Rubrics
Analytic Rubrics for Teachers and Students
2012
Bermuda MOED Curriculum and Assessment
Contents
Introduction ............................................................... 3
Word Processing Rubrics ........................................ 6
Presentation Rubrics .............................................. 12
Desktop Publishing Rubrics .................................. 17
Spreadsheet Rubrics .............................................. 20
Using Applications in Core Subjects .................... 23
Application Ideas .................................................... 25
Resources ................................................................ 27
Page | 2
Students can use the word processor to create, edit, proofread and print a
variety of text documents. Photos and graphics can also be added to
enhance communication. The ability for students to easily review and edit
their work facilitates the writing process.
reports
poems
stories
speeches
Desktop Publishing:
MS Publisher
KidPix
letters
pamphlets
plays
pamphlets
fliers
calendars
newsletters
Multimedia
Presentations: MS
PowerPoint
Spreadsheets: MS
Excel
posters
invitations
certificates
reports
stories
Spreadsheets are tables used to store data in the form of words and values.
With spreadsheet software, students can perform calculations and display
data as charts and graphs that make it easier for them to interpret data.
calculations
tables
charts
graphs
Page | 3
spreadsheets skills P4 P6
Students
Written from the students perspective, the rubrics use language that students may use to describe their
ability to use these applications. The can describe their performance in terms of Needs Improvement,
Satisfactory (on grade level), Good or Very Good. Students must understand that in order to qualify for one
description, they must have qualified for those that come before it and that over the course of the project
they can always improve their grade by using the rubric as a guide.
Teachers
There is one rubric for each application. The rubrics measure the mastery of general application skills and
those particular to that application. Teachers can use these analytic rubrics to formatively assess student
performance with these applications over the development of a project. They can be used to help students
identify areas to be improved and can serve as curriculum guides to help teachers to plan the skills and
knowledge they will be covering for a particular project. Thus, the rubrics serve as tools for students and
teachers. Teachers can design their own strategies and tools to assess more completely the products
created with these applications. Depending on the design of the assignment, additional criteria can include
content knowledge, the organization of ideas, and research and planning processes. Both product and
performance determine the student score.
Page | 4
The Rubrics
Each one has some generic
elements but then others suit the
features of that particular
application. Here is the Primary
One rubric for word processing
with an explanation key.
Scales:
Trying to Improve = below
target
Satisfactory= on target;
Good = at least one level
above target
Very Good= at least two
levels above target
Page | 5
Spelling and
grammar
Illustrations
Handling Text
Simple Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
Trying to Improve
Satisfactory
Good
Very Good
Score
Score
Page | 6
Spelling and
grammar
Illustrations
Handling Text
Simple Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
Trying to Improve
Satisfactory
Good
Very Good
I can manage my
writing files and only
occasionally need help
with saving and locating
my work
Score
Score
Page | 7
Spelling and
grammar
Illustrations
Handling Text
Simple Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
Satisfactory
Good
Very Good
I can manage my
writing files and only
occasionally need help
with saving and
locating my work
I can manage my
writing files and can
usually troubleshoot
before I ask for
assistance.
Score
Score
Page | 8
Spelling and
grammar
Illustrations
Handling Text
Simple Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
Satisfactory
Good
Very Good
I can illustrate my
writing with Word Art,
graphics, photos,
borders and can assist
others with illustrating
their work.
Score
Score
Page | 9
Illustrations
Trying to Improve
Satisfactory
Good
I can illustrate my
writing with Word Art,
graphics, photos,
borders and can assist
others with illustrating
their work.
Very Good
Score
Handling Text
Simple Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
Score
Page | 10
Spelling and
grammar
Illustrations
Satisfactory
Good
I can illustrate my
writing with Word Art,
graphics, photos,
borders and can assist
others with illustrating
their work.
