Editors-in-Chief
Departments
Articles
Teaching the Hypermobile Dancer
Moira McCormack, M.Sc.
Stretching for Dance
Matthew Wyon, Ph.D.
The IADMS Bulletin for Teachers Handout 2(1)
2010
Understanding Balance: Applying Science to
Dance Training
Glenna Batson, P.T., Sc.D.
The IADMS
Bulletin for Teachers
Volume 2, Number 1, 2010
Editors-in-Chief
Gayanne Grossman, P.T., Ed.M.
and
Marliese Kimmerle, Ph.D.
Associate Editors
Ruth Solomon
and
John Solomon
Introduction
2
Articles
5
13
14
Departments
17
www.iadms.org
distribution.
This issue includes papers on hypermobility, stretching
and balance. The stretching paper includes a handout,
which is the third in our handout series. We encourage
dance educators to continue communicating with us to
ensure that we answer your questions and address topics
that help promote our mission of bringing state of the art
dance science research into the dance studio. Please send
your letters to: media@iadms.org
The Editors
Dear Editor,
Thank you so much for the articles in Volume 1, Number
2, 2009, online. It is just the necessary information for
ballet teachers like me, living in a remote part of Sri Lanka.
Please continue these online infos.
Thanking you,
Hannelore Imig-Jayasundara, Sri Lanka
Copyright 2010 International Association for Dance Medicine & Science www.iadms.org
Copyright 2010 International Association for Dance Medicine & Science www.iadms.org
cluding collagen and elastin. Genetic defects distort the biochemical structure of these proteins and impair their tensile
properties, resulting in tissue laxity, or hypermobility. Unfortunately, this is accompanied by tissue fragility, weakness,
and a tendency to mechanical failure. Some dancers may
present with abnormal flexibility but develop strength early
on and do not injure easily. Others fall into the Joint Hypermobility Syndrome: they have generalized flexibility but
accumulate joint pain and injury that results in deselection.1
In 1973 Beighton et al. devised a quick 5-maneuver
test to score hypermobility (see photos 1-5). The 9-point
score is not an accurate measure, but it does provide an
interesting initial observation and means of recognition.
As another indicator, the skin in hypermobile tissues tends to be stretchy, especially on the back of the
hands and elbows and on the front of the knees. Further
evidence of skin involvement is the presence of stretch
marks over the lumbar spine and thighs in adolescents.
When scars heal they tend to be thickened and white.2
Testing the untrained joints wrist, fingers and elbows
gives an indication of the stretchiness of the ligaments
involved, reflecting a general type. However, the hip and
spine are tested uni-directionally with foot and ankle not
included, whereas these are very much the teachers concern
(see photos 6, 7 and 8).
A hypermobile joint has a lax capsule and ligaments
guarding its range. It is less stable, weaker, and more susceptible to injury than a normal joint. Knees and elbows
can hyperextend more than 15. The foot and ankle can
plantar flex (point) far more than the norm (photo 7). The
spine flexes and extends significantly more than normal,
indicating that the ligaments stabilizing the spine allow
increased motion between vertebrae. Therefore, joint stability is reliant on muscular support and neural control for its
integrity.
Hypermobile individuals have decreased proprioception;3 hence, posture, balance and coordination are affected.
Embedded in joint capsules and ligament are sensory nerve
endings that constantly inform the Central Nervous Sys-
Copyright 2010 International Association for Dance Medicine & Science www.iadms.org
proprioceptive system.
It is the sensory part of the nervous system that allows
us to appreciate acutely the position of our limbs in space,
be it joint position or muscular activity. The motor part
of the nervous system then responds to received information, and the result is fine control throughout the range of
movement and coordination of complex moves. However,
it is here, as already noted, that the hypermobile physique
has a deficit.
At the Royal Ballet Company and School we investigated
the incidence of hypermobility and the incidence of Joint
Hypermobility Syndrome, using the Brighton Criteria
in both cases. The Brighton Criteria for inclusion in the
syndrome takes into account the 9-point Beighton test and
history of injury. We found that 74% of girls and 82% of
boys in the lower school (1116 yrs) were hypermobile. The
incidence in the 1618 year olds was 94% of females and
83% of males. In the professional company the incidence
was 95% of females and 82% of males. These figures suggest
that a physical type is most definitely selected. Interestingly, the incidence of Joint Hypermobility Syndrome in
the Lower School was 47% in girls and 45% in boys. In
the 1618 yrs it was 46% in females and 35% in males.
