Page Number
3
3
4
6
6
6
6
10
10
10
11
13
16
17
20
21
22
22
24
26
27
29
30
30
31
35
36
39
40
41
42
43
45
45
46
48
48
Appendix
Community Resources, Agencies, and Organizations for Referring Clients
NFCC Member Code of Ethics
NFCC Member Quality Standards
50
55
56
CHAPTER 1
BASIC COUNSELING PRINCIPLES
NFCC Member Quality Standards
As a counselor you will work within the framework of the standards of the National Foundation
for Credit Counseling (NFCC). NFCC member agencies and employees must abide by the
NFCCs Member Code of Ethics and Member Quality Standards which assure that clients
seeking to achieve financial health are treated fairly and ethically. See Appendix: NFCC
Member Quality Standards.
Honest.
Fair.
Stays abreast of economic changes, creditor policies, etc. which will affect
clients and the counseling process.
Confidentiality
level. You may provide information for generating and evaluating alternatives as your clients
make decisions and plan for handling changes that will lead to economic security.
Source of Support
Clients look to you for support and understanding during difficult times or crises. You can
empathize with a client's feelings about losing a job, being sued, not knowing how to handle
finances, or being denied credit because of past mistakes. With your help and support, clients can
learn to overcome fears, real or perceived, that would prevent meeting their financial goals. This
requires that you have integrity, compassion, and good interpersonal relations, and show an
urgent concern for the client's well-being.
Clients in crisis can feel reassured by your assistance and your ability to help them relieve
immediate stress. Some clients need the reinforcement and encouragement you can provide as
they make decisions, implement plans, and work toward resolving problems or achieving goals.
Because you are available to help and not to ridicule or make judgments, clients can feel more
confident about disclosing personal information and discussing mistakes.
Educator
Many clients have problems because they do not understand the complexities of credit, the credit
process, or the consequences of mismanaging financial resources. You can educate clients about
how to budget, how to manage money and credit, and how to develop a workable system of
household financial organization. Often, clients need to be shown that what they decide today
affects their tomorrow.
In your role as educator, you can also offer tips about consumer shopping skills and practices,
including buying household goods, housing and transportation. Many clients need education
about consumer rights and responsibilities as well as education about saving for short- and longterm goals. Some clients will also need to be educated about various financial services offerings,
such as investments and insurance. Education can be informal or formal, through one-to-one
counseling, group programs, media, internet, or volunteer programs.
Resource Consultant
Because of your experience working with clients who face a variety of challenges, you can offer
many creative ideas and specific insights about finding and managing resources. In addition to
assessing each client's available income, employee benefits, credit, and other financial resources,
you can assist in identifying and drawing on the client's personal resources -- such as inner
strength and special skills.
Furthering your contacts within the community and referring to your organization's Community
Resource Guide will enable you to suggest additional resources available to clients.
Preventive Counselor
Preventive counseling is used to guard against future financial difficulties and may take two
distinct forms: immediate and long-range. Immediate help is required when an unexpected event
occurs, such as an auto accident, illness, or death in the family. Preventive counseling helps to
keep an individual from getting into excessive debt or helps by creating a realistic savings plan.
This type of counseling focuses on preventing pitfalls and maximizing the chances to achieve
financial goals. The counselor can look for ways to encourage clients to save for emergencies
and difficult times such as a layoff or an unexpected illness. Long range counseling can also
help clients learn to set aside funds for regular future expenses such as car or home repairs, gift
giving or vacation planning.
Conflict of Interest
A conflict of interest is a situation in which a counselor might jeopardize the rights or interests of
a client through involvement or contact with someone else. It is important to avoid any potential
conflicts of interest that may arise in a counseling session caused by your personal or
professional relationships. If such instances occur, it is a best practice to refer such individuals
to another counselor or a different agency. If you are unsure if a conflict of interest exists,
discuss the situation with your supervisor.
Confidentiality
One of your most important professional responsibilities is to safeguard client confidentiality.
You must never release any client information without written authorization from the client.
Also, never discuss clients or specifics of cases outside of the agency environment.
shows that the results are not as expected. Then the counselor and client may decide to revise
the diagnosis, reexamine goals and objectives, find new alternatives, change the action plan, or
change the implementation.
1. Diagnosing Problems
Before you can help your clients, you have to understand their financial circumstances and
diagnose the problems that concern them. Gathering information about your clients' finances and
problems is accomplished using questioning techniques, imperative statements, and other
communication techniques. Each individual counseling organization has its own procedures
regarding the information gathering process as a guide to summarize data about each client's
financial situation. You also prepare a budget/spending plan to analyze the client's income and
expenditures.
As you continue to build rapport and trust during the counseling interview, clients will gain
confidence and be encouraged to disclose sensitive concerns they may initially be reluctant to
reveal. Without applying excessive pressure, you should probe for more details so you can get an
accurate picture of what your clients face.
2. Setting Appropriate Goals
Now that you and your client understand the situation and the problems at hand, you can move
on to set goals that will lead to resolving those problems. There are two types of goals: process
goals and outcome goals.
The counselor is responsible for process goals, targets for building a productive relationship that
will support the client in resolving problems and achieving desired goals. Clients are responsible
for outcome goals, targets for getting out of problems and moving toward results they want to
achieve.
To be effective in guiding client actions and decisions, outcome goals should be specific,
achievable, and measurable. Vague goals don't help clients plan decisions and actions. In
contrast, a specific goal says exactly what a client expects to be able to do. If the goal is
achievable, it will encourage the client to take action. However, if the goal is unrealistic, it will
wind up discouraging the client. By setting goals that are measurable, the client can monitor
progress and determine when the goal has been achieved.
Goals, objectives, and alternatives should be developed in the context of a client's individual
values. At times, your personal values may differ from those of your clients. Nonetheless, bear in
mind that clients will be most strongly motivated to work toward goals and objectives and to
select alternatives that fit with their values and life experiences.
3. Specifying Objectives
Few people can achieve their goals right away, especially if the goals relate to long-range issues
such as saving for a comfortable retirement or planning to fund a child's college education. For
this reason, clients need to set interim objectives that will guide their behavior in the days,
weeks, and months leading up to the time when they expect to achieve their goals. As with goals,
List of the array of potential options available to the client, including bankruptcy as
applicable.
Developed with the clients participation and a copy given to the client
Focused on timely resolution of the clients needs and based on the urgency of the
problem and the length of time needed to achieve appropriate results
To create a plan with the characteristics listed above, help clients determine the real cause of the
problem and identify the resources that can be applied to solving it, including personal, family,
and community resources. Next, work with clients to clarify their goals, their alternative
solutions, and the criteria for deciding among their alternatives. Examples of general alternatives
for clients to look at include options for increasing income, decreasing expenses, looking for
ways to reallocate how debts are paid and identifying what assets are available to resolve
financial concerns.
After they have decided on a course of action, you can help clients plan action steps and set a
schedule for taking those actions. Writing the action steps down with the client will help
strengthen the proposed plan. Urge clients to take the lead in preparing action plans, so that they
gain confidence and feel more commitment to carrying out plans.
6. Implementing and Evaluating Plans
Positive and negative feedback come into play during implementation and evaluation. You can
use positive, constructive feedback to reinforce continuation of client actions that lead toward
goals. Even if a client has not taken every action in the plan, you can show support for the
actions that were taken. You will also want to tactfully point out actions that move clients away
from their goals.
In this way, you can maintain a productive relationship with clients. Clients may need additional
counseling at a later date to help them return to an earlier part of the process to revise the
diagnosis, change goals or objectives, come up with other alternatives, revise the plans or change
the way the plans are being implemented.
CHAPTER 2
COMMUNICATING EFFECTIVELY
The Communication Process
The counseling process depends on clear, effective communication between counselor and client.
Communication is the exchange of information to share meaning. In exchanging ideas, you and
your clients can use both verbal and nonverbal communication. Verbal communication is the use
of language, such as the words in a conversation or a letter, to share meaning. In contrast, sharing
meaning through nonverbal communication involves the use of body language, voice qualities,
and other methods, rather than words.
