discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: http://www.researchgate.net/publication/226667223
CITATIONS
READS
10
109
3 AUTHORS, INCLUDING:
Terrence N Hays
Victor Minichiello
La Trobe University
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
PH143-378899-03
18:16
LY
C 2002)
Journal of Aging and Identity, Vol. 7, No. 3, September 2002 (
FR
EA
IN
Many people value music as an important part of their everyday lives. The published literature reveals that the role of music in life is varied: it can be recreational,
educational, social, emotional, therapeutic, and spiritual. The importance and relevance of music depend on the life needs and interests of the individual and the
social group within which he/she lives. It is now widely recognized that music for
many older people is crucial in supporting a sense of well-being. The article reviews the evidence on the role of music in promoting health and well-being, and how
it can produce positive psychological and physiological benefits for individuals.
The aim of this article is to increase awareness among health professionals of the
importance of music and discuss how it can be used to add to older peoples lives.
PR
O
INTRODUCTION
FO
From preliterate times to today, music has been associated with the maintenance of physical and mental well-being. Historical evidence shows that, since
the first appearance of civilizations as far back as 5000 B.C., music has been used
to serve communal purposes, for example, religious ritual, warfare, and healing
(Davis, Gfeller, & Thaut, 1992; Storr, 1992). From China to Egypt to India and
to the golden age of Greece, there was a common belief that there was something immensely fundamental about the power of music. These civilizations believed that music could heal, entertain, control emotions, maintain social order, or
degrade the individuals psyche (Tame, 1984), and to this day music continues to
1 School
2 School
3 Correspondence
165
C 2002 Human Sciences Press, Inc.
1087-3732/02/0900-0165/0
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
166
PH143-378899-03
18:16
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
PH143-378899-03
18:16
167
of life and possibly the facilitation of a faster recovery period. For this reason,
Maranto states that music can be successfully used in medicine because it elicits
physiological, psychological, and cognitive responses, evokes imagery and associations, and may cause physiological and psychological entrainment.
One of the most important benefits of music on personal health is that it
simultaneously affects the biomedical and psychosocial aspects of treatment (Clair,
1996; Maranto, 1993; Merritt, 1990; Ortiz, 1997; Rider, 1987). It is painless, nonintrusive, easily accessible, and cost effective. Moreover, it has few side effects and
incorporates participation as well as a sense of personal responsibility for ones own
treatment. Phillip (1994) argues that the concept of creative expression through the
arts provides health-promoting opportunities for individuals to improve their wellbeing and self-esteem. He suggests, for example, that when peoples self-esteem
is enhanced, they are more likely to live a healthier lifestyle, and this potentially
can lead to reduced dependence, fewer prescriptions, fewer repeat visits to health
clinics, and more constructive leisure-time pursuits.
THE PSYCHOLOGICAL CONTEXT OF MUSIC
Music for most people is experienced as a sense of pleasure, whether they
listen to it intently or participate in the making of it. Our appeal for music is
primarily emotional and psychological. As Anthony Storr (1990) states, music
more aptly symbolizes human processes because music, like life, is in constant
motion (p. 11). Music can excite us, move us, entertain us, soothe us and thrill us
more than most other stimuli (Scarantino, 1987).
Radocy and Boyle (1979) suggest that there are eight types of affective responses to music. Some of these relate to an innate sensory perception of sound,
while others are associated with images, past experiences, and the emotional context of these experiences. These responses may include simple feelings; negative
and positive organic feelings; activity feelings; moral, religious and aesthetic feelings; and emotions and temperaments. Although music is not physically invasive,
for many people it is psychologically the most invasive of all stimuli because it
gets into the mind, whether we want it to or not. Because of this, quality music
often can help people confront issues which they have not dealt with earlier in their
lives. This is largely because of the association between the events of the past with
a particular piece of music (Bright, 1993; Levine & Levine, 1999; Ortiz, 1997).
Under the right circumstances, music is an effective therapeutic agent because it
can align patterns of emotions, structures of consciousness and/or psychic energy (Stewart, 1990, p. 62). It does not need to appeal to logic and rarely meets
with intellectual resistance to initiate its action (Guzzetta, 1995).
Music can help us to initiate psychological movement by modifying our mental state and cuing us towards more positive affirmations, such as sad to cheerful,
discouraged to hopeful, gloomy to sunny, or tormented to peaceful. To do this
Publisher: Delete
and close-up?
Follow
throughout?
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
168
PH143-378899-03
18:16
successfully in music therapy, Ortiz (1997, p. 317) refers to the concept of entrainment, whereby music is matched to moods. Bright (1993), from her work as
a therapist, states that it is essential to gradually change the mood of the music
with the state of the individual. It must first match the individuals state and can
then be changed to allow movement.
