Summary of Evaluation: 1 17.80 Fail Civil Engineering Research and Consultancy PVT - LTD

Summary of Evaluation
Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10
Name of Work: -Detailed Engineering Survey, Design and Report Preparation of

Haldarpur-Samsergung-Madanchowk-Baniyabhar Road,Banke
SN
Name of Firm/JV
CIVIL ENGINEERING
PVT.LTD.
Technical Mark
Obtained
RESEARCH
AND
CONSULTANCY
Remarks
17.80
Fail
SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.
17.40
Fail
RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.
14.40
Fail
Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10

Marks for Relevant Experience of the firm(Last ten years only ) : Max 10
Road Length=10 KM
Work Experience As Consultant
Name of Firm
CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND
CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.
Marks per Project
Max Mark
Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Road
10
DPR Preparation
10
Construction Survey,Design & Supervision of Road
10
0
1
TOTAL
Marks for Understanding to the TOR, Methodology, Work Plan and Technology transfer/Training : Max 40
Description
CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.
Evaluation Remarks
Total Marks
Avg marks from 3

Eval 1
evaluators
Eval 2
Eval 3
Not Significant
General
Comments or suggestions on ToR and services
1.6
1.6
0.0
0.0
0.0
12
7.2
4.0
Significant
Not Significant
General Review
Description and review any relevant documents like Design Standards
Critical Review
No Description
If any of the key personnel has visited the site and has attached a photograph, described the site and has
attached a photograph, described the site.
General Description
General Description with site photograph
Technical Description with site photograph

Not Significant
General
Methodology to perform Socio-economical & Traffic Study
Clear Methodology with flow charts

Not Significant
General Methodology Only
Methodology to perform Detailed Engineering Survey
General Methodology with flow charts
7.2

Not Significant
Fairly justify the proposed methodology
Work Scheduled with description
Relevant to proposed methodology
Not Significant
Fairly justify the proposed Work scheduled
Manning scheduled as per Work Scheduled
4.0
4
Relevant to proposed Work Scheduled

TOTAL
40
Average TOTAL
40
Description
Evaluation Remarks
16.8
16.8
Marks for Technology transfer : Max 5
The idea of sharing know-how of the works highlights on dissemination of knowledge and training proposed by the
consultant.
Total Marks
Avg marks from 3

evaluators
General (only standard method description)
0.0
0
Significant
TOTAL
Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key Personnel : Max 45

Personnel
Highway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )
No of experience in similar jobs
1.5 marks for each job but not exceeding 15 marks
Dr.Padam Bahadur Shahi

Geotechnical Engineer
1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks
Hari Krishna Mainali

Hydrologist
Binod Chandra Devkota

Sociologyist /Economist
Embika Prasad Mahato
Total
Grand Total
Remarks
Eval 1 Eval 2 Eval 3
Not Significant
Minimunm Experience
after Bachelor Degree

Education(Y/N)
Experience Marks
10
15
20
15
15
0
0.00
17.80
Fail
Road Length=10 KM
Marks per Project
DPR Preparation
1
TOTAL
Description

TOTAL
Average TOTAL

Description
consultant.
TOTAL

Personnel
Sita Ram Shah

Arun Kumar Pandit

Hydrologist
Hemant Kumar Jha

Ambar Bahadur Thapa
Total
Grand Total
Remarks
Name of Firm
Max Mark
10
10
10
0
3
Training : Max 40
Evaluation Remarks
Total Marks
Avg marks from 3

Eval 1
evaluators
Eval 2
Not Significant
General
1.6
1.6
0.0
0.0
0.0
12
7.2
1.6
4.0
Significant
Not Significant
General Review
Critical Review
General Description
Not Significant
General
Not Significant
7.2

Not Significant
1.6
Not Significant

40
40
14.4
14.4
Evaluation Remarks
Total Marks
Avg marks from 3

evaluators
Eval 1 Eval 2
Not Significant
0.0
0
Significant
Minimunm Experience

Education(Y/N)
Experience Marks
10
34
14
10
0
0.00
17.40
Fail
Eval 3
Eval 3
Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10

