M.Y. Farooqui
Gujarat State Petroleum Corporation (GSPC)
Gandhinagar, Gujarat, India
Huijun Hou
Dhahran, Saudi Arabia
Guoxin Li
PetroChina Exploration and Production
Company Limited
Beijing, China
Nigel Machin
Saudi Aramco
Dhahran, Saudi Arabia
Tom Neville
Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA
Aditi Pal
Jakarta, Indonesia
Chandramani Shrivastva
Mumbai, India
Yuhua Wang
Fengping Yang
Changhai Yin
Jie Zhao
PetroChina Daqing Oilfield Company
Daqing, China
Xingwang Yang
Tokyo, Japan
Oilfield Review Spring 2009: 21, no. 1.
Copyright 2009 Schlumberger.
DMR, ECS and FMI are marks of Schlumberger.
For help in preparation of this article, thanks to Martin
Isaacs, Sugar Land, Texas, USA; Shumao Jin, Brett Rimmer
and Michael Yang, Beijing; Charles E. Jones, University of
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Andreas Laake, Cairo; and
Hetu C. Sheth, Indian Institute of Technology, Mumbai.
36
energy, igneous layers are considered an impediment to evaluation of underlying sediments as well.
New seismic methods are advancing solutions
to this problem, but with their strong refractive qualities, igneous reservoirs remain difficult
to characterize.4
Once hydrocarbons are found in igneous
reservoirs, assessing hydrocarbon volumes and
productivity presents several challenges. Log
interpretation in igneous reservoirs often requires
adapting techniques designed for other environments. Logging tools and interpretation methods
that succeed in sedimentary rock can give meaningful answers in igneous rock, but they often
require artful application. Furthermore, because
mineralogy varies greatly in these formations,
methods that work in one volcanic province may
fail in another. Usually, a combination of methods
is required.
This article describes the complexity of volcanic reservoirs and presents technologies that
have proved successful in characterizing them.
The discussion begins with a review of igneous
rock types and follows with an examination of
the effects of igneous processes on petroleum
Oilfield Review
Oilfield Review
Winter 09
Volcanic Fig. Opener
ORWINT09-VOL Fig. Opener
Spring 2009
37
that combines conventional logging measurements and image logs with neutron-capture
spectroscopy and nuclear magnetic resonance.
Plume
Ash-cloud surge
Pyroclastic flow
Traps
Eruption
column
Volcaniclastic rocks
Laccolith
exposed
by erosion
Dikes
Volcano
Granite wash
Lava flow
Dike
Plutonic
rock
Laccolith
Sill
Country rock
Pluton
Basement
> Emplacement of igneous rocks. Plutonic rocks, formed by cooling of magma within the Earth, display
well-developed crystals with little porosity. Plutons and laccolithsbulging igneous injections into
sedimentary layersare examples of plutonic rock. Volcanic rocks, formed when magma extrudes
onto the surface and cools rapidly, show very fine crystalline or even glassy textures. Buildup
of pressures within the Earth can cause explosive eruptions; these result in the accumulation of
fragments of volcanic material in pyroclastic deposits. Rock containing clastic fragments of volcanic
origin is termed volcaniclastic. Complex porosities and permeabilities can develop as a result of these
different processes.
Structures
Textures
38
An example from India demonstrates the importance of incorporating borehole resistivity images
in the evaluation of oil-bearing volcanic rock.
About Igneous Rocks
Igneous rock is formed through the solidification
of magmaa mixture of water, dissolved gases
and molten to partially molten rock. Igneous
rocks vary from one reservoir to another because
their constituents have diverse chemistries,
originating from magma that mixes material
from the Earths mantle, crust and surface
typically oxides of silicon, iron, magnesium,
sodium, calcium and potassium. They also have
diverse structures and texturesleading to
complex porosities and permeabilitiesdepending on how they were emplaced. Emplacement
mechanisms include sudden explosive eruptions,
syrupy viscous flows and slow, deep subsurface
intrusions. Subsequent weathering and fracturing can further complicate rock properties.
