C p qi GC pi =q z G C p

Roof
weight [kip/ft]
0.36
0.36

The internal pressure is neglected thus the second term is zero.


G the gust factor
Cp the pressure coefficient.
qz is the velocity pressure:
q z=0.00256 K z K zt K d v 2 I .

Kz

velocity pressure coefficient

K zt

topography coefficient

Kd

directional factor of the wind

wind speed

importance factor

The following table contains the values of the above constants according
to the handout (pg. 20.):
Table 2.3 Wind load constants (windward side)

Kz

Consta
nt
Value
z
K z =2.01
zg

see
belo
w
z=15, z< 15
z=z , z 15

K zt

Kd

0.8
5

v
[mp
h]

90

1.1
5

Cp

0.8
5

(L/B=0.
75)
0.8

( ){

According to the handout the exposure category of our building is B. In this


case =7 and zg =1200.
Using the above equations the load acting on every floor can be calculated.
AW floor # represents the calculated area under the pressure curve (see Fig 2.4).
Table 2.4 Windward side wind loads on the floors

Floor
#

AW floor #
[p/sqft]

R
8
7

123.62
159.83
153.6

Load acting
on a typical
frame
(width 30 ft)
[kip]
3.71
4.79
4.61

6
5
4
3
2

146.67
138.8
129.61
118.42
103.63

4.4
4.16
3.89
3.55
3.11

Roof
According to the handout (pg. 20.):
Since h/L1 Cp=-1.3 (0h/2). The reduction factor is 0.8 since the roof
area is larger than 1000 sqft.
Since h/L1 Cp=-0.7 (h/2L).
G=0.85 (Rigid Structure)
p=q z (h)G C p
(0h/2) the uplift is -0.542 kip/ft
(h/2L) the uplift is -0.365 Kip/ft
It is important to note that these forces acting in the roof due to wind, are
not considered in the design due that they are acting in the vertical direction
and the weight of the structure is acting in the opposite direction and it is
much bigger, thus this loads practically dont have a significant contribution
for the response.
Leeward side
According to the handout (pg. 20.):
Since L /B0.75 Cp=-0.5
G=0.85 (Rigid Structure)
p=q z (h)G C p

Table 2.5 Wind load leeward side

Floor
R
8
7
6
5
4
3
2

AL floor #
[p/sqft]
-8.68
-8.68
-8.68
-8.68
-8.68
-8.68
-8.68
-8.68

Load
[kip]
-0.26
-0.26
-0.26
-0.26
-0.26
-0.26
-0.26
-0.26

Figure 4 shows the wind loads acting on the building.

2.4 Seismic Load


The maximum considered earthquake spectral response acceleration for
short periods, SMS is calculated using the equation below.

S MS =F a S S
Ss : Short period spectral response acceleration ( S s = 0.35g in Tucson area)
According to page 35 of the handout (and the exception), the building is in
Site Class D.
Table 2.2.2.1 shown below represent values for F a. Using straight-line
interpolation, the value of Fa required for this building can be calculated.

Table 2.2.2.1

From this table, Fa is calculated using straight-line interpolation to be 1.52.


Therefore,

S MS =F a S S=1.52 0.35 g=0.532 g

Then, the design earthquake spectral response acceleration at short period,


SDS, is found using the following equation:

2
2
S DS = S MS= 0.532 g=0.355 g
3
3
According to pages 43 to 47 of the handout, the response modification factor,
R, is found to be equal to 4 since an ordinary steel moment frame is sufficient
for a 8 story building.
According to page 33, the building is in Seismic Use Group II and thus has an
Importance Factor, I, of 1.25.

Hence the nominal value for the seismic response coefficient, Cs, is:
S
0.355 g
C s= DS =
=0.111 g
R / I 4 /1.25
S1, the 1-second period spectral response acceleration, is found to be 0.1g in
the Tucson area.
The maximum considered earthquake spectral response acceleration at 1second period, SM1, is determined using the following equation:

S M 1=F v S 1
Table 2.2.2.2 shown below represents values for Fv. Using straight-line
interpolation, the value of Fv for this building can be calculated.

Table 2.2.2.2

From this table, Fv is calculated to be 2.4 .


Therefore,

S M 1=F v S 1=2.4 0.1 g=0.24 g

Then,

2
2
S D 1= S M1 = 0.24 g=0.16 g
3
3

The fundamental period of the structure, T, according to page 50 of the


handout can be determined using the following equations:

Ta < T < Cu*Ta


Ta = CT*(hn)3/4
hn (total height of the structure) = 107 ft.
CT = 0.035 for steel frame structure.

Then, Ta = 0.035*(107)3/4 = 1.16 seconds.

According to page 50 of the handout, C u = 1.48


Then, Cu*Ta = 1.723 seconds.

In order to move towards the conservative direction we consider the average


between the upper limit and the approximate value as the fundamental
period of the structure:
T=

1.16+ 1.723
=1.44 sec
2
Therefore, the upper limit value for Cs is found using the following equation:

C s=

SD1
0.16 g
=
=0.0347
R
4
T ( ) 1.44(
)
I
1.25
Finally, the lower limit value for C s is found using the following equation:

C s=0.1 S D 1 I =0.1 0.16 g 1.25=0.02 g


Therefore, the value of Cs that will be taken is Cs = 0.0347g.
To distribute the seismic forces vertically on the building, page 51 of the
handout shows the following equations:

F x =C vx V

W x hkx

C vx =

wi hik
i=1

Where

C vx : Vertical distribution factor


V : Total design lateral force or shear at the base of the structure
wi,

W x:

the portion of the total gravity load of the structure W, located

or assigned to level l or x.

hi

And

hx

the height from the base to level i or x

k : The exponent is related to the structure period.

k=

1 if T 0.5 s
2if T 2.5 s
1 2 if 0.5 s <T <2.5 s

Since T = 1.44 s, k = 1.47.


Table 2.2.2.3 shown below represents the Seismic Load calculations.
Figure 2.2.2.1 shows how the lateral seismic loads act on a typical interior
frame.

wx

hx

w x hx

C vx

Fx

Pi

[ ]

[kip]

[ft ]

[kipft]

[kip]

[kip]

894.24

104

825074.4

0.247767 62.228

904.32

92

696771.3

0.209238 52.55124 10.51025

904.32

80

567367.5

0.170378 42.79147 8.558293

904.32

68

446797

0.134171 33.69791 6.739583

904.32

56

335860.2

0.100857 25.33094 5.066188

904.32

44

235612.1

0.070753 17.77012 3.554024

904.32

32

147534.2

0.044304 11.12719 2.225437

917.76

20

75031.43

0.022532 5.658952 1.13179

7237.92

Floor

3330048

12.4456

Table 2.2.2.6 Seismic load

V = Cs*W = 0.0347*7237.92 = 251.1558 kip.

In Figure 2.7 we can see how these forces are acting per level in our typical
frame.

3. STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS OF A TYPICAL FRAME


3.1. Structural Analysis for Dead Load
The moments due to gravity loads are calculated based on John T. DeWolf
method [1]. This is an approximate method used when the beam, girders and
column sections are not known and a structural analysis, it is quite important
to say that is just and approximate method and no exact values are obtained
although these values are very close to the real values which can be
computed using a computer program once the W section are obtained for the
different members of the typical frame.
We can see in Figure 3.1 how this method works and the general
assumptions in the John T. DeWolf method are mentioned next:
-

For gravity loads only we can use the Jonh T. DeWolf method.
The method is valid unless the ratio of adjacent spans approaches 2.
Points of contraflexure of beams are assumed to be at locations shown
in Figure 3.1 and the maximum moment will be at the end of beam.
Select beam sizes and determine I/L for each beam.

Figure 3.1 DeWolf method

Thus, following the method above mentioned we get the location of the
points of contraflexure for our typical frame as is show in Figure 3.2.
For this typical frame we have that L1= 30, L2= 30 and L3=30. Then doing
all the calculations showed in Figure 3.1, we got the Figure 3.2 where you can
see the points of contraflexure of the typical frame under analysis.

Figure 3.2 Location of Points Contraflexure in The Typical Frame

As we know the locations of the flexural points and the load acting in each
level we can compute the moments acting through each beam, as follows:
-

Span A-B (See Figure 3.2 to locate each span)

( 2.12 )+( 24.3) (2.1 )=55.99 kft


6.3
MB=( 2.25 )( 6.3 ) (
+ ( 24.3 ) ( 6.3 )=197.74 k ft
2 )
MA=( 2.25 ) ( 2.1 )

Span B-C

( 6.32 )+( 19.58) ( 6.3)=168.01 kft


6.3
MC=( 2.25 ) ( 6.3 ) (
+ ( 19.58 ) ( 6.3 )=168.01 k ft
2 )
MB=( 2.25 )( 6.3 )

Span C-D

( 6.32 )+( 24.3) ( 6.3)=197.74 kft


2.1
MD= ( 2.25 )( 2.1 ) (
+ ( 24.3 ) ( 2.1 )=55.99 k ft
2 )

MC=( 2.25 ) ( 6.3 )

Span E-F

( 32 )+( 24.84 )( 3 )=85.32 kft


6.3
MF=( 2.4 )( 6.3 )(
+ ( 24.84 ) ( 6.3 )=204.12 k ft
2 )
ME=( 2.4 ) ( 3 )

Span F-G

( 6.32 )+ ( 20.88) (6.3 )=179.17 k ft


6.3
MG= (2.4 ) ( 6.3 ) (
+ ( 20.88 ) ( 6.3 )=179.17 k ft
2 )
MF=( 2.4 )( 6.3 )

Span G-H

( 6.32 )+( 24.84 )( 6.3) =204.12k ft


3
MH= ( 2.4 ) ( 3 ) ( )+ ( 24.84 )( 3 ) =85.32 kft
2

MG= (2.4 ) ( 6.3 )

As our frame is a symmetric one and because the dead load acting from
level 7 to level 2 is the same, the analysis for all other spans of the typical
frame are the same as for the level 7, we can see more clearly this in Figure
3.3, on the next page.

3.2. Structural Analysis for Live Load


The structural analysis of Live Load is performed following the same
procedure as for the case of Dead Load analysis, i.e. based on DeWolf
method. Thus we proceed in the same manner making the analysis of each
span separately.
-

Span A-B (See Figure 3.2 to locate each span)

( 2.12 )+( 3.89) ( 2.1)=8.96 k ft


6.3
MB=( 0.36 ) ( 6.3 ) (
+ ( 3.89 ) ( 6.3 )=31.65 k ft
2 )
MA=( 0.36 )( 2.1 )

Span B-C

( 6.32 )+( 3.13) ( 6.3)=26.86 kft


6.3
MC=( 0.36 )( 6.3 ) (
+ (3.13 )( 6.3 ) =26.86 kft
2 )
MB=( 0.36 ) ( 6.3 )

Span C-D

( 6.32 )+ (3.89 )( 6.3) =31.65 kft


2.1
MD= ( 0.36 ) ( 2.1 )(
+ (3.89 )( 2.1 )=8.96 kft
2 )

MC=( 0.36 )( 6.3 )

Span E-F

( 32 )+( 18.01 ) ( 3)=61.86 k ft


6.3
MF=( 1.74 )( 6.3 ) (
+ ( 18.01 )( 6.3 ) =147.99 kft
2 )
ME=( 1.74 ) ( 3 )

Span F-G

( 6.32 )+( 15.14 ) ( 6.3)=129.91 k ft


6.3
MF=( 1.74 )( 6.3 ) (
+ ( 15.14 ) ( 6.3 )=129.91 kft
2 )

MG= (1.74 ) ( 6.3 )

Span G-H

MG= (1.74 ) ( 6.3 )

( 6.32 )+( 18.01)( 6.3 )=147.99 kft

MH= (1.74 ) ( 3 )

( 32 )+( 18.01)( 3 )=61.86 k ft

Thus, from level 7 to 2 we have the same live load acting and the same
dimensions for the spans, so the calculation should be the same and are
more clearly showed in Figure 3.4.