The communication process has five basic steps:
1) The sender has an idea.
2) The sender formulates a message -- including information and/or emotions -to share the idea with a receiver.
3) The message is sent through a medium, such as a spoken sentence or a written letter.
4) The receiver gets the message and understands its meaning.
5) The receiver responds to the sender by indicating that the meaning has been
understood or by reacting to the content with a message sent in return.
10
body position, facial expressions, voice inflection and tone, rate of speech, gestures and
mannerisms, and body movement.
Some elements of body language are used consciously and deliberately, including gestures such
as handshakes, waves, and smiles. But often counselors and clients are not aware of other actions
that communicate a message nonverbally, such as tight muscles, raised eyebrows, clenched fists,
faster breathing rate, and the space or distance between themselves and others. Even when
people are not consciously aware of these signals, they may still be receiving and responding to
the nonverbal messages from the sender.
You will also want to keep the steps of the communication process in mind as you work with
clients. Avoid the barriers that prevent sharing of meaning by making a special effort to be
accurate and consistent in conveying your message. Also train yourself to be more perceptive
and alert to the subtle messages that your clients are sending during an interview.
Listening
Listening is the process that links the sender and the receiver in the communication process. Both
client and counselor need good listening skills, because a real exchange of ideas can occur only
when each listens to the other. Effective listening helps forge a closer relationship between the
counselor and the client, allowing them to work together successfully.
When you actively listen, you do more than simply hear someone else's words. Active listening
is actually a five-step process:
Step 1. Attend to the person who is speaking by focusing on his or her words and nonverbal
signals -- and screening out any other sounds. You can use posture, eye contact, and other
nonverbal signals to show the speaker that you are paying close attention when conducting an inperson counseling session.
Step 2. Interpret the verbal and nonverbal cues being sent by the speaker so you can grasp the
meaning. During telephone or Internet counseling sessions, be aware of pauses in the
conversation and/or omission of information.
Step 3. Remember the message, especially the significant details you may need to help the client
later.
Step 4. Evaluate the message to determine whether it is complete and accurate.
Step 5. Respond to the sender's message by offering feedback. Feedback shows that you have
received and understood the sender's meaning. It also continues the two-way flow of information
that is critical to establishing and maintaining a good counseling relationship.
In a counseling situation, you will want to listen and react with empathy and compassion. Clients
-- especially new ones -- may feel nervous, discouraged, humiliated, or have other strong
emotions that are not verbally expressed. Therefore, be aware of what may be happening under
the surface as people speak.
11
12
Suggestion: Show courtesy toward your clients by minimizing the possibility of distractions.
Barrier 8. Pencil listening. Note-taking seldom improves listening. You may become so
involved in writing that you miss what the client is saying. Although notes are sometimes
necessary, be careful that this does not interfere with effective listening.
Suggestion: If you must take notes, jot only a word or two to jog your memory so you can
complete your notes after the session is over. Tell the client that you may jot a note or two so
that you dont forget something that you want to come back to.
Positive Listening Habits
To build a strong working relationship with a client through effective listening in an interview,
you will want to develop the following six habits:
1)
2)
3)
4)
Limit your talking to half or less of the time spent with a client;
Be alert to the client's verbal and nonverbal signals;
Listen for understanding, not to prepare a rebuttal;
Mentally reconstruct the client's problem as it is being discussed to reinforce your
understanding and clarify key points;
5) Concentrate on the client, not on your personal thoughts;
6) Mentally analyze and evaluate the client's points, sifting fact from opinion.
Offer internal summaries (briefly recapping ideas in the middle of a conversation) to confirm
with the client that you understood what was being said. Review and summarize at the end of the
session to confirm mutual understanding of what was communicated and what happens next.
Questioning Techniques
During a counseling interview, you can use two major types of questions to elicit information
about a client's situation, challenges, values, and goals. Primary questions are key questions that
help you bring out significant information. Secondary questions are probes used as follow-ups to
explore vague or incomplete responses to primary questions.
Primary Questions
Among the types of primary questions you can ask in a counseling session are:
1. Closed-ended questions
2. Open-ended questions
3. Hypothetical questions
4. Leading questions
A closed-ended question is phrased to obtain a specific, limited response from the client.
Examples of closed-ended questions:
How old are you?
What is the name of the collection agency?
13
Closed-ended questions are helpful when you want a brief, concise response and when you want
to reduce the amount of irrelevant information offered by the client. In some cases, a closedended question is phrased so that the client can answer with a simple yes or no (or true/false).
Alternatively, the question can offer multiple choices for the client to consider. However, closedended questions seldom elicit in-depth information. If overused, this type of questioning can lead
clients to feel like they are being interrogated. It can also turn into a rapid-fire approach where
the questions and their responses occur too rapidly for the counselor to properly absorb the
information.
In contrast, an open-ended question is worded so it does not structure the client's response.
Examples of open-ended questions:
What seems to be the problem?
What are your concerns about garnishment?
Such questions provide the client with a great deal of freedom to respond in any manner. As a
result, you will often learn a great deal by allowing clients to answer questions in their own way.
However, open-ended questions are not particularly time efficient.
A hypothetical question is used to set up a theoretical or role-simulation situation for the client to
consider when responding. Examples of hypothetical questions:
If you were in my position, what would you do?
What do you think would happen if you were laid off?
Some clients find hypothetical questions motivating, challenging, and insightful. Used skillfully,
these questions can elicit certain information or evoke client attitudes that are not easily reached
through questioning techniques.
At the same time, hypothetical questions can be time consuming. They may also be stressful to
the client. A client may feel threatened by such questions if they are introduced too early in the
interview, or if it they present a hypothetical situation to which the client cannot readily relate.
Leading questions (also known as loaded questions) are worded in such a way as to imply the
expected answer, which tends to bias the client's response. Examples of leading questions:
You certainly aren't thinking of skipping the court appearance, are you?
You didn't believe what he told you, did you?
Leading questions can be used as a device to elicit a reaction from the client when other
questioning techniques do not seem to be effective. They can also be used to encourage the client
to volunteer information that goes beyond the questions asked. However, such questions
generally influence or distort the responses, positively or negatively. Also, leading questions that
are emotionally charged can create a stressful interview environment, produce invalid responses,
14
15
In addition to encouraging the client to elaborate, internal summary questions allow you to check
whether you have correctly understood the client's answers.
Hypothetical probes, which set up theoretical situations for clients to consider, can be helpful
when clients have difficulty relating to your primary questions. Example of a hypothetical probe:
Counselor:
Do you ever purchase items at the grocery store that you dont
really need?
Client:
Yes, I probably do. My children often go along and request
expensive junk food.
Counselor: What if you found a neighbor or friend to watch your children
while you shopped so you could more easily stick to your weekly
food budget?
Hypothetical probes invite the client to assume a different role or imagine a different situation
and then respond. However, if overused, such probes can make clients feel uncomfortable or
uncertain. Use this technique sparingly, because it can sound too clinical or phony if overused.
Imperative Statements
During a counseling session, you can draw clients out through the use of imperative statements,
simple sentences designed to elicit more information, clarify meaning, and encourage client
participation and reaction. Examples of imperative statements:
Client:
"I can't seem to manage my money."
Counselor: "Tell me more. . . or Please expand on that. . . or Give me more
detail. . . or Please elaborate on that. . . or Go on. . ."
Imperative statements demonstrate your interest in what the client is saying while indicating that
you need more information. When you use an imperative statement, match your tone of voice to
the situation, sounding firm but not dictatorial.
16
Client:
"We make good money but have nothing left at the end of the
month."
Counselor: It sounds like you dont feel like youve got enough money to get
you through the month.
Client:
"These creditors are really upsetting me!"
Counselor: "They really upset you?"
A second way in which counselors can verbally pace is through paraphrasing. Unlike restating,
where you use the same words as the client, paraphrasing takes the essential content and puts it
into different words. When you paraphrase, be careful not to add or subtract words that may
communicate a different meaning. Examples of paraphrasing:
Client:
Counselor:
Client:
Counselor:
"The many bills I receive in the mail every day are driving me crazy
and my husband will not help and would not come with me today."
