Prateek
Roll No. 2933
PGDM-BM
CERTIFICATE
It is to certify that this project report entitled Analysing the risk, return and customer
satisfaction in mutual fund industry with special reference to SBI Mutual fund is a record
of project work done independently by Mr. Prateek Kumar Goyal under my guidance and
supervision and that it has not previously formed any basis for the award of any degree,
fellowship or associate-ship to him.
DECLARATION
I, Prateek Kumar Goyal hereby declare that this project report entitled Analysing the risk,
return and customer satisfaction in mutual fund industry with special reference to SBI
Mutual fund is a bonafide record of work done by me during the course of summer internship
and that it has not previously formed the basis of award to me, for any degree/diploma, associate
ship, fellowship or other similar title, of any other institute/society.
Prateek Goyal
PGDM (BM),
FMS-IRM
Jaipur
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This report bears the imprint of many people and without their support it would not have existed.
I acknowledge my deepest thanks to my project guide Mr. Praveen Saini Senior Manager,
Jaipur for his constant support and encouraging words that helped me in shaping the project in
the best possible way, also for providing me with valuable suggestions and guidance. Truly such
enriching exposure shall now firmly remain foundation pillar of my career which is about to
initiate.
I would also like to thank, here, my faculty guide Dr. Jessy John without whose guidance this
project would not have been possible and also for providing me vital inputs to co-relate the
present project work and hence provide a sound base to the report structure.
Finally, my sincere thanks to all the employees of SBI Mutual Fund for their cooperation and
support in completing the project.
With that I dedicate this work of research to my parents, friends and teachers.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This project is the result of Descriptive study of Mutual Funds in India. A Mutual Fund is a trust
that pools the savings of a number of investors who share a common financial goal. It throws the
light on how Mutual funds really work, how much risk involved in it, how they diversify
themselves and how much return is there while investing in mutual fund. Investing involves risk
of loss of principal and is more concerned on the return of investment. This total risk, measured
by standard deviation, can be divided into two parts: Unsystematic risk, systematic risk.
Unsystematic risk is also called diversifiable risk. Systematic risk may be called nondiversifiable risk, unavoidable risk or market risk and can be measured by Beta. The main
objective of the study is to give investors a basic idea of risk involved in Mutual Funds industry
and encourage them to invest in those areas where they can maximize the return on their capital.
The research provided an interesting insight into awareness about the mutual funds, differences
in age groups, occupation, income levels, risk taking ability of individuals, investment options
preferred etc. The Indian capital market has been increasing tremendously during last few years.
With the reforms of economy, reforms of industrial policy, reforms of public sector and reforms
of financial sector, the economy has been opened up and many developments have been taking
place in the Indian money market and capital market. In order to help the small investors, mutual
fund industry has come to occupy an important place. This study helps me to understand how the
companies diversify themselves in different sectors and in different companies to maximize the
return and to minimize the risk involved in it. It also taught me how to take every experience in
the right sprit & learn from each one. Finally, I shall consider all my hard work worthwhile, if
this endeavor of mine is able to satisfy all those concerned & proves useful to any one or for any
study in the future
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CONTENTS
CHAPTER-1 INTRODUCTION
1.1 OVERVIEW
1.2 CONCEPT OF MUTUAL FUND(PROCEDURE)
1.3 A BRIEF ON MUTUAL FUND
1.4 CONCEPTUAL ANALYSIS OF MUTUAL FUND
1.5 ADVANTAGE AND DISADVANTAGE OF MUTUAL FUND
1.6 TYPES OF MUTUAL FUND
1.7 ACCOUNTING AND VALUATION (PORTFOLIO ANALYSIS TOOL)
1.8 MJOR PLAYERS IN MUTUAL FUND
1.9 THEROTICAL ASPECTS OF MEASURES OF RISK & RETURN IN
MUTUAL FUND SECTOR
1.10 TYPES OF RISKS
1.11 MEASURES OF RETURNS
Page
no.
Chapter-1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 OVERVIEW
Prudent investing requires information of key financial concepts and an understanding of your
investment profile and how these works together to affect investing decisions and results.
