Cretaceous paleokarst
terrane, southern Maracaibo
Basin, Venezuela
Mara Veronica Castillo and Paul Mann
ABSTRACT
Cretaceous carbonate rocks formed an extensive passive-margin
section along the northern margin of the South American plate and
are now found in outcrops in elevated and deformed ranges like the
Merida Andes and Sierra de Perija. Regional seismic profiles correlated with well data show that a 300-m (984-ft)-thick Cretaceous
carbonate platform underlies all of the Maracaibo Basin of western Venezuela. We examined the Cretaceous carbonate section beneath the southern Maracaibo Basin using a 1600-km2 (617-mi2)
area of three-dimensional (3-D) seismic reflection data provided
by Petroleos de Venezuela, S. A., along with wells to constrain the
age and environments of seismic reflectors. Well data allow the
identification and correlation of the major lithologic subsurface
formations with formations described from outcrop studies around
the basin edges.
Seismic reflection time slices at a depth range of 3.7 4.5 s (5
7 km; 3.1 4.3 mi) reveal the presence of a prominent, irregular
reflection surface across the entire 3-D study area that is characterized by subcircular depressions up to about 600 m (1968 ft)
wide and about 100 m (328 ft) deep. We interpret the subcircular
features as sinkholes formed when the Lower Cretaceous carbonate
platform was subaerially exposed to weathering in a tropical climate. The scale of the observed circular features is consistent with
dimensions of limestone sinkholes described from modern karst
settings. Correlation of the inferred karst horizon with well logs
shows that the paleokarst horizon occurs within the shallow-water
carbonate rocks of the Aptian Apon Formation. We infer that the
karst formed during an Aptian eustatic sea level fall described from
Aptian intervals in other parts of the world, including the Gulf
of Mexico. The Aptian paleokarst zone provides a previously
unrecognized zone of porosity for hydrocarbons to accumulate
Copyright #2006. The American Association of Petroleum Geologists. All rights reserved.
Manuscript received February 18, 2005; provisional acceptance April 6, 2005; revised manuscript
received September 28, 2005; final acceptance October 12, 2005.
DOI:10.1306/10120505034
567
AUTHORS
Mara Veronica Castillo Department
of Geological Sciences and Institute for
Geophysics, Jackson School of Geosciences,
University of Texas at Austin, 4412 Spicewood
Springs Road, Building 600, Austin, Texas 78759;
present address: ENI, Caracas, Venezuela;
veronic_00@hotmail.com
Mara Veronica Castillo is an exploration geoscientist at ENI Venezuela in Caracas and lecturer on three-dimensional seismic interpretation at the Universidad Central de Venezuela
in Caracas. She obtained her Ph.D. in geology
at the University of Texas at Austin in 2001,
where she focused on the structural evolution
of the Maracaibo Basin, Venezuela. Her current
interest is using merged 3-D seismic data sets
for regional basin analysis.
Paul Mann Institute for Geophysics, Jackson
School of Geosciences, University of Texas
at Austin, 4412 Spicewood Springs Road,
Building 600, Austin, Texas 78759;
paulm@utig.ig.utexas.edu
Paul Mann is a senior research scientist at the
Institute for Geophysics, University of Texas
at Austin. He received his Ph.D. in geology at the
State University of New York in 1983 and has
published widely on the tectonics of strike-slip,
rift, and collision-related sedimentary basins.
A current focus area of research is the interplay
of tectonics, sedimentation, and hydrocarbon
occurrence in Venezuela and Trinidad.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We thank Petroleos de Venezuela, S. A., for providing seismic and well data used in this study
and for supporting M. Castillo as a Ph.D. student
in geology for 4 years at the University of Texas at
Austin. We thank J. Lugo, F. Audemard, A. Bally,
A. Escalona, A. Salvador, I. Azpiritxaga, and B.
Hardage for valuable discussions and reviews.
