Anda di halaman 1dari 68

EIVIND AAS - JESPER GUNNERLING

CARINE TRUONG - KARL ERIK MORTHEN


BENEDIKT SCHMIDT - ARNAUD PINCET!

AGRICULTURE MACHINERY
INDUSTRY!
HOW TO MAINTAIN POSITION AS AN IMPORTANT GLOBAL PLAYER IN THE
AGRICULTURE MACHINERY INDUSTRY!
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

1!

Executive summary!

The agriculture machinery industry


is a huge and stable industry. The
most profitable players are present
in many geographical areas and
with full- line and standardized
equipment. Emerging markets are
the most promising for future
growth. Sub-Saharan-Africa is
particularly interesting, mainly
because of unutilized arable land,
government support, low
mechanization level and increasing
global attention. !

16.02.2015!

The project group is suggesting


how a virtual firm, Field&Track Co,
should maintain their role as an
important global player in the
industry. Ultimately we will be giving
an entry strategy specifically
tailored for entering Kenya with the
intention of, in time, expanding to
other African countries.
!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

2!

Agenda!

Part I: Global Scope!


1)!

2)!

Market & Industry


environment!

4)!

3)!

Competitive
analysis!

Industry analysis!

?
Scenario !
analysis!

Part II: Africa scope!


1)!

Where is the future!


Growth potential?!

16.02.2015!

2)!

3)!

Market & Industry


environment
in Kenya!

Industry Analysis
of Kenya!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

4)!

Strategy for virtual


global player to
enter Kenya!

3!

MARKET & INDUSTRY


ENVIRONMENT

The food challenge!


Definition of Industry!
PESTEL Analysis!
Future Trends!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

4!

The global food challenge!


The food Challenge!
Market & Industry Environment!

Definition of Industry!

PESTEL Analysis!

Although the population growth rate decreases


in most developed countries, the rapid increase
in developing countries still causes rapid growth
worldwide. !
The demand for food increases with population
growth and higher average standard of living.!

Future Trends!

Higher standards of living imply higher demand


for proteins and thus meat. !
Huge increase in meat consumption in
developing countries!
Additional 1000 Mt of grain needs to be
produced in order to meet the demand in 2050!
On average, 5 tons of grain is needed to
produce 1 ton of meat!

Millionen!

Population evolution!
10000!
9000!
8000!
7000!
6000!
5000!
4000!
3000!
2000!
1000!
0!
1500!

Meat consumption worldwide, in Mt!

Chart Title!

+81%!
470
260
Years!

1700!

1900!

2100!

2010

2050

Rising population and changing diets causes scarcity of food !


Sources: VDMA, Freedonia, FAO, CIA World Fact Book, Oliver Whyman Analysis!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

5!

Severe challenge solutions are known!

Severe challenge solutions are known - machinery is needed!

The food Challenge!


Market & Industry Environment!

Definition of Industry!

PESTEL Analysis!

Global food Challenge!

Increasing population and meat


consumption vastly raises the
demand of food production!

Solutions!
Increase yield!
High quality seeds and
fertilizers can
substantially increase
yield/ha !
Mechanization level in
developing countries is
very low. Mechanization
would increase yield!

Mechanization level
comparison!
(unit of tractor/1000
farmers)!

70-150%!

USA!
German
y!
Brazil!
2010

2050

Future Trends!

1586!
1018!
61!

Africa!

5!

China!

3!

Exploiting unutilized land!


~ 970 million has
available cropland world
wide!
As mechanization,
irrigation and quality of
seeds and fertilizers
improve it can increase
further!

Extensive demand for


agriculture machinery
to increase yield in
developing countries
in the future.

Sources: VDMA, Freedonia, FAO, CIA World Fact Book, Oliver Whyman Analysis!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

6!

Definition of Product Range!


The food Challenge!
Market & Industry Environment!

Definition of Industry!

PESTEL Analysis!

Equipment
type!

Harvesting
machines!

Haying
machinery!

Farm
tractors!

Planting &
fertilizing!

Future Trends!

Plow &
cultivating!

Others (incl.
spraying)!

Spare parts
&
attachments!

Example!

Size in $B
(2008)!

30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Farm Tractors

Harves3ng
Machinery

Plan3ng & Fer3lizing Haying Machinery Plowing & Cul3va3ng

Others

Spare Parts &


AEachments

For easier comparison: A prerequisite for being regarded as a competitor in the analysis is that the
firm at least offers either tractors, harvesting machines or both!

Tractors and Harvesting machines are core products for the largest agricultural machinery companies!
Companies that produce tractors and harvesting machines often have a similar product portfolio!
The two segments counts for almost 45% of the total market in terms of sales (2008)!

Sources: VDMA, Freedonia, FAO, CIA World Fact Book, Oliver Whyman Analysis!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

7!

Market size segmented by products and geographical areas!


The food Challenge!
Market & Industry Environment!

Definition of Industry!

PESTEL Analysis!

Size in $B, by product segments


and geographical areas (2008)!

Farm Tractors!
Harvesting Machinery!
Planting & Fertilizing!
Haying Machinery!
Plowing & Cultivating!
Others!

Future Trends!

Geographical regions!
60 % Established markets with CAGR 4 % (2009-2012)!
40 % Emerging markets with CAGR 8 % (2009-2012)!
The market size of harvesting machinery is a good indicator
of the level of mechanization!
20 % of total market in Established markets!
5 % of total market in China and India!

Global scope, with the market segmented in two very


different market segments in terms of industry environment,
customers, competition, growth potential.!

North Europe! Japan!


America!

China!

Established markets:
60%!

India!

CIS!

Latin
RoW!
America!

Emerging markets
and others: 40%!

Established markets!
Defined as US, Europe & Japan!
Emerging markets!
Defined as BRIC countries (Brazil, Russia, India and
China), Latin America & Africa!

Sources: VDMA, Freedonia, FAO, CIA World Fact Book, Oliver Whyman Analysis!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

8!

Impact of Industry Environment is huge!


The food Challenge!
Market & Industry Environment!

PESTEL Drivers!

Farm Cash
Receipts!
Governmental
Support!

Definition of Industry!

PESTEL Analysis!

Future Trends!

Impact on demand!

Established Markets!

Emerging Markets!

Price increase on farm commodities due to:!


Population growth!
Rising GDP levels!
Scarcity of fertile land!
Urbanization!
Reduced subsidies in the long term:!
Farmers need to finance investment
Increasing subsidies:!
Drives
investments in machinery!
by internal and/or debt financing!

