Low
Low
Low
Process lm
temperature
Tube wall
temperature
Bridgewall
temperature
High
High
High
High
Cost
Low
High radiant ux
FIG. 1. Radiant heat flux vs. heater characteristics.
Hydrocarbon Processing|OCTOBER 201567
Heat Transfer
that, with this cyclic loading condition, the process inlet tubes
will witness flue gas acid dewpoint condensation during the
cold feed, which is not desirable.
To remedy this potentially undesirable condition, the process inlet was specified to be a co-current design in the convection section. The convection tube metallurgy was upgraded
from carbon steel to stainless steel (SS), resulting in a projection of longer tube life. In addition, access doors were provided
to periodically monitor tube conditions.
Heater turndown requirements should be addressed at the
initial stages of the design phase. Typically, burners witness carbon monoxide (CO) breakthrough (increased CO emissions)
and an increase in volatile organic compound (VOC) emissions, with the bridgewall temperatures lower than 1,300F.
Bridgewall temperature is a function of the process outlet
temperature and the radiant heat flux utilized. Every furnace
should be evaluated to ensure that the emission guarantees are
valid for the turndown conditions.
Salt formation in selective catalytic reduction (SCR) catalyst and downstream equipment should also be considered
when designing for heater turndown requirements. Depending
on the sulfur content in the fuel, sulfur dewpoint issues should
be addressed as well.
Among plot plan considerations, provisions should be
made for tube removal/retubing/repair activities in the design
of the fired heaters. Crane access/rigging operations should
also be considered.
For continuously operated platforms, stack emissions of
nearby continuously operated vents (i.e., heater stacks, thermal
oxidizers, etc.) should be taken into consideration. This may
require dispersion modeling to address environmental issues.
Refractory provides insulation to reduce heat loss from the
fired heaters. Refractory losses typically range between 1.5%
and 3% of the firing rate. API 560 provides guidance on the
design requirements.
The refractory material selection should consider flue gas
velocity, operating temperatures, cyclic loading, mechanical
stress, fuel impurities, maintenance access and any other form
of erosion anticipated. Heaters designed for cyclic loading induce additional thermal stresses. Ceramic fiber selection in this
scenario can help reduce the cyclic stresses.
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
300F ue gas
400F ue gas
500F ue gas
6
Excess O2, dry %
600F ue gas
800F ue gas
10
1,000F ue gas
1,200F ue gas
68OCTOBER 2015|HydrocarbonProcessing.com
12
Heat Transfer
TABLE 1 shows values for the draft correction factor for altitude
variation with respect to the mean sea level.
As a good design practice, the stack exit should be sized to
ensure a minimum velocity of 10 ft/sec at heater turndowns to
avoid inversion, which can cause draft instability. Typically, design stack exit velocities are approximately 25 ft/sec. For heaters
with extended turndowns, higher design exit velocities should
be considered. A stack cone is usually added to achieve increased
velocities. Minimum stack exit velocity requirements should
also be defined for the dispersion modeling.
Draft/ft, inWC
sign temperatures for various tube-support materials and guidelines on support lengths.
The design of external piping supports, guides and clips (requiring support from the heater) should be checked using pipe
stress analysis. Details of the external structural supports and
clips should be communicated to the heater fabricator. Material
procurement and fabrication locations can have a major impact
on the heater cost.
0.014
0.013
0.012
0.011
0.010
0.009
0.008
0.007
0.006
0.005
0.004
0.003
0.002
0.001
20
40
60
80
100
Ambient air temperature, F
120
140
160
Intel Corporation
Saadi Kermani
Product Manager,
Information
Management
Schneider
Electric
Roger Jordan
Associate Editor
World Oil
Heat Transfer
FIG. 4 shows the stack area required as a function of flue gas
temperature and flowrate for a 25-ft/sec stack exit velocity.
Requirements for aircraft warning lights should be checked
with the appropriate authorities. This will depend on the stack
height, plot plan location and nearby structures. US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) testing or continuous emissions
monitoring systems (CEMS) nozzle requirements (quantity and
size) should be checked and appropriately sized and/or specified.
Purge fans or stack steam eductors should be specified for any
purging needs (as required for natural draft startup). Using snuffing steam for purging in the radiant box during heater startup has
been associated with reliability issues to the pilot flame, the ignition rod and the flame scanner. These issues are attributable to
condensate buildup and possible refractory damage.