However, in the professionals it was 26% in females and
36% in males. The decrease in numbers in the company
suggests that hypermobile dancers who have also been
injured are less likely to progress into the profession. We
also found that none of the principals had the syndrome,
implying that professional development is jeopardized by
it. These observations suggest that a clear understanding
of the vulnerable physique is required of dancers and those
who train them, with prevention strategies in place.
The principles of teaching do not change with the hypermobile dancer, but they are harder to instil. Stability and
placement emanate from the core to the periphery. When
the placement of the pelvis is correct and well understood,
turnout at the hip can be trained, hyperextended knee
controlled, and good biomechanics of the foot applied.
In the upper body, the lumbar spine can be stabilized in
neutral, guiding the rest of the spine and shoulder girdle
into alignment over the pelvis and legs.
The swayback knee is always a challenge. Although
attractive, if the joint extends 15 or more past neutral it
is hard to teach and strengthen. If allowed to lock back
into its full extension when weight bearing, the muscles
that control it relax, the control of turnout is lost, and the
student sinks into the hip. This is often accompanied by
a tucking under (posterior tilt) of the pelvis and loss of
the neutral lumbar spine. End of range extension of the
knee can be curbed by activating the adductor muscles, the
hamstrings, and the vastus medialis part of the quadriceps,
just above the patella. This in turn allows better use of the
calf muscles and brings the weight further forward over the
center of the foot. Students should be discouraged from
resting in extreme positions relaxing in the sway back
posture, which overstretches the front of the hips and the
backs of the knees.
The foot in all dancers bears the stress of incorrect alignment above it. In the excessively flexible foot and ankle the
many small joints of the midfoot, composing longitudinal
and transverse arches, are easily compromised. Each joint
is bound by ligament and capsule, and further supported
by intrinsic muscles of the foot. If the arches are stressed
in the rolling pronated foot, the medial longitudinal arch
flattens and the foot may never recover. Working the foot
3.
References
1.
2.
4.
lexibility is an important part of fitness for dancers, as high levels of flexibility are required to meet
the choreographic demands placed on performers
today.1, 2 Flexibility can be defined as the ability of a joint
to move through its full range of motion (ROM). It can
increase within a specific program and decrease after a
period of inactivity.3 Dancers are often associated with
large ranges of motion, but these are normally very joint
specific. For example, Spanish dancers require good ROM
in the shoulders while having hip ROM similar to that
of the non-dancing population; classical ballet dancers,
on the other hand, require extensive ROM around the
hips and normal levels at the shoulder. In recent years
the ROM that dancers need has increased drastically;
this is especially seen in classical ballet, where the height
of the dvelopp in Les Sylphides has increased from 60
to nearly 180. There are two types of ROM, passive and
active. The former describes ROM when an external force
(another person, for instance) moves the limb as far as it
can go, while active ROM relies on muscular strength to
move the limb (e.g., use of the hip flexors in a dvelopp
devant).
It has been reported that up to 17 factors can affect
flexibility, including age, body morphology, genetics,
gender, bones, nerves, muscle, ligaments, and connective
tissue.1 Koutedakis and Sharp4 found that 85% of factors
limiting flexibility are related to the joints, such as articulating bone and cartilage surfaces and ligaments. The main
structure whose length can be altered is the muscle unit.
Short of any genetic disposition to passive flexibility, the
most effective way of achieving any measure of flexibility
is through some form of stretching. The aim of this article
is to look at the different stretching techniques available
to dancers, our research comparing two of these stretching techniques, and how stretching is best integrated into
dance training. The article will not cover specific stretches
for dancers, as dance is not generic enough to allow us to
prescribe stretches that are ideal for all dancers. However,
the principles discussed in the following sections can be
Physiology of Stretching
There are a variety of adaptive mechanisms that occur as
a result of stretching. The potential links between the observed effects, their causes and consequences still remain
elusive. The mechanisms most researched in humans are
structural and neurological. Brooks, Fahey and Baldwin3
note that of all the factors involved, the connective tissue
adaptations can show the greatest improvements in ROM
due to their potential to increase permanently in length.
Since a permanent increase in ROM is the main goal of
any dancers stretching program, effort should be aimed at
using stretches that permanently increase a muscles length.
