10201026
Aiming to understand the formation mechanism of dioxins in the iron ore sintering process, dust samples
obtained from some windboxes of a commercial iron ore sintering plant have been characterized with a
powder X-ray diffraction (XRD), by the transmission electron microscope (TEM) equipped with an electron
energy loss spectroscopy (EELS), and by the temperature-programmed desorption (TPD) and temperatureprogrammed oxidation (TPO) techniques. The elemental and XRD analyses reveal that the content of the Cl
present in the samples ranges from 0.075 mass%-dry to 5.1 mass%-dry and tends to be higher at smaller
dust particles, and that some of the Cl exists as KCl with the average crystalline size between 40 nm and
50 nm. Dust samples also contain a significant amount of unburned carbon, and the smallest dust particles,
500 m m, show the highest C contents in many cases and consist partly of C, K, and Cl elements. The TPD
and TPO experiments exhibit that the dust samples have several types of oxygen functional forms on the
carbon surface, and the proportion of carboxyl and lactone/acid anhydride groups, which can be partly decomposed into CO2 and carbon active sites at 150 to 500C, tends to be larger at smaller dust particles. On
the basis of the above results, the formation mechanism of chlorinated organic compounds including dioxins is discussed in term of interactions among HCl (and/or Cl2), metallic chlorides, and carbon active sites.
KEY WORDS: iron ore sintering; windbox; dust; metallic chlorides; unburned carbon; surface oxygen complexes.
1.
Introduction
2.
Experimental
Fig. 1.
Fig. 2.
3.
3.1.
2006 ISIJ
Fig. 3.
(1) are 36 kJ/mol at 50C and 6 kJ/mol at 500C, indicating significant driving forces for Cl2 formation in the
temperature region (Fig. 1) of the present WB. According
to X-ray absorption near edge structure spectra of cokes, on
the other hand, it has been reported that K present in cokes
derived from bituminous coals exists mainly as amorphous
or glassy K-containing aluminosilicates, for example, leucite
(KAlSi2O6).17,18) It might thus be reasonable to see that
the KCl identified by XRD is formed through secondary
reactions of HCl and/or Cl2 with K2CO3 (Table 2) and
KAlSi2O6 (Eqs. (2)(5)).
K2CO32HCl2KClCO2H2O...............(2)
2KAlSi2O62HCl2KClAl2O34SiO2H2O....(3)
K2CO3Cl2CO2KCl2CO2 ................(4)
2KAlSi2O6Cl2CO2KClAl2O34SiO2CO2
...........................................(5)
These reactions are favorable thermodynamically under the
temperature conditions (Fig. 1) of the present WB, because
DG values for Eqs. (2)(5) at 50500C are in the range of
17 204 kJ/mol.
The TEM photograph of the WB18-F sample is shown in
Fig. 4, and the result by the EELS analysis is provided in
Fig. 5. As expected from the results in Tables 1, 2, and
1022
Fig. 4.
Fig. 6.
Fig. 5.
2006 ISIJ
CO:
Carbon contents in dust samples used and yields of CO2 and CO evolved during TPD and TPO runs.