"Saving" and "investing" are often used interchangeably. However, there are differences between
the two. Saving refers to funds kept for making specific purchases in the relatively near future
(usually three years or less) and for emergencies. Preservation of the principal and liquidity of
the funds (ease of converting to cash) are essential aspects of savings. Consequently, savings
generally yield a low rate of return and do not maintain purchasing power. Investing, on the other
hand, focuses on increasing net worth and achieving long-term financial goals. Investing
involves risk (of loss of principal) and is to be considered only after you have adequate savings
and have done proper risk management. In short, investing is more concerned on the return of
investment, while savings is on the return of capital. All investments involve some element of
risk because the future value of an investment is uncertain. Risk, simply stated, is the possibility
that the actual return on an investment will vary from the anticipated return or that the initial
principal will decline in value. Risk implies the possibility of loss on your investment. Mutual
Fund Is a fund, managed by an investment company with the financial objective of generating
high Rate of Returns or an investment vehicle managed by finance professionals that raise
capital by selling shares (called units) in a chosen and balanced set of securities to the public. An
investment fund is a collection of investments, such as stocks, bonds or other funds. Unlike most
other types of investment funds, mutual funds are open-ended, which means as more people
invest, the fund issues new units or shares. A mutual fund typically focuses on specific types of
investments. For example, a fund may invest mainly in government bonds, stocks from large
companies or stocks from certain countries. Some funds may invest in a mix of stocks and bonds,
or other mutual funds. These asset management or investment management companies collects
money from the investors and invests those money in different Stocks, Bonds and other financial
securities in a diversified manner. Before investing they carry out thorough research and detailed
analysis on the market conditions and market trends of stock and bond prices. These things help
the fund managers to speculate properly in the right direction. The investors, who invest their
money in the Mutual fund of any Investment Management Company, receive an Equity Position
in that particular mutual fund. When after certain period of time, whether long term or short
term, the investors sell the Shares of the Mutual Fund, they receive the return according to the
market conditions.
calculated by dividing the market value of scheme's assets by the total number of units issued to
the investors.
For example:
1. If the market value of the assets of a fund is Rs 100,000
2. The total number of units issued to the investors is equal to 10,000.
3. Then the NAV of this scheme = (A)/ (B), i.e. 100,000/10,000 or 10.00
4. Now if an investor 'X' owns 5 units of this scheme
5. Then his total contribution to the fund is Rs. 50 (i.e. Number of units held multiplied by the
NAV of the scheme).
FIGURE 3.1 THE FLOW CHART BELOW DESCRIBES BROADLY THE WORKING
OF A MUTUAL FUND
FUND SCHEMES
Growth and Income
Balanced
Liquid and Money Market
Gilt
ELSS
Fund of Funds
ETFs
Open-end Funds Fund that can sell and purchase units at any point in time are
classified as Open-end Funds. The fund size (corpus) of an open-end fund is variable
(keeps changing) because of continuous selling (to investors) and repurchases (from the
investors) by the fund. An open-end fund is not required to keep selling new units to the
investors at all times but is required to always repurchase, when an investor wants to sell
his units. The NAV of an open-end fund is calculated every day.
Closed-end funds Fund that can sell a fixed number of units only during the New Fund
Offer (NFO) period are known as Closed-end Funds. The corpus of a Closed-end Fund
remains unchanged at all. After the closure of the offer, buying and redemption of units
by the investors directly from the Funds is not allowed. However, to protect the interests
of the investors, SEBI provides investors with two avenues to liquidate their positions:
1. Closed-end Funds are listed on the stock exchanges where investors can buy/sell units
from/to each other. The trading is generally done at a discount to the NAV of the
scheme. The NAV of a closed-end fund is computed on a weekly basis.
2. Closed-end Funds may also offer "buy-back of units" to the unit holders. In this case,
the corpus of the Fund and its outstanding units do get changed.
Load Funds Mutual Funds incur various expenses on marketing, distribution,
advertising, portfolio churning, fund manager's salary etc. Many funds recover these
expenses from the investors in the form of load. These funds are known as Load Funds.
A load fund may impose following types of loads on the investors:
* Entry Load - Also known as Front-end load, it refers to the load charged to an
investor at the time of his entry into a scheme. Entry load is deducted from the investor's
contribution amount to the fund.
* Exit Load - Also known as Back-end load, these charges are imposed on an
investor when he redeems his units (exits from the scheme). Exit load is deducted from
the redemption proceeds to an outgoing investor.
* Deferred Load - Deferred load is charged to the scheme over a period of time.
* Contingent Deferred Sales Charge (CDSS) - In some schemes, the percentage of
exit load reduces as the investor stays longer with the fund. This type of load is known
as Contingent Deferred Sales Charge.
No-load Funds All those funds that do not charge any of the above mentioned loads are
known as No-load Funds.
Tax-exempt Funds Fund that invests in securities free from tax are known as Taxexempt Funds. All open-end equity oriented funds are exempt from distribution tax (tax
for distributing income to investors). Long term capital gains and dividend income in
the hands of investors are tax-free. 6. Non-Tax-exempt Funds Fund that invest in taxable
securities are known as Non-Tax-exempt Funds. In India, all funds, except open-end
equity oriented funds are liable to pay tax on distribution income. Profits arising out of
sale of units by an investor within 12 months of purchase are categorized as short-term
capital gains, which are taxable. Sale of units of an equity oriented fund is subject to
Securities Transaction Tax (STT). STT is deducted from the redemption proceeds to an
investor
risk has the potential for higher return, it also has the greater potential for losses or
negative returns. Lonnie L. Bryant and Hao-Chen Liu (2008) investigated that implement
various risk measures to analysis the impacts management structure, fund objective, fund
market capitalization and other fund level characteristics have on investor wealth. Our
evidence indicates that when fund managers manage multiple funds simultaneously, the
risk of one of the managed funds is significantly increased, minimizing the inherit
benefits of mutual fund stock diversification. Thus, all else equal, the more time that a
manager devotes to an individual fund the more likely the fund will reduce its risk
exposure. This increased risk exposure of the multiple management structure results in
fund misclassification.