Igneous rocks form under a wide range of conditions, and therefore display a variety of properties
(left). Molten rock that cools deep beneath the surface forms intrusive, or plutonic, rocks. Slow cooling
of deep magmas forms large crystals, resulting in
coarse-grained rock. These formations typically
have low intergranular porosity and insignificant
permeability, making them of little interest to the
oil industry. The one exception is fractured granites,
which can produce hydrocarbons.5 Magmas that
approach the surface tend to cool more rapidly.
This allows less time for the formation of crystals,
which therefore tend to be smaller, resulting in finegrained crystalline rock.
Extrusive, or volcanic, rocks are created
when magma erupts through the Earths surface. Magma may extrude in flows of molten
lava that, when cooled, form fine- to very finegrained crystalline volcanic rock. Sometimes,
cooling occurs so quickly that crystals cannot
form, resulting in volcanic glass, such as obsidian. When magmas contain large amounts of
water and dissolved gases, buildup of excessive
pressure under the ground can cause explosive
eruptions of volcanic material. Ejected fragments, or pyroclasts, can range in size from fine
volcanic ash to bombs tens of centimeters in
diameter. Once they have been ejected, individual fragments accumulate to form pyroclastic
rock. Lava flows and pyroclastic deposits may
be a few centimeters to a few hundred meters
thick, covering thousands of square kilometers.
These deposits can have sufficient porosity
and permeability to make them viable hydrocarbon reservoirs.
Oilfield Review
Spring 2009
Coarse Grained
Peridotite
Basalt
Andesite
Dacite
Rhyolite
Gabbro
Diorite
Granodiorite
Granite
100
Calcium-rich
plagioclase
feldspars
80
Quartz
Potassium
feldspar
60
Sodium-rich
plagioclase
feldspars
Olivine
40
Pyroxene
20
Biotite
Amphibole
0
45%
75%
700C [1,300F]
> Classifying igneous rocks by mineral composition. Fine-grained and coarse-grained rocks of similar
composition have different names. For example, a magma containing quartz, potassium feldspar,
sodium-rich plagioclase and biotite may cool slowly and form coarse-grained granite. If the same
magma is extruded, it will form fine-grained rhyolite. Olivine-rich magmas do not commonly extrude,
but crystallize at depth, and so form only coarse-grained rocks.
Clast or
Crystal
Size, mm
Sedimentary
Clasts
Boulders
256
Cobbles
16
Pyroclastic
Fragments
Crystalline Rocks:
Igneous, Metamorphic
or Sedimentary
Blocks
and bombs
Very coarse
grained
Very coarse
crystalline
Gravel
64
Pebbles
Lapilli
Coarse grained
2
1
0.5
0.25
0.125
Coarse crystalline
Granules
Very coarse sand
Medium grained
Coarse sand
Medium sand
Fine sand
Very fine sand
Oilfield Review
Coarse ash
Winter 09grains
Volcanic Fig. 2
ORWINT09-VOL Fig. 2
Sand
Medium crystalline
Fine grained
Fine crystalline
0.032
Silt
0.004
Clay
Fine Grained
Fine ash
grains
> Classifying pyroclastic rocks by grain size. Pyroclastic rocks are identified
based on grain size, in a similar fashion to clastic sedimentary rocks.
39
ARGENTINA
Chaitn
CHILE
Plume
Ash cover
ATLANTIC OCEAN
km 100
miles
100
> Image of the Chaitn volcano, southern Chile, from the NASA Terra satellite. The volcano, thought
to be dormant before its May 2, 2008, eruption, sent a plume of ash and steam 10.7 to 16.8 km [35,000
to 55,000 ft] into the atmosphere. This image, acquired three days after the eruption, shows the plume
extending eastward more than 1,000 km across Argentina and into the Atlantic Ocean. The volcanic
plume (white) is distinguishable from the clouds (turquoise). The land surface is dusted with tan-gray
ash. [From Chiles Chaiten Volcano Erupts, http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/IOTD/view.php?id=8725
(accessed April 6, 2009)].