"You seem to be struggling with bill paying and it's creating family
pressures."
"Insurance is so expensive. Look how much we are spending on
family life insurance."
"You feel you should reevaluate your need for life insurance now."
Both restating and paraphrasing allow you to clarify a client's messages. Neither adds new
information, but both show understanding and lead to more thorough and meaningful discussion.
This can help build a mutual trust between counselor and client.
Summarizing serves the same general purpose as restating and paraphrasing, but it is especially
useful when a client has talked for an extended period explaining his or her situation. At this
point, there is a need to condense the client's statements and ideas. Summarizing also helps bring
a segment of the conversation to a close in order to provide more time for discussion or to end
the session. Also, summarizing can be helpful for the client in reviewing what needs to be done
at the next session or some later session. Examples of summarizing:
Counselor:
Counselor:
During a counseling interview, clients may attempt to put their situations in a positive light.
They may say only what they think you want to hear, or omit information which they think might
cause you to refuse services. They will offer excuses as to why they have not been financially
17
solvent or financially reliable in the past. They may be defensive and rationalize, particularly in
the early stages of the first interview. Some may attempt to cover up their real feelings, including
anxiety, concern and worry.
Keep in mind that clients may not appear to be completely honest, but what they are telling you
may be true from their perspective. The counselor needs to accept that clients will have anxiety
about talking about their financial problems and be careful not to appear judgmental. This will
allow clients to open up as they become more comfortable.
1. Detecting Client's Feelings And Attitudes
During an in-person counseling interview, how can you get a sense of what a client is feeling?
Nonverbal cues often signal a client's inner state. The client who sits erect and looks comfortable
is probably relaxed. When someone leans slightly forward, it indicates attention is being paid and
there is interest and involvement in the counseling session. The client who slouches or seems to
be drawing away from the counselor may be indicating disinterest, lack of trust, or boredom.
Frequent changes of position may indicate discomfort, lack of interest, or possibly unexpressed
anger.
Facial expressions are also indicators. The client whose face appears frozen in one expression
may be exhibiting fear, anxiety or anger. If the client glares or stares constantly at the counselor,
this could indicate anger or hostility. Eyes roving all around the room may indicate disinterest.
Eyes downcast and rarely meeting the gaze of the counselor may indicate shyness, shame,
anxiety, or fear. Some clients may cry during their session and the counselor can reassure the
client that financial problems are upsetting to everyone. Direct eye contact with the counselor
usually indicates that the client has a positive and concerned attitude toward solving the financial
problem.
As you know, voice patterns, tone, volume, and pitch of voice also reveal feelings. These voice
cues are especially important during telephone counseling since other nonverbal cues are not
available. The client whose tone is very loud or shouting may be indicating anger or hostility,
while the client whose tone of voice is soft may be shy or fearful. Stress may raise the pitch of
the voice and a high-pitched voice may indicate anxiety, fear, or anger. A low-pitched voice
suggests either comfort or strong control of emotions. If the pitch of a client's voice begins to rise
or starts to quiver or break, it may be that the client is about to cry.
2. Overcoming Resistance
Regardless of what approaches and techniques you use, the attitude of the client may prevent you
from having a productive counseling session. If a client is exhibiting severe resistance, you can
try these techniques:
Permit the client to vent his or her feelings before continuing with the
counseling session.
Use active listening skills to detect what is below the surface so you can
respond appropriately.
Redirect the discussion to a less threatening area and plan to return to the more
emotional topic at another time. Knowing when to back off is important if you want to
18
build a good relationship with your clients. Politely confront the client by calling
attention to the fact that he or she might be avoiding or resisting certain areas of
discussion.
3. Helping Clients Focus
You can help clients focus on key topics under discussion and take responsibility for themselves
during the counseling interview by modeling appropriate communication techniques. During the
course of counseling, a client may be dealing with one or more of eight common emotional
themes:
1) Clients may feel unique or different because of their financial problems.
2) Clients may generalize their anxieties about financial issues into a pervasive
anxiety about everything in their lives.
3) Clients may be depressed about their financial concerns.
4) Clients may experience general confusion about their ability to solve financial
problems.
5) Clients may have unrealistic financial goals or an unrealistic view of the
world.
6) Clients may feel inadequate to solve their financial problems.
7) Clients may be frustrated with themselves and/or others related to their
financial situation.
8) Clients may believe that change is beyond their control.
With focusing, clients learn to deal with their own issues and the underlying emotional themes.
One way to encourage this is to ask clients to use the first person singular and plural ("I" and
"we") rather than referring to an unspecified third person plural ("they") or talking vaguely about
"people" in general.
Also, urge clients to use present tense verbs rather than past tense verbs when referring to
continuing behavior. This encourages a focus on what the client is doing now and reinforces the
idea that the client can take control of a situation. You will also want to point out inconsistencies,
ambivalence, and distortions in client communication and behavior as a way of increasing
responsibility and movement toward problem resolution.
Through focusing, you can help clients concentrate on the underlying issues, understand that
they are able to resolve their financial problems, and prepare to take steps and make decisions
that lead to economic security.
4. Offering Feedback
In the course of counseling interviews, you will have the opportunity to provide feedback that
helps clients examine their behavior and measure progress toward achieving their goals. Positive
feedback lets clients know that their behavior is consistent with their goals. This kind of
feedback gives them encouragement to continue moving in the same direction and, once goals
have been achieved, to set and work toward new goals.
Negative feedback is used to alert people that their behavior is not consistent with their goals.
This helps clients consider the limits of behavior related to achieving their goals and see how far
19
they have to go to accomplish what they want. The purpose is to provide constructive
information that will allow clients to see how to refine their behavior in order to move closer to
their goals.
In offering feedback, be careful to discuss the client's behavior rather than the person. By
referring to what people do, you avoid sounding judgmental or critical. Keep your personal
values, feelings, needs, and wants separate from those of your clients. Clients will resent you if
you appear to be judgmental, condescending, or controlling.
The most effective approach is to concentrate on what is important to your clients and look for
ways to express your willingness to help clients achieve their goals. In addition, make your
feedback specific, confining yourself to comments about current behavior and actions under
consideration. Although people can't change what they have done in the past, they can change
what they do in the future, once you bring the consequences to their attention.
20
CHAPTER 3
THE COUNSELING RELATIONSHIP
The Building Blocks of Counseling
As you start counseling a new client, you will need to jointly work on six specific elements that
are the building blocks of a productive counseling relationship. These are:
1. Openness
2. Realistic expectations
3. Structure
4. Enabling/Empowerment
5. Confirmation of differences
6. Mutual involvement
Openness describes a willingness to offer information, including facts and relevant personal
thoughts and feelings. Openness applies to you as well as your client. You can set the tone for
the relationship by modeling openness. You can put clients at ease by mentioning that you have
experience working with other clients who faced similar problems. You can also offer
suggestions about options to be considered.
Realistic expectations are important from the very start. Clients may not understand what they
can realistically expect from the counseling relationship. Take some time during the first session
to help clients recognize that you will offer ideas and guidance but you cannot take control of
their financial situation or make decisions for them. You can also help clients gauge the reality
of the specific goals they set during counseling.
Structure comes from establishing the proper setting and goals for the relationship. This allows
you and your clients to work together to help the clients solve their problems, achieve their
personal goals and become more economically secure. Exploring means uncovering client issues
and concerns, thinking about goals and investigating the cause and dimensions of client
problems.
Understanding involves generating alternatives, evaluating these choices, and coming to a
decision about which option to choose.
Acting is the final stage of the counseling relationship, in which the client follows through on the
chosen alternative and implements plans to resolve issues and achieve goals.
Evaluation helps you and the client determine whether the actions taken are effective or whether
there is a need to return to an earlier stage for further exploring or understanding.