Financial Services!

Developed financial services:!


No impact!

Development of banking systems:!


Machinery financing options for farmers!

Farm Size!

Farmers strive for cost-efficiency:!


Consolidation, which requires new
machinery!

Fragmented landscape:!
Consolidation still not observable!

Technology &
Environment!

Increasing demand for renewable energy:!


Partly driven by increased demand from pharmaceutical and petroleum industry!

Established markets will demand bigger and higher performance machinery!


Emerging markets will demand more machinery adapted to local needs!
Sources: VDMA, Freedonia, FAO, CIA World Fact Book, Oliver Whyman Analysis!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

9!

The Industry Environment impacts the future needs of farmers!


The food Challenge!
Market & Industry Environment!

Trend!

Definition of Industry!

PESTEL Analysis!

Established markets!
Farmers has yield pressure in order to make a

solid living. Precision farming important to


Demand for
precision farming! maximize yield.!

Larger and
specialized
equipment!

Huge farms allows for large and more specialized


machinery. Increasing monoculture will further
trigger the demand for specialized equipment!

Exhaust
emissions
legislation!

Higher requirements on engine technology.


Pressure on established players!

After sales
business!

Farmers loose money for each day they are unable


to use the equipment. High demand for fast and
great service. Emerging independent parts
resellers decreases the potential for the profitable
parts business!

Future Trends!

Emerging markets!
Not a major driver in the next decades. Customer
needs are very fragmented. Mass market demands
low-end affordable machinery. !
Markets are fragmented and thus the demand for
large and specialized machinery is low. Must
increase machinery level and consolidation before
this will become a future trend!
Still relatively low significance of emission
standards. !
Increasing yield pressure puts pressure on the
parts business. Important with reliable low-end
equipment.!

Consolidation & specialization!

Generally low yield, and fragmented


needs !

Bigger and higher performance


agriculture machines!

Mechanization needed, adapted to


local needs!

Sources: VDMA, Freedonia, FAO, CIA World Fact Book, Oliver Whyman Analysis (slide 16 report)!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

10!

INDUSTRY ANALYSIS!

Overview of Players!
Porters five forces!

16.02.2015!

Intensity of Rivalry!
Bargaining power of buyers !
Bargaining power of suppliers!
Threat of new entrants and substitutes !
ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

11!

The main players and their biggest brands!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

16.02.2015!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

Threat of new entrants!

Threat of substitutes!

12!

The Intensity of Global Rivalry!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

John Deere as major player globally with AGCO,


CNH and Kubota as competitors!
High concentration in established markets!
Top-6 players tractors sold in Europe > 85
% of total (2010)!
Economies of scale (together with high
transportation costs and tariffs) drives M&A
activities and strategic partnerships!
Technology, experience and size required
to offer high-end machinery!
The global leaders are in general full-liners!
Players want to leverage from economies
of scope (e.g. distribution, sales, service)!
The global industry growth is expected to be
roughly 7 % from 2012 to 2016!
Players will boost revenues as long as they
have unutilized resources and want to
reach a higher level of economies of scale!
There is a risk of being outcompeted in the
established markets if other global players
find revenue sources in emerging markets!

Threat of new entrants!

Threat of substitutes!

Sales revenues (2011)!

AGCO Corp!
CLAAS!
CNH Global!
Deere & Co!
Kubota Corp!
Mahindra & Mahindra!
SAME Deutz-Fahr!
Other!

Rivalry among competitors is moderate on a global level. !


Players grow mainly by market development rather than market penetration. !
Sources: Bloomberg, Google Finance, Annual reports of Deere, AGCO, CNH, CLAAS, Farmers Guardian 2008, Interview with Marco Sigg, AGCO Corp. !

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

13!

The Intensity of Rivalry in Local Emerging Markets!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

Threat of new entrants!

Threat of substitutes!

The global incumbents face competition from adaptive local players in many markets. !
Nevertheless, to which grade a global player is willing to adapt its products to local needs, is highly
dependent on how much that player is willing to give up economies of scale!
Local players!

Global incumbents!

Adaptation!

Proprietary technology!

Knowledge of specific
topologies and farming!

Superior service !

Low-end smaller machinery!

Financing options!

Customer knowledge!

Economies of scale!

A general rule: The smaller the machines, the more intense is the rivalry.!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

14!

US-China Rivalry Comparison!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

USA!

Threat of new entrants!

Threat of substitutes!

China!
Well-established firms: Deere, Iseki, Kubota,
Yanmar, CNH, Mahindra & Mahindra!

Primary brand of tractors &


combines in the US Market!
John Deere
Case ICH
New Holland
Agco

Local firms: China Yituo Group (First tractors,


Shandong Shifeng, Shandong Foton, Jiansu
Yueda, Changzhou Dongfeng, Anhui Changiang!
The competition is fiercer in China!

Other

Customers strive for cost-efficiency by


consolidation and thus, are willing to pay for
global players high-end machinery!
John Deere has grown with the US market and
found itself in a very profitable situation!

US market: !
Oligopoly and moderate market growth!
Chinese market: !
Global incumbents compete with local
players!

Sources: Financial reports of all the agricultural machinery industries, Bloomberg, FAO!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

15!

The buyer bargaining power differ among customers and markets!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Dealer!

Many dealers!
The more low-end
machinery (less
differentiation), the
increased bargaining
power, due to easier
comparison!
No threat of vertical
integration!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

Threat of new entrants!

Farmers in Established Markets!

Contractor!

Contractors demand both


high-performance tractors
and harvesting machinery!
Contractors value
efficiency, service and
quality !
Put pressure on players to
offer top-performance
technology on both
tractors and harvesters!

High quality, improved efficiency,


and service are needed and thus,
price sensitiveness is low!
Switching costs due to brand loyalty
(e.g. knowledge and experience of a
certain tractors brand)!

Farmers in Emerging markets!

Established markets: !
!Low/moderate bargaining power of buyers!
Emerging markets: !
!The financial constraints of farmers lead to
!moderate/high bargaining power of buyers!

Threat of substitutes!

Valuation of low price, financing


options and proximity to dealership. !
The buyer power is higher due to
financial constraints!

Sources: VDMA, Freedonia, FAO, CIA World Fact Book, Oliver Whyman Analysis!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

16!

Bargaining power of suppliers!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

Threat of new entrants!

Threat of substitutes!

