OBSTETRICS
Introduction
Acute postpartum perineal pain is known to be common
among women undergoing vaginal delivery. However, perineal
pain is reported to be more severe in women with episiotomy
or spontaneous tears when compared with women with intact
perineum (Macarthur and Macarthur 2004). The management
of perineal pain in the early postpartum period is essential,
since it may have a negative impact on the physical and mental functioning of the women. It may consequently lead to
decreased success of the mother for breast-feeding and reduced
ability to care for her new baby; thus it may impair the establishment of a good quality motherbaby interaction (Grant and
Sleep 1989).
Numerous treatment modalities, including topical anaesthetics, oral, simple and narcotic analgesics and non-pharmacological applications in the form of gels, creams or ice packs, are
used to alleviate perineal pain in clinical practice (Sleep and
Grant 1988). When perineal pain is mild, paracetamol is the
most commonly used analgesic in clinical practice (Hedayati
et al. 2003). Maternal ingestion of paracetamol in usual analgesic doses does not appear to present a risk to breast-fed infants,
since it is excreted in small amounts (! 0.2%) in the breast milk
(Bitzn et al. 1981).
On the other hand, non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
(NSAIDs) are also used commonly in the perineal pain control.
As an example, diclofenac and ibuprofen are two of the NSAIDs
tested and shown to be effective for the treatment of postepisiotomy pain (Peter et al. 2001; Dodd et al. 2004; Yildizhan
et al. 2009).
Since some women, especially with significant perineal
trauma, experience more severe and prolonged discomfort, they
may need different or more effective treatment modalities such as
single-dose epidural narcotics used for post-caesarean analgesia
(Hedayati et al. 2003).
Dexketoprofen trometamol is a relatively new NSAID, which
is the active enantiomer of racemic ketoprofen. When compared with ketoprofen, dexketoprofen possesses the advantages
of faster onset of action, increased potency, fewer gastrointestinal side-effects (Mercorio et al. 2002; Iohom et al. 2002).
Dexketoprofen has been commonly used for management of
acute and chronic pain in different clinical situations such as
orthopaedic, general and major gynaecological surgical procedures and found to be non-inferior to other NSAIDs and paracetamol/opioid combinations (Mercorio et al. 2002; Iohom et al.
2002; Ezcurdia et al. 1998). In a trial investigating the use of
dexketoprofen in minor gynaecological surgery, it was found to
produce a satisfactory level of analgesia, similar to that achieved
with paracervical block during diagnostic hysteroscopy in
postmenopausal women (Mercorio et al. 2002). Furthermore,
ketoprofen has also been found to effectively reduce the need
for pain treatment after caesarean section and the requirement
for opioids to be decreased by about 40% (Rorarius et al. 1993).
However, there is no available study evaluating the effectiveness
of ketoprofen or dexketoprofen in episiotomy pain. Since ketoprofen is known to be excreted in only traces or small amounts
in breast milk (Jacqz-Aigrain et al. 2007), it was thought to be
a safe alternative to paracetamol in the management of early
postpartum perineal pain.
In this randomised controlled study, we aimed to compare the
analgesic efficacy of intravenous paracetamol with intravenous
dexketoprofen trometamol in reducing perineal pain after vaginal
delivery.
Correspondence: A. Akil, Bodrum Acbadem Hospital, Bodrum, Mugla, Turkey. E-mail: zkubat@yahoo.com
26
A. Akil et al.
2009. Ethical approval for the study was granted by the local
ethical committee.
The study population consisted of women who had episiotomy
or perineal tear that required repair after vaginal delivery. Neither
epidural nor combined spinalepidural analgesia was used in any
of the patients. Exclusion criteria included: women who had a
known allergy to NSAIDs or paracetamol; any known disease
contraindicating the use of NSAIDs (severe asthma, gastric or
duodenal ulcer) or paracetamol; complicating maternal diseases
(pregestational/gestational diabetes mellitus; bleeding disorders;
pre-eclampsia and other hypertensive disorders of pregnancy);
ablatio placenta; severe postpartum haemorrhage (" 1,500 ml);
inability to understand how to score a 10 cm visual analogue
scale (VAS).
