Symbolic Thought
JEAN KHALFA
Abstract:
The philosopher of Mathematics Jean Cavaills (19031944) plays an important
role in Claude Imberts thought. His published work had a significant impact
after the war. It is largely a reflection on debates on the foundation of
mathematics and on two opposed models of axiomatics, foundationalist and
constructionist. The philosophy he announced (cut short by his death during
World War II) was to be a study of the generativity of conceptual structures, as
opposed to a phenomenology of knowledge. He derived from his reflection on
invention in mathematics a great scepticism on the ideas of the separateness and
unity of consciousness and a criticism of the teleologies inherent in philosophies
of consciousness. In that, his work, according to Claude Imbert, made possible
the reflections on structures and symbolisms which were to dominate the
French context in the following decades.
Keywords: philosophy of mathematics, formal systems, epistemology,
teleology, Jean Cavaills
In Claude Imberts genealogy of the abandonment of Kantian and neoKantian theories of knowledge, logic and symbolism, Jean Cavaills
holds a prime position. He represents a moment in the late thirties
in France when, for her, a number of antinomies and false problems
were abandoned, in particular the oppositions of form and intuition,
theory and object, concept and experience, and the obsession with
absolute foundations. Because Cavaillss life was tragically cut short,
in 1944, at the age of forty one, when he was murdered by the Nazis
(he was one of the founders and heroes of the French Resistance),1 he
left a work that only announced a transformation in the philosophical
understanding of the operations of thought, but one which he did not
Paragraph 34.2 (2011): 257265
DOI: 10.3366/para.2011.0021
Edinburgh University Press
www.eupjournals.com/para
258 Paragraph
259
260 Paragraph
metamathematical control and thus reveal the solidarity of all parts of mathematics,
so that it can never be said : here is the simple. All projects of inventory, of
definition, origin, architectonics, but also of the intentional determination of a
science by its object were suddenly abolished. (Imbert 2003b, 78)9
261
262 Paragraph
2
3
5
6
263
264 Paragraph
8 La description est bien connue de ces renversements historiques o le
rsultat fait clater la mthode et le systme tout entier dont il est issu: les
procds exigs par la solution dun problme provoquent, dans lactualisation
mme qui leur donne un sens, un tel changement dclairage quil faut
dj abandonner les notions qui forment leur structure. Mais les liaisons
intellectuelles dpassent lhistoire empirique: cest leur dveloppement
dialectique qui assure la fois le mouvement de celles-ci et par elles-mmes
la permanence de leur validit (Cavaills 1962, 274).
9 Au lieu de chercher encore une thorie socle, originaire, lmentaire, et une
catgoricit axiomatique, Cavaills propose dassocier le constructivisme son
contrle mtamathmatique et de faire voir la solidarit de toutes les parties
des mathmatiques entre elles, en sorte quon ne peut jamais dire l est le
simple . Tout projet dinventaire, de dfinition, dorigine, darchitectonique
mais aussi de dtermination intentionnelle dune science par son objet, sen
trouvait soudainement annul.
10 La ncessit de lengendrement dun objet nest jamais saisissable qu travers
la constatation dune russite; lexistence dans le champ thmatique na de
sens quen tant que corrlat dun acte effectif. (. . .) la question du sens
dune opration telle que la posent les intuitionnistes mane du prjug
dontologie non critique que lobjet doit tre dfini antrieurement
lopration, alors quil en est insparable. A non-critical ontology is one
asserting the duality of a sensible world in itself and of a thought mistaken
for historical manifestations [la dualit dun monde sensible en soi et dune pense
confondue avec des manifestations historiques] (Cavaills 1981, 176).
11 Imbert refers to Cavaillss correspondence and his project of working on
probability theory (Imbert 2003b, 16). She has often stressed the importance
of the notion of pari or wager understood as risk taking, to a different form
of philosophical thought. See for instance Imbert 1982 and Imbert 2007b.
12 See Jean Khalfa, Pascals Theory of Knowledge, in The Cambridge Companion
to Pascal, edited by Nicholas Hammond (Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press, 2003), 12243.
13 On the history of the Davos disputation, see Peter Eli Gordon, Ernst Cassirer
and Martin Heidegger at Davos, 1929 an allegory of intellectual history,
Modern Intellectual History 1: 2 (2004), 21948.
14 Personal communication with Claude Imbert, 10 August 2010.
15 consciente davoir reu des procdures intellectuelles puises quil lui
incombait de reconfigurer.
16 A notion which helps understand Deleuzes later notion of a plane of
immanence.
17 Mais le sensible, conscience concrte immdiate, nest pas abandonn: ce
nest pas le quitter que dagir sur lui (tout objet abstrait, obtenu, par exemple,
par thmatisation, est un geste sur un geste, (. . .) sur un geste sur le sensible
18
19
20
21
22
23
265
primitif). Le champ thmatique nest donc pas situ hors du monde mais
est transformation de celui-ci: la pense effective (exigeant une conscience
plus complte) des choses est pense de ses objets (la pense adquate dune
pluralit est pense de son nombre).
For instance Husserls idea of a teleology immanent to the history of
philosophy. (Cavaills 1947, 77).
Le terme de conscience ne comporte pas dunivocit dapplication pas
plus que la chose, dunit isolable. Il ny a pas une conscience gnratrice
de ses produits, ou simplement immanente eux, mais elle est chaque fois
dans limmdiat de lide, perdue en elle et se perdant avec elle et ne se liant
avec dautres consciences (ce quon serait tent dappeler dautres moments
de la conscience) que par des liens internes des ides auxquelles celles-ci
appartiennent (Cavaills 1947, 78).
Essais dune pense adjective par leffet de nouveaux savoirs.
Jean-Paul Sartre, Esquisse dune thorie des motions (Paris: Hermann, 1938).
Maurice Merleau-Ponty, La Structure du comportement (Paris: Presses
Universitaires de France, 1942).
Si dans ces annes de limmdiat avant-guerre, lactivit philosophique tait
entre dans sa phase exprimentale, Cavaills avait mis en jeu sa possibilit.