Enabling or empowering is the ability to influence clients through your communication style,
specialized knowledge and expertise, and understanding of the counseling process. Your goal is
not to control clients but to assist them throughout the counseling process in a positive way as
they generate and consider alternatives, think through the consequences of each possible action,
21
Making Referrals
During a counseling relationship, you may be dealing with a wide variety of client issues and
concerns. You and your organization will be able to handle many of these, including issues
related to credit delinquency, concerns about home equity or consolidation loans, repossessions,
imminent foreclosure or mortgage default, and methods of reestablishing credit.
At times, however, a client or family may require additional help with one or more specific
issues, such as:
abuse
housing concerns
legal services
health concerns
problems with consumer products
mental health issues
family conflicts
divorce
gambling
addictions
When you are thinking about referring clients to other agencies or groups, be sure you
understand the services that these other organizations provide. Use the appendix provided in the
back of this book to help get you started as you seek out local referrals for assisting clients.
Because financial difficulties are often part of a complex set of family and life circumstances,
having clients get assistance in other need areas of their lives is often critical to the clients
ability to successfully tackle their financial issues.
22
Many communities may also be served by telephone referral centers that clients can easily access
by calling 211 on their telephone.
Whenever you make a referral, you become part of a network of specialists working with a client
family. In such a situation, you will want to separate roles and clarify the division of
responsibility.
23
CHAPTER 4
DIAGNOSING PROBLEMS AND UNDERSTANDING
CLIENT VALUES
Diagnosing Financial Problems
As you know from your work with clients, financial management can be a problem for all kinds
of people in all life stages. Having financial problems can worsen marital or family discord, as
well. However, what appears to be an obvious problem is often merely a symptom. The real
reasons for financial trouble may not be readily apparent without a diagnosis based on careful
collection of data and an understanding of client behavior, values, and attitudes.
Debts (and other concerns) are frequently symptoms of financial problems. In your counseling
sessions, you will be helping clients distinguish between symptoms and problems so they can
plan for changes that will resolve the problems.
Causes of Financial Problems
The following are basic causes of financial problems that reflect a need for the client to plan and
change attitudes or behavior:
1. The conflict between expanding desires and limited income. Even families with rising
incomes may have expectations and expenditures that rise faster still. Expanding desires are
prompted by many things, including peer pressures, advertising, boredom, and increased
availability of income. To combat this problem, families can set spending priorities and then
budget accordingly.
2. The conflict between the present and the future, between needs and wants, between security
and comfort, and between achievement and risk. All families have to come to terms with a
healthy balance among these conflicting elements. An imbalance can threaten the family's ability
to manage its finances successfully today, tomorrow, and in the long term.
3. The emotional meaning of money. Clients may not be aware of the emotions underlying their
use of money. These include using money to buy friendship or to express love, impulsive
spending, using money to control others, making up for past deprivation, gaining prestige, and so
on. These hidden meanings of the use of money may involve a power struggle over control of
family resources.
4. Lack of control over or expertise in money management. Clients may not be able to control
the family's finances for a variety of reasons: inadequate math skills, lack of knowledge about
consumer rights, lack of experience with or knowledge about financial accounts, lack of access
to or control over a second checkbook or other credit cards in the family, or inability to recognize
the danger signs of credit overextension.
5. Inadequate income or savings to meet family needs, especially unexpected expenditures. A
family may be able to live on a certain level of income for some time, then have problems when
24
that income is reduced or eliminated due to cutbacks, unemployment, or business failure. The
addition of children to the family can increase expenditures, just as can other life changes. The
wage earners may lose their self-respect or the respect of relatives if they feel they cannot
provide a certain lifestyle for the family.
6. Personal values, attitudes, and behavior. How a client feels and acts can directly affect his or
her employment possibilities, ability to meet goals through appropriate budgeting, need to avoid
risk and gain better economic security, and handling of money matters. Values and attitudes
about money, lifestyles, family roles, etc. can influence a client's financial decisions and actions.
7. Lack of communication. When family members can't or won't communicate about money,
this is usually a symptom of more basic problems in the relationships. Of course, some clients
may not have good communication skills, which can affect their ability to cooperate with other
family members in preparing and implementing financial plans. Probing for more information
will help you determine whether a basic communication problem is the cause of financial
troubles and allow you to think about appropriate referrals if needed.
8. Overestimation of income and underestimation of expenses. Some people do not want to
know how much they actually make or spend, while others may not know because of poor
record-keeping. The reason behind the client's behavior should be identified so the client can
take steps to regain control over financial matters.
As you listen to a client's presenting or stated problem and start to formulate questions and
statements that will elicit further information, be alert for the underlying cause(s). Remember
that clients may be unwilling at first to discuss sensitive issues, so you may have to concentrate
on building trust to encourage disclosure of such information.
The Diagnostic Process
The presenting or stated problem is only the starting point for identifying the real cause of a
client's problem. The first step in the diagnosis process is to gather as much data as you can
about the client's financial situation and the symptoms of the problem. Next, you will have to
identify the underlying problems at the root of the client's trouble.
Having a client admit responsibility for a problem is not as important as having a client assume
responsibility for solving it. Therefore, if the subject of blame arises, you may want to remind
clients that uncovering the real reason for a problem is important, but blaming someone for
causing that problem will not help solve it. This reminder may also reassure a client who feels
guilty for causing a problem and has been unable to get past the guilt to make needed changes.
It can be helpful to restate the problem(s) until you and the family members come to consensus
on what needs to be resolved. Then, once the nature and extent of the problems have been
clarified, you need to help the client rank the problems to determine which should be tackled
first.
Some less-severe or less-urgent problems may have to wait while the client resolves more
pressing problems. Problems that entail priority debts such as mortgages must be handled as
25
quickly as possible because of the potential for disrupting the family's security.
26
Money is a powerful tool. It is a medium for acquiring status, recognition, and control, plus
many of the essentials and luxuries of life. Money also has many symbolic meanings as a way of
expressing love, anger, jealousy, power, success, attachment, and so on.
Lack of money, of course, has many negative meanings and effects, including those that can be
life-threatening. Therefore, counseling is bound to be affected by a myriad of economic, social,
and psychological family concerns which, to one degree or another, will influence all aspects of
the counseling process and outcomes.
During the counseling interview, you will be able to get a sense of what money really means to
each client. In all your interviews, therefore, it is important to look below the surface at each
client's underlying attitudes toward money; relate these attitudes toward client values, needs, and
goals. Then help clients prepare to change inappropriate attitudes so they can achieve their
financial goals.
Cultural Values
Communication with your clients also carries with it the responsibility for the counselor to be
aware of cultural differences that the client may bring to the counseling session.
As you counsel individuals with diverse cultural backgrounds, you need to be aware of how
cultural diversity may affect understanding of attitudes toward money. This may include
understanding trust and mistrust of the following:
Financial institutions.
Insurance.
Federal and state assistance programs.
Saving.
Using cash rather than credit.
Credit and its use.
Borrowing and lending.
Legal issues in dealing with finances.
Purchasing alternatives for major items like autos and homes.
According to an article in Managing Diversity September 1995 these are eight tips that can
help you improve communication with clients who represent a different culture or who speak
English as a second language.
Slow down. If youre from New Orleans and have worked in Boston or vice versa, you may
already know how difficult it is to understand what someone is saying. With these differences
just in the United States, imagine that it can be twice as difficult for a different ethnic group. As
you speak, check in with the client from time to time to see if he/she understands what you are
saying. Watch for facial cues and body language that indicate understanding, recognition, or
utter perplexity.
27
Use basic vocabulary. Most experts agree that todays average US reading comprehension is at
the fourth grade level. So, this is a tip that applies to everyone: always use words in their most
common meaning. Choose words with the smallest range of meanings wherever possible.
Say what you have to say in several ways. Repetition is the mother of learning. By
giving your message in a variety of words and images, you will help a listener or reader
understand. However, be careful not to overwhelm the receiver with too many versions. Ask the
client if he/she understands your meaning.