Most of the suppliers have low bargaining power

Low differentiation in components and raw materials!


Backward integration possible for certain components!
Low concentration on supplier side (e.g. motors and standardized components)!
Most of the suppliers are required to communicate on their structure and on the way
they produce: John Deere has a supplier quality manual that demands high quality
level off their suppliers!

For the high-end segment and specific products, supplier power is high

The high-end machinery segment have components supplied by few high-technology


firms (e.g. GPS suppliers have high bargaining power)!
Boschs unique know-how on motor pumps are an example where players are price
takers!

The bargaining power of suppliers is very heterogeneous. !


General rule: The more high-end the segment, the higher bargaining power of suppliers, due to
technology differentiation. !
Sources: John Deere supplier quality manual, Inteview with Marco Sigg, AGCO Corp.!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

17!

Threat of new entrants!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

Capital requirements are high!

Threat of new entrants!

Threat of substitutes!

Economies of scale!

Large investments needed due to heavy


machinery production and sales, R&D expenses
and factories: !
AGCO own 10 large factories worldwide!
Equipment and inventories account for 24%
of John Deere total assets!
John Deere invested 784M (4% of sales) in
R&D in 2010!
Estimations show that around 120 Sales
offices are required to cover the UK market!
High end segment is even more intensive as
long as it requires specific technologies (A/C
devices, touchscreen technologies)!

The well performing firms are either enjoying


economies of scale or are making an effort to
standardize production of multiple brands in
order to gain economies of scale:!
John Deere is today the top performing
firm, and through standardize production
of parts they have a profit margin of 14%!
Other high performing incumbents are
switching towards using standardized
parts in multiple brands to mover towards
the same level of economies of scale as
John Deere !

New entrant will find it difficult to meet the capital requirements needed to enter and will have
trouble differentiating themselves on price due to economies of scale !

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

18!

Threat of new entrants!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

Switching costs!

No!
38%!

Yes!
62%!

Threat of substitutes!

M&A activities!

Many farmers are emotionally attached to


the brands and will not consider purchasing
another brand!
Network effects may also occur if the market
share is large. A new high-end tractor bought
by a farmer might positively affect the brand
awareness from neighbor farms.!
Brand Loyalty in the US market
Would you consider yourself as brand loyal
when you purchase agricultural machinery?!

Threat of new entrants!

Many large players uses M&A activities as a


growth strategy. If a new player develops a
strong brand, the well performing players has
opportunity to buy the firm either to increase
their product portfolio or leverage the
technology into existing product offerings.
Recent M&A activities among the well
performing players:!
Kubota acquired Kverneland in 2012!
CLAAS acquired RENAULT agriculture in
2010!
AGCO acquired Valtra in 2004!

New entrants will also have trouble with capturing market share due to network effects and
customer loyalty. If a new entrant is well performing they face the threat of being acquired by the
large players in the industry!
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

19!

Threat of substitutes!
Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Direct substitutes!

Human capital !
Agricultural tools!
Not relevant even if the cost
is lower: they are not efficient
compare to machinery
(increase from 60 to 70q/ha
in France from 1989 to 2005
through mechanization)!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

Threat of new entrants!

Threat of substitutes!

Indirect substitutes!

Production of normal food by


other means that normal
agricultural production (3D
printing)!
Substitution of land: water, air!

Change in consumer behavior!

Might not affect the


agricultural industry: meat
production requires even
more cereals than when they
are directly consumed!

Robots!
Higher threats of classical
machinery, they are however
already integrated in some
AMCs!

Because the industry is related to food production, the threats of substitutes are very low!
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

20!

Takeaways from Porters Five Forces on the global industry!


Overview of Players!
Industry Analysis!

Intensity of rivalry!

Buyer Bargaining Power!

Supplier Bargaining Power!

Threat of new entrants!

Threat of substitutes!

Threat of new entrants is low!


Capital intensive industry!
Differentiation and economies of scale highly crucial on a global scope!

Supplier power is
moderate!
Mostly low supplier power
due to a large number of
suppliers!
High-end products that
require engineering skills
has larger bargaining power
(Motor pumps, GPS etc.)!

Rivalry is
moderate!
Moderate in
established markets!
Moderate/High in
emerging markets!

Buyer power is low to


moderate!
Low in the established
markets, due to
differentiation in terms of
technology!
Moderate in emerging
markets due to farmers
financial constraints!

Threat of substitutes is very low!


Probability of a major disruptive technology in agricultural machinery is low!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

21!

COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS!

Strategic groups!
Firms analysis: What do certain market leaders do good?!
Future key factors for competitive success for market leaders!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

22!

What strategic dimensions are of relevance in this industry?!


Strategic groups!
Competitive Analysis!

What certain firms do good!

Key factors for success!

Hypotheses from the Porters Five


Forces!

Economies of Scale should yield a


correlation between EBIT margin and
Revenues!

If a player offers a wide product range,


revenues should be higher and
economies of scope should lead to
higher EBIT margin!

Measures to support/reject hypotheses!

Global coverage should yield higher


revenues!
High-end incumbents get a premium from
established market customer and thus,
EBIT margin for those players should be
higher!

16.02.2015!

EBIT margin & Revenues (including D&A


which is an important post due to high fixed
costs)!

Width of the product range (specialist, multiliner, full-liner)!

Continents present in (1-6)!

Quality aspect (Low-end, High-end)!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

23!

Size is crucial!
Strategic groups!
Competitive Analysis!

What certain firms do good!

Key factors for success!

16.00!

Deere & Co!

Revenue!
14.00!

Companies able
to ensure a large
geographic
coverage can
usually enjoy
better margins.!

12.00!

Profit margin!

Kubota Corp!

10.00!
Mahindra &!
Mahindra!

CLAAS!

8.00!

The Economies of
Scale holds
within the high
revenues interval,
but not in general.!

AGCO!

6.00!
CNH Global!
Escorts!

4.00!
2.00!

First Tractor Co
Ltd(YTO)!

Dae Dong Industrial


Co Ltd!
Iseki & Co Ltd!

0.00!
0!

1!

2!

3!

4!

5!

6!

Continents present in!


Sources: Annual reports, Google finance, Bloomberg, financials.morningstar.com!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

24!

Size is crucial!
Strategic groups!
Competitive Analysis!

4.00!

What certain firms do good!

Profit margin!

CLAAS

3.50!

Low / high end products!

Key factors for success!

