10/15/2015

AimezvousBrahms?|gramophone.co.uk
Sign In (/user/login)

Subscribe (/subscribe)

Latest issue (/latest-issue/october-2015)

Reviews Database (/reviews)

Register (/user/register)

A (#)

A (#)

Digital Archive (/classical-music-news/gramophone-launches-new-digital-archive-app)

Podcasts (https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-gramophone-magazine/id944184210)

Facebook (http://www.facebook.com/pages/Gramophone/87870680838)

Twitter (http://twitter.com/gramophonemag)

Youtube (http://www.youtube.com/user/GramophoneMagazine)

TheArchive
90 years of Gramophone now at
your fingertips

(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009240/0/225/AdId=13056162;BnId=1;itime=897530271;key=Johannes%2520Brahms%2
BBernard%2520Haitink;)

(http://www.gramophone.co.uk/
/classical-musicnews/gramophone-launchesnew-digital-archive-app)

Search
(/)

Go
Est 1923

HOME

REVIEWS

COMPOSERS

NEWS

FEATURES

(/)

(/REVIEWS)

(/COMPOSERS)

(/CLASSICAL-MUSIC-NEWS)

(/FEATURES)

AWARDS

HALL OF FAME

BLOGS

FORUM

SUBSCRIBE

(HTTP://WWW.GRAMOPHONE.CO.UK/AWARDS/2015)

(/HALLOFFAME)

(/BLOG/ALL)

(/FORUM)

(/SUBSCRIBE)

Home (/) Features (/features) Aimez-vous Brahms?

Followus

AimezvousBrahms?
James Jolly (/users/james-jolly)

JamesJollytalksBrahmswithconductorsBernard
HaitinkandMarinAlsop,bothatworkon
symphonycycles
What does the name 'Brahms' conjure up in your mind? For most

Thu 1st January 2015

(http://www.facebook.com/GramophoneMagazine)
(//twitter.com/gramophonemag)

(https://plus.google.com/115887304357022119867)

people the image that automatically springs to mind is of the

composer in middle age, corpulently rotund, lavishly and greyly
bearded and reassuringly avuncular in appearance. Blame the

(http://www.youtube.com/user/GramophoneMagazine?
sub_confirmation=1)

photographs because he belongs to the first generation of composers

who were caught on film (and images of Brahms 'at leisure' are
greater in number than for most composers). That image attaches to
his music, too from whatever time in his life. For his detractors it's
the very confirmation of stodgy North German-ness: solid and
dependable, but backward-looking. For those who adore his music,
it's an image that throws up contradictions for his is music of such
passion, of such intensity that image and imagining never quite tally.
But there was a time when he was slim, blond and, according to many
reports, almost girlish in appearance. That was the Brahms
(http://www.gramophone.co.uk/composers/johannes-brahms34098) who left his native Hamburg in the early summer of 1853,
aged just 20, returning later that year, a doted-upon composer,
known to Liszt, Wagner, Berlioz and, of course, Clara and Robert
Schumann, who declared him a genius. He had achieved fame and
presented in his first few works a solid foundation from which that
celebrity would grow. Very few people who crossed his path were

(http://adserver.adtech.de/?
adlink/1211/5009239/0/170/AdId=13056159;
BnId=1;itime=897531331;key=Johannes%2520
Brahms%2BBernard%2520Haitink;)

Thecompletesubscription

unaffected by his obvious and abundant talent.

Join the Club today andreceive all three great

Gramophone products forjust 103 per year.