RETURN
The annual return on an investment, expressed as a percentage of the total amount
invested also called rate of return or the yield of a fixed income security. The interaction
of mutual funds flows and security returns in emerging markets. Philippas Nikolaos D.,
(2006) examined the hypothesis that mutual funds may act as instability factors in
financial markets within a VAR framework. Daily data from a period, that the emerging
market of Greece had no particular trend, are used. This empirical evidence suggested
that mutual fund flows can be predicted by lagged flows and index returns. He also
obtained a negative relationship between index returns and lagged mutual fund flows, and
he found no correlation between contemporary flows and Index returns. This analysis
implied that mutual fund shareholders are unsophisticated frequently wrong and often
worse than informed investors
BETA RATIO / BETA VALUE
A high beta is good or bad depending on the state of the market. If the market sentiments are
bullish, i.e., the market is seeing a rise in general, then a high beta stock is better and if the
market sentiment is bearish then low beta is preferred.
A beta of 1 indicates that the security's price will move with the market. A beta is less
than 1 means that the security will be less volatile than the market. A beta greater than
1 indicates that the security's price will be more volatile than the market.
Every investment involves risk, and it's important to determine how much risk is appropriate
for any fund that you are considering. Risk means making less than your planned return or
even losing capital. Research by behavioral economists suggests that most people feel twice
the pain over a financial loss as they do pleasure in an equivalent gain. Although not exactly
ideal, the standard deviation (dispersion around the mean return) is generally accepted as a
measure of risk. Unlike the standard deviation, Beta measures the volatility of a fund relative
to a benchmark index. Funds of the same type can have significantly different levels of risks.
For example, funds that put in the best performances throughout the bull market of the 1990s,
such as technology and Internet sector funds, usually are ranked very low in terms of riskadjusted performance. Put another way, investors were exposed to an extreme level of
volatility in return for those stellar returns. A fund with a Beta of higher than 1.0 (1.0 = the
benchmark index) would be expected to outperform the market, while one below that figure
would likely underperform. But a Beta of greater than 1.0 also means the fund is volatile. In
bear markets, the value of these funds may fall much more than the major market indexes.
Beta, a component of Modern Portfolio Theory statistics, is a measure of a fund's
sensitivity to market movements. It measures the relationship between a fund's excess return
over T-bills and the excess return of the benchmark index. Betas are typically, but not always,
calculated over the last 36 months.
Price to Earnings Ratio (P/E Ratio): Market Price EPS When investors buy shares of
a company; they are essentially buying into its future earnings. P/E ratio indicates how
much investors in the share market are prepared to pay (to become owners of the
company), in relation to the companys earnings. This ratio is normally calculated based
on a projected EPS for a future period (also called forward EPS) A simplistic (but faulty)
view is that low P/E means that a share is cheap, and therefore should be bought; the
corollary being that high P/E means that a share is expensive, and therefore should be
sold. In reality, the P/E may be high because the companys prospects are indeed good,
while another companys P/E may be low because it is unlikely to replicate its past
performance.
3. Book Value per Share: Net Worth No. of equity shares this is an indicator of how
much each share is worth, as per the companys own books of accounts. The accounts
represent a historical perspective, and are a function of various accounting policies
adopted by the company.
4.
Price to Book Value: Market Price Book Value per Share An indicator of how much
the share market is prepared to pay for each share of the company, as compared to its
book value. Such financial parameters are compared across companies, normally within a
sector. Accordingly, recommendations are made to buy / hold / sell the shares of the
company. As in the case of P/E ratio, most financial indicators cannot be viewed as standalone numbers. They need to be viewed in the context of unique factors underlying each
company. The fundamental analyst keeps track of various companies in a sector, and the
uniqueness of each company, to ensure that various financial indicators are understood in
the right perspective. The discipline of Technical Analysis has a completely different
approach. Technical Analysts believe that price behavior of a share, and the volumes
traded are a reflection of investor sentiment, which in turn will influence future price of
the share.
Both types of analysts swear by their discipline. It is generally agreed that longer term
investment decisions are best taken through a fundamental analysis approach, while
technical analysis comes in handy for shorter term speculative decisions, including intraday trading. Even where a fundamental analysis-based decision has been taken on a
stock, technical analysis might help decide when to implement the decision i.e. the
timing. Investment Styles Growth and Value Growth investment style entails investing
in high growth stocks i.e. stocks of companies that are likely to grow much faster than the
economy. Many market players are interested in accumulating such growth stocks.