3.3. Structural Analysis for Wind Load


The moments due to lateral, loads in the typical frame, are calculated based on the
approximate technique Portal Method. This method has three principal
assumptions:
1
2
3

Points of contra-flexure are at the mid-span of all Girders.


Points of contra-flexure are at the mid-height of all columns.
Shear taken by interior columns will be twice of that of exterior columns.

Figure 3.5 shows us more clearly the above discussed.

Figure 3.5 Portal Method

The above assumptions convert the indeterminate multi-story frame to a


determinate structure. The steps involved in the analysis of the frame are detailed
below:
1
2
3

The horizontal shears on each level are distributed between the columns of
that floor according to assumption (3).
The moment in each column is equal to the column shear multiplied by half
the column height according to assumption (2).
The girder moments are determined by applying moment equilibrium
equation to the joints: by noting that the sum of the girder moments at any

4
5

joint equals the sum of the column moments at that joint. These calculations
are easily made by starting at the upper left joint and working joint by joint
across to the right end.
The shear in each girder is equal to its moment divided by half the girder
length. This is according to assumption (1).
Finally, the column axial forces are determined by summing up the beam
shears and other axial forces at each joint. These calculations again are easily
made by working from left to right and from the top floor down.

Thus, the analysis is limited just to obtain the horizontal shear acting in each floor
and then perform the corresponding static analysis to obtain the shears and
moments acting in the girders and columns, just making equilibrium in each point. A
spreadsheet in Excel 2010 program was developed to compute all this variables
(Attached in a CD at the end of the project). Next the shear by level is obtained and
we show some images about how does it works.
Next the Wind Load Analysis is developed, we should not forget that we start the
analysis from top to bottom and that as we are advancing from level to level the
corresponding horizontal shear H will be bigger, i.e. the level 2 will have the
biggest value of H with respect to the others floors, we can see more in detail this
in Figure 3.9 which show us the moment diagrams for the case of Wind Load.
-

Roof Level

For the roof level we have a lateral force acting PR=3.97k, thus we have that:
PR=H+2H+2H+H

PR=6H

H=PR/6=3.97/6=0.66k

In Figure 3.6 we can see more in detail the corresponding structural analysis for this
level.
-

8th Level

For the 8th level we have a lateral force acting of P8=9.02, thus we have that:
P8=H+2H+2H+H

P8=6H

H=P8/6=9.02/6=1.5k

From level 7th to 3rd the same calculations were performed due that these levels are
completely symmetric and thus a same procedure is followed. Thus we just show
the corresponding horizontal shear for each one of these levels.
-

Level 7th

P7=H+2H+2H+H

H=P7/6=13.89/6=2.315k

P6=6H

H=P6/6=18.55/6=3.09k

Level 6th

P6=H+2H+2H+H
-

P7=6H

Level 5th

P5=H+2H+2H+H
-

P4=6H

H=P4/6=27.12/6=4.52k

P3=6H

H=P3/6=30.93/6=5.155k

P2=6H

H=P2/6=34.3/6=5.72k

Level 3rd

P3=H+2H+2H+H
-

H=P5/6=22.97/6=3.83k

Level 4th

P4=H+2H+2H+H
-

P5=6H

Level 2nd

P2=H+2H+2H+H

Then the moments are calculated by finding the shear force in the column and
beam. The results are shown in the table below:

In Figure 3.8 we can see the structural analysis for this level.

Figure 3.8 Structural Analysis for 2nd Level Wind Load Case

Until this point we have computed the moments in girders and columns for the Wind
Load case, now we show this values schematically in Figure 3.9 in a more
compressively manner.

Structural Analysis for Seismic Load

For the case of seismic load the same procedure that for wind load is used (Portal
Method), thus the shear and moments are computed for each level following the
same steps and the analysis is performed from top to bottom of the typical frame.
-

Roof Level

For the roof level we have a lateral force acting PR=12.45k (Check Table 2.10), thus
we have that:
PR=H+2H+2H+H
-

PR=6H

H=PR/6=12.45/6=2.07k

8th Level

We have that for the 8th level a lateral load P8=22.95k is acting, thus the
corresponding horizontal shear H can be computed as follows:
P8=H+2H+2H+H

P8=6H

H=P8/6=22.95/6=3.83k

The same procedure is developed for levels 7 th to 3rd due to the size of girders and
columns are identical, i.e. our typical frame is completely symmetric.
-

Level 7th

P7=H+2H+2H+H
-

P5=6H

H=P5/6=43.32/6=7.22k

P4=6H

H=P4/6=46.87/6=7.81k

P3=6H

H=P3/6=49.1/6=8.18k

P2=6H

H=P2/6=50.23/6=8.37k

Level 3rd

P3=H+2H+2H+H
-

H=P6/6=38.25/6=6.38k

Level 4th

P4=H+2H+2H+H
-

P6=6H

Level 5th

P5=H+2H+2H+H
-

H=P7/6=31.51/6=5.25k

Level 6th

P6=H+2H+2H+H
-

P7=6H

Level 2nd

P2=H+2H+2H+H

Then the moments are calculated by finding the shear force in the column and
beam. The results are shown in the table below:

Figure 3.12 clearly explain such an analysis.

Figure 3.12 Structural Analysis for 2nd Level Seismic Load Case

Up to this point of the calculation we have all the moments acting in columns and
girders, thus for a better understanding we show it schematically in Figure 3.13.

4. LOAD COMBINATION
Based on AISC Specification sections B3.3 and B3.4 [2], the required strength (P u,
Mu, Vu, etc. for LRFD) is determined for the appropriate load magnitudes, load
factors and load combinations given in the applicable building code. These are
usually based on ASCE/SEI 7 [3], which may be used when there is no applicable
building code. The common loads found in the building structures are:
1
2

D = Dead Load
L = Live Load due to Occupancy

3
4
5
6
7

Lr = Roof Live Load


S = Snow
R = Nominal Load due to initial Rainwater or ice exclusive of the ponding of
contribution
W = Wind Load
E = Earthquake Load

For Load and Resistance Factor Design (LRFD), structures, components and
foundations shall be designed so that their design strength equals or exceeds the
effects of the factored loads in the following combinations:
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

1.4D
1.2D
1.2D
1.2D
1.2D
0.9D
0.9D

+
+
+
+
+
+

1.6L +0.5(Lr or S or R)
1.6(Lr or S or R) + (L or 0.5W)
1.0W + L + 0.5(Lr or S or R)
1.0E + L + 0.2S
1.0W
1.0E

There is an exception which can be taken into account: the load factor on L in
combinations 3, 4, and 5 is permitted to equal 0.5 for all occupancies in which L is
less than or equal to 100 psf, with exception of garages or areas occupied as places
of public assembly. For this project this exception will be taken into account due that
this is an office building and the maximum Live Load L is equal to 58 psf, thus the
factor L shall be changed by 0.5L in load combinations 3, 4, and 5.
Due that load combination 6 and 7 never will control in this design can be omitted
and just take into account the effects of load combinations 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5. Also,
due that Tucson, AZ is not a zone very affected by the snow S and the rain R, these
two factors will be omitted for effects of the design. Thus, the load combinations for
the design of this Office Building will be:
1
2
3
4
5

1.4D
1.2D
1.2D
1.2D
1.2D

+
+
+
+

1.6L +0.5Lr
1.6Lr + (0.5L or 0.5W)
1.0W + 0.5L + 0.5Lr
1.0E + 0.5L

4.1. Girder Moment


From the moment diagrams showed in the section 3 of this project, the maximum
moment (k-ft) due to Dead Load D, Live Load L, Live Load on Roof L r, Wind
Load W and Earthquake Load E, are taken and showed more in detail in Table
4.1, for exterior and interior girders respectively.
Table 4.1. Girder Moment (k-ft)
Floo
r

EXTERIOR GIRDERS
D

LR

197.7
4

31.6
5

204.1
2

INTERIOR GIRDERS

LR

3.97

12.45

168.0
1

26.8
6

3.97

12.45

147.9
9

12.9
9

35.4

179.1
7

129.9
1

12.9
9

35.4

204.1
2

147.9
9

22.9
1

54.47

179.1
7

129.9
1

22.9
1

54.47

204.1
2

147.9
9

32.4
4

69.77

179.1
7

129.9
1

32.4
4

69.77

204.1
2

147.9
9

41.5
2

81.57

179.1
7

129.9
1

41.5
2

81.57

204.1
2

147.9
9

50.0
9

90.19

179.1
7

129.9
1

50.0
9

90.19

204.1
2

147.9
9

58.0
5

95.97

179.1
7

129.9
1

58.0
5

95.97

204.1
2

147.9
9

88.1

132.8 179.1
2 7

129.9
1

88.1

132.8
2

4.2. Girder Shear Due To Moment Only


When the frame is subjected to gravity load and lateral loads there is a shear force
generated due to the moment caused by these two types of actions in the structure
and which contribute a lot in the design of the structure, thus it force should not be
ignored by the designer (In a lot of structural projects these loads are completely
ignored). As we can see in the Table 4.2, this shear is not acting in any interior
girder subjected to gravity load (D, Lr and L). Also, In Figure 4.1 we can
schematically clarify how this force acts in the member.

