long been at odds with one another. But I believe that the
seemingly irreconcilable can be conjoined.
One of the main objections that the creeds of Thelema and
Satanism have raised against each other appears to rest on
the subject of the ego and its importance, or lack thereof.
The Crowley camp believes that LaVey put too much
emphasis on the ego, and the LaVey camp believes that
Crowley did not insist on the importance of the ego enough.
Contrary to both views, I intend to illustrate that Crowley's
own words demonstrate that he believed the individual ego
was very important, provided that it represented the True
Will of that individual (after the false beliefs of church,
religion and society had been annihilated). LaVey believed
the same.
Aleister Crowley and Anton LaVey were both larger-than-life
figures whose ideas have profoundly shaped many who have
come in their wake. There is much to be said about both
men's philosophies and about the proper balance between
the two; but rather than merely comment upon these men's
ideas, I shall let them speak for themselves. By using
quotations from both thinkers, in the following passages I
will demonstrate that the difference in the philosophies put
forth by Crowley and LaVey is only a matter of degree; how
much farther towards the esoteric or the exoteric one is
willing to go. The following are a series of quotes intended to
illustrate the abundant similarities within the philosophies
of both men:
Crowley:
"These are dead, these fellows; they feel not. We are not for
the poor and sad: the lords of the earth are our kinsfolk.
Those who sorrow are not real people at all, not 'stars'-for
the time being. The fact of their being 'poor and sad' proves
them to be 'shadows,' who 'pass and are done.' The 'lords of
the earth' are those who are doing their Will."
(The Law is for All, New Falcon, pg 101)
"We have nothing with the outcast and the unfit: let them
die in their misery. For they feel not. Compassion is the vice
of kings: stamp down the wretched & the weak: this is the
law of the strong: this is our law and the joy of the world.
There is a good deal of the Nietzschean standpoint in this
verse. It is the evolutionary and natural view. Of what use is
it to perpetuate the misery of tuberculosis, and such
diseases, as we now do? Nature's way is to weed out the
weak. This is the merciful way, too. At present all the strong
are being damaged, and their progress hindered by the dead
weight of the weak limbs and the missing limbs, the diseased
limbs and the atrophied limbs. The Christians to the Lions!
Let the weak and wry productions go back into the melting
pot, as is done with flawed steel casings."
(The Law is for All, pg 102)
LaVey:
"My eyes are as a pinnacle that views the scattered
multitudes of fools who grope for things celestial; who bow
and scrape to wan and sallow gods, the spawn of shallow
minded men, forsaking life terrestrial while creeping to their
graves. I gaze upon the massive hoards that suffocate, like
Peter's fish pulled from the lake of life's sweet waters. To
perish in Heaven's foul vapors shall be their doom! The fate
of fools is justice!
"I am the tempter of life that lurks in every breast and belly;
a vibrant, torpid cavern, nectar laden, with sweetest
pleasures beckoning. I am a thrusting rod with head of iron,
drawing to me myriad nymphs, tumescent in their craving! I
am rampant carnal joy, an agent born of ecstasy's mad
flailing."
(The Satanic Rituals, Avon, pg 146-147)
LaVey [quoting from Ragnar Redbeard's social Darwinist
tome, Might Is Right]
"In this arid wilderness of steel and stone I raise up my voice
that you may hear. To the East and to the West I beckon. To
the North and to the South I show a sign proclaiming: Death
to the weakling, wealth to the strong!"
(The Satanic Bible, Avon, pg 30)
Crowley:
"Mercy let be off: damn them who pity! Kill and torture;
spare not; be upon them!
An end to the humanitarian mawkishness which is
destroying the human race by the deliberate artificial
protection of the unfit.
What has been the net result of our fine 'Christian' phrases?
In the good old days there was some sort of natural
selection; brains and stamina were necessary to survival.
The race, as such, consequently improved. But we thought
we knew oh! so much better, and we had 'Christ's Law' and
other slush. So the unfit crowded and contaminated the fit,
until the Earth herself grew nauseated with the mess.
'the royal': these are the men whose nature is kingly, the
men who 'can.' They know themselves born rulers, whether
their halidom be Art, or Science, or aught else so ever."
'the lofty': these are the men who, being themselves highhearted, endure not any baseness."
(The Law is for All, pg 183-184)
LaVey:
"The twilight is done. A glow of new light is borne out of the
night and Lucifer is risen, once more to proclaim: 'This is
the age of Satan! Satan rules the earth!' The gods of the
unjust are dead. This is the morning of magic, and undefiled
wisdom. The flesh prevaileth and a great Church shall be
builded, consecrated in its name. No longer shall man's
salvation be dependent on his self-denial. And it will be
known that the world of the flesh and the living shall be the
greatest preparation for any and all eternal delights!"
(The Satanic Bible, pg 23-24)
Crowley:
"As brothers fight ye!
Fight! Fight like gentlemen, without malice, because fighting
is the best game in the world, and love the second best."
(The Law is for All, pg 184)
LaVey:
"Satan represents vengeance, instead of turning the other
cheek!"
(The Satanic Bible, pg 25)
Crowley:
"Despise all cowards; professional soldiers who dare not to
fight, but play; all fools despise!