Therefore, valuation of these stocks tends to be on the higher side. Value investment style
is an approach of picking up stocks which are valued lower, based on fundamental
analysis. The belief is that the market has not appreciated some aspect of the value in a
companys share and hence it is cheap. When the market recognizes the intrinsic value,
then the price would shoot up. Such stocks are also called value stocks.
Since no time frame can be set for the market to recognize the value, value stocks tend to
be longer term investments, at times beyond two years. Even then, the market may not
recognize it, in which case the investment fails. It is important to note that high
valuation is not the equivalent of high share price, just as low valuation is not the
same as low share price. For example, how much is the share price as compared to its
earnings per share (Price to Earnings Ratio); or how much is the share price as compared
to its book value (Price to Book Value Ratio). Thus, a companys share price may be
high, say Rs 100, but still reasonably valued given its earnings; similarly, a company may
be seen as over-valued, even when its share price is Rs 5, if it is not matched by a
reasonably level of earnings. Investments of a scheme can thus be based on growth, value
or a blend of the two styles. In the initial phases of a bull run, growth stocks deliver good
returns. Subsequently, when the market heats up, value picks end up being safer. Portfolio
building approach Top down and Bottom up.In a top down approach, the portfolio manager decides how to distribute the investible
corpus between countries (if it invests in multiple geographies) and sectors. Thereafter,
the good stocks within the identified sectors are selected for investment. Thus sector
allocation is a key decision. A bottom-up approach on the other hand does not assign too
much importance to the country-allocation and sector-allocation. If a stock is good, it is
picked for investment. The approach is therefore also called stock picking. Stock
selection is the key decision in this approach; sector allocation is a result of the stock
selection decisions. Both approaches have their merit. What is important is that the
approach selected should be implemented professionally. Therefore, it can be said that
equity returns are a function of sector and stock selection.
DEBT
Investment in a debt security, as in the case of a loan, entails a return in the form of
interest (at a pre-specified frequency for a prespecified period), and refund of a prespecified amount at the end of the pre-specified period. The pre-specified period is also
called tenor. At the end of the tenor, the securities are said to mature. The process of
repaying the amounts due on maturity is called redemption. Debt securities that are to
mature within a year are called money market securities. The return that an investor earns
or is likely to earn on a debt security is called its yield. The yield would be a combination
of interest paid by the issuer and capital gain (if the proceeds on redemption are higher
than the amount invested) or capital loss (if the proceeds on redemption are lower than
the amount invested) Debt securities may be issued by Central Government, State
Governments, Banks, Financial Institutions, Public Sector Undertakings (PSU), Private
Companies, Municipalities etc.
Securities issued by the Government are called Government Securities or G-Sec or
Gilt.
Treasury Bills are short term debt instruments issued by the Reserve Bank of India on
behalf of the Government of India.
opportunities to earn gains by anticipating changes in credit quality, and changes in yield
spreads between different market benchmarks in the market place.
INTEREST RATES
When money is cheap and easily available, more people buy real estate. This pushes up real
estate values. Rise in interest rates therefore softens the real estate market. The behavior of real
estate is also a function of the nature of real estate viz. residential or commercial; industrial,
infrastructural, warehouse, hotel or retail. Similarly, a lot of innovation is possible in structuring
the real estate exposure. Real estate analysts are experts in assessing the future direction of
different kinds of real estate, and structuring exposure to them. The portfolio is the most
important driver of returns in a scheme. The factors that drive the return of some of the asset
classes were discussed here. The factors that cause fluctuation in the returns of these asset
classes, and the schemes that invest in them, are discussed in a later section on risk drivers.
RISK-RETURNS STRUCTURE OF SCHEMES
Changing interest rates affect both equities and bonds in many ways. Investors are reminded that
predicting which way rates will go is rarely successful. A diversified portfolio can help in
offsetting these changes.
Effect of loss of key professional and inability to adopt
An industries key asset is often the personnel who run the business i.e. intellectual
properties of the key employees of the respective companies. Given the ever-changing
complexion of few industries and the high obsolescence levels, availability of qualified,
trained and motivated personnel is very critical for the success of industries in few
sectors. It is, therefore, necessary to attract key personnel and also to retain them to meet
the changing environment and challenges all investments involve some form of risk,
which should be evaluated them potential Rewards when an investment is selected.
Managing risk
At times the prices or yields of all the securities in a particular market rises or falls due to
broad outside influences. When this happens, the Mutual prices of an outstanding, highly
profitable company and a fledgling corporation may be affected. This change in price is
due to market risk.
Interest rate risk
It referred to as loss of purchasing power. Whenever inflation sprints forward faster
than the earnings on your investment, you run the risk that you will actually be able to
buy less, not more. Inflation risk also occurs when prices rise faster than your returns.
