Research
1. Assessment of mucosal immuno-pathology and molecular and cellular biology of
persistent diarrhea in representative populations in developing countries.
2. Studies of small bowel microbiology in PD, especially in at-risk populations e.g.,
malnourished children and HIV endemic areas.
3. Evaluation of the link of micronutrient deficiencies with PD and their relationship with
intestinal repair mechanisms.
Intervention
1. Improved facility-based approaches and algorithms for the nutritional management of PD
and malnutrition.
2. Diagnosis and management of PD in public health system and primary care (including
domiciliary) settings.
3. Scaling-up environmental control measures and safe water and hygiene strategies.
Education
1. Continuing medical education strategies to educate medical students and physicians in the
recognition, management and prevention of PD.
2. Education of nursing and paramedical personnel in the recognition and management of
PD in ambulatory and health system settings.
3. Community and public health education strategies for increased awareness of the
prevention of PD and optimal management of acute and prolonged diarrheal episodes.
INTRODUCTION
Despite considerable advances in the understanding
and management of diarrheal disorders in childhood,
they are still responsible for an estimated 2.2 million
childhood deaths worldwide (1). In 1980, the World
Health Organization calculated that there were >700 million episodes of diarrhea annually in children <5 years of
age in developing countries (excluding China), with >4.6
million deaths (2). More recent reviews indicate that although global mortality has decreased, the incidence remains unchanged at >3.2 episodes per child-year (3).
These findings indicate the continuing need to focus on
the prevention and management of acute and chronic
diarrhea in children in developing countries.
S711
S712
BHUTTA ET AL.
ETIOLOGY
Broadly speaking, the origins of diarrhea may lie primarily within the small intestine, large intestine, or accessory digestive organs (pancreas and hepatobiliary
tract). Disorders of the large intestine usually cause diarrhea through defective water salvage, whereas disorders of the small intestine can be either secretory or
osmotic (in association with malabsorption). Secretory
and osmotic processes may be present concurrently (eg,
with rotavirus enteritis).
Protracted diarrhea may arise from a large number of
conditions. Globally, the most important trigger for PD is
an acute diarrheal episode caused by an enteric infection.
In areas in which HIV infection is endemic, chronic infection of the gastrointestinal tract (eg, cryptosporidiosis)
is an important cause. In the absence of an infective
etiology, other specific disease entities associated with
PD in children should be sought. The most common are
dietary protein intolerances, celiac disease, and secondary disaccharide (lactose) intolerance. In a large historical series in Europe, these diagnoses accounted for 56%
of cases of PD in infancy (5). In these infants with severe
PD, 24% had other diagnoses, but in 30%, no specific
diagnosis was reached despite extensive investigation.
Now, the subgroup of children with PD and no identifiable diagnosis accounts for <2% of cases in large European centers (K. Lindley, unpublished data, 2003).
It is useful to have a diagnostic algorithm as an aid to
diagnosis that (in a necessarily arbitrary and mutually
nonexclusive fashion) categorizes PD either by age of
onset (in utero, neonatal, infantile, or older) or into
congenital/inherited and acquired disorders. It is also
useful to group the patients into those with secretory
diarrhea and those with predominantly osmotic diarrhea
on the basis of response to fasting and of stool electrolytes. Although from a global public health perspective
these cases of protracted diarrhea are not important, an
understanding of their underlying cellular and genetic
mechanisms may provide invaluable insight into enterocyte pathophysiology, with potential implications for
therapy. The diagnosis and management of these disorders, however, will not be discussed in depth in this
report.
Risk Factors and Pathophysiology for PD in
Developing Countries
The most important epidemiological risk factor for PD
is malnutrition. Zinc deficiency, lack of breastfeeding,
male sex, infection with enteropathogenic or enteroaggregative Escherichia coli or Cryptosporidium, and a
history of intrauterine growth retardation are other important associated conditions. A recent acute diarrheal
episode (within the past 2 months) is common in PD.
Also important is immune status. Children with abnor-
S713
3. Evaluation of the link between micronutrient deficiencies and PD. Although the causal relationship between PD and micronutrient, especially zinc, malnutrition is well recognized, little is known about the
mechanisms underlying this process. Nor is it known
how micronutrients affect intestinal mucosal repair
and recovery patterns. Zinc deficiency may well be a
key factor in the widespread prevalence of PD in zincdeficient populations, and research should be undertaken to evaluate the magnitude and the mechanisms
of action of this effect.
