Resources
Resources and the Environment
Jessica Coote - 27 March 2015
1.0 Introduction
1.1 Aim of Report
With tourism contributing 4.5 Billion Australian Dollars per annum to the Gold
Coast City Council, sustaining the aesthetic beauty of the coastline has become a key
aspect of sustaining Gold Coast beaches (Mullins, 2015). However, beach and sea
processes are having a detrimental effect on any attempt to pursue greater opportunities
in the tourism industry. As part of the Ocean Beaches Strategy, the City of the Gold Coast
is developing the Palm Beach Shoreline Project- this comprehensive strategy aims to
provide permanent protection of the the foreshore at Palm Beach.
Figure 1
1.2 Location
Palm Beach is an iconic part of the Gold Coast Shoreline. The 3.8 kilometre stretch of
beach located on the southern Gold Coast, is an iconic part of the East Australian Coast,
but is susceptible to extreme beach erosion. A popular tourist destination, Palm Beach is
Figure 2
(Google Images)
Population
1954
660
1961
1491
1986
12,552
2001
13,943
2006
13,494
2011
13,956
(QLD Places)
Table of Contents
Managing Coastal Resources
Resources and the Environment
1
1
1.0 Introduction
1.2 Location
Table of Contents
List of Figures
2.0 Analysis
10
13
13
14
4.0 Conclusion
15
4.1 Recommendation
16
4.2 Justification
16
16
List of Figures
Figure 1
Figure 2
Figure 3
Figure 4
Figure 5
Figure 6
Figure 7
Figure 8
Figure 9
Figure 10
(Fieldwork Photo,2015)
(Google Images,2015)
(Fieldwork Photo,2015)
(Fieldwork Sketch,2015)
(BOM, 2013)
(Australian Government, 2001)
(USA Geological Survey, 2000)
(Fieldwork Data,2015)
(Fieldwork Photo,2015)
(Worldyword,2011)
2.0 Analysis
MANAGING COASTAL RESOURCES - JESSICA COOTE
At Palm Beach the following information was used to create a transect of the beach:
The distance from the back of the beach to the foreshore was 42 metres.
The direction of the waves on the date of fieldwork was West South West. Therefore the
prevailing wind was of a South West direction during fieldwork.
Using a clinometer, the angle of the slope of the beach is -6 degrees.
Figure 4
(Fieldwork photo)
As demonstrated in the above transect, there is clear evidence of erosion along the
coastline. This shows clearly the immediate risk Palm Beach is of greater storm damage
which, by turn, threatens the Gold Coast.
Storm damage on Palm Beach has resulted in severe erosion on the foreshore, destroying
houses along the front part of the beach. Fieldwork photographs shows evidence of
erosion on the front line of the houses on Palm Beach.
Economically, storm damage can cost residents and local councils millions of dollars of
repair. Cyclone Dinah of 1967 culminated an estimated
total financial cost of $250 Million at todays rate (W,
Figure 5
CYCLONE DINAH
2002). Severe erosion impacted houses and businesses
along the Queensland Coast
(BOM, 2013)
Socially, beaches provide an area of recreation and aesthetic beauty. Images of white sand
and crystal oceans are replaced by rubbish, plants and general detritus piled on the
coastline after storms. In 1967, several severe tropical cyclones collided with the Gold
Coast shoreline- including TC Dinah, Barbara, Dulcie, Elaine and Glenda. 8 million cubic
metres of sand was eroded from the beaches and threatened the backing Gold Coast
roads, houses and hotels (Coastal watch, 2008).The cyclones of 1967 did bring home to
people the vulnerability of this coast unless some measures were taken to improve what
was here in the way of protection and development (Coast, 2013). Generally most
residents have a positive attitude towards the protection of beaches and coasts in their
immediate area. Citizens of the Gold Coast have a
good understanding of coastal processes- in
PALM BEACH 1967
Figure 6
particular erosion and the effect it may/does
have- however some are unwilling to provide
their own services and money to help protect the
beaches; they view it as a force of nature that
should not be stopped.
Because many residences and local businesses are
situated on the front line of the beach, this has
created an enhanced environment for erosion to
(BOM,2015)
occur.
In relation to the immediate threat to Palm Beach,
storm damage has had a great impact on the houses and beaches of the southern Gold
Coast. Shown in Figure 5, Palm Beach suffered severe erosion during the tropical cyclones
of 1967. This coastal damage has been encouraged by ongoing recreational use and the
growing population of coastal apartments and residences along the Palm Beach coastline.