Credit risk
The sector offers. Failure or inability to attract/retain such qualified key personnel may
impact the prospects of the companies in the particular sector in which the fund invests.
Exchange risks
Thematic funds are a variation of sector funds. Here the investment is as per a theme,
say, and infrastructure. Multiple sectors, such as power, transportation, cement, steel,
contracting and real estate are connected to infrastructure. Thus, a thematic fund tends to
have wider exposure than a sector fund, but a narrower exposure than a diversified fund.
Therefore, thematic funds are less risky than sector funds, but riskier than diversified
equity funds.
Mid cap funds invest in mid cap stocks, which are less liquid and less researched in the
market, than the frontline stocks. Therefore, the liquidity risk is high in such portfolios.
Further, since they are intrinsically not as strong as the frontline stocks, they become
riskier during periods of economic turmoil.
Contra funds take positions that are contrary to the market. Such an investment style
has a high risk of misjudgments.
Dividend yield funds invest in shares whose prices fluctuate less, but offer attractive
returns in the form of dividend. Such funds offer equity exposure with lower downside.
Arbitrage funds are categorized as equity funds because they invest in equity. In reality,
the risks are arbitraged (i.e. cancelled out), normally between the cash market and the
F&O market. Therefore, the risk in this category of funds turns out to be the lowest
among equity funds even lower than diversified equity funds. The returns too are lower
more in line with money market returns, rather than equity market returns. However,
one should not forget the basis risk in an arbitrage fund the risk that both cash and
F&O position on a company cannot be reversed at the same time. During the time gap
between unwinding of the two positions, the market can move adverse to the scheme.
to operate. Further, SEBI has laid down detailed portfolio valuation guidelines to enhance the
transparency of NAV.
Portfolio Specific
Short maturity securities suffer lesser fluctuation in value, as compared to the ones with longer
tenor. Therefore, liquid schemes, which invest in securities of up to 91 days maturity, have the
lowest risk amongst all kinds of schemes. Even gilt schemes, which invest in only government
securities, have higher risk than liquid schemes because their NAV can fluctuate a lot more, on
account of changes in yield in the market. Greater the proportion of longer maturity securities in
the portfolio, higher would be the fluctuation in NAV. In the interim, the value of these securities
will fluctuate in line with the market and therefore, the schemes NAV too will fluctuate. If the
FMP is structured on the basis of investment in non-government paper, then the credit risk is an
issue. While an equity share is an equity share, several variants of debt securities are possible.
Advanced computing technology makes it possible to slice and dice debt securities and create
complex structures in innovative ways. In pursuit of innovation, instruments are created and
traded, without the intellectual rigour that has improved our understanding of traditional debt
instruments. In the case of specific structures like securitized debt, it is not possible for the
investor to study the debtors whose obligations support the securitization. A pure capital
guaranteed scheme is one where the guarantee comes out of sovereign debt i.e. government
securities, which mature to the requisite value on or before the closure of the scheme. Schemes
where the capital guarantee is based on investment in non-sovereign debt, even if it is an AAArated portfolio, have a credit risk. Therefore, the capital guarantee cannot be taken for granted.
There are therefore in the nature of capital protection oriented schemes rather than capital
guaranteed schemes.
whether they are investing in a debt scheme or an equity scheme. Therefore, investors do not
have clarity on whether to treat it as equity or debt, in the asset allocation for their financial plan.
MEASURES OF RETURNS
SIMPLE RETURN
Whatever the nature of a mutual fund scheme, its value is reflected in the NAV. Suppose
you invested in a scheme, when its NAV was Rs 12. Later, you found that the NAV has
grown to Rs 15. How much is your return? The Simple Return can be calculated with the
following formula: i.e. 25%
(Later value-Initial Value)*100/Initial Value
(Rs15-Rs12)*100/Rs12
ANNUALIZED RETURN
Two investment options have indicated their returns since inception as 5% and 3%
respectively. If the first investment was in existence for 6 months, and the second for 4
months, then the two returns are obviously not comparable. Annualisation helps us
compare the returns of two different time periods.
SIMPLE RETURN*12/Period of simple return (in months)
COMPANY PROFILE
Identity
With 25 years of rich experience in fund management, we at SBI Funds Management Pvt.
Ltd. bring forward our expertise by consistently delivering value to our investors. We have a
strong and proud lineage that traces back to the State Bank of India (SBI) - India's largest
bank. We are a Joint Venture between SBI and AMUNDI (France), one of the world's leading
fund management companies.
With our network of over 222 points of acceptance across India, we deliver value and nurture
the trust of our vast and varied family of investors.
Excellence has no substitute. And to ensure excellence right from the first stage of product
development to the post-investment stage, we are ably guided by our philosophy of growth
through innovation and our stable investment policies. This dedication is what helps our
customers achieve their financial objectives.