When he died, in April 1897, aged 63, he was the German-speaking

An 83 saving thanif bought separately.

world's foremost composer; indeed he was probably the most famous

(http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music1/gramophone/gramophone-premium)

composer in the entire world. His music was played across the USA as

http://www.gramophone.co.uk/feature/aimezvousbrahms

1/8

10/15/2015

AimezvousBrahms?|gramophone.co.uk

his disciples took up posts in the musical capitals of the New World.
He had amassed a considerable fortune almost entirely from the
royalties to his music with occasional supplements from performing.
He was a composer who did not rely on financial patronage but who
truly lived off his talent and was beholden to no one. Today, Brahms's
music particularly his orchestral music has a grip on the
repertoire like few others, his god Beethoven apart. No other
composer offers a symphonic legacy that is so well balanced, so
concentrated and at such an equally high level: four works, like the
four sides of a square, that comprise a unit of great strength and
integrity. It's no surprise that barely a week (hardly even a day) goes
by without a performance of one of his symphonies somewhere in the
world; in the US during the 2004-05 season Brahms, according to the
American Symphony Orchestra League, will be the fourth mostperformed composer. On disc, Brahms symphony cycles have

TheGramophone
Podcast
Subscribe today via iTunes
(https://itunes.apple.com/gb/podcast/thegramophone-magazine/id944184210?mt=2)

continued even when record companies have hesitated over

Beethoven's. This month sees the conclusion of one such cycle, from
the London Symphony Orchestra under Bernard Haitink, and the start
of another, from the London Philharmonic Orchestra underMarin
Alsop (http://www.gramophone.co.uk/features/focus/marin-alsopand-the-proms).
I caught up with both conductors just before Christmas to talk

Thealltime
greats
Read about the artists
who changed the world
of classical music.
(http://www.gramophone.co.uk/features/focus/
gramophone-hall-of-fame)

Brahms, a subject they each address with considerable passion. Alsop

was passing through London, from a concert the previous night with
the Residentie Orchestra in The Hague which had included Brahms's
First Symphony, en route to her home in Denver, where she started
2005 with a Brahms cycle with the Colorado Symphony. Bernard
Haitink was concluding a three-concert series with the LSO. There
was no Brahms on the bill, but it made a glorious close to a season
that has provided musical gold aplenty for London concert-goers in
his 75th-birthday year with a handful of Europe's greatest orchestras.

(https://twitter.com/GramophoneMag)
(https://twitter.com/GramophoneMag)

Tweets
Gramophone
@GramophoneMag

Follow
13 Oct

#VaughnWilliams is our composer of the week.

Which recordings would you recommend?
bit.ly/1L8YdQg pic.twitter.com/ak4sru8fhD

Those of us who love Brahms's music love it with a passion that

wanders through his entire output and alighting on specific pockets,
like the choral works. Marin Alsop remembers her first encounter
with Brahms's music. 'I heard the B flat Sextet when I was 11 years
old and that was the very first time I was moved by music. I had
this experience of an emotional reaction to music of course my

Tweet to @GramophoneMag

hormones were probably racing, too but I remember being just

gripped in a way I never had been before and I didn't know that music
could do that. Of course I raced off and bought the record it was
the Amadeus Quartet's and by the time I was 16 years old the
record was so thin because I'd played it so many times! There was
something very 'connecting' about Brahms's music.
'Then of course I got more engaged. It's like with an author you
read everything they wrote, until you OD on it. And I did that with
Brahms analysing the way he approached his works, particularly
the symphonies which he comes to so late in life, and what
psychologically led to them and how Beethoven's influence played a
role in them and so on. How one incorporates that interpretively
becomes a real Sherlock Holmes experience, which I love.' For Alsop,
the 2004-05 season has turned into something of a Brahmsfest. 'It
wasn't terribly conscious but I knew I'd be in the midst of these
recordings. It was interesting because a lot of orchestras asked for
Brahms from me so it seemed to work out well. It's fantastic because
orchestras who play Brahms a lot don't do the Third very often so you
have the challenge of working on a piece together.'