Blacking (1990) suggests the essential quality of music is in its ability to create
another world of virtual time. The composer Stravinsky (1936) expressed the same
concept when he said music is given to us with the sole purpose of establishing
an order in things, including, and particularly, the coordination between man and
time (p. 83). Menuhin (1972) goes further when he states that music creates
order out of chaos, for rhythm imposes unanimity upon the divergent, melody
imposes continuity upon the disjointed, and harmony imposes compatibility upon
the incongruous (p. 3). Listening to music can mean creating and expanding our
internal space where we can retreat from the norms and reality of the world. This
is achieved by creating an internal imaginative world of sound which is rich in
symbolism and personal meaning, and allowing us to revisit the emotional context
of particular memories (Bunt, 1996).
Music as a medium for channeling our emotional being is trans-cultural,
given that all known cultures had/have music. This reflects peoples attraction
to organized sound, though it is the human mind that assigns meaning to sounds.
According to Slobada (1989), the reason most of us take part in music activities (be
it listening, composing, or playing music) is that music is capable of arousing in us
deep and significant emotions. These range from the pure aesthetic delight in sound
construction, through emotions such as joy or sorrow which music sometimes
evokes or enhances, to simple relief from monotony, boredom, or depression.
Blacking (1995) notes that music can transport people in a variety of ways,
such as tapping their feet or hands, falling into a trance-like state, or giving vent to
anger. However, such physical states have no meaning unless people relate them to
particular personal associations or events in their lives. For instance, such a physical
state may be linked to an erotic or joyful situation. The music itself cannot have
extra musical meaning unless the experience to which it refers already exists in
the mind of the listener. When music has such associations, it can make people more
aware of feelings they experienced by intensifying and underlining the emotion.
While Storr (1992) believes that music causes arousal only in those who desire
pleasure and meaning from it, the converse effect is true for some people. Particular
music can evoke reminiscence of painful memories or issues that they have not dealt
with in their lives. Storr refers to this arousal as being a condition of heightened
alertness, awareness, interest, and excitement. Thus it can be an enhanced state
of being (p. 4) for many, and a natural non-chemical way of altering mood. He
also claims that there is a closer relation between hearing and emotional arousal
than there is between seeing and emotional arousal.
Boyd and Campbell (1992) observe that when we communicate with the
emotional centers of our being, such as through the use of music, we can reduce
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
PH143-378899-03
18:16
169
stress and achieve a sense of well-being. And it is through our emotions that we
can create a feeling of being bonded with other people and safe within ourselves.
Music also can help achieve a sense of peace and relaxation (Ortiz, 1997). This is
because music can trigger endorphins in the human body that help the mind create
sound images, allowing people to escape into a painless world sheltered by their
imagination. Ortiz (1997) suggests that music energizes people, and such a state can
be instrumental in altering thoughts both by reprogramming old and dysfunctional
messages that may have a negative effect on their lives and by releasing guilt
feelings and unresolved angers.
Bright (1997) comments that words are often inadequate in describing our
inner responses to the music we hear. Ironically, it is music that often can help us
to express through words the problems we may be experiencing and previously
considered inexpressible. Music at times provides a long-awaited catharsis through
laughter, joy, or tears. People who have been isolated from others may open up
to share their feelings after hearing music that triggers joy, sorrow, happiness, or
pleasant memories (Kaye & Blee, 1997).
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
170
PH143-378899-03
18:16
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
PH143-378899-03
18:16
171
Publisher: Delete
and close-up?
Follow
throughout?
Publisher: Delete
and close-up?
Follow
throughout?
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
PH143-378899-03
172
18:16
is stimulated by visual imagery along with auditory imagery. Thus people can be
transported emotionally and aurally back in time via music (assuming the individual is an active participant who is engaged in the listening process, as opposed to
being passive with music only serving as background noise).
Music evokes not only memories of past times, events, and experiences but
also the emotional context of those times (Bunt, 1996). When we listen to music
in a therapeutic environment, we are able to bring to the surface feelings that are
associated with particular experiences. These memories can be images of states
of being which are not always outwardly tangible. Stevens (1993) states that the
outward emotional expression, whether through the words of a song or the musical
sounds alone, is the manifestation of these images, and this in particular reflects the
perceived reality of these images (p. 91). Culture and personal associations with a
particular piece of music profoundly influence peoples emotional response to the
music (Bright, 1993). Music can offer satisfaction and pleasure because it mirrors
life, including its daily happenings, joys, sorrows, and frustrations (Diamond,
1979). Not surprisingly, it has been reported that music is an activity that the
healthy, impaired, talented, and interested enjoy because it provides them with a
relief from stress, anxiety, bereavement, and depression (Blacking, 1995).