Road Length=10 KM
Marks per Project
DPR Preparation
1
TOTAL
Description

TOTAL
Average TOTAL

Description
consultant.
TOTAL

Personnel
Arvind Kumar Yadav

Anand Gupta
Hydrologist
Deepak Paudel
Sohan Maharjan
Total
Grand Total
Remarks
Name of Firm
Max Mark
10
10
10
0
0
Training : Max 40
Evaluation Remarks
Total Marks
Avg marks from 3

Eval 1
evaluators
Eval 2
Not Significant
General
1.6
1.6
0.0
0.0
0.0
12
7.2
1.6
4.0
Significant
Not Significant
General Review
Critical Review
General Description
Not Significant
General
Not Significant
7.2

Not Significant
1.6
Not Significant

40
40
14.4
14.4
Evaluation Remarks
Total Marks
Avg marks from 3

evaluators
Eval 1 Eval 2
Not Significant
0.0
0
Significant
Minimunm Experience
Education(Y/N)
Experience
Marks
10
21
11
20
0
0.00
14.40
Fail
Eval 3
Eval 3
Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10

Road Length=10 KM
Marks per Project
DPR Preparation
1
TOTAL
Description

TOTAL
Average TOTAL

Description
consultant.
TOTAL

Personnel
GBS TAMRAKAR
Dr.Ram Krishna Poudel

Hydrologist
Sanjay Adhikari
Hari Darshan Shrestha
Total
Grand Total
Remarks
Name of Firm
CARD CONSULTANT PVT.LTD.
Max Mark
10
10
10
10
10
0
10
Training : Max 40
Evaluation Remarks
Total Marks
Avg marks from 3

Eval 1
evaluators
Eval 2
Not Significant
General
4.0
4
Significant
Not Significant
General Review
5.0
5
0
Critical Review
General Description
0.0
0.0
12
12.0

Not Significant
General

Not Significant
12

Not Significant
1.6
4.0
1.6
Not Significant

40
40
26.6
26.6
Evaluation Remarks
Total Marks
Avg marks from 3

evaluators
Eval 1 Eval 2
Not Significant
0.0
0
Significant
Minimunm Experience

Education(Y/N)
Experience Marks
10
20
30
23
0
0.00
36.60
Fail
Eval 3
Eval 3
Manpower Repetition Sheet

Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10
Firms
Key Personnels
Highway/ Transport Engineer
Hydrologist
Senior Surveyor

RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS
Dr.Padam Bahadur Shahi

Hari Krishna Mainali
Binod Chandra Devkota
Sita Ram Shah
Arvind Kumar Yadav
Arun Kumar Pandit

Hemant Kumar Jha
Anand Gupta
Deepak Paudel
Embika Prasad Mahato
Ambar Bahadur Thapa
Sohan Maharjan
GBS TAMRAKAR
Dr.Ram Krishna Poudel
Sanjay Adhikari
Hari Darshan Shrestha
Name of Work: -Detailed Engineering Survey, Design and Report Preparation of Haldarpur-Samsergung-Madanchowk-Baniyabhar
Road,Banke
Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10
Road Length =10KM
Marks per Project
DPR Preparation
Max Marks
CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH

AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.
10
TOTAL
10
0
1
0
3
Marks for Understanding to the TOR, Methodology, Work Plan and Technology transfer/Training
: Max 40
Description
Max Marks

1.6
1.6
0.0
12
7.2
40
40
16.8
16.8
1.6
1.6

TOTAL
Average TOTAL

Description
consultant.
Max Marks
Name of Work: -Detailed Engineering Survey, Design and Report Preparation of Haldarpur-Samsergung-Madanchowk-Baniyabhar
Road,Banke
Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10
consultant.
TOTAL

15
10
10
10
45
100
0
17.8
0
0
Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key

