/^^f^%\
NUMBER 4
*
CONTENT^
A mv
* f- %
SPECIAL ISSUE
ciJ
f'
#37
Generating Functions
Explicit Determination of the Perron
Matrices in Periodic Algorithms of
the Perron-Jacobi Type with Application
to Generalized Fibonacci Numbers
with Time Impulses
. . . . . . .
L. Carlitz 359
NOVEMBER
1969
EDITORIAL
H. L . A l d e r
M a r j o r i e Bicknell
John L. Brown s J r .
B r o t h e r A. B r o u s s e a u
L. C a r l i t z
H. W. E v e s
H. W. Gould
A. P . Hillman
V. E . Hoggatt, J r .
BOARD
Donald E . Knuth
George L e d i n , J r .
D. A. Lind
C. T. Long
Leo M o s e r
I. D. Ruggles
M. N. S. Swamy
D. E . T h o r o
OF
C h a r l e s H. King
L. H. Lange
J a m e s Maxwell
S i s t e r M. DeSales McNabb
C. D. Olds
D. W. Robinson
A z r i e l Rosi
John E . Vinson
Lloyd W a l k e r
C h a r l e s H. Wall
The California M a t h e m a t i c s Council
Let n(a,b) and N(a,b) be the number of divisions needed in finding the
greatest common divisor of positive integers a,b using the Euclidean algorithm and the least absolute value algorithm, respectively.
In addition to
showing some properties of periodicity of n(a,b) and N(a,b), the paper gives
a proof of the following theorems:
Theorem 1.
1,
(a,b)
f k + 2 ) where it =
1, f2 = 1 and f _,Q = f ^ + f , n = 1, 2, 3, .
*
n+2
n+1 n
Theorem 2. If N(a,b) = k > 1, then a + b > x, - and the pair (a,b)
with smallest sum such that N(a,b) = k is the pair (x, , x,
xj = 1, x2 = 2 and x, = 2x. - + x.
2,
k = 3,4,- .
+ x
i )> where
k-3
r
k-2
k - l rk-2
=
k-l
k k-l
b = f2,
a + b = f3 = 2 .
tfk+1^+2*)-
Since
337
338
+ b
= f k+l
+ f
[Nov.
k+2 = f k + 3 '
n(a + mi,
m = 0, 1, 2,
k = 1, 2, 3, .
This is evident since the first division would be (2a + b) = l(a + b) + a and
n(a,a + b) = n(a,b) = k.
more than n(i, a + mi) = n(i,a). The periodicity is evident in the table of
values of n(a,b) for a < b < 2a.
a = 1
2
1
12
12 3
12 2 3
12 3 4 3
12 2 2 3 3
1233443
12242533
123234343
10
1223324433
11
12
12344345543
122224253333
13
1233353464443
14
15
12
243432454533
1 2 3 2 4 2 3 3 4 4 3 5
3 43
1969]
339
a = q 2 r! r 2
r
k-3
r
k-2
k-lrk-2
=
k-l
k k-l
where
0
k-2 "
r.+1< 3 r . - r . + 1 ,
i =
V . k - 1 ,
2x
k-l
+ X
k-2
and
kn-l
k-l
Then
a + b = 2x k + x k - 1 = x k + 1
This completes the proof of the theorem.
Corollary 2, If a + b < x. x , then N(a,b) < k for k > 1.
Figure 2 exhibits the periodicity (for i fixed):
(2)
-.
d4U
(3)
N ( a , a + i) = N ( a , 2 a - i),
a = 1
'
1969
1 < i < a - 1.
2 2
2 2 2
2 3 3 2
2 2 2 2 2
2 3 3 3 3 2
2 2 3 2 3 2 2
2 3 2 3 3 2 3 2
10
2 2 3 3 2 3 3 2 2
11
2 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 2
12
2 2 2 2 4 2 4 2 2 2 2
13
2 3 3 3 4 3 3 4 3 3 3 2
14
2 2 3 3 3 3 2 3 3 3 3 2 2
15
2 3 2 3 2 3 3 3 3 2 3 2 3 2
16
2 2 3 2 3 2 4 2 4 2 3 2 3 2 2
17
2 3 3 3 4 3 4 3 3 4 3 4 3 3 2 2
18
2 2 2 3 4 2 4 2 2 2 4 2 4 3 2 2 2
19
2 3 3 3 3 3 4 4 3 3 4 4 3 3 3 3 3 2
20
2 2 3 2 2 3 3 3 4 2 4 3 3 3 2 2 3 2 2
21
2 3
22
2 2 3 3 4 2 3 3 4 3 2 3 4 3 3 2 4 3 3 2 2
23
Nov
23 3
Fig. 2
2 3 3 3 2 4 3 3 3 3 4 2 3 3 3 2 3 2
3 4 3 4 3 4 4 3 3 4 4 3 4 3 4 3 3 3 2
N(a,b)
for
b = a + 1, , 2a - 1
V. C. H a r r i s in
s h o r t e n i n g the p r o o f s .
REFERENCES
1.
2.
. . +++
1. INTRODUCTION
A sequence of generalized Fibonacci numbers u(n; p,q) which can be interpreted as sums along diagonals in Pascal* s triangle appear in papers by
Harris and Styles [1], [2].
coefficient
n =91,2,3,** * Y"Hr.
1 1
1 2
1
3
1
3
1 3 6 7 6
1 4 10 16 19
16
1
10
1 5 15 30 45
51
45
30 15
column. Then,
let
GQ
- 11
->
Gj -
-,
(1 - x) 2
G2
(1 - x) 3
The general
342
[Nov.
G ^ = ., X
(G _,, + G ) .
n+2
1 - x
n+1
n
(1)
Let
G = E Gn = E u(n; 0,l)x n
n=0
n=0
The sum G in the general case will have for the coefficient of x
the number
u(n; p,q), which, as applied to the trinomial triangle, will be the sum of the
term in the left column and the n
sequence of sums whose terms lie on particular diagonals of the trinomial t r i angle. To find G, for p = 0 and q = 1, we use the method of Polya [3]
and the recurrence relation (1). Let S be the sum of the first n terms of
n
G.
G2 = T 4 I E ( G I
+ GO)
G3 = j 4 ^ ( G 2 + Gi)
Gn+1
_L- = 1., X- x (Gn + G n-1
-)
Gn+2
-L-o = T^
_,- + Gn )
1 - x (Gn+1
Summing vertically,
+ G
n+2
+ G
n+1 " *
" <h = T T x
(S
+G + G
+ G
n+1 "
+ S
n>
r > 2, so that
1969]
n-*
1-3K^
(1__x)2j
( 1 - X ) 2
343
1 - 3x '
1 - 3x
In
is u(n; 0,1) = 3 .
Here
Gj = x p + 1 / ( l - x)2
and
with recurrence
G*
= T^ (xP G* - + x 2 p G* ) .
n+2
1 - x
n+1
n
(2)
\\L
i -x
i - xy
+
Since, again,
lim^G
G* =
I^ E
i - xj
" ^
n+1 -
(1 - x) 2
n+2
r > 2, so that
lim S*
=
^ n ' 1 - x - xp+1 - x2p+1
'
1, 1, 2, 4, 7, 13, 24, , where each term after the third is the sum of the
344
-.
[Nov.
cation, the reader is invited in each case to perform the indicated division.
Now, if we let q = 2, then we must deal with every other term of the
column generator recurrence relation.
(3)
2n+4 = ( ( 7 ^ + v ^ r ^ 2 - -^' 2
^5-'
i^
n I1 ' TT^b
(1 - X)
where R
x2
X^
\ =G
Go/l1 - ^ "
TrH;)
T^T, \ )+ 2 + R n
(1 - X) J = \I ~(1-X)2/
:
is a term involving G ?
nUffio
lim S
" ^
n = >
* and G~
r f c A
?.
lx' <
= '
= G = L^M
1 - 4x + 3x2
Again, since
= V
1/r
'
U ( n; 0 ,2)x
> 2>
n t- 0
This gives us a generating function for sums of alternate terms of rows in the
trinomial triangle.
Let p = 1 and q = 2 and return to G0 = 1/(1 - x ) , G2 = x 2 /(l - x) 2 ,
and, from recurrence (3),
,
G*
2n+4
'
K.
= x /_JE1_
" ~ Ul~Z~tf
++
x x
^ T2x
W \. -A- - JU.
G;_
^ ^/G2n+2 " 7 7 ^ 2 -to
1969]
345
1=0
L _ (2x - x 2 )x
s*
^J_xj\
(1-x)2
(1-x)2/
S*/
n
V
2 X
-X2+X
(1 - x) 2
*_
G*=
3 + X 4
U
/
_ x(2x - x 2 ) \
G*L
"V
(1 - X )2
G|
G* , and G* , . , so that
^
R = 0,
2n+2
2n+4
n-> n
(1 - 2x + X 2 - 2x2 + x 3
+X
2 ) / ( 1 _ x)3
+ R
lim 0S*w _=
1 - 2x + x J
*""
n
*->*
(i _ X )(i - 2x - x2 + x 3 + x 4 )
which simplifies to
1 - x - x^
= u(n; l,2)x n .
2
3
4
1 - 2x - x + x + x
n=0
Returning now to the more general case, we find the generating function for the
numbers u(n; p,2). Using the recurrence relation (3), but allowing for moving up p rows in the triangle, and then summing vertically as before yields
s
n
(2x - x 2 )x p
(1 - x)2
x2 x 2 p \ _
(1-x)2/
1
1
'
x p (2x - x 2 )\
L
x
"
(1 - x) 2
xp+1
+
+ R ,
n
(1 - x)
346
where again
_^
lim _ n
n^ n ~ G'
[Nov.
(1 - 2x + x 2 * x p + 2 - x p + 1 ) / ( l - x)
(1 - x) - 2xP + 1
+ XP
+2
+ x2P+2
P+l
-
X^
= "
72
p + l ^ p + 2 , 2p + 2
(1 - xr - 2x^
+ x^
+ x ^
n\
Y^
E u(n;P)2)x
n=0
G
=
G
3(n + 2)
(1
"
_ x)3
x
G
+
3(n + 1)
(1 _
x)3
G
3n
3x2 - 2x3
x3
(1 - x) 3
(1 - x)3
1
1
- * \
_ 3x2 - 2 x 3 \
'
(1-x)3/
+
2x2
x3
(1 - x)
and
u(n; 0,3)x
n=0
"
6X
= 1 + 2^
n=0
In fact,
YJ u(n; p,3)x n =
n=0
1 - 2x + x2 - x P + 2
(1 - x) 3 - 3 X P +2 + 2xP + 3 - x 2 P + 3
+ R ,
1969]
347
1 3
6 10 12 12 10
1 4 10 20 31 40 44 40 31 20 10 4 1
and use the methods of the preceding section, the expressions given below can
be derived without undue difficulty.
