Agenda
Introductions
Who we are
Session objectives
21st annual trends in logistics and transportation study
Total delivered cost
Questions
Page 1
1210-1397979
Introductions
Gary Allen
North
Tony Ross
North
Page 2
1210-1397979
Agenda
Introductions
Who we are
Session objectives
21st annual trends in logistics and transportation study
Total delivered cost
Questions
Page 3
1210-1397979
Asia Pacific
Americas
EMEIA
3,600 Advisory
professionals
11,200 Advisory
professionals
Procurement Transformation
Global
Page 4
1210-1397979
Assurance
Tax
Transaction
Agenda
Introductions
Who we are
Session objectives
21st annual trends in logistics and transportation study
Total delivered cost
Questions
Page 5
1210-1397979
Session objectives
Major trends affecting logistics and how they affect supply
chain decisions
Perspective on total delivered cost, how companies are
using it today and a road map for you to apply it within
your organization
Page 6
1210-1397979
Agenda
Introductions
Who we are
Session objectives
21st annual trends in logistics and transportation study
Total delivered cost
Questions
Page 7
1210-1397979
1,370
Page 8
1210-1397979
Survey participants overwhelmingly agreed that being better than our competitors in terms of service would
significantly improve our competitive position.
While best customers do receive better service, the difference in service levels between this group and average
customers is fairly low.
Average customers reported more service improvements from the previous year than best customers.
0
1
2
3
4
5
Scale: 1 = Strongly agree; 7 = Strongly disagree
Page 10
1210-1397979
38.8%
Advanced analytics
(including on-line analytical
processing)
25.7%
58.9%
37.1%
15.9%
19.6%
15.9% 10.6%14.5%
27.1%
14.5%
21.3%
Not Planned
Planned
Interactive visualization
57.9%
18.2% 12.6%11.2%
Implemented
Completed
Dashboards
Data mining
19.4%
26.4%
20.3%
19.5%
22.0%
24.5%
38.3%
29.5%
Page 11
1210-1397979
Domestic visibility of the physical flow of goods and products on both the inbound and outbound
sides increased.
Visibility for the remaining points in the supply chain reported no improvement.
International visibility also improved for inbound and outbound transportation. Other parts of the
supply chain halted previous years progress.
Suppliers
Supplier
5.2
Supplier
3.8
Inbound
3.0
Company
2012
2.7
Page 12
1210-1397979
Outbound
1.9
Customer
3.6
The results show that companies have placed much more effort in sharing information and
collaborating with key customers than they have with key suppliers.
Capacity forecast sharing was near the bottom of the list of primary actions taken by
companies to offset rising transportation costs.
Improved integration of information systems with external supply
chain partners was also one of the least likely initiatives to be taken.
Sharing data (as a collaboration
initiative) has focused on operations
and tactics
If we continue to focus at these
levels, how and when will
collaboration become strategic?
Shipment
status
70%
Advanced
ship notice
49%
63%
1210-1397979
62%
Production
schedules
37%
Customer
delivery
requirements
Page 13
Demand
forecasts
Order
status
68%
Most companies tend to focus on cost of good sold, few companies have the capability to understand their true cost to
serve (CTS).
CTS is often averaged across customers and products in a profitability review. Disaggregating these CTS averages
highlights opportunities to reduce value leakage.
Leading class companies segment CTS at a customer, product, brand or company level and complete the picture by
providing end-to-end supply chain costs.
CTS has recently become an area of focus, and many companies plan to launch CTS initiatives.
Page 14
1210-1397979
Page 15
1210-1397979
Agenda
Introductions
Who we are
Session objectives
21st annual trends in logistics and transportation study
Total delivered cost
Questions
Page 16
1210-1397979
Enterprise-wide imperative
Page 17
1210-1397979
Without an understanding of total delivered costs, companies cannot reward efficient behavior or
defend against changes that drive cost.
Requires a detailed understanding of total supply chain costs and profitability to uncover the next generation of cost savings
Page 18
1210-1397979
Examples
Transportation
optimization
Increase transport efficiency ratios via customer price negotiations and introduction
of logistics terms
Global trade
management
Network
optimization
Order management
Logistics
outsourcing
Use outside expertise and capabilities to help flex with market and customer
demands
Leading companies integrate all factors across supply chain and commercial
organizations to reward efficient behavior and defend against cost increases.
Total delivered
costs
Page 19
1210-1397979
Supplier
Retailer/
Distributor/
Customer
Manufacturer
Conversion cost
Cost to serve
Customers continue to struggle to understand profitability and the related impact of balancing
supply chain cost trade-offs and consumer needs across these components.
