M. J. PELLETIER
JET PROPULSION LABORATORY
4800 OAK GROVE DRIVE
PASADENA , CALIFORNIA 91109-8099
Quantitative Analysis
Using Raman
Spectrometry
INT RODUCTIO N
applications is given in the Appendix, organized by application and analytical method. This list is by no
means exhaustive of the published
quantitative Raman applications.
The result of a quantitative analysis is a value specifying the amount
of something in a sample, an estimate of the uncertainty in that value,
and if possible, independent information that tests the validity of those
results. The trend toward automating
analytical techniques in order to address very large data sets and to reduce the impact of operator bias on
the analytical results places greater
importance on robustness and validity testing. Raman experts are not always available to interpret spectra
and make sure the analytical results
are reasonable. Even when experts
are available, how do they know
their expectations for what is reasonable are correct? W hy do the analysis if the operator has greater con dence in his expectation than in the
analytical results? The real value of
the analytical method depends on its
credibility when providing surprising
results. Raman is well suited for
quantitative analysis because a single
R am an sp ectru m o ften contains
enough information to address all
2 4p 3
hI N (n 0 2 n) 4
L
2
4
45 3 c mn(1 2 e 2 h n /k T )
2 1 7(g9) 2 ]
3 [45(a9)
a
a
(1)
where
c
h
IL
N
5
5
5
5
Speed of light
Plancks constant
Excitation intensity
Number of scattering m olecules
21A
focal point
to the inner- lter effect in uorescence spectroscopy.
3. NOISE IN RAM AN
SPECTRA
A Raman spectrum can be divided
into two parts: the signal and the
noise. The signal is the part of the
Raman spectrum that contains the
desired inform ation. The noise is the
part of the Raman spectrum that contains unwanted information. Since
the subject of this article is the determination of analyte concentration
from a Raman spectrum, a Raman
band that can be used for this purpose is an example of a signal. Random intensity uctuations could not
be used to determine analyte concentration and would, therefore, be an
example of noise. A value for analyte concentration has very limited
utility, however, without estimates of
the uncertainty and robustness of
that value. Often, random intensity
uctu atio ns rep re sen t the m ajo r
source of uncertainty in the analysis
of the Raman signal. Then, for the
calculation of concentration uncertainty, the random intensity uctuations become the signal and the analyte Raman band becomes the noise!
In keeping with the subject of this
Focal Point, intensity in a Raman
spectrum that is not used to determine analyte concentration is considered noise. That noise, however, will usually provide valuable
inform ation about the uncertainty
and robustness of the analysis. The
lack of various types of noise can
also be used to improve con dence
in analytical results.
The analysis of the Raman signal
requires its isolation from the noise.
This process is never complete, so it
is generally desirable to maximize
th e R am an sig nal and m in im ize
noise in the Raman spectrum. An
important metric describing the quality of a Raman spectrum is the signal-to-noise ratio, or S/N ratio. The
uncertainty in a reported S/N ratio is
usually dominated by the uncertainty
in the noise measurem ent because
noise is generally m ore dif cult to
quantify than the signal. An understanding of the types of noise typi22A
23A
focal point
tally or found in published collections of Raman spectra. 46 W hen a
spectrum cannot be found, spectra of
similar m aterials can guide the selection of an analytically useful spectral
region. Spectral information can also
be estimated from the functional
groups they contain and published
spectral locations for various functional g ro up s. 6 S pectral regio ns
known to contain excessive noise,
perhaps due to other sample components, can be eliminated from analyte concentration calculations.
Another way to identify spectral
regions that are useful for quantitative analysis is to analyze differences
between the Raman spectra of samples having different analyte concentrations. Spectral regions that are
predictive of analyte concentration
must change with analyte concentration. The variance of Raman intensity from a set of samples containing
differing amounts of analyte can
therefore be used to target spectral
regions that are likely to be predictive of analyte concentration. A plot
of this variance as a function of Raman shift is called a variance spectrum. Spectral regions in the variance spectrum having large values
are m ore likely to be predictive of
analyte concentration than those regions having small values.
