Psycho-Oncology (2012)
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). DOI: 10.1002/pon.3228
Psycho-Oncology Research Unit, Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Head and Neck Cancer Service, Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
3
Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
4
Department of Psychiatry, St Vincents Hospital, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
5
University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
6
Department of Psychology, RMIT University, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
2
*Correspondence to:
Clinical Psychology, Peter
MacCallum Cancer Centre,
Locked Bag 1 A'Beckett Street,
Melbourne, Victoria 8006,
Australia. E-mail: Kate.Neilson@
petermac.org
Abstract
Objective: The aim of the study was to assess symptoms of depression and anxiety in patients with head
and neck cancer up to 18 months after radiotherapy.
Methods: Prospective observational study of consecutive head and neck outpatients was conducted
at a tertiary cancer centre (n = 101). Eligibility included diagnosis of cancer in the head and neck
region, where the patient agreed to radiotherapy with curative intent. Data were collected before
commencement of radiotherapy and 3 weeks and 18 months after completion. Symptoms of depression
and anxiety were assessed by the Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale. Tumour/treatment-related
physical symptoms were assessed using the Additional Concerns subscale of the Functional Assessment
of Chronic Illness Therapy for Head and Neck Cancer.
Results: The prevalence of identied probable cases of depression was 15% at baseline, increasing
to 29% 3 weeks post-treatment, falling to 8% at 18-month follow-up. The number of probable cases
of anxiety was 20% at baseline, 17% at 3 weeks post-treatment and 22% at 18-month follow-up.
Depression scores signicantly increased from baseline to 3 weeks post-treatment and decreased at
18-month follow-up. Variability in depression scores was accounted for by tumour/treatment-related
physical symptoms. Anxiety scores signicantly decreased between baseline and 3-week post-treatment
and increased at 18-month follow-up. Younger age and more tumour/treatment-related physical
symptoms predicted anxiety scores.
Conclusions: The rates of depression in head and neck cancer patients increase following cancer
treatment and are related to tumour/treatment-related physical symptoms. Anxiety levels are higher
pre-treatment, lower immediately following cancer treatment but rise to near pre-treatment levels
more than a year after completion of cancer treatment.
Copyright 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Introduction
Head and neck cancer (HNC) patients are required to
undergo some of the most distressing and disguring
treatments among all cancers. Rates of 5-year survival
range between 23% and 64% depending on the site and
type of cancer [1]. Patients often live with chronic functional impairment and disgurement. Functional changes
associated with the disease, resulting from the acute
effects of radiation can include difculties with speaking,
swallowing and breathing, as well as pain [24]. For these
reasons, HNC has been described as more emotionally
traumatic than any other form of cancer [5].
Studies have shown that patients diagnosed with an
HNC display clinically signicant levels of psychological
distress. Psychological distress can be described as a
combination of symptoms including anxiety, depression,
cognitive and behavioural impairments [6]. Psychological
distress extends along a continuum ranging from transient,
normal feelings of vulnerability, sadness and fear to
problems that can become disabling such as symptoms
of depression and anxiety. More severe symptoms of
Copyright 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
K. Neilson et al.
Method
Procedure
This was a prospective longitudinal observational study of
HNC outpatients attending the Peter MacCallum Cancer
Centre (Melbourne, Australia) between May 2008 and
May 2009. Clinic oncologists assessed patient eligibility.
Eligibility criteria were a diagnosis for the rst time of
HNC, age >17 years, where the patient agreed to undertake cancer treatment involving radiotherapy with curative
intent. Exclusion criteria included inability to give informed
consent (including active psychosis, intellectual disability
or dementia), receiving treatment for another cancer, or
Copyright 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Measures
A Demographic Questionnaire asked participants to
record their gender, age, marital status, employment,
education, current tobacco use and mental health
history.
Cancer information such as diagnosis, tumour histology and treatment were obtained from reviewing
patients medical records.
The Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS)
[7] is a well validated and reliable self-report measure designed to detect the presence and severity of
anxiety and depression [34,35]. The questionnaire
items exclude somatic symptoms and therefore
avoid symptom overlap between somatic illnesses
and mood disorders. Respondents are asked to rate
their symptoms over the previous week. Higher
scores on the two subscales (depression and anxiety)
indicate more severe symptoms. Scores >7 can be
used as a threshold for identifying probable cases
of depression. Normative data for the HADS is
available in a non-clinical sample and show a mean
score of 6.14 for the anxiety subscale and 3.68 for
the depression subscale [36]. A large study of oncology patients (n = 3035) demonstrated a mean anxiety
subscale score 6.76 and depression 4.3 [37].
The Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness
Therapy-Head and Neck Version [38] is a 39-item
scale developed to measure quality of life in
patients undergoing cancer treatment for HNC. An
Additional Concerns subscale assesses physical
symptoms specic to HNC tumours and treatment
(ability to eat, dry mouth, difculty breathing,
difculty speaking or communicating, unhappiness
with physical appearance). Respondents are asked
to report their symptoms over the previous week.
The subscale score is the sum of the respondents
ratings for the nine items. Higher subscale scores
denote higher QOL and less physical symptoms. It
is a valid and reliable measure [38].
Statistical analyses
Baseline characteristics of the study sample were summarised using means and standard deviations for continuous
variables, and frequencies and percentages for categorical
Psycho-Oncology (2012)
DOI: 10.1002/pon
Results
Participants
In total, 172 patients were referred for the study; of these,
71 declined to participate and 101 patients completed
baseline measures.
Pre-treatment demographic characteristics and cancer
type and treatment of participants are presented in detail
in Table 1. Participants consisted of 85 men and 16
women. The average age of participants was 63 years
(range 3785 years). Most participants were diagnosed with
squamous cell carcinoma, and all received radiotherapy as
part of treatment. The average duration of radiotherapy +/
chemotherapy was 6 weeks. Most participants had
surgery and radiotherapy (35%). One participant reported
a pre-treatment psychiatric condition (depression).
Of the 101 eligible patients who completed pre-treatment
questionnaires, 75 completed the 3-week post-treatment
questionnaires (26 withdrew from the study at 3 weeks
post-treatment). Of the post-treatment participants who
completed questionnaires, 23 patients were excluded from
the 18-month follow-up because of diagnosis of recurrence
or metastases during the rst 18 months after treatment
(n = 10), diagnosis and current treatment for another cancer
(n = 3), or death (n = 10). Patients with recurrent disease or
current treatment for other cancers were excluded to reduce
the inuence of these events on self-reported symptoms. A
further n = 15 withdrew at 18-month follow-up. Thus, a
total of 37 participants completed 18-month follow-up.
Participants who completed the study did not differ from
non-completers (either excluded or withdrew) on age,
sex or baseline anxiety. Completers did tend to be less
depressed at baseline compared with non-completers
(t(20) = 2.19, p = .04).
5
24
29
26
15
2
5
24
28
26
15
2
82
19
81
19
33
29
23
7
4
3
2
32
29
23
7
4
3
2
13
29
35
24
13
28
35
24
65
7
10
11
8
64
7
10
11
8
25
76
25
75
8
44
19
9
18
8
44
19
9
18
30
6
4
7
46
6
30
6
4
7
46
6
23
22
28
20
23
22
28
20
89
10
2
88
10
2
K. Neilson et al.
6
50
5.49
5.16
45
40
35
30
4.04
4.02
29.3
3.54
25
20
3
21.6
19.8
17.3
15
14.9
10
5.32
1
8.1
5
0
0
Pre-treatment
3-weeks posttreatment
18-months posttreatment
Time
Figure 1. Percentage of participants scoring above threshold (>7) and means for Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale (HADS) depression
and anxiety subscales
26.15
25
20
19.14
15
10
0
Pre-treatment
3-weeks Posttreatment
18-months Posttreatment
Time
Discussion
This is the rst prospective (up to 18 months) study of predictors of depression and anxiety symptoms for HNC
patients treated with radiotherapy. This longitudinal study
demonstrated risk factors and the change in symptoms
of psychological distress (depression and anxiety) over
the course of treatment and recovery for HNC, up to
18 months after radiotherapy.
