ن إل
ّ يا أيها الذين آمنوا اتقوا الله حق ُتقاته ول تموت
وأنتم مسلمون
“O you who believe! Fear Allāh as He should be feared,
and die not except in a state of Islām.”1
This topic is among the many topics that has divided the ummah into
three camps. You have two at the two extremes while the third in
between them. Those with the ‘khawaarij’ ideology or having
1
Surah ale-Imrān 3:102
1
inclinations towards them conclude that since the system or
Government is a disbelieving one, then it is completely not allowed for
anyone that believes in Allah (swt) to take up any kind of work directly
under it. Anyone that takes up any form of work under it, they pass the
judgment of ‘kufr’ (disbelieve) on him.
The path which is between the two, the path of Ahl-Sunnah Wal-
Jama’ah believe that from amongst the works are some that take one
out of Islam even if the person that does the work did not intend going
out of Islam (because that work is from amongst the nullifiers of Islam).
Some are classified as ‘haram’ (forbidden) which does not take its doer
out of Islam as long as he does not make it ‘halal’ (i.e. justify the work
by seeing nothing wrong in it and to accredit, authorize or approve
participating in it.). Some are seen as ‘makruh’ (discouraged) while
others are seen as ‘mubah’ (allowed).
ِ دو
{ن ُ ن
ْ م
ِ مْ ُ ما ل َك
َ و ْ ُ سك
َ م الّناُر ّ م َ موا
َ َ فت ُ َ ن ظَل َ ذيِ ّ ول ت َْرك َُنوا إ َِلى ال
َ
َ ّ
113 :ن{ ]هود َ صُرو َ م ل ُتن ّ ُ ول َِياءَ ث
ْ نأ ْ م ِ ه
ِ ]الل.
And don’t recline towards the wrong doer lest you be
(punished) with the fire. And then, you shall have (besides
Allah) no guardian nor will you be helped.
2
ن ْ َ ل ي،دي ُ َ مَراءُ ي ُ َ قا َ ،(ء؟ َ س
َ دو ُ َ قت ِ ع ْ َن ب َ كوُنو َ )أ:ل ِ ها َ ف ّ ماَرةُ ال َ ِإ
َ
م
ْ ه ُ َ عان َ وأ َ م ْ ه ِ َ م ب ِك
ِ ِ ذب ْ ه ُ ق َ ّ صد َ ن ْ م َ ف َ ،سن ِّتي ُ ِن ب َ ست َّنو ْ َ ول ي َ ،هدِْيي َ ِب
ُ
ّ َ عل
ي َ دوا ُ ر ِ َ ول ي َ ،م ْ ه ُ ْ منِ ت ُ س ْ َ ول َ مّني ِ سوا ُ ْ ك ل َي َ ِ فأول َئ َ م ْ ه ِ م ِ ْ عَلى ظُل َ
م؛ ْ ه ْ ُ َ َ َ ْ ّ صد َ
ِ مِ على ظل َ م ْ ه ُ ْ عن ِ ُم ي ْ ول َ م ْ هِ ِ ذبِ م ب ِك ْ ه
ُ ق
َ
َ ُم ي ْ نل ْ م َ و
ُ
َ ،ضي ِ و ْ حَ
ضي ِ و ْ حَ ي ّ َ عل َ دوا ُ ر ِ َ سي َ و َ ،م ْ ه ُ ْ من ِ وأَنا َ مّني ِ ك َ ِ فأول َئ َ ...).
Imam Ahmad, At-tirmizi, An-nasaa’I, and others transmitted
with an authentic chain on the authourity of Jaabir bn Abdullah
(ra), that the He (saw), said to ka’ab bn ujrah: (May Allah
fortify you from the leadership of the foolish), he said; (and
what is the leadership of the foolish?), He (saw) said; (rulers
that will come after me, they don’t take after my guidance nor
do they emulate my sunnah. Whosoever believe them in their
lies and help them in their oppression, such are not from me
and I am not from them and they shall not meet me by the
pond. For those did not belive in their lies and didn’t help
them in their oppression, such are from me and I am from
them and they shall meet me at the pond.2
قال رسول:عن أبي هريرة وأبي سعيد رضي الله عنهما قال
، )ليأتين عليكم أمراء سفهاء:الله صلى الله عليه وسلم
فمن،يقربون شرار الناس ويؤخرون الصلة عن مواقيتها
أدرك ذلك منهم؛ فل يكونن عريفا ً ول شرطيا ً ول جابيا ً ول
ً )خازنا
Abu Hurairah and abu sa’id (ra) said; the Rasul (saw) said;
(soon, will appear upon you some foolish leaders. They shall
draw close to them the worst of men and they shall delay the
salaah away from its time. Anyone that meets them should
2
This hadith is not in anyway referring to the rulers that have left Islam by preferring
Democracy other than Islam. For we know from another ahadith that those that will
not meet the Rasul (saw) at al-kawthar are the people of bid’ah and not kufaar. To
proof that show the kufr of one that rules willingly with other than the Shariah are
much. Please refer to the book “Al-Sirat” by Abdullah Ya’sin. This book brings the
statement of 49 scholars of the ahl sunnah wal jama’ah on the issue and leaves the
reader to judge for himself.