Altitude, ft
120
100
80
60
40
20
0
300
400
500
600
700
Stack temperature, F
25,000 lb/hr
50,000 lb/hr
100,000 lb/hr
800
150,000 lb/hr
200,000 lb/hr
900
1,000
250,000 lb/hr
300,000 lb/hr
Lb of ue gas/lb of fuel
10
20
30
40
50
60
Excess air, %
70
80
90
100
FIG. 5. Flue gas flowrate range for refinery fuel gases vs. excess air, %.
70OCTOBER 2015|HydrocarbonProcessing.com
Heat Transfer
CO: Result of incomplete combustion or improper
mixing of fuel.
VOC: Typically caused by incomplete combustion. API
535 defines VOC as any compound of carbon that can
participate in atmospheric photochemical reactions.
Particulate: According to API 535, all fuels contain or
produce particulates. Some particulates can also result
from eroded refractory, tube scales, etc.
SOx: Sulfur content in the fuel directly contributes to
SOx emissions. SOx emissions react with water to form
sulfuric acid. The best way to reduce SOx emissions is to
reduce the sulfur content of the fuel.
NH3: Ammonia slip emissions are caused by the
unreacted ammonia passing over the SCR catalyst. These
are to be addressed when an SCR unit is installed with
the heater. Typically, computational fluid dynamics is
carried out to ensure proper ammonia distribution.
CO2: One of the byproducts of combustion. Higher
heater efficiency reduces CO2 emissions.
Burner test. Tests are conducted for fuels specified to test
the burner for flame envelope, emissions and stability. A CO
probe should be used to check on the flame envelope. CO with
a ppm of 2,000 is typically considered a visible flame. However,
lower CO levels may also be checked to account for an invisible
flame envelope.
Pilot and burner compatibility should be checked for startup/shutdown/operating conditions to ensure safe and reliable
operations. Final burner capacity curves should reflect the actual test tip pressures and orientation.
In one case study, a vertical cylindrical natural draft heater
was experiencing unequal air to the burners, resulting in unpredictable flue gas patterns. A field visit confirmed that the heater
was located on one end of the process plant, and strong winds
blowing across the burner intakes were disrupting air intake to
the burners. A 12-ft-tall metal wall was built around the heater
to reduce the wind effects, solving the problem.
In another case study, existing raw gas burners for a reheat
furnace with arbor coils (wicket type) were retrofitted with
ultra-low-NOx burners to reduce NOx emissions. When the
heater was fired up, all the flames leaned to one side, impinging
on the tubes and resulting in disruption of heater operation. A
field visit showed that the furnace created asymmetrical flue gas
patterns because of the hot-end and cold-end tube walls. This
problem was solved by redesigning the floor, erecting a center
wall and installing new flat-flame burners.
Stack damper design considerations. Stack dampers are
used to control the draft in the natural draft heaters. Dampers are
also used in the flue gas and air ducts. Fan dampers are utilized
to control forced draft and induced-draft fans. API 560 recommends a minimum of one blade for every 13 ft2 of internal crosssection area for butterfly dampers. The stack damper material
should be 18Cr-8Ni material. A direct-mounted actuator should
be specified for the operation of a stack damper.
GALVESTON, TEXAS
+ EnergyConstructionForum.com
The second annual Energy Construction Forum (ECF) provides a unique and timely gathering covering
all phases of major expansions and new construction projects. ECF focuses on the challenges and solutions
facing the energy industry today for the Rening, Petrochemical, Chemical, LNG, GTL, Pipelines, Terminals
& Storage and Gas Processing sectors.
Facebook/
EnergyConstructionForum
@ECF_Event
#ECFCon
EnergyConstructionForum
Hydrocarbon Processing|OCTOBER 201571
Heat Transfer
Other criteria are correct bearing (for the temperature range
and type of operation) selection, shaft surface finish and hardness requirements, shaft outside diameter to bearing inside diameter clearances, and adequate clearance between the damper
blade and the refractory. Dampers should also be provided with
a pointer to provide a visual on the indication of stack-damper
position from the grade.