Figure 4.1 Girder Shear Due to Moment Only: a). Gravity load Case, b). Lateral Load Case

Table 4.2. Girder Shear due to Moment Only (k)


EXTERIOR GIRDERS

Floor

LR

INTERIOR GIRDERS

LR

4.725

0.76

0.265

0.830

0.265

0.830

3.96

2.87

0.866

2.360

0.866

2.360

3.96

2.87

1.527

3.631

1.527

3.631

3.96

2.87

2.163

4.651

2.163

4.651

3.96

2.87

2.768

5.438

2.768

5.438

3.96

2.87

3.339

6.013

3.339

6.013

3.96

2.87

3.870

6.398

3.870

6.398

3.96

2.87

5.873

8.855

5.873

8.855

4.3. Column Moment


Based on the moment diagrams showed in section 3 of this project, the maximum
moments acting were taken for the exterior and interior columns respectively, the
values are showed in Table 4.3.
Table 4.3. Column Moments (k-ft)
Floo
r

EXTERIOR COLUMNS
D

LR

INTERIOR COLUMNS
E

LR

R-8

55.99

8.96

3.97

12.45

29.73

4.79

7.94 24.89

8-7

42.66

30.93

9.02

22.96

24.95

9.04

18.04 45.91

7-6

42.66

30.93

13.89

31.51

24.95

9.04

27.78 63.03

6-5

42.66

30.93

18.55

38.25

24.95

9.04

37.1 76.51

5-4

42.66

30.93

22.97

43.32

24.95

9.04

45.94 86.64

4-3

42.66

30.93

27.12

46.87

24.95

9.04

54.24 93.75

3-2

42.66

30.93

30.93

49.1

24.95

9.04

61.86 98.20

30.93

57.17

83.72

9.04

114.3 167.4
3
4

2-1

42.66

24.95

4.4. Column Axial Force


The axial force acting in each column, exterior and interior respectively, for each
floor is showed in Table 4.4, these values are obtained taking into account the axial
load caused by the gravity and lateral load respectively. Is logical to think that as we
are descending in floor level the axial force will be increasing, it is also showed in
Table 4.4. And Figure 4.2 show us the tributary area for interior and exterior girders
respectively.

Figure 4.2 Tributary area for interior and exterior column cases.

In Table 4.4 WT represents the weight supported for each column and is
calculated as follows:
Weight due to Dead Load (D) in Exterior Columns Roof Case (R-8)
(30ft)(15ft)(75psf) + (30ft)(3ft)(10psf)= 34.65 Kip
Weight due to Dead Load (D) in Exterior Columns 8th to 2nd floor case (8-7 to 2-1)

(30ft)(15ft)(80psf) + (30ft)(12ft)(10psf)= 39.6 kip


Weight due to Dead Load (D) in Interior Columns Roof Case (R-8)
(30ft)(30ft)(75psf)= 67.5 Kip
Weight due to Dead Load (D) in Interior Columns 8th to 2nd floor case (8-7 to 2-1)
(30ft)(30ft)(80psf)= 72 kip
Weight due to Live Load (L) in Exterior Columns Roof Case (R-8)
(30ft)(15ft)(12psf)= 5.4 Kip
Weight due to Live Load (L) in Exterior Columns 8th to 2nd floor case (8-7 to 2-1)
(30ft)(15ft)(58psf)= 26.1 kip
Weight due to Live Load (L) in Interior Columns Roof Case (R-8)
(30ft)(30ft)(12psf)= 10.8 Kip
Weight due to Live Load (L) in Interior Columns 8th to 2nd floor case (8-7 to 2-1)
(30ft)(30ft)(58psf)= 52.2 kip
Table 4.4. Column Axial Force (k)
EXTERIOR COLUMNS
D

LR

Fl
oo
r

WT

GS

TOTA
L

W
T

G
S

TOT
AL

W
T

G
S

TOT
AL

W
T

GS

TOT
AL

W
T

GS

R8

34.
65

4.7
25

39.3
75

5.
4

0.
76

6.1
6

0.2
65

0.26
5

0.8
30

0.83

87

39.
6

3.9
6

82.9
35

6.1
6

26
.1

2.
87

28.9
7

0.8
66

1.13
1

2.3
60

3.19

76

39.
6

3.9
6

126.
495

6.1
6

26
.1

2.
87

28.9
7

1.5
27

2.65
8

3.6
31

6.82
1

65

39.
6

3.9
6

170.
055

6.1
6

26
.1

2.
87

57.9
4

2.1
63

4.82
1

4.6
51

11.4
72

54

39.
6

3.9
6

213.
615

6.1
6

26
.1

2.
87

86.9
1

2.7
68

7.58
9

5.4
38

16.9
1

43

39.
6

3.9
6

257.
175

6.1
6

26
.1

2.
87

115.
88

3.3
39

10.9
28

6.0
13

22.9
23

32

39.
6

3.9
6

300.
735

6.1
6

26
.1

2.
87

144.
85

3.8
70

14.7
98

6.3
98

29.3
21

TOT
AL

21

39.
6

3.9
6

344.
295

6.1
6

26
.1

2.
87

173.
82

5.8
73

20.6
71

8.8
55

38.1
76

INTERIOR COLUMNS
D

Fl
oo
r

WT

GS

R8

67.
5

87

72

76

72

65

LR

TOTA
L

W
T

G
S

TOT
AL

W
T

G
S

TOT
AL

67.5

10
.8

10.
8

139.
5

10.
8

52
.2

52.
2

211.
5

10.
8

52
.2

104
.4

72

283.
5

10.
8

52
.2

54

72

355.
5

10.
8

52
.2

43

72

427.
5

10.
8

52
.2

32

72

499.
5

10.
8

52
.2

21

72

571.
5

10.
8

52
.2

W
T

GS

TOT
AL

W
T

GS

0.2
65

0.26
5

0.8
30

0.83

0.8
66

1.13
1

2.3
60

3.19

1.5
27

2.65
8

3.6
31

6.82
1

156
.6

2.1
63

4.82
1

4.6
51

11.4
72

208
.8

2.7
68

7.58
9

5.4
38

16.9
1

3.3
39

10.9
28

6.0
13

22.9
23

313
.2

3.8
70

14.7
98

6.3
98

29.3
21

365
.4

5.8
73

20.6
71

8.8
55

38.1
76

261

TOT
AL

4.5. Load Combination Girder Moment


For this section and sections 4.6 and 4.7, as was mentioned in the beginning of
section 4, just the load combinations 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 are taken into account for the
design. The results for load combination girder moment are clearly shown in Table
4.5, for exterior and interior girders respectively. These moments are obtained
making the load combination of those moments obtained in Table 4.1.

Table 4.5. Load Combination Girder Moment (k-ft)


EXTERIOR GIRDERS
Flo
or

1.4D

276.8

1.2D+1.6L+
0.5LR
253.113

1.2D+1.6LR+(0.5L
or 0.5W)
289.913

1.2D+1.0W+0.5L
+0.5LR
257.083

1.2D+1.0E
+0.5L
249.738

36
8

285.7
68

481.728

318.939

331.929

354.339

285.7
68

481.728

318.939

341.849

373.409

285.7
68

481.728

318.939

351.379

388.709

285.7
68

481.728

318.939

360.459

400.509

285.7
68

481.728

318.939

369.029

409.129

285.7
68

481.728

318.939

376.989

414.909

285.7
68

481.728

318.939

407.039

451.759

INTERIOR GIRDERS
Flo
or

1.4D

1.2D+1.6L+
0.5LR

1.2D+1.6LR+(0.5L
or 0.5W)

1.2D+1.0W+0.5L
+0.5LR

1.2D+1.0E
+0.5L

215.0
42

246.573

219.012

214.062

235.214

422.8
6

279.959

292.949

315.359

250.838

422.8
6

279.959

302.869

334.429

250.838

422.8
6

279.959

312.399

349.729

250.838

422.8
6

279.959

321.479

361.529

250.838

422.8
6

279.959

330.049

370.149

250.838

422.8
6

279.959

338.009

375.929

250.838

422.8
6

279.959

368.059

412.779

250.838

4.6. Load Combination Column Moment


The results for load combinations column moment are shown in Table 4.6. These
results were obtained doing the combination of the moments in Table 4.3, for each
load combination case.
Table 4.6. Load Combination Column Moment (k-ft)
EXTERIOR COLUMNS
Flo
or

1.4D

1.2D+1.6L+
0.5LR

R-8

78.38
6

78.02

8-7

59.72
4

7-6

1.2D+1.6LR+(0.5L
or 0.5W)

1.2D+1.0W+0.5L
+0.5LR

1.2D+1.0E+
0.5L

81.524

75.638

79.638

100.68

66.657

75.677

89.617

59.72
4

100.68

66.657

80.547

98.167

6-5

59.72
4

100.68

66.657

85.207

104.907

5-4

59.72
4

100.68

66.657

89.627

109.977

4-3

59.72
4

100.68

66.657

93.777

113.527

3-2

59.72
4

100.68

66.657

97.587

115.757

2-1

59.72
4

100.68

79.777

123.827

150.377

1.2D+1.0W+0.5L
+0.5LR

1.2D+1.0E+
0.5L

INTERIOR COLUMNS
Flo
or

1.4D

1.2D+1.6L+
0.5LR

1.2D+1.6LR+(0.5L
or 0.5W)

R-8

41.62
2

38.071

47.31

46.011

60.566

8-7

34.93

44.404

38.96

52.5

80.37

7-6

34.93

44.404

43.83

62.24

97.49

6-5

34.93

44.404

48.49

71.56

110.97

5-4

34.93

44.404

52.91

80.4

121.1

4-3

34.93

44.404

57.06

88.7

128.21

3-2

34.93

44.404

60.87

96.32

132.66

2-1

34.93

44.404

87.105

148.79

201.9

4.7. Load Combination Column Axial Force


The axial force for each column placed in each floor was shown in Table 4.4, thus
these values were taken into account to perform the load combination column axial
force for each column exterior and interior, respectively and each level, this is
shown in Table 4.7 which is showed next.
Table 4.7. Load Combination Column Axial Force (k)
EXTERIOR COLUMNS
Flo
or

1.4D

1.2D+1.6L+
0.5LR

1.2D+1.6LR+(0.5L
or 0.5W)

1.2D+1.0W+0.5L
+0.5LR

1.2D+1.0E
+0.5L

R-8

55.12
5

50.33

57.2385

50.648

48.08

8-7

116.1
09

148.954

123.863

118.4442

117.197

7-6

177.0
93

201.226

176.135

172.5486

173.1

6-5

238.0
77

299.85

242.892

241.9012

244.508

5-4

299.0
61

398.474

309.649

311.9798

316.703

4-3

360.0
45

497.098

376.406

382.7436

389.473

3-2

421.0
29

595.722

443.163

454.1446

462.628

2-1

482.0
13

694.346

509.92

527.9492

538.24

INTERIOR COLUMNS
Flo
or

1.4D

1.2D+1.6L+
0.5LR

1.2D+1.6LR+(0.5L
or 0.5W)

1.2D+1.0W+0.5L
+0.5LR

1.2D+1.0E
+0.5L

R-8

94.5

86.4

98.4125

86.718

81.83

8-7

195.3

256.32

210.78

200.2572

196.69

7-6

296.1

426.24

323.28

314.5896

312.821

6-5

396.9

596.16

435.78

429.6852

429.972

5-4

497.7

766.08

548.28

545.5068

547.91

4-3

598.5

936

660.78

662.0136

666.423

3-2

699.3

1105.92

773.28

779.1576

785.321

2-1

800.1

1275.84

885.78

898.7052

906.676

5. - DESIGN OF MEMBERS
The design of this building is composed basically for three kind of structural (W
shapes) members: Girders, Columns and Beams. Girders are designed taking into
account the critical bending moment acting on them, for the case of Columns
design we must consider the critical axial load and bending moment, and when the
Beam design is performed the maximum moment acting along the beam due to
gravity load will control the design. Also it is important to point out that for Girders
and Beams the Shear and Deflection must be checked. All the above mentioned is
clearly explained in the next sections.