Personnel : Max 45
Personnel
No of experience in similar jobs **
Max Marks
Hydrologist
Senior Surveyor
Total
Grand Total
Remarks
ort Preparation of Haldarpur-Samsergung-Madanchowk-Baniyabhar

ad,Banke
RURAL
INFRASTRUCTURE
DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.
CARD CONSULTANT
PVT.LTD.
10
0
0
10
RURAL
CARD CONSULTANT
INFRASTRUCTURE
PVT.LTD.
DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.
1.6
1.6
1.6
RURAL
CARD CONSULTANT
INFRASTRUCTURE
PVT.LTD.
DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.
4
4
ort Preparation of Haldarpur-Samsergung-Madanchowk-Baniyabhar

ad,Banke
0
RURAL
CARD CONSULTANT
INFRASTRUCTURE
PVT.LTD.
DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.
0
0
0
0
0
0
Government of Nepal
Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and Transport
Department of Roads
Design and Planning Branch
Planning Monitoring and Evaluation Unit
Babarmahal, Kathmandu
Combined Evaluation Sheet (Technical and Financial)

Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10
SN.
Name and Address of Financial Proposal
1,504,983.84
Total estimated amount excluding VAT & contingencies =
Technical Score out

of 100
Rate/Km Without
VAT
Read out Financial

Proposal Price
Diff w.r.t. estimate
Technical
Score(80%)
Financial
Score(20%)
Total Score (100%)
Rank
CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.
17.80
(100.00)
14.24
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
17.40
(100.00)
13.92
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
14.40
(100.00)
11.52
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
#DIV/0!
37

Summary of Evaluation: 1 17.80 Fail Civil Engineering Research and Consultancy PVT - LTD

Diunggah oleh

Informasi Dokumen

Judul Asli

Hak Cipta

Format Tersedia

Bagikan dokumen Ini

Bagikan atau Tanam Dokumen

Opsi Berbagi

Apakah menurut Anda dokumen ini bermanfaat?

Apakah konten ini tidak pantas?

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

Summary of Evaluation: 1 17.80 Fail Civil Engineering Research and Consultancy PVT - LTD

Diunggah oleh

Hak Cipta:

Format Tersedia

Summary of Evaluation

Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10

Name of Work: -Detailed Engineering Survey, Design and Report Preparation of

SLATE CONSULTANTS PVT.LTD.

RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPERS PVT.LTD.

Contract No. - 337159/071/72/DPR-10

Marks per Project

Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Road

Construction Survey,Design & Supervision of Road

CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND CONSULTANCY PVT.LTD.

Avg marks from 3

Comments or suggestions on ToR and services

Description and review any relevant documents like Design Standards

Technical Description with site photograph

Methodology to perform Socio-economical & Traffic Study

Clear Methodology with flow charts

Methodology to perform Detailed Engineering Survey

General Methodology with flow charts

Clear Methodology with flow charts

Work Scheduled with description

Relevant to proposed methodology

Manning scheduled as per Work Scheduled

Relevant to proposed Work Scheduled

Marks for Technology transfer : Max 5

Avg marks from 3

General (only standard method description)

Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key Personnel : Max 45

Highway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )

No of experience in similar jobs

1.5 marks for each job but not exceeding 15 marks

Dr.Padam Bahadur Shahi

1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks

Hari Krishna Mainali

1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks

Binod Chandra Devkota

1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks

Embika Prasad Mahato

Eval 1 Eval 2 Eval 3

CIVIL ENGINEERING RESEARCH AND

Marks per Project

Detailed Engineering Survey and Design of Road

Construction Survey,Design & Supervision of Road

Comments or suggestions on ToR and services

Description and review any relevant documents like Design Standards

Methodology to perform Socio-economical & Traffic Study

Methodology to perform Detailed Engineering Survey

Work Scheduled with description

Manning scheduled as per Work Scheduled

Marks for Technology transfer : Max 5

Marks for Qualification and Competence of Key Personnel : Max 45

Highway / Transport Engineer (Team Leader )

No of experience in similar jobs

1.5 marks for each job but not exceeding 15 marks

Sita Ram Shah

1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks

Arun Kumar Pandit

1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks

Hemant Kumar Jha

1 marks for each job but not exceeding 10 marks

Ambar Bahadur Thapa

Avg marks from 3

Clear Methodology with flow charts

Relevant to proposed methodology