Prior to the study, sample size calculation was performed to
avoid type II error. The standard deviation of pain scores following perineal repair after vaginal birth was obtained from previously published studies. Sample size calculations were based on
previous research carried out by Lim et al. (2008), which showed
a mean pain score of 2.2 (SD 1.8), using a 10-point VAS scale for
perineal pain at 1 hour post-perineal repair. We calculated that to
detect an at least 1-point difference on a 10-point VAS for pain
using the t-test, assuming standard deviation of 1.5, alpha of 0.05
and power of 80%, would require 36 women in each drug arm.
Assuming a 20% dropout rate, a minimum of 86 women was
calculated to be recruited. Block randomisation was achieved by
using a computer-generated random number chart (SPSS Inc.,
Version 11.0 for Windows, Chicago IL) before the study. Consecutive numbers generated by the computer were written on
the numbered opaque envelopes, which were sealed by someone
other than those involved in the study, with the data inside indicating treatment allocation as P (paracetamol) or D (dexketoprofen). Following vaginal delivery, within 5 min after completion of
suturing, the written informed consents were obtained from all
of the patients and the patients were randomised into one of the
two study groups. All women were informed that rescue analgesia
with the same or different drugs would be available if pain relief
was inadequate and breast-feeding was not contraindicated with
any of the study drugs.
The women involved in the study were blinded to the allocated treatment group. All patients were routinely inserted an i.v.
cannulae during labour and the study drugs were administered
through this cannulae via slow infusion. Patients in Group I were
administered two doses of 50 mg i.v. dexketoprofen trometamol
(Arveles; IE Ulagay Pharmaceutical, Istanbul, Turkey) and
patients in Group II were administered two doses of 1,000 mg
i.v. paracetamol (Perfalgan; 10 mg/ml; Bristol-Myers Squibb
GmbH); the first dose given at the 5th minute after completion of
suturing and the second dose 6 hours later. Patients in both of the
groups had also placebo injections mimicking the active drug.
All patients were administered local anaesthesia by 2% lidocaine (Jetokain Simplex ampule; Adeka Pharmaceutical Company, Istanbul, Turkey) while episiotomy or tear was cut, and also
extra doses of lidocaine were administered if necessary, while
it was being repaired. Mediolateral episiotomy and 1st or 2nd
degree perineal tears were repaired in layers with a No. 0 absorbable, coated suture made of polyglycolic acid (Vicryl, Ethicon,
Inc). The perineal skin was closed with No. 2/0 interrupted sutures
of polyglycolic acid (Vicryl, Ethicon, Inc). The repair time was
similar between the groups. The episiotomy and perineal tear
repairing was performed by the two same gynaecologists (YB,
AOY) to minimise the risk of technical variation. The women
received standard postnatal care in the maternity ward and were
mobilised as soon as could be tolerated.
Results
A total of 95 patients were randomised to receive the study drug:
49 patients to dexketoprofen and 46 patients to paracetamol. Ten
patients were excluded because of extra analgesic need (six in the
dexketoprofen group and four in the paracetamol group). In total,
82 patients had complete data to be available to the final analysis.
The flowchart of the patients is shown in Figure 1.
The demographics and baseline characteristics of the women
in both groups are shown in Table I. Except gravidity, there were
no significant differences in sociodemographic data or baseline
parameters (parity, age, the length of the labour, birth weight,
dose of the local anaesthetic used during the repair of episiotomy
or perineal tears (lidocaine) and VAS 0 among the two groups
(p # 0.02 for gravidity). There were no statistically differences in
the number of patients who underwent episiotomy and repair of
lacerations between the two groups. There were no cases of 3rd or
higher degree perineal tears or instrumental vaginal delivery.