A ny R am an inten sity ch an ges
among the set of samples, whether
related to analyte concentration or
not, will increase the corresponding
values in the variance spectrum. A
more informative spectrum is a plot
of how m uch of the variance is consistent with the changes in analyte
con cen tration . This spectrum is
called a correlation spectrum or correlogram.79 At each wavenumber
point in the correlation spectrum, the
Raman intensities from the set of
samples are regressed against the actual analyte concentrations. The correlation coef cient, R, of the regression is then plotted as a function of
Raman shift. Regions of the correlation spectrum having values approaching 1 or 21 are predictive of
analyte concentration, while those
approaching 0 are not. Other regression statistics can be used to m ake
24A
FIG. 1. Synthetic Raman signals and baseline, and their Fourier transforms. Each waveform consists of 2048 points (pixels) covering a spectral range of 4330 cm 2 1 . Only the signicant Fourier frequencies of the total 1024 are shown. (a) Gaussian band with
FWHM of 25 cm 21 is red, Lorentzian band with FWHM of 25 cm 2 1 is blue, and derivative of red Gaussian band times 2 is green.
(b) Intensity of Fourier frequencies of waveforms shown in (a). (c) Shape of typical Raman baseline. (d) Intensity of Fourier frequencies making up the baseline shown in (c).
25A
focal point
scattered intensity with respect to
Raman shift rem ains proportional to
the analyte concentration. Derivatives are actually a special kind of
high-pass lter. Taking the rst derivative of a Raman spectrum multiplies the amplitude of each frequency component in the Fourier
transform of the Raman spectrum by
a value proportional to its frequency.
The rst-derivative operation also
shifts the phase of each frequency
component by 908. Derivatives provide a fairly robust and automatic
baseline correction and spectral resolution enhancement to Raman spectra. They also strongly enhance highfrequency noise and can make analytical models more sensitive to temperature variation.14
A bandpass lter attenuates both
the high and low frequencies relative
to the middle-range frequencies. Applying a bandpass lter is equivalent
to sequentially applying a low-pass
lter and a high-pass lter. Since the
Fourier transform of a typical Raman
signal is composed mainly of middle-range frequencies, bandpass lters are usually m ore effective at
separating the Raman signal from
the noise than high-pass or low-pass
lters alone. A derivative is usually
used in conjunction with a low-pass
lter in order to reduce the enhancement of high-frequency noise. This
combination is actually a special
kind of bandpass lter.
Representing a Raman spectrum
as a linear co m binatio n of sine
waves provides powerful bene ts,
but sine waves are not always the
best basis set. Each sine wave is a
single frequency that extends over
the entire Raman spectrum, so a ltering operation used to separate signal and noise at one location in the
Raman spectrum affects all the rest
of the spectrum as well. Raman
bands are localized in sm all regions
of the Raman spectrum, so representing the Raman spectrum as a linear combination of more localized
functions m ay be bene cial. This is
the idea behind the windowed Fourier transform or short-time Fourier
transform .15 Fourier transform s and
ltering operations are carried out
26A
FIG. 2. Integrated signal intensity (green), noise intensity (blue), and S/N ratio (green)
for a synthetic Lorentzian band (FWHM
50 cm 2 1 ) plus random baseline noise as a
function of the distance from peak maximum that is included in the integration. The
peak of the Lorentzian band was 1 unit high and the noise had a standard deviation
of 0.2 units. The S/N ratio is optimized for integration including all points in the isolated Lorentzian greater than about 1 3 of the peak height when random baseline noise
is the dominant noise type.
27A
focal point
the wings of the Raman band is less
than the extra noise included into the
measurem ent.
