2.
3.
4.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Bajaj Allianz
Royal Sundaram
Accidentshield
ICICI Lombard
Chola mandalam
Reliance
6.
Tata AIG
Overseas Mediclaim
Nursing expenses
dialysis,
chemotherapy,
radiotherapy,
cost
of
pacemaker,
Congenital external disease, sterility, veneral disease , intentional selfinjury, use of drugs, alcohol, rest cure etc
AIDS
10
11
Exclusions:
The normal exclusions under the Policy are
1. Pre existing disease
2. Treatment not carried out by a qualified Medical Practitioner.
3. Cosmetic & plastic surgery, unless resulting from an Accident
4. Any expense on Hospitalization incurred during first 30 days of insurance
5. Dental treatment or surgery of any kind unless due to Accident requiring
Hospitalization.
12
13
Certain diseases like hernia, cataract, piles, sinusitis etc are excluded
during the first year of operation of insurance cover.
14
15
16
17
an otherwise sane person would not do. Insurance companies say that the cost of
providing health insurance to these bad risk raises the cost of insurance to the good
insurance risks, possibly pricing them out of the market, and could create a situation in a
market where insurance was uneconomical for private insurance companies to provide.
One must also recognize that both public and private health insurance will also suffer
from ex-post moral hazard. This phenomenon is in essence the consequence of reduced
prices for medical care. Since most insurance plans, whether public or private, reduce the
out-of pocket cost of medical care, the behavior of individuals will be affected by those
reduced prices. In the same way that people treat water with little care when it is very
inexpensive, people will also tend to over-use medical care when the out-of pocket costs
are small. Of course, medical care still needs to be financed, and so taxes or premiums
will be higher than the optimal amount. This inflation of taxes or premiums to cover the
choices made under subsidized prices is what is termed ex-post moral hazard, and is a
different phenomenon than the ex-ante moral hazard mentioned above. Critics of private
health insurance state that those who are sick should be able to get health insurance
because they need it the most and that if everyone had health insurance, adverse selection
would not be a problem. With publicly funded health insurance ask, do people of moral
hazard, those who favor public health insurance or drive like maniacs if they have auto
insurance, or do some people just engage in self destructive behaviour for no rational
reason.
Insurance companies explain the economics of insurance by saying that, in
general, if many sick people buy health insurance from a private health insurance
company, but few healthy people buy it, the price of the insurance rises. (Critics of
private health insurance point out that few sick people are allowed to buy health
insurance). Insurance companies also say that if more healthy people buy health
insurance, but few sick people buy it, the price drops. In other words, the price drops
if more money goes in and less is paid out. According to the latest United States
Census Bureau figures, approximately 85% of Americans have health insurance.
19
20
2.
If insurance companies try to charge different people different amount based on their
own personal health, people will feel they are unfairly treated. Some states require
that insurance companies cover all who apply at the same cost, or that rates vary
only by age of the insured; this rule has the effect that healthy people subsidize sick
ones, and thus frequently only those in poor health buy insurance, making the
premiums very expensive.
3.
When a claim is made, particularly for a sizeable amount, it may be deemed in the
best interest of the insurance company to use paper work and bureaucracy to attempt
to avoid payment of the claim or, at a minimum, greatly delay it. Some percentage of
insureds will simply give up, leading to lower costs for the insurance company.
4.
5.
Employers can write some or all of their employee health insurance premiums off of
their taxable income whereas traditionally individuals have had to pay taxes on
income used to fund health insurance. This reduces the employees bargaining power
in negotiating service with the insurance provider and also
increases their
dependence on the employer. In the U.S., COBRA and more recent legislation has
been passed in an attempt to address the latter concern, and full tax deductibility for
health insurance premiums paid by the self-employed has recently been passed by
Congress as well.
21
6.
7.
The health Maintenance Organization (HMO) type of health insurance plan has been
criticized for excessive cost-cutting policies. The least justifiable of these efforts,
according to critics, is having accountants or other administrators
essentially making medical decisions for customers by deciding which
types of medical treatment will be covered and which will not.
8.
9.
integrated delivery systems that bring all the components of health care
22
Affordable Cost:
This new breed is expected to bring about a total transformation in
healthcare management with affordable costs and improved quality
halthcare. It will also bringing about a change in the mindset of the
masses regarding the concept of managed and preventive healthcare.