Vision
To be the most preferred and the largest fund house for all asset classes, with a
consistent track record of excellent returns and best standards in customer
service, product innovation, technology and HR practices.
Services
Mutual Funds
Investors are our priority. Our mission has been to establish Mutual Funds as a
viable investment option to the masses in the country. Working towards it, we
developed innovative, need-specific products and educated the investors about
the added benefits of investing in capital markets via Mutual Funds.
Today, we have been actively managing our investor's assets not only through
our investment expertise in domestic mutual funds, but also offshore funds and
portfolio management advisory services for institutional investors.
This makes us one of the largest investment management firms in India,
managing investment mandates of over 5.4 million investors.
Portfolio Management and Advisory Services
SBI Funds Management has emerged as one of the largest player in India advising various
financial institutions, pension funds, and local and international asset management
companies.
We have excelled by understanding our investor's requirements and terms of risk / return
expectations, based on which we suggest customized asset portfolio recommendations. We
also provide an integrated end-to-end customized asset management solution for institutions
in terms of advisory service, discretionary and non-discretionary portfolio management
services.
management company fund to launch an offshore fund called 'SBI Resurgent India
Opportunities Fund' with an objective to provide our investors with opportunities for longterm growth in capital, through well-researched investments in a diversified basket of stocks
of Indian Companies
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
Friend, et al., (1962) made an extensive and systematic study of 152 mutual funds found that
mutual fund schemes earned an average annual return of 12.4 percent, while their composite
benchmark earned a return of 12.6 percent. Their alpha was negative with 20 basis points.
Overall results did not suggest widespread inefficiency in the industry. Comparison of fund
returns with turnover and expense categories did not reveal a strong relationship
Irwin, Brown, FE (1965) analyzed issues relating to investment policy, portfolio turnover rate,
performance of mutual funds and its impact on the stock markets. They identified that mutual
funds had a significant impact on the price movement in the stock market. They concluded that,
on an average, funds did not perform better than the composite markets and there was no
persistent relationship between portfolio turnover and fund performance
Treynor (1965) used characteristic line for relating expected rate of return of a fund to the rate
of return of a suitable market average. He coined a fund performance measure taking investment
risk into account. Further, to deal with a portfolio, portfolio-possibility line was used to relate
expected return to the portfolio owners risk preference.
Sharpe, William F (1966) developed a composite measure of return and risk. He evaluated 34
open-end mutual funds for the period 1944-63. Reward to variability ratio for each scheme was
significantly less than DJIA (Dow Jones Industrial Average) and ranged from 0.43 to 0.78.
Expense ratio was inversely related with the fund performance, as correlation coefficient was
0.0505. The results depicted that good performance was associated with low expense ratio and
not with the size. Sample schemes showed consistency in risk measure.
Treynor and Mazuy (1966) evaluated the performance of 57 fund managers in terms of their
market timing abilities and found that, fund managers had not successfully outguessed the
market. The results suggested that, investors were completely dependent on fluctuations in the
market. Improvement in the rates of return was due to the fund managers ability to identify
under-priced industries and companies. The study adopted Treynors (1965) methodology for
reviewing the performance of mutual funds.
Jensen (1968) developed a composite portfolio evaluation technique concerning risk-adjusted
returns. He evaluated the ability of 115 fund managers in selecting securities during the period
1945-66. Analysis of net returns indicated that, 39 funds had above average returns, while 76
funds yielded abnormally poor returns. Using gross returns, 48 funds showed above average
results and 67 funds below average results. Jensen concluded that, there was very little evidence
that funds were able to 22 perform significantly better than expected as fund managers were not
able to forecast securities price movements.
Fama (1972) developed methods to distinguish observed return due to the ability to pick up the
best securities at a given level of risk from that of predictions of price movements in the market.
He introduced a multiperiod model allowing evaluation on a period-by-period and on a
cumulative basis. He concluded that, return on a portfolio constitutes of return for security
selection and return for bearing risk. His contributions combined the concepts from modern
theories of portfolio selection and capital market equilibrium with more traditional concepts of
good portfolio management
Klemosky (1973) analyzed investment performance of 40 funds based on quarterly returns
during the period 1966-71. He acknowledged that, biases in Sharpe, Treynor, and Jensens
measures, could be removed by using mean absolute deviation and semi-standard deviation as
risk surrogates compared to the composite measures derived from the CAPM (Capital Asset
Pricing Modal).
Gupta (1974) evaluated the performance of mutual fund industry for the period 1962-71 using
Sharpe, Treynor, and Jensen models. All the funds covered under the study outperformed the
market irrespective of the choice of market index. The results indicated that all the three models
provided identical results. Return per unit of risk varied with the level of volatility assumed and
he concluded that, funds with higher volatility exhibited superior performance.