Volumes of Volcanics
Petrologists have calculated that the shallow part
of the Earths crust contains a volume of volcanic rockformed by the ejection of lava at the
surfaceof 3.4 to 9 x 109 km3, an order of magnitude greater than the volume of sedimentary rock.
This estimate includes extrusions at seafloor rift
zones, where oceanic plates are pulling apart and
new crust is created by volcanic activity.
The presence of volcanic rocks in hydrocarbon provinces is common because volcanic
activity has taken place in or near many sedimentary basins at one time or another. Volcanism
can also affect distant basinslarge volcanoes
can push pyroclastic flows up to 1,000 km [about
600mi] from their origin and wind can carry ash
thousands of kilometers (left). Consequently,
blankets of ash and tuffs, or consolidated ash,
may be found far from their source.
Hydrocarbon-producing igneous rocks occur
the world over (below). The earliest documented oil discovery in volcanic rock may be
the Hara oil field of Japan, which began producing in 1900.8 The field produced oil from
three tuffaceous layers. Other early production was recorded in Texas, in 1915, along a
trend of seafloor volcanoes that erupted during deposition of the Austin Chalk.9 The buried
volcanic formations produced 54 million bbl
[8.6 million m3] of oil from 90 fields in more than
200 igneous bodies.
Oilfield Review
Winter 09
Volcanic Fig. 5
ORWINT09-VOL Fig. 5
> Distribution of hydrocarbon-bearing igneous rocks. Gold dots represent locations of hydrocarbon seeps, shows and reservoirs in igneous rocks. (Adapted
from Schutter, reference 36).
40
Oilfield Review
Punched Laccolith
Petroleum Systems
Volcanism can affect all aspects of a petroleum
system, producing distinctive source rocks,
accelerating fluid maturation, facilitating fluid
migration, and creating traps, reservoirs and seals.
Source RockAlthough most hydrocarbons
found in volcanic rocks come from sedimen
tary source rock, some volcanic rocks are also
source rocks. Vegetation entrained in ash flows
may contain enough water to protect it from
the heat of emplacement. Subaerial volcanism
may create lakes and swamps with kerogen-rich
sediments, and the volcanically warmed water in
these basins encourages nutrient growth, further
enhancing the production of organic material.
MaturationBy adding heat, igneous bod
ies can accelerate hydrocarbon maturation.
Large intrusive bodies, such as thick dikes and
sills, cool slowly and may affect great volumes
of surrounding rock, causing overmaturation.12
Volcanic flows cool relatively quickly, so they usu
ally have less impact on maturation. The impact
of igneous activity on fluid maturation can be
assessed by petroleum systems modeling.13
In addition to direct heat, the circulation
of hydrothermal fluids in the heated zone also
may affect maturation. For example, scientists
working in the Guaymas basin of the Gulf of
California have reported that hydrothermal
fluids heated to 400C [752F] are responsible
Spring 2009
> Traps caused by laccolith intrusion. The trap of the Omaha Dome field in
Illinois was caused by a Christmas tree laccolith (left ) of mica-peridotite
intruding into limestones and sandstones. Traps (green) can also be caused
by punched laccoliths (right), which lift overlying layers along bounding faults.