To fight is the right and duty of every male, as of every
woman to rejoice in his strength and to honour and
perpetuate it by her love. My primary objection to
Christianity is 'gentle Jesus, meek and mild,' the pacifist, the
conscientious objector, the Tolstoyan, the 'passive resister.'
When the Kaiser fled, and the Germans surrendered their
fleet, they abandoned Nietzsche for Jesus."
(The Law is for All, pg 181)
"The man who denounces life merely defines himself as the
man who is unequal to it. The brave man rejoices in giving
and taking hard knocks, and the brave man is joyous. The
Scandinavian idea of Valhalla may be primitive, but it is
manly. A heaven of popular concert, like the Christian; of
unconscious repose, like the Buddhist; or even of sensual
enjoyment, like the Moslem, excites his nausea and
contempt. He understands that the only joy worth while is
the joy of continual victory, and victory itself would become
as tame as croquet if it were not spiced by equally continual
defeat."
(Magick Without Tears, pg 78)
LaVey (quoting Redbeard):
"'Love one another' it has been said is the supreme law, but
what power made it so? Upon what rational authority does
the gospel of love rest? Why should I not hate mine
enemies-if I 'love' them does that not place me at their
mercy? Is it natural for enemies to do good unto each otherand what is good? Can the torn and bloody victim 'love' the
about moral codes. Like the wooden idols of long ago, they
are the work of human hands, and what man has made, man
can destroy!"
(The Satanic Bible, pg 31)
LaVey:
"My slant is that I'm afraid I just have to parrot Nietzsche
and go beyond good and evil. I mean, only a fool is going to
believe in absolute good or absolute evil. There are
intrinsically rotten things that people can do that violate the
Darwinian law of survival, where they're just crying out to be
destroyed; but that doesn't mean it's good and evil."
(Seconds, Anton LaVey interview by Boyd Rice, #45, pg 66)
Crowley:
"We should recognize the fact that the vast majority of
human beings have no ambition in life beyond mere ease
and animal happiness. We should allow these people to
fulfill their destinies without interference. We should give
every opportunity to the ambitious, and thereby establish a
class of morally and intellectually superior men and women.
We should have no compunction in utilizing the natural
qualities of the bulk of mankind. We do not insist on trying
to train sheep to hunt foxes or lecture on history; we look
after their physical well being, and enjoy their wool and
mutton. In this way we will have a contented class of slaves
who will accept the conditions of existence as they really are,
and enjoy life with the quiet wisdom of cattle. It is our duty
to see to it that this class of people lack for nothing."
(The Law is for All, pg 131)
LaVey:
a slave."
(The Confessions of Aleister Crowley, Penguin, pg 539)
"Crowley explained that 'the revival of true Aristocracy' had
been 'my deepest idea all my lifeWe must first of all have a
sound physical stock to pick out rulers from.'"
(Do What Thou Wilt by L. Sutin, pg 393)
LaVey:
"There are supermen and supermen-some are more superior
than others. That's why there's no way Satanism can be
egalitarian. That's what bothers people who come into it. If I
make someone a priest it's because of them; they impress
me as being qualified. It's not what they've studied; it's what
they've accomplished in the real world." ( From Book of Lies,
"Anton LaVey: A Fireside Chat with the Black Pope,"
Disinformation, pg 280)
Crowley:
"I am alone: there is no God where I am.
This refers to the spiritual experience of identity. When one
realizes one's Truth there is no room for any other
conception. It also means that the God-idea must go with
other relics of the Fear born of Ignorance into the limbo of
savagery. I speak of the Idea of God as generally understood,
God being 'something not ourselves, that makes for
righteousness.' Why this ingrained conviction that self is
unrighteous? It is the heritage of the whip, the brand of the
born slave. Incidentally, we cannot allow people who believe
in this 'God;' they are troglodytes, as dangerous to society as
any other thieves and murderers. The Christians to the
Lions!"
(The Law is for All, pg 112-113)
LaVey (quoting Redbeard):
"Say unto thine own heart, 'I am mine own redeemer."
(The Satanic Bible, pg 33)
Crowley:
"I have already indicated the philosophical scope of The
Book of the Law it reconciles an impersonal and infinite
interpretation of the Cosmos with an Egocentric and
practical view."
(Magick, Weiser, pg 701)
"Selfishness? I am glad to find you worrying that bone, for it
has plenty of meat, none of your Chilled Argentine or
Canterbury lamb. It is a pelvis, what's more; for in a way the
whole structure of the ethics of Thelema is founded upon it."
(Magick Without Tears, pg 292)
"I thought it also a point of honesty not to pretend to be
'better' then I was. I would avoid concealing my faults and
foibles. I would have no one accept me on false pretences. I
would not compromise with conventionality; even in cases
where as an ordinary man of the world, it would have been
natural to do so."
(The Confessions of Aleister Crowley, pg 582)
LaVey:
"I always felt that if you sleep on the floor, you never have to
worry about falling out of bed. And when you get yourself in
this exalted position of self-righteousness, then it's very easy
!
!
Vadge Moore / DISCRIMINATE ME