Avoid slang. If you ask the question, Where are you coming from? the answers you
receive may include the name of a persons home town or his or her last travel destination rather
than the reasons why he just said what he said. Are you into movies? may get a quizzical look
rather than an answer. Think about how you phrase a question before you ask it. Also, avoid
unfamiliar word pictures. (Blow your mind is a good example.)
Be careful with humor. Humor and jokes, while a staple or our communications, frequently
depend on intricate nuance of language. What is funny to someone born and raised in this
country may not be at all comical to a member of another culture.
Expect delayed reactions. When people are listening in a second language (or you are speaking
in one somewhat imperfectly), expect delayed reactions. It simply may take longer for your
listener to process what you said. Be patient for audience reactions and questions.
Dont assume their experiences are your experiences. Talking about your experiences,
feelings, and reactions can be an effective way to win over a listener in a conversation.
However, talk about these experiences as your own and as a member of your own cultural group.
Then, ask if their experience is different and how so. Listen to and accept their perceptions,
values and feelings even if they are not the same as yours. For example, in some cultures, the
banking establishment may be less trusted. Your acceptance and gained understanding of this
during your time with the client will help you allow the client to find options with which they
personally are comfortable.
Use the opportunity to learn about another culture. Clients may be more
respectful to you if they see that you are truly interested in them.
28
CHAPTER 5
CRISIS INTERVENTION AND THE NEED FOR CHANGE
The Sequence of a Crisis
Many of the clients who may come to you may be in some state of crisis. A crisis may be
precipitated by a catastrophic illness; sudden change in employment status; sudden change in
marital status due to divorce or a spouse's death; or another major, unexpected change in the
client's life that threatens to disrupt financial stability. Most people go through stages in the
process of recognizing a crisis and preparing to diffuse it.
Being aware of the normal sequence of crisis events can give you a better understanding of the
emotional state of the client, a sense of the impact of what may have already taken place, and an
appreciation for what may be expected in the future.
A crisis is a situation requiring:
Change and/or reevaluation of priorities, or
Change in assumptions about self and how to operate in the particular system, or
Outside help to manage the problem or to prevent a detrimental effect on self
and/or property.
A crisis can become an opportunity for growth and positive change rather than a disaster. The
Chinese characters for the word "crisis" are composed of two parts -- danger and opportunity.
With your help, clients can come to see that they will be stronger and more capable after they
have resolved their crises successfully.
The following illustrates the seven phases many clients move through in a financial crisis. As
you read about each phase, think about examples from your counseling experience and consider
what your clients were thinking, feeling, and doing in that phase.
1. Precipitating event. This is the unexpected occurrence that threatens the client's financial
stability.
2. Recognition of precipitating event as threatening. In this stage, the client realizes that the
family's finances may be endangered as a result of the event. The situation becomes more urgent.
3. Emotional reaction. Once the client realizes the danger, he or she may react emotionally,
expressing shock, disbelief, or some other outcry. Not every client expresses an emotional
reaction, however.
4. System maintenance. After the emotional reaction comes a response that helps the client
soften the impact by denying the danger, displacing attention to avoid dealing with the crisis,
projecting the problem or the cause elsewhere, delaying response, or simply feeling numb to
avoid feeling anything.
29
5. Disorganization. A client may feel disoriented as he or she begins to absorb the fact of the
crisis and the urgency of the threat. In this stage, clients commonly experience signals of distress
such as chemical abuse, over-eating, over-spending, and anxiety; they may have a lower
attention span and be unable to think clearly or make clear decisions because of confusion or
bewilderment at being overwhelmed by the crisis.
6. Acceptance. As the disorganized stage peaks and clients come to accept the crisis and the
urgent problems they face, they are ready to make changes so they can diffuse the threat. In this
stage, clients begin to move toward stability by setting priorities, choosing among alternative
solutions to solve their problems and learning from the crisis so they can better manage their
personal finances.
7. Resolution and stability. In the final stage of a crisis, the client has resolved the threatening
problems and regained stability. Now the client can move ahead to maintain the solution as long
as needed and gain strength and confidence to deal with future crises.
30
The first clue to a clients suicidal ideation comes from the client. The client may express
hopelessness, frustration, a feeling of intense isolation and loneliness. Or the client may make a
comment, which expresses a feeling that they cant go on or would be better off dead. When
a counselor hears such comments, he/she should be immediately inquisitive about the clients
state of mind regarding suicide.
It is generally wise for the counselor to immediately address any client comment about suicidal
thoughts. This can be done directly by simply asking the client how serious he/she is about
suicide as an alternative. In most cases, the client will respond with statements indicating that,
even though he/she occasionally thinks of killing him/herself, he/she would never actually do it.
At this point the counselor can return to the subject at hand but to keep monitoring client
statements regarding hopeless feelings.
In a few cases, however, the client may state that he/she is seriously considering suicide. If this
is the case, the counselor should ask questions concerning the intention to do so. If the client
reports serious intent, every attempt should be made to have the client call a mental health
professional. The client should be given a 24-hour help-line number available in most areas or
the client can be encouraged to call 911.
If the client is currently under the care of a mental health therapist, he/she should be encouraged
to call the therapist. If the client approves, the counselor could connect the client with the help
number or therapists office or emergency number during the counseling session.
In evaluating the risk of suicide, there are four components to be considered. These are:
Ideation, Means, Intent, Plan.
If the counselor hears vague references, which seem to indicate the presence of suicidal ideation
(thoughts), the client should be asked directly about each component. The presence of all four
components (ideation, means, intent, and plan) generally means that there could be a danger of
suicide and client statements should be taken seriously and addressed during the counseling
session. There is a lower risk of suicide when only the ideation is present, but there is not plan,
means or intent.
In summary, some clients can be very distressed. Financial problems are difficult to share with
friends or relatives. This can make a person feel quite isolated and alone. Some clients have
other mental health and life issues contributing to the thoughts of suicide. If a client states
suicidal thoughts, the counselor needs to be prepared to offer an appropriate response to get the
client to a skilled therapist or mental health provider.
31
In a counseling situation, your role is to be supportive of your clients as they confront change.
Help them clarify their own values, goals, and priorities as they consider their alternatives and
prepare for changes that will lead to economic security.
Stated barriers to change, which are mentioned by clients during the counseling interview, may
reflect rational thinking, whereas unstated barriers often reflect emotional responses, mistaken
thinking and beliefs, or anxiety about the change. As you read through the following seven
hypothetical situations, think about how the counselor's sample response relates to both the
stated and unstated barriers to change. Notice that the common thread is to reassure the client
that the crisis can be resolved. The responses also offer the client hope for an improved
economic future, which provides motivation for making real changes now.
1. Easing Of Crisis As A Barrier To Real Change
Client tells counselor: "I really want to change.
Unstated barrier in client's thoughts: "I have just bought more time. Now that the creditors are off
my back, I can continue to do whatever I want."
Sample counselor response: "You may be off the hook this month and maybe next month, too,
but unless you make changes, your outstanding debts will catch up with you. Remember that
your credit report will reflect your failure to repay credit obligations for seven years. Or, if a
worse emergency arises or wonderful opportunities come along, you will not be able to handle
them. As the counselor, you are the expert in knowing what the potential consequences to the
clients choices and in your role as counselor, it is important to discuss the potential longer term
consequences to the clients actions.
2. Past Deprivation As Barrier To Real Change
Client tells counselor: "I have worked so hard or have been so victimized that I deserve
something for me.
Unstated barrier in client's thoughts: "I must make up for past deprivation, working so hard, and
sacrificing for other people for such a long time."
Sample counselor response: "I know that you do deserve rewards and that you have worked hard.
I also think that you deserve to be in control of your own affairs, to be master of your own
finances rather than be controlled by indebtedness or other problem. You have achieved success
in so many areas of your life. Your finances are yet another area for you to master. You have
succeeded so much that you seem to have no fear of failure; you think that you will not be hurt
by your finances. However, do not set yourself up for failure. You can manage your financial
matters if you try."
