International Archives of
Allergy
Immunology
and
Abstract
Background: There is little information available about
the development of T-cell immunity in healthy and
atopic children. We have studied prospectively the
mean fluorescence intensity of the T-cell receptor complex-associated CD3, CD4 and CD8 in relation to atopic
family history (AFH) and the development of atopic disease. Methods: Children with a defined AFH (n = 172)
were followed from birth to 18 months and the cumulative history of atopic disease was recorded. Blood samples were obtained at birth and at 18 months, and in a
subgroup of 78 children also at 3, 6 and 12 months. Multicolour flow cytometry was used to analyse pan T-cells
(CD3+CD45+CD14-), T-helper-(CD3+CD4+) and T-cytotoxic-(CD3+CD8+) cells. Results: At 18 months, 31 children were atopic and 118 non-atopic. Children who developed atopic disease had a higher CD4 expression
(mean fluorescence intensity, MFI) on CD4+CD3+ lymphocytes at birth and at 3 months, particularly as compared with non-atopic children without AFH. Furthermore, the CD3 expression on CD3+CD45+CD14
lymphocytes increased more slowly with age in children with double atopic heredity, as compared with
children with no or only one atopic family member.
Conclusions: The higher expression of the CD4 receptor
in early infancy in children who developed atopic disease compared with non-atopics suggests a delayed expression in T-helper cells. Children with a strong AFH
had a slower increase in the expression of CD3, indicating a delayed T-cell maturation.
Introduction
Downloaded by:
Emory University
198.143.47.33 - 7/8/2015 4:30:40 PM
Key Words
T-lymphocyte CD3 CD4 CD8 MFI Newborns
Atopic disease
Study Population
Pregnant mothers at seven maternity-care centres in Linkping
were informed of the study and 172 families accepted to participate.
All children were born at the University Hospital in Linkping. At 3,
6, 12 and 18 months the parents were asked to complete a mailed
questionnaire related to possible allergic symptoms in their children.
At 18 months, a medical examination was done by one of us (H.Z.),
focusing on signs of atopic disease. In addition, a skin prick test was
performed, a venous blood sample was obtained by venipuncture after application of percutaneous anaesthesia. A family history of atopy
in the immediate family, i.e. parents and siblings of the baby, was obtained through two interviews, once at the beginning of the study and
once for rechecking the history at the 18 months follow-up visit. Double (single/no) atopic heredity implied that at least two (one/no) parents and/or siblings had a convincing history of atopic disease.
Venous blood samples were drawn at birth and at 18 months
(range 16.621.0 months). In order to reduce the number of blood
samples, for both ethical and financial reasons, and to prevent drop
outs, venous blood samples were drawn at 3 (2.54.4 months), 6
(5.37.3 months) and 12 months (11.313.5 months) only from 78
children, in addition to the samples at birth and 18 months. Thus,
blood samples were obtained from 141 infants at birth, and from 66,
71, 69 and 137 children respectively at 3, 6, 12 and 18 months. Missing samples were due to technical reasons, e.g. birth during weekends
when research laboratory facilities were unavailable, clotting of the
cord blood, difficulties with drawing the blood sample, and technical
failure in the laboratory.
Eleven samples were discarded as they were obtained from 3 children with diseases which possibly could have interfered with the
study (IgA deficiency, congenital hypothyreosis and mental retardation due to suspected mitochondrial disease). Another 6 cord blood
Flow Cytometry
The following murine IgG monoclonal antibodies were used: T3ECD (CD3), T4-FITC (CD4) and T8-FITC (CD8) (Coulter Co,
Hialeah, Calif., USA), CD45-FITC/CD14-PE (Dako, Copenhagen,
Denmark). The control antibodies included IgG1-FITC/IgG2a-RPE
(Dako), MsIgG2b-ECD and MsIgG1-FITC (Coulter Co). Time-control studies comparing freshly stained and analysed cord blood samples with cord blood samples stained after 24 h and then analysed
yielded similar results in four pilot experiments. The cord blood samples were stained within 24 h (median: 12.3 h, range: 2.024 h), and
then analysed within 6 h. The 3-, 6-, 12- and 18-month samples were
all stained within 3.5 h and then analysed within 4 h.
Twenty-five microlitres EDTA-whole blood was incubated with
5 l monoclonal antibodies for 10 min at ambient room temperature
and erythrocytes were lysed, using 1 ml of Ortho-mune Lysing
Reagent (Ortho Diagnostic Systems Inc., Raritan, N.J., USA), for 15
min, also at room temperature, followed by centrifugation at 400 g for
5 min at 4C. The pellet was resuspended in 1 ml buffer with 0.08%
HSA (Apoteksbolaget, Stockholm, Sweden) and 0.1% paraformaldehyde (Sigma-Aldrich).
Three-colour (FITC, RPE/RD1/PE, and ECD) flow cytometry
was performed on an EPICS Profile cytometer (Coulter). A lymphocyte gate was set according to characteristic forward and side scatter.