http://www.gramophone.co.uk/feature/aimezvousbrahms

2/8

10/15/2015

AimezvousBrahms?|gramophone.co.uk

For Haitink, who is just concluding his third Brahms cycle on disc, the
composer has been with him 'right from the beginning. But I have
learned by trial and error. I've discovered that concert organisers,
particularly on the Continent, give Brahms symphonies to young
conductors "Let him do a Brahms symphony!" but it's not that
easy. You need maybe now that I'm older I would say this but
you need more experience to bring off Brahms well. It's difficult to
say why. I think when we think of Brahms we all conjure up a huge,
inflated sound and that is totally wrong because Brahms wrote so
much wonderful chamber music which is a fine indication of the
textures he was after. If you look at the scores of the symphonies it's
amazing how often he writes piano dolce or pianissimo
dolce.Dolcecomes up so often, even more than with Beethoven, and
Beethoven uses that "warning" a lot. Take the beginning of Brahms's
Fourth Symphony: it's very often played far too loud, but then you
can't build it any more. When he uses piano, he creates a beautiful
sound and when you start at that level you can make a huge buildup, otherwise, with that movement in particular, it gets a little stale.
That is one of the secrets of playing Brahms: you have to be very
acute about how you pace the dynamics.'
One of the intriguing things about the composer is how
extraordinarily well he covered his tracks, both personal and musical.
He left virtually no drafts, few first thoughts or even first versions.
The published work we have is virtually all there is. For Alsop,
Brahms's witnessing at close hand Robert Schumann's mental decline,
and the public interest in it, is key. 'I think Brahms is very difficult to
get a handle on. From seeing Schumann in the limelight and watching
how the paparazzi of the time worked, he was extremely aware and
conscious of not leaving much of a trail. So he rarely documented
anything, he rarely kept notebooks and sketches, so most of what we
know is anecdotal or conjecture. I think that was all very intentional.'
Naturally this presents the double-edged situation where almost
every piece of his is in its finished text. 'Before I started work on the
symphonies I spoke with the Brahms expert Robert Pascall. We went
through the scores and what you find are mostly dynamic issues, the
kinds of minor things that you get when you transfer from a
manuscript to a print where the publisher or editor would make some
changes, often unintentionally but they're really tiny alongside,
say, Mahler's. Maybe that's a nice element not to have to agonise
over. But one agonises in different ways, but then that's great, too.
You can imbue his music with a lot of your own associations.'
For Haitink, the question of Brahms the man and Brahms's music
and indeed any composer and his music presents the ultimate
conundrum. 'How far the character of an artist has influence on his
actual creative process one never knows. I always try to read the
biography and read around the composer. It's always good to do but
as a performer one doesn't learn anything from it strangely enough,
but to be confronted again by the man and the artist is important. It
is an enormous riddle to me. How does the personal life of an artist
influence his music? Look at Mozart: during his most miserable last
years he wrote extremely sad pieces but always balanced by humour
or a slight optimism. Maybe not the G minor Symphony [No 40] which
is a very dark brooding work, but K543 [No 39] and theJupiterare
written by a man who was broke, people ignored him, perhaps he
gambled all his money and his credibility away. He was maybe a very
lonely man and he writes this fantastic C major music. It's amazing!'