Smoothing prior to band-height
measurem ent com bines the properties of a simple band-area measurement and a simple band-height measurement. A band-height measurement after sm oothing is equivalent to
a band are a m easurem ent w here
points are weighted by their proximity to the peak intensity. This approach uses m ore of the detected
photons than a simple band-height
measurem ent, but also discriminates
against both low signal-to-noise-ratio points at the wings of the Raman
band and intensity from other partially overlapping Raman bands. The
smoothing function can be adjusted
to optimally compromise the bene ts
and weaknesses of band-area and
band-height measurem ent.
Another way to improve upon
simple band-area or -height measurement is to utilize additional information about the shape of the Raman
band by curve tting. Raman band
shapes are often Lorentzian because
vibrational coherence decays exponentially with time and the Fourier
transform of an exponential decay is
Lorentzian. The shape of spectrally
narrow er R am an ban ds is m o re
strongly affected than broader bands
by the response function of the Raman instrument, which often looks
like a Gaussian, but may have asymmetry due to optical aberration. The
shape of simple, moderate-spectralresolution gas-phase Raman bands
may be largely determined by unresolved vibrational-rotational bands. 41
Curve tting provides an estimate of
the Raman band area, height, band
width, and baseline that is consistent
with the user-supplied band shape. It
uses all the detected photons in the
Raman band, discriminates against
other partially overlapping Raman
bands, and can improve baseline estimation. Curve tting must be used
cautiously, though. It is an iterative
process that can provide different results for the same data when the
starting co nditio ns are ch an ged.
Also, it often uses several operatoradjustable param eters that can be
28A
FIG. 3. Relative band areas of the C O (green) and CH (red) stretching vibrations of
acetone diluted with chloroform. The intensity of the C O vibration is affected by its
micro-environment. Adapted from Ref. 42.
29A
focal point
well and are frequently used for
qu antitativ e R am an analy sis. D e
Paepe et al.38 report coef cients of
variance below 1% using an external
standard. Many other applications
using an external standard are described in the Appendix. The primar y weakness of the multi-channel
external standard approach is potential non-equivalence of the optical
paths of the external standard and of
the sample. For example, a focusing
change at the sample or fouling of a
collection optic would change the
analyte band area without changing
the band area of the external standard.
The use of an external standard
eliminates the in uence of many experimental variables that have to be
carefully held constant when doing
quantitative analysis using absolute
Raman intensity. External standards
eliminate the effect of long-term
drift, allowing a quantitative analysis
method to work reliably over a long
period of time. The external standard
can also provide veri cation of proper instrum ent perform ance. Unfortunately, the external standard does not
correct for changes in sample properties such as opacity, refractive index, or moving inhomogeneity. External standards m ay not be practical
nor fully corrective for single-channel kinetics or for on-line measurements.
The limitations of external standards can be addressed by mixing
the standard into the sample. Sample
properties that affect analyte band
area equally affect the band area of
the standard. Ideally, no Raman intensity from th e stand ard w o uld
overlap the analytical band of the
sample. This type of standard is
called an internal standard. The concept of an internal standard was developed m ore than 70 years ago 50,51
to address similar concerns for quantitative analysis using atomic emission. Internal standards provide correction for changes in the sample
properties as well as for changes in
the Raman analyzer. The measurements of the standard and the analyte
can be simultaneous even for singlechannel analyzers and are made un30A
31A
focal point
FIG. 4. Plot of normalized Raman intensity from the analyte as a function of analyte
concentration. The green curve results from normalization using an internal standard
whose concentration does not change with changing analyte concentration. The red
curve results from normalization using an internal standard whose concentration decreases with increasing analyte concentration. In the case shown, the mole fraction of
the analyte plus that of the internal standard equals one and both materials have the
same Raman cross-section.
1
s a2 5 1
n
s b2 5
s e2
(x i 2 x ) 2
2
(x i 2 x )
where
1
n 22
s e2
i5 1
s e2 5
n
i5 1
x 2
(3)
i5 1
y i2 2 a
i5 1
2b
i5 1
xi yi
yi
RM SEP 5
i5 1
(c i 2 c i ) 2
n
(4)
33A
focal point
could hide analytically useful information.