Each sample was saved in an ungated version to list mode files, and
7
Downloaded by:
Emory University
198.143.47.33 - 7/8/2015 4:30:40 PM
The T-cell maturation process of children is poorly understood, but there is evidence that it may be defective in
atopic children [reviewed in ref. 4]. Therefore, the present
study was designed to prospectively compare the maturation process in normal and atopic children by following the
expression (measured as mean fluorescence intensity; MFI)
of the T-cell surface antigens CD3, CD4 and CD8 during
the first 18 months of life in a large cohort of children. Special reference was made to atopic family history and the development of atopic disease within this period. Threecolour flow cytometry was used to analyse peripheral blood
cells expressing the pan T-cell marker CD3 and the leucocyte marker CD45, excluding cells expressing the monocyte marker CD14. Further, the T-helper- (CD3+CD4+) and
the T-cytotoxic (CD3+CD8+) cells were analysed. Since
there still are no methods available for accurately identifying individuals who later will develop atopic disease in early childhood [5], the levels of MFI expression of CD3, CD4
and CD8 as predictive markers for atopic disease were also
evaluated.
60
]]]
]
50
CD3 MFI
40
30
20
10
]]]
0
Age, months
12
18
n=
77
60
63
65
135
Ethical Aspects
The study was approved by the Human Research Ethics Committee of the Medical Faculty at Linkping University.
Results
Aniansson Zdolsek/Ernerudh/Holt/
Nilsson/Bjrkstn
Downloaded by:
Emory University
198.143.47.33 - 7/8/2015 4:30:40 PM
Statistical Analysis
All data were approximately normally distributed. This was however difficult to decide in some analyses as the number of children in
some groups were low, e.g. for the comparisons between data of children with maternal and paternal atopic family history (AFH). In these
analyses, the Mann-Whitney U test was therefore used. One- and twoway analysis of variance were employed to compare MFI at 0, 3, 6, 12
and 18 months with respect to AFH and the occurrence of atopic disease during the first 18 months of life. Students paired t test was used
to compare changes of MFI on T-cells over time within the groups. In
atopic and non-atopic children, as well as in children with single, double and no AFH, one-way and two-way analysis of variance was performed to compare the changes of data within separate time periods
(03 months, 36 months, 612 months, 1218 months and 018
months). Only paired observations were included.
In addition, one- and two-way analysis of variance was performed
to compare the slopes (changes/month) in atopic and non-atopic children and in children with different AFH. In these analyses, only children with at least two observations during the study period were included. In order to assure that the compared groups did not differ in
age when the blood samples were obtained, the mean ages were individually calculated and the mean value for each group compared with
Students t test. No significant differences were seen. A p value d0.05
was considered to be significant. Where not otherwise indicated,
mean B 1SD are reported. A positive predictive value was defined as
the proportion of atopic children with positive tests to all children
with positive tests. Sensitivity: proportion of atopic children with true
positive test to all atopic children. Specificity: proportion of nonatopic children with true negative test to all non-atopic children.
60
50
]]]
40
MFI
]]]
30
20
s
10
]]]
]]]
s
]]
0
Age, months
12
18
n=
75
59
61
65
134
17
p = 0.032
CD4 MFI
15
NS
NS
NS
11
9
p = 0.046
7
Age, months
12
18
n=
49
40
43
48
92
n=
15
13
12
11
26
9
Downloaded by:
Emory University
198.143.47.33 - 7/8/2015 4:30:40 PM
13
p value
No AFH
Single AFH
Double AFH
31
26
38
0.003
No AFH
Single AFH
Double AFH
AD
No AD
31
25
38
23
72
0.016
0.004
d0.001
0.001
d0.001
0.002
Discussion
10
Aniansson Zdolsek/Ernerudh/Holt/
Nilsson/Bjrkstn
Downloaded by:
Emory University
198.143.47.33 - 7/8/2015 4:30:40 PM
atopic disease. One possible explanation might be that children predisposed to atopy are more easily sensitised in early infancy and/or in utero or that there is a transient maturational defect in peripheral blood mononuclear cells with
takes longer to resolve in future atopics [29]. It has also
been suggested [28] that an absence of an effective Th2-inhibitory signal within the first 6 months of life may favour
expansion of Th2-memory cells in children who later on develop atopic disease.
In conclusion, our findings support that the development
of T-cell function differs between atopic and non-atopic infants.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by grants from the Medical Research
Foundation of the County of stergtland, The National Association
for the Prevention of Asthma and Allergy (RmA), The Swedish Medical Research Council (MFR project No. 07510), The Vrdal Foundation, The Foundation of Queen Silvias Jubilee Fund and the
Samariten Foundation. Assistance by the staff at the Flow Cytometry
Unit, Department of Clinical Immunology and at the Paediatric Research Unit, as well as valuable statistical assistance by Olle Eriksson
is gratefully acknowledged.