Page 20
1210-1397979
Strategic
Global
Strategic/t
actical
Insight
Global/
regional
Landed costs
Tactical/
operational
Challenge
Regional/
local
Conversion cost
How do I balance
manufacturing performance
and demand variability?
Tactical/
operational
Component
Regional/
local
Cost to serve
How do I optimize my
executional flows?
Page 21
1210-1397979
Illustrative
Costs to serve
Secondary
Economic
Profit
Gross Profit
Net Sales
Value
1210-1397979
Deals &
Allowances
Gross Sales
Page 22
Page 23
1210-1397979
Supply chain
and
commercial
interface
Go-tomarket
distribution
strategy
Promotion
pricing and
performance
Efficiency
trade terms
Cost
to
serve
Customer
and product
profitability
Customer
joint value
creation
Customer
service
offering
Operational
continual
improvement
There can be a 10x cost differential in serving efficient customers versus inefficient customers
Page 24
1210-1397979
Plant
Plant
warehouse
Supplier
DC
Page 25
1210-1397979
Retailer store
shelves
Retailer
RDCs
15%-30% of
budget
Initial hypothesis
Consolidation of volume to
increase vehicle fill
Opportunity
Potential
impact
(% total CTS)
4.3%
1%
0.7%
6%
Approach
Using a cost to serve simulation, they conducted a thorough analysis of
their current cost to serve.
This enabled them to understand exactly where the key cost drivers were
and identify and prioritize potential solutions for further analysis.
Initially focusing primarily on their two largest retailers, using the scenario
simulation they quantified the cost and service impact to create a business
case and road map to change.
Benefits identified
Estimated net cost reduction of 6% of total cost to serve through:
Additional benefits:
Page 26
1210-1397979
Companies face growing cost, compliance and risk challenges across their global supply chains as they become
stretched in the pursuit of low-cost country sourcing and revenue growth.
Challenges of globalization
Examples
Kelloggs Indian breakfast cereal initially failed due to price, positioning and logistics
problems.
Hidden duties within delivery duty paid (DPP) contracts cost a manufacturer an additional
30% on landed costs
Recalls cost Mattel $40m in 2007 and took $612m off its market capitalization.
A multinationals VAT systems setup did not match its evolving supply chain, leading to
20m of irrecoverable VAT trapped on the balance sheet.
Weak controls over third-party distributors led to delays of up to three months in customers
getting orders delivered for this high-tech manufacturer.
Many companies continue to address global sourcing issues in a fragmented, silo-based approach that can further
contribute to these issues. These are just a handful of examples to illustrate why it is important to understand global
trade in an integrated way.
Page 27
1210-1397979
Capacity rebalancing
Landed cost
optimization will allow
procurement, logistics
and manufacturing to
uncover hidden costs.
1210-1397979
Plant rationalization
Page 28
2 Sourcing decisions
Compare different sources
in use on a total delivered
cost basis
2 3
3a
Plant rationalization
Assess and check which
plant should supply which
end market
3b
Capacity balancing
Assess and check which
plant should supply which
end market
Page 29
1210-1397979
Trade preference determination improvement and automation projects generate duty savings between
30% and 60%
Diversified manufacturing
$8.3B FY09 revenue
6,000
ROI*
First savings
$5,600
achieved in month 5
$850K income
5,000
4,000
3,000
statement impact in
first 12 months
Savings:
$3M
annually
achieved in 20
months
$2,600
Investment
Improved working
2,000
capital
Lower inventory
levels
1,000
Labor efficiencies
Lower brokerage fees
Total: $3,440,000
0
* Assumes a 4 months implementation, cost of
capital 8% and 3 years capital amortization period
Page 30
1210-1397979
Other benefits
Prior to GTS
After GTS
Lessons learned
Area
Risk
Mitigation plan
Scope of work
and complexity
BU participation
and buy-in
Tool: scalability
and alignment
Assignment and
allocation rules:
buy-in
Data availability
Page 31
1210-1397979
Page 32
1210-1397979
Strategic alignment
2.
Business segmentation
Break it down into manageable pieces & identify a pilot to get started
3.
4.
Organization collaboration
5.
System enablement
Page 33
1210-1397979
Evaluate which tools are right for you & will help sustain benefits
Conclusion
Page 34
1210-1397979
Agenda
Introductions
Who we are
Session objectives
21st annual trends in logistics and transportation study
Total delivered cost
Questions
Page 35
1210-1397979
Thank you!
Gary Allen
Executive Director, Logistics Leader
gary.allen@ey.com
+1 313 628 8639
Tony Ross
Senior Manager, Logistics Practice
tony.ross@ey.com
+1 214 969 8846
Page 36
1210-1397979