3. Need For Personal Control As Barrier To Real Change
Client tells counselor: "I think I should do such and such." Or client is silent when discussion
turns to generating alternatives.
32
Unstated barrier in client's thoughts: "I can do whatever I want to do. No one is going to tell me
what to do."
Sample counselor response: "You can do whatever you want to do. You have the right to make
your own choices. As a counselor, I have the responsibility to show you the consequences of
your choices. I would not be doing my job if I did not warn you of the possible consequences of
various choices. It takes more effort and concern for me to explain consequences than to just let
you make choices without being informed."
4. Lack Of Control As Barrier To Real Change
Client tells counselor: "I need a budget. Will you give me a workable budget?"
Unstated barrier in client's thoughts: "I cannot control my finances. I spend more than my
income," or "I am in trouble with my creditors," or "I am scared because of overwhelming
costs," or "I cannot say no to my children."
Sample counselor response: "Up until now, how have you handled your finances? Where do you
feel that your spending is out of line? Out of line with what? Who is spending ..., how much ...,
for what ... or whom? Let's write down your expenses, analyze them, and then set up a financial
plan or budget with a format and system for control, geared to your need and personality so it
will work better for you."
5. Immediate Needs As A Barrier To Real Change
Client tells counselor: "I cannot save now. I have too many expenses. I am just trying to survive
now."
Unstated barrier in client's thoughts: "Why should I save for the future when it is so uncertain
and I am so anxious about meeting my family's needs today? We need the money now."
Sample counselor response: "Drastic changes in lifestyle now are necessary for life security
throughout your later years. You will feel more secure if you save now so you can take
advantage of an opportunity or diffuse an emergency later. Statistics show that everyone will
have a crisis at one time or another, of one type or another -- and these crises can be resolved by
having a financial reserve. Financial independence comes from planning, saving, and sacrificing
now so that you have choices later. Otherwise, you will soon have fewer -- or no -- choices."
6. Hopelessness As A Barrier To Real Change
Client tells counselor: "I do not think this plan will work . . ."
Unstated barrier in client's thoughts: "Why try? Nothing ever works out right anyway." Or: "I
really do not want to take the effort to change myself, someone else, or anything else."
Sample counselor response: "Maybe the plan will not work -- that is true. The plan will certainly
not work if you do not try. But the possible outcome from taking the risk of improvement offers
more opportunity than the increasingly negative consequences of doing nothing."
33
34
CHAPTER 6
LIFE EVENTS, FAMILY STRUCTURE, AND
FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT
Life Events
As a counselor, you will work with people whose life situations vary widely. Key life events
such as getting married, having children, preparing for higher education for oneself or children,
establishing a career, becoming divorced, remarrying, and preparing for retirement can have a
profound effect on a person's financial concerns, goals and use of resources.
Regardless of the structure and composition of the client familytraditional or nontraditional
couple with or without children, single adult, single parent--you will start the counseling process
by understanding the client's individual situation and the influence of life events on that client's
economic attitudes, behavior and consumption patterns.
Once you have determined the life events and financial challenges that shape a client's situation,
you can help the client think through his or her short- and long-term goals, learn about effective
money management skills, weigh alternative solutions to pressing problems, and plan for future
economic security.
Each client is unique, and not every individual will experience every life event. For example,
some people may never marry, yet they will inevitably face retirement issues. Some clients need
help financing college or graduate school for themselves or their children, or will be coping with
outstanding debts from higher education.
Divorce can also change the course of an individual's life. Single parents may be concerned
about child support issues; remarried clients may have to manage income to cover expenses for
the new family, as well as for a spouse or children from a previous marriage. Regardless of
marital status or family structure, a client may require counseling for employment problems and
for help in planning for financial security after retirement.
Many life events affect family structure, in turn influencing the way a client manages household
finances. As you come to know more about a client's life situation, you will be better able to
determine the appropriate approach to take in resolving that client's financial issues.
The next sections offer an overview of challenges related to life events and family structure,
including specific financial challenges and opportunities that a client may face. Some life
events will require many of the following skills as a client adjusts to the changing conditions of
his or her life and finances. Depending on the clients individual situation and family structure, a
client may need to:
Establish financial independence and self-reliance;
Develop smart shopping skills to buy and maintain household goods;
Balance a checkbook;
Handle credit;
35
36
The way your client perceives and manages financial matters may be quite different from the
way you handle your own finances. You should avoid being judgmental and applying stereotypes
when working with any client. Each client is different and, although a client's values and
priorities may not match your own, you should respect the client's viewpoint and understand
what is and is not appropriate, given that client's situation.
Credit and financial counseling is based on the belief that people can:
Develop a sense of control;
Accept responsibility;
Believe that behavioral changes are necessary.
It is important to set the tone for a counseling relationship that is empathic, accepting, respectful,
sincere, and honest. Remember, however, that change comes slowly. After you have established
a climate of trust and support, you can introduce a variety of ideas and tools for clients to use in
resolving the immediate problems and getting on track toward reaching identified goals.
One of your most important functions is to demonstrate to clients that they have options. A client
can control his or her attitude toward financial matters. Any client can learn to adjust his or her
lifestyle, think creatively about increasing family income, and develop a realistic budget for the
entire family. You can help your client recognize that every action taken toward controlling
expenses, repaying outstanding debts, or increasing income is a step toward future economic
security.
Higher Income Families
Higher income families can experience severe financial problems. They may:
Misunderstand complex financial instruments;
Have lost income;
Make ill-advised investment decisions;
Have secured or unsecured debt;
Have not considered negative consequences of changes in tax laws.
However, higher income clients often have assets they can liquidate or borrow against to make
some or all of the most urgent payments. In addition, these clients may carry insurance that
cushions against problems such as medical disability.
You may find some higher income clients somewhat overwhelmed by and ashamed of money
worries. They may be concerned about how financial problems will affect their status in the
community. Many have become accustomed to a certain lifestyle and a competitive corporate
environment. Having less money to spend in keeping up appearances can be a particularly severe
emotional blow. Therefore, the higher income client will want your reassurance that his or her
case is being handled confidentially.
Higher income clients may also be especially susceptible to pressure from collectors. They are
likely to do whatever is needed to relieve the feeling of humiliation at being unable to meet their
obligations. They want to get over these feelings quickly, so you'll find that many enter
counseling seeking fast solutions.
37
38
They may not be able to find a low-cost bank account, so may handle their
finances by using payroll check-cashing services, payday loans, pawnshops
and/or rent-to-own shops, and/or by buying money orders when payments must be
mailed.
39
You will want to review each client's eligibility for individual programs, be sure that clients
understand applicable rules and time limits for receiving benefits, and continue searching for
alternatives to help clients as they resolve their financial difficulties.
Employment Issues
Job loss is another major life event that many clients may be experiencing when they seek
counseling. Few people today will find themselves working at just one job or for one employer
throughout their working lives. Most clients will probably change jobs, voluntarily or
involuntarily, at some point, which can affect their management of family finances.
Some of the reasons for involuntarily changing jobs include:
Being laid off due to downsizing programs;
Being fired;
Being part of a restructuring due to changes in required job skills.
If a client is unemployed involuntarily, suggest that he or she apply for unemployment
compensation even if he or she is not sure they qualify. Some clients may qualify for
unemployment compensation because they were fired due to discrimination or for another
reason. Also, a client may want to check with a legal services office or with a union office if he
or she was fired without appropriate cause.
A client who has been unemployed for some time may have to rethink employment goals and
start over in a new job or a new industry, sometimes at a level that is below the previous level.
The prospect of starting over can be troubling to many people.
As a counselor, it is important to acknowledge the difficulties the client faces. Urge the client to
remain positive and focused on goals, even if the new job is not the ideal job. Over time, he or
she will gain the confidence and skills needed to succeed in the new job and perhaps become
eligible for other, better-paying jobs that require these new skills, this moving closer to achieving
his or her long-term work goals.
One way a client can ease financial pressure due to unemployment or underemployment is to
consider whether another family member might take on additional employment. One of the
parents or another member of the household may want to start to work or find an additional parttime job. Before taking this step, the client should decide how much more money is needed to
meet expenses and the additional number of work hours per week needed to earn that amount.