5.1. Critical Load Acting in Members


Analyzing very carefully the load combination tables presented in Section 4 we can
obtain the maximum (critical) loads acting in each member of the Typical Frame.
Also we can see that for some cases we have different values of critical bending
moment and axial force depending on the load combination, i.e. we have a lot of
changes in W shapes. But the more changes of section are needed, the more money
is required to perform such as changes, thus in this structural design of members
just two changes in column and girder sections are considered one for interior
members and the other for exterior members for columns and girders respectively,
i.e. the typical frame will be designed for 4 columns and 4 girders sections,
depending in the critical load controlling the design. This is explained next.
For the ease of these calculations Tables 4.5, 4.6 and 4.7 are placed in this section
again and also to avoid that the reader has to be back in sections to check what is
being explained.
First, from Table 4.5 Load Combination Girder Moment, we can obtain the critical
bending moment for interior and exterior girders in each level. For Exterior Girders,
in the Roof Level case the critical bending moment is 306.214 k-ft corresponding to
the third load combination and for the 7th to 2nd level cases the critical bending
moment is 512.388 k-ft corresponding to the second load combination. For Interior
Girders, in the Roof Level case we can see a critical bending moment of 260.45 k-ft,
for the 7th to 3nd Level cases the critical bending moment is 449.74 k-ft and for the
2nd Level case the critical bending moment is 453.199 k-ft. Thus, for exterior girders,
we will have the same W section for the 7 th to 2nd Level cases and for the Roof Level
case a different section will be obtained, i.e. we have two girders sections. The

same thing happens for the case of interior girders. This can be checked next in
Table 4.5.

5.5. Controlling Load Combinations


The excel sheet presented with the report contains the entire LRFD Load
Combination calculations for Girder Moments, Column Moments and Column Axial
Loads.
Only the controlling moments and loads will be summarized in the tables below.
(To view the complete calculations of LRFD Load Combinations, refer to the excel
sheet.)

Floor
R
8
7
6
5
4
3
2

Floor
R
8
7
6
5
4
3
2

Floor
R
8
7
6

Exterior Column Axial


Force

57.2385
148.954
201.226
299.85
398.474
497.098
595.722
694.346
Interior Column Axial
Force

98.4125
256.32
426.24
596.16
766.08
936
1105.92
1275.84
Exterior Column
Moment

81.524
100.68
100.68
104.907

5
4
3
2

Floor
R
8
7
6
5
4
3
2

Floor
R

109.977
113.527
115.757
150.377
Interior Column
Moment

60.566
80.37
97.49
110.97
121.1
128.21
132.66
201.9
Exterior Girder
Moment

289.913
481.728
481.728
481.728
481.728
481.728
481.728
481.728

Floor

Interior Girder
Moment

8
7
6
5
4
3

R
8
7
6
5
4

246.573
422.86
422.86
422.86
422.86
422.86

3
2

422.86
422.86

5.2. Girder Design


As we can see in Figure 5.1 we have four different critical bending moments acting
in all the Girders, thus, we just need to design four members. The design of Girders
will be restricted to W21 or W24 shapes depending on the bending moment acting
and the availability of W sections to resist such a moment.
For the case of Girders we can appreciate from the plan and elevation views
(Figures 1.2 and 1.3) that all these members are laterally supported along the span
by the concrete composite slab, thus for these cases Lb=0 , consequently

Lb

L p , for this case Cb=1.0 and we are using for the W sections Steel Grade 50, thus
we can easily get the ideal W section for the girder under consideration using Table
3-10 (Page 3-99) Available Moment vs. Unbraced Length, of the Steel Construction
Manual (SCM) [2]. We just need to look for a section which

b M n Mr

entering

with Lb=0 .
Once the adequate W section is chosen, the section must be checked against Shear,
this is performed satisfying the next equation:

v0.6F yA wC v Vr
Where v = Shear Resistance Factor = 1.00; Fy = Ultimate Strength of the Member;
Aw = Area of the web; Cv = Web Shear Coefficient = 1 (for rolled I-shaped members
with h/tw 2.24

E/ Fy=53.95

), thus the above equation is reduced to the next

form, and must be satisfied for all the section beams chosen.

0.6F yA w Vr
The last parameter that must be checked before to consider a W section completely
appropriate for the design is Deflection. The deflection of the girder should be less
than or equal to the allowable deflection, the deflection must be checked out for a
simply supported beam and for a double fixed beam cases, i.e. the both of the
following equations must be satisfied.
4

For a simply supported beam upper bound ( max )=

5W L L
Span
a=
384 EI
360

W L L4
Span
For a doubly beam lower bound ( max ) =
a=
384 EI
360

Where

( max ) = Maximum deflection under live load (not from load combination);

W L = Distributed live load; L= Longitude of the span; E= Yungs Modulus; I=


Moment of inertia of the member. It is quite logical that if the equation for the
deflection of a simply supported beam is satisfied then the respective one for the
double fixed beam also must be satisfied, but always is good to check both
equations just to know what are our boundaries and where is the deflection for the
member.

Selection of the appropriate W section for the 2 nd to 8th Level Exterior Girder Cases:
We have acting a bending moment
the SCM with a value of
122). For this section

Lb=0

M r=481.73 kft

thus entering to Table 3-10 of

we found that the W24x55 is adequate (Page 3-

b M n =503 kft

thus

b M n Mr

is correctly satisfied.

Now checking Shear for the W24x55 section, we have that nominal shear strength
is:

23.6

0.395

v V n=0.60F yA w = ( 0.60 ) 50

kip

And the required shear is:

W T =W D +W L =

(80 psf )(30 ft) (58 psf )( 30 ft )


k
+
=4.14
1000
1000
ft

k
(4.14 )( 30 ft )
W L
ft
V r= T =
=62.1kip
2
2

Thus we have that

v V n V r

is clearly

satisfied.
Now checking Deflection for the W24x55 section, we have that the distributed live
load acting in the beam is

W L=

(58 psf )(30 ft )


k
=1.74
1000
ft

and the allowable deflection

is

a=

Span 30 ft
=
=0.083 ft=1 , thus checking simply supported beam deflection,
360 360

we have:

5 W L L4 5(1.74 12)(3012)4
( max )=
=
=0.82
384 EI
384290001330

( max ) a is satisfied,

Then

checking for a doubly fixed beam as follows:

( max )=

W L L4 (1.74 12)(3012) 4
=
=0.16
384 EI 384290001330

Then

( max ) a

USE W24x55 GRADE 50 STEEL


Selection of the appropriate W section for the Roof Level Exterior Girder Case:
We have acting a bending moment
the SCM with a value of
124). For this section

Lb=0

M r=289.91 k ft

thus entering to Table 3-10 of

we found that the W21x44 is adequate (Page 3-

b M n =358 kft

thus

b M n Mr

is correctly satisfied.

Now checking Shear for the W21x44 section, we have that nominal shear strength
is:

20.7

0.35

v V n=0.60F yA w = ( 0.60 ) 50

kip

And the required shear is:

W T =W D +W L =

W L
V r= T =
2

(75 psf )(30 ft) (12 psf )(30 ft )


k
+
=2.61
1000
1000
ft

( 2.61

k
)(30 ft )
ft
=39.15 kip
2

Thus we have that

v V n V r

is clearly

satisfied.
Now checking Deflection for the W21x44 section, we have that the distributed live
load acting in the beam is

W L=

(12 psf )(30 ft )


k
=0.36
1000
ft

and the allowable deflection

is

a=

Span 30 ft
=
=0.083 ft=1 , thus checking simply supported beam deflection,
360 360

we have:

5 W L L4 5(0.36 12)(3012)4
( max )=
=
=0.26
384 EI
38429000843

( max ) a is satisfied,

Then

checking for a doubly fixed beam as follows:

( max )=

W L L4 (0.36 12)(3012) 4
=
=0.05 Then
384 EI
38429000843

( max ) a

USE W21x44 GRADE 50 STEEL


Selection of the appropriate W section for the 2 nd to 8th Level Interior Girder Cases:
We have acting a bending moment
the SCM with a value of
122). For this section
satisfy

Lb=0

M r=422.86 kft

thus entering to Table 3-10 of

we found that the W21x55 is adequate (Page 3-

b M n =473 k ft (here we can see that this W section also

M r=453.199 kft ) thus

b M n Mr

is correctly satisfied.

Now checking Shear for the W21x55 section, we have that nominal shear strength
is:

20.8

0.375

v V n=0.60F yA w = ( 0.60 ) 50

kip

And the required shear is:

W T =W D +W L =

(80 psf )(30 ft) (58 psf )( 30 ft )


k
+
=4.14
1000
1000
ft

k
(4.14 )( 30 ft )
W L
ft
V r= T =
=62.1kip
2
2

Thus we have that

v V n V r

is clearly

satisfied.
Now checking Deflection for the W21x55 section, we have that the distributed live
load acting in the beam is

W L=

(58 psf )(30 ft )


k
=1.74
1000
ft

and the allowable deflection

is

a=

Span 30 ft
=
=0.083 ft=1 , thus checking simply supported beam deflection,
360 360

we have:

5 W L L4 5(1.74 12)(3012)4
( max )=
=
=0.96
384 EI
384290001140

( max ) a is satisfied,

Then

checking for a doubly fixed beam as follows:

( max )=

W L L4 (1.74 12)(3012) 4
=
=0.19 Then
384 EI 384290001140

( max ) a

USE W21x55 GRADE 50 STEEL


Selection of the appropriate W section for the Roof Level Interior Girder Case:
We have acting a bending moment
the SCM with a value of
124). For this section

Lb=0

M r=246.57 kft

thus entering to Table 3-10 of

we found that the W21x44 is adequate (Page 3-

b M n =358 kft

thus

b M n Mr

is correctly satisfied.

Now checking Shear for the W21x44 section, we have that nominal shear strength
is:

20.7

0.35

v V n=0.60F yA w = ( 0.60 ) 50

kip

And the required shear is:

W T =W D +W L =

W L
V r= T =
2

(75 psf )(30 ft) (12 psf )(30 ft )


k
+
=2.61
1000
1000
ft

( 2.61

k
)(30 ft )
ft
=39.15 kip
2

Thus we have that

v V n V r

is clearly

satisfied.
Now checking Deflection for the W21x44 section, we have that the distributed live
load acting in the beam is

W L=

(12 psf )(30 ft )


k
=0.36
1000
ft

and the allowable deflection

a=

is

Span 30 ft
=
=0.083 ft=1 , thus checking simply supported beam deflection,
360 360

we have:

5 W L L4 5(0.36 12)(3012)4
( max )=
=
=0.26
384 EI
38429000843

( max ) a is satisfied,

Then

checking for a doubly fixed beam as follows:

( max )=

W L L4 (0.36 12)(3012) 4
=
=0.05 Then
384 EI
38429000843

( max ) a

USE W21x44 GRADE 50 STEEL

5.3. Column (Beam-Column) Design


As was stated in section 5.1 for the typical frame being designed we just need to
design 4 columns sections, the change of columns section had been found to be
optimal in floor level 4 for exterior and interior columns respectively. The size of the
column sections will be restrained to W14. The design is then divided in four kinds
of columns: Exterior columns from 2-1 to 4-3, Interior columns from 2-1 to 43, Exterior columns from 5-4 to R-8, Interior columns from 5-4 to R-8, all
the calculations to obtain the optimum W14 section for each case are shown next.
Exterior Columns from 2-1 to 4-3
There is side sway in x direction but no side sway in Y direction
Step 1 Identification of Principal Parameters

K x =1.2(assumed)
K x Lx =1.220=24 ft

K y =0.8 ;

;
;

Lx =20 ft ;

L y =20 ft

Lb=20 ft

K y L y =0.820=16 ft

Step 2 Load Combination


From section 5.1 the critical values for axial force and bending moment in the
column are the following.