G , o =n+3
1 - x
(G , 0 + G ,.. + G )
n+2
n+1
n
where
G0 = 1/(1 - x), Gi = x / ( l - x) 2 ,
G2 = x / ( l - x) 3 ,
G4 = (3x2 - 3x3 + x 4 ) / ( l - x) 5
G3 = x / ( l - x) 4 ,
It is easy to find that u(n; 0,1) = 4 n and u(n; 1,1) = Q n+1 > where Q n is the
quadrinacci number given by 1, 1, 2, 4, 8, 15, 29, , where each term
after the fourth is the sum of the preceding four terms (see [4]).
ating function for Q
The gener-
is 1/(1 - x - x - x - x ) , and
J ] u(n; p,l)x n =
n=0
'
2(n+3)
(1
__
"5T
"V*
x)2
2(n+2)
(1
x)2
"V"
2(n+1)
(1
x)2
2n '
348
[Nov.
one finds
00
00
,
1 - 2x
i , v o2n-l x n
<r\ n
u(n; A0,2)x
= _ , = 1 + 2-, 2
J
n=0
"
n=l
u(n; l 9 2 ) x n
n=0
1 - x - x2
1 - 2x - x2 + x 3 - x 4 - x 5 ;
u(n;p,2)xn =
1 - x - x*
n=0
(1 - x) - 2xP + 1 + xP + 2 - x 2 P + 2 - x 3 P + 2
Also, from
r
3(n+3)
_ 3x - 3x2 + x 3 ^
3x2 - x 3 ^,
3
3(n+2)
(1 - x)
" (i . x) 3 3(n+l)
(1
x3
__ x ) 3
3n '
one finds
/ ^ o\ n
n=0 u(n; 0,3)x
1 - 3x
1 - 5x + 4x2
If one continues in a similar way, the analogous results for the pentanomial becomes u(n; 0,1) = 5 ;
] u(n; p , l ) x n =
n=0
1 - x -
XP
+1
1
te
u(n; 0,2)x n =
~
n=0
1 - 6x + 5x2
22 u (n; p ,2)x
n=0
(1 - x r - 2xr
1 - x - xP+1 - x 2 ? + 1
2
+ x^
- 2x ^
+ x ^
+x ^
+x^
1969]
349
1-x-x1^
oo
- x
- x
- x ^
- x
/
1 - 3x
oX n
u(n; n0,2)x
= t _ 6x I
E
n=0
<*>
rib ^ ^
P,2)XQ =
_ p+1
2p+l
(1 -x)2 - 2xP + 1 + xP +2 ~- X 2x 2 P +1 + x 2 P + 2 - x 3 P + 2 - x 4 ? + 2 - x 5 P + 2
ri + r 2 = P k l l - x ' 1 - x I'
given by P 0 = 2, Pj = x / ( l - x),
I 1 - XJ
1 - X*
and satisfying
P
k+2
(P
1 - x
k+l
k)
Now, the recurrence relation for the column generators for the trinomial case
is (let q = k)
(n+2)k "
k G (n+l)k
( 1} +
"
t-r
(r^)
nk
350
[Nov.
leading to
y lX k+l 2p k
%+2)k "
^k (n+l)k
{1
,k
%k
4-V-^FH
where
lim R
n>o
= 0, | x | < l / r ,
(1 - P , x p ) + G* + R ,
k
k
n
r > 2.
Hence,
/ ( l - x) k - xPp, (1 - x) k + ( - l ) k x 2 p + k
1 ^
)-i4^<1-Vp+rfGk
[k/2]
P
|^
(k - 2i)I i! " I 1 - xf
Since G
is the generating function for the numbers u(n; p,k), we have resolved our
problem for the trinomial triangle. Harris and Styles [1] have solved the binomial case by summing diagonals of Pascal*s triangle.
given series convergents for u(n; p , l ) for the trinomial and quadrinomial
cases. We now move on to the solution of the general case for the array of
coefficients formed from polynomials of n terms.
1969]
351
sequence.
If
(G
n+2 " T ^
n+l
n)
then
(n+2)q = P^ G (n + l)q
^ ^
(j^f
nq
where
Pl (0)
= 2,
P l (l)
= x / ( l - x)j
and
Pi(m + 2) =
(pi(m + 1) + pj(m))
352
__2L
1 - x
1 - x
[Nov.
"
..
(G . n + G , - + G )
1 - x
n+2
n+1
n
where
G
+ p
3 ( q ) G nq '
Pl(l)
= p 3 (l) = -p 2 (l) = - ^
Now,
p2(k) = (p2i(k) -
P3(W =
Next,
Pl(o)
= 3,
P I (D
P l (2k))/2
(-j
= x/d - x),
^k
Pl(2)
= (T4IE)2
r?2x_x
and
Pi(m + 3) = y-~ ( Pl (m + 2) +
P l (m
+ 1) + p^m))
1969]
353
Notice that, since our values for Pi(q), p 2 (qh and p.(q) are defined sequentially and since moving up p rows can be adjusted by multiplying by x p , we
can solve the quadrinomial case. To derive u(n; p,q), we can use (G* =
leading to
where
n (n) -
P2W -
q/3
V*
_ .
n=0
} A,
3]
^
L J Q(q - m - 2k - 1)1
V
V
l<f- 2n - 3k)Im!k!
k=0
n=0
^
0*3
q(q - m - 2k V
qiq - ni -
^K
/
x
\ ^ \ 1 - xl
\
/
2 k
xX \qI~k, , ^q-m-Sk
-y
I T1 -^ x I ( _ 1 )
- 1)?
i ; : m. II
n=0
^
2 , 7Zrr2R
- 3k)!m!k!
/ x
\ q , [x] the greatest integer
p3(q) = [=I
V
/
function-
we actually could write an explicit formula for G5 the generating function for
the numbers u(n; p,q) for the quadrinomial case.
For the pentanomial case, we would go to
n+4
1 - x
v<G_ Q
n+3
+ G_. + G_, + G ) ,
n+2
n+1
n'
354
[Nov.
Then we need
Pl(0) = 4,
Pl(l)
= x / ( l - x),
Pl (2)
= (2x - x 2 ) / ( l - x) 2 ,
and
Pl(n
+ 4) = ~ ^
( Pl (n + 3) +
P l (n
p2(k) = (pf(k) -
+ 2) +
P l (2k))/2
P l (n
+ 1) +
Pl (n)
);
p4(k) = ( - l ) k '
The relationship
G
(n + 4)q =
xP
G* = x P G.
^VL
Pi ( l ) G ( n + 3) q -
x2P
P2^)G(n+2)q
^ ^ ( n + D q "^ G , , ,
'VI
tion for u(n; p,q) for the pentanomial case, although it would be a messy computation. However, if one notes some of the relationships between the pi(k)
for the polynomials
y
_ j - ^ (y
+y
+ - - + y + l) = o
1969]
355
for different values of n, much of the labor is taken out of the computation.
The expressions Pi(k) a r e identical for the polynomial with n terms and the
polynomial with (n - 1) terms for k = 1, 2, 3, , n - 2; p^O) = n for all
cases; and
Pitm + n - 1) = =--1 V
1
x
Pitm + m - i) I
" \6
In fact,
Pl (k)
for k = l , 2, , n - l
= --r - 1
(1 - xf
be derived sequentially for any value of k for the polynomial with n terms
given by
n-1
x
. n-2 ,
,
, -v
A
y
- T~^~x ( y
+ + y + i) = o .
We can sequentially generate all sums of powers of the roots of any polynomial
because we can get the proper starting values sequentially as well as find higher
powers sequentially.
Now, it is well known that, given all the sums of the powers of the roots,
Pl(0), Pi(l) Pi(2),
8e
(See [ 7 ] ,
Pm(k> =
(-D
=m
356
[Nov.
Also, the generating functions for the coefficients arising in the expansion of
the n-nomial (1 + x + x2 + + xn~" )
xV(l - x )
i+1
, i = 0 , 1 , 2 , - , n - 1, G n = ((1 - xf'1
G n + 1 = x / ( l - x) (Gn + G n _ 1 + + G2 + Gt + G 0 ) .
- l)/(l - x)n+1,
and
ip
.,-
W n - l ) q " .
Pi ( q ) G *m+n-l-i)
and using the methods of this paper, the generating function for the numbers
u(n; p,q) could be derived.
In [11] it was promised a proof that, for p = 1,
u(n;p,l)x n =
- j
g-j
n=0
1 - x - xF
- x F
- - x v
for the general r-nomial triangle induced by the expansion
(1 + x + x2 + + x*""1)
This follows from the definition.
tflffrn
,F
n = 0,1,2,3,--- .
take sums by starting on the left edge and jumping up p and over 1 entry r e peatedly until out of the triangle. Thus,
Tntr-iyi
1
u(n;p,l) =
E
k i J(n (
k=0
kp)
where
(1 + x + x2 + + x r *
The r-nomial coefficient
+ X
P+X2P
...
n(r-l) ( >
n^r-lj
-1) =
i-x(i
- nn
+x
hp.
3
Crow
) r and j
Thus
P(r-1))
fn(r-m
LP^-hn
kp(
k
(Continued on p. 393 .)
column of
\ r^
|xn
1969]
357
+
CO
X!
"*
S3
't-4
1 XI
1
CO
CM
i XI
XI
i-i
+^ . 1
X\
1 XI
XI
LO
XI
CO
XI| %
+
i!
+
to
rH
rH
rH
X!
X!
41
1 <M
X!
rH
B
<
CO
<tt
o
o
2p+l
^X!
ft
o .3.
rH
XI
1
o &
u
CM
[CO
|rH
XI
SXI
rH
XI
+
a
XIi
CO
XI
rH
x
1
rH
rH
X!
rH
X!
r-i
rH+
+
' 1 ac*
XI
rH
rH
*
PH
rT
.3
S
w S
+
a
CM
XI
X!
(M
1 1
H
rH
rH
XI
I
XI
rH
rH
XI
X!
rH
XI
XI
1
rH
+
XI
rH
W
XI1
fc
I
CM
XI
+ *x
X!
rH
CO
XI
XI
fco
+
rHj
XI
CO
XI
XI
1
CO
.in.! ^XIr
1
'
rH
1 -""
O1
1
CM
XI
rH
rH
CO
XI
CO
rH
+
aCO
XI
<M+
rHfrH
XI
rH
i
CM
1I 1
CO
XI
CM
oJ?
(M CO
CO
+ +a
a X!
X!
f
j
XI
CO
II
jz;
XI
+
+ %\ aXI
co
CM
<M
X!
XI
CO
CD
XI
CO
1
rH
31
q-1
X!
XI
u*
i
rH
X
I
rH
.<
0*
rH
cT
3
13"
>5
1?
Is
ex?
CO
CO
o
3
*7
a
358
Nov. 1969
I?
LO
X
i
|(NI
+
&
LO
o
X
m
<
TH
s
w
o
CD
X
1
JH
SI
+
1
rH
+
^.X
Ic<i
P.
X
\t
+
+
X
I
EH
P
Pn
O
1^
X
CO
ILO
- 1
I
X
I
CD
w
w
+
+ +
a. | X
X
x +
+
i
CO
+
X
X *"*
LO
X
I
+
i
X
X
I
X
I
X
X
LO
C<!
CD
X
co
+
x
+
N
X
I
CM
C\!
CO
<M
I
I
Vb
la
a
a
X
I
CO
C\J
C
en
X
I
PH
+a.
'|(NI
X
1 1
+
+
<M
X
TH
r-\
TH
CNI
CO
Si
X
I
rH
*x
CO
urs
|X
CD
&
^H
x
I
C<!
a
3
^
3
15
CO
3
S3
Is
ii
s
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
L. CARLITZ
Duke University, Durham, North Carolina
1. INTRODUCTION
With an arbitrary sequence of (complex) numbers (a i = { a 0 , a i , a 2 , ' y
we associate the (formal) power series
a(x) = a x 11 .
n=0
(1.1)
b(x) = E b x11
n=0
by means of
f1 a }J + fl b }} = fl c )J ,
n
n
n
c = a + b (n = 0,1,2,- ) ;
n
n
n
then clearly
&)
Yl
c x
n=0
= a x +
^)
b(x)
360
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov.
by means of
(1.2)
pn = E a k b n _ k
k=0
01 = 0 . 1 . 2 . . . . ) .
00
(1.3)
A(x) -
a x n /n!
n=0 n
k ? 0 ( k ) *k Vk;
(ll4)
P =
{z n } = {0,0,(V--}
if and only if at least one factor is equal to {z }; thus the set of all sequences
constitute a domain of integrity.
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
361
In the present paper, however, we shall be primarily interested in showing how generating functions can be employed to sum or transform finite series
of various kinds. We shall also illustrate the use of generating functions in
solving several enumerative problems.
referred to [18].
In the definitions above we have considered only the case of one dimensional sequences. This can of course be generalized in an obvious way, namely
with the double sequence {a
(1.5)
a(x,y) =
OO
E a
m=0n=0
'
xmyn.
(1.6)
a r e useful.
oo
jxi n
oo
oo
i ^ - ,
E a
x m y n /n!
(1.7)
a(xl5...,xk) =
a
n l f . . . ,%=0
19
*i
(1.8)
E an /n S ;
n=li
(1.9)
p *= E a b
*n
r s
rs=n
362
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov.
We may think of (1.8) as a generalization of (1.7). For let qi,q 2 J - , q k denote the first k primes and let a
=0
unless
n = qj 1 q2^ qk
If we put
a
n
a*
n
fi,---,fk
it follows that
an/ns
n=l
(1.10)
= a(qrsJ...,q-s)
(2.1)
(1 + x)
= \
I , ]x
k=0 Y7
where, to begin with, we assume m is a nonnegative integer.
Combining
(2.1) with
(1 + x)11 =
=
" (")"
we immediately get
f, 1 = 0 if k > n or k < 0 .
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
363
Each side of (2.2) is a polynomial in m and n. Since (2.2) holds for all
nonnegative values of m 9 n it follows that it holds when m , n are arbitrary
complex numbers.