The strength of multivariate analy tical m od els o ver u niv ariate
ones their use of more of the information present in the data can
also be a weakness. Noise in the
training set that happens to correlate
with analyte concentration can be incorporated into the analytical model.
The internal consistency of such an
analytical m odel may be very good,
but it m ay fail miserably at predicting analyte concentration in new
samples when the chance correlation
breaks down. Noise can also be the
dominant source of intensity variation between spectra in the training
set, obscuring a weak, localized signal due to the analyte. Even when
such noise is not strong, it can degrade the perform ance of an analytical model. Hirschfeld 74 reports an
interesting example of this in qualitative analysis. The quality of library
searching was observed to improve
when randomly selected portions of
the spectrum were excluded from the
search. The improved searching apparently resulted from minimizing
the impact of impurities in the library spectra! M ultivariate analytical
models can also be very sensitive to
x-axis error. Small shifts in wavenumber calibration create derivativelike intensity variation between spectra that some multivariate methods
will try to correlate with analyte concentration. Powerful integrated multivariate analysis software packages
can provide plausible, but wrong, results. It is important to carefully test
multivariate m odels and to understand the basis for their predictions.
S everal differe n t m ultivariate
methods that have been used to analyze Raman data are brie y described and contrasted below. A detailed description of these methods is
beyond the scope of this article, but
can be found in chemometrics textbooks7577 and in the speci c references noted.
Spectral Stripping. The spectral
stripping operation consists of multiply ing the pu re analyte R am an
spectrum by a constant and subtracting the resulting product from the
34A
C (x) 5
S (t) A ( x 1 t) dt
(5)
2`
to correlate with analyte concentration. In both cases, internal diagnostics may indicate good predictive
performance, but the resulting model
may have poor robustness or m ay
even fail completely when applied to
new samples.
Can random noise really look like
the analytical signal? Consider the
digits of p. They can be used as a
random number generator since they
have no particular pattern . . . or do
they? If p is calculated in base 26,
each digit can be assigned to a letter
of the alphabet. Starting at the 8th
digit after the decimal point we can
nd the phrase R am an IsB est.
Starting at digit 54 is the phrase
To IR isH u m an and at dig it
136 290 is the rest of the phrase
ToRamanDivine. Although many
may consider these phrases to be an
analytical signal worthy of attention,
they are really just examples of
chance correlation.87
M u ltip le L in ear R eg ressio n
(M LR). Multiple linear regression is
one example of an ILS model. MRL
reduces the number of samples required in the training set by using
only a limited number of the spectral
variables in the Raman spectra. Selection of the spectral variables may
be based on spectral knowledge. It is
also possible to optimize MLR models by iteratively selecting variables
and testing the predictive performance of the resulting model. A bene t of MLR models is their simplicity. The elimination of most of the
spectral variables, however, reduces
m ultiv ariate sig nal av eraging an d
greatly limits m ultivariate diagnostic
capabilities.
Principal C om p onent R egression (PCR). Principal com ponent regression is another type of ILS model. PCR reduces the number of samples required in the training set by
using principal components analysis
(PC A) to compress the spectra without signi cant loss of information.
The thousands of variables in each
original spectrum are replaced by a
linear combination of several new
variables (factors or loadings). PCR
can be thought of as PCA followed
by M LR, but the actual computation
35A
focal point
3. D. H. Gudehus and D. J. Hegyi, Astronom. J. 90, 130 (1985).
4. B. Schrader, Raman/Infrared Atlas of Organic Compounds (John Wiley and Sons,
New York, 1989), 2nd ed.
5. Sadtler Research Laboratories Ram an
Spectra. A collection of 4400 Raman
spectra, Philadelphia, PA (19731976).
6. D. Lin-Vien, N. B. Colthup, W. G. Fateley, and J. G. Grasselli, The Handbook of
Infrared and Raman Characteristic Frequencies of Organic Molecules (Academ ic Press, Boston, 1991).
7. D. Jouan-Rimbaud, B. Walczak, D. L.
M assart, I. R. Last, and K. A. Prebble,
Anal. Chim. Acta 304, 285 (1995).