Improved Quality :
Such a system encourages appropriate treatment, discourages overtreatment, encourages preventive care, and attempts to promote cost
containment and quality health care delivery
Cashless System :
The entry of TPAs means the arrival of a cashless system of payment for
healthcare services. The policyholders would receive every healthcare
facility required depending on their needs and high medical costs will
not be a deterrent.
Existing Players
At present Paramount, Sedgwick Parikh, Ican Medicare, Apollo Family
Health and DMS Lifeline provide such healthcare facilities. About 25-30
new players are likely to enter soon once the regulations are in place.
23
The final modalities regarding the role of TPAs and the procedure to be
followed are yet to be worked out. But healthcare companies are
optimistic about the changed scenario and see vast scope in the health
care industry.
Governments Role in healthcare
For instance in Japan, France, Canada, England and Netherlands, majority of the
population is covered by state funded health insurance. The only large country where
private health insurance is dominant is the US, a country that has the most inefficient and
expensive health care system in the developed World. It is foolhardy to argue that health
care delivery would improve in India if the government sector were replaced by the
private sector. In fact there is a need to greatly increase the involvement
of the
24
Low educational levels have led to village folks relying on local healers. Their
advice is taken at face value and allopathic cure is only taken up as the last resort.
Hospital care is costly :
Access to affordable medical care is absent. Hospitals are located very far off
and the cost is unaffordable.
Transportation :
An absence of an efficient means of transport has only worsenend the
situation. Bullock carts are the usual mode and any other is unaffordable. Hence a
patient in need of medical help has to travel long distances to reach the nearest
health centre. The following factors will help bring about a change in the situation.
More PHC (Primary Health Centre):
More primary health care centers need to be set up by the government.
Subsidized local transport:
Local transportation to be arranged for at subsidized rates by the panchayat or
the hospital.
Education of village folk :
To spread the message volunteers can build a network of workers who can
identify the problem areas and influence the villagers on various issues. Street plays,
personal approach on a one to one basis or a group approach will go a long
way in educating the rural population.
Tailor made policies :
Insurance companies will have to take into consideration the problem
areas, and create tailor made policies.
Marketing :
25
26
27
28
considered to contain significant margins. The success of this strategy means that group
health insurance constitutes about 35% of the total about 35% of the total health
insurance business.
Historically the public sector companies have also not paid attention to developing proper
underwriting criteria and they are not required to declare the operating results of this
product line separately. Despite of years of experience they have not built proper
databases and do not carry out systematic analysis of amongst other things, disease
29
adopt dual fees schedules. A higher rate for customer preferring to get treatment under
cashless schemes administered through the TPAs and a lower one for direct settlement
and possible reimbursement by the insurer.
Future Sceneario
Despite the above teething problems the Indian economy is showing sings of
liberalization in many areas. Further, the govt. and the insurance regulator seem keen to
encourage health insurance. The obvious solution is to encourage competition by
lowering the entry barrier for new players and to recognize the potential of health
insurance as a stand alone business.
A working group, set up by the insurance regulator to suggest specific measures to
improve the state of affairs in health insurance, has recently submitted its report. One of
its major recommendations is to license exclusive health insurance companies with a
lower minimum capital requirement of Rs 250 million, one-quarte of the minimum
capital required for life and non-life insurance companies.
The group also favoured the introduction of a risk-based capital model of healthware
companies to encourage efficiency in capital allocation and a higher level of tax benefit
for health insurance premium payment for individuals. A key need to allow a higher
equity holding for foreign firms is alo being recognized, with the group favoring foreign
ownership of health insurance companies of up to 51% (compared to the current limit of
26% for insurance companies). This would require an amendment to the insurance Act,
which is a long process, unless the govt. chooses to use its emergency ordinance powers
to intervene more rapidly.
At the same time, there are signs of cooperation between some of the healthcare
providers to subject themselves to a stricter price structure. The major TPAs have
developed a database of the most common surgeries such as heart, cataract, tonsillectomy
and hysterectomy covering the average treatment cost across the primary, secondary and
tertiary hospitals. Since there is no accreditation body in the country for hospitals , the
National center for quality Management has agreed to work out a further classification of
31
hospitals from the data collected by the TPAs. The exercise is carried out in a phased way
and already about 200 hospitals have signed contracts.
Health insurance provides the important benefit of risk pooling to customers,
particularly once insurers have achieved both scale and size. Such coordinated moves
amongst healthcare players are therefore essential to spread the benefit of health
insurance among the whole population. A study by the Indian Planning Commision has,
however, indicated that the lowest earning 20% of the population spend about a fifth of
that of the highest 20% of the population on healthcare, whereas the differences in
disposable incomes is far greater. Further more, the bulk of the healthcare spending by
the lower earners is met by raising borrowings or selling family assets.