It is evident in Fig. 6 and Table 3 that the TPD/TPO behavior of unburned carbon depends strongly on the type of the
dust. It is reasonable to suppose that such differences can
affect de novo synthesis of organic chlorides including
dioxins, because the unburned carbon is the dominant carbon-source of chlorinated aromatic species.16)
3.3. Structures of Unburned Carbon
The different rates and yields of CO2 and CO observed in
the TPD/TPO experiments of several dust samples may
originate from the differences in surface oxygen complexes
on the carbon present in these samples. According to earlier
studies on surface functionalities of coal chars and carbons
using the TPD technique,1923) CO2 evolved arises mainly
from decomposition reactions of carboxyl groups, lactone/
acid anhydride groups, and inherently-present CaCO3. In
order to examine the sources of CO2 evolved in the present
TPD process, the profiles for the CO2 formation observed
were curve-fitted with the least-squares method using
Gaussian peak shapes. In this method, the CO2 peak temperature and full width at half maximum of each compound
were assumed at 35010C and 20010C for carboxyl
groups,20) 62010C and 20010C for lactone/acid anhydride groups,22) and 65010C and 6010C for CaCO3,24)
respectively. The typical deconvolution profiles for the
WB9-F, WB9-M, and WB9-C are illustrated in Fig. 7. Very
good curve resolution was obtained, and the reproducibility
fell within 3 % in every case when the curve-fitting analysis was repeated at least twice. As seen in Fig. 7, 8590 %
of the CO2 evolved from the WB9 arose from decomposition reactions of both lactone/acid anhydride groups and
CaCO3, almost independently of the size of the dust. The
sources of the CO2 observed above 820C are not clear at
present, but the CO2 evolution might be caused by the
catalysis of some minerals present in the dust samples. This
point should be clarified in the future work.
With regard to CO released during TPD, it has been
widely accepted that the CO originates mostly from ketone,
ether, and phenolic groups.21,23) Further, CO2 and CO
2006 ISIJ
Fig. 7.
Deconvolution of the rate profiles for CO2 formation observed in the TPD process of WB9 samples.
Fig. 8.
by the interaction between K2CO3 (Table 2) and carbon active sites (C( )) to provide Cl-containing intermediates, for
example, COKClH, which may subsequently
undergo decomposition reactions into chemisorbed HCl
species (C(HCl)), covalent CCl bonds (C(Cl), and/or KCl.
The presence of these species was speculated by the X-ray
photoelectron spectroscopy spectra of activated carbon (K,
0.5 mass%-dry) treated with HCl at 500C.30) The C(HCl)
and C(Cl) species, if present actually, may be transformed
to dioxins and organic chlorides by the catalytic effect of
some minerals.
It has been reported that metallic chlorides present in unburned carbon work efficiently as not only the Cl-sources
but also the catalysts (or promoter materials) for de novo
synthesis.913) The catalysis of dioxins formation by metallic chlorides is thus considered as another possibility.
According to earlier work, the Cu element (Table 1) determined by the elemental analysis is probably present as the
chloride and oxide forms.31) It is therefore possible that
fine-particles of KCl and copper chlorides might react
with C( ) to form COKClH and COCu
ClH intermediates, which may subsequently decompose
into provide organic chlorine compounds including dioxins.
However, the contribution of this route to dioxins formation
is still uncertain, because KCl and CuCl are rather stable
thermodynamically at 150500C where de novo synthesis
proceeds considerably.
Since both the contents of the C, K, Cu, and Cl present in
the dust samples examined (Tables 1 and 3) and the proportion of surface oxygen complexes on the unburned carbon
(Fig. 8) tend to be lager at smaller dust particles, dioxins
formation may proceed significantly at fine dust particles
than at the coarse ones. To clarify de novo synthesis mechanisms in detail should be the subject of future study.
carbon active sites (that is, edge carbon).26) When the complexes and active sites are designated as C(OO) (and/or
C(O)) and C( ), respectively, decomposition reactions of
the former species can be expressed as follows:
C(OO)C( )CO2...........................(6)
C(O)C( )CO.............................(7)
It has been reported that the reactivity of carbon active sites
is about 1001 000 times that of carbon atoms in condensed
aromatic structures, that is, basal plane carbon.26) It may
thus be reasonable to see that the C( ) derived from carboxyl and lactone/acid anhydride groups, which are decomposed under the present WBs temperature conditions (Figs.
1 and 7) that are almost the same as the temperature region
for de novo synthesis, is the active carbon site for the formation of dioxins and organic chlorine compounds.
4.
Conclusions
3.4.
2006 ISIJ
Acknowledgment
4)
5)
6)
7)
8)
9)
10)
11)
12)
13)
14)
2006 ISIJ
1026