M rx=150.377 kft

and

Pr=694.346 k

Step 3 Column Effect

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx


so

M ltx

B 1=1.0

and

but for this case as we dont have side sway in the y direction

B 2 are equal to zero, and thus we have

M r=B1 M ntx , supposing

M r=( 1.0 )( 150.377 ) =150.377 kft

and

Pr=694.346 k

As we know that the design of columns is restrained to W14 sections and for this

Lb=20 ft , using the table of average values of p , b x and b y

case

obtain a value

we

bav =0.98 x 103 .

Now using the interaction equations for columns subjected to axial and flexure
forces, we have that:

p P r +b x M r 1.0

When pPr 0.2 ,

It is important to note that for all the design of members of the typical frame always
the condition

pPr 0.2

was satisfied, thus to save space in the calculation this

condition is not remarked.

p ( 694.346 )+(0.98 x 103)(150.377) 1.0


preq

1.0( 0.98 x 103) ( 150.3778 )


=1.23 x 103
694.346

Thus entering to Table 6-1 of the Steel Construction Manual (SCM) with a value of

K y L y =0.820=16 ft
Check W14x90 -;

for preq , we got a trial section:

K y L y =16 ft ;

Lb=20 ft

Before start the checking of W sections we have to update the

Kx

value every

time the W section is changed. In the SCM is stated that for moment resisting
frames we can obtain the K value using the alignment chart, but before use it we
also need the value of the parameter G for each union in the column, thus the value
of G can be computed as follows:

Ic

G=

joint,

Lc
Lg
Lg
Lc=

Where

Ic=

Moment of inertia of all columns which intercept at the

Longitude of all columns which intercept at the joint,

of inertia of all girders which intercept at the joint and

Lg=

Ig=

Moment

Longitude of all

girders which intercept at the joint, in Figure 5.5 we can see this more clearly.

Figure 5.5 GA and GB values.

Thus this can be done in a general manner since we know that

Lc 1=1 2 ft=1 44 ,

Lc 2=20 ft=240 ,

Ic 1=Ic 2=Ic ,

Lg 1=Lg 2=30 ft=360 ,

Ig 1=W 21 x 55=843 4 . Thus we have for GA


Ic 1 Ic2
1
1
1
1
+
Ic (
+
)
(
+
)
Lc 1 Lc 2
Lc 1 Lc 2
144 240
G A=
=
=Ic
=( 4.74 x 103 ) Ic
Ig 1
Ig 1
843
Lg 1
Lg1
360
Where

Ic

is the moment of inertia of the W section being under consideration, for

this case, and as we have a fixed constraint in B then

GB =1.0 . Now we are ready

to check the first column section.


Check W14x90
4

Ic=1240

G A =( 4.74 x 103 ) (1240 )=5.88 ;

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =1. 7520=35 ft ;

K y L y =16 ft ;

critical since rx/ry=1.66.

K x Lx
=21.08
rx /ry

p=1. 18 x 103

(w.r.t.

interaction equation:

K x Lx ),

GB =1.0 thus entering to the

K x =1.75
Lb=20 ft , KxLx/KyLy=2.19 therfore x is

b x =1.65 x 103

(w.r.t.

Lb ), checking with

( 1. 18 x 103 ) ( 694.346 )+ ( 1.65 x 103 ) ( 150.377 )=1. 07>1.0

Not good try W14x99

Check W14x99

Ic=1110 4

G A =( 4.74 x 103 ) (1110 ) =5.26 ;

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =1.720=34 ft ;

K y L y =16 ft ;

critical since rx/ry=1.66.

p=1.06 x 103 (w.r.t.

GB =1.0 thus entering to the

K x =1.7
Lb=20 ft , KxLx/KyLy=2.19 therfore x is

K x Lx
=20.48
rx /ry

K x Lx ),

b x =1.49 x 103

Lb ), checking with

(w.r.t.

interaction equation:

( 1.06 x 103 ) ( 694.346 ) +( 1.49 x 103 ) ( 150.377 ) =0.96<1.0

good use W14x99

Step 4 Beam Effect (W14x99)

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx

but we already know that

proceed to compute the value of

B 2 M ltx=0

B 1 as follows:

As there is not load between the span

Cmx =0.60.4 (

M1
)
M 2 , and we know that the

moments acting in the end of this column are equal thus


also know that

for this case, thus we

Pr=694.346 k , and to compute

Pex

Cmx =0.60.4 ( 1 )=0.2 , we

we use Table 4.1 of the SCM

in the next manner

Pex=
B1

318 00 x 10 4
=3833.91k , then putting all this values in the equation to obtain
(1. 72 012)2

B 1=

C mx
0.2
=
=0.2 4
Pr
694.346
1
1
3833.91
P ex

factor, thus for this case

But

B 1 1.0

due that is an amplification

B 1=1.0 , and computing

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx =( 1.0 ) ( 150.377 )=150.377 kft


Step 5 Beam-Column Effect (W14x99)
Checking again interaction equation with the amplified moment

( 1.06 x 103 ) ( 694.346 ) +( 1.49 x 103 ) ( 150.377 ) =0.96<1.0

OK

USE W14x99 GRADE 50 STEEL


Interior Columns from 2-1 to 4-3
There is side sway in x direction but no side sway in Y direction
Step 1 Identification of Principal Parameters

K x =1.2(assumed)

K y =0.8 ;

K x Lx =1.220=24 ft

Lx =20 ft ;

L y =20 ft

Lb=20 ft

K y L y =0.820=16 ft

Step 2 Load Combination


From section 5.1 the critical values for axial force and bending moment in the
column are the following.

M rx=201.9 kft

and

Pr=1275.84 k

Step 3 Column Effect

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx


M ltx

and

but for this case as we dont have side sway in the y axis so

B 2 are equal to zero, and thus we have

M r=B1 M ntx , supposing

B 1=1.0
M r=( 1.0 )( 201.9 )=201.9 kft

and

Pr=1275.84 k

As we know that the design of columns is restrained to W14 sections and for this
case

Lb=20 ft , using the table of average values of p , b x and b y

obtain a value

bav =0.98 x 103 .

we

Now using the interaction equations for columns subjected to axial and flexure
forces, we have that:

p (1275.84 ) +(0.98 x 103)(201.9)1.0

1.0( 0.98 x 103) ( 201.9 )


preq
=0.63 x 103
1275.84

Thus entering to Table 6-1 of the Steel Construction Manual (SCM) with a value of

K y L y =0.820=16 ft

for preq , we got a trial section W14x145.

Before start the checking of W sections we have to update the

Kx

value every

time the W section is changed. In the SCM is stated that for moment resisting
frames we can obtain the K value using the alignment chart, but before use it we
also need the value of the parameter G for each union in the column, thus the value
of G can be computed as follows:

Ic

G=

joint,

Lc
Lg
Lg
Lc=

Where

Ic=

Moment of inertia of all columns which intercept at the

Longitude of all columns which intercept at the joint,

of inertia of all girders which intercept at the joint and

Lg=

Ig=

Moment

Longitude of all

girders which intercept at the joint, in Figure 5.5 we can see this more clearly.

Figure 5.5 GA and GB values.

Thus this can be done in a general manner since we know that

Lc 1=12 ft =144 ,

Lc 2=20 ft=240 ,

Ic 1=Ic 2=Ic ,

Lg 1=Lg 2=30 ft=360 ,

Ig 1=W 21 x 55=1140 4 . Thus we have for GA

Ic 1 Ic 2
1
1
1
1
+
Ic (
+
)
(
+
)
Lc 1 Lc 2
Lc 1 Lc 2
144 240
G A=
=
=Ic
=( 1.75 x 103) Ic
Ig 1 Ig 2
Ig 1 Ig 2
1140 1140
+
+
+
Lg1 Lg2
Lg 1 Lg 2
360 360
Where

Ic

is the moment of inertia of the W section being under consideration, for

this case, and as we have a fixed constraint in B then

GB =1.0 . Now we are ready

to check the first column section.


Check W14x145

Ic=1710 4

GB =1.0 thus entering to the

G A =( 1.75 x 103 ) ( 1710 )=2.99 ;

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =1.5420=30.8 ft ;
critical since rx/ry=1.59.

K y L y =16 ft ;

K x =1.54
Lb=20 ft , KxLx/KyLy=1.925 therefore x is

K x Lx
=19.37
rx /ry

p=0.6 68 x 103 (w.r.t. ( KL ) y ),

b x =0.956 x 10

(w.r.t.

Lb ), checking with

interaction equation:

( 0.6 68 x 103 ) ( 1275.84 )+ ( 0.956 x 103 ) ( 201.9 )=1.05>1.0

not good!

Check W14x159

Ic=1900 4

G A =( 1.75 x 103 ) ( 1900 )=3.325 ;

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =1.5 620=31.2 ft ;
critical since rx/ry=1.60.

p=0.611 x 103

K y L y =16 ft ;

GB =1.0 thus entering to the

K x =1.56
Lb=20 ft , KxLx/KyLy=1.95 therefore x is

K x Lx
=19.5
rx /ry

(w.r.t. ( KL ) y ),

b x =0.956 x 10

(w.r.t.

Lb ), checking with

interaction equation:

( 0. 611 x 103 ) ( 1275.84 ) + ( 0.863 x 103 ) ( 201.9 )=0.95<1.0


Step 4 Beam Effect (W14x159)

good! Use W14x159

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx

but we already know that

proceed to compute the value of

B 2 M ltx=0

B 1 as follows:

As there is not load between the span

Cmx =0.60.4 (

M1
)
M 2 , and we know that the
Cmx =0.60.4 ( 1 )=0.2 , we

moments acting in the end of this column are equal thus


also know that

for this case, thus we

Pr=1275.84 k , and to compute

Pex

we use Table 4.1 of the SCM

in the next manner

Pex=

544 00 x 104
=3880.85 k , then putting all this values in the equation to
2
(1.562012)

obtain

B 1=

B1

C mx
0.2
=
=0.2 9
Pr
1275.84
1
1
3880.85
P ex

thus for this case

But

B 1 1.0

due that is an amplification factor,

B 1=1.0 , and computing

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx =( 1.0 ) ( 201.9 )=201.9 k ft


Step 5 Beam-Column Effect (W14x145)
Checking again interaction equation with the amplified moment

( 0.611 x 103) ( 1275.84 )+ ( 0.863 x 103 ) ( 201.9 )=0.95< 1.0

good!