The authors acknowledge the financial support
for this publication provided by the University of
Texas at Austins Geology Foundation and the
Jackson School of Geosciences. University of
Texas, Institute for Geophysics contribution 1773.
Editors Note
Color versions of figures may be seen in the
online version of this article.
INTRODUCTION
Cretaceous Passive-Margin Section beneath Maracaibo Basin
Significance
A 300-m (984-ft)-thick, mixed carbonate-clastic section of Cretaceous sedimentary rocks was deposited
in the Maracaibo Basin during a tectonically stable period of slow, passive-margin sedimentation along the
northern edge of the South American continent (Mann
et al., 2006). Clastic sedimentation occurred during an
earliest Cretaceous transgressive period following Late
Jurassic rifting (Lugo and Mann, 1995). By the end of
the Early Cretaceous, clastic rocks passed upward into
carbonate lithologies. Mixed carbonate and clastic deposition continued until the lower Turonian (Parnaud
et al., 1995; Villamil and Pindell, 1998) (Figure 1). The
outer (northern) part of the Maracaibo platform was
tectonically deformed by the arrival of the Pacificderived Caribbean plate in the late Paleocene and Eocene (Lugo and Mann, 1995; Mann et al., 2006). Compilation of well data and outcrop data by Gonzalez de
Juana et al. (1980) and Parnaud et al. (1995) shows that
most of the Lower Cretaceous Maracaibo Basin was
underlain by a carbonate platform of inner- to middleshelf depth. Areas of shallower water and main shelf
areas with mixed carbonate-clastic deposition were located to the south and southeast of the present-day
Maracaibo Basin (Figure 1).
The widespread Cretaceous carbonate platform is
of great economic significance to hydrocarbon exploration in the Maracaibo Basin because the platform
contains Upper Cretaceous black shales of the La Luna
Formation that form the main source rocks for more
than 50 billion bbl of cumulative oil production from
the Maracaibo Basin (Escalona and Mann, 2006b).
Carbonate rocks also act as important reservoirs for oil
production in the basin (Azpiritxaga, 1991). A thick
and widespread shale seal is present above the carbonate platform rocks (Colon Formation in Figure 2).
Stratigraphic Setting
Transgressive, Barremian clastic deposits are overlain
by a Lower Cretaceous carbonate-platform succession,
collectively known as the Cogollo Group (Figure 2A).
568
The platform was well established over the large region shown in Figure 1 by the beginning of the Aptian
(Garner, 1926; Parnaud et al., 1995). The Cogollo Group
is composed of several formations, including, from
oldest to youngest, the Apon (Sutton, 1946), Lisure
(Rod and Maync, 1954), Aguardiente (Notestein, et al.,
1944), and Maraca formations (Rod and Maync, 1954)
(Figure 2A).
Type localities for outcrops of these formations
are found in the incised river valleys draining into the
Maracaibo Basin (Gonzalez de Juana et al., 1980). Formation names and lithologic descriptions of these
units indicate lithologic similarity over distances of
hundreds of kilometers, although Renz (1981) notes
significant thickness variations in the platform units
across the area of the Sierra Perija, Maracaibo Basin,
and Merida Andes. Thickness variations are attributed
to Early Cretaceous arching in the continental crust
and uplift of the proto-Andean mountains (Renz, 1981;
Salvador, 1986).
Structural Setting
Regional mapping by Audemard (1991) showed that
the PaleozoicMesozoic acoustic basement of the Maracaibo Basin and its overlying carbonate platform uniformly dip southeastward (Figure 2B). Tilting is related
to the east-west shortening of the Maracaibo Basin and
late Neogene overthrusting of the Merida Andes over
the southeastern edge of the basin (Duerto et al., 2006).