It is convenient to introduce the following notation:
(a) n = a(a + ! ) (a + n - 1)?
(a)0 = 1
ft - <- ^
and that (2.2) becomes
<-k) s (a) s _ (b - a ) k
(2,3)
s to^^r
"^-
/o A\
'
(2 4)
is very useful.
v^ / -i\k-n/m\ / k \
j 1 (m = n)
{ 1]
'
\n) [n) = \ 0 (m * n)
k?0
Since
0$-8M
it is clear that the left member of (2.4) is equal to
364
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov,
(2.5)
( 1)k
"
(k) a k
(n
O'1'2'"")
then
(2.6)
an = |
(-D^b,
(ri = 0 , 1 , 2 , . . . )
and conversely.
It is of interest to express the equivalence of (2.5) and (2.6) in terms of
generating functions.
As above, put
AW = E a n x n /ni ,
"
n '
n=0
B(x)
= b x n /n!
' \-~r
n=0
(2.7)
B(X) := e A(-x)
(2.8)
(2-9)
.,i # \ / \
= E E <-l> J "*MfcW L.
then
m
(2.io)
viH-k/ml
w
i l l
nl
|a.
>n
j=0k=0
*3 / ^ '
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
365
A(x,y) =
T a
i i ,
m n mln!
m,n=0 '
B(x,y) =
J 30
Hi__n
V b
X -J T
mfS-0 m ' n m l n !
then
A(x,y) = e X + y B ( - x 9 - y )
(2.11)
and
B(x,y) = e x + y A ( - x , - y )
(2.12)
3.
-k
k k
~m
nk
y k
Then
oA>m
tm
y + k t k ( i + t)n
= | 0 fe)( r )
'
366
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
oo
/ \
,m U n
x|.k v
y +n-k
r
L .
= ^k=0
I k\ j /* n=0
l\
n
/'
m,n=0n V n *
[Nov,
\
(yi1 +,
.n n
u
= a - u - t u r ^ E (J) t k a-u-tu) k
= (1 - u - tu)" y " X [ l + t(l - u - tu)] X ,
so that
X/i
J__\X
A
t m u n = (1 + t) ( 1 - ^
,.,
^ vv+l
A m,n
m,n=0
'
(i _ U _ tuK
(3.2)
(1
- t u ) X v + f = (1 - t u ) ^ " 1
\
(1 - u - tu) y + 1
1 - tu/
(y + r ) u r (i - t u ^ - y - 1 - 1
p/y +r j u r ^
=E
/y-x + r+kjtkuk
r=
V y> | y - x + n \ / y + n - k\ k n
k
nt'okt'ol
A n"k )
'
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
367
so that by (3.3),
(3.4)
^J
1 1
A
m ]n _ (1 + t) (l - tu)
tm
u
/I
m,n=0
j.
\V+1
(1 - u - t u r
,3*2"F j d.ej
=
- J
"
[ x j Iy + nl
rx-y-n,-n,-m]
\tri/ \ n / 3 2[_-y-n,x-m+l J
A^(x) = nA n _ 1 (x)
(n = 0 , 1 , 2 , - - ) ,
It is easily
(4.2)
where the a
(4.3)
X)
n=0
n
n *****
E an
n=0
zR/Rl
A^)
n / \
g
,
'n-k
368
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov.
k
is r e -
(4.4)
|o(-l)k^xkAn_k(x)=an.
We may view (4.3) and (4.4) as an instance of the equivalence of (2.5) and (2.6).
If a 0 ^ 0, we may define the sequence (b } by means of
n'
<>
j^Kv.HJ ;S,
B(z) = b z n /n!
n=0 n
It then follows from (4.2) and (4.5) that
<4-6>
xn
= k 4(k) b kVk< x)
(4.7)
xz
^ f - = Z B ( x ) z n /n! ;
e -1
n=0
- j i - = EBnzn/n!
e - 1
n=0 n
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
369
Since
ez- 1
zn
it follows that
(4 9)
^-g,Fh(j) B n.kW
B (x + 1) - B (x) = nx11 ,
(4.11)
B n (l - x) = (-l) n B n (x) ,
k-1
(4.12)
n(x
f|
Bn(kx)
(k = 1,2,3,-) .
(4.13)
xz
- Z _
2
+1
n=0
E(x)
zn/n!
n
E n (x + 1) + E n (x) = 2x n ,
(4.15)
E n ( l - x) = (-l) n E n (x)
(4.16)
k-1
(-l)SEn(x + J ) = knEn(kx)
*>H-
(k odd) ,
370
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
(4.17)
(-if
B n + 1 (x
[Nov.
{ ) = - | 1 E n (kx)
(k even) .
e2xz-z
(5.1)
= H (x) z % !
n=0 n
respect to z we get
n
Hn+1
n i 1 (x)z /n!
A
n=0
= 2(x - z ) e 2 x z " z 2 ,
so that
H
(5.3)
n+l
(x)
2xH (x)
n
<5-4)
(2x n
z2
> =
"
2nH
n-l
(x)
(n
>
X)
, we get
2k<n
In the next place it follows from (5.1) that
T
*-*
n
m,n=0
iv
m (x) Hn (x) Jm!n!
= e2x(u+v)-u2-y2 =
2x(u+v)
-(u+v)2e2uv
oo
k oo
0
= e 2 u v Hn (x)(u + v ) 7 n ! = %k !^ -
Hm + An
n=0
k=b
m*=0
m n
Wm !^n !T
19fi9]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
371
(5.5)
H (x)H (x) =
min(m,n) .k
k-=Q
# \ / i
2 k! H
? Hra^. W
v
ik/ U /
m+n-2k
(5.6)
H _, (x) =
m+n
min(m,n)
, ,
/ \ / \
V
(-l) K 2 K k! If) ( f ) H
. (x)H . (x) .
|^0
Ik I Ikl m-k
n-k
The formulas (5.5)s (5.6) are due to Nielsen [13]; (5C5) was rediscovered
by Feldheim [8], The above proof is due to Watson [20] .
Another interesting formula is
(5.7)
= (1 -
te'^expl43^
I
n^O
H^(x)^L
= Hn (x)^-LiL
n+k
nIk!
n!
n^O
2x(z+t)-(z+t)2
2
e 2xz-z e 2(x-z)t-t
e 2xz-z
v^ T
HT /( x
k=0
Equating coefficients, we get
(5.8)
H n + k (x)z n /n!
n=0
\ t
k - z ) FT
K
= e 2 x z _ z 2 H.(x - z) ,
'
j
)
372
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov.
Since, by (5.1),
(5.9)
(-D k k , ( / I
HnW = ^
2k),
(2x) n - 2k
we have
H (x) H (y)z7n!
n
n=0
<x>
n=0 2k<n
*n-2k
'-
. ._ ,n n+2k
k=0
n=0
g(_l)k^ e 4xy Z -4 X V
k=0
xz)
4k
'
v
kg=0
/ i\k
(2k + 2s)!
if(2k)! (k + s); z
Since
(2k)! = 22kk! ( f ) k ,
we get
2k+2s ,
(2
y-
4xz)
,2k
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
^4xyz-4x 2 z 2
-j-k
^k+s
k,s=0
=
e4xyZ-4xV
e 4xyz-4x
2 2
2 2s
2k+2s
2" z "(2 y _ 4 x z ) 2 k
s!k!(J)k
( 1} k Z
2k
(2y - 4xz) 2 k
k!
k4)
=
373
(_1)k
(k +
s=0
z 2 k (2y - 4xz) 2 k
(1
l>s
(2z)2s
s!
4z2)-k-f
k=0
= (1-4x2)
"I e x p ^ x y z
- 4x2z2 -
zH
'
' ***? }
1 - 4z 2
'
~i
= (1 - 4x 2 ) % x p / ^ L ^ l S E L j d i 2 ! \
I
1 - 4z 2
f
[16, p. 197].
6. The formula of Saalschutz [ l , p. 9] ,
n (-n), (a), (b).
v ^ k k k
k!
(a i\
(c - a) (c - b)
n
n
C C a bJ
^ W ~ <V - - n '
where
(6.2)
c + d = -n + a + b + 1 9
f
L
(6.1) becomes
^ k ^ k ^ k
E T ^ n l ^
<d-a)n(d-b)n
= (d)n(d - a - b) n
where now
(6.4)
c + d = a
+ b + l.
374
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov.
Now by <6.3)
n
> (d - a) (d - b)
> (d - a - b)
(-n). (a), (b).
n
n n _ ^p
n n y^
k k k
X
_ _ ^
"~x
~ ^ _ " """nT
^
k! (c-n). (d)~
n=0
'n
n=0
k=0
k k
(a) (b). . oo (d - a - b)
V / i\k
k k k v-*
n n
K w
n#
k=0
" k
n=0
/ n .k
(a)
k(b)k
k=0
k,,
,a+b-d
(6.5)
V*
(c - b ) ( d - b)
K K _
TcTiai
lc
Va;n
where
(6.7)
c+d
= a+b + l
Let
/ \
s>.b.o,d) = k=o
E (-DkW
m
where a , b , c , d satisfy (6.7). Then
(a + n), (b),
"^^"k
1^69]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
375
S
b c d) -- V ((-1)
l ) k^Mj ^ + n(c)
,+,1)
k(b)k '&f ,<". k (/knj V
*n+1 (a
(a.b.c.d)
(d)
- 7^5 J- ^
^v w^W ^ l
k k
k+l
k+l
n
, / \ (a + n+l), (b),
<- k " 7 5 1 W ifc+k)(d + k) - (a+n+k + l)(b+k)},
\K/ l c W w k + i
k =o
Now put
(c + k)(d + k) - (a + n + k + l)(b + k) = A(d + k) + B(c + k) ,
where A 9 B a r e independent of k.
/fi Rv
K 9 }
Then
j (d - c)A = (c - b)(a - c + n + 1) ,
j (c - d)B = (d - b)(a - d + n + 1) .
**
It follows that
S n + 1 ( a , b , c , d ) = A s n (a + l , b , c + l,d) + ~ S n (a + l , b , c , d + 1)
Assuming that (6.6) holds 9 we therefore get
(c - b + 1) (d - b)
B (c - b) (d - b + 1)
, , d)
v A
n
S n +/1 (a,b,c
- - _ 1 _ T )n ^ ^ ^ n + >- - ( c ) nn( d + D ^
5
0
(c-bil)
( d - b + 1)
-rin_-i_r
JL (A(d-b) (c-b+n) (d+n)+B(c-b) (d-b+n) (c+n)}
lc;
n+l%+l
By (6.8),
(d - c){A(d - b)(c - b + n)(d + n) + B(c - b)(d - b + n)(c + n)}
= (c - b)(d - b){(c - b + n)(d + n)(a - c + n + 1) - ( d - b + n ) ( c + n ) ( a - d + n + l)}
376
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
Sn+1(a,b,c,d) =
[Nov.
(c - b) Q+1 (d - b ) Q + 1
(c) n + 1 (d) n + 1
'
^inFi
Dj(c + 1).
xk
(-k).(a). +k (-a
" & u 0
<*>
T F l ^ c + Dk '
Then
(a), (a - b), (a - c)
k
k
k
k! (b + 1). (c + 1),,
b + c + 1).
3=0
(a - b) k (a - c),
} =
'j
(a + 2j).
k=0
'j
so that we have
(a), (a-b). ( a - c ) .
. (a) (-a+b + c + 1)
k! (b + l) k (c + l ) k
Q
=
(_1)
(2n)! (b + c + 2n + l ) n
n! (b + l) Q (c + l ) n
(6.12)
V7
(n!)3
-a-2
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
377
fJP
(6.13)
and in particular
(6.14)
k=0
a result due toMacMahon. For other proofs of these formulas see [17, pp. 4 1 ,
42].
7. We now turn to some problems involving multiple generating functions. To begin with, we take
(1 - 2x - 2y + x 2 - 2xy + y 2 )
= R l - x - y) 2 - 4xyJ
= (1-x-y)"
r:
00
(1 - x - y)2
(xy)1
(1 - x - y) 2r+l
V* P r l /
m,n=0
_1
4xy
m n
x y
\r
(2r +
+ ss+t)I
t^r
+tj!
sa tt
ifen,
min(m,n)
,
, w
^
(m + n)!
z
^^
-^
r!r!7m-r)!