USE W14x159 GRADE 50 STEEL

Exterior Columns from 7-6 to 5-4


There is side sway in x direction but no side sway in Y direction
Step 1 Identification of Principal Parameters

K x =2.0 (assumed);
K x Lx =2 .012=24 ft

K y =1.0 ;
;

Lx =12 ft ;

K y L y =1.012=12 ft

Step 2 Load Combination

L y =12 ft

Lb=12 ft

From section 5.1 the critical values for axial force and bending moment in the
column are the following.

M rx=109.977 kft

and

Pr=398.474 k

Step 3 Column Effect

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx


then

M ltx

but for this case as we dont have side sway in the column,

B 2 are equal to zero, and thus we have

and

M r=B1 M ntx , supposing

B 1=1.0
M r=( 1.0 )( 109.977 ) =109.977 kft

and

Pr=398.474 k

As we know that the design of columns is restrained to W14 sections and for this
case

Lb=12 ft , using the table of average values of p , b x and b y

obtain a value

we

bav =1.47 x 103 .

Now using the interaction equations for columns subjected to axial and flexure
forces, we have that:

p (398.474 ) +(1.47 x 103)(109.977) 1.0


1.0( 1.47 x 103 ) ( 109.977 )
preq
=2.1 x 103
398.474
Check W14x61 -

K y L y =12 ft ;

Lb=12 ft

Before start the checking of W sections we have to update the

Kx

value every

time the W section is changed. In the SCM is stated that for moment resisting
frames we can obtain the K value using the alignment chart, but before use it we
also need the value of the parameter G for each union in the column, thus the value
of G can be computed as follows:

Ic

G=

joint,

Lc
Lg
Lg
Lc=

Where

Ic=

Moment of inertia of all columns which intercept at the

Longitude of all columns which intercept at the joint,

of inertia of all girders which intercept at the joint and

Lg=

Ig=

Moment

Longitude of all

girders which intercept at the joint, in Figure 5.5 we can see this more clearly.

Figure 5.5 GA and GB values.

Thus this can be done in a general manner since we know that

Lc 1=12 ft =144 ,

Lc 2=12 ft=144 ,

Ic 1=Ic 2=Ic ,

Lg 1=Lg 2=30 ft=360 ,

Ig 1=W 21 x 55=1140 4 . Thus we have for GA


Ic 1 Ic2
1
1
1
1
+
Ic (
+
)
(
+
)
Lc 1 Lc 2
Lc 1 Lc 2
144 144
G A=
=
=Ic
=( 4.39 x 103 ) Ic
Ig 1
Ig 1
1140
Lg 1
Lg1
360
Where

Ic

is the moment of inertia of the W section being under consideration, for

this case, and as we have a pinned constraint in B then

GB =10.0 . Now we are

ready to check the first column section.


Check W14x61

Ic=640

G A =( 4.39 x 103 ) ( 640 ) =2.81 ;

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =2 .2512=27 ft ;

K y L y =12 ft ;

GB =10.0

thus entering to the

K x =2.2
Lb=12 ft , KxLx/KyLy=2.25 therefore y is

critical since rx/ry=2.44.


3

p=1.60 x 10

(w.r.t.

K y L y ),

b x =2.49 x 103

(w.r.t.

Lb ), checking with

interaction equation:

( 1.60 x 103 ) ( 398.474 ) +( 2.49 x 103 ) ( 109.977 )=0.911<1.0

good!

Thus continue the analysis with W14x61


Step 4 Beam Effect (W14x61)

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx

B 2 M ltx=0

but we already know that

proceed to compute the value of

B 1 as follows:

As there is not load between the span

Cmx =0.60.4 (

M1
)
M 2 , and we know that the

moments acting in the end of this column are equal thus

Pr=366.2k , and to compute

also know that

for this case, thus we

Pex

Cmx =0.60.4 ( 1 )=0.2 , we

we use Table 4.1 of the SCM in

the next manner


4

Pex=

18300 x 10
=10502.75 k , then putting all this values in the equation to obtain
2
(1.01112)

B1
B 1=

C mx
0.2
=
=0.21
Pr
398.474
1
1
10502.75 k
P ex

factor, thus for this case

But

B 1 1.0

due that is an amplification

B 1=1.0 , and computing

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx =( 1.0 ) ( 109.977 )=109.977 kft


Step 5 Beam-Column Effect (W14x61)
Checking again interaction equation with the amplified moment

( 1.60 x 103 ) ( 398.474 ) +( 2.49 x 103 ) ( 109.977 )=0.911<1.0

good!

USE W14x61 GRADE 50 STEEL

Interior Columns from 7-6 to 5-4


There is side sway in x direction but no side sway in Y direction
Step 1 Identification of Principal Parameters

K x =1.0 ;

K y =1.0 ;

K x Lx =1.012=12 ft

Lx =12 ft ;

L y =12 ft

K y L y =1.012=12 ft

Lb=12 ft

Step 2 Load Combination


From section 5.1 the critical values for axial force and bending moment in the
column are the following.

M rx=121.1 k ft

and

Pr=766.08 k

Step 3 Column Effect

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx


then

M ltx

but for this case as we dont have side sway in the column,

B 2 are equal to zero, and thus we have

and

M r=B1 M ntx , supposing

B 1=1.0
M r=( 1.0 )( 121.1 )=121.1 k ft

and

Pr=766.08 k

As we know that the design of columns is restrained to W14 sections and for this
case

Lb=12 ft , using the table of average values of p , b x and b y

obtain a value

we

bav =1.47 x 103 .

Now using the interaction equations for columns subjected to axial and flexure
forces, we have that:

1.0( 1.47 x 103 ) ( 121.17 )


preq
=1.07 x 103
766.08

p (766.08 )+(1.47 x 103 )(121.1) 1.0

Thus entering to Table 6-1 of the Steel Construction Manual (SCM) with a value of

K y L y =K x Lx =1.012=12 ft
Check W14x90 -

for

K y L y =12 ft ;

preq , we got a trial section:


Lb=12 ft

Before start the checking of W sections we have to update the

Kx

value every

time the W section is changed. In the SCM is stated that for moment resisting
frames we can obtain the K value using the alignment chart, but before use it we
also need the value of the parameter G for each union in the column, thus the value
of G can be computed as follows:

Ic

G=

joint,

Lc
Lg
Lg
Lc=

Where

Ic=

Moment of inertia of all columns which intercept at the

Longitude of all columns which intercept at the joint,

Ig=

Moment

of inertia of all girders which intercept at the joint and

Lg=

Longitude of all

girders which intercept at the joint, in Figure 5.5 we can see this more clearly.

Figure 5.5 GA and GB values.

Thus this can be done in a general manner since we know that

Lc 1=12 ft =144 ,

Lc 2=12 ft=144 ,

Ic1=Ic 2=Ic ,

Lg 1=Lg 2=30 ft=360 ,

Ig 1=W 21 x 55=1140 4 . Thus we have for GA


Ic 1 Ic 2
1
1
1
1
+
Ic (
+
)
(
+
)
Lc 1 Lc 2
Lc 1 Lc 2
144 144
G A=
=
=Ic
=( 2.19 x 103 ) Ic
Ig 1 Ig 2
Ig 1 Ig 2
1140 1140
+
+
+
Lg1 Lg2
Lg 1 Lg 2
360 360
Where

Ic

is the moment of inertia of the W section being under consideration, for

this case, and as we have a pinned constraint in B then

GB =10.0 . Now we are

ready to check the first column section.


Check W14x90

Ic=999 4

G A =( 2.19 x 103 ) ( 999 )=2.19 ;

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =2 .1812=2 6.16 ft ;
critical since rx/ry=1.66.

K y L y =12 ft ;
K x Lx
=15.76
rx /ry

GB =10.0

thus entering to the

K x =2.18
Lb=12 ft , KxLx/KyLy=2.18 therefore x is

p=1.01 x 103

(w.r.t.

K y L y ),

b x =1.55 x 10

(w.r.t.

Lb ), checking with

interaction equation:

( 1.01 x 103 ) ( 766.08 )+ ( 1.55 x 103 ) ( 121.1 )=0.96<1.0

good!

Thus continue the analysis with W14x90


Step 4 Beam Effect (W14x90)

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx

but we already know that

proceed to compute the value of

B 2 M ltx=0

B 1 as follows:

As there is not load between the span

Cmx =0.60.4 (

M1
)
M 2 , and we know that the

moments acting in the end of this column are equal thus


also know that

for this case, thus we

Pr=766.08 k , and to compute

Pex

Cmx =0.60.4 ( 1 )=0.2 , we

we use Table 4.1 of the SCM in

the next manner

Pex =

18300 x 104
=10502.75 k , then putting all this values in the equation to
(2.181212)2

obtain

B 1=

B1

C mx
0.2
=
=0.21
Pr
766.08
1
1
10502.75 k
P ex

factor, thus for this case

But

B 1 1.0

due that is an amplification

B 1=1.0 , and computing

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx =( 1.0 ) ( 121.1 )=121.1 kft


Step 5 Beam-Column Effect (W14x90)
Checking again interaction equation with the amplified moment

( 1.01 x 103 ) ( 766.08 )+ ( 1.55 x 103 ) ( 121.1 )=0.96<1.0

good!

USE W14x90 GRADE 50 STEEL

Exterior Columns from R-8 to 8-7


There is side sway in x direction but no side sway in Y direction

Step 1 Identification of Principal Parameters

K x =1.0 ;

K y =1.0 ;

K x Lx =1.012=12 ft

Lx =12 ft ;

L y =12 ft

Lb=12 ft

K y L y =1.012=12 ft

Step 2 Load Combination


From section 5.1 the critical values for axial force and bending moment in the
column are the following.

M rx=100.68 k ft

and

Pr=201.226 k

Step 3 Column Effect

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx


then

M ltx

but for this case as we dont have side sway in the column,

B 2 are equal to zero, and thus we have

and

M r=B1 M ntx , supposing

B 1=1.0
M r=( 1.0 )( 100.68 k )=100.68 k kft

and

Pr=201.226 k

As we know that the design of columns is restrained to W14 sections and for this
case

Lb=12 ft , using the table of average values of p , b x and b y

obtain a value

bav =1.47 x 10

we

Now using the interaction equations for columns subjected to axial and flexure
forces, we have that:

p (201.226 )+(1.47 x 103 )(100.68 k ) 1.0


1.0( 1.47 x 103 ) ( 100.68 k )
preq
=4.23 x 103
201.226
Thus entering to Table 6-1 of the Steel Construction Manual (SCM) with a value of

K y L y =K x Lx =1.012=12 ft
Check W14x38 -

for

K y L y =12 ft ;

preq , we got a trial section:


Lb=12 ft

Before start the checking of W sections we have to update the

Kx

value every

time the W section is changed. In the SCM is stated that for moment resisting
frames we can obtain the K value using the alignment chart, but before use it we

also need the value of the parameter G for each union in the column, thus the value
of G can be computed as follows:

Ic

G=

Lc
Lg
Lg

joint,

Lc=

Ic=

Where

Moment of inertia of all columns which intercept at the

Longitude of all columns which intercept at the joint,

of inertia of all girders which intercept at the joint and

Lg=

Ig=

Moment

Longitude of all

girders which intercept at the joint, in Figure 5.5 we can see this more clearly.

