The defiance and the reason why Julia could want him are still buzzing
around his mind.
3) What is ironic about the fact that Julia saw Winstons rebellion
from his physical expression?
- Julia was able to spot Winstons rebellion from his physical expression
- Ironic: Winston believed that he was putting on a proper job of
concealing his true feelings from the potential enemy, Julia.
o In reality if Julia was working with the thought police Winston
would be long gone because she was able to tell Winston was
rebellious.
4) Why is the singing bird so hard for Winston to comprehend?
- Everything in Winstons life was for a purpose; everything he did was
because someone was watching judging him, forcing him to do
whatever he did in a way.
- However, the bird sang without a mate or rival watching it. It sang for
the simple pleasure of singing, even if it all amounted to nothing.
5) What does Winston find most erotically attractive about Julia?
- Julias corruption; I hate purity, I hate goodness. I dont want any
virtue to exist anywhere. I want everyone to be corrupt to the bones.
Winston Smith
III
1) Explain the sentence she hated the Party, and said so in the
crudest words, but she made no general criticism of it
- She wanted a good time but the party was against anyone having a
good time
- She only cared about Party matters when it involved her and
therefore made no general criticism of it
- She was more into rebelling than starting a revolution
2) According to Julia, why does the Party frown on sex for
pleasure
- Sex created a world of its own which had to be destroy
- BUT mainly, sexual privation encouraged excitement, which could
transform into war-energy and leader worship
- Ultimately, to transform the madness and excitement for sexual
activity to devotion to the military and Big Brother
IV
1) What is it that makes Winston at last feel tenderness toward
Julia?
- It was when she told him she could not come and his desire
changed
- He began to care for her and adore the smell of her hair, the taste
of her mouth
- He felt great affection for her; it changed from lust LOVE
- He realises he does not want to share her with any other men and
wants to be like a normal married couple
2) How does Winston misunderstand the song of the prole woman
below the window?
It was an opeless fancy,
It passed like an Ipril dye,
Chapter V
1. The Party inflicts harm upon its own citizens. The Party does this to spur hatred
among its own citizens, who blame the enemy for all of the destruction they
receive. Society is kept together when they all have something in common to hate.
This is one of the ways in which the Party can control the citizens. The more that
the citizens hate the enemy, the more love they possess for Big Brother. Also, it
is unlikely that an enemy would commit its atrocities at a time so close to the Hate
Week.
2. The old man seemed seldom or never to go out of doors, and on the other hand to
have almost no customers. He led a ghostlike existence ... he seemed glad of the
opportunity to talk. Wandering about among his worthless stock ... he had vaguely
the air of being a collector rather than a tradesman. (pg. 150)
Mr. Charrington is a very suspicious man indeed. We find out later in the book
that he is a member of the Thought Police and turns in Winston and Julia to the
Inner Party. Seeing how he never went outside of his shop and never had any
customers, hints to us that he wasnt a shopkeeper after all, but just remained in
the shop in order to spy on Winston. His ghostlike existence suggests that
Winston couldnt exactly read who Mr. Charrington was as a person, and
separates him from people that are potentially trustworthy. His eagerness to talk to
Winston seemed like a friendly gesture initially, but it was probably just an
attempt to pry information from Winston. Lastly, Mr. Charringtons vague air of
being a collector rather than a tradesman further hints to the motives behind his
actions. Being a collector can be seen as his tendency to collect information rather
than exchange it, which goes on the fact that Mr. Charringtons job is actually do
sniff out disloyal citizens for the Party.
Police, because the Party cannot make them stop loving each other. The ironic
thing here is that both Winston and Julia end up betraying each other. They
thought they had loved each other but by betraying each other they have
demonstrated love for the Party over everything else. Now they are nothing more
than pawns of the government.
Chapter VIII
1. The wine which OBrien serves Winston and Julia is only available to Inner Party
members. They use the wine to toast Emmanuel Goldstein, the leader of the
Brotherhood. Wine reminds Winston of his vanished, romantic past, the olden
days in his secret thoughts. Winston had thought that wine would be immediately
intoxicating and intensely sweet, but once he tastes it he finds out that he cannot
stand the taste because he is so used to drinking victory gin. This is indicative of
what is to come, as Winston conspires against the Party but fails to oppose the
Party in the end. Something (wine) which had represented freedom and good days
for Winston turned out to be impossible to
2. There were millions of proles for whom the Lottery was the main if not the only
reason for remaining alive. Everyone in the Party knew that only small sums of
prizes were actually awarded out, big prizes were awarded to non-existing
persons. The lottery was also a tool of the Party to keep the masses pacified.
Proles were too concerned over the lottery to develop ideas of rebellion against
the Party. Similarly, Goldstein and the Brotherhood were invented by the Party to
eliminate oppositions. In the story, Winston tries to join the Brotherhood and that
is how OBrien traps Winston and Julia who are eventually tortured into loving
the Party.