Gupta Ramesh (1989) evaluated fund performance in India comparing the returns earned by
schemes of similar risk and similar constraints. An explicit risk-return relationship was
developed to make comparison across funds with different risk levels. His study decomposed
total return into return from investors risk, return from managers risk and target risk
RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Company Perspective : (1) To analyze the Risks associated with mutual fund
(2) To analyze the Return.
DATABASE
RESEARCH DESIGN:
Research design for the present study was descriptive. Descriptive study with regard to Mutual
fund customers and employees preferences and experiences was undertaken using structured
questionnaires. Separate questionnaires were prepared for mutual fund customers as well as for
the Employees of the Company.
Also, the working of mutual fund market was studied by reference to secondary data and
collecting data using unstructured interviews from customers and employees.
Company Brochure
Books
Internet.
ANALYSIS TOOLS AND TECHNIQUES: Analysis Tools- data was analyzed used
graphical representation, percentage analysis, t test and correlation.
Male
Female
No. of Responses
58
42
Gender of Respondents
INTERPRETATION: Most of the employees are Male i.e. 58% and 42% are female
out of 100 employees. Majority is of Male.
Q. Age of Respondents?
Table
Age of
Respondents
15-25
26-37
38-49
Above 50
Total
Responses
20
36
33
11
Total % of
Responses
20%
36%
33%
11%
Age of
Respondents
AGE
40%
35%
30%
25%
AGE
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
15-25
26-37
38-49
Above 50
Q1. How long you have been working with SBI Mutual Fund?
Table
How long
working
0-6months
6-12months
1-2yrs
Total
Responses
11
20
29
40
Total % of
Responses
11%
20%
29%
40%
15%
10%
5%
ye
ar
s
M
or
e
th
a
ye
ar
s
12
m
on
th
s
612
16
m
on
th
s
0%
Q2. What kinds of customers are mostly associated with SBI Mutual Fund?
Kinds
of
Government
Businessme
associated
employees
Total Responses
21
50
29
21%
50%
29%
Total
Responses
customers
of
Professionals
Customers
50%
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
si
on
al
s
an
Pr
of
es
m
Bu
si
ne
ss
G
ov
er
nm
en
tE
m
pl
oy
ee
s
Customers
Fig.
very much less in number therefore company should launches such schemes which attract the
government employees also.
Balanced fund
customer invest
Sectorial
Tax
fund
fund
mostly
Total Responses
25
16
26
33
Total
25%
16%
26%
33%
Responses
of
Equity Fund
Sectorial Fund
Any Other
Total Responses
27
51
22
Total % of
27%
51%
22%
Risky
Responses
Less than 1%
1%
More than 1%
Total Responses
37
43
20
Total % of
37%
43%
20%
Responses
Exit Load
INTERPRETATION: In most of the schemes the exit load will be 1% i.e. if money is
withdraw before 1 year of investment.
Q6. Are the employees of SBI Mutual Fund regular touch with Customers?
Table
Regular Touch with
Yes
No
91
Total % of Responses
91%
9%
Customers
Q7. What percentage of Return does company get from Mutual Fund?
Table
Percentage of
Return
Company Get
10-20%
20-30%
30-40%
Above 40%
Total
Responses
32
27
22
19
Total % of
32%
27%
22%
19%
Responses
Percentage of Return
Company Get
Q8. Are you satisfied with the return company getting from Mutual Fund?
Table
Satisfied With
Return
Highly
Satisfied
Satisfied
Average
Return
Total
Responses
38
27
Not Good
26
Total % of
Responses
9%
38%
27%
26%
Satisfied with
Return
INTERPRETATION: 38% are satisfied with the return that comes from mutual fund
but only 9% are highly satisfied.
Yes
No
20
80
Total % of Responses
20%
80%
Risk for
Collecting
INTERPRETATION: Majority of them did not find any risk for collecting the amount
towards the mutual fund only 20% find difficult for collecting the amount.
Yes
No
Total Responses
80
20
Total % of Responses
80%
20%
AWARENESS
80%
70%
60%
AWARENESS
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
YES
NO
INTERPRETATION:
Gender of Respondents
No. of Responses
Male
59
Female
41
41%
59%
Male
Female
Q. Age of Respondents?
Table
Age of
Respondents
15-25
26-37
38-49
Above 50
Total
Responses
35
37
15
13
Total % of
Responses
35%
37%
15%
13%
Age of
Respondents
AGE
40%
35%
30%
25%
AGE
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
15-25
26-37
38-49
Above 50
Service
of Customers
Total
31
Responses
Professionals
Business
Students
Retired
20
class
20
21
Total % of 31%
20%
21%
20%
8%
Responses
8%
20%
31%
Service
Professionals
21%
Business class
20%
Students
Retired
Below 20,000
11
11%
20,000-40,000
54
54%
Responses
40,000-60,000
35
35%
54%
35%
11%
Below 20,000
20,000-40,000
40,000-60,000
Public
Private
Total Responses
Total % of Responses
53
53%
47
47%
47%
53%
Public
Private
Table
Feature of
mutual fund
Diversification
Better return
Tax Benefit
Any other
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
20
20%
32
32%
28
28%
20
20%
Feature of mutual
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Diversification Better Return Tax Benefit
Any Other
Q3. What do you look before investing in a particular mutual fund scheme?
