Philosophyisforposh,whiteboyswithtrustfunds'whyaretheresofewwomen?|HigherEducationNetwork|TheGuardian
Philosophy stands out among the humanities: its one of the few subject areas where
women are vastly outnumbered by men.
Although male and female students take philosophy undergraduate courses in almost
equal numbers, the number of women who pursue a career in philosophy is much lower.
A recent report by the Equality Challenge Unit found that, among non-Stem (science,
technology, engineering and maths) subjects, philosophy is one of the most maledominated, with men accounting for 71.2% of the profession.
Why arent there more female philosophers? And how can university departments
become more inclusive?
1/6
15/04/2015
Philosophyisforposh,whiteboyswithtrustfunds'whyaretheresofewwomen?|HigherEducationNetwork|TheGuardian
Since the blog started, there have been several very public high-prole sexual
harassment scandals in philosophy. And theres now starting to be a backlash against the
feminists who have taken over the profession and who are now said to wield
enormous power to persecute.
The truth is were not running the profession: were still down at 17-29%. Were starting
to make some small bits of incremental progress in ghting a problem thats been going
on far too long. This is an enormous source of hope, for me. But its far from a complete
turnaround. And we have even further to go with other issues. As male as philosophy is,
for example, it is far, far whiter and philosophers are barely beginning to address this
problem.
2/6
15/04/2015
Philosophyisforposh,whiteboyswithtrustfunds'whyaretheresofewwomen?|HigherEducationNetwork|TheGuardian
Academic disciplines and practices are not immune from the tendency of societies to
gender everything. They are fully part of the social-cultural world, even if people often
consider them to be remote.
But there are also reasons internal to the discipline itself. In comparison with other
subjects philosophy tends, still, to be very inward-looking. It tends to dene itself rather
narrowly and has found it extraordinarily dicult to accept challenges to its traditional
ways of doing things.
Other disciplines in the humanities and the social sciences were generally quick to
respond to the ideas of the social movements of the past half-century, but for a long time
philosophy remained indierent to these. The kind of philosophy that dominates in the
UK has tended to see itself as engaged in a purely rational practice uninuenced by social
and political contexts. It hasnt therefore been able to see the ways in which it in fact
mirrors the interests of its relatively narrow band of practitioners and excludes others.
In the wake of the womens movement, for example, most Anglophone philosophers
clung on to the idea that thinking about gender belonged to sociology and had nothing to
do with them. The groups most aected by these social movements didnt perhaps they
still dont see their concerns taken seriously in philosophy. It is little wonder if they
choose to study in more hospitable areas.
3/6
15/04/2015
Philosophyisforposh,whiteboyswithtrustfunds'whyaretheresofewwomen?|HigherEducationNetwork|TheGuardian
These days, like most of my male colleagues of whatever age, I dont bother; nobody
mistakes me for an undergraduate. But they do and Im 46 routinely mistake me for a
PhD student or a postdoc, unless I very quickly say or do something that makes that
assumption untenable.
I sometimes think I should cultivate the look of the stereotypical woman professor. Im
not sure what that look is, but minimally I think you have to have grey hair and be over
50. So, if I stop dyeing my hair, I wont have long to wait.
4/6
15/04/2015
Philosophyisforposh,whiteboyswithtrustfunds'whyaretheresofewwomen?|HigherEducationNetwork|TheGuardian
5/6
15/04/2015
Philosophyisforposh,whiteboyswithtrustfunds'whyaretheresofewwomen?|HigherEducationNetwork|TheGuardian
Twitter @gdnhighered.
More features
Topics
Academics
Higher education
Philosophy
Women
http://www.theguardian.com/highereducationnetwork/2015/jan/05/philosophyisforposhwhiteboyswithtrustfundswhyaretheresofewwomen
6/6