Figure 5.5 GA and GB values.

Thus this can be done in a general manner since we know that

Lc 1=12 ft =144 ,

Lc 2=12 ft=144 ,
4

Ig 1=W 21 x 44=843

Ic1=Ic 2=Ic ,

Lg 1=Lg 2=30 ft=360 ,

. Thus we have for GA

Ic 1 Ic 2
1
1
1
1
+
Ic (
+
)
(
+
)
Lc 1 Lc 2
Lc 1 Lc 2
144 144
G A=
=
=Ic
=( 5.93 x 103 ) Ic
Ig 1
Ig 1
843
Lg 1
Lg1
360
Where

Ic

is the moment of inertia of the W section being under consideration, for

this case, and as we have a pinned constraint in B then


ready to check the first column section.
Check W14x38

GB =10.0 . Now we are

Ic=385 4

G A =( 5.93 x 103 ) ( 385 )=2.28 ;

thus entering to the

K x =2.18

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =2.1812=26.16 ft ;

GB =10.0

K y L y =12 ft ;

Lb=12 ft , KxLx/KyLy=2.18 therefore x is

critical since rx/ry=3.79.

p=3.73 x 10

(w.r.t.

K y L y ),

b x =5.0 x 103

Lb ), checking with

(w.r.t.

interaction equation:

( 3.73 x 103 ) ( 201.226 ) +( 5.0 x 103 ) ( 100.68 k ) =1.25>1.0


Check W14x43 -

Ic=428

K y L y =12 ft ;

Lb=12 ft

G A =( 5.93 x 103 ) ( 428 ) =2.54 ;

GB =10.0

thus entering to the

K x =2.2

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =2. 212=26.4 ft ;

Not good!

K y L y =12 ft ;

Lb=12 ft , KxLx/KyLy=2.2 therefore x is

critical since rx/ry=3.08.

p=2.7 x 103 (w.r.t.

K y L y ),

Lb ), checking with

b x =4.0 x 103 (w.r.t.

interaction equation:

( 2.7 x 103 ) ( 201.226 ) +( 4.0 x 103 ) ( 100.68 k )=0.8<1.0

good!

Thus continue the analysis with W14x43


Step 4 Beam Effect (W14x43)

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx

but we already know that

proceed to compute the value of

B 2 M ltx=0

B 1 as follows:

As there is not load between the span

Cmx =0.60.4 (

M1
)
M 2 , and we know that the

moments acting in the end of this column are equal thus


also know that
the next manner

for this case, thus we

Pr=366.2k , and to compute

Pex

Cmx =0.60.4 ( 1 )=0.2 , we

we use Table 4.1 of the SCM in

Pex=

12300 x 10
=5931.71k , then putting all this values in the equation to obtain
2
(2.21212)

B1
B 1=

C mx
0.2
=
=0.21
Pr
201.226
1
1
5931.71k
P ex

factor, thus for this case

But

B 1 1.0

due that is an amplification

B 1=1.0 , and computing

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx =( 1.0 ) ( 100.68 k )=100.68 k ft


Step 5 Beam-Column Effect (W14x43)
Checking again interaction equation with the amplified moment

( 2.7 x 103 ) ( 201.226 ) +( 4.0 x 103 ) ( 100.68 k )=0.8<1.0

good!

USE W14x43 GRADE 50 STEEL


Interior Columns from R-8 to 8-7
There is side sway in x direction but no side sway in Y direction
Step 1 Identification of Principal Parameters

K x =2.0 assumed ;

K y =1.0 ;

K x Lx =2 .012=24 ft

Lx =12 ft ;

L y =12 ft

Lb=12 ft

K y L y =1.012=12 ft

Step 2 Load Combination


From section 5.1 the critical values for axial force and bending moment in the
column are the following.

M rx=97.49 kft

and

Pr=426.24 k

Step 3 Column Effect

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx


then

M ltx

and

but for this case as we dont have side sway in the column,

B 2 are equal to zero, and thus we have

B 1=1.0
M r=( 1.0 )( 97.49 ) =97.49 kft

and

Pr=426.24 k

M r=B1 M ntx , supposing

As we know that the design of columns is restrained to W14 sections and for this
case

Lb=12 ft , using the table of average values of p , b x and b y

obtain a value

we

bav =1.47 x 103 .

Now using the interaction equations for columns subjected to axial and flexure
forces, we have that:

p ( 426.24 ) +(1.47 x 103 )(97.49) 1.0

preq

1.0( 1.47 x 103 ) ( 97.49 )


=2.01 x 103
426.24

Thus entering to Table 6-1 of the Steel Construction Manual (SCM) with a value of

K y L y =K x Lx =1.012=12 ft
Check W14x61-

for

K y L y =12 ft ;

preq , we got a trial section:


Lb=12 ft

Before start the checking of W sections we have to update the

Kx

value every

time the W section is changed. In the SCM is stated that for moment resisting
frames we can obtain the K value using the alignment chart, but before use it we
also need the value of the parameter G for each union in the column, thus the value
of G can be computed as follows:

Ic

G=

joint,

Lc
Lg
Lg
Lc=

Where

Ic=

Moment of inertia of all columns which intercept at the

Longitude of all columns which intercept at the joint,

of inertia of all girders which intercept at the joint and

Lg=

Ig=

Moment

Longitude of all

girders which intercept at the joint, in Figure 5.5 we can see this more clearly.

Figure 5.5 GA and GB values.

Thus this can be done in a general manner since we know that

Lc 1=12 ft =144 ,

Lc 2=12 ft=144 ,

Ic 1=Ic 2=Ic ,

Lg 1=Lg 2=30 ft=360 ,

Ig 1=W 21 x 44=843 4 . Thus we have for GA


Ic 1 Ic 2
1
1
1
1
+
Ic(
+
)
(
+
)
Lc 1 Lc 2
Lc 1 Lc 2
144 144
3
G A=
=
=Ic
=( 2.97 x 10 ) Ic
Ig 1 Ig 2
Ig 1 Ig 2
843 843
+
+
+
Lg1 Lg2
Lg 1 Lg 2
360 360
Where

Ic

is the moment of inertia of the W section being under consideration, for

GB =10.0 . Now we are

this case, and as we have a pinned constraint in B then


ready to check the first column section.
Check W14x61

Ic=640 4

G A =( 2.97 x 103 ) ( 640 )=1.901 ;

thus entering to the

K x =2.1

alignment chart of the SCM we got that

K x Lx =2.112=25.2 ft ;

GB =10.0

K y L y =12 ft ;

Lb=12 ft , KxLx/KyLy=2.1 therefore x is

critical since rx/ry=2.44.

p=1.6 x 103 (w.r.t.

K y L y ),

b x =2.49 x 10

Lb ), checking with

(w.r.t.

interaction equation:

( 1.6 x 103 ) ( 426.24 ) + ( 2.49 x 103 ) ( 97.49 ) =0.92<1.0

good!

Thus continue the analysis with W14x61


Step 4 Beam Effect (W14x61)

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx

but we already know that

proceed to compute the value of

B 2 M ltx=0

for this case, thus we

B 1 as follows:

As there is not load between the span

Cmx =0.60.4 (

M1
)
M 2 , and we know that the

moments acting in the end of this column are equal thus

Cmx =0.60.4 ( 1 )=0.2 , we

also know that

Pr=766.08 k , and to compute

Pex

we use Table 4.1 of the SCM in

the next manner

Pex=

18300 x 10 4
=10502.75 k , then putting all this values in the equation to
(2.11212)2

obtain

B 1=

B1

C mx
0.2
=
=0.21
Pr
426.24
1
1
10502.75 k
P ex

factor, thus for this case

But

B 1 1.0

due that is an amplification

B 1=1.0 , and computing

M r=B1 M ntx+ B 2 M ltx =( 1.0 ) ( 97.49 )=97.49 kft


Step 5 Beam-Column Effect (W14x61)
Checking again interaction equation with the amplified moment

( 1.6 x 103 ) ( 426.24 ) + ( 2.49 x 103 ) ( 97.49 ) =0.92<1.0

good!

USE W14x61 GRADE 50 STEEL

5.4. Beam Design


The design of beams is developed considering them as simply supported beams
then the maximum bending moment acting is controlling the design and this is
calculated as is shown next, in Figure 5.10.

Figure 5.10 Maximum Moment Acting in a Simply Supported Beam.

For the building under consideration we have two cases of beams, the first one
when the member is considered an exterior beam and the second one when the
member is considered an interior beam, this is shown in Figure 5.11. Also in this
Figure we can see the tributary area for each beam in which the load will be acting,
these areas are equal to (10ft) (30ft) = 300 ft2 and (5ft) (30ft) = 150 ft2 for the
exterior and interior beams respectively.
It is important to note that the beams are designed just for Dead and Live Load and
no load combinations are required for this design. Also, since we have same Dead
and Live load for the 2nd to 7th Levels but different for the Roof Level, and each level
present two kinds of beams (exterior and interior), the total number of beam
designs is four for all the building.

Figure 5.11 Interior and Exterior Beams and Tributary Area.

The selection of the adequate W section will be restrained to W16 or W18 sizes
depending on the availability of the section to resist the moment required, also this
restriction is made because the beams must be connected with the girders and thus
Beams size should be smaller than the Girders size.
Once the adequate W section is chosen, the section must be checked against Shear
and Deflection in the same way that for girders.

Selection of the appropriate W section for the Exterior Beam Roof Level Case:
The distributed load acting in this beam is

W T =W D +W L =

(75 psf )(5 ft) (12 psf )(5 ft )


k
+
=0.435
1000
1000
ft
W T L2 (0.435)(302 )
M max=
=
=48.94 kft
8
8

The maximum moment acting is

M max=M r =48.94 kft

Thus we have acting a bending moment

Lb=0

Table 3-10 of the SCM with a value of

we found that the W16x26 is

b M n =165.75 kft

adequate (Page 3-130). For this section

then entering to

thus

b M n Mr

is

correctly satisfied.
Now checking Shear for the W16x26 section, we have that nominal shear strength
is:
For this W section h/tw=56.8 then the realtion h/tw 2.24
satisfied and we need another procedure to compute

Cv

E/ Fy=53.95

is not

value, for this case we

are in the next case


h/tw 1.10 k v E /F y

1.10

because we have that h/tw=56.8

k v =5

and then

( 5 ) ( 29000 )
=59.24 then we have a value for C v =1.0 and
50

v =0.9

thus

15.7

0.250

v V n=0.90.6F y A w1.0=( 0.54 ) 50

kip

And the required shear is:

V r=

WT L
=
2

satisfied.