Deere & Co

CNH Global

Companies able
to enter the high
end market can
usually enjoy
better margins.!

3.00!
AGCO Corp

2.50!
First Tractor Co
Ltd (YTO)

A wider product
range product
range usually
increases
margins, too.!

2.00!
Iseki & Co Ltd

1.50!

Kubota
Corp
Dae Dong
Industrial Co Ltd

Escorts

1.00!
Mahindra & Mahindra

0.50!

0.00!
0.00

0.50

1.00

1.50

2.00

2.50

3.00

3.50

4.00

Width of product range!

Sources: Annual reports, Google finance, Bloomberg, financials.morningstar.com!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

25!

Four defined strategic groups!


Strategic groups!
Competitive Analysis!

What certain firms do good!

Key factors for success!

Market leaders

Low-end global players

Firms!
High revenues and
Deere & Co!
margins in general!
AGCO!
Great global coverage!
CNH Global!
Wide product range (i.e.
(SAME Deutz-Fahr)
full-liners)!
High-end machinery!

Firms!
Mahindra &
Mahindra!
Kubota!

Low-end local players

Specialists

Firms!
Iseki!
First Tractor
Company Ltd.!
Dae Dong Industrial
Escorts!

Lower global coverage!


Small product range!
Low-end smaller
machinery!

Firms!
Claas

Great global coverage!


Small product range!
Low-end machinery!

Lower global coverage!


Specialized products!
Extremely high-end
machinery !

To ensure that the market leaders outperform the other strategic groups in emerging markets, the
key factors for future competitive success within this group must be considered. This is done by
analysing what certain players within this group have done good. !
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

26!

What Deere & Co has done well!


Strategic groups!
Competitive Analysis!

What certain firms do good!

Key factors for success!

Operating margin (in %)!

Enables platform production and thus


economies of scale in the manufacturing
process!
Standardized components lower the
bargaining power of suppliers (multiple
sourcing) and thus, Deere could lower the
purchasing costs!

Operating margin (in %)!

Highest revenues, highest profit margin!


20!
15!

Deere!

10!

AGCO!
5!

CNH!

0!
-5!

2008!

Deere could live with their inefficient distribution


networks!
The Return on Invested Capital (ROIC) could be lower
than the other market leaders, but the Economic Value
Added (EVA) is still higher !

Financial Leverage (in X)!

Deere leverages from debt financing and


thus has lower weighted average cost of
capital (WACC)!

2010!

2011!

2012!

Financial leverage !
(Assets over Equity)!

High financial leverage!

2009!

10!
8!
6!

Deere!

4!

AGCO!

2!

CNH!

0!
2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

Sources: Bloomberg, Google Finance, financials.morningstar.com, Annual reports of Deere!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

27!

What AGCO has done well!


Strategic groups!
Competitive Analysis!

What certain firms do good!

Key factors for success!

Inorganic growth through market


development!

Early positioning in growth regions!


Relatively adaptive due to wide product
range!
Entering strategic partnerships or acquiring
local players which speed up adaption and
keep assets as low as possible!

Working Capital (in M$)!

Working Capital (in M$)!


25000!
20000!
15000!

Access to new markets and fast adaption!


Synergies, e.g. Strategic Alliances, Marketing,
Sales!
Access to Technology, which is crucial to gain a
competitive advantage in multiple product segments!

CNH!

0!
2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

Fixed Assets Turnover (in %)!


Fixed Assets Turnover (in %)!

Higher fixed assets turnover !


Lower working cap than Deere and CNH!

AGCO!

5000!

Strategic aspects of AGCOs acquisitions!


Centralization of distribution centers, sales, services
and thus more efficient distribution network !

Deere!

10000!

12!
10!
8!
Deere!

6!

AGCO!

4!

CNH!

2!
0!
2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

Bloomberg, Google Finance, financials.morningstar.com, Annual reports of Deere!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

28!

What are the key factors for market leaders to ensure competitive success
in the future? !
Strategic groups!
Competitive Analysis!

What certain firms do good!

Increase Revenues!
Continue to position early in
future market growth regions
(e.g. emerging markets)!

Focus on adaption !
Consider the price sensitivity of
customers in those markets!
Offer financing options!
M&A activity or strategic
partnerships to speed up local
adaption!

Long-term cost reductions!


Reach higher level of
economies of scale and lower
bargaining power of suppliers
through:!

Revenues

16.02.2015!

Streamlining of product portfolio!


Standardization and
modularization of components!
Platform production!

Supplier segmentation to
leverage from knowledge or buy
cheaper!

Profit

Key factors for success!

Supplier of strategic components


-> Partnerships to leverage from
suppliers R&D and knowledge!
Suppliers of less strategic
relevant components
-> Opportunistic relationships or
consider outsourcing (e.g.
engines)!

Costs

Short-term cost reductions!


Capacity reduction to increase
ROIC, especially after M&A!

Increase financial leverage!

Debt cheaper than equity


-> Lowered WACC increases the
economic value added (EVA)!

(Secure Parts business)!


Parts leverages the profits
heavily and is therefore
important for future competitive
success!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

Centralization of distribution
centers, sales and service
centers!
Elimination of duplicate support
activities (e.g. HR, Legal)!
Decrease working capital!

Contracts with dealers!


Patents!
29!

SCENARIO ANALYSIS!

Key factors for scenario analysis!


Impact-probability analysis!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

30!

Possible threats to change the industry - Scenario Analysis!


Key factors for scenario analysis!
Scenario Analysis!

Type!

Impact-Probability-Analysis!

Key factor!
Raw material price volatility!

Why important?!
Cost driver in machinery!

Fuel price volatility!

Cost driver for end customer!

Factors that New entrants from automobile, forestry, construction


could threaten or mining industry!
industry
profitability! Environmental factors that limit crop production /
reduce land fertility!

Potential of intensified rivalry!

Productivity decreases!

C02 emission taxes skyrocket!

Cost driver for end customer!

Substitutes such as chemical production / 3D printing


of food!

Key driver of demand for crops!

Factors that
could threaten
demand for the Diets switches from meat to seafood!
industry output !
Population growth not as expected!

Key driver of demand for crops!


Key driver of demand for crops!

We analyse what impact and probability these factors have to decide whether to investigate further!
http://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2419277,00.asp&utm_source=feedly!
http://moneymorning.com/2013/02/12/two-reasons-to-expect-greater-volatility-in-oil-prices/!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

31!

Impact and probability analysis!


