e Printed in India
AND U C KOTHYARI**
*/NSA Senior Scientist, Central Water and Power Research Station, Khadakwasla, Pune-4'11 024
Key W d' Scour in Alluvial Streams; Scour Estimation; Scour Prevention; Scour Protection Devices;
or s. Lacey-Inglis Equation; LaurSen-Toch Equation; Melville & Sutherland's Equation; Chitale's
Method; Kothyari-Garde-Ranga Raju's Method
Introduction
570
_/'/
~-~/~"
'I/'ls
PIER~
~!
'~
'
Q.~'\'"
J 1
J :
,/,)
I I /---.
.I~~
._-....:...-
UJ
""
.,..fII-
. $-c '.',
''( -At!
><-
_ HORSE - SHOE
VORTEX
"-
"
Shape
Cylindrical
1.0
Rectangular (//b=2 to 6)
1.1 to 1.25
0.93,0.79,0.70
1.0,0.86
1.0,0.80
0.45
60 apex angle
0.75
90 apex angle
0.88
0.94
1.00
571
7.5 0
crg= 1/2(ds/dso-t:dscld'6)
1.0
1.17
1.37
2.37
3.77
uniform material
.
Equilibrium scour depth for uniform
material of the same median size
... (2)
572
O"g
Cf g
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.40
2.75
3.3
7.8
Ka
1.0
0.90
0.75
0.50
0.38
0.25
0.160
0.08
Lacey-Inglis Equation
In the earlier part of this century Lacey analysed
the data from stable irrigation canals flowing
through loose noncohesive sandy material in IndoGangetic plain and obtained the following
equations for depth (or hydraulic radius) D LQ and
perimeter (or width) P .
D LQ=0.47(QIj) 1/3
... (3)
vfD.
.. , (5)
f=1.76Wl,
where K is the constant: Typical equation of this
category is U.S. Army Engineers' equation
'" (6)
19
Shen et al. have related .the clear water scour to
the pier Reynolds number Vb/von the assumption
that the strength of horse-shoe vortex is a function
of Vb/v. Here v is the kinematic viscosity of water.
They have proposed the following equation for
enveloping curve between d sc and Vb/v.
dsc=O.000223(Vb/v)O.619,
... (9)
Dse=KDLQ ,
(10)
... (7)
...(4)
573
d sem=2.5 b.
... (13)
-l.
2 _U 2 )]0,40
(b)0.75(D)0.16[(U
_
c
a -0.30
= 0.66 _
(tiysd / PI)
... (15)
(16)
dslb=O.88(bld).67(DId)4fJU -o30
(17)
... (14)
574
Field data
To assess the relative accuracy of the above
mentioned formulae, all available field data on
scour around bridge piers were compiled and
analysed. The Indian data on scour around pfer for
17 bridges in Indo-Gangetic plain, collected by
Inglis 14, were available. In addition, data collected
by RDSO (Research Designs and Standards
Organisation22.23.24,2s), Lucknow, on railway
bridges, and some data on scour at bridge piers on
Ganga canal were also used.
Scour data for 55 bridges in USA published by
Froehilch26, six bridges in New Zealand reported
by Melville27 , and for five bridges in Canada
reported by Neil 2s have also been used. Their
summary is given in Table IV.
In passing, it may be mentioned that not enough
information is available on scour measuring
equipment, even though the principles and broad
circuitry used in imported equipments are known.
There is an urgent need to fabricate the equipment
in Indiaand make it available to user agencies.
Analysis of Field Data for Scour Depth
Sediment
sizedmm
Flow depth
m
U
m/s
Pier diameter
orwidth m
Scour depth
below bed
level m
RDSO
0.43+-1.6+
1.46-19.11
N.A.
2.33-5.18
2.40-16.25
Inglis
~r-0.39+
4.4-18.3
N.A.
3-11.3
7.60*-35.7*
0.18-0.21
0.88-3.00
0.35-1.0
0.68-2.4
1.20-5.87
USA
0.25-90
0.58-19.5
0.46-3.67
0.24-13.0
0.30-7.80
New Zealand
94-230
2.7-3.8
0.87-4.27
0.92-2.4
2.75-4.88
0.50
4.0-7.5
N.A.
1.50
5.30*-9.8*
Canada
r-----------------------.
10 J
575
10'
LEGEND'
0
&II
:>
.
.
If
IE
&II
In
, -
10
'0
a A
U/~
0
fPo
-,
-,
1O
U. G CANAL DATA
+ -
GANGA AT MOkAMEH
OTHER DATA OF- R 0 SO
AA"I RIVER OAT ..
iNGLIS OAT.
A -
cP
1t
NEWZE"t.ANO
A -
o -
,.
10
10
d. ( COMPUTED)
IN m
U S DATA
10
10
Method
error band
30
SO
90
Lacey-Inglis
S9
85
100
Laursen-Toch
38
65
98
Melville-Sutherland
79
95
100
Kothyari et al.
86
96
100
f cohesive=F(1+ JC)
... (19)
576
3.125 m
2.142m
1.520 m
4.800 m
577
WS
ws
,-
DELTA WING
LIKE PLATE
Ys
/.
~/
Fig. 4 Slot in piers
~/
Fig. 5 Pier collar
578
>-
~r<----;-->
~s,
W.S
---
- -.......... ----+-
PIER fCOLLAR
-..,
.--....---....,,
+-I
,/1
Riprap Protection
Protecting the river bed and banks prone to
erosion by large size nonmovable stones (called
riprap) is an age old practice. Riprap blanket being
flexible, is not weakened by slight movement or
lowering of the bed. If 'to is the average shear stress
on the bed in Nlm 2 , the size of nonmovable stone
around the pier is given by 'tj120 m. If such stones
are placed on finer bed material, the fine material
underneath may get washed. For this reason proper
gradation of armour layer is needed. Otherwise a
filter needs to be provided underneath the riprap.
Limited experience about riprap protection
underlain by properly designed filter has indicated
that it is rather difficult to place relatively thin
layers of filter under deep water which is flowing.
Hence, efforts have been made to provide riprap
Protection without filters. This has been done by
47
.
Worman47 According to Worman a geometnc
standard deviation of 2 can be assumed for riprap
and d.IS can be determined. The thickness of riprap
T at the scour hole is given by
0'302 b
Concluding Remarks
Fig. 8 Pier group tested by He
579
D
DLQ
DLQ
Dsc
Dse
f
Fr
K
K.
Ka
~
T
To
V
VI
~c
y
a
Yf Ys
580
ReferCDces
I