Very Good
Score
Trying to Improve
Handling Text
Simple Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
Score
Page | 11
P2 Presentation Rubric
Running the
Presentation
Spelling and
grammar
Animatio
n
slide design
Illustrations
Handling Text
Simple
Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
General file
management
Trying to Improve
Satisfactory
Good
Very Good
I can assist my
teacher with creating
new presentations. I
can also help with
saving and printing
my work.
I can assist my
teacher with creating
new presentations by
clicking on icons in
the menu and can
explain what some of
them mean.
I can help my teacher
to add, cut and move
slides around in my
presentation.
Score
Score
Page | 12
P3 Presentation Rubric
Satisfactory
Spelling and
grammar
Running the
presentation
Good
Very Good
I can run my
presentation and can
help others. I can help
my teachers with special
settings for my
presentation
Multimedia
Animation
slide design
Illustrations
Handling
Text
Simple
Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
General file
management
Trying to Improve
Score
Score
Page | 13
P4 Presentation Rubric
Satisfactory
Good
Very Good
I can manage my
documents and print slides
or handouts of my
presentation. If I have a
problem, I can usually solve
it myself. I can assist others
with their presentations.
Spelling and
grammar
Running the
presentation
Score
I can redesign a
presentation to suit a
different audience and can
help others make their
presentations look better.
I can run my
presentation and can
help others. I can help
my teachers with special
settings for my
presentation
Multimedia
Animation
slide design
Illustrations
Handling
Text
Simple
Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
General file
management
Trying to Improve
Score
Page | 14
Satisfactory
Good
I can manage my
documents and print slides
or handouts of my
presentation. If I have a
problem, I can usually solve
it myself. I can assist others
with their presentations.
I can redesign a
presentation to suit a
different audience and can
help others make their
presentations look better.
I can add custom animation
to pictures and text to add
meaning and emphasis.
I can run my
presentation and can
help others. I can help
my teachers with special
settings for my
presentation
Multimedia
Spelling
and
grammar
Very Good
Score
Trying to Improve
Running the
presentation
Animation
slide design
Illustrations
Handling
Text
Simple
Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
General file
management
P5 Presentation Rubric
Score
Page | 15
Running the
presentation
Spelling and
grammar
Multimedia
Animation
Satisfactory
I can manage my
documents and print slides
or handouts of my
presentation. If I have a
problem, I can usually solve
it myself. I can assist others
with their presentations.
Good
I can redesign a
presentation to suit a
different audience and can
help others make their
presentations look better.
I can add custom animation
to pictures and text to add
meaning and emphasis
Very Good
Score
Trying to Improve
slide design
Illustrations
Handling
Text
Simple
Editing
Toolbar
Navigation
General file
management
P6 Presentation Rubric
Score
Page | 16
Spelling and
grammar
Layout
Handling Illustrations :
Handling Text
Navigating the
Toolbars and
Publications
General file
management
Trying to Improve
Satisfactory
Good
Very Good
I can manage my
publications and print
them. If I have a
problem, I can usually
solve it myself. I can
assist others managing
their publications.
I know my way around
the menus and can
easily navigate the pages
of my publications. I can
help others locate the
tools and features they
need.
Score
Score
Page | 17
Spelling and
grammar
Layout
Trying to Improve
Satisfactory
I can manage my
publications and print
them. If I have a
problem, I can usually
solve it myself. I can
assist others managing
their publications.
I explore menus to
locate tools and features
needed to edit my
publication. I can insert,
delete and move pages
or panels in my
publications.
Good
Very Good
Score
Handling Illustrations
Handling Text
Navigating the
Toolbars and
Publications
General file
management
Score
Page | 18
Spelling and
grammar
I can manage my
publications and print
them. If I have a
problem, I can usually
solve it myself. I can
assist others managing
their publications.
