Prologue
Original plan was to write on Bitcoins. But for Bitcoin related MCQs, group
discussion (GD) and interview questions, one must know the basics of money itself.
Only then you can see how Bitcoin is better or worse than the money we use todayrupees, dollars or Euros. Hence a long series of articles.
1. In the first few of articles (total 3), well see why did people start using
traditional money (Rupee, dollar), how is it better than bartering system. And
how is bitcoin better or worse, on those parameters?
2. In the second batch of articles, well see evolution of money system: from
commodity money, metallic coins, fiduciary money, gold backed paper
currency, fiat money, bank money etc.-what were their advantages and
limitations. And how is bitcoin better or worse on those parameters.
3. And in the final articles, well see what is bitcoin exactly? from where does it
come? How does it operate? Advantages, limitations, future applications and
regulatory issues etc.
Bitcoins overview
Bitcoin is a digital code. (Some) people use it as currency.
Started in 2009 by Satoshi Nakomoto. He could be a man or a woman or a group
of people- real identity unknown.
There are two ways to get Bitcoins:
http://mrunal.org/2013/12/economy-barter-money-bitcoin-fungibility-double-coincidence-of-wants-division-of-labour-part-1.html/print/
1/12
7/9/2014
#1: Mining
#2: Exchange
Barter system
People have been trading with each other even before the advent of money, coin,
cash, currency, rupee, dollar, euro or Yuan.
They simply exchanged goods and services with each other through barter
system- 1 kg rice for a 200 gms tomatoes, 1 kg tomatoes for 50 gm almonds and
so on
2/12
7/9/2014
2.
3.
4.
5.
But Bartering system had many limitations, thats why people shifted to the money
system. So,
What are the limitations of Barter System?
Another case
My son wants to get admission in your coaching class. I can give you 500
beer bottles as fees.
I dont drink at all! Although I do want new table and benches for my
Sir
classroom.
But I dont know any carpenter in this area, and even if I find one, there is no
Mallya
guarantee hell accept beer bottles as payment for making furniture!
Mallya
Thus, under barter system, the wants of two parties must coincide with each
other, otherwise they cannot trade with each other. This increases the transaction
cost as everyone will have to waste time and energy to find another party with
double coincidence of wants.
Money system solves this problem. Farmer can sell his rice for money, use that
money to get a haircut, and barber can use the same payment to buy tomatoes
from another farmer.
Money thus facilitates the exchange of goods and services, lessens the time and
effort required to carry on trade.
3/12
7/9/2014
Bitcoin also serves the same purpose but with some caveats
Fiat money
Bitcoins
An IT professional in
Banglore may accept
bitcoin payment for
creating software for
some American
businessman.
But if the same techie
offers to pay house rent in
bitcoins, the landlord is
legally free to refuse this
payment and can even
order him to vacate the
property.
BARTER
FIAT
MONEY
BITCOIN
No
Yes
Yes, if two
parties agree.
4/12
7/9/2014
5/12
7/9/2014
AI uses these bitcoins for paying the cost of raw material, warehouse rent,
electricity bill etc. to humans (or other AIs).
And whatever bitcoins left (=profit), are reinvested in buying more drones,
bigger servers and so on.
This is not possible in the present money system because legally- an AI or Robot
doesnt meet the KYC norms for opening a bank account = impossible for them to
pay electricity bills through netbanking or creditcard!
Anyways, lets update the table:
Features
barter
fiat money
(Rs./$)
No
yes
No
Yes
Bitcoin
Only if both parties
agree.
Yes, lot possibilities
in future.
Give me a cup of tea, Ill give you two pages from the latest Harry Potter
book.
http://mrunal.org/2013/12/economy-barter-money-bitcoin-fungibility-double-coincidence-of-wants-division-of-labour-part-1.html/print/
6/12
7/9/2014
chaiwalla
I dont want just two pages, I want the whole book for my son!
Even if chai-walla continues serving tea to Ms. Rowling for 300-400 days, gets
all the pages of Harry Potter book and staples them together => still that stapled
book will not sell at the original value of a brand new Harry potter book (which
is say worth 30 kilos of rice).
