Department of
Agriculture
Forest Service
Forest
Products
Laboratory
Research
Paper
FPL 457
Rotational
Characteristics of
Pallet Joints
Thomas Lee Wilkinson
Abstract
August 1985
Rotational Characteristics of
Pallet Joints
Thomas Lee Wilkinson, Research General Engineer
Forest Products Laboratory, Madison, WI
Introduction
Past Work
Experimental Design
Variables
Specimens
Length, inches
Wire diameter,
inches
Thread-crest
diameter, inches1
Number of flutes2
Thread length, inches
Number of helix per
inch
MIBANT bend angle,
degree?
Head diameter,
inches
3-inch
hardened
nail
2-1/4-inch
hardened
nail
2-1/2-inch
stiffstock
nail
2-7/8
2-1/8
2-7/16
0.120
0.113
0.122
0.138
4
0.127
4
2.0
1.50
0.135
5
1.69
5.00
5.33
4.74
15
21
48
0.288
0.282
0.259
Experimental Procedure
The residual sum of squares for equation (1) was less than
for equation (2) for 493 of the 518 curves. A typical fit
(fig. 5) shows equation (1) closely follows the data points,
whereas equation (2) does not. Visual examination of the
fitted curves with the experimental data in cases where
equation (2) had lower residual sum of squares shows
equation (1) fits the initial portion of the moment-rotation
nearly as well as equation (2), figure 6. Therefore,
equation (1) describes pallet joint moment-rotation more
appropriately than equation (2).
The A parameter of equation (1) relates to the amount of
moment carried by the joint, i.e. the larger A is, the more
moment carried. The B parameter relates to the amount of
curvature in the moment-rotation curve, i.e. the larger B is,
the more curvature there is. The mean values for the
parameters are presented in tables 2 through 6 along with
the standard deviation, maximum, and minimum values.
Some general observations are as follows:
1. Fastener effect.The A parameters are highest for
the 3- x 0.120-inch nails. In general, the staples have the
second highest A values, followed by the 2-1/2- x 0.120inch nails. The B parameters are generally highest for the
staples. The three nails have nearly equal B parameters.
2. Pattern effect.The A parameters are highest for
pattern I and lowest for pattern III. The B parameters are
nearly equal for all patterns.
3. Species effect.The A parameters are highest for
the all oak specimens. The next highest values are for the
yellow-poplar stringers with oak decks and then the oak
stringers with yellow-poplar decks. This indicates the density
of the deck is more important than the density of the stringer
in giving high A values. The lowest A values are for the all
Douglas-fir specimens. The B values vary between species
groups, but are considerably lower for the Douglas-fir
specimens. As mentioned, the Douglas-fir specimens had
thinner deckboards. They also had slightly rounded corners
on the stringers while the other species had sharp corners.
where
FP = factor for fastener pattern:
Fastener pattern
Pattern factor
I
II
III
0.287
.008
.295
Fastener pattern
Pattern factor
I
II
III
IV
V
0.276
.018
.294
.580
1.348
Table 2.Parameter values for specimens with oak stringers and oak decks. Parameters determined by fitting M = A tanh ( )
to the experimental moment-rotation data (sample sizes are 9)
A, inch-pounds
Specific gravity
Fastener
Pattern1
Inches
2-1/4 x 0.112 I
II
Ill
I
3 x 0.120
II
Ill
2-1/2 x 0.120 I
II
Ill
2-1/2 staple I
II
Ill
1
Standard
S t r i n g e r D e c k M e a n deviation
0.61
.63
.60
.63
.63
.62
.61
.61
.60
.63
.62
.63
0.64
.63
.64
.62
.64
.63
.60
.64
.63
.63
.63
.62
997
770
563
1122
905
595
806
651
490
913
641
463
96
114
55
171
96
65
130
141
33
146
69
80
834
560
475
914
790
499
677
466
451
706
553
362
1117
907
646
1432
1124
709
1119
921
549
1198
756
596
21.6
22.2
22.0
19.9
21.1
23.0
23.0
23.5
25.6
25.0
29.7
30.7
Standard
deviation
Minimum Maximum
3.8
3.7
3.2
3.5
3.0
2.4
2.5
3.4
3.6
1.9
2.7
4.9
15.9
18.5
18.4
17.1
14.9
18.8
20.2
17.6
19.1
22.3
25.8
22.0
26.1
28.8
28.3
25.9
24.6
25.4
26.3
29.0
30.2
28.0
33.4
34.8
See figure 2.