(n-r)2
Since
min(m,n)
^
we have
(m + n)l
rJ r! (m - rJUn^rTl
m +n\
m /
min(m,n)
r=0
n i
i m + n )2
r) ~ \
m j
'
378
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
(1 - 2x - 2y + x2 - 2xy
(7.1)
y2)
[Nov.
"= t (mr)'
=
^
m 9 n=0 \
m 9 n=0 \
x mmy j n
/
/
(1 - 2xz + z 2 )
(7.2)
-i
= P (x) z n .
n=0
It is known that
PM(x)zn
n=0
(7.4)
= E ^ R ^ d
- z + r)- Q (l - z + R ) ^ ,
where
R = (1 - 2xz + z 2 )
v = x (x + l)z
we have
(7.5)
1
R = [(1 - u - v)2 - 4uv] 2
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
379
(7 5
J A
*r -
+iS
R ^ l - u + v + R j ^ d + u - v + R)"' 3
(1 - x) J '"(1 - y)J
j,k=0
k^
-m n S
m,n=0
r,s=0
JL (-m).(-n).
3=0 k=0
(a + m + 1). (j3 + n + l ) .
k^
(-n) m
(-m) n
(j8 + 1) (a + 1)
^
m
n
Now put
Then
= " 7i
^T7T-^>
(mEjir^T)'
vv
T\ _
)(i"
-- nr^rnrr-yj
380
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov,
[,1 - x - y - z>* - 4 ^ , - K M
*>'
r=0 \ /
,m
(1 = x - y - z)
Since
-sW'
,1.x-,-,)-2'-1. r
2 +k
y^
s,a=o
t*
+ y + z)
(2r + s + t + u ) !
s t u
2r !s:t!u! x y z
< >
'
we get
i
y^
m y p
m,n,p=lXyZ
min(m,n,p)
y* ^
vk
/ , ,
\.
(m+n+p-r)!
rtr!fci-r)!a-r)!<p-r)l
Now by (6.1)
= (m + n + p)I
m! n! pi
r!r!
r ' r
- n -
r=0
^ + 1 >m
(m + n + p) ! ( n + 1) m (p
m! n! p!
m! <n + p +
'^m
(m + n)! (m + p)f. (n + P)I
m ! m ! rL! n! p !p!
/m + n j / n + p j / p + mj
m
n
A P /
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
381
(8.1)
[(l^x-y-Z)2-4xyz]-2-=
(m +n)(
+ P ) / P + m ) x m ya *P
(1 - v)
In the
"U&
(1
w
1 3 j k kk r
=
t
E
(
1 ) : V ;r)<
VwV
(';<)(T)(
)(l - x) - w ]M
j=0 k=0 r=0
(i w x)1
[(1 -
1+1
(8.2)
[( 1
- w)(l - y) - x]
oo
oo
oo
oo
= E E E E
j=0 k=0 r=0 s=0
(ir)(^k)(k")(rr)'Jk
r s
x y
382
(8.3)
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov.
EEEI:
i=0
\ /
\ /
\/
+k
k r r
k r s-i
w x y
Ef ;! (\ )( ; y :>v
/ \
/ V
/\
We are concerned with that part of the multiple sum that is independent of y.
The left member of (8.3) is equal to
(L(l - v)(l - x) - w + u(l - w)] - (1 - v - w)y - (1 - w - x)xy
r=0
r
]
[(1 - y)(l - x) - w + u(l - w)] r + i
f(l - v - w)y + (1 - w - x)uy
Expanding the numerator by the binomial theorem, it is clear that the terms
independent of y contribute
vr H
r
xr
v - w) (1 - w - x) u
"o \\ V7 [[a( 1-- vv)) ( l - x ) - w + u ( l - w ) ] 2 r + 1
r=0
= {['(1 - v)(l - x ) - w + u (1 - w)] 2 - 4u(l - v - w ) ( l - w - x ) } " r
= {(1 - U - V - W - X + UW + vx)2 - 4uvwx}
k r
w x
= { ( l - u - v - w - x + u w + vx)2 - 4uvwx}
( l - 2 u - 2 w + u 2 + w 2 ) - 4u2w2 = ( l - u - v ) 2 ( l - 2 u - 2 v + u 2 -2uv + v 2 )
= (i_U-.v)2[(l-u-v)2 - 4uv],
Eq. (8.4) becomes
1969]
(8.5)
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
H(m,n)u m v n = (1 - u - v ) " 1 [ ( l - u - v ) 2
m,n=0
383
- 4uv]"r
where
(8.7)
an identity due to Paul Brock [2], [3]. We remark also that (8.5) implies
2
^-2r-2
(1 - u - v ) _ 1 [ ( l - u - v) 2 - 4uv],4* _
= V
J^ (\ A^A^H
* |(uv) r (l -
u - v)
r=0
y
m^O
|2r\ ,
^r v
m nminp'a)
V
rtt.
(2r + s + t + 1)!
L\
W
(m + n + 1)1
(2r + D!(m-r)!(n-r).'
it follows that
..
s t
BM = h f ; f ^ B ( i ]
For the generalized version of (8.4), see [4], [6], [18, Ch. 4 ] ,
384
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
9.
[Nov.
The
(9.1)
This recurrence is obtained when the element n + 1 is adjoined to any permutation of { l , 2 , - * , n } . Now put
B(x)
11
n(n-l)/2
B(n,r)xr.
r=0
Then by (9.1),
Wx)
n(n+l)/2
r=0
S B(n,r - s)
s=0
s<n
n
n(n-l)/2
= xS
B(n,r)x r ,
s=0
r=0
so that
(9.2)
n+l(x)
(1 + x +
'"
+x n )/3 n (x)
(9.3)
*W
(l-x)(l-x2)-..(l-xn)
(1 - x)
1969
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
385
B(n,l) = n - 1,
(n > 1),
(n > 2) ,
(n > 3) .
o.4)
EO /yx)z7(x)n = Xi
J.JL
~"
X
"~
where
(x)n = (1 - x)(l - x 2 ) . . . (1 - x n ) ,
(x)0 = 1 .
This is the first occurrence in the present paper of a generating function with
denominator (x) ; see the remark in Section 11 below.
If we make use of Euler 1 s formula
(9.5)
( -i) k x' k ( 3 k + 1 )
n <i->=
n=l
k=
_L v 5b _t_ -v?
= 1 - x - xr2 +
x + x( - -v-12
x1^ - -y-15
x1D + . .
we obtain an explicit formula for B(n,r) when r < n. For example, we have
B,n,4, = ( ;
) - (
B < . - (
) - ( " ;
) 3
(" t )
) - ( " 3
*>-*
2
) ^
<is>.
386
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov.
(1 + x + + x n - 1 ) ,
xj + x2 + + x
= r
(k =
l,2,'",n)
r=0
B(n,r) = n! ,
n(n-l)/2
(-l)rB(n,r) = 0
r=0
n(n-l)/2
n
r B(n,r) = n!
/.v
(Jj
( n > 1) ,
= | n ( n - 1) n! .
-.
{l,2,ea#,n},
(10.1)
A ^ . = (n - k + 2)A . - + kA . .
n+l,k
n,k-l
n,k
I+I
If
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
387
'
n,l=An,n
to
- 1.2,3.-) ;
{l,2,",n},
re-
By means of (10.1) and (10.2), we can easily compute the first few
n,k
1
1
1
1 4
11
11
26
66
26
n,k =
n,n-k+l '
T A . = n!
k=l n ' k
(10.4)
Put
A0(x) = 1,
n
A (x) = E
k ti
n
k
n k
'
,
(n = 1,2,3,-)
(10.5)
- l ^ - * - = (x - l ) " n A ( x ) Z n / n !
e - x
n=0
388
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
[Nov.
means of (10.5) and show that the other properties follow from this definition.
For references, see [ 5 ] , [18, Ch. 8 ] .
The symmetry property (10.3) is not obvious from (10.5). This suggests
the following change in notation. Put
(10.6)
ACr.s) = A r + s + 1 > r + 1
Then by (10.3),
(10.7)
A(r,s) = A(s,r)
,10 8)
F(x y, =
'
; ^ -
! o
A (
s ,
T ^ ^
(10.9)
(1 + x F ( x , y ) ) ( l + xF(x,y)) =
r s
x
A(r,s) , * / . lr + s;
r,s=0
'
The denominator in the right members of (10.8) and (10.9) should be noticed.
11. We conclude with a few remarks about q-series; an instance has
appeared in (9.4). Simple examples a r e
n a - A r 1 = zn/(x)n,
(ii.i)
n=0
(n.2)
where a s above
n=0
n=0
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
(x) = (1 - x)(l - x 2 ) (1 - x n )
n
(x)o = 1,
(ii.3)
n=0 1 - x z
o (a)
- L j j - z
n=0 x 'n
where
(a) n = (1 - a)(l - ax) (1 - ax11 *
(a)0 = 1,
To prove (11.3), put
F(z)
..
n
*>
i1 ^- ax
i z = 5] A Z 1 1 ,
n=0 1 - x z
n=0
n
F(xz)
= ^.
F(z)
so that
oo
(1 - az) A n x n z n = (1 - z) A z n
n=0 n
n=0 n
This gives
(1 - x n )A
= (1 - ax 11 " 1 ) A 1 ,
n-1
390
(x )
k-i
(11.4)
[Nov.
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
k,
Yi ,.,
n v-1
v^
n n
V k + n - 1
n
II (1 - x z)
= 2 ^ T ^ V z = Z^
z ,
n
n
n=0
n=0 l X ' n
n=0L
-
where
(x)
(0 < n < k)
^K^
-k
If we take a = x
k
and r e p l a c e z by x z we get
k-1
n=0
n=0
r e d u c e s to
II (1 - xnz) =
(11.5)
(11.6)
[3
for a r b i t r a r y a , b .
Specializing a , b
roU sj[sJ
Jn(a-l)zn
()
(a), (b) , a
k n-k
k
(11.7)
(-l)n
= (ab)
s2-ks+ms
m + n"|
e(z) =
n (1 - x n z f *
n=0
T h i s s u g g e s t s the
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
(11.8)
e(tz) a n z n / ( x ) n = A ( t ) z n / ( x )
n=0
n=0 n
oo
391
oo
(11.9)
An(t) = |
[ J ] a k t11"1
(11.10)
AA n (t) = (1 - x 11 )A n _ 1 (t)
= 1 is of particular interest.
Put
00
so that
The
392
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
(11.11)
[Nov.
II
- . n o
1 - x uvz4
Gleichungen
1969]
GENERATING FUNCTIONS
393
pp. 29-32.
.* *
(k = 0 , 1 , ' ) ,
k-1A
lk
an - l , k
394
(k = 0, ! , - )
Nov. 1969
395
0k
lj
lks
'"
Vl
In the algorithmj which in the special case n = 2 of ordinary continued fractions reduce essentially to only one a.,,
in each step.
.. in the form
J JL
<-D
0kVn*-
( k >> >
Vl,k*k-1
-n
-1
n-1
*k-l
'
Thus the recurrency formulae (0.1) with the initial conditions (0.2) become
(0.3)
(v)
k "
y^1
^
V
(V)
k-(n-^)
(
k > 0
\
\ v = 0, , n - 1 /
with
(0 4)
(Ua4;
DM
-(n-^)
= e M - I1
V
for
V = V
'\
~ \0 for v V*)
396
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
would be the A
(\ =
(o 5)
k
0
I
x=0
i/=0
4
/n a\
(-6>
W
Pk -
>
fa
r
V * W ^ )
I
k > 0
\
(v = 0,- r . , n . x J
with the n linearly independent initial conditions (0.4). In this case we shall
obtain the following simple explicit expressions for the entries p^
Perron matrices P^. (last column):
L ( k o . - . . , k 1 )=k+(n-i')
kk , - - - , kk , > 0
0
<""''
n-i^
(0.7)
k
- - -
*<> +
Vi
(k
\K'
M
'n-l/
n-l /
k > 0
\
n - l I v=0,--- , n - l J
of the
1969]
(0.8)
L(k 0 , , k ^ )
397
= nk0 + (n - l)ki + + l k ^
(0.9)
' "'
n-l /
(k0 + + k n _ 1 ) !
=
k !
" V l 1 "
The procedure by which we reach our aim (0.7) is the very old method
of Euler, viz. , to translate the recurrency formula (0.6) for the sequences
(v)
p^ into algebraic expressions for the generating functions
k
>(l/)<x) = E P^x
y
A
K
{v = 0, - , n - 1)
k>0
p*
expressions.