Key factors for scenario analysis!
Scenario Analysis!

Impact-Probability-Analysis!

Impact-probability-plot!

Register of threats!

10
9
High

Threat 8

Threat 7

7
Impact

Profitability driver threats!


1. Raw material price volatility!
2. Fuel price volatility!
3. Increased competition through entrants from
automotive, forestry, construction or mining
industry!
4. Environmental factors that limit crop
production / reduce land fertility!
5. C02 emission taxes skyrocket!

Threat 5

5
4

Threat 4

Threat 1

Threat 6
Threat 2

2
Low
1

Threat 3

0
0

Low
2

4
5
6
Probability

High
8
9

10

Demand driver threats!


6. Substitutes such as chemical production / 3D
printing of food!
7. Diets switches to seafood!
8. Population growth much lower than expected!

No threat combines high impact with high probability, and we conclude that major changes in the
industry from external factors are unlikely. !
http://www.un.org/esa/population/publications/longrange2/WorldPop2300final.pdf!
http://moneymorning.com/2013/02/12/two-reasons-to-expect-greater-volatility-in-oil-prices/!
http://newsfeed.time.com/2013/01/11/overcrowding-nah-the-worlds-population-may-actually-be-declining/!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

32!

Which emerging market is of highest attractiveness for market leaders? !

Part I: Global Scope!


1)!

2)!

Market & Industry


environment!

4)!

3)!

Competitive
analysis!

Industry analysis!

?
Scenario !
analysis!

Part 2: Growth Strategy !


5)!

Where is the future!


Growth potential?!

16.02.2015!

6)!

7)!

Market & Industry


environment
in Kenya!

8)!

Industry Analysis
of Kenya!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

Strategy for !
entering Kenya!

33!

WHERE IS THE FUTURE GROWTH


POTENTIAL?!
Where
Comparison
of emerging
is the
futuremarkets!
growth
African comparison!

16.02.2015!

potential?!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

34!

Overview of important factors in different emerging markets!


Comparison of emerging markets!
Future growth potential!

Indicator!

African comparison!

Brazil!

Russia!

India!

China!

SS Africa!

Agricultural
preconditions!

59 million ha of arable
123 million ha of arable
land.!
land. Consolidated
Increasing consolidation!
agricultural sector!

161 million ha of arable 142 million ha of arable


237 million ha of arable
land. Very fragmented
land. Fragmented
land. Very fragmented!
agricultural sector!
agricultural sector!

Productivity/
Mechanization!

Relatively high
Low productivity despite
productivity and
high mechanization level
mechanization level (61)!
(96)!

Relatively low
High productivity despite Very low mechanization
mechanization level (6)! lowest emerging market
level, high potential
Low productivity!
mechanization level (3)!
growth!

Very strong, due to


potential huge
agricultural growth
thanks to mechan.!
Emerging government
Moderate, as India has
Strong with focus on Mainly limited to national
Very strong focus on the initiatives, cooperation
Government support!
a current focus on
national players!
players!
agricultural sector!
with development
infrastructure!
programs!
Fully developed network
Developed network with No network of global
Developed network of
Local and global
of local suppliers, but
Emerging global
both local & global
suppliers and low quality
both global and local
suppliers!
limited number of global
suppliers, few local!
suppliers!
of national suppliers!
suppliers!
suppliers!
RANKING!
3!
4!
5!
2!
1!

Yield Pressure (needs


footnote)!

Medium due to
balanced ratio of
population to utilized
land!

Weak due to low


population!

Strong, due to
imbalance between
population and utilized
land!

Very strong, due to


imbalance between
population and arable
land!

Sub Saharan Africa seems to be the final frontier with huge arable land and low mechanization
level. The potential for an increase in mechanization might be large and are depending on external
factors. !
Sources: VDMA, Freedonia, FAO, CIA World Fact Book, Oliver Whyman Analysis!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

35!

Introducing the Sub-Saharan-African region!


Comparison of emerging markets!
Future growth potential!

African comparison!

Economic!
Huge potential growth rate (based
on potential growth for agricultural
goods of 50% to 68% by 2030)!
More than 50% of the population
work in agriculture manually !

Political!
Instability in some countries
Growing commitment for some
governments encouraged by
international development
programmes!

Technological!
Lack of technological knowledge !
Lack of infrastructure
(transportation, irrigation,
electricity)!

Social!
Fast growing population!
Education and training
needed for the use of new
technological material!
Small-scale farming!

Environmental!
Holds around 60% of the worlds
remaining uncultivated land.
Environmental circumstances
allows for two seasons of crop
per year. Global warming
increases yield pressure.!

Legal!
Problems with property rights,
Farmers usually rent land from the
government. In many countries
women are not allowed to own land.!

Sources: FAO, CIA World Fact Book, IMF reports (Regional Economic Outlook: Sub-Saharan Africa, Oct 2012)!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

36!

Determining a region with the highest potential for mechanization!


Comparison of emerging markets!
Future growth potential!

African comparison!

75 % of the absolute increase in output is expected to occur in two clusters of countries !


Region II!
Sudan!

Region I!
Ghana!
Cte dIvoire!
Nigeria!
Cameroon!
Angola!

Ethiopia!

Kenya!
Tanzania!

Region II!
Higher political stability!
Vast investments from abroad in practically all
the countries during the last decade!
Higher increase in the Human Development
index the last couple of years!

Mozambique!
Madagascar!

Region II stands out as the most promising region. To decide which country to enter, we need
to compare agricultural demand drivers and PESTEL factors for the countries in region II!

Sources: Four lessons for transforming African agriculture, McKinsey Quarterly, April 2011, FAO Statistics 2012!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

37!

Agricultural factors and credit ratings in region II !


Comparison of emerging markets!
Future growth potential!

African comparison!

Country!

Arable Land
(1000ha)!

# of
tractors!

Tractors/
arable land!

Fertilizer/
arable land!

Credit rating!
(Fitch)!

C. R. Outlook
(Fitch)!

Infrastructu
re inv.!

Mozambique!

2800!

9400!

3.35!

17.95!

CCC!

negative!

low!

Ethiopia!

13606!

3000!

0.22!

32.20!

CCC!

stable!

high!

Kenya!

5300!

14000!

2.64!

95.44!

B+!

stable!

high!

Madagascar!

37500!

30000!

0.8!

0.99!

BB-!

stable!

high!

Sudan!

20698!

22600!

1.09!

4.0!