Priority Goals for Medical Interventions
Although parenteral nutrition has been occasionally
life-saving in selected cases in developing countries, it is
clearly an impractical option for most of the developing
world. There is now clear evidence supporting the enteral
route for nutritional rehabilitation of malnourished children with PD (4,12). Starvation has been shown to have
deleterious effects on the intestinal mucosa, thereby
causing a reduction in the nutritive transporters for glutamine and arginine. It is thus imperative that malnourished children with PD receive enteral nutrition during
their rehabilitation. Continued breastfeeding is universally accepted and recommended during diarrhea, and
the disorder is frequently seen in the wake of lactation
failure or after weaning. The choice of an appropriate
diet or feeding regimen for these children is much debated because the diet offered must be well tolerated and
of a sufficient nutritional quality to ensure adequate absorption without an osmotic penalty.
Regardless of the cellular mechanisms and structural
alterations in malnourished children with PD, the result
is one of altered brush border and luminal enzymes and
consequent malabsorption. Despite the aforementioned
alterations in digestive and absorptive mechanisms,
analysis of metabolic balance studies in children with PD
indicates that satisfactory carbohydrate, protein, and fat
absorption can take place on a variety of diets (14).
Postinfectious cases of PD can usually be managed by
dietary measures, including provision of dietary complex
carbohydrates, eg, cereals such as rice, maize, lentils, or
legumes, bananas, vegetable oil, and milk as a source of
protein (human or cows milk, the former being preferable). Soy formulas may be acceptable but are significantly more expensive and in some studies were less
effective than the cereal-lentilbased diets (4). Generally, the goal is to provide at least 150 kcalkg1d1
enterally. Research is underway to determine which
complex carbohydrate is optimal for enhancing absorption (colonic) and bowel repair in PD. Candidates are
maize, green banana fibers, pectin, and guar gum. Other
potentially effective treatments are L-glutamine, which
provides intestinal fuel, nucleotides for proliferating enterocytes, corticosteroids for children with protein-losing
S714
BHUTTA ET AL.
enteropathy and bowel inflammation, preparations containing growth factors for ostensible intestinal trophic
effects, and immunoglobulins (eg, bovine colostrum or
bovine serum concentrate) for their antirotavirus effects.
When this is unsuccessful, replacement of milk with another protein source, eg, egg white or chicken, is often
effective.
Most nutritional rehabilitation protocols for the treatment of PD in developed countries entail the administration of specialized enteral formulations, mainly
lactose-free formulations or semielemental diets. However, these are beyond the reach of health resources in
developing countries. They are also frequently unpalatable, require continuous administration, and thus are not
appropriate in ambulatory settings. Because most PD
cases occur in the community and parents frequently
hesitate to seek help, the challenge is to develop a form
of dietary therapy using inexpensive, home-available,
and culturally acceptable ingredients. Recent data indicate that it may be entirely feasible to do so in community settings (15).
The key role of micronutrients, especially zinc, in the
treatment and prevention of PD is also well recognized.
However, zinc supplementation is not included in public
health programs in developing countries. Zinc supplementation during acute episodes has been shown to reduce the duration and severity of diarrhea (16), and when
administered as part of a community treatment package
for diarrhea, it reduces mortality and the rates of prescribing antimicrobials (17).
As stated earlier, the biggest public health challenge is
the development and widespread implementation of
evidence-based strategies to treat PD. However, these
must be based on information from intervention protocols in other settings. Too much emphasis is placed on
developing new strategies when the technology and information needed to prevent most child deaths resulting
from diarrhea are widely available (18).
1. Improved facility-based approaches and algorithms
for the nutritional management of PD and malnutrition. Good nutrition is central to rapid and complete
recovery from PD. Thus, the development and assessment of cost-effective enteral multinutrient formulations for the nutritional rehabilitation and therapy of
children with PD and malnutrition remain a priority.
These formulations need to be based on our understanding of the gut absorptive capacity and the critical
nutrients required for repair and should consist of an
appropriate balance of macronutrients and micronutrients. Although past dietary approaches have included soy formulations and elemental diets, they
have not been shown to be superior to other diets or
combinations validated in facility settings in developing countries. Oral antibiotics, either singly or in combination, have not been proven useful, but antimicrobial therapy is required for proven Clostridium diffi-
S715
S716
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
BHUTTA ET AL.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.