However, as some muscles provide postural stability and
need to be stiff,5 caution must be taken as to which muscles
are being stretched. Neural adaptations can be two-fold.
First, the myelin sheath that surrounds the nerves needs to
be stressed gently (aggressive stress can cause tethering,
which results in muscle spasm, pain, and tingling along the
path of the nerve).6 Secondly, neuromuscular monitoring
of the muscles status is initiated by nerve endings, such as
the nerves of the muscle spindles. These nerves monitor
muscle length and need to adapt to the increased ROM
so that it continues to provide relevant information about
its length. Rapid increases in length, such as occurs in an
ankle sprain, result in incorrect information being relayed
back to the brain, causing increased instability and reduced
proprioception.7 The Golgi Tendon Organ (GTO), found
in the muscle tendon, adapts by reducing its autogenic
inhibition reflex, thereby allowing more force to occur
within the muscle before its protective mechanism causes
it to contract. That said, as with mechanical adaptations,
there is no current consensus on a singular mechanical
adaptation due to stretching.6, 8
Copyright 2010 International Association for Dance Medicine & Science www.iadms.org
10
11
Summary
Stretching is a vital aspect of dance to provide the dancer
with the ROM necessary for artistic expression. This review
has shown that stretching alone is not enough, and more
thought is often required to select the correct technique to
prepare, develop, or recover the muscle. It is also a good
idea to start each stretch session with a different muscle, as
otherwise some muscles will always be over-looked, which
could limit or compromise movement. Every few months
review what you are doing or prescribing, according to the
developments achieved.
Acknowledgment
This article was generated from Wyon M, Felton L, Galloway S.A comparison of two stretching modalities on lower
limb range of motion measurements in recreational dancers.
J Strength Cond Res. 2009;23(7):21448.
References
1.
12
Sport. 1998;69(4):411-415.
18. Knudson D, Bennett K, Corn R, Leick D, Smith C. Acute
effects of stretching are not evident in the kinematics of the
vertical jump. J Strength Cond Res. 2001;15(1): 98-101.
19. Smith C. The warm-up procedure: to stretch or not
to stretch. A brief review. J Orthop Sports Phys Ther.
1994;19(1):12-17.
20. Wyon M, Felton L, Galloway S. A comparison of two
stretching modalities on lower limb range of motion measurements in recreational dancers. J Strength Cond Res.
2009;23(7):21442148.
21. Grossman G, Wilmerding M. The effect of conditioning
on the height of dancers extension in a la seconde. J Dance
Med Sci. 2000;4(4):117-121.
www.iadms.org
Copyright 2010 International Association for Dance Medicine & Science www.iadms.org
13
Understanding Balance
Figure 1 Balance A Complex System of Support Combining Person, Place & Movement Task. (Batson G, derived from
Resources on Balance, http://resourcesonbalance.com/clinical_info/BalanceControl.aspx.)
Copyright 2010 International Association for Dance Medicine & Science www.iadms.org
14
15
16
References
1. Massion J. Postural control systems in developmental perspective. Neuroscience and Biobehav Rev. 1998;22:465-72.
2. Krasnow D, Monasterio R, Chatfield SJ. Emerging concepts
of posture and alignment. Med Problems Perform Art.
2001;8:12-20.
3. Resources on Balance. http://www.resourcesonbalance.com.
NeuroCom International, accessed November 20, 2009.
4. Blakeslee S, Blakeslee M. The Body Has a Mind of its Own.
New York: Random House, 2008.
5. Woollacott M, Shumway-Cook A. Changes in postural
control across the life-span: a systems approach. Phys Ther.
1990;20(12):799-807.
6. Assaiante C, Mallau S, Sebastien V, Jover M, Schmitz C.
Development of postural control in healthy children: a
functional approach. Neural Plast. 2005;12:109-18.
7. Wulf G. Attention and Motor Skill Learning. Champaign, IL:
Human Kinetics, 2007.
Copyright 2010 International Association for Dance Medicine & Science www.iadms.org
17
18
Hosted by IADMS
The University of Wolverhampton
The Birmingham Royal Ballet
A Day for Teachers is an annual IADMS event
organized by
the Program Subcommittee of the IADMS Education Committee
Copyright 2010 International Association for Dance Medicine & Science www.iadms.org
19