CCC!

negative!

middle!

Tanzania!

9600!

6000!

0.625!

9.66!

CCC!

stable!

middle!

The promising countries differ very on each factor. Kenya has overall strong agricultural numbers
and strong credit rating !

Sources: faostat.fao.org, tradingeconomics.com, afdb.org!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

38!

A selection of PESTEL factors for the region II countries!


Comparison of emerging markets!
Future growth potential!

African comparison!

Competitiveness comparison!
Tanzania

Ethiopia

Innova3on
Business
sophis3ca3on

Madagascar
Ins3tu3ons
5
4
3
2

Mozambique

Kenya *

Infrastructure

Macroeconomic
environment

1
Market size

Technological
readiness

Health and primary


educa3on

Financing and Infrastructure are the two main


factors that drives success in Africa for the
MAS1!
The competitiveness comparison shows that
Kenya has an overall higher ranking than
neighbouring countries. !
Kenya ranked first compared to the other 5
countries in terms of overall infrastructure2!
Also, Kenya is located in the middle of the
region, making it a geographically strategic
starting point.!

Higher educa3on and


training

Financial market
development

Goods market
eciency
Labor market
eciency

*No data on Sudan

By its central position in the region as well as its high ranking compared to neighbouring countries, !
Kenya is the most promising country to entry for an agricultural machinery company.!
Sources: 1US agri equipment giant AGCO explains why it will invest $100 m ion Africa

16.02.2015!

2The

Global Competitiveness report 2011-2012, World Economic Forum!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

39!

Kenya as a favorable point of entry!


Comparison of emerging markets!
Future growth potential!

African comparison!

Strengths and opportunities!

Arable land!
Need for mechanization!
Yield pressure!
Mechanization readiness!
Foreign investments and
global attention!
Government commitment!

Global

16.02.2015!

Hindrances!
Lack of infrastructure
even though highest
among region II!
Mainly small farms!
Training of farmers
to use equipment is
required!

..Analysis..

..Kenya

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

Africa seems to be the


last continent that is
not dominated by the
market leaders.
Presence in this
continent is important
for future growth.
Without conducting an
industry analysis,
Kenya seems to be a
favourable entry point
in Africa for an
agricultural machinery
company. We now
need to look at the
industry environment
in Kenya to develop
and implement an
appropriate strategy
for entering the market!
40!

INDUSTRY ANALYSIS OF KENYA!


Porters five forces!
Competition!
Bargaining power of buyers and suppliers!
Threat of new entrants and substitutes!
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

41!

Existing players in the Kenyan market!


Competition!
Industry Analysis of Kenya!

Customer characteristics!

Bargaining powers!

CNH was first to move in to the Kenyan


market:!
Joint venture with CMC motors, located in
Kenya, Uganda and Tanzania!
Domestic assembly to avoid high import tariffs!
Increasing brand recognition through training
farmers in a model farm!
Putting huge efforts in making sales!
Late entry of other large competitors by joint
venture!
John Deere entered through Tata Kenya!
AGCO entered with Massey Ferguson
through Tractor Corner!
Kubota entered through Car & Company!

Threats!

Market share in terms of sales!

30%!
70%!

CNH!

Others!

The industry is very concentrated with CNH enjoying 70% of the market!
However, they are struggeling with sales due to the level of maturity in the market. !
The state of the market indicates that competition is not a major threat.!
Sources: CMC motors, kmi.co Kenya & John Deere, Tractorcorner, Capitalfm.co.ke!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

42!

Customer characteristics Kenya!


Competition!
Industry Analysis of Kenya!

Endcustomer!
types!

Customer characteristics!

Bargaining powers!

Hirers!

Farmers!

Some large and small scale farmers


are hirers. They predominantly rent
machines to their neighbouring
farmers. !

Number of medium to
large farms !
( < 3 ha ) !

Differences
and farmers
needs!

Number of small farms!


( 0,2 3 ha ) !

< 25%!

Farmers produce a wide range of products!


What are the
farmers
producing? !

Threats!

Food crops!

Cash crops!

Diary and
meat!

Cereals!
Pulses!
Roots and tubers!

Coffee, Tea, ! Cattle meat!


Sugar cane, Milk!
Cotton !

> 75%!
Tractors will increase
production efficiency of all
crops. !
Other machinery must be
quite specialized. !
There are some differences
but the small farmers (>
75%) have basic needs.!

What differences are there between


farmers!

What do the current farmers value !

Land holding!
Farm family labour!
Resources!
Types of animals!

Increase household food!


Income security!
Employment opportunity!
Life style enhancement!

Sources: FAO reports!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

43!

Moderate buyer bargaining power suppliers are negligible!


Competition!
Industry Analysis of Kenya!

Customer characteristics!

Bargaining powers!

Buyer bargaining power is low to moderate!


Buyer price sensitivity: !
Kenyan farmers are largely very price sensitive.!
Availability of substitute products: !
Most farmers are using animals. Choosing to keep
using animals, is indeed a possibility.!
Buyer concentration!
There is little cooperation between farmers by
now, and few manufacturers providing machinery. !
Buyer
price
sensitivity!

Availability of
substitute
products!

Buyer
concentration!

High!

Moderate!

Low!

Threats!

Supplier bargaining power!


Business
model in
Kenya!
Interaction
with
Kenyan
suppliers!

Bargaining
power of
buyers!

Moderate!

1.
Produce

2.
Assemble!

3.
Export!

Yes!

Little or
no !

No!

The likely models for a firm entering, is


either 2 or 3. !
Either way, there is little or no interaction
with Kenyan suppliers.!
The supplier power will therefore be
according to the Porters on the global
level. !

Sources: FAO reports!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

44!

Threat of entry and threat of substitutes in Kenyan market!


Competition!
Industry Analysis of Kenya!

Customer characteristics!

Bargaining powers!

Threat of new entries !


only from market leaders!

Threat of substitutes

1!

Entry
strategy!
Joint
venture!
Acquisitions!
Start from
scratch!

Deals !
with policy
makers and
NGOs!

Education !
and training!
for farmers
and!
local policy
makers!

Trust!
from the
com-!
munity to
increase
productivity!

An entry in Kenya demands a long term strategy


and large investments in order to capture a
substantial part of the market. The risk, and
possibly the return, is therefor high. The capital
investments needed in order to implement this long
term strategy is high, and the threat of entry is
only from the large players!
16.02.2015!

Threats!