http://www.gramophone.co.uk/feature/aimezvousbrahms

3/8

10/15/2015

AimezvousBrahms?|gramophone.co.uk

Over the years, Haitink admits, his attitude to the music has changed.
'I'm much more touched by it, much more intrigued by it. Brahms was
not an easy man and I think you can hear that in his music. One of
the famous things he said when he left an evening gathering was "If I
haven't offended someone here, I apologise!" He was difficult. People
always think of this man with the beard, relaxing with his cigar, but
there was so much more to him that that. I was in the Musikverein in
Vienna a while back where he left his library and it's amazing
what is there. He was an incredibly well-read man, very educated. But
I think he was a very lonely man, too.'
Read the booklet-note or programme-note to any Brahms symphony
and you'll learn that the composer waited until middle age to unveil
his first work in the genre well after he'd grown that splendid
beard and taken up the mantle of upholder of German music. He
spoke often of the towering example of Beethoven's remarkable nine
symphonies. But scale alone did not deter him one of Brahms's
earliest works is the Piano Sonata in F minor, Op 5, a five-movement
work of titanic proportions and reach. Perhaps a need to develop an
orchestral language delayed his first attempts, but by the time he
started work on his First Symphony, some time in the mid-1860s,
he'd already written two serenades (admittedly for small ensemble)
and the huge (in every respect) First Piano Concerto. When he did
grapple with the symphony he published two in relatively short
succession (1877 and 1878) and then, before a decade was through,
another two, again almost as a pair (1884 and 1886). So when we
reach Brahms's First Symphony, we are not encountering the work of
a tyro composer: it is the mature embracing of a form that he always
viewed with dread. 'You don't know what it is like,' he once told the
conductor Hermann Levi, 'always to hear that giant marching along
behind me'.
How many other composers have started their first symphony in so
imposing and confident a way? The steady tread pounded out as
if to acknowledge that marching giant but defiantly refusing to be
cowed by it. For Alsop, the key to interpreting the First is not to allow
indulgence. 'You cannot wallow. There's an organic tempo in each
symphony. For me, I feel there is a very particular tempo but I've
certainly heard some dramatic extremes. I think it just depends on
what one's take on this pulse at the beginning is. If it's a heartbeat
then for me it has to be manageable I'm not having to run a sixminute mile. But if it's not, and is just a general kind of life-pulse,
then I can understand speeding it up. One has to be very committed
to it.
'The music is so strong. More than with any other composer the
timpanist shapes Brahms for me. It's absolutely critical to have
someone who understands not only pacing and timing, but also the
colour of sound and the weight of sound. One of the things I adore
about Brahms is his ability to have one foot firmly anchored in the
tradition of music. He was famed for his adoration of Beethoven, but
also of Bach as well and that leads to his beautiful bass-line
construction but he was also completely aware of where music was
heading. And to be able to straddle those two worlds successfully is
his real genius. Take his choice of instrumentation in the First
Symphony he saves the trombones for the last movement just so they
were still something special. Or to use the tuba in only one symphony
to make these choices, to use horns as if they were still natural
instruments even though he didn't need to. He could really play
tribute to the past but look ahead to the future so strongly.'

http://www.gramophone.co.uk/feature/aimezvousbrahms

4/8

10/15/2015

AimezvousBrahms?|gramophone.co.uk

Haitink is in agreement. 'The opening of the First Symphony is

markedPoco sostenuto. It should not be too slow. He can tempt
indulgence. It sounds a bit odd for a conductor to say this but one
should leave it alone. It plays itself in many ways as long as one takes
care of the sound, of the tempo, of the dynamics that's already a
lot to ask! but don't fool around with ritardandi that he hasn't
written. When he writes poco ritenuto, don't make it molto. It's a
habit that when people want to impress, they think they impress by
pulling it around. But they don't. Going back to that opening of No 1,
it's passionate but there's also the danger that performers want
itfortissimo, when he writes forte. Later on they will have the chance
forfortissimoin the resolution. It's very important to get a wonderful
sound for that beginning: passionate but notfortissimo.'
Symphonies Nos 1 and 2 were written just a couple of years apart, so
does that encourage thinking of them as a pair? Alsop: 'One of the
great rewards about conducting these symphonies is that they're all
different planets but they belong to the same solar system. With
Brahms there's a completely unique world with each work: it's a life
unto itself, and a very different cohesive life. That's the joy of it. But I
really do see them as complements of each other so No 1 and No 2
feel related. I feel so strongly in Nos 1 and 2 the influence of
Beethoven. For me, No 2 is highly influenced by theEroicaso I don't
feel the term that is often applied to it Pastoral is quite accurate
because it has that inner strength.
'If you look at the openings of 1 and 2 they couldn't be more
diametrically opposed. No 1 is all about downbeats and No 2's all
about upbeats.' A very Bernstein-y comment? 'The one thing I
remember Bernstein talking to me about in Brahms and yes, he
loved to make those epic statements was when he was working on
the Fourth Symphony. He was explaining to the orchestra that
"there's always a moment in Brahms when there's an amazing silence"
actually there are many moments but he would try and prioritise
what the biggest silent moment in a Brahms symphony would be.
Those things are so great to think about, those big ideas.'
Haitink, too, findsPastoralfor No 2 a misnomer: 'I think that's a bit
simplistic because it could invite a very relaxed attitude. Of course
the first movement is relaxed, but it should not be too slow in tempo:
it should be very transparent and it has some wonderful textures.
One can't sit back and enjoy the countryside all the time! The second
movement has no pastoral atmosphere at all for me. It's a very
strange movement, I love it, but it's so dark and brooding. The third
movement is lovely, a real scherzo in mood and the finale is very
festive. One could almost think of Haydn there. But it's so dangerous
to use these labels. In comparison with the other symphonies, yes
there's a pastoral feel but ...'
The Third and Fourth Symphonies followed in the mid 1880s and, in
their very special way, present an even more intriguing pairing than
the first two symphonies: No 3 is concise and concentrated and
fiendishly difficult to bring off the equivalent perhaps of
Beethoven's similarly proportioned Eighth Symphony, a powerful little
work before the epic splendours of theChoralSymphony. The Third
is traditionally the most neglected of the four. Marin Alsop laughs
and admits to the vapidity of the conducting profession who avoid it,
it's often suggested, because of its gentle ending, hardly a way for a
conductor to leave the stage in a blaze of sonorous glory. 'I think the
Third is probably the most challenging to conduct but I don't think it
is obscure in any way. The opening is crucial. I think it's really a

