748
Institut fur Theoretische Physik, Technische Universitat Berlin, D-10623 Berlin, Germany
Polymer Physics, ETH Zurich, Wolfgang-Pauli-Str. 10, CH-8093 Zurich, Switzerland
Received: March 18, 2004; Revised: August 30, 2004; Accepted: October 14, 2004; DOI: 10.1002/mats.200400021
Keywords: linear viscoelasticity; molecular dynamics; non-equilibrium; polymer melt
Introduction
The molecular dynamics (MD) method applied to mesoscopic models for macromolecules is known as a powerful
approach enabling the simulation of the dynamics of polymeric fluids of arbitrary architecture. Often, results are in
remarkable good agreement with known rheological and
structure-resolving experimental findings. Extensive MD
simulations of polymer melts have been performed earlier[1,2] in order to study the different regimes of diffusive
motion of polymer chains in melts. These studies allowed to
determine a critical chain length (/ molecular weight)
a
b
PACS: 83.10.Mj,61.25.Hq,83.50.Ax.
Present address: Dep. de Qumica Fsica, Universidad de
Murcia, Campus Espinardo, 30100 Murcia, Spain.
E-mail: jghc@um.es
characterizing the dynamical crossover from the qualitatively different Rouse[3] to reptation[4] regimes. Further, the
flow behavior of polymer melts, subjected to simple
shear,[5,6] uniaxial elongational flow,[7,8] and stress relaxation[9] has been investigated using non-equilibrium molecular dynamics (NEMD). For reviews on this method we
refer to ref.[5,10] In ref.[6], a rheological crossover from
Rouse to reptation had been obtained via NEMD. Based on
these findings, we know that the polymer melts to be studied
in this article (N < 100 beads) should be in the unentangled
regime. The viscoelasticity of unentangled polystyrene
melts has been investigated in detail in ref.[11,12] Computational work devoted to the study of the model polymer melts
under oscillatory shear flow is scarce, although the linear
viscoelastic response is of great practical importance.
Frequency-dependent properties of simple fluids have been
studied via NEMD[1315] (linear viscoelasticity under elongational flow) and extensively discussed in ref.[13,14,16]
DOI: 10.1002/mats.200400021
749
Linear Viscoelastic Behavior of Unentangled Polymer Melts via Non-Equilibrium Molecular Dynamics
(non-linear response under periodic external fields). Experimentally, the linear viscoelastic properties of polymeric
systems are usually obtained by subjecting the sample to a
small strain amplitude oscillatory shear flow characterized
by the dynamic moduli (G0 and G00 ). This article is devoted
to show the use of NEMD to study polymer melts under
oscillatory shear flow. Relaxation time of melts strongly
increases with chain length and therefore frequencies corresponding to the terminal zone of dynamic moduli where
the viscous behavior dominates are such small that direct
simulations targeting this regime are still very time consuming. This work is devoted to summarize our findings
using unapproximated MD. The results should serve to test
approximate methods and single segment theories. Alternate methods (variance reduction,[17] transient time correlation function,[18] average stress fluctuations,[1921]
beyond-equilibrium MD[22]) particularly useful at low
shear rates (and certainly also useful at low frequencies)
have been proposed and should be mentioned, but would
not be employed in this brief article.
~2 =e,
density, temperature, and pressure are tref m s
~3 , Tref e/kB, and pref e s
~3 , respectively. To
rref s
transform our dimensionless results to dimensional results
suitable for comparison with experimental data, our results
must be just rescaled depending on the physical units of the
quantity of interest and the polymer system at hand. For
a representative set of experimental data for different
polymers along with the corresponding simulation data
(FENE model) in dimensionless form, we refer to Table 1 of
ref.[6] In order to study bulk properties, periodic boundary
conditions and the nearest image convention together
with Lees-Edwards boundary conditions are employed.
Macromol. Theory Simul. 2004, 13, 748753
www.mts-journal.de
750
www.mts-journal.de
Results
We studied the linear viscoelastic behavior of FENE polymer melts, characterized by bead number density n 0.84
and (reference) temperature T 1 (LJ units). Concerning
initial conditions, a total number of Nt 3 500 beads
allocated to FENE chains of length N are placed into the
periodic simulation box along the lines indicated in ref.[28]
As in experimental works, a suitable working strain amplitude, g0, must be chosen; low enough in order to be in the
linear regime but not so low that values of the properties
are largely affected by noise. A good value turned out to be
g0 0.1 which is also a common value used in experiments.