41
Fresh basalt
Weathered basalt
Nonbasalt rocks
Fresh basalt
Payun
Payun
Weathered basalt
Basalt with sparse vegetation
Nonvolcanic sediments
0
0
km 20
mi
20
Vegetation
> Remote sensing in volcanic provinces. Satellite data from visible, near-infrared, infrared and thermal
bands help geophysicists assess topography and ground surface character before planning seismic
survey acquisition. In this example from Argentina, satellite data (bottom) from several spectral bands
are combined and color-coded to distinguish different surface characteristics. Recently erupted
basalt flows are highlighted as dark red in both satellite images. Acquisition crews use the information
to determine whether the terrain is accessible to vibrator trucks and other equipment (top). The
photograph of the survey vehicles shows the Payun volcano seen from the south.
bubbles, in igneous rock. Porosities in vesicular surface mapping of elevated structures has
basalts and andesites may reach 50%.17 Secondary revealed volcanic deposits. For example, in
porosity is important for many volcanic reservoirs Japan, rhyolitic volcanic rocks containing large
and is sometimes the only porosity present. It may hydrocarbon accumulations have been discovresult from hydrothermal alteration, fracturing ered by mapping structural highs.18 Another traand late-stage metamorphismmetamorphism ditional method, the recognition of hydrocarbon
Oilfield
Review
during the late stages of igneous activity
that
seeps at the surface, is used to find deeper reserWinter 09
alters the minerals formed earlier. Sills and lac- voirs. Oil and gas sometimes rise to the surface
Volcanic Fig. 8
coliths may become reservoirs, especially
when alongFig.
contacts
between igneous and sedimentary
ORWINT09-VOL
8
they intrude into source rocks. They may fracture rocks. Seeps in the Golden Lane area of eastern
upon cooling, providing porosity, permeability Mexico have been associated with steeply dipand migration pathways.
ping igneous rocks that have penetrated thick
SealsIgneous rocks can provide seals. After oil-rich carbonate layers.19
alteration to clay, extrusive layers may act as
Advanced techniques are also used. Satellite
tight seals. Impermeable intruded rocks, such as imagery has been applied to evaluate the basaltlaccoliths that form traps, also may seal hydro- covered Columbia basin in Washington and
carbons in formations beneath them.
Oregon, USA.20 Geochemical analysis of groundwater in the same region has detected significant
Exploration in Volcanic Provinces
levels of methane over a large area, indicating
Hydrocarbon exploration in and around igneous potentially commercial quantities of natural gas
rocks may involve a variety of geological, geo in Columbia River basalts.21
physical and geochemical techniques. Traditional
42
Oilfield Review
Spring 2009
XS8
X,200
XS401
XS4
XS602
XS6
XS601
X,400
X,600
X,800
Y,000
Y,200
Y,400
km
Conglomerate
Shale
Upper volcanic
Sedimentary
Lower volcanic
Basalt
2
mi
Y,600
Y,800
R U S S I A
Daqing
MONGOLIA
N. KOREA
Beijing
C
0
km 400
mi
S. KOREA
X,000
Depth, m
400
> Structure of the Yingcheng volcanic group beneath the Daqing field. Interpretation of seismic data
determined the top of the volcanic group, and integration of seismic and log data allowed delineation
of the upper volcanic, lower volcanic and predominantly basaltic sequences.
43
650
700
750
800
850
900
Pyroclastic flow
Lava flow
Pyroclastic fall
Extrusive
FMI Image
50
Porosity
%
Facies
Lava
flow
Tuff
Pyroclastic
flow
Water laid
Pyroclastic flow
Pyroclastic fall
Surge flow
Intrusive
Pyroclastic
fall
> Correlation of igneous rock types with seismic data. Rock types were identified using FMI images,
NMR T2 distributions and ECS elemental concentrations. Rock types were classified into seven
crystalline lithologies (greens, pinks and purples) and four pyroclastic lithologies (orange and yellows).
A sample correlation (bottom) shows an FMI image acquired through an interval of predominantly
pyroclastic layers. A seismic section (top) through the central well is used to extend rock types across
the field. The rock types observed in the central well are displayed at the well location using the color
codes for volcaniclastic and crystalline lithologies. Rock types extrapolated away from the central well
are displayed as semitransparent colors on the seismic section.