http://www.gramophone.co.uk/feature/aimezvousbrahms

5/8

10/15/2015

AimezvousBrahms?|gramophone.co.uk

technical dilemma which must stem from an interpretive question on

the part of conductors because it's quite tricky to find the right
tempo that propels it without pushing it too much. That is crucial and
that is the key to Brahms to give it the space without making it
sound slow. And I think great orchestras can really do that. They can
fill in the time so you push the envelope of time without really
expanding it. Just like filling it up as much as you can before it
changes shape. I think that in the Third it's really important to feel
the water filling in all those chords at the beginning.'
Haitink agrees. 'It's always said that conductors don't want to end
with it because of its quiet close. No 3 is a very complex piece and
it's not for nothing that's it's not performed as often as the other
symphonies. But I would always place it last. When I do it later this
year in Berlin the programme goes Haydn symphony, BartkDance
Suite interval then Brahms Third. The first movement is
incredibly symphonic and technically quite difficult for a conductor to
keep together in 6/4. It's very difficult to launch: there was this old
tradition of those two chords, major and minor in the brass and that
conductors made a crescendo towards the third bar. For me they're
two pillars that shouldn't be messed around with: here's one and
there's one. It's very passionate, but then it breaks down at the end
of the first movement already to a piano finish. Then this wonderful
second movement, which is pure chamber music, and the third
movement is so introverted, but such an extremely touching piece.
And the last movement starts very foggy, rather North German fog
but then the sun cuts through and there is an enormous, heroic
outburst but at the end it breaks down again and ends maybe again
in resignation.'
And so to the great Fourth Symphony. Every time I hear it I have a
feeling that something has been happening before the music starts.
Marin Alsop points out that in its original form and it's one of the
few examples of an early thought that survives there was a slow
chordal opening. 'I can see why he abandoned the original opening of
the Fourth which was four bars of sustained chords because the Third
opens with those chords, I think the idea of having these pillars again
just doesn't appeal. With the Fourth you sort of open the door and
the conversation is already happening. That was a brilliant thing.' For
Haitink, 'something already's going on and the curtain rises. And
there it is...'
And again, the label that often gets attached to the Fourth is Tragic.
Haitink: 'It reminds me always of autumn, and like that season there's
always a little resignation with life. Summer has gone... but again
we're putting stickers on it, and that's so dangerous!' Alsop, too,
doesn't see anything as strong as a tragedy here. 'I think there's an
element of longing, perhaps a sense of loss but not "spoken-outloud" loss, more like "I wish I had said what I meant to that person
but didn't" that kind of thing. To me the slow movement of the
Fourth really is one of the most sublime movements in music. I think
it's spectacular. The way it opens with this repetitive figure it's
almost like you're all by yourself in the mountains, you're singing
something out that keeps echoing back and forth. The audience has
no real feel for where the beat is and Brahms puts us off centre so
often. He moves bar lines by displacing the downbeat and that's just
a brilliant compositional technique. People who aren't musicians
don't understand why, but they feel a little bit uncomfortable: that's
fantastic. But that slow movement in particular I find very poignant
and gorgeous.'