Meaning:
You cannot always divide the value
You cannot always re-unite the divided values.
Other scenarios:
1. Jeweler wants a matchstick box. But its not possible to divide gold to such a
micro-micro-micro quantity where gold becomes proportional to the value of a
matchbox.
2. Mallya wants to buy a pencil box for his son, offers 1 table-spoon of liquor for 1
pencil box but stationary-walla will not accept because such low quantity of
alcohol cannot give the kick.
3. To pay for a cup of tea, Picasso cannot cutout 1 mm2 of canvass from his
original painting.
Fiat Money system (and Bitcoins) dont suffer from this problem of divisibility, and
hence facilitate the trade.
currency
Rupee (Rs.)
smallest unit
1 paisa=0.01 Rupee (that is 10-2)
#4: Fungibility
Even if items are divisible, their fungibility is a problem under barter system.
Fungible items = those items whose individual units have same uniform value and
http://mrunal.org/2013/12/economy-barter-money-bitcoin-fungibility-double-coincidence-of-wants-division-of-labour-part-1.html/print/
7/12
7/9/2014
8/12
7/9/2014
10Rs.
Still Money system too has limitations:
You cannot pay Rs.149.75 through notes and coins because 25 paisa is out of
circulation. (Although possible if you pay via credit card, debit card or internet
banking)
Persistent shortage of chillar coins. And if you cut a ten rupee note into ten parts
using a scissors, itll not become ten 1Rs. notes.
Persistent looting by Shopping malls. Items priced @Rs.99, 499 or 999 often,
cashier wont give you one rupee coin back but instead gives a chocolate. (He is
making additional profit because for him cost price of 1 chocolate is less than
1 rupee.)
9/12
7/9/2014
barter
No
Fiat money
(Rs./$)
Bitcoin
In the next article, well see more on Barter vs Money vs Bitcoin, with reference to
storing wealth, account keeping, deferred payment, circular flow of income etc.
parameters. click me
Mock Questions
Assertion reasoning instructions: Each of the following questions contain a set of
Assertion (A) and Reasoning (R) statements. Answer codes are as following
A.
B.
C.
D.
Questions:
1. (A) Money brings down the cost of transaction in trade, compared to barter
system. (R) Money promotes division of labour.
2. (A) A trader is free to refuse payment in Bitcoins. (R) Bitcoin is not a fiat
currency.
3. (A) A Barter economy is less likely to have to food inflation. (R) In Barter
system, trade can happen without double coincidence of wants.
MCQs
4. Correct Statement(s) about Bitcoins?
a. It is a digital fiat currency without fungibility.
b. It is not a fiat currency but has all the properties of a fiat currency.
c. Both A and B
d. Neither A nor B.
5. Find Incorrect Statement(s)
a. One fiat currency can be exchanged with other fiat currency.
http://mrunal.org/2013/12/economy-barter-money-bitcoin-fungibility-double-coincidence-of-wants-division-of-labour-part-1.html/print/
10/12
7/9/2014
Only 1 and 2
Only 2 and 3
Only 1 and 3
All of them.
Q8. Which of the following is/are the benefit(s) of barter system over money
system?
1. Trade is possible without double coincidence of wants.
2. It promotes division of labour
3. Bartered commodities are always fungible.
Choice
A.
B.
C.
D.
Only 1 and 2
Only 2 and 3
Only 1 and 3
None of Them.
Q9. If a Barter economy is transformed into Money economy, what will be the
consequences?
1. Increased Economic Efficiency
2. Increased Transaction costs
3. Increased specialization among workers
Choice
http://mrunal.org/2013/12/economy-barter-money-bitcoin-fungibility-double-coincidence-of-wants-division-of-labour-part-1.html/print/
11/12
7/9/2014
A.
B.
C.
D.
Only 1 and 2
Only 2 and 3
Only 1 and 3
All of them
http://mrunal.org/2013/12/economy-barter-money-bitcoin-fungibility-double-coincidence-of-wants-division-of-labour-part-1.html/print/
12/12