Brewer and Campbell (1992), along with Bright (1997), state that music
has two main roles in the lives of older people. First, it has evocative powers,
and second, it provides scope for people to enjoy shared interests and activities,
thus justifiably allowing music to be regarded as a branch of preventive medicine.
Music is an easy and convenient way of encouraging social interaction by removing
the barriers that divide people. Isolation and loneliness are common phenomena
among older people, and often lead to depression and withdrawal from social
contacts. Music has been shown to provide excellent motivation for patients in
Publisher: Delete psycho-geriatrics to take an active role in becoming well; it helps withdrawn
and close-up?
people, who may be lacking interest and self-expression, to become animated. An
Follow
example of this is Miss D in Awakenings (Sacks, 1973). This is especially so
throughout?
for people suffering from dementia (Bright, 1997; Coulson & Ronaldson, 1997).
Music, coupled with personal attention and care from other people, can provide
gratification and restore a sense of worth to older people who may be experiencing
depression or low self-esteem (Crystal, Grober, & Masur, 1989).
CONCLUSION
Since the 1960s, the importance of music as a therapeutic tool in aged care has
become better understood and researched (Hanser, 1985; Hanser, 1990; Kartman,
1980; Kurz, 1960; McClosky, 1985; Olderog & Smith, 1989; Sacks, 1973). Bunt
(1996) states that the essence of our humanity can be captured by the music in our
lives. Acknowledging the potency and potential of the use of music as a therapeutic
device makes it possible to integrate people of different backgrounds, cultures, and
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
PH143-378899-03
18:16
173
experiences. Music therapy and holistic medicine share the same perspective as the
arts therapies in that they are largely concerned with the maintenance of wellness.
Music has the potential of extending the boundaries of all personswhether ill or
healthy, disadvantaged or not (Bright, 1997).
A growing literature explores how music is used as a therapeutic tool that can
influence the psychological and physiological processes in the body to promote
health and well-being (Ansdell, 1995; Bunt, 1996; Jonas, 1991; Olderog & Smith,
1989; Sacks, 1992). However, there is still a lack of research that shows how older
people use music to facilitate positive aging. Although the literature discusses the
use of music as a therapeutic tool, health care practitioners need a broader approach
that advocates and more clearly demonstrates the role and use of music by older
persons to promote personhood and positive aging.
Positive aging is a debatable topic and depends on individual interpretation,
but there is no doubt that participation in activities, such as the use of music,
contributes to an older persons quality of life (Kendig, 1996). Music can be
incorporated into social programs that assist older people in maintaining selfesteem, building bridges between people, providing an opportunity for working
together, aiding in the sharing of memories, and fostering social interests, to name
but a few of the benefits (Bright, 1997).
Further research might include mapping the meaning and role that music
has for older persons, understanding how music assists older persons in later life
to enhance quality of life, identifying how music can be an indicator of positive
health and well-being, and describing the specific circumstances under which
health professionals can best apply music in their practices and what health benefits
are achieved. As Christie (1992) reminds us, if the maintenance of a persons
cognitive, emotional, and physical skill level for as long as possible is an important
goal in the care of the elderly then health professionals need to be more acutely
aware of how music can contribute to older peoples quality of life, health and
well-being (p. 71).
REFERENCES
Aldridge, David. (1996). Music Therapy Research and Practice in Medicine: From Out of the Silence.
London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Ansdell, Gary. (1995). Music for Life: Aspects of Creative Music Therapy With Adult Clients. London:
Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Beatty, W., Zavadil, K., & Bailly, R. (1988). Preserved Musical Skills in a Severely Demented Patient.
International Journal of Clinical Neuropsychology, 10, 158164.
Blacking, John. (1990). How Musical Is Man? Seattle: University of Washington Press.
Blacking, John. (1995). Expressing Human Experience Through Music. In R. Byron (Ed.), Music,
Culture, and Experience: Selected Papers of John Blacking (pp. 223242). Chicago: University
of Chicago Press.
Bonny, Helen. (1997). The State of the Art of Music Therapy. Arts in Psychotherapy, 24 (1), 6573.
Boyd, Chris, & Campbell, Don. (1992). Rhythms of Learning: Creative Tools for Developing Lifelong
Skills. New York: Hawker Brownlow Education.