Only a purposeful and time bound plan could therefore bring relief to every segment
of the population, enabling access to vital healthcare cover. As a result, there is a
significant opportunity in India for insurers if they can proactively contribute to govt.
initiatives to achieve better and more widespread healthcare provision and funding.
Reference :
Insurance Chronicle
February 2006, Page no. 33-36
By- Rajagopalan Krishnamurth, head,
Distribution consulting in India, Watson Wyatt
Walter de Oude, Senior Consultant
Watson Wyatt, Singapore
32
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
A literature review is a body of text that aims to review the critical points of current
knowledge and or methodological approaches on a particular topic. Literature reviews are
secondary sources, and as such, do not report any new or original experimental work.
Most often associated with academic-oriented literature, such as theses, a literature
review usually precedes a research proposal and results section. Its ultimate goal is to
bring the reader up to date with current literature on a topic and forms the basis for
another goal, such as future research that may be needed in the area. Some information
regarding health insurance is as follow:
The public health investment in the country over the years has been comparatively low,
and as a percentage of GDP has declined from 1.3 percent in 1990 to 0.9 percent in 1999.
The aggregate expenditure in the Health sector is 5.2 percent of the GDP. Out of this,
about 17 percent of the aggregate expenditure is public health spending, the balance
being out-of-pocket expenditure. The central budgetary allocation for health over this
period, as a percentage of the total Central Budget, has been stagnant at 1.3 percent,
while that in the States has declined from 7.0 percent to 5.5 percent. The current annual
per capita public health expenditure in the country is no more than Rs. 200. Given these
statistics, it is no surprise that the reach and quality of public health services has been
below the desirable standard. Under the constitutional structure, public health is the
responsibility of the States. In this framework, it has been the expectation that the
principal contribution for the funding of public health services will be from the resources
of the States, with some supplementary input from Central resources. In this backdrop,
the contribution of Central resources to the overall public health funding has been limited
to about 15 percent. The fiscal resources of the State Governments are known to be very
inelastic. This is reflected in the declining percentage of State resources allocated to the
33
health sector out of the State Budget. If the decentralized pubic health services in the
country are to improve significantly, there is a need for the injection of substantial
resources into the health sector from the Central Government Budget. This approach is a
necessity despite the formal Constitutional provision in regard to public health, -- if the
State public health services, which are a major component of the initiatives in the social
sector, are not to become entirely moribund. The NHP-2002 has been formulated taking
into consideration these ground realities in regard to the availability of resources.
34
35
36
Old age Health care: Medical gerontology to take care of health care problems
associated with ageing
Long term care: for illnesses that require prolonged treatment and care
Health cover for daily wage earners (seasonal workers, casual laborers, construction
workers, etc)
Juvenile insurance plans - to meet ill health / medical expenses associated with
health related problems of children
Preferred Health Risks policies like the Preferred Life insurance policies
37
38
39
High incidence of moral hazard is also visible amongst male claimants across all age
groups. Short duration hospitalization claims for less than 5 days were more in number.
Examination of frequent and short duration claims requires greater care (see Table 10).
* Claim amounts
The claims ranged mostly between Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 20,000 amongst males and females.
40 percent of the claims were below Rs. 5,000. Out of these claimants 65 percent were
males, below 35 years. The same trend is seen even amongst the females. 32 percent of
the claims filed were for amounts between Rs. 5,000 and Rs. 10,000, out of which again
about 90 percent were males from age below 45 years. Only 15 percent of the claims
filed were for high amounts above Rs.10,000 Rs.20,000, with 90percent being males.
Claims exceeding Rs.20,000 were made by 14 percent of the claimants, all males.
Claims data clearly show adverse experience from policyholders (mostly males)
belonging to lower age groups, particularly below 45 years. The company experiences
high frequency and low severity cases. Stringent claims evaluations standards can
mitigate the adverse claims experience (see Table 11).