Urge the client to consider additional costs such as child-care that come about as a result of
employment, and find ways to minimize them. Also, a client should examine transportation
alternatives and the schedules of family members, and think about how to redistribute household
chores so housework is more evenly spread among family members.
In preparing to look for a new job, your client should start by conducting a self-analysis of skills
and goals, thinking through what he or she wants from his or her working life. The client needs
to identify jobs and employers, investigating jobs and job openings in a systematic way.
40
He or she should seek help from state and private employment agencies, temporary employment
agencies, technical colleges and other community resources to prepare for new employment.
Many resources will provide testing and practice interviews to provide additional assistance to
the client.
A client may need to rethink goals and priorities. What would he or she like to be doing in a
year, in three years, and in five years? How might the family situation change, and what impact
could the changes have on employment goals? What are his or her short-term and long-term
goals and priorities? What impact would these goals and priorities have on the client's current job
search and future employment plans?
Next, a client should begin to systematically explore job possibilities and prospective employers.
Remind the client that, during this period, finding a job is the job. He or she needs to take some
steps every day toward finding out which industries, jobs, and employers make sense for his or
her particular skills and goals.
A client should recognize that only a small percentage of job openings are advertised in
newspapers or listed with employment services. Nearly three-quarters of all jobs are filled
through personal contacts. Therefore, the client should fan out and talk to everyone he or she
knows--relatives, friends, schoolmates, customers and suppliers, doctors and dentists, religious
leaders, club members--about the job search. One of these people may hear of an appropriate job
or know someone at a local company that has just started hiring. By making personal contacts
and following up on leads, your client increases the odds of identifying suitable jobs and getting
invited to interviews.
Non-Traditional Households
Along with life events, family structure is another important aspect of each clients financial
picture. Key life events and family structure affect the way people live, work, spend money, and
plan for the future. Many clients seeking counseling are living in non-traditional households.
Some examples of non-traditional households include:
Single parent families;
Blended families;
Widow and widower households;
Couples living together; and/or
Gay and lesbian couples.
The problems that face non-traditional households may affect the way you approach the
counseling process.
Single Parent Families
Counseling single parent families provides its own set of challenges. Areas of concern may
include:
Work and child care expenses;
Transportation;
Dealing with the emotional issues;
Time demands to balance family and job;
41
42
people who are separated, divorced, or remarried, especially when children are involved.
Resolving the financial issues stemming from these major life events can be complex.
Divorce can have a definite effect on the financial well being of husbands, wives, and children.
As a counselor, you are in a unique position to help clients think about the decisions they make
in handling family resources during the transition from marriage to divorce and after a divorce is
final.
By injecting sound resource management principles into the process, you can help clients avoid
poor decisions and actions that can threaten future economic security. Helping clients learn about
goal setting, considering alternatives and consequences, analyzing costs and benefits, budgeting,
and controlling family finances will benefit them during and after the divorce. It is also important
that clients consider the legal and tax aspects of divorce.
Complicating the transition from marriage to divorce are issues related to the clients emotional
state attitudes toward money, self-concept and job situation. Your emotional support and
objectivity can be helpful to clients who must consider their alternatives and the consequences.
43
Once the decision to divorce has been made, you will want to help your client plan rather than
panic. During a divorce, people may make irrational decisions due to an impulse to express hurt
or frustration with the other spouse or because of an urgent desire to accomplish the move
quickly, without considering the impact on the future. Since some people in this time of crisis
lose confidence, ability to function, and self-control, your involvement can help your client make
better decisions and regain a positive self-image.
A client may need your help identifying decisions to be made, ranking them in priority or
chronological order, finding information needed for each decision, and investigating available
resources. Although many people in the divorce process tend to be focused on what has
happened in the past and present, you need to help the client think through decisions that will
affect the future.
The decision to divorce dissolves the economic partnership. In preparation for this, you can work
with your client on the following issues: Income, Credit, Child Support and Alimony, Assets,
Insurance, and Housing.
Income: Income considerations begin with a definition of what is income (current and
projected), and who has contributed to income.
Credit: Divorcing couples need to be informed as to proper handling of credit obligations.
Debts: A divorce decree does not eliminate debt obligations that were established during a
marriage.
Child Support and Alimony: The arrangement of child support and alimony payments should be
discussed with an attorney, since many spouses fail to receive these payments as planned. An
annuity trust is an alternative to alimony. If possible, the child support or alimony agreement
should call for a check, recording, and enforcing system. In many cases, child support (and
alimony) may be paid through the court, and wages can be garnisheed. If payments are in
arrears, arrangements can be made to deduct these from assets liquidated at a later time, such as
after the sale of the home.
A number of other remedies may be available as more states strengthen their laws in this regard.
Remind your client that the division of responsibility for debts is only enforceable by the divorce
decree and between the couple. If payments are not made when due, creditors will try to collect
from the person or people who signed the contract. In many states, marital law may effect the
collection activity and divorce agreements. You should check state laws to see if they are
applicable.
Assets: Assets and property are considered in combination with income for equitable divorce
settlements. If a premarital agreement is in place, this can guide the division of assets and
property. If not, general guidelines are that assets and property acquired prior to marriage or after
decree of separation need not be shared with the spouse. Equity and reasonableness should be
used in dividing assets and property acquired during marriage through joint effort. Usually the
44
couple can do a better job of dividing household items than the court.
Insurance: Spouses should arrange for "stop-gap" insurance, insurance on the ex-spouse, and
continuation of health insurance benefits. One ex-spouse can own the life insurance policy on the
other to protect child support payments and other projected expenses.
Housing: The couple should have the family house appraised for its actual fair market value, and
should compare the currently monthly mortgage payment and interest rate to the interest rate and
monthly payment to be made on an alternative home or rental. They should also examine current
real estate market conditions and what might happen to the value of the house if it is sold at a
later date. This is important because some custodial parents remain in the family home while the
children are minors. In addition, urge divorcing clients to think about the tax benefits inherent in
their mortgage payment when arranging their finances prior to divorce. Generally, some portion
of the monthly mortgage payment is returned as a tax benefit.
45
If a client is not receiving support or alimony payments as scheduled, you may want to help him
or her investigate the possibility of having support payments made through the support registry
of the courts. This insures that payments are made regularly and provides legal documentation
when they are not. Your agency may have additional information about methods that other
clients have successfully used to collect support.
In adjusting to divorce, your client may have to find new resources, be flexible and modify goals
or develop new goals to deal with the reality of the situation. He or she can seek support from
your agency as well as from other community or social resources, informal support groups,
friendships, and relatives. This is a time when a client can set a new life course and regain
financial control. Managing resources can move your client toward economic security in the
future.
In general, federal law requires that states establish and maintain a child-support program to
assist residents. Most states have adopted a set of rules to assist the courts in determining child
support payments, including medical support obligations. In addition, many states have
procedures for withholding income to collect court-ordered child support. Check your state's
laws for details.
Federal law also provides for collection of past due child support payments by intercepting
federal income tax refunds. Since only Attorney General Child Support Enforcement cases are
eligible, custodial parents must apply for an IRS intercept through the nearest Attorney General's
office. There may be a fee involved and the process can be time-consuming, but this may be a
workable option for a client who hasnt been receiving child support payments as agreed.
Consult your local Attorney General's office for more information.
Gambling Addictions
Many clients or family members of clients are affected by gambling additions. Recognizing the
signs of a gambling problem and referring a client to appropriate resources are important
counselor skills when helping a client address problem gambling.
The following information comes from Gamblers Anonymous (www.gam-anon.org).
Gamblers Anonymous offers the following questions to anyone who may have a gambling
problem. These questions are provided to help the individual decide if he or she is a compulsive
gambler and wants to stop gambling.
Twenty Questions
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Did you ever lose time from work or school due to gambling?
Has gambling ever made your home life unhappy?
Did gambling affect your reputation?