In another case study, a vertical cylindrical heater had a stack
damper with an actuator. To adjust the draft, the operator closed
the damper, using an actuator from the control room. The stack
damper became stuck, and the extra force from the actuator
caused the damper to free up and close suddenly, which created
a pressure surge in the box and put out the burner flames and
the pilots. Since no flame scanners were installed, the heater
witnessed flame-out with fuel leak. Flame-out was evident from
the falling process outlet temperature and an increase in O2 in
the radiant box.
To remedy this issue, a stack damper was retrofitted with new
bearings with adequate clearances. All linkages and blades were refurbished to ensure that the damper did not stick and cause another safety hazard. Flame scanners were also installed as safeguards.
Air preheat considerations. There are two types of air preheaters: rotary (regenerative) and static (recuperative). A static
air preheater offers the advantage of no leakage and no moving parts. When considering an air preheater, the burner design
should conform to the new operating conditions.
Acid dewpoint issues should be given consideration at the
cold end. Cold-air bypass or air preheating are common methods
to prevent cold-end dewpoint issues. In certain circumstances, a
borosilicate glass tube design is used at the entry section to address the cold-end dewpoint issues. When utilizing an air preheater with an SCR unit, water wash or other cleaning means
should be provided for salt cleaning.
Heater instrumentation. API 556 provides guidance on heater instrumentation. However, several key parameters should
also be given appropriate consideration during the design phase.
Process flow imbalance in the process passes should be minimized, since this leads to tube overheating, increased coke formation and heat flux imbalance in the heater. Manifold designs
should ensure low process pass imbalance. For conventional heaters, the installations of flow transmitters, individual pass flow controllers on the process inlet passes and temperature transmitters
at the outlet passes are required. These transmitters help make
required flow adjustments to avoid process heat flux imbalances.
Process low-flow alarms and trips should be configured appropriately. Tube skins provide valuable information on tube
conditions. A minimum of two tube-skin thermocouples per
pass are recommended. Crossovers should also be specified with
temperature connections.
The provision of spare access ports at the radiant floor,
bridgewall, upstream and downstream of the dampers is recommended. Similar access ports are recommended for monitoring
duct pressures upstream and downstream of fans, heat recovery
equipment and emission-reduction units. Several instruments
are recommended for the flue gas side:
An O2 , temperature and draft transmitter at the radiant
bridgewall
72OCTOBER 2015|HydrocarbonProcessing.com
Heat Transfer
is critical and would result in a shutdown of the downstream
units, then a spare fan should be specified. For low turndowns, a
variable frequency drive or a combination inlet/outlet damper
should be considered.
A heater shall be provided with sufficient peep doors to provide visuals for all radiant tubes and burners. A sealed self-closing
peep door with glass protection ensures that the heater is sealed
against tramp air leakage. The glass protection also provides
shielding against any positive pressure conditions. Floor view
ports can be considered to provide an unrestricted view between
the tubes and the burners. Any special requirements needed for
infrared scanning should be discussed and investigated. Heaters
should be specified with tube seals to seal up all of the tube penetrations and guides. All unwelded seams should be caulked.
Ladders and platforms should be provided to access all peep
doors, maintenance access doors, stack dampers, fans, emissions reduction equipment, EPA nozzles and heater instrumentation. Ladders and platforms are generally hot-dip galvanized.
Requirements on safety gates (color designation and type)
should be checked in the site-specific needs or project specifications. Consideration should be given for modularized construction to reduce field work and facilitate shipping and transportation, as well.
Startup spares should be specified as a part of the heater package. Heater paint should be specified as per the project specifications. Fireproofing should be addressed in the field installation.
Clips for fire protection installation should be provided by the
Introducing the
US GAS
PROCESSING
PLANT
DIRECTORY
US GAS PROCESSING
PLANT DIRECTORY
500+ Plants with Information about Name, Capacity, Plant Scope and Detail,
and Owner/Operator Information.
Hydrocarbon Processing and Gas Processings rst annual US Gas Processing Plant Directory is now available. The
directory provides detailed information for more than 500 gas processing plants, including natural gas processing,
cryogenic and fractionation. The fully searchable directory will allow users to gain detailed information on hundreds
of plants across the US. The directory will also have a detailed prologue on major trends in the US gas processing,
production and construction industries.
Gain the market knowledge to grow your business and inform your decisions in the booming United States gas market.
Order the directory to: Benet your planning and strategy / Locate new opportunities / Gain a competitive advantage.
$1,195 per edition. Searchable, digital format. Group rates and site licenses are available.