3
At-tabari and others narrated it with a sound chain.
3
never be an ‘arif’ (an position of authority like being a
corporal, monitor, etc), nor should he be a policeman, nor a
revenue collector, nor a treasurer)4
4
( كتاب الحكام13/123) راجع كلم الحافظ في الفتح
وتفاصيل ذلك ليس هذا محلها كما قلنا من قبل إنما محلها
( حيث بيان كيف نصر الدين بالحديد،في كتابنا )نزع الحسام.
Hafidh ibn Hajar (rh) said in fathul baari as regarding the ruler that has
clearly perpetrated kufr; “(it is compulsory on every Muslim to stand
against him and work towards forcefully deposing him) he mentioned
that people as regarding such situations are in three groups; the one
that is able on forcefully removing him, this person has a (great)
reward. (The second is) the one that is not able to forcefully remove
him, on such, it become compulsory on him to leave that land. (The
third is the one) that (flatters, compliments or bootlick), on such is a
(great) sin.”6
6
Al Fathul Bari sarh sahih Bukhari. (13/123)
7
According to the understanding of the pious predecessors, they see kufr and shirk
as same. For any one that falls into shirk has committed kufr and vice-versa. An
example to clarify this is the hadith of tariku-sallah. The Rasul (saw) described this
act as shirk in some ahadith while he described as kufr in some others. Please refer
to tahzeeb of sharh of aqidatu at-tahweiyah by Shaykh AbdulMunim Mustapha Halima
(hz) for more details.
5
verse was revealed; haven’t you seen the one that belies Our
..…signs and say
ً لحتمال أن يكون مقيدا- أي الجواز- )ولم يجزم المصنف بالحكم:"قال ابن حجر في "الفتح
ومنابذتهم وقبل المر بعدم إذلل المؤمن، أو أن جواز ذلك كان قبل الذن في قتال المشركين،بالضرورة
.(نفسه
، إل لضرورة بشرطين- أي العمل عند المشركين- )كره أهل العلم ذلك:ثم نقل عن المهّلب قوله
( والخر؛ أن ل يعينه على ما يعود ضرره على المسلمين،أحدهما؛ أن يكون عمله فيما يحل للمسلم فعله
ibn Hajar (rh) said; “…. And he the writer (i.e. Bukhari) didn’t resolve
on the ruling of approval because of the possibility of –the approval-
being conditioned by necessity, or (of the possibility of this ruling (of
approval)) being only before the injunction of fighting the mushrikeen
and opposing them was revealed, or (of the possibility of it) being
before the (injunction) of preventing a believer from humiliating
himself (was reavealed)” he (i.e. ibn Rajab) then quoted al Mahlab
thus; “the scholars detest this -i.e. working under the mushrikeen-
except for (cases) of necessity but with two conditions. The first
condition; that the work should be a kind of work that a Muslim
ordinarily is allowed to do, secondly, that he should never partake or
assist in anything that its repercussion will translate to harm on the
Muslims.8
8
Fathu Bari (4/452)
6
2. That the work must not be a form of helping kufr or the kufaar
against Muslims nor should it be a work that exposes the secrets
of the Muslims to the kufaar.
The type that is neither of the two above, we don’t say anything
except that it is disliked. And we declare it as being disliked
because of the fear that the Muslim may be dominated (by the
kuffar) and thus his right be denied and he will be weakened and
be forced to do something that pleases them (i.e. the
mushrikeen) in order to get his right, just as same was requested
from the great companion Khabaab (ra) by the disbeliever and
was denied his wages. Also, for the fear of he (i.e. the Muslim)
being accustomed to the ways of the kufaar and thus (because of
long mingling with them) develop an intimacy that gradually
erodes the injunction of al-walla wal-baraa, the injunction of love
and hate for the sake of Allah. As you have seen that when
Khabaab was working with them, he was honourably and openly
practicing his deen and never did he flatter (or become
apologetic) not withstanding his weakness (i.e. not regarding
being under their authority). The one that uses his (i.e.
Khabaab’s) case as prove has to consider his aforementioned
situation.”9
Abu Khadijah
9
المصابيح المنيرة في الرد على أسئلة أهل الجزيرة
7
(20th November 2009)