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
174
PH143-378899-03
18:16
Bright, Ruth. (1993). Cultural Aspects of Music in Therapy. In M. Heal & T. Wigram (Eds.), Music
Therapy in Health and Education (pp.193207). London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Bright, Ruth. (1997). Wholeness in Later Life. London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Bunt, Leslie. (1996). Music Therapy: An Art Beyond Words. New York: Routledge.
Campbell, Don. (1995). Music Physician for Times to Come. Wheaton: Quest Books.
Christie, Mary. (1992). Music Therapy Applications in a Skilled and Intermediate Care Nursing Home
Facility: A Clinical Study. Activities, Adaptation and Aging, 16 (4), 6987.
Clair, Alicia Ann. (1990). A Preliminary Study of Music Therapy Programming for Severely Regressed
Persons With Alzheimers Type Dementia. Journal of Applied Gerontology, 9 (3), 299311.
Clair, Alicia Ann. (1994). Music Therapy and Elderly People. Silver Spring: National Association for
Music Therapy.
Clair, Alicia Ann. (1996). Therapeutic Uses of Music With Older People. Baltimore: Health Professionals Press.
Clair, Alicia Ann, & Hanser, Suzanne. (1995). Music Therapy: Retrieving the Losses of Dementia of
the Alzheimers Type for Patient and Caregiver. In T. Wigram & B. Saperton (Eds.), The Art and
Science of Music Therapy: A Handbook (pp. 342360). Chur, Switzerland: Harwood Academic
Press.
Clair, A., Tebb, S., & Bernstein, B. (1993). The Effect of a Socialization and Music Therapy Intervention
on Self Esteem and Loneliness in Spouse Caregivers of Those Diagnosed With Dementia of the
Alzheimers Type: A Pilot Study. American Journal of Alzheimers Care and Related Disorders
and Research, 2, 2432.
Colt, G. (1996, September). See Me, Touch Me, Feel Me. Life, 9, 3550.
Cozier, W. Ray. (1997). Music and Social Influence. In David Hargreaves & Adrian North (Eds.), The
Social Psychology of Music. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Crystal, H., Grober, E., & Masur, D. (1989). Preservation of Musical Memory in Alzheimers Disease.
Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery, and Psychiatry, 52 (12), 14151416.
Davis, William, Gfeller, Kate, & Thaut, Michael. (1992). An Introduction to Music Therapy Theory
and Practice. Dubuque: W.C. Brown Publishers.
Diamond, John. (1979). Your Body Doesnt Lie. New York: Warner Books.
Felten, D. (1991). A Personal Perspective on Psychoneuroimmunology. Advances: The Journal of
Mind-Body Health, 7 (2), 2831.
Gibson, Diane. (1998). Aged Care: Old Policies, New Problems. Melbourne: Cambridge University
Press.
Guzzetta, Cathie. (1995). Music Therapy: Nursing the Music of the Soul. In Don Campbell (Ed.),
Music Physician for Times to Come (pp. 146166). Wheaton: Quest Books.
Hanser, Suzanne. (1985). Music Therapy and Stress Reduction Research. Music Therapy, 22, 193206.
Hanser, Suzanne. (1990). A Music Therapy for Depressed Older Adults in the Community. Journal of
Applied Gerontology, 9 (3), 283298.
Jamieson, Anne, Harper, Sara, & Victor, Christina (Eds.). (1997). Critical Approaches to Ageing and
Later Life. Buckingham: Open University Press.
Jonas, Jennifer. (1991). Preferences of Elderly Music Listeners Residing in Nursing Homes for Arts
Music, Traditional Jazz, Popular Music of Today, and Country Music. Music Therapy, 28 (3),
149160.
Jourdain, Robert. (1997). Music, the Brain and Ecstasy: How Music Captures Our Imagination. New
York: William Morrow and Company.
Kartman, L. (1980). The Power of Music With Patients in a Nursing Home. Activities, Adaptation and
Aging, 1, 917.
Kaye, Charles, & Blee, Tony (Eds.). (1997). The Arts in Health Care: A Palette of Possibilities. London:
Jessica Kingsley Publishers.
Kendig, Hal. (1996). Promoting Health in Later Life: Personal, Professional, and Social Issues. In
Victor Minichiello, Neena Chappell, Hal Kendig, & Allan Walker (Eds.), Sociology of Aging
(pp. 358361). Melbourne: International Sociological Association.
Kenny, Carolyn. (1989). The Field of Play: A Guide for the Theory and Practice of Music Therapy.
Atascadero: Ridgeway Publishers.
Kurz, C. (1960). The Effects of a Planned Music Program on the Day Hall Sound and Appearance of
Geriatric Patients. Masters thesis, University of Kansas, Lawrence.
P1: IBC
Journal of Aging and Identity [jai]
PH143-378899-03
18:16
175