Machinery resale!
Resale of second hand tractors!
enables farmers to get powerful and!
reliable machinery for about half the
price of a new machine !

2!

Manual labor!
Both prices and access to manual
labor is good. Farm animals can also
be a good substitute for Kenyas
many small-farm owners!

3!
Crop substitutes!
Farmers might shift their food crops
to crops that does not!
demand a high level of machinery!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

45!

STRATEGY FOR FIELD&TRACK CO


TO ENTER KENYA!

Strategy outline!
Two phase model!
Product portfolio!

16.02.2015!

Entry strategy!
SWOT!
Issues and challenges!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

46!

Strategic goals and the traditional strategy for market entry in Kenya!
Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Strategic goals for market


entry!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

Gap! !

Capture market share!


Strengthen brand image!

Unable of expanding the market


and increasing the machinery
readiness in Kenya.!

Maintain position as
market leader!

Issues and challenges!

Traditional strategy for


market entry!
Joint venture with local
firm!

Expand market!
Kill competition!

SWOT!

Gap!!

Sales model!
Low end products!
Internal or external
financial solutions!

There is a gap between the goals and what the firm can achieve by entering with the same strategy as the
incumbents. How can F&T fill this gap? !
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

47!

Strategy outline!
Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

SWOT!

Issues and challenges!

F&T will ensure a profitable business in Sub-Saharan-Africa by implementing a two-phase strategy with the
aim of gaining market share and making small and mid-size farmers use agriculture machinery.!

Phase I:!
Renting!

Phase II:!
Selling!

The first phase will make less


affluent farmers able to use
machinery and strengthen F&Ts
brand.!

The second phase will in turn


serve a large market and ensure
a profitable business.!

What is meant by the renting model, and is it feasible ? !

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

48!

Renting model !
Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

Strategy!

SWOT!

Issues and challenges!

Support activity Demo Farm!

Renting easy-to-use machinery!

Educate farmers!

Joint venture with local firm to benefit from

Allow farmers to familiarize themselves with

existing distribution network.!

F&Ts products!

Resale of used tractors!

Demonstrate for policy makers that higher


mechanization increases yield!

The main reasons for entering with a renting


model is that it will:!
Boost the machinery readiness
development!
Enable F&T to defeat competition by
providing a cheaper alternative!
Give fast product feedback which is very
valuable when adapting to local needs!
But can the renting price be low enough? !
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

49!

Pricing example - Tractors !


Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

SWOT!

Issues and challenges!

Engine
size!
(in HP)!

Unit price!
to buy ($)!

Fuel cost
+!
($/h)!

Maintenance +! Depreciation
($/h)!
+!
($/h)!

Overhead
=!
($/h)!

Total costs!
($/h)!

60!

26000!

10,45!

0,33!

3,47!

3,83!

18,08!

105!

80000!

18,30!

1,00!

10,67!

11,79!

41,75!

Based on!
Insurance & housing!

7%!

Nominal interest rate!

1%!

# years in use!

12!

Fuel consumption gallons/hp/hour!

0,044!

Price of diesel/gallon!

3,6!

Lubrication costs in % of fuel


consumption!

10%!

Salvage value!

36%!

Repair cost as % of machine price!

0,06!

Break even renting


price!

Renting model makes sense from a


financial point of view. The price of
renting tractors is low compared to
buying. !
This also makes the small farmers
likely to directly use the service
without a middle man (contractor) !

Sources: Lazarus, William F. "Machinery cost estimates." University of Minnesota Extension, St. Paul (2009)., http://www.farmdoc.illinois.edu/manage/machinery/machinery_tractors.html !

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

50!

The two phase model!


Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

Evolving into selling model!

SWOT!

Issues and challenges!

Possible evolution!

Higher mechanization readiness, increasing

(# of tractors rented or sold)!

Ren3ng

yield and income of farmers expands the market


willing to buy tractors!

Selling

The time it takes for the market to mature,


largely depends on external factors!

Recall: Filling the gap with a renting period!

Sales model is introduced when the market is


ready for it, gradually taking over for renting!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

51!

Simulation of the sales over time!


Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

Evolution of the number of tractors!


60000
50000
40000
30000
20000
10000
0

Issues and challenges!

Evolution of sales ($ Millions)!


200
180
160
140
120
100
80
60
40
20
0

1.50
1.00
0.50
-
2012
2014
2016
2018
2020
2022
2024
2026
2028

70000

SWOT!

Renting phase!

2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 2024 2026 2028 2030 2032 2034 2036 2038 2040

The number of tractors is likely to increase steadily for the 15 years to


come. It is then expected to increase more rapidly, time around which the
selling phase can start.!
After farmers get used to machinery thanks to the renting schemes,
revenues up to $ 180 millions can be generated. !

Sources: FAO stats, Agriculture statistics on www. Nationmaster.com (data for Mexico), http://thepeople.co.ke/story.php?com=41&item=3059#.UYai_0o_iSo!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

52!

Product Portfolio!
Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

SWOT!

Issues and challenges!

Tractors

Harvesters

Add-ons

Spare parts and

ConservaHon add-ons

30 to 150hp!
Lower range for
small farms!
Higher range for
larger farms or
contractors!

Adapted to local
needs and to local
products!
Coffee!
Sugar cane!
Grain!
Corn!
++!

Seeders!
Ploughs!
Cultivators!
Harrows!

Tractors are the core of the portfolio. To increase efficiency in all steps of farming, !
harvesters, add-ons and conservation parts are included. !
Maintenance and service requires the supply of spare parts.!
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

53!

Why joint venture? !


Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Entry strategy!

Joint Venture!

M & A!
Pros!

Product portfolio!

Cons!

Pros !

Cons!

Possible to
locate suitable
company!

Work moral in
acquired
company!

Lowest risk!

Must agree on
final assembly!

Use existing
suppliers and
distribution
channels!

Capital
intensive!

Lowest capital
requirements!

Must agree on
Hilti-strategy!

Private
ownership!

Risky!
Problems
during merging
process!

SWOT!

Issues and challenges!

Start from scratch!


Pros!

Cons!

Private
ownership!

Time
consuming!
Capital
intensive!

Easy access
to distribution
channels and
suppliers!

Build up
distribution
channels and
relations with
suppliers!

Many possible
partnering
companies!

Build up trust
with authorities
and end
customers!

Joint venture with an existing African firm is the most promising entry strategy. Efforts is needed to
find a suitable, multinational partnering company.!
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

54!