* Sum Insured
Examination of the sum insured amounts of the claimants showed that a very small per
centage of claimants had sum insured below Rs.50, 000. 71 percent of the claimants had
above Rs. 1,00,000 as sum insured. Only 10 percent of the claimants had high covers of
more than Rs. 2,00,000. Barely 7.5 percent of claimants had very high cover policies
above Rs. 3 lakhs. Most of the claimants had low sum insured coverage
* Claims in relation to Premium
Interestingly, the data revealed an inverse correlation between claims and premium
figures. Claimants, who paid premiums between Rs.1000 and Rs. 2000 made more
frequent claims that too for low amounts below Rs.5000. Only 14 percent of the total
claims constituted high claims exceeding Rs. 20,000.
Data revealed significant correlation between low premium payments and claims
incurred. There were no significant claims from persons who paid high premiums. This
implies that low sum insured policies must be underwritten more carefully
40
41
entire data reflect a high frequency of low claims. The analysis of the demographic
profiles of the claimants also reveals a clear evidence of high incidence of moral hazard
and the tendency of the low-age group members, particularly the males to over utilize the
medical utilities, that too for short duration, and not-so-serious illnesses reflecting their
mentality to simply take back the premium that they have paid. But, fundamentally,
insurance mitigates the financial costs of only pure risks. The lack of understanding of the
essence of insurance is clearly visible in the sample taken. The Adverse selection and
moral hazard factor can be curtailed to some extent by incorporating strict underwriting
guidelines at the time of issue of the policy.
42
Objectives
To study the awareness level & prefrences among customers towards health
insurance.
43
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
PROBLEM STATEMENT
Keeping in view the fact that there is a cut throat competition between
the life insurance companies as well as in the non-life insurance
companies. The companies spent a lot of amount of money in promoting
the health insurance products. But the problem in cities is that peoples are
not so much aware about the health insurance products and moreover they
do not feel any kind of need to buy these products. They say that some for
the life insurance products are now covering the medical expenses also.
The government employees do not buy health insurance products
because they know that any kind of exepenses, they do on the medical
services will be reimbursed by their respective departments. So the
problem was
to know
customers
awareness level
regarding health
insurance products and the attitudes and perception. So that it can help
non-life insurance companies to sell and promote health insurance
products.
Research Objective
Every research project is based on some objectives so for this study
my objective is to find out people awareness about health insurance, and
how they perceive & think about the same.
Research Design
Research design is descriptive type. As this project undertakes to study customer
preferences towards health insurance descriptive research design is adopted in the study.
Sources of Data
44
The research plan calls for gathering primary data i.e. data for a specified purpose
as well as taking help from secondary data. The primary data will collect by personal
interview with the help of questionnaire and secondary data will collect from the books
and magazines, journals & internet.
Instrument of Research
In collecting primary data questionnaire is use. Structured questionnaire will prepare
with the help of close-ended question.
Sampling Plan
This decision includes a careful consideration of the following dimensions:
Sample Size
In this research project sample size consist of 100 respondents.
Sample Area
It consist 100 respondents in Hisar city.
Sampling
Random sampling will be used.
Data Collection
The data collection method use for the study is survey through questionnaire method.
Data Analysis
45
After undergoing through the above steps in the research process the last step is to
express finding from the collected data. Data will present in tabular and graphs form. The
statistical tools will use percentage and average.
46
ANALYSIS OF DATA
TABLE 1
ARE PEOPLE AWARE ABOUT HEALTH INSURANCE POLICY
Yes
No
89
11
DIAGRAM
Table no. one depicts that out of 100 peoples those who know about health
insurance policies are 89 & those who are not aware are 11.
TABLE 2
47
No
18
82
DIAGRAM
Table no. two depicts that out of 100 peoples those who have health insurance
policies are only 18 & those who have not purchased this policy are 82.
TABLE 3
REASON FOR NOT BUYING HEALTH INSURANCE POLICY
48
Awareness
Funds
Willingness
Any Other
11
61
25
DIAGRAM
Table no., three reveals that out of 100 peoples, many people have not
purchased health insurance policy and it was mainly due to willingness (25
peoples), lack of sufficient information (11 peoples) and lack of funds (61
peoples) & 3 have not purchased due to any other reasons.
49
TABLE 4
DO THEY FEEL THE NEED OF BUYING HEALTH INSURANCE
POLICY
Yes
No
78
22
DIAGRAM
Table no., 4 reveals that out of 100 peoples, 78 people feel the need of buying
policy and 22 did not feel of purchasing of health insurance policy.
50
TABLE 5
SOURCES OF INFORMATION ABOUT HEALTH INSURANCE POLICY
Advertisement
Agents
Relatives
Others
20
74
DIAGRAM
Table no., 5 depicts that what were the sources of information while buying
health insurance policies were or will be? And in this table we can see that 74
peoples have got information from the agents and only 6 from his relatives,
but 20 will get information from the advertisements.