Table 3.Parameter values for specimens with oak stringers and yellow-poplar decks. Parameters determined by fitting
M = A tanh ( ) to the experimental moment-rotation data (sample sizes are 9)
A, inch-pounds
Specific gravity
Fastener
Pattern1
Stringer Deck Mean
Inches
2-1/4 x 0.112
3 x 0.120
2-1/2 x 0.120
2-1/2 staple
I
II
Ill
I
II
Ill
I
II
Ill
I
II
Ill
0.60
.62
.61
.62
.62
.62
.62
.61
.61
.61
.60
.61
0.39
.39
.39
.40
.40
.40
.39
.39
.41
.41
.38
.39
486
362
277
576
404
298
497
361
302
509
377
234
Standard
deviation
137
65
37
86
82
34
78
70
56
133
73
51
323
245
227
447
248
236
357
253
254
325
252
160
749
434
331
767
506
340
610
458
426
691
464
324
26.3
27.2
27.6
28.3
30.8
29.9
30.6
29.3
29.6
34.1
37.2
44.7
Standard
deviation
3.7
2.1
2.8
3.0
2.4
2.3
4.8
3.0
3.2
4.4
8.0
11.9
Minimum Maximum
21.0
23.2
24.0
23.5
26.8
26.6
24.3
23.1
24.1
28.2
27.5
32.8
32.1
30.4
32.7
33.6
35.8
33.4
40.4
33.2
33.0
41.0
46.4
65.1
See figure 2.
Table 4.Parameter values for specimens with yellow-poplar stringers and oak decks. Parameters determined by fitting
M = A tanh (
) to the experimental moment-rotation data (sample sizes are 9)
Specific gravity
Fastener
A, inch-pounds
Pattern1
Stringer Deck Mean
inches
2-1/4 x 0.112 I
II
Ill
3 x 0.120
I
II
Ill
2-1/2 x 0.120 I
II
Ill
2-1/2 staple I
II
Ill
1
0.39
.38
.40
.38
.39
.37
.40
.39
.39
.39
.41
.39
0.62
.62
.62
.65
.61
.64
.62
.61
.64
.65
.64
.64
550
440
292
648
485
375
615
496
329
611
433
343
Standard
deviation
426
347
193
495
334
286
477
389
237
460
346
311
76
85
55
143
104
66
90
102
70
90
64
41
685
631
379
919
690
457
757
706
449
735
539
436
26.3
20.1
28.6
24.6
25.9
24.3
24.9
26.1
26.6
25.7
26.6
25.4
Standard
deviation
Minimum Maximum
3.5
3.3
3.2
4.1
4.0
3.0
5.0
2.5
4.4
2.9
5.3
2.3
20.0
15.8
23.4
18.2
18.5
19.2
17.9
20.8
19.4
19.6
19.6
21.7
31.8
25.7
33.0
30.3
31.2
28.3
31.8
29.5
32.9
29.3
36.9
28.9
See figure 2.
Table B.Parameter values for specimens with yellow-poplar stringers and yellow-poplar decks. Parameters determined by
fitting M = A tanh ( ) to the experimental moment-rotation data (sample sizes are 9)
A, inch-pounds
Specific gravity
Fastener
Pattern1
Stringer Deck Mean
Inches
2-1/4 x 0.112
3 x 0.120
2-1/2 x 0.120
2-1/2 staple
See figure 2.