Very Good
Score
Good
Satisfactory
Layout
Handling Illustrations :
Handling Text
Navigating the
Toolbars and
Publications
General file
management
Trying to Improve
Score
Page | 19
P4 Spreadsheet Rubric
Accuracy, Spelling
and Grammar
illustrations
Creating Charts/Graphs
Entering data
Navigating the
Spreadsheet
General file
management
Trying to Improve
Satisfactory
Good
Very Good
I can manage my work
with spreadsheets and
can set the print area to
print them. If I have a
problem, I can usually
solve it myself. I can
assist others with
managing their work.
I can explain
spreadsheet terms. I can
explore the menus to
locate the features I
need and can help
others.
Score
Score
Page | 20
P5 Spreadsheet Rubric
Good
Score
Very Good
Creating Charts/Graphs
illustrations
Accuracy, Spelling
and Grammar
Satisfactory
Entering data
Navigating the
Spreadsheet
General file
management
Trying to Improve
Score
Page | 21
P6 Spreadsheet Rubric
Accuracy, Spelling
and Grammar
illustrations
Good
Score
Very Good
Satisfactory
Creating Charts/Graphs
Entering data
Navigating the
Spreadsheet
General file
management
Trying to Improve
Score
Page | 22
Word Processing
ELA
Math
Science
Social
Studies
use for independent and guided writing across a variety of genre using photographs and pictures to convey ideas; use appropriate conventions
of print, font, text size and colour spelling and grammar to convey meaning; use the features of the word processor to enhance the writing
process such as editing, spell check
use word processing features to communicate using mathematical language; use for writing word problems or explanations to problems;
writing self assessments and communicating about a topic, concept or problem solving,
use to produce journals, poems, stories, reports, letters, constructed answers incorporating scientific language and graphics; use to create
documents relating to scientific observations, experimentation, comparisons, exploration and collection of evidence; use to create tables for
classification, log and tally sheet and other tools for investigations
use to produce journals, poems, stories, reports, letters, plays and constructed answers related to historical content/events
Desktop Publishing
ELA
Math
Science
Social
Studies
Page | 23
use layout features to incorporate text, graphics, photographs and pictures to convey ideas; create books; calendars; photo essays; graphic
interpretations; greeting cards, posters, newsletters, exploring different styles and formats of print materials
use to create a variety of documents using layouts, formatting, graphics and shapes to communicate mathematical concepts, to teach
processes and to demonstrate problem solving strategies
use to create pamphlets and books detailing investigations; posters, fliers, multi fold projects; use graphics, photographs, text and layout to
document investigations and to organize results and communicate findings
use a variety of layouts to document events and outcomes, create timelines and present research
Presentations
ELA
Science
Social
Studies
use to promote listening and speaking skills with audio/visual presentations; use for retelling accompanied by on-screen presentation
including dramatization and oral reports; use presentations to support responding to questions and adapting presentations/content for
different audiences
use to create presentations designed to teach others about the process and outcomes of science investigations, present information gathered
from research using text, graphics, animation and hyperlinks
use to create presentations designed to teach others about the process and information gathered from research and to create an online
presentation illustrating a historical event including original art, text and graphics to illustrate the main points
Spreadsheets
ELA
Math
Science
Social
Studies
Page | 24
use to create simple graphs and to organize information gathered from original or other texts
Enter data into a table and create simple graphs; enter data to perform simple calculations; use the graphs with other applications to
communicate math concepts; explore a variety of graph types using data students collect and enter into a table on a spreadsheet
collect and chart data from science experiments; generate graphs and create questions that the graph may answer
use survey data to create graphs; use graphs to compare data collected over time
Page | 25
Page | 26
Resources:
Word Processing Lesson Plan Ideas
Spreadsheet Resources
Page | 27
http://office.microsoft.com/en-us/excel/excel-skills-builderlearn-how-to-create-spreadsheets-andworkbooks-use-formulas-and-perform-data-analysisFX102592909.aspx?WT%2Emc%5Fid=Hero%5Fenus%5FRM%2DExcelSillsBuilder%5FExcelPageHero
Videos for learning to use Excel 2010.
Page | 28