In the general case of arbitrary period length i we shall show that the
same object can be achieved in principle.
would be so complicated that one can hardly expect to write them down in extenso, but for simpler special cases. As an example, we shall carry through
in extenso the very special case i = 2 with n = 2, i. e. , the case of purely
periodic ordinary continued fractions with period length 2.
There i s , however, a special case of a more general type in which we
can obtain as definite a result as (0.7). Amongst the numerous periodic algorithms, discovered by the first author in previous papers*, a particular period
structure prevails, viz., of length ^ = n and with the following specialization
of the coefficients in (0.5)s
(0.10)
= t
a^
where
(A,z/J = 0, . . . f n - 1) ,
398
[Nov.
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
n
'
1 for X + V* > n
is the so-called "number to be carried over" in the addition of the n-adic digits
A,^ f .
generalization:
_ri^
(0.12)
*YJ
p' = t
+ k
" -
\ 0>
kQ+- +k._
Vl
n-l\k0
'Vl/ 0
k
a
k
a
n-l
0 " n-l
+k
'--
--
lv
\
+ k
n-l
k
>
=.
,) .
-l/
(1.2)
PX-I/I) = w
{V V% =
>
= F(x) = 1 - J^ V ^
l/ f =0
'
1=1.
1969]
399
(V)
(v). .
y*
(v) k
pv
= p v '(x) = ^
pi
x
K
k>0
Now
~ 4-( V p k
k>0
V*
=
(u)
a
_ V*
" ?6
^-<*-v>)
k
X
(i/)
k
X
-(n-^)
I/,Pk
V"
(i>)
- A-* V P k - ( n -
k>0
la^x
)
- ^ ^
k>o\i/=o
Here the negative terms on the left and right a r e equal to each other on account
of the recurrency formula (1.1). This gives the algebraic expressions
400
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
{P)
(V)
A
p^
= _ ^
(1.3)
./)
Av
...
W 1 th
(l
[Nov.
(l/ =
(x) = ^ V ^ " ^
I"=0
for the generating functions P
(I/)
"
a^ x
k>oWt=0
(2.1)
...TJh.1>o\V Vi/
0)'
x a
n-l
o - Vi
kL>0\]
>0\LW=k\k0'
nko+(n-1)kl+-"+lkn-l
n-l/
n 1
L(sm) = nk 0 + (n - 1 ) ^ + + l k ^
^'"
n-l
1969]
401
In order to obtain from (2.1) the power series for the rational functions
p
of the poly-
nomials A
-L{z( r::: r)
I/x
k>0\L(3Ji)=kW
' V l
k
1
k
0
V +1
n-l\
X a Q .- zv,
- - - a ^ Ix
/
W-V)
= El
E
/k0 + " + k n - l \
k>oyL(sK)=k-(v-w)\ko! ;*' V i z
ak 0
k ,+1
In order to simplify the subsequent summation over 1" we have here formally
admitted terms with L(ko 9 ' 9 k n _^) < 0, which actually vanish because the
summation condition is empty. Summation over v* then yields the development
Vk0'
*" '
n-1 /
k^.+l
X o ' " v*
for the generating functions, and thus the explicit expressions
p" = E
(2t3)
(k,
Vt=0 L ( 9 K ) = k - ( ^ - ^ )
V1
X aQ . . . a,,,
for the recurrent sequences in question.
.... kn J
'
k
n-l
a n - 1
402
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[ NoV .
-. This is achieved by
J a further transformation of summation which, in its
n-1
turn, allows to reverse the order of the two summations.
The transformation, leading to this, is
(3.1)
ky, - ^ k y , - 1 .
LM->LM
- (n - v<)
and hence
^
X
k
a
,B
K*
Vt
"
n-l
V l
Here the sum of all terms in the "numerator" is surely non-negative, because
L W = k + (n - v) > k + 1 > 1 and hence not all k0, >k n _i vanish.
Since by this transformation the inner summation condition in (3.2) has
become independent of the outer summation variable vf,
summations may now be reversed:
1969]
403
(E (:::::%:?::".+fc))*
pP-
n_1
L(3K)=k+(n-y) \ i;i=0
(3.3)
'
k0
k .,
n-1
X
a
a
n l
Thus the polynomial (2.3)0 has already
been put into canonical form.
u
But,
...+kn_1^
k,
WS0 f r K* = 0) '
= Uo . . k n _Jk 0 H-... + k n _ 1
and hence
/ k o + . . . + (ky, - 1) + . . -
^
;t=0
(3.4)
\k 0 , . k
= /ko +
+ k
-fk^v
- 1 , , k
-i\
"
\k0 , . ^ J k o t . . .
+k
J
v
+k n _ 1
P^ =
Zv
---
U.
+kn_1\
... .
""jX
L(9tt)=k+(n-z/)
(3.5)
k0 + "
krr-
+ k
n-l
+ kQ_1 * " V l
k>0
\v = 0 , - - - , n - 1 /
as announced in (0.7).
We remark that (3.5), conveniently interpreted, holds even for k > -n,
i8 e. j including the initial values corresponding to k = -(n - V) {v* = 0, ,
n-1).
- = 0,
404
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
1
if vi = v9 and only such solutions with k0, ,k^ = 0 if V > v. Hence for
V* < v the sum is 0 by the usual convention for empty sums, for W > v it is
also zero with regard to the factor
-"
+ k
n-l
'
(3.6)
Pk
2-
lk
,...,k
'al
( k
- V l
0 )
U*
v/ k 0
" '
+ (
V -
1 )
--
+ k
/k0
n-A
-'
+ k
n-l\
+ k
n - l \ _(k0
V o V i /
~-
MX
\ o V
(4.2)
/(k 0
... + v
\k0
-.-
kv;,
+k m
kv+1
...
+kn_1\
, ,
k^J*
1969]
405
for any V = ! , ,n - 2. For V = 1, the first factor on the right is the binomial coefficient
/ko + kA
Iterating this case of (4.2) in the second factor on the right, and putting
= k
h
k
i
/
(4.3)
= k
n-l =
o
o+
+ k
i
X
* "
+k
n-l
'
ft:::::a-fflfi)-(aApplication of this reduction to our final result (3,5) yields the equivalent
expression
..G)K-(&>
SW=k+(n-i>)
(4.5)
k
K
0 k i" k 0
^-1-^-2 /
k> 0
\
a
T\
l
""Vl
Vf = 0,- . . . n - l /
n-1
where
(4.6)
S W = kjj + . . . + k ^ x
is the simpler linear form obtained by the transformation (4.3) from L(9tt) in
(2.2). The silent summation condition k 0 , , # - , k
<
~
k < < k
0- n-l '
- > 0 is transformed in 0
406
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
Special cases of the formulae (4.5), with n = 2 and n = 3, have r e cently been developed by Arkin-Hoggatt [ 4 ] .
5. We now turn to the general case of an arbitrary period length i.
To
"i;
(v)
\lL+\
n-1
_ \^
" LJ
(X) (v)
^ p (k+X)-(n-^)
(
k> o
\
\ \ = 0, , n - 1/
(5.2)
P^vf)
t*
Ci"
= 0f . . . , n - 1)
polynomials
n-1
,<X> _
W(A)^
, _ V
pv'' = pv)(x) = E
Px''x"
k>0
We split these polynomials and functions into components, corresponding to the
residue classes mod# of the x-exponents:
(5.3)
F(X) = 5 ? F A >
A'=0
A
with
i/=o
n-v1 =A.?mod#
pW
A
1969]
407
-1
V
vvx,xx
p
.<"> - E pR
*>
pf?
-X
Aff
P yK W
Xu
X"=0
(5.4)
E
k>0
(v)
lf)
P
K+A"
Jk
+An
In order to translate the recurrency formulae (5.1) .with the initial conditions (5.2) into algebraic expressions for the generating functions, we multiply, for each fixed X and v$ the terms a*,x n ~
of a component F ! T
by
(5.5)
(5.6)
,
According to the congruences
(n - P*) + X" = X + M
with an integer h > 0. The whole procedure will be quite analogous to that in
Section 1 for the special case ft = 1. In the first place, one has
(X) n-i/'(i/)
_ V*
(X) (v)
v (kl+X")+(n-^)
k>0
kX)
k>h
K>h
,(A) W
k+A
oWAV)
V p (k-h)+A' ?
408
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
Va(A)o(i;)
xM+X
p
LJ V
fe-fA)-(n-^)
k>0
1L
fe+A)-(n-y')X
0<k<h-l
(A)(w)
k+A
Z-f V p
k>0
>o
ptr^"^
for
0 otherwise
The latter one sees as follows. The summation condition 0 < k < h - 1 i m plies, again by (5.7), the inequality chain
-n < -(n - V) < A - (n - V) < (M + A) - (n - ff) < ( (h - IK + A")
_ (n _ yf)
or else,
kl + A = V - V1 .
If these condi-
tions are satisfied, it actually occurs, because then the equation kS. + A = V vx has a solution k > 0 with
M = (i; - i/t) - A < (n - i/T) - A = M - A " < h ,
1969]
(F Af
n-1
\7*
2^
*"=0
JO) sJW _ x^ /
- eAf)pA - - W
k>0\
409
(A) (V)
\ M
V p ( + A ) - ( n ^ ) , x.
+A
(A) v-v*
i/i
n-z^=Af mod
^-^f=Amodj2
and summation over the pairs Af, A" with A? + Af? = A mod I
F (A)
F
E
A +A =modi
f
A<
ff
PW
A'
further
yields
n-1
-2
(A) DG
X
V P ( +x)-(n-i; f )
a
k>0 [ ^ =0
n-1
X
ktf+A
X
Vx
V- i/ =Amod0
Here the negative terms on the left and right a r e equal to each other on account
of the recurrency formulae (5.1). Thus the following system of I linear equations for the I components "9 \ of the generating function P
results:
I-WpJ)
= A<A,*>
with
A (A,^)
A'+A"=Amod
(5.8)
n-1
=
A<A,^)
l>-^=Amod0
The matrix of its coefficients is built up from the components F . f
(A)
of the
characteristic polynomials F . Lines and columns of this matrix a r e specified by A and A" = A - AT mod i (not by A and Af). Written out fully, it
is the matrix
410
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
(F ( A )
s
/'?
F<>
F>
\
\
[Nov.
...
rf
',W
^
F ^
'J" U
2-2
Here X - X" on the left is to be understood as reduced to its least non-negative
residue mod i.
Now let
D =
F(A)
X lines
X" columns
denote the determinant of this matrix and (D^
(5.9)
Pj! = 2
(X" = (>,, I - 1)
From this one obtains the following algebraic expressions for the generating
functions themselves:
J>)
(5.10)
(V)
A A
A=0\X"=0
= M
^ L Z T _ _ ^/
(1/ = 0, , n - 1> .
1969]
411
VfP2k-(n-^)
JLJ
'
n-1
P
2k+1
/ ^ V p (2k+l)-(n-&") ,
i"=0
V(Z-W)
*V<
"' 1 " = 0, - - - . n - 1) .
For the sake of easier readability, we here have distinguished the two coefficient sequences, hitherto denoted by a
0,1 by writing them with two different letters a,b. In the same manner we
denote the polynomial pairs F
(v) (v)
A , B , respectively.
and A
V x 1 1 " ^ = F0
= F (x) = 1 - ^
FA ,
n-1
= G0 + Gi ,
i> =0
each decomposed in its even and odd components, algebraic expressions for the
generating functions
PMPM(D
=x) p - ) x k = p r + p r
k>0
412
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
The linear equation pair (5.8) for the component pair P ft , Pmatrix
(\ GFi M
G /
0
/ G0
-FA
V"GI
F/
z/-y?=0mod 2
v-v'
y-y f =lmod 2
Hence the solution (5.9) for the components is
w
0
G p A ^ - F t B<
F0G0 -
FJGJ
(v)
Pl
- G ^
H- F 0 B ^
F 0 G 0 - F!Gi
(6.1)
, .
W
has the
1969]
413
It is worth remarking that this can be written in such a way that only the
characteristic polynomials F,G themselves, not their components, figure in
it. For, the component pairs a r e given by
- i w + pfc*)
F | W
F I ( X) = F<*> ; F<~*> .