The inset of Figure 1 shows the amplitude dependence of
the loss modulus, G00 , for a melt of linear FENE chains of
N 20 using a value of oscillatory frequency o 0.1. As
observed, for g0 0.1, we are fully in the linear region but
far from the noisy region appearing at very low g0. Thus, all
plots presented in this work correspond to that selected g0.
Figure 2 shows the frequency dependence of the storage
modulus, G0 (black symbols) and G00 (empty symbols) for
different melts of linear FENE chains with N 5, 20, 70.
751
Linear Viscoelastic Behavior of Unentangled Polymer Melts via Non-Equilibrium Molecular Dynamics
This kind of representation helps to appreciate the frequency evolution of the solid-like and liquid-like behaviors
of the material under study as well as their relative importance. The chain lengths simulated in this work are below
the critical entanglement length Nc 100.[6] For chain
lengths below the rheological crossover length, the G0 and
G00 in the low frequency zone are expected to conform well
to the modified Rouse theory for undiluted polymer solutions as long as the temperature is well above the glass
transition temperature, cf. ref.[11] In addition, when entanglements are not formed, there is a transition from the
terminal zone (smallest o values in our dynamic moduli
curves) directly to the glassy zone, without an intermediate
rubbery range.[11] Let us first compare the behavior of G0
(i.e., black symbols only) by varying the chain length N.
Figure 2 shows that at the low frequency range swept, the
shorter the chain, the smaller is the value of G0 , while at high
frequencies all G0 curves tend to converge. Differences in
the G0 curves start to occur in reaching the terminal zone
(predominant liquid-like behavior). In the transition zone to
the glassy consistency, viscoelastic properties are dominated by configurational rearrangements of chain segments
which are not very extended (chains remain near the coil
equilibrium conformation because of the small g0 applied).
There possible crosslinks play a minor role. As a result, the
behavior is not much affected by differences in chain
length. For N 20 and N 70, because of their relatively
large relaxation times,[1] the simulated frequencies are
located above the terminal zone and therefore their G0
curves in general, superimpose. For N 5, however, the
work frequencies are close to the terminal liquid-like region
and at the lowest frequencies simulated its G0 values diverge
from those of the larger chains. In contrast, the quantity G00
(empty symbols only) is much less sensitive to the transition
from the glassy to the terminal zone since the characteristic
slopes of each zone in the log-log plot are closer than in the
Macromol. Theory Simul. 2004, 13, 748753
www.mts-journal.de
752
Figure 4. Both (absolute) dynamic viscosity jZ*j and steadyshear viscosity, Z, versus frequency, o, and shear rate, g_ ,
respectively (both in reduced Lennard-Jones (LJ) units). CoxMerz rule verified.
Macromol. Theory Simul. 2004, 13, 748753
www.mts-journal.de
753
Linear Viscoelastic Behavior of Unentangled Polymer Melts via Non-Equilibrium Molecular Dynamics
Conclusion
Small strain oscillatory rheometry is widely used to characterize the mechanical behavior of viscoelastic systems.
Nevertheless, computational studies devoted to reproduce
this experimental setup are scarce. We have shown the
adequacy of NEMD of a coarse-grained polymer (FENE)
model to simulate oscillatory flow in spite of its limitations
in sweeping a broad frequency range due to the enormous
CPU time required to get results in the terminal zone. In
order to extend the frequency range, we make use of the
time-temperature superposition rule, widely used in experimental works. In simulations, care must be taken if applying
that empirical rule, because variations of the work temperature entail changes in the temperature-dependent model
parameters (for instance, the spring coefficient) and in the
thermodynamic properties of the system (pressure, volume,
density). We think that as long as temperature keeps closed
to T0, these changes play a negligible role in simulation
results.
Results obtained for chain lengths under the critical
entanglement length give rise to results which, at least
qualitatively, agree with experimental findings for melts of
low molecular weight.[12] Furthermore, we were able to
check the validity of the empirical Cox-Merz rule. Apart
from CPU time requirements, NEMD has, in principle, no
Macromol. Theory Simul. 2004, 13, 748753
www.mts-journal.de