http://www.gramophone.co.uk/feature/aimezvousbrahms

6/8

10/15/2015

AimezvousBrahms?|gramophone.co.uk

Brahms was, famously, anointed by Schumann as Beethoven's natural

successor, a man who from his earliest compositions was the creator
of 'veiled symphonies'. He was seen as the torch-bearer for the great
German tradition that seemed to jump from peak to peak from Bach
to Beethoven to Brahms. In the opposite camp were Liszt whose
music Brahms loathed and Wagner whose music, especially
Meistersinger, he rather admired. But was Brahms the loyal,
traditionalist, more keen on carrying a tradition, or was he forwardlooking, into the future. Arnold Schoenberg, a man who altered the
course of music as no other, was a great Brahmsian, the man who
spoke in a lecture given in February 1933 on the centenary of
Brahms's birth, of 'Brahms the Progressive'.
Marin Alsop in is no doubt as to Brahms's musical direction. 'I do
think he's a real progressive. And I think that often great
progressives are the ones who pay homage to the past whilst looking
into the future. One of my favourite things is to do the Schoenberg
orchestration of the First Piano Quartet. I'd love to do it as part of this
cycle. It's fun and actually very Brahmsian.' And let's leave the last
words to Bernard Haitink. 'I have friends, many of whom really do
know and love music, but for them Brahms is too Teutonic. How can I
answer that? I think it's probably the fault of bad interpretation, when
the sound gets clogged, it's a problem. That can happen easily it's
the same a bit with the music of Elgar who occupies a similar sort of
sound world. I always get irritated when people say he is a
traditionalist and a reactionary. Schoenberg, who was hardly a fool,
recognised that! When you listen to Brahms's music, you encounter
his imagination, his orchestration, his incredible structural strength.
For me, there is nothing backward-looking about Brahms.'
Composer:
Johannes Brahms (/composers/johannes-brahms-34098)
Bernard Haitink (/musicians/artist/bernard-haitink-47964)
Like

296

Gramophone
Subscriptions

Print
Edition(#)

Tweet

2(#)

(#)

GramophonePrint

TheGramophone
Club

(#)

(#)

Digital
Edition(#)

TheGramophone
DigitalClub

Gramophone
Reviews

(#)

Digital
Archive(#)

(#)

Reviews
Database
(#)
Events&
Offers(#)

(#)

Gramophone
DigitalEdition

(#)

(#)

(#)
(#)

(#)
(#)

From50/year

From50/year

(#)

From50/year

(#)
Subscribe(http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music1/gramophone/gramophonemagazine?utm_source=gramophone.co.uk&utm
Subscribe(http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music
From
/year
Subscribe(http://magsubscrip

From82/year

66

Subscribe(http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music1/gramophone/gramopho
Subscribe(http://magsubscriptions.com/leisure/music1/gramophone/gramophonepremium?utm_source=

http://www.gramophone.co.uk/feature/aimezvousbrahms

7/8

10/15/2015

Home (/)
Composers
(/composers)
Features (/Features)
Hall of Fame
(/halloffame)
Awards (/awards)
Blogs (/blog/all)

AimezvousBrahms?|gramophone.co.uk

Contact Us (/contactus)
House Rules (/houserules)
Privacy Policy
(/privacy-policy)
Terms & Conditions
(/page/websiteterms-andconditions)
Twitter
(http://twitter.com/gr
amophonemag)
Facebook
(http://www.facebook
.com/pages/Gramop
hone/87870680838)

Sign In (/user/login)
Register
(/user/register)
Latest issue (/latestissue/october-2015)

Gramophone is brought to you by Mark Allen Group

(http://www.markallengroup.com)
Gramophone is part of MA Business and Leisure
(http://www.markallengroup.com)
About Mark Allen Group (http://www.markallengroup.com)
| International licensing (http://www.markallengroup.com)

MA Business and Leisure Ltd. 2015

http://www.gramophone.co.uk/feature/aimezvousbrahms

8/8