G(x) + G(-x)
G0(x)
G(x) - G(-x)
G!(x)
_ G(-x)A{U)(x)
V(V)(,
(6.2)
> -- o
a
0)
= 0
(1 -
= (1 - b ^ ) - b t x
,
,
A* * = a ,
B ( 1 ) = b0x ,
aox
) (1 - b ^ 2 ) -
a^x2
a 0 + a0biX - a0b0x2
D
(1)
[Nov.
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
414
1_
D
+ kl
)
k
Kl
(ao
b0
a 1 b 1 ) k O(-a 0 b 0 ) k ix 2k o +4k i
2k
E
E
(-Dkl(k M
u k l V o + b0 + a ^ ^ f e o b o ) ^
k>0 k0+2kf=k
\
/
From this, one obtains easily the following power series developments for the
even and odd components of the two generating functions:
(0)
_a0-aob0x2 _
2k
= Eko+2k
;1 = k
kXO
K1
, , , , \kn-l ki+l,kf+1
DM V
J(a + bo + a b ) a * b *
- E kS+2k =k (, --vk-i/ko+ki-lY
\
/
1
k>0
a 0 bi
,(0)
(7.1)
"IT"
"
1 1
L (kq>D
E T E
(-l)kl(kV+kl)b1(a0+b0
k>0 k0+2ki=k
\ M /
a1b1)kOa^^lx2k+1
J
E
(~D kl ( k k + k l ) ai(a 0 + b 0 + a l b l ) k ^ b k * l x 2 k
\ M/
J
kXO k0+2ki=k
^ (1) ^ ( b o + a ^ i J x - a o b o x 3
I~
k>DLk0+2ki=k
k
X ( k+
kl
^k
(-if 1 X
) (b0 + a l b l )(a 0
Ef E
k>0 ko+2k!=k
L (kt>L)
+ b0
+ a^/oa^lx 2 1 ^ 1
(-Dklfkk+ kl"*V
\
+1 k +1
i +, bi. +, a ^ui ) ^ k
o-l ak i *
uboi1 l x 2 k + 1
(a
0
0
0
The sums in square brackets or in the first and fourth cases, more exactly,
their differences are the looked for explicit expressions for the recurrent
sequences
(Q)
P
2k *
(Q)
P
2k+1
a n d P
(1)
&)
2k'
2k+1 '
2k
1969]
415
(8 2)
D<">
^>
- y't^'^a
kn+A ~ ^
DW
V (kn+A)-(n-t")
\u
k > 0
<8'3)
P-"(U<) = e ?
(V V
' ' = 0, - - - . n - 1) .
sequences
(8 4)
15e4j
rT{v) = tk+VU)
kn+A
kn+A
They satisfy again the initial conditions (8.3). Now the p^ -subscripts on the
right of (8.2) reduce as follows to the canonical form on the left:
416
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
Hence 9
V*-t
<kn+A)-(n-i)
(kn+A)-(n-i)
kn+A
kn+A
n-1
k+l^yx^)
(v)
p
~ ifco
V ( n+A)-(n-i")
the modified coefficients ta,, and, as already said, with the same initial
conditions (0.4). According to (0.7), they a r e therefore given explicitly by
-(v)
(8.6)
Pto+A
/ k , + +k n V
-"
+k
v^~ w
/
k
V-'^n-l^
n-l
kn
> ^
Vv = 0, , n - 1 /
'
1969]
Pk
/o 7 \
/ k0 + ... + kn j X
jr
Ul *
= t
417
L(^)=k+(n-^)\ k O
6 9 9
k + .. + k
k +...+k
t
0
V . 0
n-1 0
k
0 + " + k n - l
n/
k .
n-1
n 1
"
/
k>0
\
\v = 0 , , n - 1/
as announced in (0.12). The remark after (3.5), concerning validity even for
k > -n, i. e. , including the initial values holds obviously for (8.7) as well.
Application of the reduction (4.3), (4.4) of polynomial to binomial coefficients to this result yields, in analogy to (4.5), the equivalent expression
-M
pjf'
=tLnJ
(8.8)
k ^
/ k lY k A - / k n-l\
0 al
V l
/
\U
k>0
= (),, n -
\
1)
Fibonacci numbers F k ,
recurrency formula
(9.1)
Fk+2 = Fk + Fk+1
(k > 1)
Fi = 1,
F 2 = 1,
(9.2')
LA = 1,
L2 = 3 .
418
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
viz. ,
(9.5)
n
n
F. = a A F. +
k+n
0 k
+ a
n
,F. ^ ,
n-1 k+n-1
(k > 1)
Formula (9.5) is actually the reeurrency law (0.6) of our introductory section.
The question which is the natural generalization of the original Fibonacci
numbers is idle. The answer to it depends on the viewpoint one takes and is a
matter of mathematical taste and preferences.
- according
to the more general reeurrency law (0.5) of our introductory section. As initial values we admit throughout ihe n linearly independent standard sets (0.4).
1969]
419
From them any set of n initial values may be linearly combined, and the corresponding recurrent sequence will then be obtained from those corresponding
to (0.4) by the same linear combination,
10. Before we apply the general results (8.7), (8.8) of our first chapter
to special cases of the generalized Fibonacci numbers with time impulses, let
us make some preliminary remarks.
1.) The restriction of summation
LW
= nk0 + (n - l)ki + + Ik
= k + (n - v)
\k0 ,
kn-1 = k + ( Q - ^ ) - ( n k
+ . . . + 2k n _ 2 )
wherever k
become
P*
V
2->
k
/ so^>
I t "... u-
0'-"' n-2
(10.2)
\ / k + (n-l>) - L 0 (^)\
II
a.fm\
"
lx
k + (n - V) - L0(3K)
k-|!J+<n-i>)-l-L 0 $ii)
x t
k
k
0 kl
n-2 k + ( n - ^ - L o W - S 0 ( ^ )
x a A0 a-1 an-20 an-1.,
y = 0, , n - 2J
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
420
>-D
(10.2T)
xt
xa
S0W
[Nov.
\/k + l-L0^)\
H^" L o x
%
k+1 L
n-2
- o(^)-S0^)
o i V 2 V i
>\
9,
n-2
S 0 W = kn + . . . + k
0
n-2
For confirmation of (10.2), (10.2 ! ), notice that with the help of these two linear
forms the substitution (101) takes the form
k
n-l
= k + (n
L 0 $JO + S0(^)
< k + (n -
v)
For
ial coefficient vanishes if S0($t) > k+(n-i>) - L0$K); in particular for L<j(3tt) =
k + (n - v)9 however, we convene to consider the denominator of the subsequent
fraction cancelled against the same factor of the factorial in the numerator of
the binomial coefficient, as will actually be done later.
v),
accordance with the usual extension of Pascal's triangle to negative "numerat o r s n - k by means of the fundamental recurrency property, fixing arbitrarily,
1969]
42i
(t) - > .
since this extension gives them non-zero values as long as the T'denominator'f
is non-negative.
Observe, by the way, that for V = n - 2 one has k0.+ + k = S0W>.
Hence in this case the binomial coefficient can be combined with the subsequent
fraction to
/k + (n - V) - L0fa) - l \
V
S0W - 1
/
In (10.2), (10.2f)9 the restriction of summation L(9tt) = k + (n - v) has
disappeared.
efficient a
This is deceptive, however, in cases where the recurrency co- is specialized to 0. F o r , in such cases only the terms in which
bargain since now there is no longer a term with coefficient 1 which would allow
a further elimination.
2.) Things stand better with the sums (8.8), in which the polynomial coefficients have been reduced to products
U/ 'VW
of binomial coefficients.
S W = kjj + + k ^
= k + (n -i>) ,
= kj,f
How-
not specialized to 0.
i/'-f-x
. alone is
nI
422
[Nov.
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
We shall chiefly be concerned with the latter case a
- =# 0, in which
reduction of the sums (8.7) to unrestricted summation has already been achieved
in (10.2), (10.21). For treating the eases where some of the preceding a ^ a r e
specialized to 0, it will, however, be more convenient to start from the corresponding reduction of the sums (8.8), viz. ,
V"'kk-2V K)
v
K
k + (n -
__
\^kn-- 3 /
v
~w^^m
xt k "L E J
(10.3)
(ti-V)
-1-S0M
b ki
n-2 -K-" 3 x
a 0
n-2
x a Q a.x
k+(n-^)-S 0 ^ , )-kJ i _ 2
x a ti-1
(
b-" k k-2V k o/
k>0
W-iA
n 2
k - l ^ -S 0 (^') X
x t
(10.3') {
'o
'r k o
k'
n - 2-kn -3 x
n-2
\?iv.)
with the reduced linear form
So(^!)
+ k*n-20
1969]
423
The remark made after (10.2), (10.2f) about the silent summation condition k*
> 0 holds, mutatis mutandis, also for the silent summation condi-
tion k'
> k'
in (10.3), (10.3T), the latter corresponding to the former
nx n u
under the transformation (4.3). We uphold the conventions made in that remark,
We must enlarge, however, on the subsequent observation about the possibility of combining the binomial coefficient in (10.2) with the subsequent fraction for v = n - 2 9 because this observation generalizes here to all v = 0,
, n - 2 and thus allows to get rid of these fractions altogether.
seen by the following chain of reductions.
/k + (n - v) - S 0 (^ f )\
k^2
k^
kj,
=
/k + (n-i/) - S0(^?) = 1\
JTTlJr- v) - s0(R-) k ^ \
, , k
This is
k^-l
/ ki+i\
/k;-2vk
\ K)"\k'n-3A
+ (n
-v) K-2-1
/ k m 1- x\
\ K-
s m
!k + (n - v) - S0$R')
J "W-s-Vl
K-2-
By the transformation
k
i ;
-i^k.)-.-
> k
+ 2
-i-k^
, ,kf
> 0, then
424
[Nov.
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
S(9R')
S(9R') + (n - V) - 1 ,
C)
Pk
/k.e^-So^Ak-g]^ - S o ^ ' )
(10.4)
k ^ '
X aQ
k
k.-kk^-k^
ax
ay
--X
(V)
k>0
^> = o , - - - , n - iy
where the modified middle terms
and
e9
(V)
(V)
in the first and last column of the unit matrix, introduced in (0.4); by inserting
e - at the two places, the case v = n - 1, split off in (10.2 ! ), (10.3 f ), could
now be re-included. Formulae (10.4) could be expressed more concisely introducing also the other e^f (i/f = 1,* ,n - 1) and using the product sign:
1969]
(10.5)
+ e(V)\
425
k' +e (I,) -k
k-f-l-S0Gwf) A + e W
Xt
k+e^'-So&R^-k'
n-1
n-2
X an-1
> )
yp = o,---,n - i y
where one has to understand formally k* = 0. For our intention of passing
to special cases, though, formulae (10.4) allow a better survey.
Notice that for each V = 0,* * ,n - 2 the silent summation condition for
kfp in the formula (10.4) o r (10.5) for pV' has to be modified into k ' + 1 >
kf
V-l'
Since the original formulae (3.5), (8.7), (10,2) and (1Q.21) with the polynomial coefficients will not be referred to again, we shall hence forward simplify the notation by omitting the dashes on k l s ,kn_2
3.) As to specialization of the recurrency coefficients RQia1,' an_-^s
we may suppose without loss of generality a 0 ^ 0, by considering only recurrencies of the exact order n. In the Jacobi-Perron algorithm there is always
even a 0 = 1; see (0.1) and what was explained before and afterwards.
4.)
p1
and
with the first and last set of our standard initial values (0.4) a r e essen-
tially equal to each other, i. e., they differ only by a translation of the sequence
variable k:
(10.6)
(n-1)
(0)
P,k+1
(k > -n)
426
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
11. We now apply our general results to special cases of the generalized
Fibonacci numbers.
appropriately adapted main result (10.4) for cases with recurrently coefficient
a
k0,.-.9kn_2\V
(11.1)
X
\ V l
\kn-3/
/k + e ^ - S o W V
k
n-2
^^^
\V
= 0,-~ , n - l ] '
with
S0(*R) = k0 + + k n _ 2
The first and last of these sequences, essentially equal to each other according to (10.6), a r e essentially equal to the sequence of generalized Fibonacci
numbers considered by the first author in his previous paper [3], and mentioned above in (9.3). F o r , adaptation to the initial values (9.4) of those latter
yields
n
n,m
n,
1969]
427
These two sequences are essentially equal to the sequence (9.1) of the original
Fibonacci numbers. For, adaptation to the initial values (9.2) of those latter
yields
Notice that, unfortunately, the initial values (9.4) of the generalized Fibonacci
numbers
n
a r e not in accordance with the traditional initial values (9.2) of the original
Fibonacci numbers F^., corresponding to the special case n = 2. By (11.2),
(11.4) the connection is
(11.5)
lk+1 = Fk
rk = i r _ r - ,
(k > o)
where
1 + *y/5
2
(k > 0)
428
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
2,^
(11.6)
[Nov.