44
Oilfield Review
Spring 2009
PA
S
KI
TA
C H I N A
NEP
AL
Cambay basin
BANGLADESH
Deccan Traps
I
Mahabaleshwar
0
0
km
500
miles
500
SRI LANKA
> The Deccan Traps of India. The Deccan Traps are a sequence of approximately 40 basalt layers
covering portions of central western India. Differences between the basalts, which are competent,
and interlayered sands, shales and limestones, which are more easily eroded, give rise to the rough
terrain (right ). This photograph was taken at the Mahabaleshwar escarpment in the Western Ghats.
The Cambay basin (left) is a downdropped graben with oil-bearing sediments overlying the basalts.
Basalt outcrops are shown in orange. (Photograph courtesy of Dr. Hetu C. Sheth, Department of Earth
Sciences, Indian Institute of Technology, Mumbai.)
the top of the volcanic deposits was considered by Well PK-2 was laterally extensive. Based on
economic basement, below which commercial this model, Well PK-6 was drilled in 2005 just
hydrocarbon reservoirs were not expected to be 600 m [1,970 ft] to the southwest of PK-2, but
Oilfield
Review
found. However, in the past few years,
oil has
unfortunately it did not flow any hydrocarbon.
Winter
been discovered in these deeper volcanic
rocks.09 This unexpected result encouraged GSPC to
Volcanic Fig. 11
In 2003, Gujarat State Petroleum Corporation
update
ORWINT09-VOL
Fig. the
11 reservoir model through further data
(GSPC) initiated a six-well campaign in analysis, specifically considering the rock facies
Block CB-ONN-2000/1. The first three wells and fractures and their interplay with faults
exhibited oil shows in the volcanic layers. In within the volcanic layers.34
2004, the fourth well, PK-2, proved to be a signifiAs a first step, geologists developed a textural
cant oil discovery, testing at 64m3/d [400bbl/d]. classification of the volcanic layers. Three main
For planning the next well, a simplistic reservoir faciesvesicular basalt, nonvesicular basalt
model was constructed that assumed the hydro- and volcaniclastic unitswere identified using
carbon-bearing topmost basalt layer penetrated borehole image logs, petrography from Well PK-1
45
Vesicular Basalt
Nonvesicular Basalt
Well PK-2
Volcaniclastic Rock
Well PK-6
Top
Basalt A
1,775
1,775
Top
Basalt B
1,800
1,800
1,825
1,825
3 cm
Top
Basalt C
1,850
1,850
1,875
1,900
1,900
Depth, m
1,875
> Textural classification of Deccan basalt facies. Images from the FMI borehole
resistivity imaging tool helped geologists identify three main rock types.
Vesicular basalts (left) exhibited vesicles in image (top), in hand specimen
sample (bottom) and also in sidewall cores from a neighboring well.
Nonvesicular basalts (center ) showed no such gas bubbles in borehole
images or in sidewall cores. Images of volcaniclastic basalts (right) showed
fine-scale layering of angular particles. (Basalt photograph courtesy of
Charles E. Jones, University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.)
and hand specimens of basalt (above). Next, the aluminum, iron and titanium for Basalts A, B and
facies were correlated from well to wellan C showed that Basalt A, the top unit, is composiexercise that was far from straightforward. Lava tionally different in the key wells, while BasaltsB
flows can commingle, and after solidification and C are compositionally similar (next page).
other changes can occur, such as hydrother- This suggests that the top basalt layer is disconmal alteration, weathering, cementation and tinuous laterally between the two wells, contrary
structural deformation. These changes can be to the assumption in the original model.
Following the facies analysis, the next phase
identified in outcrop, but tracking them in the
subsurface is not easy. Based on image facies and of the study involved characterizing natural fracOilfield Review
log signatures, three main basalt layers, A, B and tures, which are abundant within the volcanic
Winter 09
C, could be correlated between key wells
PK-2 Fig.layers.
Volcanic
12 In the discovery Well PK-2, the top basalt
that
flowed
and PK-6 (above right).
ORWINT09-VOL Fig.