Participants anxiety levels were lower at 3 weeks
post-treatment compared with baseline and 18 months
post-treatment. A number of risk factors for anxiety over
the course of treatment were identied, with younger age
and more severe physical symptoms associated with
higher anxiety levels.
Depression, when analysed alone, increased signicantly between baseline and 3 weeks post-treatment, and
then decreased at 18-month follow-up. However, further
analysis revealed that variability in depression scores
was accounted for by participants experience of physical
symptoms associated with HNC tumours and treatment
(ability to eat, dry mouth, difculty breathing, difculty
speaking or communicating, unhappiness with physical
appearance). Results suggest that as physical symptoms
associated with their cancer and treatment increased, so
did symptoms of depression. This highlights the important
relationship between HNC patients tumour/treatmentrelated physical symptoms and psychological distress.
This nding is supported by previous studies of HNC
patients [9,23].
The pattern of change observed in depression scores
over treatment is similar to other studies [15,1719].
Psycho-Oncology (2012)
DOI: 10.1002/pon
References
1. English E, et al. Cancer Survival Victoria:
Estimates of Survival in 2004, Victorian
Cancer Registry, Cancer Epidemiology Centre,
Cancer Council Victoria: Melbourne, 2007.
2. Allison P, et al. Teaching head and neck
cancer patients coping strategies: results of
a feasibility study. Oral Oncol 2004;40
(5):53844.
3. Fischer D, et al. Anxiety, depression, and
pain: differences by primary cancer. Support
Care Cancer 2010;18(7):801810.
4. Glavassevich M, McKibbon A, Thomas S.
Information needs of patients who undergo
surgery for head and neck cancer. Can Oncol
Nurs J 1995;5:911.
5. Koster M, Bergsma J. Problems and coping
behaviours of facial cancer patients. Soc Sci
Med 1990;30:569578.
6. Kallay E, Degi L, Vincze A. Dysfunctional
attitudes, depression and quality of life in a
sample of Romanian Hungarian cancer
patients. J Cogn Behav Psychot 2007;7
(1):97108.
Copyright 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Acknowledgements
This research was funded by beyondblue: The National Depression Initiative. Thank you also to Karen Mead and Marcelle Gray, who assisted
this project as part of their postgraduate (psychology) dissertations.
K. Neilson et al.
20. Derks W, et al. Elderly patients with head and
neck cancer: physical, social and psychological aspects after 1 year. Acta Otolaryngol
2004;124(4):509514.
21. Ronis D, et al. Changes in quality of life over
1 year in patients with head and neck cancer.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 2008;134
(3):241248.
22. Britton B, et al. Baseline depression predicts
malnutrition in head and neck cancer patients
undergoing radiotherapy. Support Care Cancer
2012;20(2):335342.
23. de Leeuw J, et al. Prediction of depressive
symptomatology after treatment of head and
neck cancer: the inuence of pre-treatment
physical and depressive symptoms, coping,
and social support. Head Neck 2000;22
(8):799807.
24. Hawton K, van Heeringen K. Suicide. Lancet
2009;373:13721381.
25. Zeller J. High suicide risk found for patients
with head and neck cancer. J Am Med Assoc
2006;296(14):17161717.
26. Massie M, Popkin M. Depressive disorders.
In Psycho-Oncology, Holland JC (ed.). Oxford
University Press: New York, 1998.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
Psycho-Oncology (2012)
DOI: 10.1002/pon