8. J. M . Brenchley, U. Horchner, and J. H.
Kalivas, Appl. Spectrosc. 51, 689 (1997).
9. Galactic Industries Corporation, PLSplus/
IQ Users Guide (Galactic, Salem, NH,
1997), p. 85.
10. C. B. Lucasius and G. Kateman, Trends
Anal. Chem. 10, 254 (1991).
11. A. S. Bangalore, R. E. Shaffer, G. W.
Small, and M. A. Arnold, Anal. Chem.
68, 4200 (1996).
12. M . J. McShane, B. D. Cameron, G. L.
Cote, M . M otamedi, and C. H. Spiegelm an, Anal. Chim. Acta 388, 251 (1999).
13. L. Norgaard, A. Saudland, J. Wagner, J.
P. Nielsen, L. Munck, and S. B. Engelsen,
Appl. Spectrosc. 54, 413 (2000).
14. O. Svensson, M. Josefson, and F. W.
Langkilde, Eur. J. Pharm. Sci. 11, 141
(2000).
15. F. T. S. Yu and G. Lu, Appl. Opt. 33, 5262
(1994).
16. B. K. Alsberg, A. M. Woodward, and D.
B. Kell, Chemom. Intell. Lab. Syst. 37,
215 (1997).
17. B. Walczak, W avelets in Chemistry (Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2000).
18. D. Jouan-Rimbaud, B. Walczak, R. J.
Poppi, O. E. de Noord, and D. L. Massart,
Anal. Chem. 69, 4317 (1997).
19. W. Cai, L. Wang, Z. Pan, J. Zuo, C. Xu,
and X. Shao, J. Raman Spectrosc. 32, 207
(2001).
20. H. Takeuchi, S. Hashim oto, and I. Harada, Appl. Spectrosc. 47, 129 (1993).
21. D. Zhang, K. N. Jallad, and D. BenAmotz, Appl. Spectrosc. 55, 1523 (2001).
22. R. Bhargava and I. W. Levin, Anal.
Chem. 74, 1429 (2002).
23. L. Kay and D. A. Sadler, M eas. Sci. Technol. 2, 532 (1991).
24. L. Kay, M eas. Sci. Technol. 3, 400
(1992).
25. G. R. Phillips and J. M. Harris, Anal.
Chem. 62, 2351 (1990).
26. W. Hill and D. Rogalla, Anal. Chem. 64,
2575 (1992).
27. A. W. Moore, Jr., and J. W. Jorgenson,
Anal. Chem. 65, 188 (1993).
28. W. Hill, Appl. Spectrosc. 47, 2171 (1993).
29. J. L. Koenig, Appl. Spectrosc. 29, 293
(1975).
30. M . G. Shim and B. C. Wilson, J. Raman
Spectrosc. 28, 131 (1997).
31. T. J. Vickers, R. E. Wambles, Jr., and C.
36A
32.
33.
34.
35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
40.
41.
42.
43.
44.
45.
46.
47.
48.
49.
50.
51.
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
MSC
SNV
FRACT
APPENDIX
Examples of Quantitative Analysis Using Raman Spectroscopy.
Raman spectroscopy has been used
for quantitative analysis for several
decades. The table in this appendix
and its references summarize over
20 0 exam ples from th e peer-review ed technical literature. N um bered references in the table refer to
the reference list contained in this
appendix, not the reference list for
the body of the Focal Point article.
Descriptive information for the table
colum n headings is given below.