SWOT for F&T entering Kenya!

SWOT!

Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

Strengths!

Former adaptation to emerging markets!


Kenya has a central position in the market
expansion region!
Existing agricultural machinery supply chains!
Government commitment to development in
agriculture and infrastructure !
F&T is a global well-known player!

Relatively uncertain political evolution (although


trend towards improvements and democracy)!
Specific farm configuration (ethnic groups)!

Threats!

Possible market expansion to neighbouring


countries and to the whole continent!
Possible joint-ventures with Kenyan agricultural
machinery manufacturers or local players!
Possible partnerships with increasing number of
agricultural projects!

16.02.2015!

Issues and challenges!

Weaknesses!

Opportunities!

SWOT!

Slow adaptation to new technological


machinery!
Slow creation of adequate infrastructure!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

55!

Issues and challenges!


Strategy outline!
F&Ts strategy!

The two phase model!

Product portfolio!

Entry strategy!

SWOT!

Issues and challenges!

Issues and challenges!

Possible neutralizing initiatives!

High capital requirements!

Import used tractors from other markets to lower initial


investments.!

Reaching the farmers!

Joint Venture with local firm provides distribution channels!


High service level and low prices make renting attractive.!

Seasonal demand!

Seasonal renting prices with lower prices during heat


periods to encourage use outside season!

Need of marketing / sales force!

Outsource renting service and only supply machinery. !

Too small farms: !


No need or money for machinery?!

Encourage coalitions of farmers to afford tractors. Higher


utilization rate of machinery.!

Complete change in business model:


Manufacturer as service company?!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

56!

Summary!
1) Market & Industry environment:!

After decades of growth still high growth rates!


Population growth and higher standards of living increase demand for crop!
Global players reach out to emerging markets!

2) Where is the future Growth potential?:!

Low yields and mechanization in African countries!


Much lowly unutilized arable land and ambitious governments!
Biggest potential in Kenya and adjacent countries!

3) Strategy for virtual global player to enter Kenya:!

16.02.2015!

Two phase strategy: First renting then selling!


1. Renting at affordable prices to expand market!
2. Selling to increase company profit!

Gaining market share and farmer loyalty!


Preferably in joint venture with local player!
Renting as tool for geographic growth!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

57!

BACKUP SLIDES!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

58!

Margins & growth rates!

Operating margin (in %)!


Operating margin (in %)!

16!
14!
12!
10!

Deere!

8!

AGCO!
Kubota!

6!

CNH!

4!

M&M!

2!
0!
-2!

2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

Gross margin (in %)!


Gross margin (in %)!

60!
50!
40!

Deere!

30!

AGCO!
Kubota!

20!

CNH!

10!

M&M!

0!
2008!
16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!
59!

The growth is heavily affected by the economic crisis!

CAGR over 3 years (in %)!


40!
35!

CAGR over 3 years (in %)!

30!
25!
Deere!

20!

AGCO!
15!

Kubota!
CNH!

10!

M&M!

5!
0!
2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

-5!
-10!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

60!

PROFITABILITY RATIOS!
ROA (in %)!

ROIC (in %)!


20!

ROA (in %)!

8!

Deere!

6!

AGCO!

4!

Kubota!
CNH!

2!

M&M!

0!
-2!

2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

ROIC (in %)!

10!

15!

Deere!

10!

AGCO!
Kubota!

5!

CNH!
M&M!

0!
-5!

2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

ROE (in %)!


50!
ROE (in %)!

40!

Deere!

30!

AGCO!

20!

Kubota!

10!

CNH!
M&M!

0!
-10!

2008!

16.02.2015!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

61!

Financial leverage !
(Assets over Equity)!

Working Capital (in M$)!

10!
8!

Deere!

6!

AGCO!

4!

Kubota!

2!

CNH!

0!

M&M!
2008!

16.02.2015!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

Working Capital (in M$)!

Financial Leverage (in X)!

EFFICIENCY RATIOS!
25000!
20000!

Deere!

15000!

AGCO!

10000!

Kubota!
CNH!

5000!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

M&M!

0!
2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

62!

Working capital management by Mahindra & Mahindra!

Cash Conversion Cycle (in days)!


250!

200!

CCC (in days)!

150!
Deere!
AGCO!
100!

Kubota!
CNH!
M&M!

50!

0!
2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

-50!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

63!

TURNOVER!
Inventory turnover (in X)!

12!
10!
8!

Deere!

6!

AGCO!

4!

Kubota!
CNH!

2!

M&M!

0!

16.02.2015!

2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

Inventory turnover (in X)!

Fixed Assets Turnover (in


X)!

Fixed Assets Turnover (in X)!


8!
6!

Deere!

4!

AGCO!
Kubota!

2!

CNH!
M&M!

0!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

2008!

2009!

2010!

2011!

2012!

64!

Current raHo (in %)


3

Current raHo (in %)

2.5

2
Deere
AGCO

1.5

Kubota
CNH

M&M

0.5

0
2008

16.02.2015!

2009

2010

2011

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

2012

65!

Investment ratios!

CAPEX over Revenues (in %)!


12!

CAPEX over Revenues (in %)!

10!

8!
Deere!
AGCO!

6!

Kubota!
CNH!
4!

M&M!

2!

0!
2008!

16.02.2015!

2009!

2010!

2011!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

2012!

66!

Strategy!
External factors!

TEMP: DELETED!

Farmers Investments in Africa!

79% of the population depends on


agriculture!
45% of the population (14.3 mios) work on
family farms, mainly womens!
The GNI/person of $820 and more than 45%
of the people living under the poverty line!
Land ownership is not clearly define!

If farmers cant develop more than a


family business, it is because they are
facing an investment trap!
Production!

Even if Kenya is a strong African


economy, it is facing extreme poverty
in the farming sector!

R!

R!

P!

Banks are risk adverse, they will not lend to


farmers. Even more because they cannot use
the land as a collateral!

O!

Source: Poor Economics, Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo, PublicAffairs, 2011!


World development indicator, World Bank 2011!
www.ruralpovertyportal.org!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

Q!

Capital Invested!

Farmers are not rich enough to start a


business at Q point, they start with nothing at
O, the origin.!
Starting at Q (machinery instead of manual
work) help farmers to go over the Marginal
Cost curve!
Thus, production will increase significantly!
67!

Financials Cost of renting!

16.02.2015!

ICA-Agricultural Machinery!

68!

Anda mungkin juga menyukai