Pabalate
CIVICS
III C
PLATO AND ARISTOTLE ON DEMOCRACY
Plato and Aristotle are considered to be the two most influential Greek
philosophers of their time. These two men have maintained a relationship
that lasted for almost twenty years. Aristotle was Platos pupil and served to
be the master of the latter. Plato, the philosopher, is more of an idealist. He
has shown this through his abstractions, his dialogues and his mystical
thoughts. Aristotle, on the other hand, who is a rationalist, was concerned
with material things, methodical inventories and systemization. The two are
known for political theories. Plato is regarded by many as the first writer of
political philosophy while Aristotle is recognized as the political scientist.
They have argued about politics, most especially, on democracy and the
form of government. Both Plato and Aristotle wanted a change in the
democratic government, since it is known to be corrupt.
What is comparable about their views on democracy is that generally,
they want a better government for the place. They both criticized democracy
as a poor form of government. Platos argument is that democracy causes
corruption to the people, by way of public opinion and it results to the
creation of rulers who are not knowledgeable on ruling but only on
influencing the people. In a similar way, Aristotles thoughts say that
democratic positions will just cause corruption in the people and that if they
choose to redistribute the wealth of the rich ones, it will result to chaos and
destruction of the state since they have no knowledge about governance
when they elect rulers. The two agree that justice is objective in sense, that
good life should be provided to all individuals regardless of social status.
Furthermore, because the problem on this type of government, Plato left
Athens, and Aristotle, as well.
for all the people. Democracy will just bring about corruption and unjust
people. The society must be composed of educated ones. The government
must provide the people the good life no matter what their social statuses
are.