ID (classi cation used to group similar applications)
11 Polymer, polybutadiene
12 Polymer, polystyrene
13 Polymer, epoxy
14 Polymer, poly(methylmethacr ylate)
15 Polymer, density and crystallinity
16 Polymer, miscellaneous
17 Polymer, co-polymers
21 Hydrocarbons, C 8 separation
22 Hydrocarbons, xylenes
23 Hydrocarbons, fuel composition and
classi cation
24 Hydrocarbons, fuel properties
25 Hydrocarbons, miscellaneous
30 Glucose, biological applications
40 Fats and oils
50 Pharmaceutical applications
60 Gas-phase applications
80 Inorganic applications
Metric (spectral property related to analyte
concentration)
H
Band height
A
Band area
PCA
Principal components analysis
PLS
Partial least squares
SHIFT Change in band position
PCR
Principal components regression
CORR
Cross-correlation
Norm (method used to normalize intensity
of Raman spectrum)
NONE
Absolute intensity, no normalization
IN STD
Internal standard already part
of sample
1 IN STD
Internal standard added to
sample
S SPEC
Area of whole Raman spectrum set equal to 1
S SEG
Area of spectral segm ent set
equal to 1
w S BAND Weighted sum of Raman
bands
EX STD
RATIO
OTHER
37A
focal point
52.
53.
54.
55.
56.
57.
58.
59.
60.
61.
62.
63.
64.
65.
66.
67.
68.
69.
70.
71.
72.
73.
38A
74.
75.
76.
77.
78.
79.
80.
81.
82.
83.
84.
85.
86.
87.
88.
89.
90.
91.
92.
93.
94.
95.
96.
97.
98.
99.
127.
128.
129.
130.
131.
132.
133.
134.
135.
136.
137.
138.
139.
140.
141.
APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY
39A
focal point
Application
Polybutadiene structural content
Polybutadiene microstructure
Butadiene microstructure
Polybutadiene structural content
C5C during polybutadiene hydrogenation
Butadiene polymerization
Hydrogenated polybutadiene microstructure
Styrene polymerization
Styrene polymerization
Styrene polymerization
Styrene polymerization
Styrene polymerization
Styrene polymerization in benzene
Styrene emulsion polymerization
Epoxy cure
Epoxy cure
Epoxy cure
Epoxy cure
Epoxy cure
Epoxy cure
Methyl methacrylate polymerization
Methyl methacrylate polymerization
Methyl methacrylate polymerization
Methyl methacrylate polymerization
Methyl methacrylate emulsion polymerization
Poly(methylmethacrylate) residual monomer
Emulsion polymerization of methylethacrylate
Polyethylene cr ystallinity (density)
Poly(aryl ether ether ketone) cr ystallinity
Poly(aryl ether ether ketone) cr ystallinity
Polyethylene density (cr ystallinity)
PET yarn shrinkage
Polyethylene density (cr ystallinity)
Polyurethane ex modulus
Butylacr ylate polymerization
Acr ylamide polymerization kinetics
Diacetylene polymerization kinetics
Melam ine, melam ine cyanurate in nylon
Polyimide curing
Polyimide curing
trans-Polyactylene synthesis
Photopolymerization of divinyl ethers
Poly(aryl ether sulphone) sulfonation
Poly(ethylene glycol) in chloroform
Polyester synthesis
Vinyl acetate emulsion polymerization
Vinyl acetate emulsion polymerization
Photocuring of halogenated acr ylates
Norbornene polymerization
Styrene, butadiene, methylethacrylate terpolymer composition
Styrene monomer in styrene/butadiene
Styrene-divinylbenzene C5C content
Styrene-divinylbenzene polymer content
C5C in styrene-ethylene dimethacr ylate
Nitrile in nitrile-butadiene rubber
PES/PEES co-polymer composition
Emulsion polymerization (3 monomers)
Sulphone co-polymer composition
Co-polymer butadiene M MA C5C type
Monomer in melamine-formaldehyde
Epoxy-methacrylate copolymerization
Styrene-butylacrylate polymerization
Lactide-glycolide copolymer composition
Styrene-ethylene dimethacr ylate copolymer content
Styrene-butadiene polymerization
Content of epoxy-thermoplastic blends
Content of epoxy-thermoplastic blends
Styrene-ethylene dimethacr ylate copolymer content
Melam ine-formaldehyde copolymer composition
40A
ID
Metric
11
11
11
11
11
11
11
12
12
12
12
12
12
12
13
13
13
13
13
13
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
15
15
15
15
15
15
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
16
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
17
H
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
H
A
H
A
H
A
H
?