Acoustic basement reaches a maximum depth of 9 km
(5.5 mi) near the southeastern edge of the basin near
the area described in this article (Figure 2B). Interpretation of three-dimensional (3-D) seismic volumes by
Escalona and Mann (2006a) and Castillo and Mann
(2006) shows that the main structures in the carbonate platform rocks are northeast- to northwest-striking
faults related to either the reactivation of sub-Cretaceous
basement faults or to the Eocene flexural deformation
of the basin.
Objectives of This Paper
This article advances the understanding of the
Maracaibo Basin reservoirs of Lower Cretaceous age
by presenting 3-D seismic reflection and well evidence
of a regionally extensive and deeply buried Cretaceous
paleokarst terrane at a depth of 5 7 km (3.1 4.3 mi)
beneath the southern Maracaibo Basin. The karst zone
provides a previously unrecognized zone of porosity
for hydrocarbons to accumulate within the deeply buried passive-margin carbonate section of the Maracaibo
Basin.
569
Figure 1. Paleogeography of the Maracaibo Basin area from the Aptian to Cenomanian modified from Parnaud et al. (1995). A mixed carbonate-clastic section was deposited
under stable conditions along a broad passive margin, fringing the northern edge of the South American continent. (A) Aptian paleogeography. Contours show thickness of the
Aptian interval. (B) Albian lower Cenomanian. Contours show thickness of the Aptian lower Cenomanian interval. (C) Top of the lower Cenomanian. Positive land areas by the
top of the lower Cenomanian are interpreted as a sea level drop in the Lake Maracaibo area.
570
Figure 2. (A) Regional-stratigraphic chart for Cretaceous passive-margin carbonate rocks in the area of the
Maracaibo Basin compiled from Gonzalez de Juana et al. (1980), Audemard (1991), and Lugo (1991). Numerical
time scale is based on Gradstein et al. (1995). (B) Structural contour map in kilometers showing the top of the
acoustic basement (either Late Jurassic sedimentary rocks or Paleozoic metamorphic rocks) and the overlying
carbonate platform dipping to the southeast (map modified from Audemard, 1991). (C) Log of a well in the northern
part of the study area showing measured thicknesses of formations and gamma-ray response from Cretaceous
carbonate section.
571
572
Figure 3. (A) (1) Uninterpreted seismic reflection time slice at 3.8 s TWT from the 3-D seismic reflection study area in the southern
Maracaibo Basin. (2) Interpreted seismic reflection time slice following the method of Castillo and Mann (2006). The Lower Cretaceous
section displays subcircular features interpreted as sinkholes in a paleokarst terrane. (B) (1) Uninterpreted seismic reflection time slice at
4.1 s TWT from the 3-D seismic reflection study area in the southern Maracaibo Basin. (2) Interpreted seismic reflection time slice
following the method of Castillo and Mann (2006). The Lower Cretaceous section displays subcircular features interpreted as sinkholes
in a paleokarst terrane. (C) Radar image indicating the location of the seismic survey in the southern Maracaibo Basin and the
stratigraphic column with color code correlated with the colors used on the interpreted time slice.
Castillo and Mann
573
Figure 5. (A) Sonic log, synthetic seismogram, and seismic data response to Lower Cretaceous lithologic formations from a well
penetrating into the Cretaceous passive-margin section. (B) (1) Uninterpreted seismic line 1050 extracted from the 3-D seismic data
volume. (2) Interpreted seismic line showing Lower Cretaceous units. Seismic reflectors correlated with the Apon Formation are
discontinuous and, in some cases, truncated. We interpret this truncation surface as the expression of a regional paleokarst horizon.
(C) Location map of the well and seismic line.