11
Downloaded by:
Emory University
198.143.47.33 - 7/8/2015 4:30:40 PM
tive studies they were similar in atopic and non-atopic individuals [21, 22]. However, a great deal of biological information is being lost by not determining the fluorescence intensity of the positive cells [23]. Flow cytometry
fluorescence intensity correlates directly with the number of
receptor molecules on the cell surface [24] and variations in
expression may reflect a functional difference [25]. To our
knowledge, this is the first prospective study following the
MFI expression of the CD3, CD4 and CD8 expression in
children.
It has been hypothesised that the balance between Th1
and Th2 memory cells is set during early childhood by a
process of an antigen-driven Th1/Th2 selection [26]. In
non-atopic individuals this will lead to a Th1 dominance,
but when the selection occasionally fails, this will lead to a
dominance for Th2 cells, and eventually atopy. We found
that CD3+CD4+ cells had a higher CD4 expression at birth
and at 3 months in children who subsequently developed
atopic disease, as compared to non-atopics. Since CD4 expression on CD3+CD4+ cells normally decreases during
the first 6 months of life, the elevated levels of expression in
atopic children may be indicative of a delayed functional
maturation. This suggestion is consistent with findings
demonstrating low interferon gamma (IFN-) producing capacity of cord blood mononuclear cells [reviewed in ref. 27]
and CD4+ cells in children [4] with an atopic family history. Further, a recent report has shown a lower IFN- production at birth by cord blood mononuclear cells and purified CD4+ cells stimulated by anti-CD3/CD2/CD28 and
interleukin 2 in children with definite atopy by 2 years compared to non-atopic children [28].
The atopic children in our study had a higher expression
of CD4 on CD3+CD4+ cells at birth and at 3 months, but
not at 6, 12 and 18 months. Miles et al. [29] reported higher
proliferation at birth in response to anti-CD3 or allergens in
infants with a positive family history who developed atopic
eczema, as compared with high-risk infants who did not develop atopic disease. Similar to our observations, these differences had all disappeared at 6 months of age. Our findings are also supported by Prescott et al. [28]. They reported
a consistent fall in cellular interleukin 4 (IL-4) mRNA responses to house dust mite in non-atopic children from birth
to 18 months of age. This appeared to be initiated during the
first 6 months of age, while atopic children continued to
show persistent IL-4 mRNA. They further observed low
IFN- responses at birth in non-atopic infants followed by a
significantly increase to 6 months of age. This was not seen
in the atopic children. Our findings may support the concept
that the first months of life, perhaps even the first 6 months
of life, is a vulnerable period for development of future
References
12
21 Miles EA, Warner JA, C LA, Jones AC, Colwell BC, Warner JO: Altered T lymphocyte
phenotype at birth in babies born to atopic parents. Pediatr Allergy Immunol 1994;5:202
208.
22 Martinez FD, Stern AD, Wright AL, Holberg
CJ, Taussig LM, Halonen M: Association of
interleukin-2 and interferon- production by
blood mononuclear cells in infancy with
parental allergy tests and with subsequent development of atopy. J Allergy Clin Immunol
1995;96:652660.
23 Schwartz A, Fernndez-Repollet E: Development of clinical standards for flow cytometry.
Ann N Y Acad Sci 1993;677:2839.
24 Sumner H, Abraham D, Bou-Gharios G,
Plater-Zyberk C, Olsen I: Simultaneous measurement of cell surface and intracellular antigens by multiple flow cytometry. J Immunol
Methods 1991;136:259267.
25 Ginaldi L, Farahat N, Matutes E, De Martinis
M, Morilla R, Catovski D: Differential expression of T-cell antigens in normal peripheral
blood lymphocytes: a quantitative analysis by
flow cytometry. J Clin Pathol 1996;49:539
544.
26 Holt PG: Immunoprophylaxes of atopy: Light
at the end of the tunnel? Immunol Today 1994;
15:484489.
27 Holt PG, Clough JB, Holt BJ, Baron-Hay MJ,
Rose AH, Robonson BWS, Thomas WR: Genetic risk for atopy is associated with delayed
postnatal maturation of T-cell competence.
Clin Exp Allergy 1992;22:10931099.
28 Prescott SL, Macaubas C, Smallacombe T,
Holt BJ, Sly PD, Holt PG: Fetal allergen-specific Th2 responses persist in atopic infants but
are rapidly suppressed in non-atopics. Lancet,
in press.
29 Miles EA, Warner JA, Jones AC, Colwell BM,
Bryant TN and Warner JO: Peripheral blood
mononuclear cell proliferative responses in the
first year of life in babies born to atopic parents. Clin Exp Allergy 1996;26:780788.
Aniansson Zdolsek/Ernerudh/Holt/
Nilsson/Bjrkstn
Downloaded by:
Emory University
198.143.47.33 - 7/8/2015 4:30:40 PM