A
H
PCA
PCA
A
H
H
A
CLS
A
H
A
PLS
SHIFT
PLS
PLS
PLS
PLS
H
A
H
CLS
H
PCA
A
H
A
A
PLS
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
A
H
H
H
A
A
A
H
A
H
A
PLS
PLS
H
A
Norm
S SEG
S SEG
S SEG
S SEG
IN STD
IN STD
S SEG
IN STD
IN STD
NO NE
NO NE
IN STD
FRACT
IN STD
IN STD
FRACT
FRACT
IN STD
IN STD
S SPEC
NO NE
IN STD
NO NE
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
NO NE
IN STD
IN STD
NO NE
S SPEC
NO NE
MSC
IN STD
NO NE
NO NE
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
FRACT
FRACT
IN STD
IN STD
S SEG
IN STD
IN STD
RATIO
IN STD
IN STD
RATIO
RATIO
RATIO
S SEG
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
RATIO
RATIO
IN STD
IN STD
S SPEC
RATIO
RATIO
Ref
10
143
59
17
85
120
85
114
140
11
1
120
89
37
54
50
58
71
32
30
148
174
1
67
172
141
102
7
83
83
8
104
36
14
61
69
68
80
79
79
13
121
99
170
98
89
90
129
161
12
164
173
173
173
2
54
53
51
72
156
106
102
100
173
37
158
158
173
18
Application
ID
Metric
Norm
Ref
17
17
17
17
21
21
21
21
21
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
22
23
23
23
23
23
23
23
23
23
23
23
24
24
24
24
24
24
25
25
25
25
25
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
30
40
40
40
40
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
50
A
PLS
PLS
H
A
A
A
A
PLS
H
A
PLS
PLS
PLS
PLS
PLS
PLS
H
H
H
A
A
MLR
A
MLR
PLS
PCR
PLS
PCR
A
PLS
PLS
PLS
PLS
H
A
H
A
PLS
A
H
PLS
H
A
PLS
A
H
PLS
PLS
A
PLS
A
H
A
H
H
CORR
A
A
PCR
H
H
PLS
H
PLS
PLS
A
PLS
A, H
MLR
S SEG
MSC
S SPEC
IN STD
w S BAND
w S BAND
w S BAND
w S BAND
NO NE
IN STD
RATIO
NO NE
OTHER
OTHER
NO NE
NO NE
NO NE
1 IN STD
EX STD
EX STD
EX STD
EX STD
NO NE
NO NE
NO NE
NO NE
NO NE
NO NE
NO NE
RATIO
OTHER
OTHER
NO NE
OTHER
IN STD
IN STD
RATIO
EX STD
NO NE
IN STD
IN STD
NO NE
NO NE
IN STD
NO NE
OTHER
RATIO
NO NE
NO NE
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
1 IN STD
1 IN STD
RATIO
RATIO
S SEG
RATIO
RATIO
MSC
RATIO
NO NE
NO NE
IN STD
SNV
EX STD
EX STD
17
107
107
34
134
132
135
133
133
118
138
31
31
31
98
92
93
115
116
117
6
91
44
44
20
20
20
96
5
24
28
4
86
35
3
43
139
151
97
81
108
111
21
87
112
22
29
110
63
166
167
105
60
60
66
39
39
16
49
41
130
128
131
127
38
40
103
125
165
165
APPLIED SPECTROSCOPY
41A
focal point
Application
Pharmaceutical active in tablets
Pharmaceutical active in tablets
Remote gas analysis
Remote gas analysis
Remote gas analysis
Gas phase isotope ratio
Headspace in sealed drug vials
Multiple gas analysis
Multiple gas analysis
Multiple gas analysis
Wobbe index of natural gas
Multiple component gas analysis
N 2 and O 2 in double-pane windows
Hydrogen trace level analysis
Oxygen gas in nitrogen
Components in exhaled air
Metabolic gases
Xenon in anaesthetic
Nitrite, nitrate in water
Nitrate impurity in nitrite
Sulfate concentration
Sulfate in sodium nitrate
PO 4 2 3 and HPO 4 2 equilibria