574
Table 1. Geometric Characteristics of Scales of Subcircular, Geologic Features from Stewart (1999)
Geologic Feature
Diapir (salt, shale)
Pillow (salt, sand, shale)
Withdrawal basin (salt)
Polygonal fault system
Carbonate dissolution/
collapse pit
Volcanic diatreme/maar
Volcanic calderas
Volcano (igneous)
Gas pockmark
Reef/carbonate mound
Glacial kettle hole
Pull-apart basin
Impact crater
Scale Typical
Diameter (km)
1 5
1 5
215
0.3 2
0.01 1
1
1+
1+
1
1
15
0.01 1
0.5 1
0.5 1
01
No
No
Yes
Yes
0.01 3
250
150
0.01 0.3
0.01 2
0.01 1
040
1100 +
1
1
1+
1
1+
1+
2 5
1
2+
0.1 1
0.1 0.5
0.01 0.2
0.1 0.5
0.01 0.1
01
0.1 0.2
No
Yes
No
Yes
Yes
Yes
DISCUSSION
Paleokarst Interpretation
In previously published studies of surficial, modern
karst areas, the identification of paleokarst terranes is
based on lithostratigraphic characteristics, including
visual identification of hiatuses in carbonate sections,
paleosols, sinkhole fillings, and filled solution cavities
(White and White, 1995). However, paleokarst surfaces are rarely recognized in the rock record (James
and Choquette, 1984).
Coherent Internal
Structure/Fill(?)
In the south Maracaibo study area, the identification of the paleokarst surface is based on the identification of sinkholes interpreted on 3-D seismic time slices
(Figures 3A, B; 4) that are then correlated with the
vertical seismic profile, and well shown in Figure 5.
The Apon Formation is the thickest (90 m; 295 ft) and
most massive carbonate unit in the Cogollo Group
(Figure 2). For that reason, it would be the most likely
unit of the Cogollo Group (Figure 2B) to exhibit prominent, subcircular karst weathering features if subaerially exposed in a tropical climate.
Stewart (1999) provided an interpretation of geological features that are approximately circular in plan
view but are difficult to interpret from 2-D seismic reflection profiles alone. He provided a summary of the
geological and geometrical criteria that might be used
for identification of circular features interpreted from
3-D seismic reflection data ( Table 1). His compilation
shows that the scale range for carbonate dissolution and
collapse features in karst terranes ranges from 10 m
(33 ft) to 1 km (0.6 mi), which is comparable to the
sizes of circular features observed using the seismic
data (600 m [1968 ft] wide) (Figures 3, 4).
Hardage et al. (1996) showed 3-D seismic reflection evidence of the effects of widespread carbonate
karst collapse of Paleozoic carbonate rocks of the Ellenburger Group on the overlying Pennsylvanian clastic
stratigraphy in the Fort Worth basin of Texas. In their
study, Hardage et al. (1996) used 3-D seismic data
to identify circular to oval-shaped depressions with
Castillo and Mann
575
Figure 7. Comparison of sea level curves constructed from worldwide examples of Cretaceous rocks (modified from Scott et al.,
1988). The gray line indicates a sea level fall during the Aptian that is present in most of the sections compiled. The sea level curve for
the Maracaibo Basin, Venezuela, is taken from Azpiritxaga (1991).
Mendez (1989) also proposed the influence of the
vadose and phreatic zones during the diagenetic evolution of the carbonates of the Cogollo Group in the Perija,
Urdaneta, and central lake areas of the Maracaibo Basin.
In addition, he proposed that brecciation and collapse
affected the base of the Apon Formation during the
Lower Cretaceous. Mendez (1989) did not consider
Oligocene basin inversion and uplift a significant mechanism for brecciation and collapse of Cretaceous carbonates as proposed by Kummerow and Perez de Meja
(1989).
Nelson et al. (2000) studied the Cretaceous reservoirs in the La Paz field in the northwestern part of
the Maracaibo Basin. They concluded that the anomalously high oil production in some parts of the field
resulted from the development of secondary porosity
formed during the Eocene inversion and exposure of
the Cretaceous carbonate rocks.