I
II
Ill
IV
V
I
II
Ill
I
II
Ill
I
II
Ill
0.36
.38
.39
.39
.40
.37
.39
.38
.39
.37
.37
.39
.40
.38
0.41
.41
.41
.38
.39
.41
.40
.41
.39
.41
.40
.41
.40
.40
423
343
251
171
83
520
367
286
431
360
235
515
330
255
Standard
deviation
98
48
76
24
9
70
50
59
65
48
46
100
56
46
243
280
161
135
70
412
308
226
321
290
151
384
261
189
530
419
398
216
97
608
435
416
528
423
301
656
438
314
26.2
25.1
25.1
31.0
26.4
23.2
22.7
25.0
26.2
23.4
27.6
31.1
31.6
30.9
Standard
deviation
4.9
3.3
4.6
2.9
3.8
4.1
3.1
2.7
4.1
4.4
4.0
5.3
3.1
5.4
Minimum Maximum
19.7
19.9
18.3
26.3
21.0
18.4
16.7
22.5
20.2
17.2
22.7
23.8
27.1
22.0
33.7
30.6
32.4
34.5
31.0
29.6
27.5
29.6
31.7
30.1
.0
41.8
37.4
38.3
Table B.Parameter values for specimens with Douglas-fir stringers and Douglas-fir decks. Parameters determined by fitting
M = A tanh ( ) to the experimental moment-rotation data (sample sizes are 9)
A, inch-pounds
Specific gravity
Fastener
Pattern1
Stringer Deck Mean
Inches
2-1/4 x 0.112 I
II
Ill
3 x 0.120
I
II
Ill
2-1/2 x 0.120 I
II
Ill
2-1/2 staple I
II
Ill
0.45
.45
.41
.41
.42
.43
.43
.45
.43
.45
.45
.44
0.43
.46
.42
.46
.45
.40
.43
.44
.40
.42
.41
.40
419
351
228
490
391
283
430
396
256
421
334
247
Standard
deviation
85
52
35
81
63
34
82
47
42
130
39
42
335
275
185
363
323
230
342
325
199
217
273
163
611
409
281
625
526
341
566
487
321
672
388
309
18.7
15.3
18.2
17.0
13.9
16.4
21.2
15.1
17.1
23.1
23.5
23.3
Standard
deviation
3.0
3.9
4.1
1.7
1.9
3.7
4.9
3.4
3.0
5.2
5.5
5.6
Minimum Maximum
14.1
11.7
12.8
14.7
10.8
11.5
12.8
10.0
11.7
13.6
15.9
17.1
22.1
22.9
25.1
20.1
16.3
22.1
28.0
19.0
21.1
31.0
32.5
35.4
'See figure 2.
I
II
Pattern1
See figure 2
21.6
21.6
21.6
--21.6
21.6
21.6
21.6
21.6
21.6
26.9
26.9
26.9
Constant
B parameter
Standard
deviation
982
768
563
--1065
889
607
823
664
519
887
659
477
84
99
50
--109
104
54
135
121
40
123
80
78
- Inch-pounds -
Mean
A parameter
Deck
Oak
Yellow-poplar
Oak
Yellow-poplar
Douglas-fir
Stringer
Oak
Oak
Yellow-poplar
Yellow-poplar
Douglas-fir
Species
0.573
.184
.040
.264
.303
Standard
deviation
125
64
38
--86
86
36
75
74
50
126
76
49
- Inch-pounds 468
356
274
--573
412
301
503
364
303
502
378
241
28.6
28.6
28.6
--28.6
28.6
28.6
28.6
28.6
28.6
34.9
34.9
34.9
Mean
A parameter
III
IV
V
3 x 0.120 I
II
Ill
2-1/2 x 0.120 I
II
Ill
Staple
I
II
Ill
2-1/4 x 0.112
Inches
Fastener
Standard
deviation
559
402
306
--633
488
372
610
506
333
610
433
342
58
77
52
--114
87
69
86
104
59
79
64
47
-Inch-pounds -
Mean
A parameter
0.674
.030
.128
.140
.185
3- x 0.120inch nail
24.6
24.6
24.6
24.6
24.6
24.6
24.6
24.6
24.6
24.6
24.6
30.5
30.5
30.5
Constant
Bparameter
0.434
.114
.092
.248
.208
Standard
deviation
424
345
247
183
85
503
354
287
436
348
243
512
332
253
0.428
.188
.054
.198
.284
17.3
17.3
17.3
--17.3
17.3
17.3
17.3
17.3
17.3
22.3
22.3
22.3
Standard
deviation
427
320
228
--482
344
269
460
356
250
409
333
245
72
67
38
60
40
33
91
38
36
--
60
57
32
--
- Inch-pounds -
Mean
A parameter
2-1/2-inch
staple
86
56
64
26
9
70
51
61
60
42
47
93
55
45
- Inch-pounds -
Mean
A parameter
24.3
24.3
24.3
24.3
24.3
24.3
25.5
25.5
25.5
---
24.3
24.3
24.3
Constant
B parameter
Yellow-poplar stringer
and oak deck
Table 7.Parameter values obtained assuming B constant. Parameters were obtained by fitting M = A tanh (q
B ) to the experimental moment-rotation
data with the restriction that B be held constant for (1) ail patterns with ail nails within a species combination and (2) ail patterns with staples within a
species combination
Summary of Findings
where
M
= moment, inch-pounds
= rotation, radians (0 0.09)
and
A and B = equation parameters, table 7.
Literature Cited
2.5-8/85
12