2,
>*-&*&-(*-:-)('-:-)
*>*
t arbitrary ,
simplest possible manner, observe that the sum of the exponents of ao,aj,- ,
a n 1- in (10.4) (or (10.5)) reduces to k + 1 - S 0 W . But since here only a 4 ,
"
(v)
. . . ,a - = a whereas a 0 = 1* the exponent k0 + e 0
has to be subtracted.
Thus
/
(11.7)
^
/kl
V . ^ k n > 0 "
, + 1 \ / k n-2V k + e n"A- S oV
Vl/'>n-3A
V2
/
k-[|]-So0O k + l - e ^ - S o ^ J - k o
Xt
a
with
S0^)
= kQ + + k n _ 2
> pf = i ; ( - k v k > k - ^ * -
(;_)..
1969]
D(0)
(11.9)
,<D
,(2) _
&M
v
429
ki
k
r //k,
/ kl -- (k
(k0 ++ ki)\
kl)V -[|]-(ko-*i)ak+l-(2k0+k1)
k A+/ kl \ +
0
k,kA k ;l
k ^ k + 1 - (k0 +
k
k
kl)^ -(|]-( o-*i)ak+l-(2k04k1)
(k > 0) .
It would be worthwhile to confirm (11.8) from (7.1) by specializing there a 0
1, bo = 1, aj = a, bj = ta.
3.) Reduced multiple uniform cases: some a,,. = 0, the other a
V
v
a ^ 0 (i" = ! , ,n - 1).
a) Cases with a _ 1 = a ^ 0.
As we saw in Section 10, in these cases, the general reduction (10.4) to
unrestricted summation is effective.
V = "V-l
K = Vl " !
for a11
if
"' ^ "
V =
wift
'
L:-0
- (x:/)
drop out becoming 1, and that the linear form S0(^) is changed to no longer
homogeneous linear functions Spfa)
430
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
[Nov.
We illustrate this in the two eases where all but one or all of the coefficients aj,* ,a
(i)
are
i>*"'ar-l'
specialized to 0.
a
o = ;
"-n-2
r+l'"
=a ^ 0
(1 < r < n - 2)
L',k"\ 'A
"
/
/
\v
k>0
\
= ( > , , r - 1}
.(y)
(11.10)
k-SJ,(k',k"),
;',k\
k1
k"
^)
\v
= r, ,n-2/
') k+l-SJ/k^k")
/ k \ / k + 1 - S^(k',k")\ k-^J-S^k'.k'-: a
(n-1)
k>*
:',k"\k'A
k"
vv
1/
y
for
v - r
0
for
for
==
=
=
(),
0,'" , rr - 1 )
r,-- , n - 2 }
n - 1
)
and
Sj,(k',k")
(ii)
for
v - r for
0
for
v = 0, , r - l )
1/ = r ,
M n - 1
l''"'an-2 "
n - 2>
)
1969]
(11.11)
(V)
431
k + e
Ei
1
k
k<
'
/
\v
\
= n - 1 /
S^k')
and
S^(k') = Sj/k'J'+k' = nk' + V for v = 0 , - - - ,n-2
nk'
for V = n - 1
(0)
(11.12) {
k
2k 1
k - 2k'
- l\/t
< . "L'5j" '" k-3k'-l
^,
a
k-|-gj-2k'
( k > 0)
k+1_3k,
a
\
The term with k = 0, kf = 0 in the second formula is an example for the
necessity of our deviating convention after (10.2), (10.2?) about the binomial
coefficients with negative "numerator. " From the recurrency
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
432
[Nov.
4] = IPS + P-2 + ^ 1
with
p(1) = 0
it is obvious that p^
= 0.
p(1) = 1
p(1) = 0
with negative exponents of t and a into the bargain, if the binomial coefficient
~
of the first term of the sum would be given the usual value 1.
b) Cases with a
- = 0
, a
We shall consider here again only cases where all but one of the coefficients a- , %a
the recurrency
is trivial.
Let a
_ p Jv)
k-n
the pair a 0 = 1, a
result (8.8).
(i) a 4 = a ^ 0; a 2 , - " , a n _ ! = 0
Here, in (8.8) are to be added the summation conditions
K
2 = =
n-2
= K
>
so that now
S(m) = S(K0,K) = K0 + (n - 1)K
For r = 1
1969]
Z
S<K,
K K
( )
433
lEj-laK-Ko
K)=k+nVK'/
S(Ko,K)=k+n\ K9 " V
(i-^\K-Kn
(11.13)
K-K 0
S(K,
k>()\
l" ""7
.K-Kn
K
S{K0,K)=k+(n- . y ) \ o /
k > 0
= l , - - ' . n - 11'
K0 =
j k - (n - 1)K
for v = 0
| k + (n - V) - <n - 1)K for v = ! , ,n - if
Making this substitution, we can however no longer silently pass over the summation conditions 0 < K0 < K. Thus we obtain
inlnK-k
(n-l)K<k<nK\^ k - (n - l)Kf *
(Hi)
(11.14)
M
=
(n-l)K<k5(n-.)<nK(
k +
(n
" ^ "
<n "
1 ) K
X^lnJ-^nK-k^n-^)
>
y V = !,'',n
We illustrate this by the lowest case:
\
- 1J
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
434
[Nov.
n = 3
(
2K<k<3k \k
^
- 2K)
K
t -[3Ja3K-k
tHjd" 1 a3K-k-2
(i)
(11.15)
2K<k+2<3K
,?2<3K\k
P?
2K
k+ 1 2K
c?i<3K(
2K<k+l<3K
)
*
t
L13]
J
3K-k-l
( k > 0)
a ^ , - 9*Rmml = 0; a^ = a ^ 0
(2 < r < n - 2)
= K
r - 11
= K,
= K
- = Kf
n-1
so that now
= S(K,K T ) = rK + (n - r)K'
SW
T h u s (8.8) b e c o m e s
(V)
Pk
(11.16)
S(K,K )=k+(n-i^)
y
S(K
Mt K '"Lnl a K'-K
k>o
1969]
435
a r e equal, or else:
n = 2r
for
v =
for y
> e e 8 ' n / 2 ~ *
=n/2,"--,n-l
(v)
/
Hence the sequences p
contain non-zero terms:only for k = z^modn/2,
respectively. Putting accordingly
k =
lfh
for v= 0 , -
l l h + (. } )
for
* -
n - 1
' 92
... ,n- 1
(h > 0) ,
K +K
h +1
for i> = , ,n - 1
h - K
for
h + 1 - K
for
V = , , n - 1
Thus in this very special case the non-zero terms of the sequences pJ
the unrestricted sums
are
436
FIBONACCI QUARTERLY
Bh+,
2
KV
^=0,.--,2-V
(11.17)
(t>)
Nov. 1969
v / h + l-K\
K I'M Tf
L2J
h+l-2K
- W
~ KV h -L2j" K h-2K
/ h >: 0\
(11.18)
P
2h+(^-2)
V- / h + 1 - K \ . h ""L2j"" K Q h+l-2K
K\
/ h >> 0 \
^=2,3J'
L. Bernstein and H. Hasse, "Einheitenberechnung mittels de JacobiPerronschen Algorithmus," Journ. reine angew. Math. 218 (1965), 51-69.
5.
6.
P{X = j}
=(J
l/\>
i = 1.2,---.n
where
n
E aJn
= B , n = l , 2 ,
n
3=1
given by
n
(1.2)
D(X ) = J ] ik(Ji/\
= B n k) / B n
(sa
^;
j=l
438
(1)
n
(2)
Q\
= B
(k)
[Nov.
a r e given by
+1
n+1
- B
= B _^ - 2B
n+2
n+1
= B ^ - 3B ^ Q + OB ^ + B
n+3
n+2
n+1
n
B ( 4 ) = B . - 4B ^ Q + OB ^ + 4B , - + B
n
n+4
n+3
n+2
n+1
n
B ( 5 ) = B _L_ - 5B ^ + OB ^ Q + 10B ^ 0 + 5B _,, - 2B .
n
n+5
n+4
n+3
n+2
n+1
n
T h i s led us to look for an e x p r e s s i o n for B
(k)
in t e r m s of the Bell n u m b e r s
B ,, j B ,, - , , , B
of the f o r m
n+k
n+k-1
' n
i=0
The f i r s t few C ,
C3 = 1 ,
i = 1 , 2 , '
a r e given by C 0 = 1,
Cj = - 1 , C 2 = 0,
In Section 3 , we will d e r i v e s o m e
In Section 4 , we will o b -
, n=0,l,2,i--}
nential g e n e r a t i n g function,
oo
(2.1)
2^
k=0
k
k
KT
= e x p (1
~ eX)
is defined by i t s e x p o -
1969]
439
From the power series expansion of exp (1 - e ) we will give an infinite series
representation for C, .
Proposition 1;
(2.2)
= e
M ) r
rT'
k = 0,1,2,- .
r=0
exp (1 - e x ) = e Y j ( - l ) r e x r /r. ?
r=0
z
P
6
LJ
r=0
lXr
( 1)
"
r!
OO
V
LJ-
k=0
k k
-iLk!
OO
k=0
r=0
= e
S(-1)r7FJ
k = 0,1,2,'-
r=0
We will use this series representation to obtain the relationship between the
Stirling numbers of the second kind cr? and C. . We define a 0 = 1 and cr =
0, k = 1 , 2 , " - .
Proposition 2:
k
(2.3)
Ck = J^ ^ H
440
[Nov.
j-0
k
r=0
r=0
j=0
--h^h^
r=0
k
j=0
i k
j=0
r=j
j=0
which proves the result since A^O ) = j - 0 " ^
Customarily, Stirling numbers of the first kind a r e defined a s numbers
with alternate signs, whereas Stirling numbers of the second kind a r e defined
as numbers with positive signs. The relation (2.3) for the C , and the corresponding relation for the Bell numbers B , given by
B =V<r>
n
L*d n
j=0
suggest that the Stirling numbers of the second kind may also be defined with
alternate signs.
1969]
441
(2 4)
k+1 = - Z ( j ) C j
k = 0 , l , . . . ; C0 = 1
j=0
Proof:
k+1
k + i = Z <-' V
r=l
= e (-1)S+1
^ -
s=0
s=0
j=0
) sJ
= -E0>E^ = -E0h
j=0 * '
s=0
j=0
satisfies an n
order dif-
ference equation. As before, let A denote the difference operator and let E
= 1 + A, so that E:iC() = C ,
j = 1,2,' " .
Proposition 4:
(2.5)
A*Cl =
( 1)n 3
" (\ jJ)/C M
J'r-L
~ C n'n
n = 1,2,-
3=0
Proof. The first equality will be established by the binomial expansion
1) ,, and
and the
the second
second equality
equality follows
follows from
from proposition
pr
of (E! -- 1)
1.
pleteness, the proof is sketched on the following page.
For com-
442
[Nov.
n
n
j=0
^ 4=0.
r=l
j=0
00
r=l
T h e difference equation A C- = - C
for s m a l l v a l u e s of n.
T h i s computation can b e a r r a n g e d in a t r i a n g u l a r a r r a y
C!
(2.6)
can b e u s e d on computing C i , C 2 , * , C n
ACi
A2CA
A 3 Ci
C2
AC 2
A C2
A C2
c3
AC 3
A2C3
...
C4
AC 4
...
c5
...
A 4 Ci
.-
u s to find C 2 = C t + AC 4 = 0.
= - C 2 = 0.
enables
C 3 , we find C 3 = 1.
(2.7)
differences
-1
0
1
1
-2
-9
0 - 1 - 1
1 - 1 - 2 1
0 - 3 - 1
-3
-4
-7
1969]
443
21.
3. RELATIONSHIPS BETWEEN THE BELL NUMBERS B , AND THE C
n
n
It is well known (Riordan [5]) that the exponential generating function of
the Bell numbers B is given by
(3.1)
J B
n=0
= exp (e x - 1)
B
= r
n!
and
C
= rn!