12 hydrocarbon is thick, comprising a
In outcrop studies, volcanic rocks can be cor- nonvesicular basalt layer overlying a vesicular
related using geochemical analysis of major and basalt section with a number of fractures that
minor elemental composition. In the subsurface, appear conductive on borehole images.35 The
similar data can be acquired using the ECS tool. presence of open fractures and vesicles creates
Crossplots of elemental silicon versus calcium, a good-quality reservoir with a dual-porosity
system, and the fracture network enhances per35. In the absence of acoustic or testing data, conductive frac
meability. In contrast, in Well PK-6, the top basalt
tures on borehole images are considered open to flow.
36. Schutter SR: Occurrences of Hydrocarbons in and
layer, which is thinner, essentially nonvesicular
Around Igneous Rocks, in Petford N and McCaffrey KJW
and less fractured, is not a good reservoir.
(eds): Hydrocarbons in Crystalline Rocks, Geological
Society Special Publication 214. London: Geological
In addition to facies type and the presence of
Society (2003): 3568.
fractures, the geometrical relationship between
46
1,925
Volcaniclastics
Nonvesicular
basalt
Vesicular
basalt
Brecciated zone in
nonweathered basalt
> Initial well-to-well facies correlation. Texturebased facies classification allowed correlation
of three basalt layers between Well PK-2 and
Well PK-6. BasaltA (blue) is the producing zone
in Well PK-2, but not in PK-6. Basalts B and C are
nonproductive.
Oilfield Review
Depth, m
Well PK-2
Gamma Ray
Lithology
Image
Logs
1,760
1,770
Ca/Si
Fe/Si
0.20
0.15
Basalt A
1,780
0.15
0.10
1,790
0.10
1,800
1,810
0.05
Basalt B
0.05
1,820
0
0.10
1,830
0
0.15
1,840
1,850
0.25
0.30
0.35
Al/Si
0.14
Basalt C
0.20
0.05
0.15
0.35
Ti/Si
0.06
0.12
0.25
0.05
0.10
0.04
0.08
0.03
0.06
Depth, m
Well PK-6
Lithology
Gamma Ray
0.02
0.04
0.01
0.02
1,760
1,770
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.10
0.20
0.30
Basalt A
1,780
1,790
Ca/Si
0.15
Fe/Si
0.20
1,800
0.15
1,810
1,820
0.10
Basalt B
1,830
0.10
0.05
0.05
1,840
1,850
0
0.10
0
0.15
0.20
0.25
0.30
0.35
0.10
0.20
0.30
1,860
1,870
Al/Si
0.14
1,880
1,890
1,900
Ti/Si
0.06
0.12
0.10
Basalt C
1,910
0.06
1,920
0.04
1,930
0.04
0.08
0.02
0.02
0
1,940
0
0
0.10
0.20
0.30
0.10
0.20
0.30
> Comparison of basalts in two wells. Elemental concentrations (right) from the ECS tool are expressed as ratios of
calcium, iron, aluminum and titanium to silicon (Ca/Si, Fe/Si, Al/Si and Ti/Si). Ratios are plotted for Basalts A (blue
oval), B (green oval) and C (red oval). In each of the ratio plots, the red and green ovals have approximately the
same relationship to each other, but not to the blue ovals. For example, in the Ca/Si plot for Well PK-2 (top), the red
and green ovals are next to each other, and the blue oval is inside the red oval. However, in the Ca/Si plot for Well
PK-6, the red and green ovals are still next to each other, but the blue oval is inside the green oval. This arrangement
indicates that Basalts B and C correlate from one well to the other, but Basalt A does not.
Spring 2009
Unlike their sedimentary counterparts, volcanic rock reservoirs have not been studied
systematically. In addition to the few examples
Oilfield Review
described inWinter
this article,
09 hydrocarbons occur in
or around igneous
rocks
Volcanic Fig.in14more than 100 counORWINT09-VOL
Fig. 14
tries.36 In many
instances, only
oil shows and
seeps have been documented, but further exploration may uncover significant reserves.
47