51
TABLE 6
THROUGH WHICH CHANNEL HAVE YOU PURCHASED OR WILL
PURCHASE THIS POLICY
Directly from Co.
Agents
94
DIAGRAM
52
TABLE 7
FEASIBILITY OF PREMIUM PAID FOR HEALTH INSURANCE
POLICY
Yes
No
82
18
DIAGRAM
Table no.,7 reveals that the 82 persons think that the premium they are paying
is very much feasible for the health insurance policy. Premium is not so high.
53
TABLE 8
ARE THEY SATISFIED WITH THE COMPANYS SERVICES
Yes
No
79
21
DIAGRAM
Table no.,8 tells that 79 people are very much satisfied with the services given
by the company, but 21 are not satisfied by the companys services
54
TABLE 9
HAVE THEY EVER REIMBURSED ANY HOSPITALIZATION
EXPENSES
Yes
No
16
84
DIAGRAM
Table no., 9 reveals that only 16 persons have reimbursed their hospitalization
expenses, they have incurred before.
TABLE 10
55
Good
Bad
Moderate
19
23
58
Table no., 10 depicts that out of 100 persons, 19 persons says that the
procedure was good 23 said it was bad & 58 says that it was moderate.
56
57
TABLE 11
ARE THEY SEEKING MORE INFORMATION ABOUT HEALTH
INSURANCE POLICY
Yes
No
83
17
DIAGRAM
Table no., 11 shows that out of 100 peoples 17 are not interesting in seeking
more information related to the health insurance policies.
58
59
SUGGESTIONS
This is not so much easy task to give findings because before concluding
anything there should be a long research, the research based only on 100
peoples in not sufficient, so considering it in mind I have reached on some
findings. All of these findings are my own perception and knowledge that I
got while completing this research project.
During the completion of the research project report, I have met many
different kind of peoples includes shopkeepers, professors and doctors. And
out of these professors and doctors are known as the most intelligent persons
in the society. The concept of the Health Insurance is very old, it came into
picture in 1694 but the awareness level about the health insurance policies is
considerably very low. I have contacted 100 peoples, out of these 89 are aware
about health insurance policy but only 18 have purchased the health insurance
policy. The reasons may be like these :1. Peoples are not so much health conscious in India.
2. Companies are not promoting health insurance policies.
3. There is no education regarding health insurance.
4. India is not so much rich country, so peoples do not have enough funds to
purchase health insurance policies in fact there are only less than 10
percent population is having life insurance.
5. Peoples those who have enough funds, they do not feel to buy a health
insurance companies.
6. This, health insurance concept can take a generation or more time to get
popular in India.
60
QUESTIONNAIRE (ANNEXURE)
AWARENESS AND PERCEPTION ABOUT HEALTH INSURANCE
HISAR
Qu. 1. General Information
a) Respondents Name
: ____________________________
b) Age
: ____________________________
c) Sex
: ____________________________
d) Education
: ____________________________
e) Occupation
: ____________________________
f) Annually Income
: ____________________________
[ ]
b) No
[ ]
Qu.4.
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
c) Willingness
Qu.5.
b) No
[ ]
b) Funds
[ ]
[ ]
b) No
[ ]
61
IN
Qu. 7. From where doyou get the information about these policies?
a) Advertisements
c) Relatives
[ ]
[ ]
b) Agents
d) Others
[ ]
[ ]
[ ]
b) Agents
[ ]
[ ]
b) No
[ ]
Qu.10. Are you satisfied with the services given by the co.?
a) Yes
[ ]
b) No
[ ]
Qu.11. Have you ever reimbursed the hospitalization expenses done by you?
a) Yes
[ ]
b) No
[ ]
[ ]
b) Bad
[ ]
c) Moderate
[ ]
Qu. 13. Which one plans of Health insurance are you aware of?
a) Personal Accident Insurance
[ ] b) Overseas Mediclaim
[ ]
Qu. 14. Are you seeking more information about Health Insurance?
a) Yes
[ ]b) No
[ ]
62
BIBLIOGRAPHY
www.irdaindia.org
www.google.com
www.yahoo.com
karhfw.gov.in/.../NATIONAL%20HEALTH%20POLICY%202002
www.medvarsity.com/vmu1.2/st/lp/.../Dr.%20Savitha.html
63