(3 2)
1 J \k/BkCn-k
k=0
n =
'2'"*'
with
fih
L l i h V i r
j=0
'
Proposition 6:
(3.3)
n o 0.1,2.-
444
[Nov.
xk-i
L k-3bi)7 =
eXex
p<eX-1)
k=l
we obtain
(H(l^) -'
which implies that
oo
n=0
(n) ZL =
l
n!
ee
where
< - (?hvn
as defined in the introduction.
/\
= 1, h = 0 , l , 2 , - " ,
since
oo
e =
n
v^ i x
L1^
n=0
is the exponential generating function of the sequence with unity in every place.
A !dualT to proposition 6 can be stated as
1969]
445
Proposition 7:
(3.4)
(b c
n = 0,1,2,-
-1.
n+l-j
Proof. This follows along the same lines as that of Proposition 6, where
we now differentiate the exponential generating function of the C .
4. DETERMINANTAL REPRESENTATIONS OF C
We noted in Section 3 that the sequences
j - m
and
{",
(c }
/ .vii
( 1} a
-n-1
a
a
2
a
Vi
a
n
(-l)na-n"16n
Vs
n- 2
a n-1
n-2
can be shown,
n-1
n = E <-!>
k=0
0ak+l
n-k-l'
= 1
we will have
(say).
446
[Nov.
P r o p o s i t i o n 8:
C
a)
<-l)n
n!
"B.
1
1!
2
2!
(4.1)
3
3!
n
n!
(4.2)
(-D
b)
TT
2
2!
l
1!
-,
n-1
ft=Tjl
(-l)n^n
...
(say)
BJ
B o BJ
n-2
(57151 1!
n-1
-a
= V (- 1 )
Bk+
k=0
'n+1
n = 0,1,2,3=0 V /
'n+1
(-1)
1
1
(4.3)
1
1 1
t)
1969]
447
'n+1
n+li 1
(-1)"
1
1!
1
2!
1
1!
1
31
1
2!
1
1!
1
n!
rar
Tn^2Fl
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The authors would like to express their sincere thanks to Dr. A. S.
Householder, for his comments on an earlier draft
REFERENCES
1. H. Finlayson, "Numbers Generated by exp (e x - 1)," Masters thesis, 1954,
University of Alberta, Canada.
2. J. Ginsburg, "Iterated Exponentials," Scripta Mathematica, 11, 1945, pp.
340-353.
3. C. Jordan, Calculus of Finite Differences, Chelsea Publishing Co. , New
York, 1947.
4. L. Moser and M. Wyman, "On an Array of Aitken," Trans. Roy. Soc.
Canada, 48 (1954), pp. 31-37.
5. J. Riordan, An Introduction to Combinatorial Analysis? Wiley? New York,
1958.
448
t> CO CO CO (M rH
OS CO LO O t- OS
l> -^ 00 rH OS rH
CO LO CM CO CM CO
CO O 00 L> "*
OS OS -*# C- CO CO
H H O O H Q 0
I rH CO <M CO CO
I I CM LO rH
CO LO
CO CO Oi CM rH CM
CO "^H
L> L> CO OS rH 00 L>
rH OS ^F CM 00 L> OS
CO CM LO CO OS
rH L> 00 CO rH rH LO
rH OS ^ CO CO OS
I CM CO ^ CO E- LO
I rH T# I> CO O
I I H t- Cft
CO 00
C O C O C O L O t - ^ t - r H
CM
O S r H O O L O L O O C O C O O L O t - O O L O
xtfiLOLOCOOSCOO-tfiCOrHfNICOCO
I
rHrHrHL>rH00L>COC0COrH
rHCOCOOOtMOOOOrH
I TH ^ rH CO
CM OS OS <N
I rH CO rH
I I (N
*vH
00
CO
CM
LO
^ 00 CO
CM rH rH rH
I CM OS CM
I I rH
O
CO
CO
LO
S3
<J
rH rH CM rH rH T^I LO
CM ^ LO CO CO
I CM rH
CO
I rH
CO
rHrHCMrHl>O0O5rHCDLOO5i00COrH<
rH OS
I
rH^tlT^CMCOLOCMLOCOCOrHCOf
OS CO
C O ^ L O a S O C D O S ^
00 L>
I CM L> LO LO rH CD CD ^H rH
I
I
rH OS rH
O LO rH
o as
o
CM CM OS 00
CM
rH CM rH
OS CO rH T ^ rH
LO LO
00 CO
r H ( N r H r H N C C C O O 5 c 0 C N I r H C i ^ L O r H C M t >
I
I
l r H W C l N C O r H C f c < x ) O C O t > ^ C O
I CM^
, r H
, c o r j i LQ
i H O H O O ^ i f l l O t CMLO^COLOLO"^
LO co as oo oo
0 ( N l a i
> C N
rH L> 00 CO L>
I CM CO
CM
I rH CO OS
O H C 0 ^ t > 0 5 C 0 H Q 0 0 H H ( M H W C 0 Q H 5 0
I
I
I
I
LOLOt-COlOLOrHrHLOCMCMCO
rH
Ib-asCMlOOSCMOOOOLO-sjHLO
CMCMD-C0LOLOrHC0L>(MCM
I
rHrHOSOSrHt-rHCOCMLO
I
I r H C O r H C M O O C O ' ^
rH CD OS LO LO CO LO
I 00 L> rH CO
CM OS CM
I rH LO TH
H C 0 t > a S L > C O C 0 r H C M a S r H C M r H a S 0 0 a S
L>
I
I
LOrH->vr,aSLOCML>LOL>-*^LO
CMrHLOLO00L>CO00asi>-^00
l>
<NLOCMCrHaSC0rHC0
00
I
rHCOCDLOb-aSrHOO'^'
I
IrHOOOSCMrHr^OSrH
r H t > r H l > CM LO OS
I 00 CO L> 00
CM CM CM OS
I CM L> CO
I
I CO
)rH<Niasast-corHcocoL>asoorHasooas
I
| L O c O r H 0 0 C 0 C 0 l > a s c O r H C O L O a S
C M ^ T H L > L O r H L > C D l > L O C 0 C 0
C N J L > C O 0 0 0 0 L O C O 0 0
I
rHLOrHCOCOCOb-LOCDOO
I
IrHOSOSCO^OSOOCM
rH OS 00 00 CO CM
t> rfH rH L>
CM LO 00 rH
i C M as t1 I CM
CO-vHrHLOTjlCO^CM
LOCOCOOCOTfCMCM
OCTSCOOi-vHcOOO
LOLOCOrHOOCM^O
I rH rH LO L> CO CO
CM CD O LO CO OS
I rH CO rH LO LO
I
I rH 00 t>
CO CM
CO
H^HWOt-t-^ifl
COCOCMCSlOascOrHCO
L>CMCDCSC0C0LO
t-COCONt-HWLOLO
rHCO
CM -# CO OS CO CO
rH CM 00 00 CM LO
CM 00 00 CO O OS
I rH L> CO OS <#
II
00 CO
CO CO
rHLOCOasaSCOOSLO
CO
COHt>C5O5-^^t-C0l>
OS L>
CO
LO 00
rHCSrHl>rHCMCOLOL>CM
CMCTSOOCOrHOOCS-^OCO
rH00C5C0l>rHCMLO
CM rH CM
CM OS CM
I CM OS CO
I I I
5>
LO
00 L>
CM L>
00 ^
CO
co c- oo co as as LO -^
rH frCDfc-CO
LO ^t<
LO r I 00
|> CO ^H
-# ^
CM
r H C O t - L O ^ H L O O S ^ C M L> OS
^ t - L Q C O L O m t - ^ O
1 rHrHOSCOTj<CMCMt>
CM CM rH CM LO rH
co as
as ^
oo as t>
rH CM 00 rH CM ^
rH CM rH CO
I CM CM 00
L> rH L>
CM 00 rH
CM LO
V rH rH
L > L > l O 0 0 t - C 0 C M t > r H r H
COOOOOCOrHCDOOOOCMLOCOTH
CMCOL>COCMCMLOLOrHrH
I
lrHCMCMaSLO00l>COCD
CMC0C000Q0CMCOrH
rHCO^LOOOCMCOLO
rH CO T ^ 00 CO 00
I CM " * (M rH CO
I rH CO CO - ^
I
I CO L>
l>L>LOCOC0LOCMC0l>00
LOrHOSaSLOt-^'^CMLOOLOOS
icoas
oo^t-iflcoHt-rHLO
i i
cMLO^oooascoasLO
cMLoasasi>L>Lot>
rHrt<OSLOCOCOl>CM
i ^ as L> oo t>
CM CD OS
I rH ^
I
I
rHCMC0TtlLOCOl>00asiHC
co co
LO rH
rH LO
00 CM
CM
M C LO
0
00 CO CO
i <& i I LO
t- co as co
oo co L> co
CO CO CO rH
CO 00 CM LO
oo as as co
i co oo co
CM
CM
CO 00
as
co
co
oo
co as
oo LO co
co as oo
L> oo co
L>
as
rH
CM
co
CO L> LO CM <*
as LO CM LO
OS 00 rH
L>
rH CM CO "SH LO
SUSTAINING MEMBERS
*H* L 9 A l d e r
V. V. A l d e r m a n
G. L , A l e x a n d e r son
R. H. Anglin
*J o s e p h A r k i n
L a r r y Badii
Col. R. S. B e a r d
Leon B e r n s t e i n
* M a r j o r i e Bicknell
John W. Biggs
F r a n k Boehm
J . Le Bohnert
M. B B o i s e n , J r .
L . H. B r a c k e n b e r r y
* T e r r y Brennan
C. A. B r i d g e r
Leonard Bristow
Maxey Brooke
* B r o , A. B r o u s s e a u
*J. L. Brown, J r .
C. R. Burton
* P a u l F . Byrd
N . S. C a m e r o n
L. Carlitz
L . C. C a r p e n t e r
P . V. C h a r l a n d
P. J . Cocussa
D. B . Cooper
J . R. C r e n s h a w
D . E . Daykin
J . W. D e C e l i s
F . DeKoven
J . E . Desmond
A. W. Dickinson
N. A. D r a i m
D. C Duncan
M. H. E a s t m a n
C. F . E l l i s
H. S. E l l s w o r t h
Merritt Elmore
^Charter Members
R. S* E r l e i n
H. W. E v e s
R. A. F a i r b a i r n
A, J e F a u l c o n b r i d g e
* H . H. F e r n s
D. C. F i e l d e r
E. T. Frankel
H. M. Gehman
G. R. Glabe
E . L 0 Godfrey
Ruth Goodman
*H . W. Gould
Nicholas G r a n t
G. B . G r e e n e
B . H. Gundlach
*J e H. Halton
W. R, H a r r i s f J r .
V. C. H a r r i s
L . B . Hedge
Cletus Hemsteger
*Aa P . Hillman
B r u c e H. H o e l t e r
*V. E . Hoggatt, J r .
*A F . H o r a d a m
D. F . Howells
J . A. H. Hunter
*Dov J a r d e n
*S. K. J e r b i c
J . H. J o r d a n
D. A. K l a r n e r
Kenneth K l o s s
D E . Knuth
Eugene K o h l b e c k e r
Sidney K r a v i t z
George L e d i n , J r .
Hal L e o n a r d
Eugene Levine
J . B L e w i s
*D. A. Lind
*C. T . Long
A. F . Lopez
F . W. Ludecke
J . S Madachy
*J. A. Maxwell
* S i s t e r M . D e S a L e s McNabb
John Mellish, J r .
C. T . M e r r i m a n
M r s . Lucile Morton
Mel Most
Stephen Nytch
R o g e r O f Connell
P . B. Onderdonk
F. J. Ossiander
E . A. P a p e
R. J . P e g i s
M. M. Risueno
*D. W. Robinson
*Azriel Rosenfeld
T. J. Ross
F . G. Rothwell
I. D . Ruggles
H. J . Schafer
J . A. S c h u m a k e r
H. D. Seielstad
B . B . Sharpe
E . R. Shenton
G. Singh
David S i n g m a s t e r
A. N. Spitz
M. N. S. Swamy
A. S y l v e s t e r
*D. E . T h o r o
H. L . U m a n s k y
M. E . Waddill
*C 8 R. WaU
* L . A. W a l k e r
R. J . Weinshenk
R. A. White
V. White
H. E . Whitney
P . A. Willis
C h a r l e s Ziegenfus
THE CALIFORNIA
MATHEMATICS COUNCIL