Table
Look Before
Investing
Past
Performance
(NAV)
Ratings (by
CRISIL, ICRA,
Etc.)
Asset
Management
Companies
(AMC)
Expert Advise
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
33
33%
34
34%
9
9%
24
24%
24%
33%
9%
34%
Short-term
Medium term
Long term
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
25
25%
24
24%
51
51%
51%
Investment Horizon
25%
Short-term
24%
Medium term
Long term
Liquidity
Low risk
High return
Trust
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
27
27%
20
20%
30
30%
23
23%
Factor Do You
Prefer
27%
Liquidity
20%
Low risk
30%
High return
Trust23%
Dividend payout
Dividend reinvestment
Growth in NAV
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
24
24%
44
44%
32
32%
Like To Receive
Return
24%
Dividend payout
44%
Dividend re-investment
Growth in32%
NAV
Q7. Do you know what is current NAV (Net Asset Value) of your plan?
Table
Current NAV
Yes
No
Total Responses
Total % of Responses
75
75%
25
25%
Current
NAV
25%
Yes
75%
No
Q8. What do you feel about services provided by SBI in terms of Mutual Fund?
Table
Services
Provided
Excellent
Good
Satisfactory
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
48
48%
28
28%
13
13%
Bad
11
11%
48%
Services Provided
28%
13%
Excellent
Good
Satisfactory
11%
Bad
Q9. What do you think about the transparency level of your account?
Table
Transparency
Level
Excellent
Good
Satisfactory
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
65
65%
18
18%
13
13%
Bad
4
4%
65%
Transparency Level
18%
13%
4%
Excellent
Good
Satisfactory
Bad
Total Responses
Total % of Responses
30
30%
40
40%
Others
30
30%
[Type a quote from the document or the summary of an interesting point. You can
position the text box anywhere in the document. Use the Drawing Tools tab to
change the formatting of the pull quote text box.]
PREFERENCES
Birla Sun Life
30%
OTHERS
30%
40%
CONCLUSION: Majority of them are satisfied after investment in SBI and from these we can
conclude that they are happy with the return from the company.
5% to 10%
10% to 20%
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
11
11%
41
41%
48
48%
Return Expect
11%
5% to 10%
41%
10% to 20%
More than48%
20%
Q12. How would you like to invest your money in mutual fund?
Table
Like to Invest The Money
SIP
Total Responses
Total % of Responses
9
9%
91
91%
0.91
Q13. Are you satisfied with the return from your investment?
Table
Yes
No
Total Responses
Total % of Responses
65
65%
35
35%
35%
65%
Yes
NO
Sectorial fund
Equity fund
Balanced Fund
Total Responses
Total % of
Responses
49
49%
38
38%
13
13%
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
Sectorial Fund
Equity Fund
Bakanced Fund
CONCLUSION
The Indian mutual funds industry has transformed totally for good since last decade and has
shown growth and potential. Though the Asset under Management and number of schemes has
increased significantly, but it is yet to be a household product, and needs to cover the retail
segment effectively. Moreover, there are still many remote and potential areas which lack the
required knowledge and infrastructure of mutual funds.
Mutual fund is an excellent product offering great flexibility and liquidity,
which can be tailored to suit any investors objective and it is affordable for the all people of
different income levels and saving habits. Mutual funds now represent perhaps most appropriate
investment opportunity for most investors. As financial market become more sophisticated and
complex, investor need a financial intermediary who provides the required knowledge nd
professional expertise on successful investing, as the investor always try to maximize the return
and minimize the risk. Mutual funds satisfy these requirements by providing attractive return and
affordable risks. The fund industry has already overtaken the banking industry, more funds being
under mutual fund management than deposited with banks. With the emergence of tough
competition in this sector mutual funds are launching a variety of schemes which caters to the
requirement of the particular class of investors, risk takers for getting capital appreciation should
invest in growth, equity schemes. Investors who are in need of regular income should invest in
income plans.
The stock market has also been rising for over three years now. This in turn has not only
protected the money invested in funds but has also to help grow these investments. This has also
instilled greater confidence among fund investors who are investing more into market through
the MF route than ever before.
After doing study it is concluded that yes mutual funds are much better investment option but as
future is uncertain so no one can give a sure guarantee of good return, no matter whether it is
equity or a mutual fund. Investors can minimize their risk by doing little research before
investing in the markets which will help them to decide the right investment plan or product.
have been short on specifies indicating how those losses will be measured and how
the compensation will be provided.
Mutual fund should use appropriate and simple names for the schemes, which match
the feature of the schemes, so that investors are not confused and feel cheated after
investing.