Chromium oxide lm thickness
Sulfate, nitrate in single aerosol particles
Aqueous uranium solutions
Carbonate, bicarbonate, carbamate in water
Hydroxyapatite, calcium oxalate monohydrate m ixtures
PCl3 reactor material
Nitronium ion in acid
Phosphite and hypophosphite in water
Atmospheric corrosion products of lead
Carbon dioxide dissolved in water
Metals in cation exchange resins
Nitronium ion in acid and water
SC-1 cleaning bath composition
Water in sodium nitrate
(NH 4 ) 2 CO 3 aqueous equilibria
Nitrite decomposition kinetics
Silicon in silica dust
Gypsum in sulfated m arble
Nitrile oxidation by peroxides
Chlorosilane process streams
Hydrogen peroxide in water
Phosphate in conc. phosphoric acid
Perchlorate ion in aqueous extracts
Perchlorate, nitrate in aqueous extracts
Titanium dioxide, anatase in rutile
Autooxidation of unsaturated fatty acid ethyl esters
Cyanate hydrolysis kinetics
Isomerization of Quadricyclane to norbornadiene
CH 4 and CO 2 in quartz inclusions
Azo dyes in methanol
Butyl acr ylate in solvent
Urea in aqueous solution
Phenols in water
Phenols in water
Film thickness
Speci c gravity of Ivories
Dietary ber in cereal foods
Dietary ber in cereal foods
Esteri cation of ethylene glycol and dimethylterephthalic acid
Ethyl acetate synthesis and hydrolysis
Ethyl acetate synthesis and hydrolysis
Ethanol, methanol, acetone in water
Fenthion in pesticide formulations
Adipic acid, (NH 4 ) 2 SO 4 , and NaSO 4 in caprolactam
Diazinon in pesticide formulations
Methyl-parathion in pesticide formulations
Methyl-parathion in pesticide formulations
CCl4 in ethanol
Ethanol/water solution
42A
ID
Metric
Norm
Ref
50
50
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
60
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
80
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
90
PLS
H
A
A
A
A
H
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
H
H
H
A
A
A
A
H
H
H
A
H
H
A
H
H
PLS
CLS
A
A
CLS
H
A
H
H
PLS
A
H
SHIFT
A
A
A
H
A
CLS
A
A
H
H
A
CORR
H
PLS
PLS
PLS
PLS
H
PLS
CLS
A
H
H, A
H, A
MLR
H
A
NO NE
1 IN STD
NO NE
IN STD
IN STD
RATIO
IN STD
EX STD
EX STD
EX STD
EX STD
NO NE
EX STD
NO NE
w S BAND
IN STD
IN STD
EX STD
IN STD
IN STD
NO NE
IN STD
1 IN STD
EX STD
RATIO
IN STD
IN STD
RATIO
IN STD
EX STD
IN STD
RATIO
NO NE
IN STD
EX STD
IN STD
RATIO
NO NE
NO NE
1 IN STD
RATIO
NO NE
NO NE
NO NE
NO NE
IN STD
RATIO
RATIO
IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
RATIO
IN STD
1 IN STD
1 IN STD
IN STD
IN STD
NO NE
MSC
S SPEC
SNV
IN STD
IN STD
SNV
IN STD
EX STD
RATIO
EX STD
EX STD
EX STD
NO NE
EX STD
119
119
26
26
25
23
42
55
56
57
19
45
15
70
52
95
101
33
118
147
147
146
136
9
145
171
155
88
73
77
84
153
113
74
76
142
152
144
64
122
123
109
168
94
149
27
27
154
62
78
82
150
159
118
175
47
47
75
48
169
169
93
126
126
160
46
157
124
163
163
137
162