Have you ever felt remorse after gambling?
Did you ever gamble to get money with which to pay debts or otherwise solve financial
difficulties?
6. Did gambling cause a decrease in your ambition or efficiency?
46
7. After losing did you feel you must return as soon as possible and win back your losses?
8. After a win did you have a strong urge to return and win more?
9. Did you often gamble until your last dollar was gone?
10. Did you ever borrow to finance your gambling?
11. Have you ever sold anything to finance gambling?
12. Were you reluctant to use "gambling money" for normal expenditures?
13. Did gambling make you careless of the welfare of yourself or your family?
14. Did you ever gamble longer than you had planned?
15. Have you ever gambled to escape worry or trouble?
16. Have you ever committed, or considered committing, an illegal act to finance gambling?
17. Did gambling cause you to have difficulty in sleeping?
18. Do arguments, disappointments or frustrations create within you an urge to gamble?
19. Did you ever have an urge to celebrate any good fortune by a few hours of gambling?
20. Have you ever considered self destruction or suicide as a result of your gambling?
Most compulsive gamblers will answer yes to at least seven of these questions.
Because gambling is a recognized addiction, referral of the client for outside assistance is usually
a proper course of action, though some organizations may employ on-site help for clients with
gambling issues. Some clients have been successful in using the Debt Management Program to
repay debts in conjunction with individual and group therapy for gambling.
47
CHAPTER 7
COUNSELING EFFECTIVENESS
Analyzing Counseling Effectiveness
Just as clients need to analyze the results of their decisions and actions and prepare to make
changes where needed to get back on track or to improve. Counselors also need to analyze the
results of their work with clients. There are two broad areas to consider, process and outcome,
when conducting this analysis.
The Process Perspective
From a process perspective, this analysis helps you focus on the steps you took in the course of
helping clients make plans to solve problems and achieve goals. In this analysis, you look at the
effectiveness of what you and your organization did to help clients overcome their difficulties.
The Outcome Perspective
From an outcome perspective, you can look at whether the planned change has occurred in the
client's life. The outcomes of a completely effective counseling encounter would show that
actions chosen by the client and reinforced by the counselor achieved the goals set, that needs
had been satisfied and problems solved.
48
49
APPENDIX
Community Resources, Agencies, and Organizations
for Referring Clients
Children and Youth
Alanon and Alateen
Big Brothers and Sisters
Boys Clubs
Child welfare services
Childrens' homes
Community centers
Day care centers
Service clubs
Family Service Agency
Girl Scouts, Boy Scouts
Head Start
Public school social workers
United Way
YWCA, YMCA
Clothing
American Red Cross
Clothing certificates (local stores)
Community centers
Discount stores
Garage sales
Goodwill Industries
Local churches
Salvation Army
Thrift clothes shops and used clothes stores
Consumer Problems and Complaints
Better Business Bureaus
Chamber of Commerce
Consumer Service Division (state or local government)
Federal Trade Commission
Legal Aid Service
Newspapers
Small claims courts
State attorney general's office
Trade associations
50
51
52
53
Taxes
Certified public accountants
Internal Revenue Service (Federal or state)
Volunteer and professional tax consultants
Transportation
Advocates for the Poor
Ambulance service (local or hospital)
American Red Cross
Salvation Army
Township trustees (may need an advocate)
Volunteers-in-transportation
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
that the amount available for the repayment of the clients indebtedness represents the
clients best effort after a thorough evaluation of income, expenses, assets and debts;
that proposed debt management plans will reflect that the consumers indebtedness can
be repaid in 60 months or less, including interest. A plan may be established for longer
than 60 months, with documented extenuating circumstances. Debts with contractual
repayment periods of over 60 months, such as automobiles, mortgages, and other secured
debt, may be included in the plan, but can be excluded from the monthly payout
calculation;
that in any proposed plan, negative amortization shall be avoided and that all known
debts are accounted for in the written action plan;
that neither the agency nor the client exclude selected creditors from the program unless
the counselor and client determine that inclusion of the creditor on the plan will be
detrimental to the client, for example the creditor automatically increases the interest rate
to the maximum allowed by law. All creditor exclusions must be approved by member
agency management;
that a method of prorating accounts shall be employed that treats like creditors alike,
assuring that no creditor receives preferential treatment in return for financial support;
that the DMP reflects that the client will close all lines of credit and refrain from
obtaining future credit without the member agencys approval;
that client confidentiality and the creditors rights to information are recognized. All
counseling provided by member agencies is strictly confidential. Client confidentiality as
it relates to debt management plans refers to family, friends, employers, etc. A creditor
participating in a debt management plan has the right to pertinent information (full
61
disclosure) such as: addresses, phone numbers (unless the phone number is unlisted),
assets, income, expenses, other creditors involved in plan, balances owed, reason for
plan, etc. Nonparticipating creditor should not be given any information without the
clients approval. When a clients debt management plan has been closed, information
may also be verified and/or released to only those original creditors listed on the original
plan. Any creditor found to be using the information provided to harass an existing
depositing client should be reported to the agencys management/creditor relations
division and may be denied information in the future. The NFCCs Monitoring and
Compliance Committee should be notified of any such actions taken with creditors;
that the agency provides, at a minimum, a quarterly status report to active DMP clients
that fully discloses their deposit and disbursement history and approximate balances;
that the agency establishes and adheres to a process of reviewing existing debt
management plans annually, preferably including the client; and
that the agency does not create any plans for the benefit of an individual client which
jeopardizes the plans of existing or future clients.
Member agencies will avoid conflicts of interest by not paying agents, counselors, or employees
commissions or referral fees for DMP accounts.
Member agencies will avoid conflicts of interest by not paying creditors for client referrals or
agreeing to receive reduced fair share to receive referrals.
62
63
OFFICIAL COMMENT:
Optional language is underlined above.
Agencies must submit their dual role disclosure form to the NFCC annually or when the
disclosure form is changed.
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
Nothing in this standard or official comment prohibits a person who serves as an officer,
director, employee, partner, proprietor, or owns or controls 10% or more of a credit granting
organization from serving as a governing board member of a NFCC member agency, provided,
however, that no more than 40% of an NFCC member agency governing board may be
comprised of such persons.
Related parties include family members and businesses in which a person owns or controls 10%
or more of the entity. Family members include, but are not limited to, parents, spouses, siblings,
children, stepchildren and relatives-in-law.
71
72
73
OFFICIAL COMMENT
Member agencies are prohibited from providing false or misleading information about an
organization or individual to the public; this prohibition precludes using NFCCs communication
tools and systems to provide information to NFCC members that cannot be substantiated.
Member agencies must maintain the confidentiality of information entrusted to them or known to
them as a result of their professional activities.
Member agencies must manage all financial activities honestly following policies and procedures
established to ensure financial honesty and prevent individual gain at the expense of a member
organization or the NFCC.
Member agencies must assume responsibility for remediating errors caused by any of their
employees.
74
75
OFFICIAL COMMENT:
Member agencies must notify the NFCC of any notice of investigation or actual investigation by
a federal or state regulatory entity within five business days of receipt.
76
OFFICIAL COMMENT:
Member agencies must provide consumers a grievance procedure at the time of initial
application, and to clients upon request or at the initiation of a grievance.
Member agencies must include an appeal process and ensure the timely resolution of issues. At
the conclusion of the process, written documentation of final resolution must be included in
client files.
Member agencies must provide all clients access to their individual files as long as the clients
review is done on site and in the presence of agency personnel. Clients have the right to include
statements in their files regarding the services they have or wish to receive.
Member agencies must provide NFCC with their grievance policy and procedures if requested.
77
78
79
OFFICIAL COMMENT:
NFCC defines nepotism as favoritism based on a personal relationship.
Member agencies must report annually all situations of direct and indirect family member
supervision that exist at the Officer or Key Individual level as defined by the Internal
Revenue Service for Form 990 purposes. Such member agencies must annually submit all
policies related to the direct or indirect supervision of individuals.
Member agencies must have nepotism policies and procedures in place that:
80
81