FLORIDA MANAGEMENT
10
In terms of Palm Beach specifically, the local council has had a mixed response in regards
to the idea of a seawall and sand replenishment on their beach- some arguing that the wall
will provide great and successful protection to the front line of houses- others arguing that
it will destroy the local and relaxed nature of the healthy beach environment.
Figure 8
11
Management strategy
What is it
Other Information
Groynes
!
Sea Wall
Typically concrete
structures, sea walls are
built at the back of
beaches to offer
protection from large
waves.
Construction of a sea
wall at Broadbeach
began in February 2015
(Queensland
Government, 2015).
Artificial Reef
An artificial reed is a
man-made structure,
built to promote marine
life , control erosion or
improve surfing.
Beach Nourishment
Beach nourishment
involves moving sand
from one location to
another to create a larger
volume of sand to be
moved during storms,
therefore protecting
property behind the
beach.
Many experts suggest that the beaches of the Gold Coast are the basis of the Tourist
industry, and that is a good enough reason for councils to continue preserving, managing
and maintaining them. Adopted in 2010, the Gold Coast Shoreline Management Plan
(GCSMP) identified Palm Beach as requiring priority action to protect local public and
private infrastructure from storm surge and erosion (Australian tenders). In late 2014 it
was decided that the Plan would adopt the strategy of Beach Replenishment stabilised by
a continuous seawall. This plan will be evaluated in Section 3.1.
12
Figure 9
SAND BY-PASS
(Fieldwork photo)
13
14
implemented at Narrowneck on the Gold Coast was a successful project in terms of both
widening the beach (by 40metres over a decade) and reducing the power and impact of
harsh waves. Promoting a clearer break of the waves would, as stated above, encourage
more constructive waves rather than destructive ones; consequently building up the beach
with sediment. The lack of maintenance needed is also a largely positive aspect. Although
economically compared to the first solution of a sea wall and beach replenishment they
are quite similar, the first stated possible solution requires constant preservation and
conservation for it to protect the beach to its fullest potential. The level of protection the
reef would offer Palm Beach would take years to be demonstrated and it would therefore
be unclear to measure an immediate success rate. This, of course, is one of the main
negatives of the solution for an artificial reef; another negative being that initially and
during the construction process, the surfing capabilities of the beach would be disruptedthis possibly causing distress to the local Gold Coast surfing community of Palm Beach.
4.0 Conclusion
15
In conclusion, Palm Beach requires priority action to protect local public and private
infrastructure from storm surge and erosion.
4.1 Recommendation
The original strategy of Beach replenishment stabilised by a continuous seawall is not, in
fact, the right strategy to implement. The alternative solution of implementing an artificial
reef off the coast of Palm Beach satisfies the chosen criteria to a higher standard, and it
would therefore be logical to implement this strategy instead. In terms of better achieving
the first aim of the Palm Beach Shoreline Project- to reduce the vulnerability of the beach
and beachfront development to storm damage, an artificial reef would work best.
4.2 Justification
The conservation of local beach communities on the Gold Coast is of key importance
when considering manners of protection from storm damage. The preservation of the
beach and beachfront development at Palm Beach is the initial stage of the Shoreline
Project on the Gold Coast, in addition to protecting, and if practical, enhancing the beach
amenity for the community, providing a sustainable, cost effective and integrated solution,
and avoid or mitigate environmental and social impacts. In conclusion, Palm Beach
requires priority action to protect local public and private infrastructure from storm surge
and erosion. An artificial reef will help armour the beach from storm and weather
destruction. Extensive digital imagery, hydrographic survey and observational monitoring
shows that the reef implemented at Narrowneck on the Gold Coast was a successful
project in terms of both widening the beach (by 40metres over a decade) and reducing the
power and impact of harsh waves. It is evident that if the same strategy be implemented
on Palm Beach, the coastline and community would react positively and the resulting
environmental protection caused by the artificial reef would be powerfully conclusive and
decisive.
An artifical reef is a categorically better strategy than the original plan of a seawall and
sand replenishment. From a plan which would require a large ongoing cost, little local
community support, major disruption to coastal processes and only limited protection
from storm damage, in comparison to a smaller cost, more public approval, less
environment damage and greater protection from storm damage; an artificial reef is the
right strategy to implement at Palm Beach.
16
17
18