In southern Lake Maracaibo, Castillo and Mann
(2006) recognize no evidence for exposure of Cretaceous carbonate rocks at any time during their Paleogene history. We suggest that the brecciation and collapse of the Apon Formation recognized by Mendez
CONCLUSIONS
The interpretation of seismic reflection time slices
allowed the identification of subcircular features in the
Lower Cretaceous carbonates of the Cogollo Group.
According to their scale, these features were interpreted as sinkholes in a paleokarst terrane that formed
by subaerially tropical weathering of the shallow-water
carbonate lithologies of the Apon Formation. In addition, this study suggests that the paleokarst surface
formed during the Aptian, during a well-known eustatic drop in the sea level observed in other parts of the
world (Figure 7).
Castillo and Mann
577
REFERENCES CITED
Audemard, F., 1991, Tectonics of western Venezuela: Ph.D. dissertation, Rice University, Houston, 245 p.
Azpiritxaga, I., 1991, Carbonate depositional styles controlled by
siliciclastic influx and relative sea level changes, Lower
Cretaceous, central Lake Maracaibo, Venezuela: M.A. thesis,
University of Texas at Austin, Austin, Texas, 151 p.
Brown, A., 1999, Interpretation of three-dimensional seismic data:
AAPG Memoir 42, 514 p.
Caldwell, W., 1984, Early Cretaceous transgressions and regressions
in the Southern Interior plains, in D. Scott and D. Glass, eds.,
The Mesozoic of middle North America: Canadian Society of
Petroleum Geologists Memoir 9, p. 173 203.
Castillo, M. V., and P. Mann, 2006, Cretaceous to Holocene structural and stratigraphic development in south Lake Maracaibo,
Venezuela, inferred from well and three-dimensional seismic
data: AAPG Bulletin, v. 90, p. 529 565.
Duerto, L., A. Escalona, and P. Mann, 2006, Deep structure of the
Merida Andes and Sierra de Perija mountain fronts, Maracaibo
Basin: AAPG Bulletin, v. 90, p. 505 528.
Escalona, A., and P. Mann, 2006a, Tectonic controls of the rightlateral Burro Negro tear fault on Paleogene structure and stratigraphy, northeastern Maracaibo Basin: AAPG Bulletin, v. 90,
p. 479 504.
Escalona, A., and P. Mann, 2006b, An overview of the petroleum
system of Maracaibo Basin: AAPG Bulletin, v. 90, p. 657 678.
Flexer, A., A. Rosenfeld, S. Lipson-Benitah, and A. Honigstein,
1986, Relative sea level changes during the Cretaceous in
Israel: AAPG Bulletin, v. 70, p. 1685 1699.
Garner, A., 1926, Suggested nomenclature and correlation of the
geological formations in Venezuela: American Institute Mining
and Metallurgy Engineers Transactions, p. 677 684.
Gonzalez de Juana, C., J. Iturralde, and X. Picard, 1980, Caracas,
Geologa de Venezuela y de sus Cuencas Petrolferas: Ediciones
Foninves, Tomos I y II, 1031 p.
Gradstein, F., F. Agterberg, J. Ogg, J. Hardenbol, P. Van Veen, J.
Thierry, and Z. Huang, 1995, A Triassic, Jurassic and
Cretaceous time scale, in W. Kent, D. Aubry, and J. Hardenbol,
eds., Geochronology, time scales and global stratigraphy
correlation: SEPM Special Publication 54, p. 95 126.
Haq, B., J. Hardenbol, and P. Vail, 1987, Chronology of fluctuating
sea levels since the Triassic: Science, v. 235, p. 1156 1167.
Hardage, B., D. Carr, D. Lancaster, J. Simmons, R. Elphick, V.
Pendleton, and R. Johns, 1996, 3-D seismic evidence of the
effects of carbonate karst collapse on overlying clastic stratigraphy and reservoir compartmentalization: Geophysics, v. 61,
p. 1336 1350.
Harris, P. M., S. H. Frost, G. A. Seiglie, and N. Schneidermann, 1984,
578
579