The mean pain scores in the two groups revealed significant
reductions from the beginning at the first hour (Group I, p ! 0.0001;
Group II, p # 0.04). Mean VAS pain score declined in 31/41 patients
in group I (%75.6) and 25/41 patients in group II (%60.9) (p # 0.15
Age (years)
Height (cm)
Weight (kg)
Gravidity
Parity
Length of labour (h)
Birth weight (g)
Lidocaine dose (mg)
VAS 0 score
Group I:
Dexketoprofen
Group II:
Paracetamol
24.71 $ 5.83
161.23 $ 5.56
66.08 $ 8.3
1.85 $ 1.29
1.20 $ 1.01
9.43 $ 14.9
3163.9 $ 588.9
108.4 $ 40.4
31.1 $ 23.5
24.71 $ 4.91
161.97 $ 5.65
72.21 $ 10.65
1.55 $ 0.75
0.74 $ 0.69
6.05 $ 5.28
3257.38 $ 500.5
110.4 $ 47.2
26.5 $ 25.1
Discussion
The aim of this randomised controlled study was to assess the
analgesic efficacy of a non-steroid anti-inflammatory drug,
dexketoprofen, compared with paracetamol for perineal pain after
perineal repair. The self-assessments of pain with a 10 cm VAS
showed that, administration of both intravenous paracetamol and
dexketoprofen were similarly effective in perineal pain relief.
Although it is no longer recommended to have routine episiotomy (Shahraki et al. 2011), in Turkey, still the majority of
women who give birth by the vaginal route have episiotomy to
prevent undesirable tearing or significant labial or vaginal lacerations. Episiotomy or spontaneous tearing of perineal tissues
during vaginal birth is associated with significant pain, infection
and loss of mobility during the immediate postpartum period
(Hedayati et al. 2005). Perineal pain can also have negative
impacts on a womans daily activities, including sleep patterns,
urinary and bowel function and providing practical care of her
infant (Hedayati et al. 2003). Perineal pain is reported to be most
Table II. Mean reductions in the VAS scores between the two groups.
Group I: Dexketoprofen
(n # 41)
VASt0VASt1
VASt1VASt2
VASt2VASt3
VASt3VASt6
VASt6VASt12
Reduction
(mean $ SD)
p value
Reduction
(mean $ SD)
p value
12.14 $ 19.3
5.65 $ 12.8
0.32 $ 8.8
2.05 $ 8.05
0.97 $ 11.1
! 0.0001
0.007
0.82
0.11
0.57
7.7 $ 16.3
2.7 $ 10.1
1.04 $ 11.4
2.72 $ 9.4
1.1 $ 12.2
0.004
0.09
0.56
0.07
0.57
Figure 2. VAS scores in the two groups in dierent time points. Dierences
between the groups were not statistically significant.
28
A. Akil et al.
References
American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Drugs (AAPCD). 2001.
The transfer of drugs and other chemicals into human milk. Pediatrics
108:776789.
Bitzn PO, Gustafsson B, Jostell KG, Melander A, Whlin-Boll E. 1981. Excretion of paracetamol in human breast milk. European Journal of Clinical
Pharmacology 20:123125.
Bush DJ, Lyons G, MacDonald R. 1992. Diclofenac for analgesia after caesarean section. Anaesthesia 47:10751077.
Carlborg L, LindoV C, Hellman A. 1987. Diclofenac versus pethidine in the
treatment of pain after hysterectomy. European Journal of Anaesthesiology 4:241247.
Dodd JM, Hedayati H, Pearce E, Hotham N, Crowther CA. 2004. Rectal analgesia for the relief of perineal pain after childbirth: a randomised controlled trial of diclofenac suppositories. British Journal of Obstetrics and
Gynaecology 111:10591064.
Copyright of Journal of Obstetrics & Gynaecology is the property of Taylor & Francis Ltd
and its content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without
the copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or
email articles for individual use.