(0.435

k
)(30 ft )
ft
=6.525 kip
2

Thus we have that

v V n V r

is clearly

Now checking Deflection for the W16x26 section, we have that the distributed live
load acting in the beam is
is

a=

W L=

(12 psf )(5 ft )


k
=0.06
1000
ft

and the allowable deflection

Span 30 ft
=
=0.083 ft=1 , thus checking simply supported beam deflection,
360 360

we have:
4

5 W L L 5(0.06 12)(3012)4
( max )=
=
=0.13
384 EI
38429000301

Then

( max ) a is satisfied,

checking for a doubly fixed beam as follows:

( max )=

W L L4 (0.06 12)(3012) 4
=
=0.03 Then
384 EI
38429000301

( max ) a is completely

satisfied
USE W16x26 GRADE 50 STEEL
Selection of the appropriate W section for the Interior Beam Roof Level Case:
The distributed load acting in this beam is

W T =W D +W L =

(75 psf )(10 ft) (12 psf )(10 ft )


k
+
=0.87
1000
1000
ft
M max=

The maximum moment acting is

W T L2 (0.87)(30 2)
=
=97.88 k ft
8
8
M max=M r =97.88 k ft

Thus we have acting a bending moment

Lb=0

Table 3-10 of the SCM with a value of

we found that the W16x26 is

b M n =165.75 kft

adequate (Page 3-130). For this section

thus entering to

thus

b M n Mr

is

correctly satisfied.
Now checking Shear for the W16x26 section, we have that nominal shear strength
is:

15.7

0.250

v V n=0.90.6F y A w1.0=( 0.54 ) 50


And the required shear is:

kip

V r=

WT L
=
2

( 0.87

k
)(30 ft )
ft
=13.05 kip
2

Thus we have that

v V n V r

is clearly

satisfied.
Now checking Deflection for the W16x26 section, we have that the distributed live
load acting in the beam is
is

a=

W L=

(12 psf )(10 ft )


k
=0.12
1000
ft

and the allowable deflection

Span 30 ft
=
=0.083 ft=1 , thus checking simply supported beam deflection,
360 360

we have:
4

( max )=

5 W L L 5(0.12 12)(3012)4
=
=0.25 Then
384 EI
38429000301

( max ) a is satisfied,

checking for a doubly fixed beam as follows:

W L L4 (0.12 12)(3012)4
( max )=
=
=0.05
384 EI
38429000301

Then

( max ) a is completely

satisfied
USE W16x26 GRADE 50 STEEL
Selection of the appropriate W section for the Exterior Beam 2 nd to 8th Level Case:
The distributed load acting in this beam is

W T =W D +W L =

(80 psf )(5 ft) (58 psf )(5 ft )


k
+
=0.69
1000
1000
ft

The maximum moment acting is

W T L2 (0.69)(302 )
M max=
=
=77.625 kft
8
8

Thus we have acting a bending moment


Table 3-10 of the SCM with a value of
adequate (Page 3-130). For this section

M max=M r =77.625 kft

Lb=0

thus entering to

we found that the W16x26 is

b M n =165.75 kft

thus

b M n Mr

is

correctly satisfied.
Now checking Shear for the W16x26 section, we have that nominal shear strength
is:

15.7

0.250

v V n=0.90.6F y A w1.0=( 0.54 ) 50

kip

And the required shear is:

W L
V r= T =
2

k
(0.69 )(30 ft )
ft
=10.35 kip
2

Thus we have that

v V n V r

is clearly

satisfied.
Now checking Deflection for the W16x26 section, we have that the distributed live
load acting in the beam is

Span

W L=

(58 psf )(5 ft )


k
=0.29
1000
ft

and the allowable deflection

30 ft

is a= 360 = 360 =0.083 ft=1 , thus checking simply supported beam deflection,
we have:

5 W L L4 5(0.29 12)(3012) 4
( max )=
=
=0.61
384 EI
38429000301

Then

( max ) a is satisfied,

checking for a doubly fixed beam as follows:

( max )=

W L L4 (0.29 12)(3012)4
=
=0.12
384 EI
38429000301

Then

( max ) a is completely

satisfied.
USE W16x26 GRADE 50 STEEL
Selection of the appropriate W section for the Interior Beam 2 nd to 8th Level Case:
The distributed load acting in this beam is

W T =W D +W L =

(80 psf )(10 ft) (58 psf )(10 ft)


k
+
=1.38
1000
1000
ft

The maximum moment acting is

M max=

Thus we have acting a bending moment


Table 3-10 of the SCM with a value of

W T L2 (1.38)(302 )
=
=155.25 kft
8
8
M max=M r =155.25 kft

Lb=0

thus entering to

we found that the W16x26 is

b M n =165.75 kft

adequate (Page 3-130). For this section

thus

b M n Mr

is

correctly satisfied.
Now checking Shear for the W16x26 section, we have that nominal shear strength
is:

15.7

0.250

v V n=0.90.6F y A w1.0=( 0.54 ) 50

kip

And the required shear is:

W L
V r= T =
2

k
(0.69 )(30 ft )
ft
=10.35 kip
2

Thus we have that

v V n V r

is clearly

satisfied.
Now checking Deflection for the W16x26 section, we have that the distributed live
load acting in the beam is

Span

W L=

(58 psf )(5 ft )


k
=0.29
1000
ft

and the allowable deflection

30 ft

is a= 360 = 360 =0.083 ft=1 , thus checking simply supported beam deflection,
we have:

5 W L L4 5(0.29 12)(3012) 4
( max )=
=
=0.61
384 EI
38429000301

Then

( max ) a is satisfied,

checking for a doubly fixed beam as follows:

W L L4 (0.29 12)(3012)4
( max )=
=
=0.12
384 EI
38429000301

Then

( max ) a is completely

satisfied.
USE W16x26 GRADE 50 STEEL

For the ease of the above calculation needed to obtain the beam W sections, are
introduced Figures 5.12 and 5.23. In Figure 5.12 we can appreciate the beam
member W sections for the case of the Roof level and Figure 5.13 shows the beam
members W sections for the 8th to 2nd level cases.

Figure 5.12 Interior and Exterior Beam W16 sections for the Roof Level Case

Figure 5.13 Interior and Exterior Beam W16 sections for the 2nd to 8th Cases

7. Self Weight of the Steel Structure


Up to this point we have all the members of the building and all the structural
detail, thus we are ready to compute the weight of steel required for the building.

7.1. Weight of the Typical Frame


The exterior columns from the foundation till the fourth floor are W14x99
sections and the interior columns from the foundation till the fourth floor
are W14x159 sections.
The length of these columns is 20+12+12+3 (column splice is 3 feet
above the slab) = 47 ft.
The total weight of the columns from the foundation till the 4 th floor is:
(2 columns)*(47 ft/column)*(99lb/ft) + (2 columns)*(47
ft/column)*(159lb/ft) = 15139 lb.
The exterior columns from 3 feet above the fourth floor till 3 feet above
the 7th floor are W14x61 sections and the interior columns from 3 feet
above the fourth floor till 3 feet above the 7th floor are W14x90 sections.
The length of these columns is (12-3)+12+12+3 = 36 ft.
The total weight of the columns from the fourth floor till the roof is:
(2)(36)(61) + (2)(36)(90) = 10872 lb.
The exterior columns from 3 feet above the 7th floor till 3 feet above the
roof are W14x43 sections and the interior columns from 3 feet above the
7th floor till 3 feet above the roof are W14x61 sections.
The length of these columns is (12-3) +12+3 = 24 ft.
The total weight of the columns from the fourth floor till the roof is:
(2)(24)(43) + (2)(24)(61) = 4992 lb.

The exterior girders from the 2nd floor till the roof are W24x55 sections
and the interior girders from the 2nd floor till the roof are W24x55 sections.
The exterior girders on the roof are W21x44 sections and the interior
girder on the roof is a W21x44 sections.
The length of all exterior girders is 30 ft and the length of all interior
girders is 30 ft.
The total weight of all the girders in the typical interior frame is:
{(2 girders/floor)*(30 ft/girder)*(55 lb/ft) +(1girder/floor)*(30ft/girder)*(55lb/ft)}*7
+ (2girders/floor)*(30 ft/girder)*(44 lb/ft) + (1 girder/floor)*(30ft/girder)*(44lb/ft)

= 38610 lb

The total weight of the frame is: 4992 + 38610+


15139+10872 = 69613 lb.
7.2. Weight of the Beams
For the case of beams, we have the same size of beams for the Roof level, this size
of this beam is: W16x26 and in total there are 40 beams every floor, thus the total
weight for beams in the roof level case can be computed as follows:

( 40 beam ) 30

ft
lb
26 =31200lb
beam
ft

)( )

For the cases from 8th floor to 2nd floor we W16x26:

( 40 beam ) 30

ft
lb
26 =31200lb
beam
ft

)( )

Finally the total weight of all the beams in the building can be computed as follows:

Total Weight of Beams=( 31200 lb ) +7 ( 31200 )=249600 lb

7.3. Total Weight of the Steel Structure


The total weight of all the steel structure is the weight of all the frames and all the
beams, thus as we have for this building five frames and we already compute the
total weight of beams, the total weight of all the structure can be computed as
follows:

Total Weight=5 ( Total weight of the Frame )+ (Totale Weight of beams )


Total Weight=5 ( 69613 lb )+ ( 249600 )=597665 lb

6. STRUCTURAL DETAILS
In this section the structural details are shown with the help of figures, the
calculation of such details is beyond the scope of this final project but in general
these are the minimal details required in the structural engineering professional
field. These details are: Connections, Column Splice, Column base plate, Interior
shear wall and Composite slab.

6.1. Connections
For the case of connection, there are three types for this building: Girder-Column
Connection (Moment Connection), Beam-Girder Connection (Shear Connection) and
Beam-Column Connection (Shear Connection).
In Figure 5.14 we can appreciate how the girders must be connected to the columns
to form a moment connection, this is necessary because our typical frame is a Steel
Moment Resisting Frame (SMRF), thus the basic condition is that the connections for
such a frame must be moment connections.
Moment connections are designed to transfer bending moments, shear forces and
sometimes normal forces. The design strength and stiffness of a moment
connection are defined in relation to the strength and stiffness of the connected
members. The design strength of a moment connection may be full- strength or
partial-strength. Similarly the stiffness of a moment connection can be rigid or semirigid compared to the stiffness of the connected member. For this project the
connections are considered designed with full strength requirement and with rigid
stiffness. As is shown in Figure 5.14 five bolts are used to connect the flanges of the
girders with the plates fixed to the flanges of columns, six bolts for the web plate
and four bolts in each connection of the angles with columns.

Figure 5.14 Girder-Column Moment Connections

In Figure 5.15 is shown the beam-girder connection, these elements must be


connected to resist shear forces. A plate shear connection is a single rectangular
plate of steel bolted to a girder web on one end and bolted to a supported beam on
the other. For this case we need six bolts for each angle connected to the webs of
beams and girders respectively, also as we can see in Figure 5.15 for this case
always the size of the beam section must be smaller than the girder section.

Figure 5.15 Laterals and Isometric Views of Girder-Beam Shear Connections

For the case of beam-column connections the same procedure that for the beamgirder connection is followed, there are just two differences: The first one is that for
beam-column connection the shear plates must be reinforced with six bolts instead
of three and the second difference is that beams are connected to the flange of the
column instead to the web. We can clearly see this in Figure 5.16.

Figure 5.16 Beam-Column Shear Connections

Anda mungkin juga menyukai